Skip to content
Get App

The Throne Is Never Empty: Iain McGilchrist on what rules a civilisation that dismissed the sacred

Iain McGilchrist discusses how the loss of the sacred led to moral relativism, reductive materialism, and a crisis of truth in modernity, and whether AI can be conscious.

Key Takeaways

  • The loss of the sacred is seen as the root cause of moral relativism, utilitarian values, and the erosion of truth in modern civilisation.
  • Hubris, lack of awe, and lack of compassion are identified as key dispositions that must be corrected.
  • Consequences should be acknowledged and learned from, but not interpreted through a punitive divine framework.
  • Consciousness is argued to be primary rather than emergent from matter, which casts doubt on claims that AI could be conscious.
  • Agnosticism is treated as a more honest stance than dogmatic belief or denial.

What the video covers

  • Host frames humanity as having great power but little wisdom, arguing that the dismissal of the sacred inverted the hierarchy of values and led to utility and pleasure displacing the holy.
  • The discussion traces the sequence from loss of the sacred to moral relativism and totalitarianism, with the host asking whether the resulting consequences are deserved.
  • McGilchrist cites Chesterton's line that when people stop believing in God they believe in anything, and identifies hubris, a failure to wonder, and absent compassion as central modern dispositions.
  • He argues the drive toward reductive materialism is a distinctively Western development, while acknowledging the West also produced great art and ideas.
  • He rejects a punitive view of God, holding that consequences should be confronted and learned from rather than interpreted as divine punishment.
  • The host, an agnostic, asks whether the Enlightenment's emphasis on truth, placed below the sacred in Max Scheler's hierarchy of values, left truth vulnerable once nothing higher is served.
  • Agnosticism is presented as an honourable position compared with dogmatism in either direction.
  • Discussion touches on the sacred as a placeholder for what language cannot capture, and on the value of a sacred canopy that expands the context in which humans see themselves.
  • The conversation turns to whether AI could be conscious, with McGilchrist expressing strong rejection and arguing consciousness is more fundamental than matter.
  • McGilchrist draws on hemispheric lateralisation, describing the left hemisphere as dealing in abstractions and maps, and critiques Laplacian determinism and readiness-potential experiments.

Answers

Questions about this video

What does McGilchrist identify as the root cause of modern moral relativism?

He traces it to the dismissal of the sacred, which he sees as displacing the hierarchy of values. Once the sacred is removed, utility and pleasure take its place, leaving no shared higher standard for truth or goodness.

Does McGilchrist believe consequences are a divine punishment?

No. He explicitly rejects a punitive deity, arguing it would be absurd for God to create fallible beings and then punish them for not being better. Instead, he stresses recognising consequences so that people can learn and change.

What is McGilchrist's view on whether AI can be conscious?

He expresses a strong sense of rejection toward the idea. He argues consciousness is more fundamental than matter and that matter is itself a manifestation of consciousness, which makes machine consciousness implausible in his framework.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00
Speaker A
Okay, so I'll I'll start with the short preamble if you don't mind and we can we can take it where where it goes from there.
00:07
Speaker A
Yes, surely. Um, I think we are children holding nuclear weapons. We have more power than any people in history and less wisdom than most of them.
00:25
Speaker A
Yeah. I can't see how that arrangement ends well. Extinction or catastrophe of some sort looks to me like the most likely outcome.
00:35
Speaker A
I've studied and tried to elicit the sequence that you lay out, perhaps to some degree implicitly in your work for how we got here.
00:43
Speaker A
Uh, it seems to me that it begins with the dismissal of the sacred which led to the hierarchy of values being inverted and followed by utility and pleasure taking the place of uh taking the place that belonged to the holy.
00:58
Speaker A
Moral relativism inevitably followed and totalitarianism came after because someone will always fill the vacancy at the top of the hierarchy and demand to be served.
01:09
Speaker A
I can't regard this as an accident. We were given a world ordered by value and we turned it upside down.
01:18
Speaker A
I see it as a betrayal a betrayal of God, some might say. And I struggle to see how it is forgivable.
01:27
Speaker A
So I want to put two questions uh to this conversation and we can see if we can we can if we can touch on them in any in any manner.
01:40
Speaker A
Oh. If the loss was our doing is the consequence deserved? And what would a path to redemption, which to me doesn't sound like anything short I'm short of a miracle look like to someone like you who calls himself a hopeful
02:03
Speaker A
And Yes. That's it. I'm I'm done with the um the preamble, but um uh we can, I guess, begin uh begin by perhaps laying down a sequence um I I um I keep calling it a sequence because uh I I'm obsessed with um root cause um
02:24
Speaker A
analysis and every time I think about this predicament, I can't help but go back to the point or or the era or the turning point in the evolution of our thought that that made us susceptible to falling into moral relativism.
02:48
Speaker A
And I cannot see how we can get ourselves out of this in in any way other than by resurrecting the sacred, whatever that is, whatever that that looks like.
03:07
Speaker A
Well, you raise a a number of of interesting points. How did we get here?
03:14
Speaker A
Um if this is something that we have brought on ourselves, are the consequences deserved?
03:21
Speaker A
Um is it possible to to move away from the position we're in back towards one in which we once more reverence the sacred?
03:32
Speaker A
I think all of those are are worth attempting. Um I think uh when you were speaking about that, I was thinking of I think it was G.K. Chesterton who said when people stop believing in God, they don't believe in nothing. They believe in
03:51
Speaker A
anything. And I think that's a description of where we now are. It is a tragedy.
04:05
Speaker A
It certainly does threaten this civilization. And the Greeks saw that tragedy came through hubris, through the belief that we could do more than we can do, know more than we can know, and have a right as it were to
04:28
Speaker A
be honored for doing so. So I think there are a number of things wrong in terms of the disposition that we hold in modernity, and one of them is hubris.
04:43
Speaker A
Another is a complete failure to wonder, to to have any sense any longer of awe before the mystery of the world.
04:57
Speaker A
And the third is compassion. I mean it's notably absent from um the way in which public discourse takes place these days.
05:06
Speaker A
It's uncivilized. It's extreme minutes positions and shows no sign of an attempt to understand another person's point of view, provided that point of view of course is sincerely held.
05:23
Speaker A
How did we get here? Well I think I would point to certain moments in the history of the West because I think that this is a peculiarly western problem. I'm not saying that it isn't shared by people all around the world,
05:43
Speaker A
but I think the genesis of this particular um [clears throat] drive towards reductive materialism must come out of the West, I'm afraid.
05:54
Speaker A
And I'm not here to sort of jump on a bandwagon of detesting the West.
06:00
Speaker A
Um the West also produced um uncalculably beautiful and great ideas, art, and so forth, but it the other side of its productivity and fruitfulness is that it can also give rise to dangerous and destructive thinking, and I think that's
06:21
Speaker A
uh what we've inherited. I I I I myself I mean I'm very much in in um sympathy with your your your vision that the loss of the sacred is at the heart of it.
06:36
Speaker A
But I suppose I don't altogether embrace a view that whatever comes is deserved if that deserving implies a punitive deity.
06:57
Speaker A
I I the the god I believe in is is not a punitive god. It would be ridiculous for god to create fallible very fallible creatures and then punish them for not being better than they are.
07:13
Speaker A
So I don't think that's the way the cosmos works. And I also think that it's very important that we do see that we the consequences of our actions. So that's the the other side of that, the balancing um
07:32
Speaker A
conception. That it's very important that we we don't turn our eyes away from the consequences of what we've done and see the connections. I think that's how we learn and that's how we change.
07:44
Speaker A
So that is important. And perhaps that's as much as I need to say right now because there's a lot to say about how do we deal [clears throat] with all this. But those are some of my thoughts.
07:56
Speaker A
Do they make any sense and is there anything that you'd like to like to pick up?
08:02
Speaker A
Um I would like to make uh first a clarification and then uh follow up on something that touched on.
08:10
Speaker A
And this was one of the things that perhaps challenged me during the talk as well and when I speak of the sacred and when I even when I use the word God as an agnostic myself if I were to
08:23
Speaker A
categorize myself I would have to I would have to put myself in that category because I don't know I don't know how one comes to faith.
08:32
Speaker A
I myself don't haven't been gifted with it yet I suppose but and this was one of the one of the one of the most frequently repeated questions in during the conversation which lasted for three hours actually that how is one to think of
08:57
Speaker A
this notion when I think about the notion of the sacred and and and perhaps because I have been immersed in your work that the hierarchy of value that Max Scheler puts forward and and the very fact that the sacred
09:13
Speaker A
sits above truth beauty and goodness and justice I guess different translations of of of of the rung before the sacred could mean different things but but certainly truth fits in that in that rung.
09:33
Speaker A
Is it is it reasonable to suggest that the reason that the Enlightenment which began by a an over emphasis on the notion of truth and and the necessity and of the truth and and the idea that if you just
09:50
Speaker A
observe carefully enough and if you if you just dissect closely enough there is nothing that you cannot there is nothing that that you can't know given that you have tools sophisticated sufficiently sophisticated to be able to do the
10:09
Speaker A
um do the dissection. Um, and and now we we we see our predicament. Uh uh we we we see what what kind of a world we've um ended up in, which um despite our technological prowess on on a socio-political level, we uh
10:27
Speaker A
that the the utility of truth is even uh questioned and under assault. And whether or not it matters is a is a is is a question to contend with these days. I don't believe um I don't believe Bacon and Locke ever ever wondered
10:44
Speaker A
that there would come a time that people questioned the utility of truth um let alone getting to the question what the truth is.
10:54
Speaker A
So I I guess if I if I were to distill a question out of that, it um it would have to be is it as simple as suggesting that if there is nothing that truth is serving, in other words, if there's nothing above
11:13
Speaker A
the truth in Scheler's hierarchy, the truth itself will inevitably become irrelevant. Oh. Mm. Well, I think behind everything we're discussing here lies a reflection prompted by your first comments there, which were that you consider yourself an agnostic.
11:42
Speaker A
And I myself think of agnosticism as an extremely um honorable position. I think it's preferable to thinking you know when you don't know.
11:56
Speaker A
Um, and I think there are dogmatists of faith and no faith um to whom I would prefer people who have honest, honorable intention of seeking whatever is good, true beautiful.
12:14
Speaker A
[sighs] Um, but each of those, well, particularly let us focus on truth. The problem here is the idea that either truth doesn't exist or it exists in a form that is um completely perfectly encompassable in language.
12:45
Speaker A
And And this was an ideal of the Enlightenment. And I I should just put in a caveat here that um I'm not I'm not an enemy of the Enlightenment in itself. I think if I'd lived at the time, I'd probably have been
12:58
Speaker A
um pleased by what it was aiming to accomplish. But like many human enterprises, it it went too far. It thought it could do more than it could. It didn't understand itself.
13:16
Speaker A
And And one of the ideas of the Enlightenment was that all truths can be fully expressed in language.
13:23
Speaker A
That these statements of truth could be passed to another person who simply by reading them could fully understand.
13:32
Speaker A
And that all those statements are mutually compatible. These I'm I'm I'm here paraphrasing Isaiah Berlin talking about the Enlightenment idea of truth. And each of those three things there seem to me entirely um Well, let me say highly questionable.
13:54
Speaker A
Um, I think if you think you've encapsulated it in language, you probably haven't got it at all.
14:03
Speaker A
I think that there are many things, all the highest truths, all the most important things that it's very very hard to capture in language at all.
14:12
Speaker A
It certainly it wouldn't be possible to convey what's fully meant by simply giving a text to another person who could ingest it and is ah I understand.
14:22
Speaker A
It has to come through experience you know and and you know here I'll just very briefly as a side issue refer to the problem in English that we have only one word for know to know the facts and to know by
14:34
Speaker A
experience whereas in most other languages that I know these have quite different verbs knowledge by acquaintance and knowledge of the facts and they're quite different things.
14:49
Speaker A
And and the third thing is that it seems to me quite unlikely that all these truths are um at least at any level that the human mind can encompass mutually compatible.
15:05
Speaker A
Uh there's a very fine tradition of the coincidence of opposites which as you know from uh reading the matter of things I I take as the very first chapter of part three of the matter of things which is the metaphysics or ontology
15:22
Speaker A
however you like to describe it. And I take that as a as a an important starting point. It's in all the wisdom traditions outside of the West and it was a feature of the Western tradition until the time of Plato and Aristotle
15:38
Speaker A
notably in in Heraclitus who I consider to be the greatest of Western philosophers. So um let's dispense with the idea that um truth is something so simple it can be stated in language and so on but that does not
15:54
Speaker A
that it doesn't exist. And and part of what I would consider the domination of our minds by the left hemisphere's mode of approach [snorts] is that the left hemisphere revolutionary reasons needs to know right now is it this or is it that
16:12
Speaker A
because it's the one that is grabbing and getting it's getting food it's catching a rabbit it's whatever it's doing it it hasn't got time to get but it might not be, or it might be something else, or there's something
16:21
Speaker A
else going on. It has to just go for it. So, quite contrary to what people used to say about the left hemisphere, that it was at least dependable, reliable, and so on, if a little bit dull.
16:33
Speaker A
Um, it's it's very clear, and we can talk about that if you have a desire to go there, but very clear that the left hemisphere is um absolutely not reliable. In fact, um I'm not the only neuroscientist who says
16:49
Speaker A
that the left hemisphere unsupervised by the right hemisphere, which sees very much more, understands very much more, is delusional.
16:57
Speaker A
So, um what what I'm really getting at is that we don't we mustn't fall into either there's no truth or I can tell you what it is.
17:08
Speaker A
It's very important to hold on to the idea that there is truth, even though you may find it very hard to do justice to it in language. And And this is also very much true of the sacred and beyond that, the divine. These are
17:24
Speaker A
things that when people make statements about them in the positive sense are almost certainly wrong.
17:32
Speaker A
I I I am a believer in the so-called apophatic tradition or the via negativa.
17:38
Speaker A
In other words, that what we say about the divine, it will be mistaken. And the best we can do is to clear away the things that are said that must be wrong, that get between us and a proper
17:51
Speaker A
uh understanding of what we mean when we use terms like the sacred and the divine.
17:57
Speaker A
Now, finally one one point which you raised, which is an interesting one. Um, if there were nothing above the true, the good, and the beautiful, would there even be truth?
18:14
Speaker A
First of all, it's perfectly possible, it seems to me, to be a certain kind of dogmatic materialist who says I don't know what you mean by sacred.
18:28
Speaker A
Doesn't mean anything as far as I'm concerned. Um but still to hold the truth is very important. I mean after all if there really were no truth, there'd be no point in saying anything. This conversation would be would be complete
18:42
Speaker A
um wasted time and actually doing anything would be purposeless because we wouldn't know what was true in the world and what was worth pursuing and and so on. So in fact whether we acknowledge it or not we all
18:56
Speaker A
hold um an idea of um goals, values, whatever you like to call them. I think values is probably the best word.
19:08
Speaker A
Um and and for me the three important ones are the true, the good and the beautiful.
19:13
Speaker A
That these are um things that speak to us, that guide us. And in the end I think if you really feel them and know them and respond to them, then the idea behind the word sacred will become clear to you.
19:36
Speaker A
I want to emphasize on the on this while we are focusing on on the um on the notion of truth um one of the things that my audience struggled to uh uh I suppose we all did. Um I still
19:56
Speaker A
struggle to to um connect the dots uh if I'm formulating my thoughts in the form of a diagnosis.
20:04
Speaker A
Um in that it wasn't like it wasn't like one day we woke up and decided to um adopt a left hemispheric approach to to perceiving the world.
20:19
Speaker A
Right. It rather it rather seems to me and I think I heard this in a conversation you had with with um with Alex whose last name escapes me, in one of the 20 29 conversations on on the different
20:33
Speaker A
chapters of Alex Gomez Marin. Correct, yes. Apologies for that. I remember that you you point to the idea that if you don't the the simple but rich idea that if you don't use a faculty, you you you if you don't use it for long enough, you
20:55
Speaker A
stop you first stop the ability to use it and and gradually over time you you probably become increasingly aware of of possessing it.
21:05
Speaker A
And the the the affliction, if you would, which has to a great degree compromised our ability to to adopt a right hemispheric approach to to how we perceive the world and how we perceive the nature of being.
21:31
Speaker A
It it it seems very much to me to be a byproduct of of that losing of the ability of of of having that that that that right hemispheric approach to to the way we we perceive things, to the
21:49
Speaker A
way we perceive each other. And and the reason that I keep going back to the sacred is because I think once humanity it seems to me that once humanity convinced himself that this is all there is.
22:06
Speaker A
I can see all that there is and I can and I can grasp it and I can dissect it.
22:13
Speaker A
The the moment that that attitude took over it was game over. because because at that at that point the the the the the very important faculty which which is which is enabled by the right hemisphere is basically dismissed or dispensed with.
22:35
Speaker A
And let's say this term the sacred I I use it to to represent all that can't be articulated, all that can't be known by observation, by dissection.
22:55
Speaker A
So say until four or 500 years ago we were enmeshed and enveloped in an environment, in a culture, in an atmosphere that was that was imbued with with the notion of the sacred. It was it was mixed in our vernacular. It was
23:17
Speaker A
it characterized the way we we saw everything. And gradually over a over a period of time we dispensed with that, we dismissed it.
23:28
Speaker A
Nietzsche says we killed it. And and came after that the the loss of the faculty that that enabled us to see that or to perceive it.
23:45
Speaker A
And so as the result it seems to me that with that gone, with the summit gone, again when I use the word hierarchy summit, the top I'm I'm actively thinking of Shayler's hierarchy that with that with with the top rung gone
24:08
Speaker A
there is no reason why everything shouldn't be reduced to utility to utility. Mm. Mm.
24:18
Speaker A
And when I think of when I think about the hierarchy of value, the way that say for example Sam Harris does as much of an absolutist as he is, or he attempts to be, I do not I don't see how the materialist
24:37
Speaker A
reductionist can ground their self-proclaimed absolutist moral framework in anything but because Sam Harris likes it that way.
24:52
Speaker A
Meaning [clears throat] in anything but preference, which is indistinguishable from utility at the end of the day.
25:04
Speaker A
I think I I'd like to sort of just put another point of view about the sacred there really.
25:16
Speaker A
I I know I'm saying that you mean this, but there could be a danger in people understanding that unless they have a body of beliefs of a certain spiritual nature, then none of these values can have meaning. And I I don't
25:34
Speaker A
think that is the best way to understand the sacred. I think what the sacred does is to keep us always aware of some very very important foundational truths that can easily slip out of the picture unless there is
25:59
Speaker A
this what we call the sense of the sacred. One is that it is the ultimate placeholder for something where we we we feel there is something very important here, but we're not able to capture it in language.
26:22
Speaker A
And so traditionally it has often been approached through music in fact, but also through the the arts including poetry and narrative and so on, through ritual and other kind of embodied, metaphorical ways of understanding.
26:40
Speaker A
So the the sacred holds that always there, that the delusional idea that we can pin everything down in everyday language is surely the biggest mistake we could make.
26:53
Speaker A
Um this is demonstratively false um in the greatness of art, if not in the business of living.
27:06
Speaker A
Um so I think that's one thing. I think another is that it from the perspective of what I understand about hemisphere differences, it's a way of holding the relationship between right and left hemispheres. So I think you will
27:35
Speaker A
familiar with my view that the right hemisphere is not just an equal partner with the left hemisphere. It's not like there are these two ways of of of looking at the world.
27:45
Speaker A
One of them is far more of a radical than the other sees more, perceives more, makes better judgments on the basis of what it sees, um is more intelligent and more creative. So that is pretty important.
28:00
Speaker A
And the work of the left hemisphere is important in itself, but only in as much as it gets referred back to the overarching view of the right hemisphere.
28:13
Speaker A
So the work that the left hemisphere does is that of a high-functioning bureaucrat effectively.
28:19
Speaker A
Uh the the image and the story of the master and his emissary is is that of um a wise spiritual master who sees looks after the the well-being of a community and um sees that he cannot actually look everything that needs to be done.
28:36
Speaker A
There needs to be somebody who is focused on the everyday administrative realities um and that will enable the master to carry on holding the overall picture.
28:51
Speaker A
But what happens is that the um the hemisphere, the left hemisphere um knowing much less thinks it knows everything and as a result becomes um vain, arrogant, usurps the master and everything falls apart. So that is an important image to hold in one's mind
29:10
Speaker A
when one's thinking about the role of the sacred. And here I'm thinking also of the work of um a 20th century uh sociologist Peter Berger Berger, b e r g e r who um who wrote a book um
29:33
Speaker A
on the sacred canopy. And what he meant by the sacred canopy was this overarching uh [sighs] sense of something that supported, sustained made apparent and made to the extent that it can be comprehensible, the rich things that are
29:54
Speaker A
foundational for a sense of a fulfilling life. And without truth, without beauty, without goodness, nothing we do, nothing we think matters.
30:05
Speaker A
So that overarching canopy, that sacred canopy that holds these things in place is very important and it also I think importantly expands the context in which we see ourselves.
30:21
Speaker A
So if you're a reductive materialist you take this view well um what are we? We're just these tiny uh organisms. We don't know why we ever evolved. Um uh we live on this tiny planet that's lost amongst the you know
30:41
Speaker A
the the enormous magnitude of the known cosmos. Um how can any of this have any meaning?
30:47
Speaker A
This is a typical um mistake made by the left hemisphere which is to try and take as it were a view from nowhere.
30:56
Speaker A
And um and therefore to stand outside anything that could give value or meaning. But at the same time there's another way of looking at ourselves which is that we are part of something we don't fully understand. We don't know
31:11
Speaker A
why human life I mean life at all why anything. You know first of all this question why is there anything rather than nothing?
31:20
Speaker A
Then there's a question why is the life? Because it's very expensive [laughter] and we're not sure what it's all about.
31:27
Speaker A
And [snorts] and then why is the human life which is particularly expensive in terms of energy and and so on.
31:33
Speaker A
And um there are the questions we could turn to but I mean I'm not going to try and wrap them up in in what I'm saying now. But all I'm really saying is that I think the the value of the idea of the
31:45
Speaker A
sacred is is it re situates ourselves and the things that we are aware of through deep intuitions that shouldn't be just discarded.
31:56
Speaker A
That there are things that are in themselves good are in themselves beautiful and are ultimately true.
32:03
Speaker A
So that's something of what I would wish to reflect there. When I think about [snorts] this um all too present phenomenon of artificial intelligence um and observe and watch people who whose IQs are likely by one or two standard deviation at
32:28
Speaker A
least higher than mine and I hear them talk about the the possibility that or likelihood that AI at some point is going to be conscious.
32:37
Speaker A
Um the immediacy by which that ideas strikes me as just ludicrous and and um, and uh, it seems to me if there must be something uh, and I want to I'm I'm tempted to go go go as far as
33:01
Speaker A
attributing a physical um, characteristic to the to the to the faculty that must be missing from one's cognition for someone to think that way about AI.
33:11
Speaker A
Uh, it's it's it's it's an overwhelming sense of rejection that that that emerges within me when I when I hear that the idea that AI could be conscious.
33:24
Speaker A
But I see um, many many very smart people who are who are perfectly comfortable with with with entertaining that idea.
33:35
Speaker A
I um, I often um, basically I guess arrive at the at the conclusion that that it that actually a coherent thinker once they adopt the premise that that there's nothing but there's nothing but the the material substrate that that
33:56
Speaker A
shapes us and forms us. Um, once that premise is is adopted, there is actually no alternative place to arrive at with regards to consciousness because if consciousness is is simply if consciousness arises simply in material beings, just as long as the matter is put
34:23
Speaker A
together sufficiently uh um um, in a sufficiently complex form or um, whatever it is that that that that allows consciousness to emerge in us, then yes, you do arrive at a at at a at at that why should um why shouldn't AI be
34:44
Speaker A
conscious? Why shouldn't a robot that that's equipped with with a with an ultimately sophisticated brain um machine brain however uh why shouldn't it be able to be um to become conscious?
34:58
Speaker A
And so um how how do you express that that cuz if um correct me if I'm wrong but I'm but I'm convinced that you you um you reject that idea. You you reject the possibility or the likelihood that um
35:14
Speaker A
that AI could be could be conscious as I do. Um but how would you go about it uh um about articulating why the idea is simply just you know um there's there's something missing from it. There is there is
35:37
Speaker A
uh there has to be something missing from from from from from cognition for for someone to arrive at that conclusion. How how do you how do you talk about that?
35:52
Speaker A
Mm. With difficulty. Yes, indeed. Uh um I I'm not a fan of dogmatic statements.
36:07
Speaker A
So I I can't say it's completely impossible that AI could ever have some sort of consciousness.
36:15
Speaker A
Um I think it highly highly unlikely. We're fooled by appearances. So AI is trained on a vast amount of human material that is the product of experience, the experience of creatures that are embodied and I believe also have such a thing as a soul.
36:44
Speaker A
And because it is trained on an enormous amount of this material, it's able to simulate very um increasingly accurately the sort of responses that a human being would make.
37:00
Speaker A
But it doesn't mean that as we were inside there, there is a consciousness of the kind that there is in a human being.
37:07
Speaker A
The topic of consciousness and matter is um deserves quite a bit of unpacking, I'm afraid, but but if if I if I'm if I cut to the chase, I I think that we make a mistake partly because we
37:33
Speaker A
believe that matter is obvious. We know what matter is. It's this stuff sitting in front of me, my table and so forth.
37:40
Speaker A
[snorts] And but because it has that immediacy, it doesn't mean that it's obvious what its nature is.
37:47
Speaker A
And and the thing that we have direct experience of is consciousness. We have indirect experience of matter because we have consciousness. Our consciousness allows us to experience elements that we call material. So in all that we experience in
38:10
Speaker A
consciousness, there are elements that have the qualities of a degree of persistence and a degree of resistance. And that is those are the things that we call material. And that we then abstract um a thing that doesn't exist called matter
38:30
Speaker A
and say that that's what they're made of. I argue at some length in chapter I think 25 of the matter of things, which is on matter and consciousness, that broadly speaking consciousness must be primary.
38:53
Speaker A
There there are, you know, only three ways in which the brain and consciousness can relate. Either the brain emits consciousness or it transmits consciousness or it permits consciousness.
39:03
Speaker A
Transmitting is something like a radio receiver that doesn't generate the program that it's um [snorts] giving out but receives it and transmits it.
39:17
Speaker A
Permitting has the idea of constraint shaping um if you like sculpting of what it is that comes through.
39:28
Speaker A
And and um the least likely of all these is that the brain could emit consciousness. I mean nobody has had anything useful to say about how a lump of grayish white matter which you can take out and sit on a desk can in itself
39:48
Speaker A
generate consciousness. But it may very well be able to tune into as it were receive and shape consciousness.
39:56
Speaker A
So my view is that the brain permits consciousness and that consciousness therefore pre-exists the brain.
40:04
Speaker A
And I think it pre-exists everything because I don't know I mean this is a very in my view rational position because as I say nobody has the slightest idea how consciousness could come out of matter if importantly matter is simply lumpen
40:29
Speaker A
matter. I have to be careful when I say this because I find people quoting me and saying oh Miguel thinks that matter is just lumpen matter. Well if you think that then of course but no I'm not saying that. Listen carefully. I'm
40:40
Speaker A
saying if you were to assume that matter were lumpen matter then you'd have a hell of a job getting consciousness out of it.
40:49
Speaker A
Um in fact, it's impossible. So I believe that matter is not lump and matter. It is not simple matter without anything to do with consciousness.
41:00
Speaker A
is already engaged with consciousness and indeed I believe it is a way in which consciousness manifests. So consciousness has phenomenology and in some of its phenomenology it is ideas, thoughts, beliefs, feelings. And in some of its phenomenology it is
41:21
Speaker A
physical entities with which we interact. So that's how I in brief see the relationship. And therefore take the view that consciousness is um what what in philosophical terms is called an ontological primitive. I something that can't be derived from
41:41
Speaker A
something else. It is as it were a starting point. And if that is the case then it must be the primal stuff of the cosmos, which means again that matter has something of consciousness about it.
41:58
Speaker A
Now quite what you mean by that is the question. There must be an interiority to um everything that exists and this must includes subatomic particles. So there is in essence something it is like to be an electron. I mean we can't imagine it.
42:19
Speaker A
It's not like our experience, but there's something about it that must have that quality. Otherwise it can't be brought forth later.
42:28
Speaker A
And I believe that the the consciousness that is um uh proper to speak of that um a an AI excuse me there's an AI might produce is not of a different kind from the AI that my breakfast table produces. It's
42:53
Speaker A
made from from from chips and metal and so on and there it is. Um but the fact that it it it is able to give this simulation, we should be aware all the time of the difference between reality and the simulation. Now that is
43:11
Speaker A
particularly interesting to me because my way of understanding the relationship between the two hemispheres of the brain is that the right hemisphere is actually in touch with whatever is that exists apart from ourselves.
43:27
Speaker A
So things for the right hemisphere are present is one way of putting it, but I prefer the active verb presence.
43:37
Speaker A
They presence to us using a term made popular by Heidegger, the German um which means he had to invent a verb from a noun and the presence. So when we say presencing, it's a perfect translation of of Heidegger's term. But
43:57
Speaker A
the idea that comes across there is not just that something is passively wheeled into a display that we then passively detect like a Geiger counter or a photographic plate. No, what we experience is something in which we play a part. We don't make
44:16
Speaker A
it up, but we take part in its coming into being. So there's something that exists apart from ourselves very importantly.
44:26
Speaker A
I mean this comes back to the conversation about truth. It's neither that we make it all up nor that it just exists out there and that's it and the end of the story. That there is this necessity of an encounter. Everything
44:38
Speaker A
comes out of an encounter. Everything that exists is an encounter between some form of consciousness and and something that is outside of that particular consciousness.
44:50
Speaker A
So um so that's what I say about um the relationship between hemispheres is that the right hemisphere is one in which things actually come into being for us and are vividly there.
45:10
Speaker A
And the left hemisphere is always dealing at one remove. It's dealing with a concept of a thought about, an abstraction from, a category in which this thing sits. It's always dealing with an abstraction. And in that sense it is like a map.
45:27
Speaker A
And and the map and the world that is mapped are completely different from one another obviously and it would be a gross mistake to mistake the map for the world.
45:36
Speaker A
The map has much less in it than the world but that's not a mistake or a problem or a deficit for the map having very little information is its strength because it enables us to use it for one
45:47
Speaker A
particular purpose. Now what I think that has happened to us is that we started to believe that the map is the world, that our theory about the world is the reality that we experience.
46:00
Speaker A
That we live as it were in a diagram that we have cleverly evolved and we can understand it fully therefore.
46:07
Speaker A
But what is left out of that is just about everything that matters which is the sense of belonging that um an embodied spirit or an embodied soul which is what I think we are has in relation to an embodied world.
46:29
Speaker A
Do you see a do you see a relationship between the left hemispheric way of thinking and one's stance on on the concept or notion of free will?
46:47
Speaker A
Is there is there a relation there? Definitely. Could you please um could you please um elaborate on that Yeah.
46:57
Speaker A
um the way you think about it well as I say for evolutionary reasons and we we haven't unpacked the the story of the two hemispheres and perhaps we we don't need to do that for the purposes of this
47:14
Speaker A
um conversation but I'm happy to go there if you if you think it's important but the two hemispheres evolved to pay attention to the world in a different way the left hemisphere for looking out for stuff that is needed principally food
47:30
Speaker A
but also anything else that we want to manipulate in our environment and and that requires this highly focused attention to a detail um and the right hemisphere evolved to pay at the same time a completely different attention which is broad open
47:44
Speaker A
sustained uncommitted vigilant looking out for what we might not have thought of so the left hemisphere in if I may put it in a sound bite the left hemisphere is always trying to um narrow down to a certainty whereas
47:59
Speaker A
the right hemisphere is always opening up to a possibility um the great neuroscientist vs ramachandran says of the right hemisphere and I completely agree with him that it is the devil's advocate it's the one that's saying hey hey hang on a minute it might
48:14
Speaker A
not be like that at all so the left hemisphere wants things to be clear fixed and certain because without fixing them with its gorgon stare it can't necessarily accurately quickly get it so it privileges an idea of a world in
48:33
Speaker A
which it has control and power over the outcomes and it can predict what those outcomes will be and this is a mechanistic world in which as long as you know enough about um the position and momentum of every
48:52
Speaker A
particle in the universe going back to laplace in the 18th century you can predict everything that will follow from there onwards, um including the words I'm saying now and you're listening to me and so Um this idea was all very well when the
49:14
Speaker A
cosmos appeared to be a sophisticated game of billiards with balls bouncing off one another and so on.
49:22
Speaker A
But it it turns out that the cosmos is nothing like that. I mean, first of all, we know from um Heisenberg and and other physicists of the 20th century that the idea that we know and can in principle know
49:37
Speaker A
or could if we knew just a bit more ever um know the full story is is false.
49:45
Speaker A
Um and I one thing that interests me is the remarkable number of physicists who have written to me, approached me and said, what you have written about is very important from our perspective and explained.
50:02
Speaker A
So I'm very grateful for that. But one of them sent me a paper saying, let us just take the the the Laplacian idea of a sort of collision of billiard balls that the universe is an endless um matter of particles colliding with
50:16
Speaker A
one another and if we just knew enough, we could predict the next move. And he said on such a measure, after a certain number of collisions of billiard balls, you cannot for certain predict what the next collision will be.
50:30
Speaker A
And and I thought, gosh, that's interesting. I wonder how many 100 billion or or what? The answer is eight.
50:39
Speaker A
So after eight collisions, you can no longer be absolutely certain what the next collision will be. Not because we don't know enough, because in the nature of things that's how they are.
50:49
Speaker A
So the idea it's built in. is built in. So it is it is nonsense when people talk about determinism. What they're seeing is a very limited within a certain as long as you define things very narrowly, then within that
51:08
Speaker A
and as long as you allow a degree of you know flexibility and indeterminacy, you can be pretty sure. That's right. So I'm not saying that obviously there are no patterns to the way things unfold and we could never know anything about them.
51:23
Speaker A
But once again um as in absolutely everything I I find myself fighting a battle between two ridiculous extreme positions. Either it's all completely determined or it's chaotic and the answer is it's neither of those things.
51:38
Speaker A
Uh it is not chaotic, but it is also not fully determined. So it has shape, it has forms.
51:46
Speaker A
It has indeed I believe um um what Aristotle would have called a telos a final cause that things tend towards certain things. And and the idea of a final cause is of something beyond that is drawing something rather like a a
52:07
Speaker A
magnetic force in that direction. Um and it it's different from being pushed from behind mechanically because pushed from behind um means that the the the path of the thing is determined. And what we now are excitingly understanding in terms of
52:27
Speaker A
cell development, the development of embryos and so forth is that if you frustrate the way an organism is um tending to develop uh and do it in a way that it cannot be um either primed for by previous experience
52:48
Speaker A
uh of its own or by its genetic loading. It will find an intelligent way round the obstacle. It won't just keep on pushing, pushing, pushing at the obstacle futilely. It will think okay, I need to get beyond this because I know
53:06
Speaker A
where it is I want to go, and it will find a way of getting around that optical obstacle.
53:13
Speaker A
And this is absolutely extraordinary. It shows that the the the development of organisms, of complex living systems is not like complicated systems. It has its own capacity to be drawn towards certain um teloi.
53:34
Speaker A
So um that that's what I would say. Now the left hemisphere wants to believe that everything is fixed and sorted out and determined. But the right hemisphere, as I say, being always on the alert for there might be something else going on
53:48
Speaker A
here, is much more open to the idea that this may be intrinsically unknowable. And all the wisdom traditions I know, all indeed the thrust of even Western philosophy, if viewed in its broadest um sense, leads us towards the right hemisphere being correct about
54:10
Speaker A
this, that we will never be fully certain of the the big and important things. But that doesn't mean we can't have ideas that guide us and tendencies that we tend to embrace.
54:26
Speaker A
So [snorts] so to sum up the relationship between um the left hemisphere and free will, it is the um it um it's the it's it's the idea that it's the it's the it's the total predictability that that that
54:49
Speaker A
which is which is the tendency of the left um left hemisphere thinking which leads to the rejection of free will.
54:56
Speaker A
Because if everything is predictable, it's determined therefore. Um Importantly, we are free, although within constraints. Obviously we can't do anything we want.
55:05
Speaker A
Correct. Yes. Um, and if I if I were to take that one step further, if one as the result of adopting a left hemispheric approach to the world, if one arrives at the conclusion that there is no free will, which
55:25
Speaker A
many intellectuals of our time do believe that actually, is there room for the notion of consciousness beyond that? If if you don't believe in free will, can you attribute the the the quality of being conscious to human beings?
55:46
Speaker A
Does it logically follow? It's an interesting exercise because I've never believed in the idea of determinism in any case.
55:55
Speaker A
And I I I don't see why you couldn't believe in a kind of pointless consciousness which just involved suffering but being unable to do anything effective.
56:14
Speaker A
Frankly, if you believe that, you'll believe anything, it seems to me. You know, it doesn't make sense from physics point of view as I've explained, but it doesn't make sense from a psychobiological sense either. I mean, the famous Libet experiments which
56:34
Speaker A
supposedly showed that we were determined to make choices before we were aware of them only demonstrates that much of what goes on as part of our will and our understanding is not in the glare of consciousness all the time.
56:48
Speaker A
As well as having many problems with the way the experiment was set up, I I take it apart in the matter with things for those who are interested.
56:56
Speaker A
So really it's a it's a it's an non-starter. And what people I think mainly mean, and if one's sort of generous to colleagues who who go around and talking about determinism, I think what they really saying is we all pick up
57:15
Speaker A
partly from genetics and partly from upbringing and environment. We we pick up influences. And why not? As I say, we're not we're not without influences. But given those influences, we have choices as to the decisions we can make.
57:31
Speaker A
And it's really important that we should hold people responsible for the choices they make. If people are fully determined, then of course there is no reason to believe that people can be better or worse or avoid committing crimes
57:48
Speaker A
or anything else. So we we we wouldn't we wouldn't get very far if we really lived by an understanding of that. We would have to allow things to dissolve into anarchy very rapidly.
58:05
Speaker A
And that's not a path I particularly recommend. One of the [snorts] lines I usually use is you have no business telling your children you I know you can do better than that.
58:19
Speaker A
I know if you just worked a little bit harder, you could do better. If if you if you truly if you truly believe in the idea of determinism.
58:29
Speaker A
Yes, and and indeed these things are effective. The more we tell children well, you do have options and you can do better and so on, the better they will do.
58:41
Speaker A
So people broadly live up to or down to the assumptions that they hold about human beings and about themselves.
58:53
Speaker A
Um I don't know how you think about this, but I um I take the when I think about how much cachet and how much what a strong selling point the idea of victimhood is in our culture today.
59:09
Speaker A
I can't help but but um but think that uh consciously or unconsciously we we have on a societal level at least um at least to some degree adopted uh this idea that that human beings are just simply defense defenseless um
59:28
Speaker A
infants with no free will and their uh circumstances of of birth and upbringing determines uh almost everything about their their lives and where they end up whereas uh and and and Nietzsche strongly uh strongly rejects this idea and and and
59:46
Speaker A
each and every single one of us uh know at least uh um one or two person in our circles who have been uh tragically unlucky with their with their life circumstances with their uh with their with the with the family they they
60:02
Speaker A
they grow up in yet they uh they went on to achieve um um enormously um glorious things.
60:12
Speaker A
absolutely. Yes. Um Dr. Michael Christ, if I if I may close with this sorry go ahead go ahead please.
60:19
Speaker A
should I just say something about what you've just said or not? Please please go ahead please.
60:24
Speaker A
okay no I think there are two things to worth saying. Um one is exactly that that if you teach people that they're victims they will become victims. They they will lose um agency um and they will spend their time um
60:41
Speaker A
blaming others which is never a fruitful way forward in life. Um take responsibility is a pretty important injunction um if you want to thrive.
60:52
Speaker A
And in the past when life was a very great deal tougher in the West than it is or has been during my lifetime.
61:04
Speaker A
Excuse me. People were far far more resilient than they are now and um as it were took the rough with the smooth and got on with life.
61:19
Speaker A
Um which is not to say that there isn't something um that needs to be said about the proper apportioning of responsibility. So where others are guilty, then they should be held um responsible. But a good position for understanding
61:37
Speaker A
yourself and your life is holding yourself responsible. I can't remember who it was, therapist who said to somebody who was talking about all the ways in which they'd been badly treated and by everyone. And he said, have you noticed
61:50
Speaker A
that in all these situations there was one common element, you were there. [laughter] I I quite like it.
61:59
Speaker A
But so there's that. But the other thing I'd say is that I don't think that what's behind it is is necessarily determinism, but I think it's something um at least as sinister, which is infantilization.
62:15
Speaker A
So I feel very strongly that we are as adults being infantilized by the bureaucracies, the governments, the the whatever's that have power over the nature of our lives.
62:31
Speaker A
And I see this everywhere that I'm I'm cheated um as it were like a child.
62:38
Speaker A
Um and of course we don't hold children responsible to the same degree for their actions in the way that we hold adults responsible. So I think it goes with that.
62:47
Speaker A
And I think this tendency towards infantilization is endemic and extremely damaging. Completely agree. And and insofar as infantilization gives one gives one control over the infantilized uh if if that sentence makes any sense.
63:08
Speaker A
Um it it does it does follow from from the tendency of the left hemisphere insofar as the left hemisphere is is is interested um ultimately in control.
63:21
Speaker A
If you infantilize uh a a person, it it's it becomes a lot easier to um to to to control.
63:31
Speaker A
No, I think that's it. I mean, I think a lot of what we see in the world evolving around us is changes the way we think which make it easier for those who wish to have totalitarian control.
63:46
Speaker A
Right. Right. Right. Exactly. Exactly. [sighs and gasps] Um perhaps perhaps we can close with with with this next question that I will um I'll I'll take a I'll I'll return to the original um I guess the preamble that I started with.
64:09
Speaker A
When I when I think about because because of of of heard you arrive at this point uh through through different avenues and and and and and different angles uh at being pessimistic about our our world but being hopeful.
64:31
Speaker A
When I mentioned in the in in the um the beginning statement that that we we inherited a world that is ordered and we have inverted that order. What I mean by that, to put it in a little bit more of a
64:48
Speaker A
practical uh uh um terms, what I mean by that is the world has a has a structure and that structure gets you to a different gets you to different destinations depending on how you behave and how you act in the world. If you behave in a
65:06
Speaker A
certain way, if you adopt a certain set of principles in your life, you will arrive at one point and if you adopt the opposite set of principles, you will arrive at a different point. That's what I mean by by uh
65:21
Speaker A
positing that the world has an order to itself. Uh that that reality has a has a fabric, has a structure.
65:29
Speaker A
Mhm. Now having having studied your work closely and carefully, I cannot help and and and correct me if I'm wrong here, but given the given the value structure and and and the ordering that's that's that's adopted regarding our value structure in the
65:50
Speaker A
modern world, I don't see how I I I don't see how we can save ourselves if we if we keep at it, if we keep going down the the path that we're going.
66:06
Speaker A
Um too much power, too little wisdom, too little interest for attaining wisdom. Now when I hear you say you're a pessimist, what I hear is you you what I hear is your intellect speaking.
66:25
Speaker A
And when I hear you say you're a you're you're hopeful, uh what I hear is you're basically implying that you're obliged to be you're obligated to be hopeful because because being hopeless is immoral.
66:43
Speaker A
Am I am I writing reading reading you that way? Partly yes. I mean so I do hold that hope is a duty.
66:51
Speaker A
And and it's it's it's but it's not as all these things they're not just pointless injunctions.
67:00
Speaker A
The reason it's very important to remain hopeful is once again um it it helps to resituate what our intellect can tell us.
67:12
Speaker A
You know it it can't answer everything. It doesn't know the future. It's unaided by intuition and imagination. It leads to dead ends.
67:22
Speaker A
So it's it for me what I would say is that the hope is attending to other things.
67:32
Speaker A
And one of the things I feel is important to come back to um something we briefly touched on um some while ago is the coming together of opposites.
67:49
Speaker A
And I think that there's a sense in which the worse things get the better they get in that it requires um a confrontation with an unpleasant reality to jolt us out of a kind of dream we've been living in
68:08
Speaker A
Mm. in which we could just let things go and it'll all be marvelous and the world just gets better and better.
68:20
Speaker A
So the way I see it is that there are hopeful signs uh particularly amongst young people and of course young people are most influential on the future that for humanity that they are no longer willing to accept this in my view
68:42
Speaker A
intellectually, morally and imaginatively bankrupt vision of reductive materialism that has been peddled for far too long and that they're not accepting it and that they they attend to their experience which is of things that are beyond this and they
69:02
Speaker A
may not be able to pin down exactly what they are. It doesn't matter. Don't reject them because you can't pin them down.
69:09
Speaker A
The important things will be hard to pin down. So I think that's that's good. I think there is a return towards a a more spiritual vision. I think there are indications that young people may be returning to organised religion, which I
69:27
Speaker A
think is going to be important if we are to survive as a society. Um and I think that a sort of cleverness got between us and those values of beauty, goodness, and truth.
69:45
Speaker A
So it seemed clever uh to say um no, there is no truth. You know, it's just whatever you think it is. It's it's don't imagine there's anything real behind it.
69:56
Speaker A
Or beauty. Well, no, beauty isn't really the the goal of art and the goal of art is to be powerful, which is interesting. Artists want their work to be described as powerful. And power is the only value, the one at the bottom
70:11
Speaker A
of Shayla's pyramid that the left hemisphere recognizes. All the higher values that lead up through the truth, the good, and the beautiful to the sacred are just um seen as well, in as much as they have utility, then I
70:27
Speaker A
I guess we would subscribe to them. So it a sort of cleverness got between us and the perception of of reality.
70:35
Speaker A
And the same with goodness, that we calculate what is good. But in fact, calculating goodness leads to some very peculiar conclusions. And calculating is almost stereotypically the sort of approach to the idea of morality that is typical of psychopaths and
70:56
Speaker A
schizophrenics. It's interesting it's also typical of um a number of people holding positions in university faculties of philosophy in the Western world.
71:07
Speaker A
So I um and it's expressed in in in the way in which people now talk about um uh [snorts] moral outcomes. They don't understand that they're to do with a disposition.
71:22
Speaker A
They're not they're not just a matter of actions or outcomes. They are what matters for a moral um judgment is what is going on in the heart and mind, the interior things that the machine doesn't see.
71:42
Speaker A
Um and you know it perhaps it's just worth very very briefly um reporting this interesting case in which people were asked to evaluate a moral scenario in one of three conditions um and uh or certainly they were asked to evaluate
71:59
Speaker A
it in the normal state of mind and then with the right temporary parietal junction inhibited um electronically which can be done safely and painlessly for a short period.
72:11
Speaker A
And the scenario was um a woman goes out for coffee with a friend, puts what she thinks is sugar in her friend's coffee but it turns out to be poison and the friend dies. And the other scenario is a woman goes out with
72:26
Speaker A
her friend and puts what she believes to be poison in her coffee but in fact it's sugar and the friend lives. Which was the more immoral action? And obviously in the normal state we think the first one in which she intended to murder. But
72:41
Speaker A
with the right temporary parietal junction [laughter] suppressed people go no no it was the it was the second case because it why?
72:49
Speaker A
Because the outcome was that she died. So that [laughter] complete incapacity to understand morality as it comes from a disposition from the inside. And as it happens I I think that in religion there is too much emphasis on
73:08
Speaker A
propositions and not enough on dispositions. That really belief is yes can be viewed as propositional belief but I think more importantly much more importantly is disposition of the heart.
73:24
Speaker A
[sighs] That is that is such a beautiful example to demonstrate that um that that that that think in our moral moral moral um moral framework uh um on these days. Australian government, the Australian government has started as of um as of two years ago passing a
73:43
Speaker A
number of hate speech laws. And the the most the most dreadful the most dreadful aspects of this of of um of this set of legislations is that it it elevates impact over intent drastically. It it's it's almost disregarded completely what the intent
74:10
Speaker A
of this speaker is and and I think to myself it it takes a lot of work to come up with to to come up with an idea more unwise than that.
74:21
Speaker A
I I agree. I mean of course it's hopeless as a criterion. Absolutely. Absolutely. Yes, sorry you you're about to say something.
74:36
Speaker A
No no no no really. No no no. I'm I'm Okay. uh I'm I'm just sorry about you know what's happening in Australia because um I actually think Australia is a wonderful country.
74:49
Speaker A
Um it has so much going for it and just lately it started to espouse fashionable positions um in irrational ways and Yes.
75:02
Speaker A
this is a change for the worse, but let's hope that the deep sense good sense of Australians at least the the ones that I'm familiar with will one day triumph.
75:17
Speaker A
There is that hope. I I really hope I can I can adopt some of it um take a page from take a page from your book of taken many pages from your book.
75:26
Speaker A
Um hopefully I can I can learn I can learn to be a little bit more hopeful.
75:31
Speaker A
Um uh one of the one of the greatest regrets of my life is the fact that I just wanted to share this piece of personal personal news as well that that Ralston College doesn't accept applications from people from outside of
75:44
Speaker A
outside of the US. I just wanted to mention that. I have been following I have been following them closely over the past couple of years and it seems to be such a such a privilege for anyone really.
75:56
Speaker A
maybe maybe they will. I don't know. But it as it is they get so many applications for so few places.
76:06
Speaker A
You know there's you know I don't know how many I can't give you a precise figure but scores more people apply than can actually get in so I'm certain I'm certain of that.
76:18
Speaker A
It's a it's a fantastic opportunity. Yes. Yes. Dr. Margaret Chris, thank you thank you very much for your time. You've been very generous with your time despite despite being under the weather.
76:31
Speaker A
Oh goodness I'm I'm emerging from the weather and I'm I'm sorry we had to postpone it but it's been a delight in any case telling you thank you.
76:40
Speaker A
Likewise for me. Thank you very much. Okay thank you. Okay. Dr. Margaret Chris. Bye-bye.
76:49
Speaker A
Bye.
Topics:Iain McGilchristthe sacredmoral relativismEnlightenmentMax Schelerhierarchy of valuesconsciousnessreductive materialismAI consciousnessagnosticism

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →