Skip to content
Get App

Is the (New) New World Order Really Any Better?

Richard the Fourth critiques Alexander Dugin's multipolar traditionalism, arguing it is geopolitical and instrumental rather than Guénon's neutral metaphysics.

Key Takeaways

  • Dugin's multipolar traditionalism is a geopolitical project using traditionalist language instrumentally.
  • Guénon's metaphysical critique of modernity differs fundamentally from Dugin's political appropriation of it.
  • Russia, China and Trump-era America are all modern, secular or materialist powers, undermining claims of a traditional restoration.
  • Genuine traditionalism concerns cosmic and metaphysical orientation, not winning elections or power struggles.

What the video covers

  • The speaker reacts to Alexander Dugin's enthusiasm over the Trump-Xi-Putin summit, which Dugin frames as the emergence of a multipolar world.
  • Dugin's proposed spheres of influence (Russia over Europe and Africa, China over Asia, America over the Americas) are questioned as unrealistic.
  • The speaker argues Dugin uses traditionalism instrumentally to pursue a modern political project rather than living within tradition.
  • Guénon's critique of modernity is presented as neutral and metaphysical, whereas Dugin's is seen as geopolitical and animated by hostility toward the Anglo-American West.
  • Historical Russian animosity toward the Anglo-American world is suggested as a driver of Dugin's thinking.
  • Dugin's praise of Candace Owens is criticized as populist rather than traditionalist.
  • Russia, China and Trump are each analyzed as modern secular or materialist powers rather than restorers of tradition.
  • The speaker argues true traditionalism sees modernity as fundamentally disordered, which cannot be fixed by replacing leaders or seizing political power.
  • The speaker notes Dugin's neglect of international finance capital as a critique from others.
  • The video ends with a call to subscribe.

Answers

Questions about this video

What is the speaker's main criticism of Alexander Dugin?

The speaker argues Dugin uses traditionalism instrumentally to advance a modern geopolitical project aimed at undermining the West. Unlike René Guénon's neutral metaphysical critique, Dugin's approach is seen as driven by animosity and political ambition.

Why does the speaker say Russia, China and Trump are not traditional powers?

Russia is described as a modern industrial nation state operating outside the liberal frame, China as a secular technological superstate, and Trump as a materialist, commerce-focused nationalist with little interest in spiritual matters.

What does the speaker say true traditionalism requires?

True traditionalism recognizes the modern world as fundamentally disordered at a metaphysical level. The speaker argues it cannot be achieved simply by changing who holds political power, since that relies on the modern tools it seeks to transcend.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:01
Speaker A
Hello everyone. Hope you're doing well today. Sorry if I sound a bit dejected. I've got a horrible seasonal flu. Not pleasant at all, but we soldier on, don't we? Uh anyway, I saw uh Alexander Dugan was piping up recently. He was
00:17
Speaker A
very excited cuz Trump went to China to meet Putin and uh President Xi. It was a big event to be fair. You know, it was clearly a sign of a shifting geopolitical power structure.
00:30
Speaker A
However, I was quite interested to see Dugan who gets quite vocal at these times because he sees it as the completion of his theory of this new multipolar world. He's been posting about it how Russia will dominate Europe
00:42
Speaker A
and Africa, China will have Asia and America the Americas. I don't quite buy that for for many reasons. But he's spoken a lot about this future multipolar world of tradition in which key arenas uh of global influence basically
00:58
Speaker A
dominate given regions and uh reestablish more traditional religious formations. And as you might imagine uh on first hearing it sounds quite attractive to someone like me, maybe you too. But uh the more you look into doing, the more odd and strange and well
01:13
Speaker A
unrealistic it gets. For starters, you know, he's proposed this sort of multipolar world where everybody respects each other's traditions and so on. And that sounds very nice, obviously, but you can already tell there's a sort of modern equalitarianism imposed upon traditional
01:30
Speaker A
structures in the modern world. And there's many traditionalist critiques from moderns uh that you find. It sort of undermines his own argument because you see that he's not actually living in tradition but utilizing tradition in an instrumental way in order to enact a
01:47
Speaker A
very modern political project. And that's what we're going to explore and why I think this is a load of hot air personally speaking. I mean, look, it's clear that that Trump is had it's been dragged to the table. I mean, America
01:58
Speaker A
isn't the power it once was. It's got challenges in many different directions. It has to think about its long-term future, and China is a serious player.
02:06
Speaker A
Russia not to the same extent but you know Russia is always going to be uh on the table it's always going to huge huge mass of people huge land mass and huge ambitions but like I say I think the
02:18
Speaker A
first thing to speak about here because Dugan has become slightly famous for his use of traditionalism in the modern era and that he will lean quite heavily on Gwinon and Eva and traditionalist metaphysics to critique western modernity to say where liberalism has
02:35
Speaker A
has gone wrong and he doesn't really offer anything new in that regard. He just utiliz it utilizes it in the same way that Guinana and would. But there is a really important difference here. When you start to read Guinano or at least
02:48
Speaker A
just [clears throat] look at his pieces on his Substack, you start to realize quite quickly that Dugan isn't really speaking about this objective traditional restoration.
03:00
Speaker A
number one and number two it becomes really clear that you know if you read Gwenon crisis of the modern world or whatever it's quite clear that Guanon is neutral he is making a neutral analysis due to years of study of religious
03:13
Speaker A
traditions and philosophy and civilization and I would imagine his own spiritual practice he is making a neutral observation about the western world you could arguably say there are elements here and there of concern for the west but more purely it's it's just
03:29
Speaker A
a neutral critique and that's very much his sort of orientation as a person. He's quite an austere thinker, an austere writer.
03:37
Speaker A
But the point is that Gwinon is making his metaphysical critique in an objective manner like a scientist in a way you could say like a metaphysician.
03:49
Speaker A
Dugan when you start to really get beneath the surface level it's quite clear that he utilizes it as I say instrumentally to undermine and ultimately defeat the west. It doesn't take long with Dugan before you will find this very strong animosity towards
04:07
Speaker A
the west but especially the Anglo the Angloamerican but but I'd say the Anglo more than anything which I don't think we're aware of this uh in Britain but you know [laughter] we have a quite a strong historic beef with the Russians
04:19
Speaker A
which has largely uh for for much of the right been been forgotten but I don't think it's been forgotten in in Russia you know they they very much see themselves as in the 20th century you know the great competitor
04:31
Speaker A
of uh the western world which was Anglo-American and obviously the Anglo-Americans won. So they very much see it as, you know, you're sort of sly, you're backhanded, you undermined, you're materialistic, and we are sort of the true power. And I
04:45
Speaker A
think that that's been in the Russian psyche uh for for quite a while. And I think it does come out with with Dugan quite clearly. And you know, someone who's interested in traditionalism, you're reading him sometimes and thinking, well, hang on, this isn't
04:56
Speaker A
tradition critique, this is just animosity amongst much of boomerisms that he comes out with as well about how much he fancies Candace Owens and so on.
05:04
Speaker A
And that's another thing I think from the outside, you know, it's why I sometimes question how into traditional traditionalism he really is because of course Candace Owens and like are just basically populist slop, you know, it's uh it's really just mainline Tory party
05:17
Speaker A
nonsense. You know, the big black strong woman and all this sort of thing, the big feminist girl boss and yeah, are takes really, you know, that penetrating? It's pretty much just just slop, isn't it? Anyway, the point I'm
05:29
Speaker A
making is that it's quite clear in my mind that um Gordon's critique has has been broadly metaphysical and and Dugan has been geopolitical.
05:39
Speaker A
And I don't think that we can differentiate Dugan's take from a historic beef that Russia has with the Western world. And Dugan will almost paint Trump as being some sense anti- the globalist, anti-American uh power structure, which he's just not. He's just not. He's
05:59
Speaker A
bought into the very same power structure. And you know, some people critique Dugan for uh not mentioning the nature of international finance capital as well. But the point is that I think that what we're seeing here is very
06:12
Speaker A
unrealistic use of traditionalism and this political unity or supposed political unity between Trump Xi and Putin as some reawakening tradition is is a massive cope if you ask me. Um, I think if we're to look at each of these,
06:30
Speaker A
you know, nations, Putin's Russia, I think we like to view it is this trad elements of that which are true, but in many senses, it is the modern nation state. You know, it's the same industrial military power that it always
06:44
Speaker A
has been and it thinks like a modern nation state. It's just outside of the liberal frame, which again, it does deserve some credit for.
06:52
Speaker A
And China, you know, really is a technological superstate which is secular by nature. You know, it still has the Communist Party in charge. And I know people doubt it's communist. I think that's a fair critique. It seems more sort of state capitalist or even
07:06
Speaker A
fascist in elements. But again, it is secular. It's not trying to reawaken its uh spiritual religious traditions and put them front and center. is trying to place ideology at the very spearhead of of of its governing ideology which again is completely
07:24
Speaker A
counter to the traditional world. I don't think you could call China communist in the pure sense of the word but uh I don't think ane oron would would necessarily look at China and say that that's the uh the reawakening of a
07:36
Speaker A
of a traditional world. Uh and Trump of course as well that Trump would be the standard bearer of tradition. you know, he's king merchant. That's what Trump is. It's commerce. Nationalism in the protectionist sense in terms of economics. Trump doesn't really have
07:53
Speaker A
much interest in spiritual and religious matters. He's a guy who's rooted in material power and a sort of crude morality of of winning uh essentially.
08:05
Speaker A
Again, there's something to be said for that on one level, but at the same time, I wouldn't see it as the reawakening of some, you know, traditional triumvirate that's going to uh take over the world and and reestablish tradition because
08:17
Speaker A
you look at each and the central question is, well, what where exactly is the restoration of spiritual authority?
08:23
Speaker A
And the only one you could say there is anything there is the Orthodox Church in Russia. I would say it's the only one, but that's got its own problems anyway.
08:31
Speaker A
Not to mention the critique I give quite a lot. You're assuming that tradition and realignment is manifested through the ballot box and manifested through political power which is not a traditional line at all. It's quite the opposite of a traditional
08:50
Speaker A
belief system which would be that these things are organic and come from living alive traditions you know that have developed really from the source and have to be kept alive you know the flame has to be kept alive so
09:05
Speaker A
it it's not really something that you just reimplement and of course then you have the problem itself and you this is another great problem with Dugan and many people who speak about traditionalism you know if you do read it we are in the
09:18
Speaker A
cali UA and to be simple about that what it basically means is there's a metaphysical orientation towards matter at this time which is way bigger than day-to-day politics. This is a cosmic orientation that can be overcome but it's not
09:34
Speaker A
overcome necessarily by the actions of man. You could say there might be a collapse and a recognition of the truth.
09:40
Speaker A
That might be the well more of a pure way to put it. [snorts] But the point is and you get this a lot that you know we seem to have this idea that we just reimplement a traditional world. You
09:52
Speaker A
just take power here and now do what the left have done and it will work. That's not a traditional line on things because you're utilizing the tools of modernism.
10:00
Speaker A
Try and implement the the essence of organic tradition which are different things. Now that's not to say politics is useless and meaningless. You know, you can still work within and do what you can. But as I say, I think this
10:11
Speaker A
notion that Dugan is coming out with here is really just a bit of a front. And I think it's a front really for his own political operation, perhaps a political operation of of Russia.
10:26
Speaker A
In essence, you know, I think traditionalism isn't about deciding which modern empire you want to rule the world. It's about recognizing the entire modern orientation of the world is fundamentally disordered and you cannot simply overcome that by changing the people sitting at the top.
10:45
Speaker A
It's a much deeper essence than that. So I'm not quite sure about all this tough talk from from Duke and I think it's simple geopolitics. It's a simple play of new power structure and that this is going to be some awakening of a
10:57
Speaker A
traditional golden age. Not quite sure. Not quite sure. As always, if you'd like to learn more about tradition, you can check out uh my course on it down below.
11:06
Speaker A
And also do subscribe to this channel if you're new.
Topics:Alexander Dugintraditionalismmultipolar worldRené GuénongeopoliticsRussiaChinaTrumpmodernityEurasianism

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →