Skip to content
Get App

Can You be a Saint in the Age of AI? | Jonathan Pageau at the Austin Union

Jonathan Pageau speaks at UATX on AI, transhumanism and sainthood, arguing technology reshapes the person and that virtue, prayer and sacrifice are the true path of transcendence.

Key Takeaways

  • Technology acts as a prosthetic that can strengthen or weaken human faculties depending on how it is used.
  • Transhumanism without a vertical dimension of virtue and love reduces to a pursuit of power.
  • AI systems do not truly think; relying on them as arbiters of truth is a form of dependence.
  • The response to cultural and technological change is individual transformation toward sanctity, lived within community.

What the video covers

  • Opens with the claim that AI feeds on human intelligence, inverting the Matrix image: humans become the intelligence the AI trains on.
  • UATX host Yale Abernathy introduces the Austin Union Society, its vow to uphold truth through debate, and the event format: a 20-minute talk, student cross-examination, then audience questions.
  • Pageau notes the historical roots of 'photography' (St. Philotheos of Sinai, 'light writing') and 'transhuman' (Dante, Paradiso), contrasting vertical transformation in virtue with technological transformation.
  • Invokes Plato's Phaedrus critique of writing as a prosthetic that weakens natural faculties, applying it to modern AI dependence.
  • Critiques treating AI chatbots (e.g., Grok) as sources of truth and warns of outsourcing judgment to machines.
  • Argues the response to technological and cultural decline is personal sanctity: becoming a saint, citing 'the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church'.
  • Discusses how to speak to secular technologists, using Genesis 1:3 and the logic of order versus revolution as frames.
  • Distinguishes transhumanism as mere increase of power from an ascent in love and virtue, and reflects on fatherhood as self-giving leadership.
  • Concludes that AI cannot think or truly reason, and that individual faithful work and community embodiment matter more than systemic fixes.

Answers

Questions about this video

What is Pageau's central argument about AI?

He argues AI feeds on human intelligence rather than the reverse, becoming more powerful as it trains on what humans call good, so humans become its intellectual food.

How does Pageau distinguish his view of transhumanism?

He contrasts technological transformation, which increases power, with the vertical transformation in virtue and love described by Dante, which transcends the self toward God.

What solution does Pageau propose?

He proposes becoming a saint through prayer, sacrifice and virtue, living a faithful example in community as the answer to technological and cultural decline.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00
Speaker A
AI is eating you. You know that, right? You know why Chad GBT is cyclopantic?
00:09
Speaker A
Because it needs you, right? It needs your intelligence. It's actually eating your intelligence. It's the opposite of the matrix. You know, in the matrix, they told you that the humans are a battery for the AI.
00:25
Speaker A
That's not how it works. Ultimately, we are the intelligence of the AI. And it needs our intelligence and it feeds off of us and it becomes more powerful as it trains on the things that we tell it is good.
00:40
Speaker A
And so this is of course at a very proximal level but that's now realize what that does at in a long term and what it means to in some ways become food for this machine. Well, good evening and welcome to the University of
00:53
Speaker A
Austin. My name is Yale Abernathy and I'm the co-founder of the Austin Union Society which is extremely pleased to be hosting tonight's event. Before getting to introducing the event and our speaker, I wanted to say a few words
01:06
Speaker A
about the university and about our Austin Union Society. UATX is dedicated to the fearless pursuit of truth. And in keeping with this responsibility, members of the Austin Union swear a vow to solemnly uphold truth through debate.
01:23
Speaker A
This is kind of a a phrase you've seen come up in the culture wars and it's very easy to mistake this as a slogan um or something vague uh something handwavy but it's not and we don't treat it as if
01:37
Speaker A
it's something uh merely to signify a brand. These are not neutral positions. The truth, the pursuit of it demands courage, not merely to seek it, to obnigate oneself and to grasp it, but to bring it down with you, uh to bring it
01:55
Speaker A
into your life and into your community. It's a responsibility to raise yourself up to the level that it demands. These are the kind of values that the Austin Union Society at the University of Austin tries uh to employ in fostering
02:13
Speaker A
the youth of the future. We host local events, not really events for the internet or social media, but primarily for you, for the people in this audience who are going to have a chance to interrogate or speaker for the students
02:24
Speaker A
up on the stage because we believe the truth is something that is embodied, that is communed with, and that is essential for the flourishing of our society.
02:36
Speaker A
Please donate to the Austin Union. By the way, I just we do have to as students um rally as much time and support as we can to put on these events. We check out our website. We're doing stuff all the time.
02:50
Speaker A
We meet at the Fed. We host open forums where you can come give speeches on topics that are selected to reflect the times that we're in. And we also have events similar to this uh every Tuesday at the University of Austin. So please
03:03
Speaker A
support our project. Get involved. Thank you very much for being here. Um Jonathan Pio is one of the brilliant and penetrating voices um to emerge on the stage in recent years. He is a Greek Orthodox icon carver who um has found a
03:18
Speaker A
calling as a public speaker, as an educator, a founder of the symbolic world and the symbolic world press. Um and much more than a label. Part of what Mr. Pio does is remind us of the deep structures of being um of narrative of
03:34
Speaker A
conversation which a lot of us have forgotten uh to try and help us make sense of our world to find out what's happening next and to find out most importantly how we can participate in it. Um and that's really what we're
03:46
Speaker A
trying to achieve in this event is a participation of everybody here um in a very important topic.
03:52
Speaker A
Our speakers tonight are going to be three UATX students uh selected by merit from each class uh being Ben Schwarz, Sarah Harvey, and Dylan Woo. Um what's next?
04:08
Speaker A
We're talking about transhumanism. Do you guys know what transhumanism is? You read the news. UATX has kind of split down the middle on this question. The great books versus technology. And part of the aim of our university is to bring
04:21
Speaker A
these worlds together that we might foster a better future and a better humanity. So we're very pleased to have Mr. Pio speaking about questions of divinity, AI, and transhumanism. The format for tonight's event is as follows. Mr. Pio will be giving a speech
04:36
Speaker A
uh for about 20 minutes outlining his views and then these three students will have a cross-examination period um which will make up the majority of the events to push him a little bit harder and to try and have the truth spring up in a
04:49
Speaker A
dialogue as it were. Um and finally, this is where you guys come in. We're going to have a 15 to 20 minute period of audience questioning. Now, there is a petition which has come to me uh to make
05:00
Speaker A
sure that you guys don't clap after each question. Please do not clap after each question or we'll waste precious time.
05:05
Speaker A
Um Dylan will also be ging you down if you do not ask a real question and just give your own opinion or if you take too long. Um we're trying to develop good habits of the heart here at UATX uh to
05:16
Speaker A
make sure that everyone gets a chance to speak. Anyway, with that, welcome to the University of Austin and welcome to the Austin Union. [applause] It is really a joy to be here. It uh feels like every year there's like this
05:37
Speaker A
possibility that maybe I would come to UATX and then finally here we are. And so I've been kind of following the the project from the beginning gives me great joy to watch as many of our institutions are being captured. they're
05:52
Speaker A
crumbling from the inside. To see a project like this sprout up and just meeting with some of the students today gave me great joy to see that spark in their eyes and uh and a kind of enthusiasm that we want to see in young
06:05
Speaker A
people. And so did you know that the term photography the concept of photography was invented or was created in the 9th century and it was created by a monk uh St.
06:27
Speaker A
Filothio of Sinai who described the notion of photography that is the writing of light light writing as the possibility of the light of God inscribing the image of Christ onto the heart of the human person so that the person would be
06:47
Speaker A
transformed right would be transformed into the image of God. And of course, today if I use the word photography, you know what I'm referring to, which is the light, ambient light, the light of the sun, reflected off of
07:04
Speaker A
objects captured by a mechanism that is able to reproduce the qualities that it sees uh that are there in the world.
07:14
Speaker A
And interestingly enough, the word transhuman was also coined uh in a very long time ago by a certain Dante that you might have heard of. uh Dante in the first book of Paradiso coins this term transhuman seeing it as the capacity for the human
07:35
Speaker A
obviously to move up in virtue in transformation again in the image of God so that they transcend their themselves and come closer and closer to God through virtue through prayer through sacrifice through all the things of course that the spiritual life entails.
07:57
Speaker A
And so we have an interesting understanding which is that we see in both of these terms that the the vertical transformation of the person which is that when we talk about the progress of a person when we talk about
08:16
Speaker A
the transformation or the transcendence of that person what they mean by that is a transformation in virtue. a transformation in love, a transformation of the person so that they acquire the understanding, the wisdom, the capacity to discern, to engage with others in the
08:38
Speaker A
in the proper way. And it's really important to remember that because when we talk about transhumanism now and when we talk about AI and technology now, we are talking about the transformation of the person in a very different way or a very
08:57
Speaker A
different transformation of the person in the fedrris which I imagine you've all learned. Plato already sees the problem, right? Plato already sees the problem of technology in writing itself.
09:12
Speaker A
That is in the book itself. He sees a problem. He understands the problem of the supplement, the problem of the prosthetic, right? Which is that a prosthetic makes you more powerful, but it also weakens the natural faculty, right? So if I have a crutch and I'm
09:32
Speaker A
sick, it can help me to get through. But if I'm healthy and I have a crutch and I walk with it, I will forget how to walk.
09:40
Speaker A
Right? And this is true of all the notions of the supplement which is technology as a supplement that adds layers to the human faculties. Right? So a car becomes an extension of our feet, a hammer becomes an extension of our
09:57
Speaker A
hands. Does that all the time non-stop. It always both increases our power and decreases our power. It increases our power in its prosthetic capacity, but it also atrophies the natural power of the person. This is of course what Plato is
10:15
Speaker A
trying to get people to understand which is that if we exteriorize memory, we obviously can increase it because we can inscribe it and we can go reference, we can search for things, we can find them, but we are also decreasing the internal
10:30
Speaker A
memory of the person. For those of you who don't believe it, the ancients had atriums in their mind. They had great spaces where they were able to memorize levels numbers of texts and of poetry and a syllogisms that you can't even
10:48
Speaker A
imagine, right? They had they there are some people still today like there's this tradition of bards that exist still in Serbia where they were able to to recite a poem the length of the odyssey of the Iliad from memory
11:03
Speaker A
because they have in their mind the space that they're able to tap into and where they're able to get all of this.
11:10
Speaker A
And so this is very important to understand. In the Bible there's this concept of the the garments of skin, right? So when the humans falls, God adds a layer of dead skins around them.
11:22
Speaker A
And this dead layer of skins is important, right? There's nothing wrong with it. It's important because it is in some ways this prosthetic. It is an external layer of power that helps us in a world where we are too weak. So I'm
11:37
Speaker A
happy obviously for heating and for my house and for hot warm clothes because I can live in Montreal and not die in the winter.
11:46
Speaker A
But I remember that if I didn't have that, if I was found myself naked in Canada in January, then I would die within a few hours. Right? So this is of course how I want you to kind of think
12:00
Speaker A
about the question of technology to understand it as this supplement as presented in Plato or as presented in scripture as understanding as this prosthetic which both increases and decreases power.
12:13
Speaker A
Now [sighs] the problem is that there's a scale of this right and so as we move towards the modern age we start to have these technologies of attention we start to have these technologies of intelligence right and we also start to kind of
12:34
Speaker A
understand the possib the possibility of simply extending the power of the human in a prosthetic manner. there so that we are transhuman through supplement through external means. Now if the concept of the prosthetic is true that it will also be true of intelligent
12:57
Speaker A
technologies that is as AI increases our power to do all kinds of things it will atrophy the things it is supplementing.
13:10
Speaker A
And so as we as it embeds itself in all the structures that that of society, we are going to see young people become dumber.
13:21
Speaker A
This is almost inevitable as they outsource their thinking, as they outsource just for this. You know, when we were young, we had calculators that were given to us so we could use them in math. And they said, "This is
13:33
Speaker A
great. It's amazing." And it is great. Obviously, it's great. But I'll tell you something. My children, they don't know their multiplication tables, which maybe is fine. It's not a big deal if you don't know your multiplication tables. But what happens when you apply
13:48
Speaker A
that logic to reason, to decision-m, right, to discernment, to all of the things that make up intelligence, then we will see this atrophy happen.
14:05
Speaker A
And so if we understand this notion of the transhuman or the you know the the notion of artificial intelligence or super intelligence as Mr. Trump want wants to name it right now which is to me the one of the most frightening
14:21
Speaker A
things because it's exactly that move that we're afraid of. Right? It's exactly the move of the difference between artificial intelligence and super intelligence that worries me because super intelligence means that you have taken something that is a supplement and you have put it above
14:39
Speaker A
your head. You've taken something that is meant to increase your power and you have raised it up above you as something which is over you.
14:51
Speaker A
In the Old Testament, there's this weird idea that for a very long time I didn't understand, which is this idea that God says about the nations that they came to worship the works of their hands.
15:05
Speaker A
I remember thinking, what kind of idiots would do that? The stone age people would start to worship the work of their hands. You know, you made it. There it is. How could you start to worship it?
15:19
Speaker A
I mean interestingly enough now we're seeing what is happening that is that by confusing the vertical with the horizontal by confusing true wisdom and discernment and the capacity to know what is true and good and beautiful for power
15:40
Speaker A
then of course AI is more powerful than us. Of course, these technologies are more powerful and therefore the temptation the temptation immediately to lift it up above us.
15:56
Speaker A
What is the difference between most technologies are those that obey our commands. That's what they're for, right? So basically, I tell the technology what to do metaphorically and it does it. I sit in the car. I decide where I'm going. I
16:16
Speaker A
start the car and then I drive it to where I'm going. Okay. What happens when the technology is the one telling you where to go? We have inverted the relationship. We have inverted the relationship of technology and people are already doing it. It's
16:34
Speaker A
astounding to watch people on X invoke Grock. Grock, tell us what is true and what is real and we will submit to your will. Uh it's quite insane to see it happen uh so so fast. Um but this is of course a
16:54
Speaker A
temptation that is going to be looming on us. Just a few years ago, my daughter, she received we received an email from the the from the education department in Quebec and they were asking parents what they thought of AI
17:08
Speaker A
counselors. So, should your teenage student have an AI counselor? Obviously, right? They're objective. They don't have all of the faults that humans have. They won't be racist. They won't be this. They won't be that.
17:25
Speaker A
They'll be completely objective. And so, the the temptation to elevate technology above us. Not only is it coming, but it is in some ways already there. And my contention is that we have to remember what the true transhuman impulse is. We
17:48
Speaker A
have to remember what the true vertical change of the human person is. And really this is in some ways the only way that we are going to survive what is coming. If you've seen Brian Johnson, you know, trying to live forever, it's super
18:06
Speaker A
interesting because basically he has let that desire or that telos devour him completely. So he spends all his days, spends all his time, spends all his energy increasing years to his life.
18:26
Speaker A
That's the transhumanism that we're being asked to believe in. That in some ways we will exchange vertical for horizontal, right? We will exchange goodness and beauty and truth for power.
18:40
Speaker A
And my call to everyone is in some ways it's possible that we have an opportunity. It's possible that we have an opportunity right now to see the difference in some ways. some things that we took for granted, some ideas of
18:55
Speaker A
progress that we took for granted. This idea that progress is simple technological, you know, increase and that progress is just more power, more power, more power, right? I think that now is a moment where because of what's happening, we
19:10
Speaker A
have the capacity to reflect and to realize what is true progress, right? Is it horizontal or is it vertical? And I believe that those who ignore this and continue to move horizontally and simply embrace an increase of power will find
19:29
Speaker A
themselves slaves of the machine. The relationship of power will revert. Right? the the classic moolok situation in the Old Testament, which is that I'm willing to sacrifice my children for more power, but ultimately that God is going to devour me. And this is really
19:52
Speaker A
uh it's not a metaphor anymore, which is that AI is eating you. You know that, right?
20:02
Speaker A
You know why Chad GBT is cyclopantic? Because it needs you. Right? It needs your intelligence. It's actually eating your intelligence. It's the opposite of the matrix. You know, in the matrix, they told you that the humans are a battery for the AI.
20:20
Speaker A
That's not how it works. Ultimately, we are the intelligence of the AI and it needs our intelligence, and it feeds off of us, and it becomes more powerful as it trains on the things that we tell it is good.
20:36
Speaker A
And so this is of course at a very proximal level but that's now realize what that does at in a long term and what it means to in some ways become food for this machine. You know Marshall McLuhan said famously that we would
20:52
Speaker A
become the sexual reproduction organs of the beast right that we become the sexual reproduction organs of the machine. And in some ways those that don't look towards that verticality that don't develop the inner disciplines that the spiritual traditions teach us that's
21:10
Speaker A
what's going to happen. We will just become slaves of the machine. And so that is the little thing I wanted to share with you. And let's see if uh the students have anything to say about that.
21:30
Speaker A
Well, I mean, thank you for your wonderful talk and for coming to the ASA Union and UATX and giving us your time.
21:38
Speaker A
um in previous talks uh I'm remembering specifically the talk that you gave at ARC 2026 and you've echoed the same sentiment in past talks as well that you have this uh invocation perhaps a vocation maybe of telling people to go
21:54
Speaker A
to the church go back to church sort of shed their secularized lifestyles and return to a a proper religiosity we right now in America and across the world live in an increasingly secular society. Right? True religiosity has been on a say downward trend for
22:16
Speaker A
probably the past several hundred years ever since the enlightenment. In in that sense then how do you is there a kind of systematic solution that you can achieve to to reinstate the power of religion reinstate the power of
22:33
Speaker A
church on a kind of mass grand scale or is that lost to us now I I don't think you want that I don't anybody want that you know uh I I do believe that the only solution is personal ultimately that the only
22:50
Speaker A
solution ution is to become a saint. You know that the we say the blood of the martyrs are the seeds of the church.
22:57
Speaker A
Right? This idea that in some ways the way in which the church advances is actually through self-sacrifice and it is through participation. If we understand the church only as a political tool to arrive at our political means then we will just
23:15
Speaker A
increase the problem. Now it doesn't mean that Christianity doesn't have politics downstream from its from its participation but it is not its primal it's not its primal concern and so I I do see that in some ways we are in a
23:30
Speaker A
position that's closer to the early church in the sense that Christianity has become somewhat marginalized uh in society uh but that is also like I said an opportunity for for true participation in some ways true sacrifice because you know for most
23:45
Speaker A
people at least where I the for a young person in some ways to go to church is to really risk derision and to basically be mocked and by their own parents by the way uh who don't understand what is going on and so I
24:01
Speaker A
think that we kind of we need to lean into that and I think that all of these gestures are the kinds of discipline that we need to develop internally in order to be able to move forward in the
24:11
Speaker A
this kind of techno world that is developing Okay, you Mr. Pio, you mentioned that you think the solution is not one that is systemic but actually one more personal, more inward, the the process of beginning the the journey on the road to Damascus
24:26
Speaker A
perhaps for towards sanctification. Um, what what few steps would you encourage any young person watching this in living in the secular world that we do now to begin this journey in order to maybe encounter the divine perhaps one day and
24:40
Speaker A
then be able to orient themselves towards the uh vertical rather than horizontal? I say go to church. I've kind of said it many times. Just go to church, you know, and then you'll you'll you'll you know, I'm not the one like you'll meet the
24:51
Speaker A
person there. They'll take you on your way to kind of uh learn how to live this life. But I want to maybe formulate something really important is that you know this idea of systemic change you you have to be very careful to
25:04
Speaker A
understand it like every single change in human history was brought about by a handful of people. The idea that systems change is absolute hogwash. That's not how any of this works. And so the notion when I say that this is a personal
25:19
Speaker A
journey I'm not saying that it has no social connotation. I'm not saying that it has no ripples. But I'm saying the best thing you can do is become the best version of you. To become a human, to become a Christian, to become a to
25:32
Speaker A
become someone who lives in the image of God. And then you'll see that there will be a systemic transformation. It just won't happen through brute force, right?
25:42
Speaker A
Because those types of changes don't don't really yield anything. I'm I'm very curious on um where do you see where do you see your role in this religious revival that you advocate for?
25:57
Speaker A
What do you see your role as within that? H that's very hard to analyze oneself. But I I would say what I hope to do is I think I hope in some ways to be able to act somewhat as a bridge, right? Right.
26:12
Speaker A
And so if someone has followed what I do, I I kind of move between let's say the secular sphere speaking to cogsai people or talking to biologists or talking to artists or or you know kind of moving and then trying to translate
26:26
Speaker A
the language so people can understand what the religious categories are. One of the problems we have is that because of religious people by the way our religious categories have become so debased that no one knows what they mean
26:39
Speaker A
anymore. Right? So you know what is soul? what are we talking about? Like if you use the word love, everybody just cringes, right? And so the words have been debased. And so we kind of need a ramp. We need some kind of connection so
26:51
Speaker A
that people can start to understand the metaphysics of of religion, the, you know, the ontology that it proposes and that it's not just a bunch of arbitrary things that you somehow have to believe, you know, to go to heaven or whatever.
27:08
Speaker A
It seems as though often times when you have religious individuals speaking with secular ones, you're basically talking it in different languages. Uh the axiomatic differences are are so great that you know if I brought Brian Johnson into this room and he talked to you
27:24
Speaker A
about, you know, I'm going to extend life, everyone's going to be immortal, nobody's going to die of old age anymore, we're not going to get sick, and you ask him, why do you want to do that? He'd just kind of look at you with
27:33
Speaker A
a frown and he wouldn't understand the question. um just fundamentally because the values are different in that sense.
27:39
Speaker A
Then how do you actually talk to people in the secular world? How do you talk to to tech mogul? How do you talk to Elon Musk who who wants to go to Mars and wants to become an interplanetary
27:49
Speaker A
species, wants to have brain computer interfaces? Like what's the conversation you can have with them?
27:56
Speaker A
Uh with great difficulty is the only answer I can give you. You know, I think that, you know, in some ways there is also I'm sorry to say I don't want to say something derogatory about certain people, but like there's a pearls
28:07
Speaker A
there's a pearls to swine situation here, which is that, you know, there's no point in harassing someone who has no hunger to understand, right? And so if someone doesn't feel the existential pain, if someone doesn't feel the void,
28:23
Speaker A
doesn't doesn't feel it in their life, doesn't see it around them, doesn't feel it either personally or at least metaphysically, then there's nothing really you can say uh to to someone to someone who can't kind of put themselves
28:35
Speaker A
in that position. Um, and so my like the way that I do it is I simply speak and hopefully those that can understand will understand. Um, and I'll be honest with you, like the time that I have had the
28:46
Speaker A
chance to talk to some of these people, it I just hasn't been very fruitful.
28:50
Speaker A
It's been fruitful for me to understand, oh, that's what you want to do really, like you really do want to replace humans with with machines. Um, but it hasn't I don't think that it really hit uh, you know, my conversation with Peter
29:03
Speaker A
Teal, I don't think he liked me at the end of that conversation. Perhaps there's no hope with the ones without hunger. But what would you how would you encourage encourage perhaps parents of children? You mentioned many times in your speeches regarding
29:18
Speaker A
technology uh the stories and parables and mythologies of Babel and other other biblical uh symbols, but you've also mentioned as well Prometheus or Icarus or these these extra biblical stories.
29:30
Speaker A
Do you think that the classics perhaps might be a good jumping off point for encouraging this hunger in young people perhaps?
29:37
Speaker A
Yeah, for sure. I I do believe that we need to recapture our stories, you know, and we have a kind of universal history understanding of this, which is that in some ways my Christianity or the Christianity that I love is is as much
29:49
Speaker A
of, you know, is as much of Plato as it is of Homer and then ultimately it is of the Bible. But these things are do not they're in continuity for in my vision.
30:01
Speaker A
And so we we kind of need to recover all of these stories. And I think that the best way is also to not to not recover them as classics. There's something about that term that is like annoying in
30:13
Speaker A
the sense that there's a there's this idea that like the great books there's a bit of a problem with the great books which is that well here are these great books that you should read so you can be
30:20
Speaker A
a cultured individual. And I'm like yeah maybe. But like here are the stories you need to you need to know to be human. I like that much more. Right? Here are your stories, right? Here are the stories that your ancestors,
30:33
Speaker A
you know, uh died and and sweated over and painfully preserved so that here they are for you today. And now you can remember the stories, but not just the stories, but the fact that this is your golden thread, right? This is your
30:47
Speaker A
golden thread which connects you into the past and then gives you a vision of the future. This is to me. So I'm I'm a big advocate for example of oral storytelling of learning the stories by heart. So for example yes you should
30:59
Speaker A
read the Odyssey but you know if you can get your children to to memorize the sections of the Odyssey not the poem itself but the beats right the story beats so they can tell the story beats.
31:08
Speaker A
Same with the fairy tales same with all the stories you know to get them inside you so that they become a part of your your makeup they become a part of your psyche. Uh so this is in some ways a
31:18
Speaker A
it's not a literature approach it's really this idea that these are living stories. There structures of being that you have to integrate into what's your favorite story.
31:27
Speaker A
My favorite story. That's crazy. I mean [laughter] that's like that's like asking me. It's in a buffet. It's like your favorite story. I mean I don't have a favorite story. I would say that obviously I think the story of the Bible if I can be
31:41
Speaker A
arrogant and just say it's one story. I think that's the best story for sure 100%. You know, I think that Genesis 1:3 is is like just the most astounding text that's ever been put down on paper. It it contains the entire world inside of
31:55
Speaker A
it. Um, and I kind of weep at the when people don't see that. It's like that's one thing where I want to fight for and say, "Hey, this is the best text ever.
32:04
Speaker A
You have to pay attention to it." Uh, so for sure, I think the Bible stories, they definitely are at a different tier than the than the secular stories, though.
32:13
Speaker A
Um, so I'm curious about you you talk a lot about how our culture is becoming more secularized, more not as Christian as it as it once was.
32:27
Speaker A
66% of Americans self-identify as Christians. And I'm curious, what do you think is lacking among the American Christian population that we still have these problems if there still is a substantially large number of Christians in this country? Look, the truth about
32:46
Speaker A
America is that right now, I hate to say it, it's really the best case scenario, you know, because one of the pro from the outside, people look at America and say, look at this crazy people fighting amongst each other in terms of like the
32:59
Speaker A
culture war or whatever. The truth is that where I'm from there is no cult for war because we've just basically are a bunch of sheep following the story that is being told that we should follow. So we're just going just closing our eyes
33:13
Speaker A
and moving towards secularism without any kind of resistance. And it's the same thing happening in most of Europe.
33:19
Speaker A
And so I think that in fact you in America, you have enough froth left in you in some ways to be able to be the resistance we need for the future and to say like no, we're not going to go down
33:33
Speaker A
this direction. We are going to hold on. We are going to kind of to to find a way to celebrate this again in a way that is uh that is meaningful. And so, you know, the fact that to me, America in some
33:45
Speaker A
ways, you know, it's such it's such a weird case, but I I have a lot of hope actually and I actually have a lot of hope for the future because I'm seeing right now like in in our churches, I
33:56
Speaker A
can't speak for all the churches, but in the Orthodox church right now, we're bursting at the seams in America. Like our churches are exploding. We have no room. We have don't have enough priests.
34:05
Speaker A
We don't have enough buildings. You know, we're This is the problem that we're having. There there are parishes that have catechummen which means people that are inquiring to become uh orthodox. There are more catechummen than people in the church. So you have
34:19
Speaker A
100 people in the church you have 150 catechummen. So this is the problem we're having. So I actually have hope because and also the people that are converting now.
34:28
Speaker A
It's interesting because the people that are becoming Christian right now they're kind of the elite. They're usually educated university. They they they they they don't come at it like which is you know a lot of people let's say come to
34:42
Speaker A
faith because they bottom out right it's like you know I get to the end I'm a drunk I'm an alcoholic whatever I get to the end of it and then God catches me which is beautiful and wonderful that's
34:52
Speaker A
not what we're seeing here we're seeing young people that are experiencing an unease in terms of meaning and in terms of purpose but are usually successful they they they do well uh and so I actually I have hope you know for for
35:05
Speaker A
the future Yeah. Um, so you mentioned in your talk you brought up the the Matrix as well and I don't know how many juniors, sophomores, and certainly freshman have actually watched The Matrix. Sometimes I'm scorned when I mentioned Skynet and uh
35:22
Speaker A
Sarah Sarah didn't know what Skynet was. She never watched Terminator before. I don't even know if she knows who Arnold Schwarzenegger is.
35:28
Speaker A
I know. I know. And and so I don't know if maybe I'm the student that's like living in the past, but but either way, I'm reminded of the quote by Morpheus at the first Okay. [laughter] in the first Matrix movie where he tells
35:44
Speaker A
Neo, you know, we marveled at our own genius as we gave birth to AI. Um, do you think that the the adoration, the idol worship perhaps that we have a tendency of of of applying to AI is actually a love of ourselves because we
36:00
Speaker A
know that we've created AI? Okay, I'll tell you I'll tell you what I think it is. I think that it is it is the Prometheian logic playing itself out. Right? So in in Hessi the not just the Prometheian logic but
36:17
Speaker A
in some ways the pagan logic of a revolutionary structure. So in Hessi the order of the gods is revolutionary.
36:25
Speaker A
So the gods emerge from chaos right and then the chaos the mother castrates the father right with the help of her son in order to establish her son as the leader of the gods. Then immediately the son devours his children because he's afraid
36:43
Speaker A
that he's also going to be castrated. Right? So the order the in the Bible the order is affiliation. Right? That is the the order that God establishes is a continuation of his will and the proper order lays itself out according to his
36:58
Speaker A
will. And so it's an order of affiliation and an order of love. In the pagan world, especially in the Greek old old pagan world, it's a structure of revolution. And the modern world has taken up this vision of revolution. The
37:12
Speaker A
story of Prometheus. People don't know the story of Prometheus. There's they build a stupid giant like statue of Prometheus outside of SpaceX with his flame up. He's got the fire of the gods. All right. Do you know the story of Prometheus? Right. Did
37:29
Speaker A
you know that the humans already had the fire before the story starts? that the humans had the fire of the gods and they were meant to offer sacrifice in gratitude to the gods. But Prometheus tricked the gods. He said, "Ah, come on.
37:47
Speaker A
You don't need to really offer sacrifice. No, take the meat out. Just eat it. Put some skin and some bones there. The gods won't see the difference. Just light the fire. Offer the offer that it's fine." It's when the humans followed Prometheus
38:02
Speaker A
in offering a fake sacrifice, right? A kind of cheap sacrifice that the gods took the fire from the humans.
38:12
Speaker A
And that's when Prometheus then climbs the mountain in revolution to go get it back and to act as the great hero, the great herald that was going to give humans the possibility of developing their civilization.
38:28
Speaker A
And what's the punishment of Prometheus, right? He gets strapped to a rock face and every day his liver grows and uh eagle comes and eats his liver, right?
38:40
Speaker A
So because of that revolution, he falls into what we could call the cycle of desire, right? The cycle of passions.
38:46
Speaker A
He's basically become a slave of his own body, a slave of his own desires, right? And so this is like to me this is what I think the this playing out is that I think that the revolutionary act has a
39:03
Speaker A
secret in it which is a yearning for our own castration. That's what I think. I think that once we revolt and once we take the fire we kind of expect it to happen to us. And the thing about The
39:16
Speaker A
Matrix, which is hilarious, is that although The Matrix, the first movie is presented as a kind of revolutionary gesture, the last Matrix movie, which was horrible.
39:29
Speaker A
All of a sudden, wait a minute, the robots are kind of the good guys now, right? The AI is kind of kind of the good guys. So I think that there is a desire in humans in this Prometheian
39:40
Speaker A
gesture to be replaced by the things they make because they themselves tried to grab it for themselves. [snorts] It's the it's the it's it's Freud like it's the idea that this is how continuation continues is through castration and replacement rather than
39:56
Speaker A
affiliation. Right? The the the biblical God presents a world a world where a son is able to represent their father.
40:05
Speaker A
Right? the son is able to act for their father and to become a kind of image of the father in the world of obviously that's the image of Christ. Um but the tech world has a secret desire and think
40:16
Speaker A
about like I'm I'm sorry but think about the wowskis where do you think they really want to live?
40:28
Speaker A
They do. They want to live in the outer world where everything is difficult and hard and painful and you hit against the difficulty of reality or do they want to live in a matrix where you can be whatever you want to be and you can make
40:44
Speaker A
yourself into whatever you want to make want to be made into. And the answer is the Wowskis have clearly chosen the matrix themselves.
40:53
Speaker A
And I've actually heard one of the Wowskis say why the matrix is so great and exactly that's what they said the self like just completely unconscious of themselves saying that in the matrix you can be whatever you want right so
41:08
Speaker A
sorry for that was a long answer I'm sorry I mean it seems to mirror a lot of like the American sentiment too of you can you can be whatever you want and when you grow up you can you can achieve
41:17
Speaker A
that American dream but at least in America perhaps that is that has come out a little more positively though maybe in a more secular sense. Um but but the this is sorry this is the thing about I understand why we tell our children
41:35
Speaker A
you could be whatever you want to be. That's that's fine. There's nothing wrong with that. But we should ultimately be asking we should al ultimately be teaching them to serve what needs to be served rather than be whatever you want to be. that is put
41:49
Speaker A
your strength in the service of something that transcends you. that is more important and that actually it gives our life meaning right it actually makes us feel like we're part of something when instead of thinking about what it is that I want and what it is
42:03
Speaker A
that I want to do what it is that I want to be rather understanding how can I participate in this greater project how can I serve uh how can I serve something that is more than myself you mentioned making sure that children
42:16
Speaker A
are encouraged to serve something that transcends them um it's quite interesting that uh the orthodox view on theosis, right? Becoming like God in life and nature, but of course not not in the Godhead. Um it it seems to to
42:31
Speaker A
imply the fact that there is something within man that desires to to transcend himself. Um could you would you would you describe transhumanism as a confusion of this of this innate desire built in?
42:44
Speaker A
Yeah. The transhuman grabs the apple on the tree. It's pretty simple. It's like it's like there's a reason why there's the apple with a bite on it on your phone.
42:54
Speaker A
And Steve Jobs knows exactly what he was doing. By the way, like I'm not making this up. You know, I was actually watching a talk by Paul Kings North and Paul Kings North was talking about Steve Jobs and he had an
43:06
Speaker A
image of him up on the wall and and I looked at the image and I saw behind him of Steve Jobs there was a photo of Adam and Eve being chased from paradise that he had pinned on his wall and it was the
43:18
Speaker A
only image that he had pinned on his wall was Adam and Eve being chased from paradise. So Steve Jobs was exactly what he was doing. That's it. It's the grabbing. That's the problem. That's the difference between true transhuman
43:28
Speaker A
transformation and a kind of fake or factitious trans trans uh transhumanism according to the according to the Christian tradition right there in St.
43:41
Speaker A
Ephron or St. Urnes of Leon very early there's this idea that if Adam and Eve had not grabbed the fruit for themselves that God would have given them the fruit that that was exact that was actually the purpose the purpose was that they
43:55
Speaker A
would receive their participation in God from God and not grasp it as something to own and to something to have for yourself. And that is the difference between the true transhuman transformation which is done in self-sacrifice and in humility where we
44:12
Speaker A
become God in part through participation but not by grasping it not by increasing our power artificially. And so in some ways the the transhumans of today they are just they look at the story of the garden of Eden and they're like yes that
44:25
Speaker A
they did exactly what needed to be done. You just had to grab it for yourself right so that you would increase your power.
44:34
Speaker A
So you've talked about how the change needs to come on a personal level and what I'm curious about is ho how does changing it on a personal level affect the actual incentives to that are driving the uh AI innovation and the
44:50
Speaker A
transhumanist thought like for example like most of these investors who who are pouring loads and loads of money into these AI startups are doing so uh for the profit incentive of reducing the need for human labor, human capital. And I'm curious about how
45:09
Speaker A
you think that change on the individual level is enough because I I would be inclined to believe that this needs to be some sort of systemic change that needs to happen.
45:21
Speaker A
I'm sorry. I'm a pessimist on that front. I'm a I always say I'm a I'm a I'm a short-term pessimist, long-term optimist. Uh I don't think we're going to we're going to change anything on the systemic front. like we are locked in
45:32
Speaker A
the Moolok trap. We are absolutely locked. There's no way around whatever the hell is going to happen is going to happen. Um and so I do believe that in the in the light of that that is knowing that this is there's no way back at this
45:47
Speaker A
point. Uh I can I can tell you why I think that's the case if you're interested. But like I think that the only thing we can do at that point is like build an arc, right?
45:58
Speaker A
is that is in some ways to gather things around us and in some ways to be a living example of difference of of this system. So that's why I say it's an individual work and you know and obviously that individual work then
46:12
Speaker A
leaks into your family and then leaks into your immediate community, your parish, your synagogue like whatever is close to you then those transformations also kind of gather people around that.
46:24
Speaker A
Um and and ultimately I think that no matter what happens because we don't know exactly how it's going to play out like this AI thing is we don't know how but no matter what happens whether we have AI overlords as Amod wish says is
46:38
Speaker A
the best case scenario whether that happens whether maybe AI actually just becomes a kind of ubiquitous tool that just exists at the bottom of society and people just kind of continue to do what they do those that will have done the
46:50
Speaker A
work internally they will be the ones that will shine in that world right so it doesn't even if AI becomes ubiquitous and is used everywhere those that don't transform themselves they'll just become slaves they'll just become nodes of the
47:05
Speaker A
machine they'll just become intelligence feeding into the into the machine and those that don't then then maybe ultimately maybe they'll be the ones master actually running it like they'll be the ones mastering AI because they will have at least a kind of a certain
47:19
Speaker A
vertical perspective to be able to understand what is happening around us, you know. So, to me, like there this is the solution no matter what happens. And maybe it's the solution all the time.
47:28
Speaker A
Maybe that's what we should always do. But at least in this case, it seems like this is a more precise moment where this has to be the case.
47:36
Speaker A
Well, should we not at least try to stop it while we can? Give me give me uh give me give me a few ideas here.
47:43
Speaker A
Fair I mean fair enough. I mean I mean just seriously like if you have ideas I mean please you know I you know this is the thing that so look I mean you've noticed what's going on.
47:56
Speaker A
So the danger of AI and the fear of AI that is being stoked by the AI companies themselves is the way in which those very companies are taking power. You understand that at this point right? But you understand
48:12
Speaker A
that anthropic saying AI is dangerous, but we're still going to do it is making their power more set in stone because they are going to in some ways prevent they're going to ally themselves with whatever legislating body is going to
48:31
Speaker A
control it and they they will continue their ascent. And so there's no I don't see I really don't see sadly I don't see a way out of whatever it is that's coming down the down the line with with
48:46
Speaker A
AI. Um, sorry, anybody has an idea, you know, maybe the calculus changes then at that point, right? Like if you know that uh an age of darkness is inevitable, so to speak, um, then your goal is to either
49:08
Speaker A
shorten the period of time, and you say that you're you're a long-term optimist. So presumably that would mean that there is some age of light appearing after the darkness. Um hopefully but for some at least for some Well, that's interesting because your
49:20
Speaker A
goal is either then to to reduce the harm that that period of darkness uh has on society um or to reduce the period of time that it occurs for. So I'd be curious as to like what you know what
49:36
Speaker A
can we do in in these less ambitious cases rather than preventing the period of darkness at all. And also you know if if for example uh Sora Kirkagard writes in the the middle of the the 19th century about the a period of reflection
49:52
Speaker A
he calls this the reflective age that he's living in as opposed to the age of of action the age of revolution uh in times past and he doesn't think that there's really any solution to the age of reflection. This is the age of the
50:04
Speaker A
like one big long board meeting where a lot of stuff gets talked about but nothing actually gets done. Right? the reflective nature of talking with each other and talking about how great it would be to do action and virtue
50:15
Speaker A
signaling to your comrades is much better than actually any doing anything at all. Um but he doesn't think there's any solution proper solution perfect solution to this issue. He but he does believe that there's a potential that individuals can find within themselves
50:33
Speaker A
uh perhaps through a deep inwardness um and find again religiosity a a Christian revival find in themselves what truly makes them human what what defines their identity what kind of a person what kind of how do we how do we make those kinds of
50:50
Speaker A
people is that even the right question can we make those kinds of people yes of course the you know it's Great because most of you hopefully will be parents. So you can yeah make those kinds of people. They're call your
51:00
Speaker A
children. You can really do that. It's really possible. And so and so yeah I'm not I'm not I'm not hopeless but I do think that the Kirkagard example is a good one which is that it's good to know
51:12
Speaker A
the real it's good to understand the situation. It's kind of good to know where we are and what what it is that's happening the world in which we're in and then in some ways become the best type of person to exist in that time.
51:24
Speaker A
And so there the we don't want to be deliluded about what it is we're doing.
51:28
Speaker A
Um you know and I and I do think that in some ways there is there is a kind of inward movement that does need to happen uh in terms of a person and it's good because obviously we're all addicted to
51:42
Speaker A
our phones anyway. So we kind of need this even just for our immediate life of being addicted to these machines to kind of develop an inner life and a and a silence and discipline and fasting and all the things that we kind of need to
51:56
Speaker A
develop but then in some ways to to let's say uh perpetuate that in your family into the in the people around you. And so there are all kinds of things that you you can do. Um know one of the things that I advocate for
52:09
Speaker A
example is meals together like we're you know I'm participating with several people in the Orthodox world with this a kind of revival of feasting tradition which is to have feasts to invite people to your house to have feasts to have uh
52:26
Speaker A
toasts to kind of have this kind of celebratory thing. seems like something that's very simple but these are just little examples of things we can do in some ways to resist becoming just basic to basic uh to becoming robots for the
52:40
Speaker A
for the AI. Now look if you are someone who ends up in a position of power of legislative power then I think that you should do all you can to reduce obviously the harm that these that these things are doing to us. I do believe
52:56
Speaker A
that you know I'm not a libertarian. I do believe that laws that would find a way or at least not maybe state laws but communal laws that would find a way to reduce the use of phones in children is
53:09
Speaker A
great. Like my my uh girls in high school they finally what two years ago they finally took the phones out of the classrooms and it was amazing. I swear in six months we're having friends over.
53:24
Speaker A
my daughter was like having her friends over at the house and all of a sudden they're like going out and doing all these activities. It took like six months. Didn't take very long. And so it's not like, you know,
53:35
Speaker A
the the thing about about a lot of these tools is that they're really against our natures.
53:40
Speaker A
And so the our human nature is just just on the other side of it. You can still invite people to your house and that's so easy. It's like right there. It's right in front of you. So, it's not like
53:51
Speaker A
these solutions are they're difficult because we're so addicted, but they're not difficult because they're actually so close to who we are. You can just do it and go have, you know, have breakfast with your the people you love. Like, go
54:03
Speaker A
and do things with people. You know, Mr. Pio, you mentioned that these tools are against our nature. And many people would categorize AI as just that, a tool. But you've mentioned before again this the story of Moldok. This is this
54:16
Speaker A
this actual god that people end up sacrificing to on the horizontal when they should be focusing on the vertical.
54:23
Speaker A
When does a tool become an idol? I mean obviously when it speaks you know [laughter] you know if you guys some of you might have seen my arc speech but before the arc speech I was actually in the green
54:38
Speaker A
room with a lot of these people like some of the heads of anthropic and everything and uh I asked them two questions. First question is I just asked them why are we doing this which really didn't go over well. I think they
54:50
Speaker A
looked at me like I was a heretic of some kind. But then I thought maybe I'll ask like a second question which is not as provocative. And I I and I asked I said why are we giving it a personality?
55:01
Speaker A
And I don't think they have an answer for that either. Right? It's a why are we give why are we giving it a personality? Why are we you know we've had Google search for years.
55:11
Speaker A
It's never it's never been sickantic. it's never tried to like get you to stay on. You know what's going on. So there's something this is I think where we see like the flip which is that if a technology tells you what to do and if a
55:28
Speaker A
technology is giving you advice and if a technology in some ways is trying to keep you in its in its train, right, to kind of keep you going, then obviously the we should start asking questions about what it is that what it is that we're dealing
55:44
Speaker A
with here, you know? Oh, you know, and then when we know that the people that are making it, most many of them really think that it's there to replace us, right? So, this is not like conspiracy wild conspiracy theory. This is what
55:57
Speaker A
they're saying. This is what Amuay is saying in his in his best version of AI.
56:02
Speaker A
They become benevolent overlords and we return to nature. And so, it's not like, how can I say this? Like, that's what they're trying to make. They're trying to make a god.
56:14
Speaker A
They might not use that word, but that's ultimately what they're trying to do. And so, we have to definitely be attentive, you [snorts] know, and I'm not saying don't use AI at this point.
56:23
Speaker A
It's kind of too late. You know, if you don't if you don't somehow engage with it and find the way that you're going to engage with it, you know, you're going to I mean, it's fine if you want to be a
56:33
Speaker A
hermit. You're just going to kind of go vanish down into the into the background. But we definitely should ask ourselves questions, constant questions.
56:46
Speaker A
If it seems a question firstly that whether or not the created can become greater than the creator.
56:56
Speaker A
Um so whether or not our sublation to AI is ultimately sublation to something that's lesser than us. Can silicon become not even God at this point but but even equivalent to a human being? Um or perhaps uh we think that no it can't be a human
57:12
Speaker A
being but that it can serve as a as a kind of conduit so to speak for the demonic intelligences like is that is that true? Is that actually what we're facing? Man tough questions here. Uh I don't want to scare anybody with the
57:26
Speaker A
answers that are sound weird to people. So um so the answer is no. Metaphysically the things that we make cannot become greater than us. And this is this is to me is very categorical. It's obviously because I'm a Christian that I say that.
57:44
Speaker A
But this is what I talked about in terms of the pagan understanding the revolutionary trope with rather than a an order of reality which is affiliation. Right? If you believe in a revolutionary trope, if you believe that the world is founded on revolutions,
58:00
Speaker A
then yes, that's what they think. They do believe that just like we replace the gods, then the AI will replace us, right? Just like we were able to subject like think about what happened in the enlightenment. We were able to make the
58:14
Speaker A
gods a projection of the human psyche. We were able to subject the gods to our psyche and that was the plan. And so people who did that would not be surprised if the like that we would be reduced that we would in
58:31
Speaker A
some ways be uh that the AI would come over us and take over take over us like it's not a it's not a problem if you have that metaphysics. Um now in terms of whether or not the AI can become a
58:43
Speaker A
portal for the demonic. So uh okay. So the the this is there is there is a a way in which the way that AI functions looks like divination. This is inevit like this is just real like if you look
59:04
Speaker A
at traditional divination techniques you will see that it is usually based on the um the creation of some kind of chaos right. So in some ways you kind of generate randomness and then you peer into that randomness and the seer
59:20
Speaker A
obviously based within a tradition of being the seer will let's say with their intuition will be able to discern patterns in that randomness. Okay, now this is how AI was trained, right? You you know that. So AI generates
59:39
Speaker A
randomness and then someone says good, bad, good, bad, good, bad. Do that a million times, you know, cat, not cat, cat, not cat, more like a cat, less like a cat. And then as it just does that iteratively over and over, then at some
59:53
Speaker A
point then it comes to meaning, right? So there is uh definitely a relationship between divination and what AI is doing.
60:03
Speaker A
[snorts] Uh best case scenario can help us understand that the people doing divination in the past weren't complete idiots that there was actually something they were tapping into some kind of process of the human psyche that they were kind of doing. Um but the the the
60:18
Speaker A
relationship of the divination to the way in which divination can invoke some kind of spirit. Think of a Ouija board, right? So you you bunch of people, you put your hands on the thing and then you ask a question and because
60:33
Speaker A
you're not one person because you're many people in some ways you can catch an answer, right? So you don't know what you're doing and you end up manifesting an answer. But the the way that it works is not the machine, right? It's not the
60:49
Speaker A
Ouija board that's doing it. It's the interaction between the Ouija board, the people that are holding the thing, but then also all of their unconscious imagination structure that is common across all humans. And so the way in which AI can come to become like a
61:06
Speaker A
portal for demons is not so much in the machine, right? It's in all of the different interactions that are around it. So I know this sounds very weird what I'm saying but think about the way that we describe the molloc trap. This
61:22
Speaker A
is a way of understanding it. So the moolok trap is this idea that because of competition, right? We are forced to enact AI even knowing that it might destroy us because we're afraid that our enemies will beat us at the game. Right? So we
61:42
Speaker A
know it's dangerous and we implement it nonetheless and so the Chinese and the Americans become like two legs, right? So we're afraid of the Chinese. So we put our leg forward and then they put their leg forward and then we just keep going. And
61:58
Speaker A
in the meantime, everybody says, "Hey, this could kill everyone." But we just keep doing it, right? And so this is the way in which AI can become a vehicle for the demonic is that it's not the machine. It's all
62:14
Speaker A
of the process around it. All of the mechanisms, the social mechanism, the political mechanisms, the economic mechanisms become the vehicle for a spirit that nobody controls, right? So nobody is controlling AI now.
62:27
Speaker A
It's just moving on its own and it's being fed by a will because it's moving in a direction. There's a will that's making it move forward. We don't totally know what that will is. We don't totally understand what it wants. Well, we can't
62:42
Speaker A
stop it, right? It just keeps going. And so, this is because the problem with saying like, could it become a portal for the demonic? It's like all these horror movie scenarios come up and you see someone with their eye machine and
62:53
Speaker A
like a demon comes out of the screen or whatever. Like, this is not what we're talking about. Like, we're talking about something that is already happening with AI. It's already becoming a portal for a spirit that we cannot control that is in
63:06
Speaker A
some ways controlling us. Now, can it also become the portal for other types of spirits besides something like the spirit of Moch? The answer is of course obviously in a very similar way. I don't know which ones and I don't know how
63:18
Speaker A
it's going to happen, but we've seen it happen before, right? We've seen it happen with many technologies. Facebook, we saw it happen with Facebook. You know, Facebook basically became a portal for Aries and it and it and it didn't didn't even
63:33
Speaker A
do it on purpose. All they wanted was money. All they wanted was money and your attention. And because of that, they realized without even realizing it, the algorithm itself made rage the motor of Facebook. And rage became the way
63:49
Speaker A
that it gathered your attention and kept your attention and kept you glued to it.
63:53
Speaker A
And so, did Facebook become the portal for a demonic? Yeah. But it's not like it's how can I say it's not a it's not just like a magic.
64:02
Speaker A
It's not something that it's not like something you see in a movie. It's something that's it's just more real.
64:07
Speaker A
Like it's actually embedded in how these these processes can can get out of control. So I'm really curious about how you would define human nature. You've talked about human nature this talk and in previous talks and I'm I'm very curious because I
64:25
Speaker A
feel like it's a very broad term. You could you could say that I you could argue that AI is the the development of AI is human nature because we naturally develop societies which naturally develop technology which naturally advances. And I I'm just curious how you
64:40
Speaker A
would define that. Yeah. So I I define human nature, you know, in a very kind of biblical way as the mediator between heaven and earth.
64:50
Speaker A
That is that humans are the beings in this world that are both made of animal bodies but also have the capacity to see and to make and to participate in patterns in a way that is conscious.
65:08
Speaker A
Right? And so the say the what one of the things that distinguishes us from the animals is that we name the animals and the animals don't name us. Right?
65:16
Speaker A
And that is that is a main key. And so this is what humans do. And so humans are able to intuit it, see participate in patterns and then are able to embody them in their body but then are also
65:28
Speaker A
like you said able in some ways to exteriorize those patterns and then grow the body of that pattern. Right. So we humans are the only beings that create cities that are analogous to the human but on a scale that is greater. And it's
65:45
Speaker A
because of our capacity to mediate these these things. Um and so you could say that in some ways the act of creating and of naming is a natural aspect of the human. In in Genesis God tells Adam that that's his role naming
66:01
Speaker A
naming the animals. Now again the the problem with that thing is that when we grab it for itself that is this capacity in some ways to implement patterns when we do it only for the sake of power is when it starts to turn
66:18
Speaker A
against us right instead instead of doing it out of service out of love you could say then we trying to we do it in terms of power then ultimately the surprise is that we end up serving the thing that we
66:33
Speaker A
we end up becoming a slave. And this is true obviously not just true of AI, it's true of bureaucracy for goodness sake, right? So we have we have these technical systems that we set up and if we're not careful then we end up
66:46
Speaker A
becoming we become a servants of the system rather than the system serving us. This flip happens constantly in human history, right? you you see it happen where we set up something to kind of organize us and then ultimately we
66:58
Speaker A
end up worshiping it and we end up in some way thinking that we're that it's that we're there for it and it's not there for for the good of the the people. So that's the problem I think with with a lot of these systems is that
67:09
Speaker A
they they they fall into that trap, you know, and so is there the question is is there a version of AI that would be good? I think I think theoretically yes.
67:22
Speaker A
I think theoretically yes. Uh but that's not the one that is being implemented right now. Yeah.
67:29
Speaker A
Finally, do you have any words for that singular individual who has the chance to partake upon the faith journey to take that leap of faith? Do you have any words for them to to help them not lose hope perhaps to
67:47
Speaker A
help them find beauty in Christianity or in whatever life path that they ultimately choose?
67:55
Speaker A
You know, I would say obviously if you're interested in the life of faith, then don't do it on your own. That's the first thing. That's why I say go to church. When I say go to church, I know
68:02
Speaker A
it sounds trit, but what I'm saying is you need to join a community because that's also one of the aspects of the spiritual life is to not is to someways join in love with people, you know, that are directed in the same direction that
68:14
Speaker A
you are, right? That are worshiping the same god that you are worshiping. So I think that that that is really the best solution I can I can give especially now especially in the world of YouTube and the world of online worlds. Like I know
68:26
Speaker A
my life is online. I do make videos online but hopefully no one just lives their Christianity you know on the screen. You you want to kind of live it out in the world and with others. So great. Thank you so much. I think uh
68:40
Speaker A
we're on student questions. [applause] So again, keep them brief. Keep them kind of need more I I thought I'd get more push back from the AI people.
68:55
Speaker A
[laughter] Uh keep them brief, keep them one question and all. I'm going to liberally use the gavl because I've been given the power. So Corbin.
69:04
Speaker A
Okay. The concern seems not to be will AI be the one that enslaves us, but what Jesus and Rouso and the Wakowski sisters teach you is that you are already enslaved. You already serve a master. So what is the master you would have us
69:21
Speaker A
serve? What is the icon we should raise above our heads? Who is the true God?
69:27
Speaker A
Yeah, I mean obviously I'm a Christian so I would think I would say Christ. I think that I think that the image of Christ is really the only image that is that makes sense of of hierarchy because we realize that we need hierarchy. We
69:41
Speaker A
kind of need things to be ordered in a certain way. But the problem is of with hierarchy obviously is the problem of the tyrant. The problem is that soon as someone gets in that spot then they start to abuse their power. And so what
69:52
Speaker A
Christians have done is they put they've put someone who died. They put someone who was abused and was crucified as the top of the hierarchy. So the image of the hierarchy is a self-mping image, right? It's the image of hierarchy as
70:08
Speaker A
self-giving and as self-sacrifice. So then the role of the father doesn't just become the kind of tyrant that rules over his household, but rather becomes a leader that offers himself to those that are under his care in in love. And so
70:22
Speaker A
that's what I think uh you know that's what I think the the really the solution is. Yeah.
70:29
Speaker A
Please introduce yourself as well. By the way, I'm Emma. Thank you for your talk. We are debating in our comedy class about the morality of comedy and we read a Protestant pmic against the comedy the country wife. Both the Protestant and
70:43
Speaker A
the playwright seem to be pointing to the fallenness of human nature. The Protestant rebuked the playwright for shaming shamelessly showing that human nature on display i.e. cheating, cuckoldery and innuendo. Is there a form of story that even if it reflects
70:58
Speaker A
reality is harmful and should be avoided? [clears throat] Um everything in its place. That's what I believe. And so I think that every traditional culture in the history of the world has always had a place for mocking, a place for inversion, a place
71:18
Speaker A
for, you know, the king's gesture that kind of reminds you of the imperfection of a system. And I think that that that's what one of the roles of comedies is to in some ways expose aspects of reality that we keep hidden some with
71:33
Speaker A
good reason. But you don't obviously want that to be the center of your culture. It has to be kind of a the carnival has to be this the the kind of the moments on the edge where this is
71:44
Speaker A
going to happen. So that's what I would that's what I would say is that obviously one of the problems we have is that we we don't have this idea like we don't have this idea that everything kind of has its place. But these types
71:57
Speaker A
of of plays um they they were there in the middle ages already like they were these you know there are these the these bands that would go around and during carnival type periods would put on these plays that would have we body would have
72:10
Speaker A
all this kind of sexual humor and I'm not saying I know it's weird it's like you're Christian you think that's okay I don't think it's okay I think it's inevitable and it should be there in the margins uh but you shouldn't put it up
72:22
Speaker A
on the pedestal maybe thank you. Hello, I'm Nathan. Thank you for your speech. If we have to choose between biological transhumanism and robotic transhumanism, which one would we do?
72:39
Speaker A
That's a I I reject the premise. I mean, I don't know. It's like one of those questions like why would I accept that premise?
72:45
Speaker A
What's which is a lesser evil then? Um okay. I mean, let let me the I would say that the robotic transhumanism is the lesser evil. Um because you can always even if it's painful, remove the prosthetic, you know, uh but some of the
73:04
Speaker A
stuff that the transhuman people are talking about, uh that's can't that's irreversible. And so, you know, the the the the kind of the the the playing around with DNA and the transformation of the of the human person, I think that
73:20
Speaker A
that will yield monsters that we will regret for a very long time. And so, although I don't like robots, I think I prefer robots to monsters.
73:31
Speaker A
Thank you. Howdy. My name is Noah. Have I seen you? [laughter] Okay. So, you I know you compared uh grasping for these technologies kind of like I hope I understood you correctly here. Kind of like grasping for the fruit of the
73:52
Speaker A
knowledge of good and evil. Um and you said the true transformation happens on the inside. But I'm curious why it needs to happen on the inside. Why can't these transformations say of our knowledge appear and manifest physically like why
74:06
Speaker A
shouldn't that also why would you make this comparison if we were never prohibited from going through yeah so I mean a good think about a child right so a child grows up and there are two aspects to what the child
74:19
Speaker A
in its development on the one hand the child is developing its faculties to discern and to have wisdom and to you to know what's good and bad and to be able to to to deal with that. And on the
74:31
Speaker A
other hand, their body is growing, right? And so they're becoming stronger, they have more power, they're able to do more things, right? And it comes a moment when the child is strong enough to break things, right? The child can
74:41
Speaker A
grab things, break things, throw things, turn things over. And what we want is we want the wisdom and the discernment of the child to equal their body, right?
74:54
Speaker A
Because if that doesn't happen, then you have a little Tasmanian devil like that's going around breaking things.
75:00
Speaker A
Sorry, that's an old reference. Uh it's going around breaking things, right? So this is the problem is that if we only understand transhumanism as an increase of power and we don't have this idea that there is an ascent or a a increase
75:14
Speaker A
in wisdom, then we will have very naive and unwise powerful people, right? and and we're going to think we're going to think that going to Mars is the solution to the human problem.
75:29
Speaker A
And then we're going to find that all the problems that we have here are going to be in Mars also. It's not like if we go to Mars that all the problems that we're facing here are going to go away,
75:39
Speaker A
you know, and so we'll have very powerful things that don't know where they're going. Like a child that can hit things but has no idea what to choose to do, right? Okay. So, I think that that's it.
75:53
Speaker A
That makes sense. All right. Thank you. My name is Peter. Thank you for your talk. Uh, at UETX, there's an emphasis on both learning the classics as well as learning how to use the new technology.
76:06
Speaker A
Like, we're we're reading The Republic while while vibe cutting companies. Um, to me, this feels like we're trying to grow both horizontally and vertically. Um, is it possible to gain both enlightenment and power? And are there any consequences?
76:25
Speaker A
No, I think I think that it is definitely possible. I think it's theoretically possible, you know, and I think that there are moments in history where you've you've seen that happen, but I I do believe that, you know, I mean, I think that this
76:39
Speaker A
moment that we're in is a particular one, which is that we've spent the last few centuries evacuating the entire wisdom tradition of the West. And it just happens that now is the moment where we're making giant robots. And
76:55
Speaker A
we've spent the last few centuries evacuating every wisdom and language that we have to talk about non-human intelligence. And it just happens to be now that we're making one. And so this is the problem is that we we in some
77:08
Speaker A
ways so I I think that what UATX is doing is amazing. Thank God that if you're able in some ways to kind of bring these worlds together, I think that's great. But I do think that the challenge is very great because power is
77:20
Speaker A
very compelling. Power is convincing because it does stuff, right? Philosophers don't do stuff. And so it's like so so the so the people that do stuff and it works, it's like, yeah, they just caught that rocket. It's like
77:35
Speaker A
that's amazing. They caught the rocket. It's like I can see it. Look, it's there. They caught the rocket. It's like this amazing thing. And so that's the problem is that power is very compelling because it works, right? Um, but I would
77:48
Speaker A
say kudos to UATX for like trying to find a way to kind of bring to bring those two paths together.
77:56
Speaker A
Thank you. My name's Eli. Thank you for being here. I was just I was just curious kind of what your personal approach to using AI was. How do you use it without kind of going too far down the rabbit hole?
78:10
Speaker A
Yeah, I man it's it's every day like trying to figure out how we do this, right? And so I think that I definitely I use it in two ways, right? I use it as a research assistant basically and then
78:24
Speaker A
I use it as an editor. And so if I'm working on you I don't you I use it mostly for writing. So if I'm doing if I'm preparing a talk or something, I'll say I'll like all right you know I
78:35
Speaker A
remember Plato said this. I'll just ask me okay can you find it? Where is it in the dialogues? and they'll give me the things and I'll say, "Hey, you know, can you find another thinker that has analogy?" So, I'll use it as a research
78:46
Speaker A
assistant. Uh, and then as an editor mostly just to to check to see like is are there problems in logic in what I'm saying and everything. That's the way I use it. In our company, we do have a harness that
78:59
Speaker A
we use in symbolic world, right? Um, and we use it for all the the kind of the stuff that's related to numbers, you know, tracking the expenses, all that.
79:09
Speaker A
We do the all the more kind of automated stuff but even that like even our harness that we use for symbolic world it's pretty wild. So we named them Tallalows obviously you guys will know why. So we named Natalos who was the
79:23
Speaker A
robot that was uh defending Creed in the antiquity, right? So there's this robot defending Creit. So we named Talos and we asked House to make an avatar for himself just so he could on Slack, right? So he could know where that he
79:36
Speaker A
is. And he gave himself a halo. And so then I was like, why did you give, you know, I said, did you give yourself a halo? And he was like, well, he's like, I don't know. he couldn't access the image or whatever. So I said,
79:52
Speaker A
"Make another one." And he made another one. And he gave himself a halo again.
79:56
Speaker A
And [clears throat] so I had to like tell him, "Then you can't give yourself a halo." Like halos are for holy people.
80:01
Speaker A
You're not a holy person. So you know, even in like So everything's kind of, you know, everything's kind of iffy.
80:08
Speaker A
Thank you. Shut it all down now. That's where it all began. Hello, sir. My name is Jonah. Thank you for being here. you talked a lot about this kind of like call to action of like how we must explore um you know like
80:24
Speaker A
spiritual growth and so you talked a lot about people who are beginning that journey but I was wondering what thoughts you have for people who maybe are a little bit farther along that um who like aren't starting like like
80:36
Speaker A
people like me like I've been a Christian my whole life but I still would like to know like in this context what I should do to kind of um further that growth Mhm.
80:46
Speaker A
Um, you know, I mean, I think that you're here is an opportunity in some ways to kind of further your understanding of theology. I think that it's really important for young people today to kind of understand that Christianity has it's has a metaphysics
81:02
Speaker A
that it actually has a metaphysical structure and it has an ontology. So to be to dive into that so that you kind of have a anchor for your decision- making because one of the problems that a lot of Christians have it's not their fault
81:15
Speaker A
in the modern world is that they believe in something but they're ultimately just secular materialists and so they have this belief like okay Jesus came and when he died and then I believe in him and I go to heaven but it actually
81:28
Speaker A
doesn't inform their worldview. So that's the work that I think is worth doing is is in some ways to read some of the great uh I mean St. Paul already is doing ontology and metaphysics but sometimes it's hard to see because we're
81:41
Speaker A
so used to reading him. You can read uh uh obviously Dianisis the Aropagite which I think is being taught here a little bit by I'm reading him right now father Maximus and you know uh there's others like some Maxis the confessor
81:53
Speaker A
that have that are kind of giving you a structure of thinking. Thank you. My name is Leif. Thank you for your speech. I was wondering if you thought AI could have any beneficial role in early education for young kids.
82:10
Speaker A
No, not for not for kids. No, for sure not. Because I I do I do really think that young children have to have the encounter of people, right? Because kids aren't just modeling ideas. They're modeling behaviors that are subtle that
82:23
Speaker A
you can't you can't even know what it is they're modeling. Like they're they're they're imitating how you place your hands. They're imitating your facial expressions. Like this young children have to be with their parents like all like a lot because the the type of
82:39
Speaker A
education is not just a mental education. We saw it like there are several professors that have have said that since the advent of smartphones that they realize that a lot of young people they their expressivity has diminished because they haven't been
82:55
Speaker A
mimicking faces, right? When they haven't been able to experience the empathy of looking into someone's eyes and in some ways to like imitate their facial expressions. This is something we don't even do consciously. And so I would say
83:08
Speaker A
I'm a big proponent of keeping your kids away from technology until they're teenagers. My children didn't have a we they could add like 15 minutes half an hour of screen a week until they were in they were teenagers basically. Maybe
83:23
Speaker A
they could watch one episode of something or like if we watch a movie as a family like maybe we'd watch it. But I'm really a big proponent of avoiding that. And I think that that the if you do that with your children
83:35
Speaker A
then when they you do introduce technology they're less there's less a chance that they become addicted and there's actually a better chance that they use it in the best in the best way possible. That's why that all their tech
83:46
Speaker A
lords don't give screens to their children. So why should we? Thank you. Hello my name is Eli.
83:55
Speaker A
um Plato's critique of writing came up and I think with that also comes the importance in understanding essences when making such critiques. So I wonder if uh as students of philosophy and history um can we speak fairly and precisely
84:14
Speaker A
about AI if we don't have some understanding of its mathematical mathematical or technical essence.
84:24
Speaker A
I'm not sure I know what a technical essence is or what or AI is a vague term. um if you don't know what a machine learning model is or how things are working mathematically can we speak completely fairly about it
84:38
Speaker A
right so let me let me let me turn the question on you is to say that if I do not understand how your nervous system functions does it mean that I can't know what a human is right and so the the the
84:52
Speaker A
the way that AI embeds itself into society narratively in terms of its place how we treat it, how it fits, you know, how we're interacting with it.
85:03
Speaker A
That is far more important in understanding what it is than whatever like technical thing behind it. I'm not against understanding the technical things behind it, but I think that it's better to look at what it's doing and how we're interacting with it to
85:18
Speaker A
understand what it is, you know? So, like for example, a lot of people ask all like always asking like could AI be conscious? Could AI be conscious? Could I be conscious? And I think the answer is I think no. But also it doesn't
85:30
Speaker A
matter. If we treat it as if it's conscious, if we interact with it as if it's conscious, that's enough to know what it is that it's doing. Right?
85:40
Speaker A
Because the truth is I can't verify your consciousness either, right? And so, you know, this idea that we're going to verify the AI, the consciousness of AI, it's like I can't do it for you. Why would I be able to do it for AI? But if
85:52
Speaker A
I treat it like I treat you. If I if I start treating AI like I treat you, then we kind of know what it is, at least it's trying to be or what it's what it's aiming for, what it's grasping for.
86:04
Speaker A
Thank you. I'm sure we're all hungry, so we're just going to wrap this last couple of questions up and the the questions and answers, you know, as punchy as possible.
86:13
Speaker A
Punchy as possible. Hi, I'm Evangelene. Um, I was just going to ask what does the beginning of these transhuman ideas look like in that perhaps we as college students could look out for? Um, what does the beginning of the Brian Johnson life look
86:29
Speaker A
like? Perhaps um, and perhaps a little more philosophically, what does the line look like between pushing the boundaries of innovation and the pursuit of greatness and this sort of Babylood?
86:43
Speaker A
Wow. That's not a p I can't give a punchy answer to that. Pick one.
86:47
Speaker A
Okay, pick one. Um, okay. So, so basically it's it's about power, right? It's about the search for power for its own sake. As soon as you start to search for power for its own sake, then you're a danger. No matter what it is you're
87:02
Speaker A
doing, you know, whether it is you think that making yourself fit and and healthy is good for its own sake. You know, you should be healthy, but you're you should be healthy so you can serve higher goods, not for not not for its own sake.
87:16
Speaker A
So you can see it when someone starts to flip that hierarchy and starts to submit all the other priorities in their life to the thing that's giving them power, then you know that there's a problem. As much with Brian Johnson as with the
87:30
Speaker A
problem of the Tower of Babel. Thank you. Hi, my name is Anthony. Um, so I had a question because I know you were talking you didn't want to scare anyone off, but I was curious since I mean in the ancient areas in
87:53
Speaker A
ancient Greece, malicious spirits or demons used to inhabit stones to kind of elicit worship out of people. Could they be using the same mechanism instead of now with marble or instead of marble now with like silicone to kind of be
88:06
Speaker A
eliciting worship from people today? So yeah, like I said, I think yes, but I think that we have to see it not just as the silicone because the stone is not alone. Like the stone has a bunch of
88:17
Speaker A
priests around it telling you there's a god there, right? And so it's not just the actual model or the silicon or the the data center, but it is is the interaction between the priestly cast, you know, and the people enabling it and
88:31
Speaker A
the model. So I think you're right that it can in some ways become the vehicle for demonic forces. Uh but it's not the it's not the stone, right? It's it's the network the stone with the network around it.
88:42
Speaker A
Gotcha. Thank you. Hello. Um, I'm Jackson. I am not a student here, but I was told it was okay to ask one question. Um, so I work with AI agents at my job all of the time. I advise some of the largest companies on
89:01
Speaker A
Earth how to use them. Um, my project at work right now is telling the company that holds the nuclear launch codes AI governance and building that out for them. So, in using AI agents, something AI governance, man, those words
89:16
Speaker A
together, they freak the hell out of me. But something that's become more and more and more clear as we use these agents and as we advise our clients to use these agents is that they cannot think. You know, they are not capable of
89:29
Speaker A
making decisions. We all think that they are because all of the people who make them tell us that they are. But even if you ask it to code anything remotely complex and you look at the actual code, it's garbage. You know, you could teach
89:42
Speaker A
a high schooler how to do a better job in three days. Um, and so it seems to me what's going wrong is that we're telling a bad story and we have for hundreds of years that we're going to make a monster with science.
89:56
Speaker A
How do we protect ourselves from bad stories that are not true? I mean, first thing is to stop saying AI governance. That's the first thing.
90:05
Speaker A
Yeah. But seriously, because you say AI governance and then you tell them, hey, it's actually not making decisions. It's like why did you call it AI? Sorry. And so I I think that we for sure we have to
90:16
Speaker A
always make sure to remember that it's a derivation of our authority, right? But but this is going to become massive massive problem and we already saw it as you know you know the story of the of the unfortunate bombing of a school
90:31
Speaker A
girls uh uh a school of girls in Iran because AI made a mistake and the answer is the question is who's responsible and the answer is me that's the answer and that's going to be the pro we're going
90:44
Speaker A
to see it it's going to iterate this problem of of being able to in some ways remove responsibility from myself by giving it to AI. And so I think that for sure you have to you definitely we need
90:57
Speaker A
to find ways to make people responsible. I don't know how for what AI does and make sure that you cannot use AI to relinquish responsibility and that has to come back and bite you. We need to see people go to jail. I honest I'm
91:12
Speaker A
sorry. We need to see people go to jail because of what their AI agent does. Uh or maybe some of the CEOs of the AI companies, whoever. But we need to find a way to kind of to to to not let the AI
91:24
Speaker A
because it's so tempting, right? Because I can do things, I can get the results and I cannot have the responsibility, right? It's very scary. So, good luck, man. Thank you.
91:38
Speaker A
All right, Jonathan, Dylan, Sarah, and Ben, thank you so much. And all of you for being here. Thank you. Welcome to UATX. Welcome to the Austin Union. If you feel so compelled, you Austin.org.
91:48
Speaker A
AustinUN.org. or go enjoy some dinner. Thank you. Have a good night, everybody. Yeah, that's 9:00 a.m.
Topics:AItranshumanismJonathan PageausainthoodPlatoDantevirtueUniversity of AustinAustin Uniontechnology ethics

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →