Skip to content
Get App

DEBATE JOTA vs ANUJ | Inmigración, Familia Tradicional y Feminismo /@redpillpodcast_ @anujbostt

A structured debate on social issues between a conservative podcast host and a progressive socialist commentator, covering traditional family, immigration, feminism and demographics.

Key Takeaways

  • The debate is framed around opposing ideological positions, with each side challenging the other's sources and statistics.
  • Both participants agree on the value of open debate, though they disagree sharply on the substance of family, immigration and gender issues.
  • Empirical claims (crime rates, birth rates, child outcomes) are repeatedly contested for methodology and causation.
  • Economic conditions are presented by both sides as a major explanatory factor for social outcomes.

What the video covers

  • The ConPdePodcast hosts a first-of-its-kind debate between J (Redpill Podcast, conservative) and Anuj (progressive socialist commentator) on social issues.
  • Opening exchanges set the tone: both speakers emphasize the value of debating opposing views rather than staying in ideological echo chambers.
  • Discussion of the 'traditional family' model, including whether women should be primarily at home, and the claim that adoption is a child's right rather than an adult's.
  • Debate on falling birth rates, with one side attributing it to economic inability to support children and the other to broader social and environmental factors.
  • Immigration and the 'demographic replacement' claim are contested, including crime statistics and the argument about youth working rates among migrant minors.
  • Discussion of the role of fathers in child outcomes, with challenges over the cited statistics and calls for peer-reviewed sources.
  • Feminism and its relationship to family priorities, and whether feminist movements deprioritize motherhood.
  • Economic arguments about migration: whether employers use migrant labor to suppress wages, and whether economic crisis drives radicalization.
  • Debate over whether safety for women in Spain has worsened due to migration, with contrasting interpretations of crime data.
  • The episode closes with the question of national identity ('When is a Spaniard a Spaniard?'), reflecting the broader theme of cultural belonging.

Answers

Questions about this video

What is the central format of this video?

It is a live-style debate between two guests with opposing ideologies, moderated by the ConPdePodcast host. The discussion covers social issues such as family, immigration, and feminism, and is presented as the channel's first debate of this kind.

Which social topics are debated?

The main topics are the traditional family model, falling birth rates, immigration and demographic change, the role of fathers, feminism, and women's safety. Economic factors are also discussed as drivers of these issues.

Do the debaters reach agreement?

Some limited agreement emerges, such as on the economic pressures affecting family formation and on the value of open debate itself. However, the participants remain sharply divided on immigration, gender roles and the interpretation of statistics.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00
Speaker A
We don't stop, man. The thing is, I hate it when they delegitimize what I say solely and exclusively because I don't remember exactly.
00:06
Speaker A
Traditional family, the only family that exists. Yeah, the family where the woman has to be at home, can't work and develop her life, in order to raise a child at the cost of her own development. You just said that yourself.
00:16
Speaker A
Adoption is not a right of adults. You don't have the right to adopt. Adoption is a right of the child. People don't have children, not because of feminists or anything like that, they don't have them because they can't afford to
00:27
Speaker A
support a child. Your opinion about him, I imagine you don't like it. Not much.
00:30
Speaker A
Well, you're a premium progressive, huh ? What do you think about this demographic replacement we are experiencing? And these are numbers, people can't fight against this, and many people from your ideological framework deny it. The "menas," who are
00:44
Speaker A
talked about so often, at 16 and 17 years old, they work three times as much as locals. But that's not a good statistic. That means there are kids, youngsters, who should be studying, who are working instead, and everyone has
00:53
Speaker A
their own take on that. I, for example, don't. To live in peace, would you go live in a neighborhood that is predominantly immigrant? Maghreb. It depends. Don't lie, man. That's it, not much else. I'm a conservative old fossil, and that's that. And I'm a
01:07
Speaker A
progressive, that's it. Welcome to a new episode of IC Comp podcast. It is a true pleasure, as always, to be behind your screens, and today we bring history here to the channel, to Comp podcast. For the first time, we are
01:19
Speaker A
going to have the first debate in the history of the channel on very interesting topics: social issues. They could have been economic or more political topics, but today we are going to talk about social issues, which are always, well, the order of
01:32
Speaker A
the day; which we all, to a greater or lesser extent, have opinions about and which influence our day-to-day lives.
01:39
Speaker A
So, well, today my guests are going to introduce themselves. I have J here to my left, and ANU to my right. How are things? How are you doing? Good, great, great.
01:48
Speaker A
Thank you so much for coming. First of all, it's a pleasure. I was really looking forward to—well, I already knew Lu because he was interviewed on the podcast a few months ago, but I didn't know you, so I was really
01:56
Speaker A
looking forward to meeting you, and, well, I really appreciate the debate we're going to have today.
01:59
Speaker A
Besides, I'll be in debates within this format, so it's the first for you and for me.
02:03
Speaker A
Perfect. For J as well. Wait, what do you mean it's the first for me? No, no, no, no, on social media. I'm usually more into academic debates. Ah, okay, okay.
02:12
Speaker A
No, I'm quite seasoned on social media, but anyway, Good luck, and well, uh, first, introductions. For those who don't know you, although I think everyone knows you, at least those watching this debate, but surely people know how content gets shared and reaches random
02:29
Speaker A
people who have never opened YouTube. So, uh, who are you two? If you want to start, Anug. Uh, I'm Anug. I focus on current events, political analysis, international analysis, and, well, I'm starting to debate a bit now because I
02:42
Speaker A
think it's good; it's something that profiles, people with my profile, usually don't do, and I say: well, I think it's time for someone to try and stir things up a bit, right?
02:51
Speaker A
Yes, I admire you for that. You were absolutely right to say that people with your profile don't usually engage in debates. They usually operate in echo chambers where everyone applauds like seals whatever they say, which is something I respect and admire on your
03:02
Speaker A
part. I'm J, host of the Redpar Podcast , a person who finds great difficulty in finding people of your profile to debate, so I thank you for being able to make this debate happen. I have a mindset that many call old-fashioned,
03:16
Speaker A
conservative, and so on. I simply consider myself very anchored in reality, and that's it, nothing more.
03:24
Speaker A
I'm an old-fashioned conservative, period. And I'm a progressive socialist, right? We are a progressive socialist. Well, that's it, we have the labels clear now, right ?
03:32
Speaker A
And I thank you both for coming and for your honesty, because it's true that it's always very difficult to organize debates. People tend to, uh, reinforce their own confirmation bias, right?
03:44
Speaker A
Right-leaning people tend to go more to right-leaning channels, people on the left to left-leaning channels; finding a balance point, right? A channel—I don't mean just mine, but in general— that brings both sides together so that you can actually talk, right? Didn't
03:58
Speaker A
the thing with Charlie Kids happen recently, right? A person who, regardless of his ideology—which you may or may not agree with—was someone who was willing to debate, right?
04:05
Speaker A
Always. Mm. Forgive the brief interruption, but if you want to debate as well as J and Nug do, I recommend the best supplements in Spain. Zen Focus for concentration and energy, Zen Calm for stress and anxiety , and Zen Sleep to promote deep,
04:20
Speaker A
restorative sleep. I'll leave the link in the description and the pinned comment. And for Compcast followers, there is a 10%discount, which is something that is never, ever offered.
04:31
Speaker A
So, use code "Comp" for podcast, enter it, and you get your discount. Uh, so, well, if you want, before starting the debate, we can continue delving into this a bit. I find it interesting, don't you? Why do you
04:39
Speaker A
think there is so much conflict when it comes to— If you want, can I start? There is no conflict on my part or on my side, generally speaking.
04:48
Speaker A
I, uh— No. I would tell you that almost everyone in the circles I move in has more or less my ideological framework, because one person doesn't think exactly the same as another. And a Greek philosopher said this a long time
05:02
Speaker A
ago: if two people think exactly the same 100%of the time, one of the two is 100%stupid. Therefore, people I have an affinity with have always been open to debate. With people who are, let's say, ideological nemeses, you always find
05:16
Speaker A
this refusal to debate, and it doesn't just happen in Spain; it happens in Argentina, in the United States, it happens almost everywhere. So that is why, I repeat, I admire Nug, because it is high time that the social democratic
05:31
Speaker A
or "socialist-progressive" side—as you said disparagingly, but jokingly— be willing to confront ideas. Yes, what I see, what I have seen historically, is that there are certain ideas that are complicated and often directly imply a way of confronting the
05:47
Speaker A
existence of many people and—there are people who don't want to risk having to debate their own existence, like trans people, even though that's not going to stop them from existing.
05:56
Speaker A
Obviously, debates go beyond the mere existence of things. I mean, the 12- hour workday wasn't abolished just because there was a debate, but precisely because there was an enormous social mobilization. So, I'm no longer a fan of that thesis of not looking at
06:08
Speaker A
the monsters, but rather I want to debate, and I want people, even if they don't change their minds, to at least have ideas that can open up their worldview, which I think is the most important thing at the end of the day;
06:17
Speaker A
that is, to have different visions and be able to say, "Well, maybe I agree on this, but not on that." I think that's what ends up building a person's personality.
06:26
Speaker A
What I would tell you is the following. You will gain many more followers by confronting me than by confronting anyone else you disagree with. There are many people who are going to hate me too. Well, I'll say from here that
06:37
Speaker A
anyone who throws hate at Nug on social media, if they are from my community, I don't want them in it, because this is a person who is showing courage when it comes to confronting their ideas, and I never promote hate toward any person.
06:51
Speaker A
Eh, it's something that hurts me a lot when they tell me that, because what I promote and what drives me above all else is love. Now, I do not confront the existence of people. What I confront is whether the self-perception
07:03
Speaker A
of existence that those people have is real or not. And that is a completely different topic. And just because you have the right to exist doesn't mean I don't have the right to question whether how you perceive yourself is
07:15
Speaker A
real or not. Those are quite different things and I think it's important. Sure. I mean, I don't think there's a problem with you perhaps having doubts about whether someone or their particular life situation is more or less legitimate. The problem is when,
07:27
Speaker A
by doubting it, that person, for example, is subjected to hate or subjected to people who go beyond ideas and start taking action.
07:33
Speaker A
And I go back a bit to the Charlie Kirk topic. I thought Charlie Kirk was a guy whose ideas I didn't like, but I wouldn't kill him. And if I had to put it on a scale of people who would kill,
07:42
Speaker A
they would be much further along in their ideas regarding how a person can directly seek to say, "Okay, we have to hit them or we have to go after these types of people." I don't think that, when you debate or say: "Well, I think
07:53
Speaker A
these people...", well, I mean, I think that when you take away so much weight, especially at the end of the day, you say: "Let people do whatever they want and if you want, uh, and you're a woman and you're a trans person, I don't care
08:04
Speaker A
." I mean, I think there are many problems and there are people who are already oppressing the majority of people who deserve much more hatred and focus than a trans person, or a gay person, or questioning whether or not
08:15
Speaker A
it makes sense for two people of the same sex to have, uh, sexual relations, or someone who might be a woman who has a penis. I mean, have you seen the news about what happened yesterday at a summer camp in the Basque Country?
08:27
Speaker A
Are you aware of it? Not entirely, I mean, not not the a person said, uh, screw you all, I'm going to to "faggotize", what was it?
08:37
Speaker A
Faggotize your children. And it turns out that many parents have reported that this counselor, a member of the LGBT community, forced the children to suck on his toe before getting into the shower. Many of the criticisms that the
08:50
Speaker A
LGBT community receives are greatly confused with criticisms simply of homosexual people. They are quite different things. I clearly distinguish between the rainbow collective and individuals to whom they do not.
09:02
Speaker A
You believe the LGBT community wants to turn children gay. They say it themselves. Many people, many people say it, yes.
09:08
Speaker A
So, because two people say it, hundreds of thousands think the same thing. Two. And why do they want to get into schools constantly then, to try to sell sexual orientations to children who are all the fruit of heterosexual relationships? I one one
09:25
Speaker A
thing, Nug, I'm only going to ask for one thing in this debate and that is that when I'm making a point, at least let me finish it and then if you want I will try to mediate, okay? But but I was already there in
09:34
Speaker A
the middle and believe me, it's quite complicated to be able to formulate a whole sentence when you're already here trying to respond over me. I like the tone of this debate and I think that's good. I don't believe that all members of the
09:45
Speaker A
LGBTI community want to make our children gay. What I do believe is that the LGBT community gains many people, many detractors like me, as soon as they try to interfere in children's education at younger and younger ages.
10:01
Speaker A
That is a red line that I do not cross. I, my child, I have the right for them to have my values. I am a conservative, Catholic old fogey. I don't want them teaching that to my child, and if it
10:11
Speaker A
turns out they are gay later, well, so be it, that's that, it's absolutely fine. But why do I have to?
10:16
Speaker A
Can I ask you a question? Yes. Do you believe that people become gay or are born gay?
10:20
Speaker A
That's a very good question, man. It's an extremely good question. The truth is there is no scientific evidence saying that people are born that way.
10:30
Speaker A
There isn't any. I wouldn't truly know how to answer you. I think they can be made. The environment can, in a certain sense—and here I’m getting very conspiratorial—I consider that food, water, endocrine disruptors, microplastics, and other things affect
10:44
Speaker A
the hormonal axis in a certain way, and that is why we have a boom in LGBT people in large cities. It is a topic, it is a quite delicate question, and believe me, I don't want to talk about
10:54
Speaker A
certain things on this program because I cannot talk about certain things on social media.
10:58
Speaker A
Sure, I mean, I ask you this question mostly because, well, there are two basic lines of thought. If people cannot become gay, which is somewhat the line followed by the LGBT community —meaning that's why it doesn't work, right? Yes, I mean, it's a combined
11:10
Speaker A
part, but yes, it is mainly something you are born with. In other words, if you cannot make a person stop being gay, if conversion therapies don't work, you cannot make a child become gay. I can use myself as
11:21
Speaker A
an example, because we could make a clear rule if we were to say people can become gay or they become gay if they receive information from gay people.
11:29
Speaker A
When I was 11 years old, I received a talk from a trans girl who had transitioned at my school, and I am not trans.
11:34
Speaker A
How old are you? Just to put Ah, 25. Okay. 25. So I think that, evidently, especially if we look at the evidence regarding what you say about big cities and we could, if you want to talk about the water issue, etc., it is quite
11:47
Speaker A
clear that people, and especially the LGBT community, do not want to turn children gay. You want to say this exists, maybe you relate to it, that you have something bad and therefore it doesn't mean to children, to people.
12:01
Speaker A
To people. I mean, because you say, you say, "I want my child to be, uh, to have my values, that means to be heterosexual." You can't do that.
12:06
Speaker A
Look, I would like my child, especially if I have an only child, to be heterosexual because I want descendants . Well, I mean, I think it's legitimate to want your child to have descendants. But if your child were gay, they could have
12:16
Speaker A
descendants. They couldn't have descendants with the person they love, right? Just like I want to be a p, look, I have a show and I always say that one of my biggest dreams in life and one of my great
12:25
Speaker A
aspirations is to be a father. Mm. Regardless of what I desire and what I aspire to, if I don't find a woman with whom to start a family, I'm not going to be so selfish as to deny that child a mother.
12:41
Speaker A
And that and a child and a child can only be conceived through a father and a mother . The problem with conservatives, all of us, is that we haven't fought hard enough to define what the family is.
12:54
Speaker A
And the family is made up of a man and a woman. And I, the traditional family, the only family that exists Yes. The family where the woman has to be at home, cannot work and develop her life to raise a child at the cost of
13:06
Speaker A
her own development. You're the one who just said that. It's the traditional family. That's why I don't defend the traditional family.
13:11
Speaker A
Look, the family, the only one, the heterosexual relationship is the only one capable of conceiving life. What do you mean, and what? That is the biggest , I mean, your whole life revolves around having a child.
13:23
Speaker A
If you want, guys, to not get too off track and to define this a bit more, let's talk, if you're okay with it, about what the role of men and women should be in society and of so that we skip the blocks, we invert
13:33
Speaker A
them. Okay, perfect. Yes, because we're going to, I tell people this, we're going to start on immigration, but since it's gone down this path, if you don't mind, we'll continue here.
13:40
Speaker A
It's tough, moderated, but, but it's okay, it's okay. So, if you all are okay with it, what should the role of men and women be? All I want to say about the topic of family, I am in favor of the family, and as for family,
13:50
Speaker A
I am heterosexual and I am a person, I consider myself masculine, I'm not very different from what could be called the archetype of the white, straight man, okay? I mean, that is what I am. Even being progressive, I am aware of the
14:00
Speaker A
position I'm in, I want to have a family, I want to have children. But if it were to happen, and for example the woman I fall in love with and who I want, who I want that part of my life
14:08
Speaker A
with, cannot have children, I am not thinking every day that I can't have a child and I would like to have three.
14:13
Speaker A
But not everyone is driven in life by having a child, and that doesn't just go from the heterosexual perspective, but it goes from the perspective of lesbian people and gay people. When you find love, perhaps there are times that
14:24
Speaker A
not everything will turn out as you want, and it is part of life to accept that the family is the place where you are comfortable and the place where you develop, and not always the place that leads to perfection. So, I am in favor
14:33
Speaker A
of the family. Yes, I am in favor of the family in which the woman has a specific role, the man a specific role, it is not flexible and a project of advancement cannot be developed. No, I believe that women, just like men, have
14:44
Speaker A
their concerns, they want to have a job , they want to have a life, they may want to have a certain freedom, and they may desire, for example, to have children sooner or later. And I know the reverse cases of women who want to
14:54
Speaker A
have children very soon and men who don't want to have them. And that is a natural thing.
14:58
Speaker A
More and more, it happens more and more . Let's see, several things. You have made a correlation that the traditional family model is not at all flexible, that is to say, that the woman is submissive. Traditional. Traditional.
15:13
Speaker A
Let's see, let's see, let's see, no, we are talking about the fact that today many women are realizing the scam that feminism has been. They find themselves at 40, with cats, wine, and anti-anxiety meds and they say, "Damn,
15:21
Speaker A
I've been deceived." And they have great careers. They can afford a Gucci bag, they can afford a ton of material things, but they are missing a very essential part which is motherhood.
15:30
Speaker A
Actually, there is no reference to that . Uh, there are, there are actually quite a few, but I'll tell you one very important thing. When you say that you are open to the idea that if your partner cannot have children, that it's
15:42
Speaker A
not the most important thing in life, that's perfect. But imagine, you are a heterosexual man, your wife is, in a specific case due to a specific problem or your own sterility, uh, infertility, I think it is, or her
15:55
Speaker A
sterility is a specific case. In the case of homosexual couples, they will never be able to have children. They will never be able to have children.
16:04
Speaker A
I cannot equate, okay? Two, two models of relationships when the consequences of those models are completely different. Imagine that you and I are friends, we go to live together. You and I have a separation because we argue, because you left the
16:22
Speaker A
PlayStation controller in the kitchen and that makes me very nervous and I decide to argue with you and you and I separate. I leave, I take my things and I go. The State does not get involved in settling absolutely anything in that
16:33
Speaker A
separation. However, the State has a fundamental role in marriage and has had a fundamental role in marriage throughout history because it is understood that from the union of man and woman, society is born, which is the offspring.
16:45
Speaker A
Therefore, there is a clear distinction between the family, what the family is, which is now called a family, any social construct really. And that is where my battle is. My battle is that you cannot call everything just anything. Things work in a certain way
17:00
Speaker A
and biology, to this day science has not been able to eliminate it and only one sperm and only one egg is capable of conceiving life. That is my point.
17:10
Speaker A
That we later want to play God and that people have, play house and play at such, or older single men say, "No, I want to be a father." And because I want to be a father, I am going to
17:19
Speaker A
raise my children alone, "or a single mother like Ana Obregón saying," No, I am going to raise this little girl. "" I find it regrettable and I want to make it clear, and this is very important, that adoption because, of
17:28
Speaker A
course, when we talk about family you have to put a little bit of offspring into the equation because a couple and so on with a dog for me is not a family . Okay, I want to make this clear as
17:36
Speaker A
well. Adoption is not a right of adults . You do not have a right to adopt.
17:43
Speaker A
Adoption is a right of childhood. Yes, we agree on that. And the proper conditions must be met for that child to grow up harmoniously.
17:51
Speaker A
The stance of the conservative dinosaur you have in front of you is that a child needs the role of a mother and the role of a father, or masculine energy and feminine energy. And I am not talking about the woman washing the
18:02
Speaker A
dishes and the man going out to hunt mammoths. So then, what does masculine and feminine energy mean?
18:06
Speaker A
Masculine and feminine energy means that hormonally, children, especially at the nursing age, Do you have proof of what you are saying?
18:12
Speaker A
Yes. Where are the proofs? Yes, look, you can look up any study that reflects how children who have not been Any study. Which one? You talk about this constantly. You must have a you must have a study, you should be able
18:23
Speaker A
to cite a source. Listen to me, I have, uh, I think more than 50 studies published in my community. Obviously, I don't have, I am not in your community. I mean, where is the study? If you are going to cite
18:31
Speaker A
a study, you have to tell me which one it is. I can say, there is a study that says the exact opposite. I am going to pin the study in the comment. I will post it and pin it because right now I don't remember
18:42
Speaker A
exactly, because as I tell you, I handle too many studies, but it is proven that women release oxytocin in large amounts. Anyone can look this up, okay? Okay, very well. You are trying to attack, uh, which study? But what I
18:55
Speaker A
am going to tell you, you will tell me if it is true or not true. A woman releases a lot of oxytocin when she has an orgasm and when she is breastfeeding and nursing the child. At that moment,
19:08
Speaker A
the child is hormonally feeling a lot of affection because I don't know if you knew that oxytocin is the hormone of emotional bonding. Right? Did you know that or not?
19:17
Speaker A
Yes, but yes, but that is irrelevant. I mean, wh What happens? That during that stage the mother is extremely important; deliberately depriving a child of that —mind you, there are cases and cases, and you always bring me the exception,
19:27
Speaker A
the child in war—deliberately depriving a child of that seems like a mistake to me. Then it is proven that children, as they develop, find the male hormone starts to become more prevalent in adolescence, because it is no longer love and affection that take
19:40
Speaker A
precedence; it starts to be discipline, it starts to be teaching you that your actions have consequences, and that is what I call the extremely important masculine and feminine role. Together we form a yin and a yang, together we
19:52
Speaker A
form the perfect complementarity from which everyone in this room has come. That is what an old-school conservative like me defends, nothing more. No, but the problem, the problem is not that you defend biological studies when I don't know what their sample size is, I
20:05
Speaker A
don't know where they were done, I don't know their dispersion, I haven't seen them. So, I don't know if what you're saying is true or not, because, fundamentally, most biological studies start from the fact that they first have to be peer-reviewed, they have to
20:17
Speaker A
be published; and many of the studies you cite, and that I've seen people who talk about these things cite, are not verified and are studies done in isolation. So, we could talk at length and say: "Yes, because I've seen a
20:27
Speaker A
study and I'll cite it for you here," or I could pull one out and tell you: " Yes, because I've seen the exact opposite, that single-parent families have a higher success rate for their children in university." That is proven not to be true.
20:38
Speaker A
Yeah, but where is the study? The study, but guys, let's focus on, or what I think I would like is for you to counter-argue rather than attack. But how am I going to counter-argue something you aren't showing me? I mean
20:49
Speaker A
, you're telling me to argue against what I'm telling you, and I already said first of all, I'm not a biologist.
20:53
Speaker A
Okay, but I, okay, I have committed to providing the citations. Yes, yes. And to pass them on to Luis.
20:57
Speaker A
I can commit to responding to it if you want, but we’re back to the same thing. In a debate, you can't come and tell me "yes, because there's a study that says such and such." I think that, regardless of anything, I mean, you can
21:05
Speaker A
enter into these debates without, um, I mean, you can support them with genetic or environmental factors or arguments; but I'm saying you can rebut one another without needing to anchor yourselves, solely and exclusively, in the biological part. Because, for
21:17
Speaker A
example, the categorical debate about the family, which is the one you were raising, right?,about what family is, beyond the margin of certain neurotransmitters being released like oxytocin, which by the way is also released when, for example, you consume
21:28
Speaker A
, uh, drugs like MDMA and such. Uh, I mean, uh, there is an interesting categorical debate of, hey, aside from biology influencing it, uh, is family only and exclusively the traditional family or can we endow other human groups with that semantic relationship.
21:44
Speaker A
I think so. I think family is something quite broad because in family, beyond conception, because often one cannot conceive or because often life situations make families not structured and perfect. In fact, most families are not structured, they never have been;
22:00
Speaker A
and precisely they haven't been because the traditional family model—and I'm talking about the traditional family model where the man has to be...uh, usually very early relationships are formed where the man and woman are inexperienced, where there is social
22:14
Speaker A
pressure for that family nucleus to exist for conception, which is why many men end up going to prostitutes or end up looking for other partners because they aren't happy in a relationship that is artificial and, in many cases,
22:27
Speaker A
only has the goal of nurturing that spirit of trying to maintain a society, a civilization. When, in reality, when you look at the majority of society, regardless of religion or culture, what you see is that with development, people and families become more open,
22:41
Speaker A
because family is the place where you are comfortable and it's the place where you want to have a future with someone around you; it's not the place where you only go to have a child. So, having a child is fine and it is a
22:52
Speaker A
factor, but it is not the only factor. So, when we talk about family, you can tell me, "Yes, oxytocin this and that." "The most important thing, especially in it's not oxytocin this and that. I said that the father's role and the mother's
23:03
Speaker A
role are important. Don't discredit everything I've told you by calling it that. No, but, I mean, I'm not discrediting it. It's just that when you are talking in biological terms, I don't know if, I mean, have you studied biology or do
23:14
Speaker A
you have any kind of background where you can, you know? Say, I have studied sports science, I am self-taught like you.
23:19
Speaker A
Yes, yes, but it’s different, do you understand? No, I mean, if we are going to talk about science, we have to talk about it properly with papers. But anyway, what I wanted to say is that family is something open, not just one
23:29
Speaker A
type of family, right? Family is something quite open because it is also the most practical thing. If you really want civilization to move forward, what you cannot do is force people to have relationships to see if at some point
23:40
Speaker A
civilization grows. The most concrete point I want to make about the topic of family is, I think, that when human beings have the ability to reach space, have the capacity to develop technology , and have the ability to see beyond
23:52
Speaker A
what they have always been able to see given the time they’ve had, that makes their minds grow, it makes the way we relate to each other grow, and in the end, family, like other social structures, also becomes broader and
24:03
Speaker A
doesn't have to be what it has been during certain periods of history, like it might have been 100 years ago, because family has not always been a man and a woman. Most of the time, especially during almost 7000 years,
24:16
Speaker A
family was a collective matter, because raising a child couldn't just be up to a father and a mother. So, when we talk about family, we don't just talk about who has the child, because when one parent is absent and the other,
24:29
Speaker A
we talk about tribe. Yes, we can talk about the collective, not tribe, because within tribes there are groups that often look after the children and it isn't always the tribe.
24:36
Speaker A
When we talk about, for example, Mesopotamia, when we talk about classical civilizations, we see that children cannot always be cared for by their parents, because their parents have to be working or their parents have to go to war or their parents have
24:47
Speaker A
to do many things. And that is where society takes on the role of care and education and that is where the child grows. So, that whole family structure of conception is the basic one. Sure, biologically speaking, there can only
25:02
Speaker A
be a child from a man and a woman at a biological level that has the capacity to, uh, reproduce, etc.
25:07
Speaker A
Yes, I am not denying that other models can exist, what I defend 100%is that the model I defend is the one that gives the best results for children. On the hormonal issue, are you also going to tell me which study that is? I
25:23
Speaker A
don’t know it by heart right now. If you want, anyone who wants it, I’ll send a list of all the studies because it’s a personal commitment now. And what I am going to tell you is that children, when they grow up in a
25:33
Speaker A
structured home with mom and dad—mind you, not an alcoholic dad, don't give me a mom who's a prostitute or does OnlyFans and gets bullied at school, no . When mom and dad have a good relationship and a healthy relationship
25:46
Speaker A
, children tend to have much better results across all metrics. Uh, better grades, uh, a more prosperous life, less tendency to end up in jail, less tendency to be rapists, to be criminals . When you remove, mind you, and here
26:01
Speaker A
the factor is especially the absence of the father. When you remove the father from the equation in raising them, more prone to being a murderer, more prone to being, uh, a rap—incredibly more so.
26:14
Speaker A
How much? I mean, 70, the statistic— I’ve mentioned this like four times, but the statistics are: 70 or between 70 and 80%of the prison population grew up without a father, 75%of rapists didn't have a father, 80%of kids who
26:28
Speaker A
don't finish school don't have a father figure in the home. And do you know the proportion of the number of families that don't have a father and nothing happens? Let's see, that is—that is manipulating statistics; correlation doesn't imply
26:44
Speaker A
causation. Okay, but listen to me, let's see, just because the father is missing doesn't mean it’s the cause.
26:48
Speaker A
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, one second, one second. I don’t like these mental gymnastics. Let me, let me tell you one thing. Evidently, if there are a million families that have grown up without a father and many of them
27:05
Speaker A
turned out fine, it doesn't mean that the absence of a father isn't relevant. Because when in so many statistics that I just cited to you, and I can cite even more, the absence of the father is the common
27:17
Speaker A
factor, it doesn't mean that the father figure doesn't affect the cognitive and social development of infants, when it is quite proven that it does.
27:26
Speaker A
It is also well proven that the majority of murderers have one part of the brain more developed than others.
27:32
Speaker A
For example, the part What kind of argument is that? I mean, I’m telling you that just because something seems causal doesn't mean that’s the origin. That is to say, many criminals—I can't say if that is the reason or not, because in most
27:43
Speaker A
criminal statistics, nobody says that it is the reason. I am telling you that I’m not saying that when you remove the father figure from the home, the trend is that you are much more likely to end up in these statistics I just
27:58
Speaker A
mentioned. The father figure is extremely important, and when you take the father out of the equation, the numbers are there. If you're just finishing them, let me ask: could it be that it's not the lack of a father
28:10
Speaker A
figure, but rather that many families rely on the father's income? Without the father's job, there is economic failure, family instability, and therefore, that child who has no money, who often has an absent family, who has worse education, ends up in
28:22
Speaker A
environments that promote ending up a murderer. It could be that it's not exactly the lack of masculine energy, but the side effects it causes, because most families—especially in these types of studies, which are American— depend on the father; and if the father
28:37
Speaker A
isn't home, there is no money. If there is no money, there is no education, and if there is no education, it is easier for you to commit murder. I ask because maybe I can answer you, and I think those are
28:48
Speaker A
absolute mental gymnastics instead of admitting: look, if I...but honestly, seeing your ideological stance, if I told you:" Hey, the mother is extremely important in the home and when children grow up without a mother, "and I cited a series of statistics, I’d bet
28:59
Speaker A
anything that you would never have started investigating:" Hey, but maybe it's not the mother, maybe it's that the father is missing. "However, when I say the father is important, I don't care, I mean, I don't care if honestly, honestly you'll see, you'll
29:11
Speaker A
see as the debate goes on that I don't care because I literally look at sociology. In sociology, when the mother is missing, what often happens is that fathers, who often need companionship in more traditional societies, tend to fall into alcoholic
29:24
Speaker A
tendencies, drug addiction, criminal behavior, and that often leads to the family breaking down. But it's such a tiny percentage that when we speak in generalities we say," No, the lack of a father or mother affects things. "" Of
29:36
Speaker A
course it affects things, but the top three causes for a criminal to be a criminal is family instability, regardless of which one.
29:42
Speaker A
The lack of education that leads to school failure and the lack of access to opportunities and development within the surrounding society. Those are the three main causes. If you remove the father or the mother, there will be that family structure issue that will
29:55
Speaker A
affect them economically in their studies and therefore will affect how they develop. And why does it affect it so differently when it's the father figure who is absent versus when it's the father's economic figure in most cases?
30:05
Speaker A
You put everything on the father's economic dependency. How long have women been working? Because I can actually tell you about that. But the thing is, I don't know when your study is from, that's why I'm telling you. There are classic studies
30:14
Speaker A
from the United States that talk about the father's absence as a factor. Okay, but this isn't a classic study.
30:18
Speaker A
If I recall correctly, if I recall correctly, this study by María Calvo. If I recall correctly, if I recall correctly, by María Calvo. And it talks about And with what sample size, how many families, huh? Damn, man, listen to me, dude, I'm
30:29
Speaker A
juggling way too much information, man. But bring it. Brother, listen to me, brother. Listen to me, man. That's not legitimate. I'm telling you that everything I'm going to bring here, I'm going to give to him. That study is
30:39
Speaker A
published, because at the end of the day, you're...what is the study? Look, bro, you're talking to me about studies and I'm telling you that I'm almost certain it's by the sociologist María Calvo.
30:47
Speaker A
What you have to understand is that I come here like this, okay? And how is that my fault?
30:53
Speaker A
It's not, it's not that it's your fault . One second, one second, let me finish . It's not about whether or not it's your fault. The point is that if I'm giving you information, don't use...
30:59
Speaker A
What study is that? I'm telling you. Later you can look at all the bibliography and all the studies I'm going to give him and you tell me what you think of them. But you want me to take for granted that your study is
31:08
Speaker A
good so that your argument makes sense, when maybe it is, because you can say here: "Yeah, because I saw a study that says such and such." But if you don't show me a study and I don't see it here
31:16
Speaker A
...and, a question, man: if I were to bring you the study, would you read it entirely here, stop to look at least at the abstract, look at the sample, look at the dispersion, look at the basic data to see if...look if it's
31:25
Speaker A
peer-reviewed, look, I mean, basic things of science that when you see them you say: "Ah, this study might make more or less sense"? It could be, there are studies about autism that are done with 76 children in Finland and
31:36
Speaker A
maybe you could be there and say, "No, well, the consumption of some food causes autism and it's a study of 70 people.""And I should say,""Yeah, well, you might be right, I'll give you that.
31:44
Speaker A
""No, if you're going to talk about science, you're going to talk about what it is." That's why I'm asking you for it. If you're going to cite a study to me, you can stop. Yes, we can stop now and you can look it up. Okay, yeah,
31:52
Speaker A
yeah, yeah. That's what we're going to do. I don't have any problem with that, man. let's stop.
31:57
Speaker A
Man, it's just that I hate it when they delegitimize what I say solely and exclusively because I don't remember exactly which study it is. Look, ladies and gentlemen, I had my phone on airplane mode, but Nug here has really
32:06
Speaker A
annoyed me, so I'm going to send it to him, and now he'll say that this isn't worth anything, that this is toilet paper, and that Skylar's study is worth more. Here. No, no, let's see it. Uh, importance of the paternal figure in
32:19
Speaker A
the education of children. Family stability, social development. 2025. This is where all the statistics I gave you appear, that 75%of rapists have, uh , grown up in a fatherless home.
32:31
Speaker A
Everything, I mean, all the catastrophe that usually happens in all the negative metrics when kids don't have a father. This does not mean that 75%of people who have grown up without a father are going to meet these statistics. Please, it means that the
32:47
Speaker A
people who end up being a rapist, being a murderer, or dropping out of school tend to not have a father. But is this published anywhere?
32:57
Speaker A
Yes. Where? I mean, because I see it's from an institute. I mean, it says International Institute of Family Studies. But in what journal is this published? I mean, because it's not even a study, it's—it’s a report. I mean, it’s a report on the
33:08
Speaker A
father's situation; it’s not even a study because there’s no sample, there's no it doesn’t cite the bibliography of the studies it was taken from.
33:14
Speaker A
Yeah, but it doesn't give the exact data, it doesn't even provide the sample or the variance, it doesn't— Yeah, does that work for you? Let's leave it at, uh well, that's it, it doesn't matter if the father bit isn't there, it's the
33:22
Speaker A
conclusion. I didn't say that. let the public handle the fact-checking , I mean, as a conclusion, because I’ll tell you one thing: if for everything I say you tell me "this is how it is," I’m going to have to be on my damn
33:31
Speaker A
phone the whole time to check if it's valid or not, it’s going to be a pain in the ass. I—I just want, I mean, I want to make it clear that an absent father has an effect. What I’m not...
33:40
Speaker A
what you’re saying, or the way you’re framing it, makes it sound like the absence in a small percentage of millions of people causes a situation, while you're ignoring many other causes that are much more generic .
33:51
Speaker A
No, not at all. Are you—are you twisting what I said? I’m not twisting it, I mean, based on the study.
33:55
Speaker A
No, but wait a second, what I’m saying is this: in all measurable negative statistics, there tends to be a common pattern, especially in men, of male absence in the home. That is what I am saying. Now, does this mean, I
34:10
Speaker A
repeat and insist, that everyone who grew up without a father is going to be part of these statistics? Absolutely not. So, don't distort what Perfect, perfect. What is the point then? Yes, if it’s not an absolute and it’s a specific issue that can be
34:24
Speaker A
analyzed in many ways: does it matter or not that the father is missing regarding criminality in development?
34:31
Speaker A
Look, it matters when you analyze the prison population and you realize this extrapolates to almost all members, up to 80%. So, of course it matters, it matters, but not for the reason you say, or does it?
34:46
Speaker A
Why does it matter? Does it matter because male energy is missing during upbringing, or does it matter because when a father is missing, in many cases income is missing, and therefore it can affect the family? Which of the two
34:55
Speaker A
points? Hm, it affects everything, obviously everything. Wait, but what is, I mean, what would your analysis be if it's money? When the father is missing, money is missing. What is your analysis ? It's money, education, the environment. When one is missing
35:07
Speaker A
obviously, right? Or a certain predisposition. Damn, with the genetic topic, be careful. That's another debate. I am not That, that is another debate regarding the genetic topic.
35:16
Speaker A
If you want to debate with a geneticist , I have a very interesting podcast here, analyzing violence. I mean, the point, what I, uh, want to establish is that when we have been talking about the family and the absence of the father,
35:26
Speaker A
you have tried to talk about masculine energy, how that affects biological levels and then you've tried to say that the father's absence causes a series of behaviors seen in inmates.
35:35
Speaker A
And I've told you: it doesn't have to be that behavior, I mean, it doesn't have to be the lack of a paternal figure that causes it. That is the only thing I want to say, that no. I mean,
35:44
Speaker A
when we talk about why a family, a child, may or may not end up in a bad place, it might be more important than when the father is missing.
35:52
Speaker A
It may, it may be that, but what is clear is that in all these people, the same pattern repeats. Therefore, I believe a healthy society should promote the importance of the father, and not a sick society like the one we
36:07
Speaker A
live in, in which women are encouraged to eliminate him, not to marry, not to start a, not to start a family, saying: "If you don't find a good husband, don't worry, you'll just adopt a Thai girl and raise her as if she were your
36:19
Speaker A
daughter." That, that, that is the problem. I defend the family and by defending the family I defend the man within it, I defend the woman within it . Your discourse is like it doesn't matter if the father is there or not,
36:34
Speaker A
that it doesn't matter if the mother is there or not, uh maybe it's other factors that affect it. I say, "Okay, that is 100%true." Just like when I accuse this society of having a gigantic birth rate problem, I say that
36:44
Speaker A
feminism for me is one of the causes. However, it is multifactorial. Obviously, I am not denying what you are saying. Now, I do want to emphasize that I find it extremely relevant, even if you don't, that all these statistics I just gave you
36:59
Speaker A
share the common pattern of the absence of a father. I think this debate has run its course. You give it importance.
37:06
Speaker A
I, I, mean, because, for that, I mean, you...Yes, you give more importance to the family structure than to a mother or a father, whereas I prioritize that whoever is raising the child has good economic conditions, has good social
37:15
Speaker A
development, a well-paid job, and can take their child to a place where they are well-educated, because, even if it's just a mother, if she has all those resources, the child will likely turn out just fine. But a child and a
37:25
Speaker A
mother, both in precarious conditions, working 12 hours a day in a society that treats them like machines and doesn't allow them the leisure time to raise their child—very likely that child, even with a mother and a father, as has happened historically, will end
37:35
Speaker A
up in a terrible situation. So, all I’m saying is that, and also along these lines, it's not because of feminism in Iran—there is no feminism there—the birth rate is at 1.40, which is almost the same as Eastern European countries that literally
37:54
Speaker A
Yes, Iran's birth rate dropped significantly, and it was precisely because of the reforms in the 90s that granted sexual freedom, not feminism, meaning, where one could choose not to start a family. In other words, feminism is an isolated factor, just
38:05
Speaker A
like homosexuality is an isolated factor. If people aren't having children, as the INE—sorry, the National Statistics Institute—says in their population study, 70%of women aren't having children because: 40%due to a lack of economic stability; 20%due to not being able to find a stable
38:23
Speaker A
partner; and another 10%of that 70%is due to the volatility of job availability. That is to say, people aren't having children because of feminists or anything like that; they aren't having them because they lack the means to support a child.
38:34
Speaker A
Serious question. Mm. I don't deny that the answers to what you said are those. Don't you think an entire society can be conditioned by a narrative to completely shift its priorities? What makes the economy such an extremely important factor when
38:53
Speaker A
deciding whether or not to have a child now? Mm. And if you think that the economic situation in Spain now is better than that of post-war Spain.
39:04
Speaker A
Of post-war Spain. Yes. No, it is not. I mean, now it is better than that Spain.
39:08
Speaker A
And the women of that time decided to keep having children. When I accuse feminism of being an important factor it is because you don't force women to have children.
39:18
Speaker A
Because "force" is a word I haven't used. Man, I didn't use that regarding the post-war period. I guarantee you that women were not forced to have children, huh?
39:25
Speaker A
In the post-war period. Wait, but one second, just let me finish, please. What I am saying, Anug, is that feminism has made women's priorities change completely. And that's why the answers, look how curious, I'm going to cite the poll in the United States,
39:41
Speaker A
right? I don't know if you've seen it, the priorities of conservative people versus the priorities of progressive people in the US elections. Donald Trump's voters put having a family and having children in their top three priorities. Kamala Harris's voters put
39:56
Speaker A
it in 12th place, if they put it at all . What does this mean? That Kamala Harris, for those who don't know, was very feminist and I think all the people who voted for Kamala Harris had that progressive, feminist, egalitarian
40:11
Speaker A
mentality, uh, gender identity, roles, all that garbage in my point of view. And that is where I attack and say: " Let's see, if all these voters for the progressive, Kamala Harris, don't have having children as a priority, it's
40:27
Speaker A
because perhaps within that ideology, starting a family isn't encouraged, isn't rewarded, it's not the priority," something that I do consider, and we conservatives consider, a priority.
40:38
Speaker A
That's why the decisions you make today can affect the future, and that is the mindset that I operate in. So, those answers that women give today, we can agree that Spain is a very feminist country, right?
40:52
Speaker A
Okay. Yes. Are they not conditioned by this movement? I think that what is conditioned when it comes to having a child, mainly in Spain, according to polls, is the economic condition that feminism makes.
41:04
Speaker A
You're not answering my question, you're doing mental gymnastics. No, I'm telling you, I'm telling you, you're talking to me about Spain, the postwar period. In Spain, the postwar period. I don't know if you know how it worked, for example, the issue of using
41:14
Speaker A
condoms, which was not allowed. I don't know if you know how the issue of marriage worked, that women couldn't vote and there was a situation where the man could own the family because without the man, the woman had no legal
41:24
Speaker A
capacity to do many other things. That is, you say, "There is no explicit obligation.""Of course not, but a woman without a husband was a repudiated woman, who was socially cast out, who couldn't have an account, who couldn't have anything of her own, who depended
41:37
Speaker A
on her father. So, you are telling me, of course, at that time people had many children. Of course, if you take a woman and treat her like a cow, having a child every year, well, she has 12. I
41:45
Speaker A
mean, my family is that family. I mean, literally, I have 11 uncles and aunts, and it was because they were from the countryside, because condoms couldn't be brought in, because nothing could be done at all. So, when we talk about the
41:56
Speaker A
family, what I don't want is that. I mean, we can talk about the family being...I have...
41:59
Speaker A
You don't want the product, I don't want the woman to be a cow. Okay.
42:04
Speaker A
I don't want the woman to be a cow either. That's it, I think it's logical , right? I mean, I want women to freely understand that family and being a mother is a better option than working 24/7 for a boss who
42:17
Speaker A
doesn't give a damn about you. Okay, but that, I do believe that, eh, but that already happens with the, I mean, no, no, no. The feminist woman in Spain does not see the family as a priority.
42:28
Speaker A
That is a fact. And in fact, I tell you , I tell you, Anug, everything you say is very good. You are very good dialectically. I'm going to give you your props, you're good at this. The point is, and in fact, I like finally
42:39
Speaker A
having a worthy rival. You are...when I planned this debate, I wanted there to be good people.
42:44
Speaker A
No, no, no. He's good, he's good, I'll acknowledge that in the debate. He's good. The point I want to make to you is the following.
42:50
Speaker A
You haven't answered me regarding whether you don't think it affects... that feminism has caused women's priorities to be completely inverted.
42:59
Speaker A
So, it is legitimate to say that part of the problem is that women have changed their priorities because of feminism. So, if you acknowledge that feminism has affected the priority given to family and motherhood, you are validating my statement by
43:16
Speaker A
saying that feminism is one of the main causes for which you say main, one of the main ones, right? Main, one of the main ones. Sure, but I am telling you, I believe so, because feminism has changed the vision and
43:26
Speaker A
life preferences of women. Because they no longer have to dedicate themselves solely to reproductive tasks, but can have a career, have goals, and that makes you rethink certain things when it comes to starting a family.
43:37
Speaker A
Obviously, it is the main cause. I think the main cause is having created a society where families do not have enough leisure time, where they have to be working constantly.
43:47
Speaker A
Do you think that's the problem? Well, to be able to have a child you need time, especially if you want to have a well-raised child, which is the difference. Before you had children, you had 20 children because you needed
43:55
Speaker A
them to raise, uh, the farm and cultivate such and such. Now you want to have good children because you know that this child is going to be in the city working in an office, probably.
44:03
Speaker A
So, how can you call an ideology progressive when it destroys the foundation and base of any society, which is the family? Because it is clear and we both agree that Spain is going to disappear.
44:13
Speaker A
No, no, no. Spain. Do you know that a society needs a 2.11 %birth rate to survive? Do you know what the Spanish birth rate is? Korea.
44:23
Speaker A
Yes. Uh, it is also going to have a war , Japan is feminist. It's going to have one, right? But I agree with an analysis you made earlier, which is that obviously when progress arrives, uh, industrialization in offices, air
44:36
Speaker A
conditioning, and women enter the labor market, uh, obviously preferences change and this happens. But, how can that be called progress when society is going to age and we are truly going to have an inversion of the demographic pyramid? What I, okay, we
44:51
Speaker A
agree, but I do not agree that it is feminism. But look, Anug, you have to let me finish making my points. What I am saying, okay? How can you call it progress in a society that would need a
45:04
Speaker A
fertility rate and number of children per woman of 2.11, when today we are at 1.11? And on top of that, I’m going to link this to the topic of immigration, which I find extremely important. We bring in people from
45:16
Speaker A
abroad who have seven children per woman. Well, it’s not 7. That’s about where it’s headed, right? It's four, isn't it? Exactly.
45:22
Speaker A
Three point five, something like that. Okay. I mean, they triple it. Yes, yes. I mean, but you are a rational person, you like numbers. I am quite bad at mental math.
45:35
Speaker A
It means that demographically, yes? How long until they outnumber us? Uh, 2060 more or less.
45:43
Speaker A
Okay. And do you think those people coming from abroad are feminist? No. And do you think Spain will continue to exist as you know it if we continue on this path?
45:57
Speaker A
The main issue with that question is that you are looking at it through the lens of the West, but it’s also happening in Africa. In Africa, in Nigeria, they have gone from seven children to four, and by 2040 they will
46:07
Speaker A
have less than two. In fact, Iran, Tunisia, Turkey, the UAE, and Dubai, all have fewer than two children. It's curious that in the Emirates and Dubai, it's curious that in the Emirates and Dubai, where precisely what has happened is
46:21
Speaker A
great economic development, people no longer have as many children, and it's because of feminism, right? Because in Dubai, there isn't any. In Japan, there is feminism, it's prohibited, you cannot practice feminism. The government banned it, well, it banned,
46:31
Speaker A
uh, breaks up the protests. So, socially Japan, right? Uh, the Japanese are based and yet they still have, uh, and it's much worse than us. I mean, no , Japan is totally screwed.
46:40
Speaker A
So, feminism could be a key. I believe the key is that since the 70s in the West and throughout the world, we have lived through a process of wealth concentration that hasn't allowed the majority of people to reduce their
46:52
Speaker A
working hours, have time to start a family, or afford a good home. In most of the West, we have an economic problem. Feminism is a factor. Feminism is a factor in Japan doesn't have it, right?
47:01
Speaker A
The what? The economic problem. Yes, they definitely do. They've been stagnant for 20 years.
47:05
Speaker A
They’ve been extremely stagnant for 20 years. Okay. Yes. On a macroeconomic level. Yes. I'm going to give you credit on this one, eh? I mean, I'm not going to debate you here. I consider the socio-capitalist factor we live in to
47:15
Speaker A
be extremely important, and it's true that people don't have work and so on, but I also consider that society—and I think you've agreed with me on this too—has completely changed its priorities.
47:28
Speaker A
Because it no longer has the capacity to economically articulate new ones, right? Exactly. And we agree on that.
47:34
Speaker A
Sure, but not because of feminism, feminism is a very key factor, and specifically in Spain, let me tell you one thing: we cannot extrapolate the birth rate decline to all countries and the same cause.
47:45
Speaker A
Okay, that seems fine to me. So, let's be specific. I'm talking about Spain, okay? So, it's not just me talking about Spain, and we were talking— that's why I told you, don't play mental gymnastics with me and don't
47:55
Speaker A
deviate from the topic of immigration, which was another block we had. In fact , the subject of immigration, how a progressive person—because, of course , a conservative old fogey wants to preserve what Spain has been and the traditions it’s had all its life.
48:08
Speaker A
And mind you, I tell you that I have more Black and Moorish friends, and they couldn't care less if I call them Black or Moors. That stuff about" racialized people "is for idiots. Call a Black person" racialized, "call Bene
48:21
Speaker A
from the Black Panthers or my friends from the Black Panthers" racialized, " and they'll laugh in your damn face.
48:25
Speaker A
They’ll say," Racialized my ass. " They might even slap you; that's what actually offends them, right? Black, I wanted to make that small clarification .
48:32
Speaker A
I do say racialized, but well, you're a premium progressive, huh ? I—I am not in favor of the current migratory model, I mean, I believe that migration must be regulated.
48:41
Speaker A
Well, damn, that's great then. But, what is in store for Spain if we continue on this path? So, this is where all the ideologies that progressives defend and the migration model they also defend come into conflict. It's like there's going to be
48:57
Speaker A
a clash of both visions that makes no sense, because at least my vision, accurate or not, is quite coherent. I mean, I consider myself quite consistent in what I believe, in what I think, and I try to live in accordance
49:09
Speaker A
with what I believe and think. I don't criticize OF girls and then consume it.
49:13
Speaker A
I don't do that. I demand, hey, you can't criticize OnlyFans girls and then go and masturbate paying them because you're a a lot of people on Twitter do it too many, and that seems to me. So, consistency in people matters a lot to
49:24
Speaker A
me, regardless of whether I might agree with you, right? I want to find consistency within your narrative. What is your opinion on this demographic substitution we are experiencing? And these are numbers, people can't fight against this, and many people from your
49:39
Speaker A
ideological framework deny it. And here enters a debate that, well, uh, is very heated on social media, right? Which is , uh, well, also by various groups that have mentioned it, right? Which is the topic of the great replacement, of
49:51
Speaker A
conspiracies, of all those issues. Do you believe in the great replacement ? I mean, that there is one, that the elites who Obviously, man, how can I not believe in something that I'm seeing? I mean, it's like if you tell me, do you
50:03
Speaker A
believe this microphone is a microphone ? Uh, it's not agreed upon, obviously, look, but if it's that, I mean, you think there's a European elite that says, no, I'm not going to explain to you how the world works based on the theory of some
50:15
Speaker A
old paranoid conspiracy theorist. If no, outside of that, I mean, I want to know how it weighs. Well, I have to explain it to you, okay?
50:21
Speaker A
In Europe, national sovereignty does not exist. No country has sovereignty. We are all controlled by debt and those to whom we owe it. That's why we see European governments acting against the interests of their own population.
50:34
Speaker A
Pedro Sánchez, Starmer, Macron, uh Merkel," Welcome Refugees, "etc., etc., etc. This is obviously orchestrated because there is a ton of money behind it and also a ton of lobbies that are the ones who truly run the world. I
50:46
Speaker A
believe the world is a corporatist dictatorship where governments are simply there to make people believe that they have the capacity to decide.
50:53
Speaker A
You are free, you can vote, you, uh, uh , uh, this happens because you want it to. If I tell you, even PSOE voters are not in favor of the migration model.
51:03
Speaker A
No one is. Even so, it gets done. Even so, we have the army, and I am going to interview an army commander who is putting his job on the line this Friday , that they go and pick up the flotillas,
51:16
Speaker A
that it’s all pre-arranged, that there are NGOs, that there is a multi-million dollar system that only benefits those who work in this. This is human trafficking and, evidently, there is a lot of money behind it. How can I not believe it when the
51:29
Speaker A
government is consenting to it—not just one, but all European governments —when there are funds like George Soros's Open Society? How can I not believe there is a plan?
51:40
Speaker A
Open Society already has very little capital, like... Uh, well, let me tell you one thing, and actually I'm going to say one thing , but anyway, But let me finish so you can get an idea of what I think the world is like.
51:50
Speaker A
I believe that, today, there is a specific group: Zionism. I believe it 100%and I'm risking a lot by saying this, by doing this; it is quite dangerous and this truly scares me, but well, whatever God wants. If something
52:01
Speaker A
happens to me at any point, well, I’m not suicidal, I just want to say that.
52:05
Speaker A
But I consider that Zionism, okay?, funds the pro-Palestinians in here; it has society completely divided and they don't realize that they are the ones bringing in and also financing migration inside Europe.
52:19
Speaker A
What for? The great... But, what do you want a replacement for ? Ask them, but the truth is, Man, you must have—you must have a theory at least. No, I have several, but honestly, man, that’s where I get lost. I—you know
52:33
Speaker A
how much I've rambled and thought, why are they doing this? Why? What is the motive? The truth is I have never seen a video of people from these circles proving me right. What I have seen is them saying what they were going to do.
52:46
Speaker A
I’ve seen it a lot. I can quote Barbara Lerner Spectre here saying that in 1980 Europe, Europe is too white.
52:54
Speaker A
Europe is too Christian and we have to —I won't say we—we have to be at the focus of this new multicultural change and we are going to promote it and we are going to be at the center of
53:04
Speaker A
all this change. I mean, I want to ask you a question because of one issue, I mean, why is it a great replacement that I understand is from Africa? It doesn't matter. The replacement is that they want to
53:16
Speaker A
eliminate what Europe has been. Europe is going to end up like a museum. What I don't understand is why we pay Tunisia, Egypt, Algeria, Mauritania, Turkey, and Greece to stop the migrants . And to...
53:27
Speaker A
I want to ask you a question. I mean, no, I mean, answer me, no, answer me. I mean, if there is a Great Replacement theory, why does Europe pay countries so that immigrants don't come ? But if it is that at the end of the
53:38
Speaker A
day, look, it's that you have that the TZ government let me answer you, let me answer you.
53:46
Speaker A
That whole thing about whether they pay or don't pay or stop paying or don't stop paying, it all seems like a [ __ ] circus to me, because no matter how much they pay, then you have military personnel writing to me saying
53:54
Speaker A
that they are the ones picking up the flotillas and bringing them to Spanish shores. No, we pay, but at the same time we pick them up, right? It's true.
54:01
Speaker A
Uh, we receive money for each migrant through European associations, but then we pay over there. That is to say, it's theater, it's a circus and it's meant to fool people. Why has Italian migration decreased? Italian migration has dropped 60%since we started paying
54:14
Speaker A
Tunisia, Algeria, and Mauritania. Since Meloni started paying, no, no, since Europe started paying, because Meloni doesn't pay. I mean, literally the current Tunisian government stayed in the previous elections thanks to the discourse on sustaining the migration coming from
54:26
Speaker A
the Sahel, because that is what allows the current government to remain in power. I ask because it doesn't make much sense, I mean, if migration has been reduced in most of Europe. Merch is it has been reduced since let's see
54:37
Speaker A
since two years ago that was applied in Italy. Screw you, from two years ago.
54:41
Speaker A
You have to look at the macro of the last 10 years. Obviously, but if there is a plan, it makes no sense to decrease it. That is what I am telling you.
54:46
Speaker A
It is a it is a good question, honestly . I'm not going to deny that it's a good question, but I, obviously, cannot stop thinking that if we have reached this point, for example...man, very well, now they are trying, maybe...I'll
54:57
Speaker A
tell you one thing: when it comes to these things, I do not speak in absolutes, eh? I'm not at UN tables, I'm not at European Union tables; I can tell you what I believe and what I think and what my essence and my being
55:09
Speaker A
tell me. Maybe they are realizing that Europeans, the way they are pushing it so aggressively with that, let's say, cruising speed in what they intend to do, they are waking up. Now there is a rise of the far right. Really,
55:22
Speaker A
yes, really, eh? No, no, I Yeah, yeah. I'm a Hispanist. I mean, the whole race thing, I don't care about it. And maybe they said," Hey, listen, let's slow this down a bit because it might get out of hand. "
55:35
Speaker A
I can explain to you why I think so. That's what I was going to ask you.
55:38
Speaker A
I’ve given you the reasons I think are behind it and why they want to do it, and well, I don’t admit the" why "because the" why "is very complex and ...
55:47
Speaker A
Okay. The thing is, man, I can't speak with all the freedom I’d like, honestly. I wish.
55:52
Speaker A
Not because of us, not because of... No man, no, no. He already played it badly enough by mentioning Zionism.
55:58
Speaker A
I mean, my explanation isn't about replacement; it’s a much simpler matter, it seems to me. Since the 70s, with the rise of globalization—moving companies to Vietnam and China—and certain sectors that you can't move, like agriculture, local manufacturing, sectors where over time workers demand
56:17
Speaker A
higher wages, a simple thing happens: the labor supply and demand market is simple; people offer labor and companies demand it. What happens when, for example, in Southern Europe, with the economic growth of the 80s, countries start growing a lot
56:31
Speaker A
economically? They need labor, but where do they need the labor? Do they need engineer labor?
56:37
Speaker A
No, they need cheap labor. So, what happens with that? Well, an economic model is created where business owners, along with states, realize that what they need is cheap labor. And where is the cheap, low-skilled labor? In North Africa and
56:50
Speaker A
Latin America. What is the program that is put in place? A program that promotes, as if they were merchandise, that human beings come to sustain a model in which local people live at a pace of life that migrant people do not
57:03
Speaker A
. That is the false European multicultural model, based on benefiting corporations and companies that lack labor, but it's not a replacement because there is a plan; it's a much more organic replacement, the same replacement you could see when
57:18
Speaker A
...uh, it's a simple thing: I need people to work in the fields. But you, who have been raised by a society that gives you hope, because it has schools where they say," You're going to work picking tomatoes, right? "They tell you
57:30
Speaker A
, you are going to be an engineer, you're going to be this or that. But when that person arrives, they have their job, and society starts to normalize the idea that immigrants are a kind of slave who have to provide
57:40
Speaker A
maintenance, who have to wipe asses, who have to pick tomatoes. It’s an economic, capitalist, modern model that sustains itself because there is a series of migrants used as slave labor to support sectors that are either deficit-ridden, uncompetitive, or where
57:54
Speaker A
business owners simply don't want to pay higher wages—the same thing done in the US when they used the African American population by bringing them to places where the locals wanted to earn more, because I say:" Hey, boss, I want
58:06
Speaker A
to earn more. "And he says," Okay, well , I'm going to bring in immigrants so they get paid less than you. "That is the model. It’s not a replacement because there’s a plan; it’s an economic issue. I'm going to tell you
58:16
Speaker A
one thing: I am 100%in agreement with everything you said, I won't add a single" but. "Now, the topic of replacement— it is true that since I believe the world is a corporatist dictatorship, that's the theory, but this has been
58:32
Speaker A
done deliberately so that we Europeans become fewer and fewer. So, but what is the point of that?
58:38
Speaker A
What is the point? Yes. Why? Why? That is the million-dollar question, man. That really is the million-dollar question. Why the hell have they been trying for so long to stop us from reproducing, trying to attack motherhood, trying to attack fatherhood
58:51
Speaker A
? What I can tell you is that, as of today, in Spain, there is no work, and there hasn't been , and we have a structural unemployment rate of 21%, if I remember correctly.
59:02
Speaker A
Uh, 14%structural, and youth unemployment reaches what, 21%or up to 20-something. Yes. Okay, so the point is, we have kept attracting a ton of people when there is no work in Spain. In Europe, in Europe, business owners, I acknowledge they have great—but watch
59:18
Speaker A
out, not small businesses, eh? The big business owners who are part of the damn problem and who I believe are part of it, they are the ones who truly rule the world. I don't think governments rule the world, far from it. So, I
59:31
Speaker A
wouldn't have an answer to tell you why the Great Replacement. I don't know. You'd have to ask Ignatieff, you'd have to ask Barbara Lerner Spectre, you'd have to ask George Soros, and you'd have to ask all those who, with their
59:42
Speaker A
money, their speeches, and their books, have promoted this. I that there may be individual people, I tell you that there are, but no, no, no, I'm talking about lobbies with thousands and thousands and thousands of millions of euros. But I'm
59:54
Speaker A
saying one thing: the biggest lobby in Europe, which is the agricultural lobby , which takes 40%of the entire European Union budget, the agricultural lobby is the one that has pushed the most for cheap labor to come, because no
60:03
Speaker A
European deigns to fight for the rights of people in the countryside, nor to work by getting their hands dirty.
60:09
Speaker A
So, but that isn't a question of lobbies that want there to be fewer white people, it's an economic issue.
60:14
Speaker A
We have a growth situation since the 80s that stagnates with 2008 and that increases the migratory model because you can't raise wages and keep companies competitive in a world where we receive products made with cheap labor from Southeast Asia by Western
60:27
Speaker A
companies themselves that maintain that model. And that's why I want to make myself, don't you believe in the free market?
60:33
Speaker A
Well, I believe the free market exists, it existed. Listen, we agree more on this than you might imagine. The point is that I do give it a little more, look, honestly, I, I mean, with this, but just so we
60:44
Speaker A
understand this from 200 years ago, this is anti-immigration propaganda from New York. We'll put this up later. Pass me the Yes. This is anti-Italian saying that it's analysis.
60:52
Speaker A
These are anti-Chinese. Yes, these are anti-Chinese. So, there is anti-Chinese, anti-Irish, and anti-Italian propaganda.
61:00
Speaker A
Well, with the Black Legend and with the Spanish as well. 200 years ago, when the United States was still growing and was, uh, making, uh, conquering the Far West, labor was needed.
61:11
Speaker A
What happened with the original colonizers? That the original colonizers didn't need to, I mean, their standard of living had already increased a lot. What happened in Europe, where there were crises, so Italians started to go, Irish started to go, Chinese started to go during the
61:25
Speaker A
time of the crisis in China, which lasted from 1880 to 1950, until Mao arrived and there was that pretty screwed-up change. What happened to those people? poor people, with no resources, arrived. And what happened?
61:35
Speaker A
Because often when talking about criminality, for example, the topic of culture, right? Culture does not cause criminality. What causes criminality is being a dog that goes to work in the fields, working in a shitty sector, poverty, that's what ends up causing it
61:45
Speaker A
. And we see the same, the same rhetoric in this, in this specific sheet here, the one about China, it says," They can live on 50 cents. "We don't know why it's cut off." And it says, "But they can't." Does that
61:55
Speaker A
rhetoric sound familiar to you? Because it's a speech from 1880. We have the same discourse about the crap coming from Europe. 3%United States, all the Europeans coming in through a funnel.
62:06
Speaker A
Let's see, this is Uncle Sam, right? Uncle Sam bringing in Europeans to work in the United States during times of crisis.
62:14
Speaker A
It hasn't changed at all. Of course, it hasn't changed. And who were all these people? Workers, cheap labor who ended up founding what? The Irish mafia, the Italian mafia, and the Chinese mafia, which is what we are living today. This discourse is 200
62:26
Speaker A
years old, and back then they were already talking about how it could imply things, because Italians and Spaniards, as is often discussed, were not considered white in the United States, right? No, no, in the United States, of course. And they already say things
62:37
Speaker A
about it's a paranoia that I find, it's hilarious to me. But that's the reason for the white discourse, for saying that, right?
62:41
Speaker A
Because they want to replace white people. Yeah, but who are the white people? We are the white people. I want one thing. I want a small parenthesis. Small parenthesis. I don't believe in the racial substitution discourse, eh, I don't
62:52
Speaker A
lean so much towards racial substitution, I lean more towards religious substitution. I do believe that the attack is towards Christ, I mean, they want to end Christianity, I believe that 100%. That, I mean, 75%of Spanish migration is Latino and they
63:06
Speaker A
are Christians. The plan wouldn't make much sense. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. In Europe no, but in I mean, but, but listen to me, when I talk about this I talk in macro terms, okay? But let's do like feminism, of
63:16
Speaker A
and here more and more people from Morocco are arriving, right? No, 320,000 last year, 75%of you've been to Barcelona, okay?
63:24
Speaker A
I mean, you've been to Catalonia and you've seen the Madrid metro. We're in Madrid, we're in Madrid, and the population, I mean, in a specific place there, Moroccans. Yes, yes, I've seen, I've been through it. It's, it's, it's crazy
63:35
Speaker A
if you go through El Raval, it's crazy if you go to the south of Madrid. What I'm saying is that, evidently, right now Morocco, which is our geopolitical enemy—that's how I see it, and I think you might see it that way too,
63:45
Speaker A
financed by the globalists, right? Yes, a rather delicate subject that many have in common, huh?
63:50
Speaker A
Yes, yes, they know it. If I, if I, with all your sociological analysis, I am 100%in agreement. I'm not denying anything you're saying. I'm listening to you carefully here, and in fact, I'm learning things, but I do believe there
64:00
Speaker A
is a slightly more spiritual and metaphysical issue behind all of this. That is the point.
64:05
Speaker A
If it's okay with you, instead of getting so much into the whys, the whos , and so on, let's go to the what. And the question I want to ask you is: how would you regularize immigration?
64:17
Speaker A
Because from what you've said, both of you are in favor of the fact that perhaps there isn't too much immigration, but I want to lay the groundwork. You and I agree that there is an immigration problem and that it hurts the working class
64:28
Speaker A
most of all. Yes. And the migrants, and the migrants themselves, I also agree. Yes, they are also victims of this immigration model.
64:35
Speaker A
Yes. I, I...I mean, my fundamental point on this is: I don't think I like maintaining an immigration system that consists of a new form of slavery where poor people are brought in to support richer people, and I mean, I see
64:47
Speaker A
migrants like me, I don't, I mean, I don't think, no, I'm not racist, I don't think culturally, "Moroccans are culturally incompatible," or anything like that. I mean, I know many Moroccan people, I know many Latin people, there usually isn't any problem. What I do
64:59
Speaker A
believe is that I am not in favor of a migration model that uses people as if they were a resource, which seeks to facilitate increased corporate profits at the expense of what it can cause in neighborhoods that are, normally, poor
65:11
Speaker A
neighborhoods, because immigrants have an average...I mean, the average Spanish income is € 28,000; migrants 'is € 14,000. 50%of people experiencing homelessness are migrants.
65:22
Speaker A
The unaccompanied minors, who are often talked about, work three times as much at 16 and 17 as the locals do. But that is not a good statistic. That means there are kids, youngsters, who should be studying, who are working because
65:32
Speaker A
they cannot support themselves, despite all the talk about handouts. So, now, I mean, my point is, I am not in favor of the model because I don't want people to be treated like commodities to maintain a system.
65:41
Speaker A
And what solution do you propose? My proposal is the trade union work visa entry model, which is: a person is going to enter a country, they send a visa, they say: "Hey, I want to work here in Australia," more or less, that
65:53
Speaker A
you go with a work permit, with a fixed contract, or that you already go with conditions that will allow you to integrate immediately into society. I mean, integration is purely economic.
66:02
Speaker A
So, I am talking, for example, about the model that Denmark also wants to implement. I am a worker.
66:06
Speaker A
Uh, wait, what you just said has quite a few nuances in the United Kingdom. In the United Kingdom, many Pakistani people and people who are from or from Asia or Africa haven't done poorly economically, and the integration and the integration
66:21
Speaker A
hasn't happened. Uh, there is a racial problem there that is mind-boggling, right? Well, but that is a different issue. That is a different issue. What issue, man? The organization. First, the housing program from the 90s that created literal ghettos, as happens in
66:33
Speaker A
France and as happens in Sweden. Well, this is an easy thing to understand. The ghettos. How is a ghetto formed?
66:38
Speaker A
There is a neighborhood where the average income is very low. What happens with migrants? They are poor.
66:42
Speaker A
Where do the poor go to live? In poor neighborhoods. As the local population increases their status, they leave those neighborhoods, and the migrants arrive. What happens to migrants who are labor for sectors that are very volatile? For example, industrial
66:52
Speaker A
sectors that suddenly disappear in 10 years. What happens to those people? They have no work. What happens to those neighborhoods full of unemployed people that become ghettos? What happens? What is criminality, delinquency, rapes, etc.?
67:03
Speaker A
But both, both levels, meaning when people live poorly, they have two options: try as hard as possible to get ahead and out of the mud, or commit crimes. And both occur among migrants.
67:12
Speaker A
I mean, migrants are often overrepresented in certain structures, for example, living on the street, which I often hear, no, I don't know if it's your thesis, but that, no, migrants get handouts and that's why they can live and others can't. And I
67:24
Speaker A
say, so then, why are half the people living on the street, 50%, even though they are 20%of the population, migrants ? It's that migrant people suffer both ends of the Gaussian bell curve: those who commit more crimes in proportion,
67:35
Speaker A
which is still 2%total, and those who try the hardest to get ahead. But and it gives more people. There is a very serious problem here in Europe, we agree.
67:45
Speaker A
There is polarization. I don't think the UK has any kind of solution anymore unless it's through arms, because Islam has already gained political power. But you have to let me finish, because I listened to you quiet as a tomb.
67:59
Speaker A
I am going to ask you questions now because I find it extremely interesting to know what your opinion is. You don't think there's a problem in the UK, you don't think there's a problem in France , you don't think there's a problem in
68:10
Speaker A
Sweden. Yes. What solution do you propose? Look, the first problem is what I just said.
68:15
Speaker A
No, no, no, I'm not talking about those arriving, I'm talking about those who are already there.
68:19
Speaker A
Well, the first thing would be to do a, well, in those countries where the issue is so bad, you would probably have to redistribute the population like Singapore, which is setting an ethnic limit per neighborhood, moving populations from poor places to places
68:31
Speaker A
where there are more resources and they can be compensated economically, or they can be encouraged to work so that income distribution doesn't get trapped in ghettos. I mean, we would have to de-ghettoize. France, above all, needs that. But the thing is France, the
68:44
Speaker A
model The UK is worse, eh, France has a much bigger problem. I mean, I don't think it's the UK, London is the problem. The UK, no, no, my friend, no. Birmingham.
68:52
Speaker A
Yes, but it's the hubs of the biggest cities that were mainly industrial centers, where there have been migrant populations from the colonies who have been working and who, over time, have either started businesses or are a workforce that has remained in poverty
69:03
Speaker A
and has adopted a criminal logic, which is the same logic—let's go back to that—the same logic as the Italian mafia. Does the cultural and religious issue not affect at all the integration of certain people into a territory that
69:15
Speaker A
has traditionally been Christian? Europe is Christian, we agree on that. Well, most of Europe is atheist, but yes, I mean, yes, but let's talk about Christian, listen to me. Do you consider something to be good or bad, even without knowing
69:29
Speaker A
it, based on Christian values? That is reality. Morality, everything that has been built here. I understand, I understand the discourse. Yes, but no, no, not the discourse, the reality.
69:38
Speaker A
So, don't you think there is a conflict between people who come from different cultures, from a different moral and religious structure when arriving here?
69:53
Speaker A
I mean, you focus everything from sociology, that seems perfect to me. There is something else.
69:58
Speaker A
Yes, yes, yes. I mean, there is a factor, there is one more factor. There are certain factors you cannot control.
70:03
Speaker A
And in the UK, I know because I have lived there, there are many people who have done well, who have prospered and even then have not integrated and do not interact with native people. I have, well, many people and I believe that immigration,
70:15
Speaker A
as long as there is integration into the host country, is a positive formula , it doesn't have to be anything bad.
70:21
Speaker A
The problem is that we now have an issue in which white people are suffering racism in the UK, white people are being beaten, native people—I don't like using the word white—lifelong English people are being beaten, kids are recording
70:36
Speaker A
themselves, imagine the feeling of impunity they have. Kids are recording themselves. Africans, who even if they are from London, for me they are from Africa, of African origin.
70:46
Speaker A
Phew! You can be amazed by everything that's out there, right? They break into elderly women's homes, beat them, rob them, record it, and upload it to social media without any issues at all. There are even videos of how, during the protests over
70:58
Speaker A
the Tommy Robinson issue—which, mind you, is another point to defend the argument that this is all orchestrated, because the UK courts didn't want the issue of the Pakistani grooming gangs leaked, who were exclusively, who were exclusively dedicated to raping white
71:12
Speaker A
and English girls. They didn't rape Pakistani girls, they only went and targeted white girls. Obviously, the media doesn't cover this, when if it had been —we all know, I think you agree too because I see you as very coherent—
71:30
Speaker A
that if it had been a gang of white men raping Pakistani girls, it would have blown up all over the networks.
71:36
Speaker A
Therefore, there is a moral problem there. Of course there is. Okay, so then there is a moral problem in the media. Then you also understand that the media plays an extremely important role in all of this. And when
71:49
Speaker A
you put all the factors together, you say, "The judges lock up a guy who leaks trials against gangs of Pakistanis raping white girls." The media silences it. Governments also do their part in the scheme. There are big corporate lobbies, all that you've said
72:07
Speaker A
, I buy into it 100%. "I don't think it's in opposition to my speech. I don't think so, I think both things are compatible and that's where you mention the great replacement. How is it possible that when all these factors come together,
72:20
Speaker A
the whole system in general seems to want to omit the problems caused by all this immigration?
72:25
Speaker A
It’s just that I think it is, I mean, it seems to me that it’s quite a bit simpler than a plan like that. I mean, because but wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, listen to me. It’s not that, there
72:34
Speaker A
are too many agents, there are too many agents playing in favor of promoting this.
72:38
Speaker A
Sure, but I want to explain, I mean, I want to try, I mean, when I have analyzed these types of things, I see a series of patterns that, furthermore, in the latest intelligence report from Europe that was published on the
72:47
Speaker A
subject of immigration, it was already made clear because Merch led it, which talked about this. The problem with these kinds of issues is that Europe has had a policy of great control and caution regarding racial wars, because it is true that there have been
72:59
Speaker A
Pakistani ghettos; especially in the UK , which has been the most serious, and in Sweden too, where there has been a bombing every day since January. I mean , in certain countries, migration as an economic product has gotten out of hand
73:12
Speaker A
because, since there is a crisis— Germany has been stagnant for 5 years, France too, Italy is in bad shape— Europe is in a delicate economic moment . What happens to migrants during delicate economic times? They have no resources and they become radicalized.
73:26
Speaker A
And they become radicalized as well. And this is a point I can address at a religious level, as it is true that there are external agents, such as the Emirates, building mosques and trying to impose certain discourses in some
73:36
Speaker A
places so that the population carries out or follows certain destabilization. But well, that is a factor that exists.
73:41
Speaker A
All those factors exist. They are greater, right? The biggest factor is that Europe has lost control of a migration model that sustained an industry that no longer exists because Europe is no longer functional, and now the media is afraid that racial
73:53
Speaker A
manhunts will end up leading to racial civil wars, as is happening. It will happen, it won't happen. But it will happen in the United Kingdom.
74:00
Speaker A
I find that very difficult. Why? Because modern states are very complex and, I mean, yes, the police are completely against the native population, that is true.
74:10
Speaker A
But no, I'm not talking about that. What I am saying is that usually what you don't want is for migrants to end up in wars and have internal conflicts.
74:17
Speaker A
Okay, then the media has done poorly because they have followed a line that has also been followed in other European countries regarding the fact that we must be careful with migrants because it is very easy for radicalization to
74:27
Speaker A
end up leading to severe social conflicts like racial civil wars. So, what I'm saying is much simpler than that in terms of the timeline. It is a question of we have an unsustainable situation that has reached a breaking point with the
74:41
Speaker A
crisis. Migrants are now the ones most likely to lead to those conflicts where there is impunity, because those children we talk about, for example, in Spain, have a huge school failure rate.
74:51
Speaker A
What were the three factors we mentioned earlier that make a person commit a crime? That their family structure is broken, failing school, and lack of access or opportunities. And what do older European migrants have? That, okay, but, but, but all very
75:06
Speaker A
well. The idea that we won't reach that conflict, I find it extremely complicated because truly the situation is starting to become unsustainable.
75:17
Speaker A
More things are happening all the time, they are happening more frequently, and the fed-up nature of the European is greater, which I think is justified, and the solution isn't calling everyone who sees a problem, evident to anyone who steps outside, a Nazi, far-right,
75:32
Speaker A
or racist. I don't have a problem talking about the migration issue, but saying it's the Black people, that I do see as a problem, because proportionally—I’m not saying you, not you, but, let’s see, I mean, in general, eh, I mean,
75:45
Speaker A
in the UK, man, in the UK you have to understand what’s there, and what’s there is that if you go out into the neighborhood and someone stabs you, or in London there are jokes that, come on, like Catalonia, yeah, the jokes about
75:58
Speaker A
... No, but London is a step above when it comes to stabbings, and truly, yes, it is the African population, it's just— you can't, no, okay, they have the passport, whatever, that’s a completely different topic. But to put
76:09
Speaker A
it bluntly, the solution you propose, what is the Singapore solution? Because I have the solut—no. I mean, you wouldn't deport anyone.
76:23
Speaker A
I mean, let’s see, let’s go back to the basics. For example, those who cause trouble, those who cause trouble can be deported . No, no, no, no, but I’m talking about...but we have a much bigger problem than people imagine, because
76:33
Speaker A
people think the one who just...I think everyone agrees that if you just arrived here and you rape a woman, we should deport you somewhere. We are all in agreement, right? We are all in agreement.
76:42
Speaker A
Yes, it’s cons— What do we do with the second generation? That you can't send them away from here, okay? What happens when there are too many? What happens when they might have interests different from those of the nation? What happens when you have to
76:55
Speaker A
act at the root? In the sense that, first, we obviously have to limit migration, but what we need to do is a Singapore-style program. First, we need to talk about true multiculturalism, not the multiculturalism of just bringing in migrants. Neighborhoods
77:09
Speaker A
need to be ethnically limited—when ethnic concentration—develop that," ethnically limited. " That there must be a percentage of different ethnicities, and there must be— And the state is responsible for ensuring there is a specific percentage . In Singapore, after the problem of—
77:21
Speaker A
that is, when Singapore began to develop as a country, there were a lot of minorities that were quite dangerous to each other. What was done was a limitation by neighborhoods because there was a problem with coexistence, but it wasn't done—I mean, they
77:32
Speaker A
didn't say," Come on, let's put everyone in their own neighborhood, " right? Because that's worse. What was done was because they set up their own mafias and things.
77:38
Speaker A
Sure, sure. What needs to be done is to divide and limit and say," Okay, look, in this neighborhood we have to get people to blend in so there isn't a strong local ethnic component, "because , for example, it has happened
77:47
Speaker A
historically with the Roma, which is happening less and less. The latest study showing the inclusion of the Roma population in Spain said it had grown a lot, approximately 60%, and you see more and more, for example, Roma outside of patriarchal environments and
77:59
Speaker A
in more social environments, and there are engineers, judges, that has already emerged. That has basically been a natural process in which the population , as happens with religion—in fact, I have another graph here that I find interesting regarding the subject of
78:12
Speaker A
Islam, which, precisely—shows how second-generation people are increasingly less Muslim, that's in France. Uh. It's a—the inclusion process is not just a matter of kicking out— Less Muslim, but more criminal than their parents. That's also an important topic.
78:31
Speaker A
Well, depending on the context. Yes. The second generation commits many more crimes, and that also has a simple explanation. The fir— In fact, Islam does not allow theft for those who believe in it.
78:40
Speaker A
Yes, yes. No, no culture allows theft. I mean— But that is not a culture, it is a religion. Well, it's a cultural religion.
78:46
Speaker A
Yes, but I mean— And political, you know? That is the problem. What I want to refer to is one thing.
78:50
Speaker A
That— When you have a program, a—because this is what has been missing. Since the 2008 crisis, there has been no planning in Europe. That lack of planning has led to a certain chaos in urban development and the housing
79:02
Speaker A
problem. But what has it consequently led to? That when you want to organize a population that has problems, you have to make decisions. When there are neighborhoods that are ghettos and you don't act, or you just raise prices to
79:13
Speaker A
push them elsewhere, that solves nothing. And historically, when we talk about this, for example in the United States, what happened with the ghettos that disappeared due to gentrification, but moved elsewhere? For example, the ghettos in Detroit, the ghettos in the
79:25
Speaker A
Bronx; there are still ghettos. Sure, sure. But they've moved to other places ; they're no longer in the Bronx, it's no longer an unsafe area.
79:31
Speaker A
So, they've moved further to the periphery. Right, they keep moving further and further to the periphery. That doesn't solve the problem. What solves the problem is first having a limitation, and this is very important at the state level: perceiving the migrant as a
79:43
Speaker A
person like any other, and therefore they shouldn't be overrepresented in places where there is poverty, because that's quite logical. You take a child born into a poor family in a ghetto, they go to school, but that school has
79:55
Speaker A
more resources. To a migrant, you take different migrants and you divide them up so there aren't concentrations, you put them in La Moraleja, you can't plan that, I mean, that's large-scale planning, okay? Large-scale planning where you put them in the poshest residential
80:08
Speaker A
area of San Sebastián de los Reyes, you distribute them, you give them a house. It's already happening in Mallorca. Yes, no, it depends, it depends on how you want to do it. There are a lot of migrants and
80:17
Speaker A
it depends, right? I think you should have contributed a minimum amount to receive state aid. It is, and I believe we should prioritize people who have spent their whole lives here contributing and maintaining this system, which I don't agree with at all
80:29
Speaker A
. Well, that already happens; people who have contributed more have more rights when it comes to receiving their own social aid is truly given depending on the level of need you have, right? Yes, and people who have just
80:43
Speaker A
arrived and are regularized or whatever , as a general rule, almost always meet the metrics to be given much more aid.
80:49
Speaker A
It's not that we only give them to Moors and Black people, no. It's that they meet the requirements, they are much poorer, and that’s why they get almost all of them. I mean, that's not almost all, no, 30%, but
81:02
Speaker A
well, yes, but they represent 14%of the population, just like in Spanish prisons 70%are Spanish, man. Evidently, if we are 86%of the population, it means that an immigrant is, uh, 4.5 times or 3.5 times more likely to be represented for the same reason. It's
81:21
Speaker A
evident. It's evident. Yes. I don't attribute everything to the issue of poverty. There are other factors. Truly in Africa. Violence continues to be a vehicle for resolving conflicts. You know this.
81:35
Speaker A
I mean, depending on which country you're talking about. Mauritania, which our dear Pedro Sánchez—no, I haven't asked for your opinion on him. I imagine you don't like him, do you? Because I see you as coherent, obviously. And if you tell me
81:47
Speaker A
you like him, if you were to say you like Pedro Sánchez, believe me, all the good work you've done on this podcast would have been lost on the entire audience. Almost certainly, right? I don't know, I uh or you don't agree
81:56
Speaker A
taking, taking into account the situation of the left, I don't Well, but Pedro isn't the debate.
82:02
Speaker A
No, no, no, it's not the debate. But, what are we talking about? That about the endemic violence in Africa.
82:06
Speaker A
Are you saying there are countries where Yes, but we have a government of—well , I don't even consider it left-wing or anything, that truly, truly is saying we need to bring in 200,000 Mauritanians. Man, in Mauritania, genital mutilation is a thing, 75%of
82:21
Speaker A
women suffer from genital mutilation. I mean, I am the biggest feminist, look who is telling you. When I say that women, how the hell are you going to, uh, mutilate them genitally so they don't feel pleasure due to religious or
82:32
Speaker A
cultural issues? It makes no sense. And what makes the least sense to me is promoting that 200,000 people come from a culture where this occurs. The percentage of rape or the number of rapes in Africa is eight or 10 times higher than in
82:47
Speaker A
Europe. Yes, yes. I mean, but uh, that is to say, if you fill Europe with Africans without filtering who they are or where they come from, and we take them in when they arrive in a dinghy, you don't
82:56
Speaker A
know who the hell is coming in, man. Yes, but we’re back to the same thing again. There is often an educational problem in their own countries regarding this figure because there hasn't been a feminist movement, there hasn't been any type of liberation for
83:09
Speaker A
women, and therefore that yoke still exists and is maintained structurally, which many people keep when they come here. But there is a difference here.
83:16
Speaker A
When it comes to applying the law, unlike many parts of the UK, it is applied here. So, in the UK you acknowledge that the law is applied. In the UK it’s a bit more complicated because the authorities prefer to maintain a certain ignorance
83:28
Speaker A
at times. That’s true, like, it’s proven, but it’s not the media here, no No, I wouldn’t say that about Spain in particular. I mean, because, for example, genital mutilation in Spain is something that is heavily prosecuted, and even if someone comes who wants to
83:41
Speaker A
do it, there is this logic:" I... "I mean, because the majority of migrants have this logic:" I'm going to adapt to the place I go. "It’s a minority that doesn’t want to adapt for a simple reason: if you go to a country...
83:51
Speaker A
Because people from Mauritania...There are probably many problems in Mauritania, well, not probably, there are, and many of the people coming to Spain see it as an opportunity to live better, and those people aren't going to risk committing a crime they know is
84:02
Speaker A
a crime just to get deported or thrown in jail. So, whenever we talk about this component, it seems to me that while it may occur in certain cases, it’s a minority. In fact, if you break down the crimes, actually, I have
84:12
Speaker A
them here, I mean, you can take the number of—there are 1.5 million people from Africa in Spain, okay? And there were approximately 45,541, approximately, no, 45,000 crimes last year. It’s 2.99%of the entire population, three out of every 100. But
84:28
Speaker A
if we talk about crimes like homicide, there were 51. So, when 51 homicides in Spain last year committed by Africans.
84:35
Speaker A
Oh, yeah. There weren’t more, eh? Which is 0.033%. Because I was going to say," Damn, no, no, there weren’t more. " So, the point is that when you look at it, and that's why I say, culture has an impact, culture affects many things.
84:48
Speaker A
If you live with a Korean, Koreans, for example, the issue of smoke and the issue of talking, or with a Japanese person, they might take it worse. Okay, that's a factor.
84:57
Speaker A
Smoking, you say, yes? Smoking in closed spaces, the issue of cleanliness, I mean, there are cultural factors around the perception of the environment that change, but they can be just that, things. But the thing is that at a social level, when
85:09
Speaker A
we talk about a very large society, that is tiny. So, I think there is an overestimation of the cultural factor and very little proportion of what the real problem is, which is that outside of Yes, regardless of where you might come
85:25
Speaker A
from, it's not the same for a kid. A question, why? But there is a gigantic overrepresentation in sexual offenses. This is consider-gigantic.
85:33
Speaker A
Yes, gigantic. And it is still very how a person because of their socioeconomic conditions rapes a woman.
85:42
Speaker A
I'm going to explain it to you. You are a you are a kid. You are going to try because there is little explanation, right? No, plenty of explanation. Do you know what the three main factors for rape are?
85:51
Speaker A
They are very similar to those of criminality. Family dysfunction, lack of access to education, and lack of education regarding the sexual environment. Those are things that you receive by being a person who goes to a place where they teach you. Because
86:04
Speaker A
lack of education in the sexual environment. I don't know if you are aware that today child abuse within Spain has also increased when more sex education is being provided than ever in history. So that's where I think your argument falters a bit,
86:14
Speaker A
right? Because we are talking about the same thing again, the majority of the population doesn't do it. 99.9%or do you think that all of But that education how you think, I mean, that it has increased proportionally doesn't mean it didn't. Let's see, at a
86:27
Speaker A
general level, I mean, if you said that the lack of sex education is a factor it's a factor when judging or analyzing rapists and now at the moment the rapist makes a decision.
86:42
Speaker A
At the moment the rapist makes a decision. Perfect. We are in a society where kids are being given the most sex education and where it has increased proportionally child rapes because it isn't efficient.
86:56
Speaker A
There are many factors around that. I mean, let's understand, let's understand that sexuality is a complicated thing.
87:03
Speaker A
And that we live in a moment where I’m not going to say the typical thing, that...that it makes you, but let’s understand that access to a lot of information, and precisely, the moment Spain also has a problem with
87:12
Speaker A
school failure and, curiously, the majority of subjects (I don’t want to make a false correlation, but, I mean, usually most studies that talk about people who aren’t known, because the majority are in the family environment) don’t depend on education, they
87:23
Speaker A
depend on power; I mean, that is something I think we can agree on. Yes.
87:33
Speaker A
Abuse and power because he is a sick person. Usually, I mean, in biology, when talking about this, rather than sick, we talk about the sexual capacity of a person who simply abuses because they have power, like a father who hits his
87:46
Speaker A
child because he can, period, or like a teacher who yells at his student, in a dimension that is obviously much larger . But let's talk about this small percentage, small but still very worrying. The 8%. When a person,
87:58
Speaker A
especially a migrant, is raised in an environment where their parents, for example, aren't very present because they have to be working all day, where their own family might have incorrect behaviors and you go to school. Is a school in a poor neighborhood better or
88:13
Speaker A
worse than one in a rich neighborhood? It is worse. But if there is also a large number of troubled people due to their social environment, where there is poverty and criminality, are there more teachers? There aren't. I mean,
88:25
Speaker A
there is a lack of investment in education in environments with poverty, which causes 40%of migrant children in Spain to fail in school. Failing in school is repeating a grade or dropping out, well, the school dropout rate is at 25%. So, it is serious. What happens
88:39
Speaker A
when a child leaves school at an early age because they perceive that it is of no use to them? What do they do? Often commit crimes, other times do nothing, but that has a consequence on your life . So, when we talk about them we are
88:52
Speaker A
also talking about a kid. It has consequences on your life. So, since I have failed in school, since I haven't had teachers who taught me about penises, vaginas, and consent, I go and rape a woman, right? But that is a very small
89:02
Speaker A
percentage, we're back to the same point, I mean, it's one of the minor consequences that happen when many people don't have a favorable environment where they have something to lose, which is the most important thing.
89:10
Speaker A
So, so, let's see, it's just that as we are giving a very small percentage, I mean, of the crimes against sexual freedom and indemnity, they are 501, 0.033%. Exactly. We are not saying that all immigrants commit rapes, what we
89:23
Speaker A
are saying is that there is a gigantic overrepresentation. It is very large. It is, it is very large, but very small as a percentage of all migrants.
89:28
Speaker A
Yes, yes. That must always be kept in mind. The numbers cannot be falsified by saying," Hey, what about in Catalonia? The number of rapes has gone up 400%, and 90%are migrant people. It doesn't mean, it doesn't, it doesn't
89:44
Speaker A
mean that 90%of migrant people commit rapes. "I mean, you have to analyze, because I am, I mean, I watch a lot of sociology, I like to know why a group does something and [why] a minority within a minority. You try to find a
89:56
Speaker A
reason for it. I think it is an extremely big problem that it is becoming more unsafe every day to be a woman in Spain because of migration.
90:04
Speaker A
And I also consider it extremely serious, I'm not saying you, eh, I'm talking about progressivism in general, I don't consider you that progressive, just so you know. that it tries to bring a bunch of people into Spain with
90:18
Speaker A
the socioeconomic factors that make people more prone to commit crimes. Yes, but that propensity, we're back to the same thing, that the factors don't matter. Then, a prototype of immigration should be prioritized, yes, that doesn't have these root causes. Yes, but we're back
90:36
Speaker A
to the same thing, the factor of origin is not the main factor, it's another factor that will occur in any group, but I'm not talking about the origin, but look, for example, the unaccompanied minors, right?
90:46
Speaker A
Yes, they have all the factors that you have mentioned, yes? For there to be a propensity to end up in jail, and we here promote their arrival, that they be given resources.
90:57
Speaker A
It makes no sense. We have to give them resources because otherwise it promotes, they must be sent back where they belong, which is to their country and with their parents. Look, I agree with you on many things regarding this topic
91:06
Speaker A
. The point is that I'm a bit more radical and I say, folks, there are many people having a hard time. Spain is a country that needs resources where it needs them, and I don't believe we should spend a single euro on
91:16
Speaker A
unaccompanied minors. And but I'm coming back to the same point, if you can't send a minor back, I am not going to let people die at sea.
91:23
Speaker A
neither am I, no, nobody is saying that people Yes, yes, yes, it's just a figure of speech. It's just a figure of speech, I'm not saying you're saying that. What I am saying is that I don't want to, I
91:30
Speaker A
mean, we see the statistics, we go back to the same thing. If we take cultural factors, there is no link because it's 0.0%. I mean, we say," No, but it could be that since they come from a country
91:40
Speaker A
where genital mutilation exists, they commit crimes, "but there is no correlation because if there were, that specific Mauritanian population, 90%of Mauritanians would be rapists due to a cultural issue.
91:48
Speaker A
Sure. That 90%, even if it were 10%, it would already be worrying. Man, but we are talking about the cultural environment. Yes, yes, but even with 10%it would be enough. With 90%, but it is the that nobody is saying, but I am not
92:00
Speaker A
defending that. I mean, you are making a counterargument against an argument I didn't make. What I am telling you, what I am telling you, Anug they are trying to integrate into society and they are trying to promote the arrival of people who fit all the
92:13
Speaker A
criteria that make people more prone to delinquency at a level based on your own discourse. Based on that, that is why I want to limit migration. On that, we agree. So, there is very little to debate here, the
92:24
Speaker A
thing is that I am more radical. We must send them With this, we are going to one of the last questions, since we are finishing up. It is very simple, and it is, when do you consider a person to be of a
92:34
Speaker A
certain nationality? Oh, that is very curious. When is a Spaniard a Spaniard? We return to categorical debates that The thing is, I don't believe in nationality. I mean, I believe in group coexistence. I mean, it seems to me,
92:44
Speaker A
well, I consider myself Spain, I like Spain. I think what's important in a country, regardless of where a person comes from, is that they live well, that they don't create conflict, that there's no crime, and that people celebrate different, uh, events or
92:58
Speaker A
festivities, no matter the origin, so they can. But do you agree that, I mean, on an organizational level it’s interesting to have nationalities, precisely for all this migration issue, right? For example, hey, to see if someone can come and maybe there are too many of us
93:12
Speaker A
or not, well, use the demarcation criterion of nationality. It’s just that for me, nationality doesn't define anything. I mean, apart from, I mean, on a cultural level, every culture has many things to contribute and other things that don't.
93:24
Speaker A
I mean, I’m not ethnocentric either, but I say, look, when I live, when I think about my daily life, beyond the theory, I think: I want to live peacefully and I want to be surrounded by people who live peacefully, who have
93:33
Speaker A
economic resources, and each one has their own holidays. Me, for example, no . And to live peacefully, would you go live in a neighborhood where there is predominantly Maghreb immigration?
93:42
Speaker A
It depends. Don’t lie, man. Be honest. If they’re all rich, and you’re just bluffing.
93:49
Speaker A
No, that’s not true. I mean, I’ve lived in Toronto, and in Toronto there’s a bit of everything. There are Mexican neighborhoods.
93:53
Speaker A
But let's see, I mean, you’re telling me you wouldn't go live in Dubai. No, but you wouldn't go live in Dubai.
93:59
Speaker A
But they aren’t Maghrebi. They aren’t Maghrebi. No, no. The Maghreb is the Maghreb. And listen, let me tell you one thing, here .
94:06
Speaker A
But what’s wrong with the Maghreb? In the Maghreb, there are a lot of people.
94:08
Speaker A
Damn, brother, let me tell you one little thing. Go live in El Gorronal in Villalba.
94:11
Speaker A
Yeah, yeah, but. You wouldn't go live there, not because of their culture, but because they’re poor, because it’s a dump, because the buildings are falling apart, because when people are poor, it’s not the same. You’d go live in Dubai,
94:20
Speaker A
and they’re Muslims and also Shiites, and most of the people from those countries, Look, I, I get along great with the gypsies. They love me a lot, I love them a lot. Now, don’t kill me, gypsies, please. I wouldn't go live
94:33
Speaker A
with gypsies either. That thing about being there until 6 in the morning, clapping away, right? So understand, dammit, that But what does that have to do with anything?
94:39
Speaker A
It has a hell of a lot to do with it. When is a Spaniard a Spaniard?
94:42
Speaker A
It has a lot to do with it, man. Dude, when when is a Spaniard a Spaniard?
94:45
Speaker A
Let's see, uh, you adopt we have to get this done here. Sorry for changing the subject so radically, I don't know what time it is, but we've been at it for a while. Almost done with this.
94:55
Speaker A
Uh, here is the paper. Then there's what it means to be, in capital letters , Spanish or not Spanish. To me, being Spanish transcends a bit more than just what an ID card says. Uh, for me it's a
95:09
Speaker A
culture, it's traditions, it's values. I think blood also plays a big role, which I think is an important topic.
95:16
Speaker A
Yeah, people do that, but the jus sanguinis topic is going to trigger people, huh?
95:20
Speaker A
I know. Yes, I am, and I'm Venezuelan, but precisely for that reason I am Spanish, because I consider the Spanish nation to transcend the sea, so I consider all Hispanic people to be Spanish. In fact, we were compatriots
95:37
Speaker A
for longer, we were compatriots for longer than we've been separate countries. Spain has spent more time being Spain with the other side of the pond as compatriots than not. And that's that. For me, that's the definition. However, now there are many
95:52
Speaker A
people who have a Spanish ID and literally, if we had a geopolitical conflict, which we have with Morocco, they would side with them. Is that person Spanish? Well, for me, just because a paper says so doesn't make them Spanish. That's what I want to say
96:06
Speaker A
. Now then, this is this is not up for debate. No, no, because I say, let's debate this, because it could take another while.
96:11
Speaker A
No, we're not going to debate this. This isn't yeah, because if you have to leave and all.
96:15
Speaker A
Yes, I'm incredibly busy. give your opinion briefly if you want. I mean, for me, being Spanish isn't a territorial demarcation, and I think that within Spain there are a ton of different ways to see local culture, and precisely that's what I like about
96:30
Speaker A
Spain, if I can say it, that we have a ton of of different cultures with a ton of traditions, with a ton of ways of seeing the world I am more of an internationalist in that regard; I prefer to see how
96:42
Speaker A
peoples develop certain customs and ensure those customs are maintained, remain peaceful, and can coexist, that's it. I mean, it doesn't matter to me if someone is more Spanish; I don't believe in clubs or nations, I see it more as a kind of territorial religion
96:57
Speaker A
that many people practice. Well, I mean , Spaniards and Venezuelans can have things in common. Yes, the French and the Italians and many other groups, but not at the same level.
97:07
Speaker A
Well, at the same level. I think most current Venezuelans might even doubt they have anything to do with Spaniards. They might even have an anti-Spanish discourse on the matter.
97:17
Speaker A
They might. Well, Spain was not a colonialist empire. Yes, it was. Well, we can debate that. That’s another topic.
97:23
Speaker A
If you want, we can do a part two on this topic, which is more my specialty, not so much the Black Legend and these issues. That’s where you’ve got me.
97:29
Speaker A
I’m going to tell you one thing. I invite you to my show, I’m going to offer you another debate.
97:34
Speaker A
I was very interested in many things you said, and I consider that there are people better trained than me on the topic of immigration and I would like to invite you to my program because I thought you did a
97:44
Speaker A
hell of a job, I liked it and hey, thank you very much. I accept.
97:47
Speaker A
My pleasure. And we are also going to send a message that even though we have points of disagreement, it doesn't mean we are enemies, something that today’s society seems to want to keep us completely at odds. If we look at it,
97:59
Speaker A
look, a priori he was a progressive person, I was a conservative relic, and we ended up agreeing on a great many things. Something that, today, the elites that I say seek this, are in charge of highlighting the things that
98:12
Speaker A
divide us, when I really believe that if you put all people at a table, there are almost always far more things that unite them than things that divide them , and I think it’s very important to keep that in mind. Yes,
98:27
Speaker A
I, well, for me the most important thing about the topic of debating is coexistence, the same as my model. I mean, I...ideas are things I cannot change, and I think there are certain ideas that aren't right, but I believe
98:38
Speaker A
the most important thing is that ideas don't translate into attacking, for example, a minority for being a minority or things like that. Well, maybe doubting, and I might not like it and we can disagree, but the most important thing is creating a situation
98:50
Speaker A
where we can coexist and not kill each other or encourage others to want to kill one another. And don't you think that's only possible by having these conversations? Yes, yes, of course.
98:59
Speaker A
Well, that's why this has been very productive. I remember talking about this subject with Ernesto Castro, the subject of ideas, right? And he, citing, told me that ideas come and go, right? That they are like cards being discarded and
99:10
Speaker A
in the end, it's the ideas that change and the characters, right? So, a real pleasure to have had you here on the podcast, and to the audience, thank you very much for listening to this debate between two honest people who, regardless of your
99:22
Speaker A
opinions regarding their ideas, which you may agree with more or less, we cannot deny that there has been absolute honesty. So we'll see you next week for another super special episode.
Topics:debatetraditional familyimmigrationfeminismbirth ratedemographicsconservativeprogressiveSpainsocial issues

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →