Skip to content
Get App

The Real Roots of US Empire EXPOSED | Prof. Samir Saul

Historian Samir Saul discusses his book on imperialism, arguing Lenin's definition is outdated and that imperialism persists today beyond colonialism, despite the term fading after the 1980s.

Key Takeaways

  • Imperialism remains a relevant analytical concept, even though colonialism has largely disappeared.
  • Lenin's 1900s-era definition based on finance capital needs updating to explain contemporary power structures.
  • Economic and geopolitical analysis should be combined rather than treated as contradictory approaches.
  • The disappearance of 'imperialism' from public vocabulary reflects a shift toward softer framings like globalization.

What the video covers

  • Prof. Samir Saul (University of Montreal) introduces his book 'Imperialism as rampant today as in the past', written because existing theories failed to explain contemporary power dynamics.
  • The term imperialism largely vanished from public discourse in the 1980s, overtaken by the sanitized concept of globalization, including on the left.
  • Saul says Marxists still using the term rely almost entirely on Lenin's definition, which he considers an excellent work but dated and in need of updating.
  • Lenin's model linked imperialism to monopoly capitalism and finance capital (Hilferding), a fusion of bank and industrial capital that Saul argues did not materialize in Britain or the US.
  • Saul argues imperialist expansion and capital export predate the rise of finance capital, so Lenin's chronology is historically inaccurate.
  • Lenin's key achievement, per Saul, was distinguishing colonialism (direct control) from imperialism (broader control, including over sovereign states).
  • Saul advances a hierarchical, pyramid-like model of imperialism with the US at the top, and discusses US economic dominance after 1945 and efforts to re-establish hegemony.
  • The conversation touches on Soviet economic management, debt and interest burdens in the 1970s, and Western interventions such as Libya described as proxy warfare.
  • Saul is skeptical of explanations that reduce foreign policy to ideology alone, favoring analyses integrating economic factors with realism.

Answers

Questions about this video

Why does Samir Saul say he wrote his book on imperialism?

He observed that contemporary international behavior looked like imperialism, yet existing theories did not explain it. He also noticed the term had largely disappeared from public discourse, so he set out to revisit and update the concept.

What is Saul's main criticism of Lenin's theory of imperialism?

Saul argues Lenin's definition rests on finance capital as the fusion of bank and industrial capital, which did not materialize as predicted in major capitalist powers like Britain and the US. He also notes that imperialism and capital export predated the rise of finance capital, making Lenin's chronology historically inaccurate.

What did Lenin contribute that Saul still values?

Saul credits Lenin with distinguishing colonialism, which is direct control by a colonial power, from imperialism, a broader system of control that can extend even to independent, sovereign states.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:01
Speaker A
Welcome back everybody to Neutrality Studies. Today, for the first time, with Professor Samir Saul, a full professor of international history at the University of Montreal. Samir, welcome.
00:12
Speaker A
Uh, pleased to be with you. I'm very glad having you because you wrote a wonderful book. Let me just show it for a second. Uh, it's called Imperialism as rampant today as in the past. And just so people know like the
00:26
Speaker A
lower part of the cover actually shows the the flag of the United States being held up somewhere in the world. So, um yeah, um Samir, um where do we even start when we discuss imperialism?
00:39
Speaker A
Because in your book, you actually start in basically prehistory and in in very early times. Um, what's the what's the core of the concept to you?
00:50
Speaker A
Uh, I think we should start with the present. In fact, that's how the book started.
00:54
Speaker A
It started by observing what was going on around me and looking for explanations, looking for analytical tools to understand what was going on.
01:05
Speaker A
It looked very much like imperialism, but none of the existing explanations or theories seemed to fit.
01:16
Speaker A
The international situation, the the powers that are active on the international scene are not acting in the way powers acted in the past.
01:29
Speaker A
Uh, and yet there is there is definitely exploitation and domination. Now, I turn to imperialism because this seemed to be a a good good starting point.
01:43
Speaker A
Uh, I was thinking that in terms of the you know if if the situation looks is often there's a saying that says if something looks like a duck, walks like a duck, sounds like a duck, it's a duck.
01:57
Speaker A
Uh, so I thought this it is imperialism, but none of the explanations seem to answer the the need.
02:06
Speaker A
And surprisingly, the term imperialism sort of had disappeared from public discourse. It was a common term used in the up to the 60s, 70s, and then suddenly in 1980s it disappeared, including in the left, which is very surprising because the
02:24
Speaker A
left and especially the Marxists were used it very often. But it sort of went out of usage. It went out of practice during the 80s and it was overwhelmed by the concept of globalization.
02:43
Speaker A
Globalization is a very sanitized form expression of international control and economic, you know, expansion of capitalism around the world.
02:58
Speaker A
And imperialism sort of disappeared. So I thought, well, something had to be done about that and I had to look into into that concept.
03:07
Speaker A
I've been thinking about this for for many many years. This is not new. You know, this is something that goes back in fact time when I was an undergraduate student, but continued.
03:18
Speaker A
And since theories seemed not you know, answer the you know, the requirements of of the moment, I thought, which is normal for a historian, going back to history would be the way to reconstitute the concept.
03:38
Speaker A
Restart the analysis in a way in order to arrive at an explanation or a definition suitable especially for our times, but also applicable to the past.
03:53
Speaker A
Now that's quite an undertaking because society is changed and economic conditions change. So that I had a a lot of looking research to do and thinking, especially thinking, to do to revisit the concept and try to refresh it.
04:12
Speaker A
So the book is an attempt to update explanations or definitions of imperialism in order to have a definition that is applicable for today.
04:22
Speaker A
Very important because today imperialism has sort of disappeared in the in the clouds in the sort of people don't know what it is, including the left, to my great surprise, including the left. So I had to start from scratch, basically. That's it.
04:37
Speaker A
And I I I do agree, although I must I must qualify the mainstream left. The actual Marxists, like the people who still call themselves Marxists, they actually still still use the concept, but they are a tiny minority by now,
04:48
Speaker A
right? And um there's one more group that recently emerged that's using it again, which is the people who are criticizing Russia for being imperialists as in land grabbing a land grabbing power, which is what they mean with the concept. The Marxists on the
05:02
Speaker A
other hand, they use it in order to describe the tendency of a liberal capitalist system that that strives for dominance and exploitation that then out of the logic of how it works must go and and dominate other places um which
05:18
Speaker A
in are you using the concept yourself in one of these two ways? Um if yes, which one? And if no, then what how are you using it?
05:28
Speaker A
No, I'm not using it either of these ways because uh the problem with the minority of Marxists that still remembers the term imperialism is that they rely entirely on Lenin's definition.
05:43
Speaker A
Yes. Which is a very it's an excellent definition. It's an excellent it's it's an excellent book. In fact, I write in my book that Lenin's pamphlet is the best book ever written on imperialism.
05:54
Speaker A
Uh the problem is that it it is dated. It has it has to be updated. It has to be refreshed.
06:03
Speaker A
Lenin's definition is based on the idea that imperialism is monopoly capitalism. Monopoly capitalism is for Lenin finance capital.
06:16
Speaker A
Rudolf Hilferding's finance capital which means for Hilferding and Lenin the fusion of bank capital and industrial capital into one form of capital, one a single capital.
06:30
Speaker A
That's what was taking place in Germany before 1914. In Wilhelmian Germany that was in fact the evolution of capitalism. It was concentrated with a an interpenetration of bank and industrial capital.
06:47
Speaker A
That to Lenin looked to be the future of capitalism. It didn't turn out to to be that way. In fact this was an exception in other capitalist big capitalist powers like Britain, US.
07:04
Speaker A
This fusion did not take place. We had huge enterprises, large banks, large industries dominating their their sector.
07:12
Speaker A
But there was no fusion. There's no finance capital in in Hilferding's sense. We have finance capital today in a different sense but we'll we'll talk about that about that later.
07:24
Speaker A
So there's there's a a problem with Lenin's definition. And there's also another problem in that definition is that it it dates the beginning of imperialism around the 1900s with the birth of finance capital.
07:40
Speaker A
Now historically this does not it's not accurate because expansionism and and imperialism started long before the arrival of this finance capital assuming that this was the future of capitalism.
07:54
Speaker A
Expansionism colonialism cap even capital export of capital which is one of the major achievements of Lenin is to pinpoint the importance of finance of the export of capital had started before the arrival of finance capital, before the arrival of
08:10
Speaker A
monopoly capitalism. So there's a historical distortion. There's something something wrong. So the phenomenon the phenomenon predates the the the economic underpinnings that Lenin put its finger on that that it rests Correct.
08:25
Speaker A
Correct. Correct. Having said that, you know, Lenin's definitely Lenin's study of imperialism has very very important key achievements, key features.
08:36
Speaker A
He is the first to be able to distinguish colonialism from imperialism. Right. In other words, possessions of empires, colonies is one thing.
08:48
Speaker A
Imperialism, as Lenin understood it, is a much wider method or much wider system of control.
08:56
Speaker A
Even independent countries, even sovereign states can be under foreign control with imperialism. Whereas colonialism is direct immediate control by a colonial power.
09:09
Speaker A
Now he was the first and to to be able to distinguish this this the two the two aspects, the two phenomena.
09:18
Speaker A
And this discovery is extremely important because we live in an era where colonialism is largely has largely disappeared.
09:28
Speaker A
But not imperialism. Mhm. It has continued. So this is Lenin's major achievement in in his study of imperialism.
09:38
Speaker A
Although the the the basic definition is dated and has to be refreshed. And this is what I what I tried to do in my book.
09:47
Speaker A
I'm trying to bring it up to date. Hey guys, Autumn Spirit is here and we launched a new merch. For instance, the monster from our Kilt Symposium has arrived on t-shirts, tumblers, and magnets. The little fellow is really
10:00
Speaker A
cute. Check it out and your purchase helps us directly to keep the lights on.
10:03
Speaker A
So thanks a lot and see you soon. So what what what is it? What is the up-to-date definition of imperialism?
10:12
Speaker A
Having turned all this all over in my mind, having gone through centuries of of historical development of capitalism and and even pre-capitalist states, I arrive at the definition at the following definition.
10:27
Speaker A
Imperialism is a system of international economic transfers by extra-economic means. Every word is important.
10:41
Speaker A
It's a system. It's not just an operation, a raid, you know, for to plunder. It's a Not just the government, not just the king who orders his army. It's like it's more than that.
10:52
Speaker A
Correct. It's an it's a system. You know, implying political you know, very strong political influence, economic control, yeah, and especially transfers.
11:05
Speaker A
It's the the the main object of imperialism is the transfer of value from outside toward the imperialist center.
11:17
Speaker A
So it's a it is a system of value transfers but by by extra-economic means, mainly by force.
11:26
Speaker A
It's not just trade. Trade is not imperialism. Imperialism is using extra-economic means, in other words, force basically, but but other you know, for example, extraterritorial application of one's law.
11:41
Speaker A
Yeah, types of coercion, different types of coercion. Different types of coercion to in order to extract wealth from from abroad and bring it to the center.
11:52
Speaker A
So in in in in this sense, what we've seen this year, earlier this year with Venezuela is just a textbook case, right?
12:00
Speaker A
Perfect. It's a it's a perfect illustration of this definition. Trump went into Venezuela to seize the oil.
12:11
Speaker A
Uh he now says Venezuela could sell its oil, but the money has to go into an American bank account.
12:19
Speaker A
Right. And the US decides what amounts go back to Venezuela. In other words, he used force to seize wealth and appropriate for for the US. It's a perfect definition of imperialism.
12:37
Speaker A
Perfect a perfect application of imperialism. So this the the idea of expropriation, you need to take what the wealth of other nations or for other places and transfer a a large part of that to yourself. In in in how far do you then
12:52
Speaker A
distinguish this this version of imperialism from like from concepts like neocolonialism? I mean, some of these some of these imperialist structures we would find like in the way that let's say for instance, France is extracting rent from the 14 or 15 African states for which it
13:10
Speaker A
still prints their money the the the the African Yeah. How how big is that that one to me I would I would categorize that as as a as a type of neocolonialism. Would you would you say like, no, this is actually
13:28
Speaker A
also a type of imperialism? There are similarities. Neocolonialism looks very much like you know, it is imperialism.
13:36
Speaker A
I would say it's imperialism applied to countries that are not less less developed to less developed countries that acquired their independence their with decolonization, but in fact lost much of it by maintenance of of ties or control by the
13:53
Speaker A
former colonial powers. Now, imperialism is wider because it applies not only to less developed previously colonized states, but even to developed states.
14:06
Speaker A
Imperialism is very is universal. US control today does not limit itself to less developed the resource producing south.
14:19
Speaker A
It controls developed countries. Its aim is to control the entire world. So new colonialism is part of imperialism applicable, I would say applicable to less, you know, less well less developed countries. Countries that underwent colonialism and are now
14:40
Speaker A
under under neocolonial control. Can you share a couple of examples of how the current imperial core is actually even extracting rent from from developed countries?
14:54
Speaker A
Well, the it started with multinationals, US multinationals during the '60s and '70s that invested and opened plants and in in Europe, Western Europe especially, in order to control the market.
15:16
Speaker A
Their aim is it's a it's a monopoly strategy. It's not so much compete on prices. It's to drive out competition and take over the market.
15:30
Speaker A
That that was the the starting point of US control of Western economies. That's the case also in Canada. You know, Canada was probably the most most controlled Western country by by the US during the '50s and '60s.
15:48
Speaker A
Massive investments in in in in resources and oil and so on and mining in Canada, but not only even in in in in high high technology sectors.
16:03
Speaker A
US companies controlled. That was the former you know method or or or or or or means of control.
16:14
Speaker A
It was a perfect example of export of capital, which is what Lenin pinpointed as one of the you know one of the elements of of of imperialism.
16:25
Speaker A
But after the 70s, the the main method has been the use of the dollar.
16:34
Speaker A
What happened in this in the in the 70s is the end of the period of of expansion of the the economic boom during the from 19 from the Second World War to the early 1970s.
16:49
Speaker A
Something in French in French they call the 30 years of glorious growth that ended in the early 70s.
16:58
Speaker A
And it led to the detachment of the the dollar from gold. The Bretton Woods system is based on a close link between the dollar and and and and and gold.
17:14
Speaker A
$35 you know $35 1 oz of gold. That broke down. And in the in in the early 70s gold dollar was detached from gold, which meant that the US could print dollars freely.
17:31
Speaker A
And that's what it's doing. It's printing dollars and with these dollars is buying things from abroad for nothing, for paper.
17:41
Speaker A
Now that's a a method of exploitation and transfer of wealth that is formidable. Nothing was there was nothing like it in the past.
17:53
Speaker A
All one has to do is issue dollars and gain goods, obtain goods. Yeah yeah.
18:02
Speaker A
This is imperialism in its most perfect form. And and and this continued for decades.
18:07
Speaker A
And you know if we look at other times like especially like right after the Second World War, the Marshall aid that was given to Europe was not aid. It was it was basically loans that that trapped trapped countries. But
18:21
Speaker A
it did actually invest infrastructure. It did create infrastructure because it was stuff from the United States shipped over to Europe in order then to use it in these infrastructure projects and and so on. I mean, there was a real transfer of of
18:37
Speaker A
infrastructure. But all of that then stopped in the in my view financialization in the US and in Europe really took off or started really started for for seriously in the 1970s and deindustrialization of these of these economies.
18:53
Speaker A
How how how does that one fit into the imperialist framework? The Marshall Plan was was a response to specific conditions.
19:04
Speaker A
It is it is special. Specific conditions were that European countries had great needs after the war for because of the destruction and so on but had no means to buy from the US.
19:20
Speaker A
The only country that could export anything after the Second World War was the US.
19:26
Speaker A
It had surpluses. Europeans had needs but no means. So what the Marshall Plan did is give them the means, give them the dollars with which to buy US products.
19:36
Speaker A
One reason. Second reason is that the US had surpluses from the war. And without without customers fanning fanning the imports by customers there would have been an economic crisis in the US.
19:52
Speaker A
So it was a way to avert economic crisis. Overall, third reason is that it was necessary to put European economies back in order in in order to avoid the risk of these countries going left going socialist, going communist.
20:14
Speaker A
Let's not forget that in at this period the Soviet Union was in was was a model.
20:23
Speaker A
It's not the Soviet Union. Sorry? The counter concept. It was a counter proposal to how to structure a socio-economic entity.
20:33
Speaker A
Exactly. And at that at that point in history, a successful It had succeeded in that in industrializing.
20:39
Speaker A
It had succeeded in in pushing back German German aggression. Yeah. So the US Soviet Union had had a good reputation.
20:48
Speaker A
Had good press. The US had to fight this this counter model. And in for that reason, it made concessions to European countries in order to raise them, to make sure that they don't they don't collapse.
21:05
Speaker A
So the Marshall Plan is in itself not specifically imperialist because of the circumstances. But overall, it's an it's an attempt to to consolidate the Western Western capitalism and therefore US imperialism.
21:23
Speaker A
Because if its local allies, if its European allies were failing, the US system would would be in danger.
21:32
Speaker A
The US had after 1945, the US had as its objective large-scale expansion around the world and competition with with the with the Soviet Union.
21:44
Speaker A
So they couldn't afford to have one of its components in in trouble. So the Marshall Plan is a is a is a complex is a nuanced issue. It's not it's not clear-cut imperialism, but it's within an imperialist objective.
22:03
Speaker A
And then the as this as this system went forward, the the clash of systems to me stopped somewhere in the 1980s. There was a moment when the Soviet Union and certainly with Perestroika, I mean ever since '85, since Gorbachev came to
22:22
Speaker A
power, Perestroika and Glasnost, when basically the the Soviet Union as counter-concept started failing. What how important was that for this development of modern imperialism?
22:33
Speaker A
It's extremely important. It's vital because the the problems in the Soviet Union did not start in the '80s.
22:42
Speaker A
They started in in the late '60s when there was a slowdown in the economy.
22:48
Speaker A
There was a loss of productivity and various attempts to correct the problem. None of them successful.
22:57
Speaker A
These attempts continued till the till the 1980s and they all failed. The problem is is you know one of the you know the problems in the Soviet Union is is the the management of a huge economy from the center.
23:11
Speaker A
The centralized economy was had become so complex that the the the the center was unable to to keep up and and respond to various needs.
23:25
Speaker A
So the there's an economic slowdown in the in the in the Soviet Union from the end from the end of the '60s and it gets worse during the during the Now one of the answers the Soviet Union sought to its problems
23:39
Speaker A
was technology. Introduce technology in order to increase production and productivity. The technology the the Soviet Union sought was in the West.
23:51
Speaker A
It wanted to to import this technology. And to import this technology it it began borrowing.
24:00
Speaker A
Borrowing in the West. And it's its Comicon allies borrowed even more. Poland, Romania borrowed you know very large amounts to import this technology.
24:18
Speaker A
Now the the aim was to produce in order to sell to the West. Now this is a relationship that looks very much like what pre-capitalist or or less developed countries did. They borrowed in the 19th century. From from Paris and and London.
24:34
Speaker A
In order to export their raw materials. Yeah. Which means they were very dependent on Western markets.
24:41
Speaker A
If Western markets were in in in in a state of boom imports would be good would be high.
24:48
Speaker A
If they enter into a recession or a crisis they would import less. Now in Western Europe in 1970s entered into a recession into a fact a long-term recession. We're still into it.
25:00
Speaker A
We haven't found a way the path toward recovery and and and growth. So they borrowed at the wrong time.
25:10
Speaker A
They borrowed at a moment when the West was not was not ready to to to import was it was importing less.
25:17
Speaker A
And as the the imported as they as they borrowed they had to pay interest to the banks that that Now this interest became more and more you know heavier and heavier to bear in the in the in the 70s.
25:33
Speaker A
And the West launched an offensive. The the human rights offensive. The Helsinki Conference of 1975 is an offensive to shake up the system.
25:48
Speaker A
It's different from what the from what anti-communism did during the 50s and 60s. In the 70s it was offensive to transform the system or bring it down.
26:00
Speaker A
The Soviet Union was therefore under under pressure. First by by its lower productivity economic economy not going well.
26:10
Speaker A
And an ideological offensive by the West. As well as the need to pay interest to Western countries.
26:20
Speaker A
To take an example. Ceausescu in 18 in 1999 89 when he was overthrown he was pressuring his population to pay back interest to uh Western banks, pressuring them hard, impoverishing them, and therefore uh setting them up against him,
26:45
Speaker A
making them, you know, opponents. They're the ones who brought him down because he was paying the West. He was he was in in in obliged uh in contractual obligations to pay interest and find that interest in in in his
26:59
Speaker A
population. So your your interpretation of the fall down of the communist system is that it got it got itself trapped in a debt debt trap?
27:11
Speaker A
Partly. And it got it trapped in a in a debt trap because it was it had internal problems for which it didn't seem to have solutions.
27:22
Speaker A
There seems to have been uh a stoppage or some some problem in in the in the superstructural system in new in the Soviet Union to uh understand what was going on, understand the evolution of technologies uh production and so on.
27:43
Speaker A
Uh lack of imagination too that ended up in a sort of a sclerosis of the system.
27:53
Speaker A
And and how why is it in this in this interpretation that the um that it is the imperialist drive of this well I mean in your in your interpretation it's not capitalism per se but it is the this exploitative
28:08
Speaker A
system that that managed to actually convince the the communist block to do the the exact steps that that actually lead to capture, right?
28:20
Speaker A
Because this is a form of capture, isn't it? It's a form of capture. Is that the Sorry, I didn't hear your question very well.
28:30
Speaker A
So sorry, the the question is like how did the how did the this system, the imperialist system, manage to sell this form of capture which previous generations of communists managed to to avoid. I mean, as you said, until the 1960s it was
28:48
Speaker A
going relatively well for the communists. Desperation. Lack of solutions. Impasse. They were in an impasse. They were there was a blockage.
29:00
Speaker A
And they were unable to resolve it by their own means. There's a loss of imagination, a loss of I would say there's been a a loss of of creativity within the system that made them turn towards their adversaries.
29:20
Speaker A
They must have known for a while that they they were taking risks. I mean, this is basic basic knowledge to communists.
29:28
Speaker A
You don't borrow from capitalists. It's so simple as that. And they did. If they did, it's because they had to.
29:37
Speaker A
And how did then the this imperialist system it it I mean, it it crowned itself king of the hill in 1991 after the Soviet Union finally collapsed, right? To the point again where Fukuyama wrote The End of History and said like now now the
29:56
Speaker A
contest is decided. Liberal capitalism will reign supreme until the end of humanity, right? History stopped. History stopped.
30:06
Speaker A
Yeah. I mean, according to him. He he meant it in the sense of like system contest, right? System contest has been decided.
30:14
Speaker A
Right. And then liberal liberal imperialism went went on on a haywire and again then changed the entire global discourse about imperialism to one about globalization. [laughter] That's right.
30:30
Speaker A
What is your interpretation about this unipolar moment actually? Well, the unipolar moment was something that the US would have liked in 1945.
30:42
Speaker A
When it was it was absolutely dominant economically in 1945. In terms of industrial production, gold, raw materials, capital, it had everything.
30:54
Speaker A
Except one thing. Control of Eastern Europe. It could not control Eastern Europe. There was this problem that was called the Soviet Union.
31:03
Speaker A
And it couldn't be resolved by by force because Soviet Union was just too strong for for for pressure.
31:09
Speaker A
So the attempt to establish world domination in had to be postponed. It arrived in 19 in 1990 1991.
31:22
Speaker A
That's the moment when the US thought that the world was at their disposal. That we it could finally establish what I call planetary imperialism.
31:35
Speaker A
Imperialism over everything and everybody. Not just southern countries, which is what European imperialists did in 19th century or in the 20th also.
31:45
Speaker A
But the whole world, including developed countries. And in fact, it seemed to be on its way to doing that.
31:54
Speaker A
In the 1990s, the US was dominant and seemed to be penetrating everywhere, reducing everyone to its to obeying its its its orders and its its needs.
32:07
Speaker A
Using dollars as the dollar as the instrument of penetration. And we were on the way to a universal imperialism.
32:15
Speaker A
A planet what I call a planetary imperialism. And it seemed to be to people like Fukuyama and others the end of the end of history.
32:23
Speaker A
And And just on a side note, they very self-servingly started calling it the Pax Americana, right? The American peace. Very beautiful, right?
32:32
Speaker A
But okay, let's continue. Of course. And they they assimilated it or or or or associated with Pax Pax Britannica of the 19th century.
32:43
Speaker A
This idea that we Britain ruled the world for the best interests of the world.
32:49
Speaker A
The last empire, the last version of imperialism that that crumbled down. Yeah, you see how like they they hand over the staff, right? Like like in a marathon.
32:58
Speaker A
The continuity, you know, continuity. You just continue. Now, this seemed to be going very well, fine and dandy for some time.
33:05
Speaker A
Except that problems problems appeared. The system is not perfect, does not function as as as as it should.
33:14
Speaker A
Because it it subjects other countries to outside domination. And it so happens that other countries did not some other countries anyway did not accept it and were able to recover some independence as much as possible, as much independence as they
33:32
Speaker A
could. Now these this is the case especially with with with China and with with Russia, even Russia.
33:41
Speaker A
That's the whole point of the of the conflict with Russia is that Russia does not accept US hegemony.
33:48
Speaker A
Does not accept to be ruled in its internal affairs and its world world history by outside control.
33:55
Speaker A
So there there are dissidents within the system. And the system itself does not function correctly.
34:02
Speaker A
The crisis of of of 2000 you know 20 2008 the subprime crisis is a major major break in the attempt of the US to dominate the world.
34:14
Speaker A
It's a a a a a an instance where globalization presented as the best solution, as the ultimate paradise for everybody would not work.
34:27
Speaker A
So the system had had flaws in it. And these flaws became larger and larger and we have now a system that is on the verge of disintegrating.
34:39
Speaker A
Unipolarity is strongly contested. And the effort, US policy, that's that's the explanation for what what what US is doing around the world, is an attempt to re-establish that hegemony by force.
34:54
Speaker A
Yeah. By force. That's the reason the US intervenes everywhere. It's because there are rebels in the system.
35:02
Speaker A
And it has to put down these rebels. And so it this is this is a very useful kind of interpretation in my view because like um it does a couple of it does a couple of things. One is it actually brings back
35:16
Speaker A
this economic perspective into how things work and connects violence to to to economics, which of course the Marxists have always done, right? And and said.
35:25
Speaker A
But on the other hand, you would shift you would shift the the attention a little bit from what the realists in international relations do, right? People like John Mearsheimer, they will reduce everything to security competition, right? It's just the sheer
35:38
Speaker A
size of these countries which then leads them to feel insecure and hence they blah blah blah blah security competition. You would say like no, it's not security competition that animates Russia and China. It is the resistance to imperial domination. And this would
35:54
Speaker A
ring very very loud with uh in other with with other colleagues who for instance research what is happening at the moment on the Arabian Peninsula and the resistance movements there are resistance to imperialism, resistance to colonialism.
36:08
Speaker A
Uh and you would say like this is the same underlying motivation behind China's and Russia's actions. Is is that about it?
36:15
Speaker A
Yes. Uh Russia and China are uh trying to set up a national national systems of of economic national economies.
36:30
Speaker A
Now national economies are uh completely in complete opposition to imperial control. Yeah and So by definition they're they're they're in they're moving in a direction that does not does not correspond to what the US wants.
36:47
Speaker A
Now, the security issue is not secondary for a country like Russia, for example. In order to defend its national economy or national existence as a state, as a nation, a nation state, Russia has to protect its borders.
37:04
Speaker A
US action against Russia is not just economic, it's military. Yeah. The expansion of NATO on on the frontier of Russia is a direct threat to Russian security.
37:21
Speaker A
So there's no there's no real contradiction between realism and I would say an an overall a more exhaustive analysis of international international problems taking in economic economic issues.
37:35
Speaker A
No, I I I didn't mean to pit your interpretation of imperialism against realism, not at all. I do think they're very very compatible. I just wanted to point out that the realists will will will seek the will say that the the at
37:47
Speaker A
at the bottom, if we go all the way down, it it all boils down to the security competition. But if we take yours, then security competition is just one element in going even deeper down, which is actually resistance to
37:58
Speaker A
imperialism, resistance to being dominated. And that that's the core of of what the resistance is actually about.
38:05
Speaker A
Correct. Especially in in in at a time when the when imperialism is the one the type of imperialism that we have today, one imperialist power Yeah.
38:15
Speaker A
aiming to world control, aiming at establishing a planetary universal imperialism. In other words, any any state that wants to protect itself will find itself in an anti-imperialist position.
38:30
Speaker A
Yeah. That applies, and this is where I I I take my distance from some some some analysts, some, you know, not they're not many any case work in that field, who think that um Russia and are imperialist competitors
38:51
Speaker A
Mhm. to the US. That's not correct. Uh if when uh anchors our analysis in history, the present period emerges from from unipolarity, from total US domination of the world, 1990s.
39:12
Speaker A
Russia and China were to be dominated like any other country in the American vision, in this universal imperialism that that the US had in mind.
39:24
Speaker A
What Russia and China are doing is trying to extract themselves from foreign control, from US control.
39:32
Speaker A
They are not competitors for imperial They are not trying to install an imperial system themselves. That's what you would say.
39:41
Speaker A
Correct. Now that that's observing the world as it is, not as we think it might be in the future.
39:50
Speaker A
Mhm. This is what what some analysts or theoreticians, you know, if I can call them that, uh where they go wrong.
39:59
Speaker A
They say or they think China has the the various has very the the the features of a country that could dominate the world.
40:07
Speaker A
Therefore therefore it dominates the world. No. It might dominate the world in the future.
40:13
Speaker A
And if it uses force to extract wealth from the rest of the world, it will be imperialist.
40:22
Speaker A
But at the moment, it's not. Russia is certainly not. Russia is certainly not because it doesn't have the means to extract wealth from the rest of the world.
40:31
Speaker A
So the world today does not look like 1914 where we had several competing imperialist powers, relatively equal.
40:42
Speaker A
Relatively, you know, some some, you know, Italy was not in the, you know, but Britain and and and and Germany especially were at about the same level.
40:51
Speaker A
And both competing for world domination. We don't have that today. Today there's one imperialist power that is losing its its its hegemony and is doing everything possible to reestablish it.
41:05
Speaker A
Yeah, and in your interpretation then Russia and China, what they do is they do trade with the world, but they do that basically upon reciprocity I I would suppose and not in terms of trying to extract through force, through
41:16
Speaker A
through extra economic means wealth from other states and even what Russia is doing in Ukraine is in a sense maybe a land grab, but it is not the extraction of wealth from Ukraine by extra economic means. Is that how you
41:30
Speaker A
understand it? Correct. Correct. What Russia is doing in in Ukraine is protecting itself. It is threatened.
41:41
Speaker A
Clearly threatened by NATO expansion and has been threatened for some time. Now it's it's back is to the wall in in in in Ukraine.
41:53
Speaker A
And faced with this ultimate danger it took it it took action. It's protecting itself.
42:01
Speaker A
It's not it's not searching for wealth in Ukraine. There's not there's no wealth in Ukraine.
42:06
Speaker A
No, it's there's no there's no wealth in Ukraine. I mean certainly not. It's it's being destroyed right now and the Russians the Russians are actually also like bleeding quite significantly. But so in this sense really the only imperialist power
42:18
Speaker A
that we have left is the United States. What about what about is there something like downstream imperialism like you know the way that the Europeans are acting again towards the global south or in a sense even my beloved Japan
42:34
Speaker A
after the Second World War there was this very interesting period when Japan was forced to pay reparations, but these reparation pays and payments which went mostly towards Southeast Asia immediately became an economic motor to do maybe you know something like a
42:48
Speaker A
Marshall plan like this the the that that money was then used in order to bring Japanese goods into Southeast Asia and built and became actually the kernel of the modern-day Japan's foreign aid program under JICA, which is a huge
43:01
Speaker A
which is very very important for Japan in order to foster economic dependencies in in Southeast Asia and Africa. And but actually that is a kind of a win-win situation because the others do get something out of it. But how do you do
43:14
Speaker A
you Is there a form of downstream imperialism as well in the in the global system of imperialism?
43:20
Speaker A
Yes. It's because again history history go back to history. Developed countries were themselves imperialists.
43:28
Speaker A
France, Germany, Britain especially, you know, Japan, you know, they were imperialists. Now what happens after 1945 is that they come under the control of a much more powerful imperialism.
43:42
Speaker A
So the US have been imperial super imperialist if one can call it that. So they they find themselves in a in a in an intermediary position of being dominated by the US but being dominant in regions or areas
43:57
Speaker A
they formerly controlled. Correct. There is there are sub imperialisms within an overall imperial system.
44:05
Speaker A
The imperial system is hierarchical. It's like a pyramid. On top there is the leading imperialism, US.
44:15
Speaker A
Lower down now you have the former imperialist powers, Europe, Japan, some developed countries like Canada which was not an imperial state, but is one of the part of the imperial system.
44:26
Speaker A
And at the very bottom the rest of the world. So it's a hierarchy. It's not it's [laughter] not equality. It's not a, you know, a a an international community as they often say.
44:38
Speaker A
It's a hierarchy. Yeah. And and and a lot of people need to be dirt poor in order for a few of them to be very very rich. And in this sense though Marxists traditional Marxists will would of course say that any
44:51
Speaker A
capitalist system must necessarily has necessarily like imperialist tendencies. Is that the same for you or do you think that there are other drivers of imperialism different from just you know unfettered capitalism?
45:06
Speaker A
In my analysis in the book I I relate imperialism to very primitive forms of plunder and and you know extra booty you know plunder going back to previous times.
45:21
Speaker A
These habits are adopted and developed by capitalism made more complex not just a raiding party going to steal slaves or gold or or or or or spices but a system put in place with a you know interrelations very complex
45:44
Speaker A
interrelations in order for the the wealth to be extracted in an invisible way. That's what capitalism does.
45:55
Speaker A
Capitalism does have these tendencies from by its very nature because it is it is expansionist it has to find profit.
46:04
Speaker A
Without profit capitalism collapses. So if profit is unavailable in one place it has to find it elsewhere.
46:11
Speaker A
So definitely capitalism has within it the the seeds of expansionism and imperialism by its very nature you know as a system yes.
46:24
Speaker A
But in this sense like if we especially if we take your definition you could imagine something else but capitalism to have also imperialist tendencies like let's say let's say just a very very violent dictator gets the idea that I now want
46:42
Speaker A
to force everybody else to pay rent to me. I mean that could be like a source of of then that dictator to go out and and implement imperialism without necessarily his state being capitalist.
46:54
Speaker A
Correct. You know this is the primitive type of of imperialism. I call it I call it extractive. I don't remember the term I used.
47:03
Speaker A
Extraction by coercion, you know. [snorts] Go back to Rome, for example. Rome in the past would attack in order to seize wealth and bring back slaves to Rome.
47:17
Speaker A
You kind of a simple form of imperialism, right? A a very very direct form and in this sense capitalist imperialism is much more refined, much more indirect, much more camouflaged form of imperialism.
47:30
Speaker A
Correct, because the system is more complex. Yeah. You know, trade, you know, finance, you know, makes, you know, makes it less visible, less evident, less obvious than theft in the past like simply Yeah, and it it looks much nicer, right?
47:47
Speaker A
Pax Americana looks so much nicer than just like beating people's heads off in order to to take their wealth back home.
47:55
Speaker A
It's more respectable. Now, that doesn't mean that heads are not are not chopped, you know.
48:01
Speaker A
are. They are. But it's not presented as the as the acme or as the as the the the the model. It's something that should be concealed because it's not consonant with ideals, principles, and values, you know. So we keep it hidden.
48:21
Speaker A
But the violence is part and parcel of the system, you know, of course. And the drive the drive to domination, the drive to domination.
48:28
Speaker A
Yes, the drive to domination and the urge to use force. Anytime you have a disparity of power between collectivities, societies, and states, there's a danger of of the use of force by the stronger party.
48:45
Speaker A
And they it becomes imperious when that use of force has as its objective the transfer of wealth.
48:54
Speaker A
You know, the the interpretation by Jeffrey Sachs and a couple of others in the US is of course that this is the the part of the malaise that we're seeing today is the victory lapse of the neo conservative movement in the United
49:07
Speaker A
States in the 1990s and he keeps saying these people just want one thing and one thing only total dominance dominating the entire globe. So you would you would then in that sense integrate the the neo conservative movement into this
49:22
Speaker A
overall imperialist drive of the United States, right? It's how how it works, how it implements itself.
49:28
Speaker A
Correct. They they're the ultimate form of US domination because they don't just say we want to use covert means they want to use brute force brute force in order to capture wealth from abroad.
49:48
Speaker A
They are the I say the the summit you know the the the perfect form of imperialist control.
49:56
Speaker A
And where so where your analysis where where does it lead you to in the end like when we now look at 2026 and we see that imperialism this this this capitalist driven fall of imperialism is running against the brick wall in
50:08
Speaker A
Ukraine and wall is called Russia and it's running into a brick wall in the east it's called China it's running its brick wall in Iran.
50:17
Speaker A
So where what does this do to like running into these walls to an imperialist power or an imperialist system?
50:27
Speaker A
It puts you in a state of deep deep deep crisis. It is faced with huge decisions and big problems.
50:38
Speaker A
Continuing along the path of force does not seem to succeed at least at this level of force.
50:46
Speaker A
Let's keep in mind that the US has not launched full-scale war against anyone yet.
50:50
Speaker A
Right. It has been fighting in a indirect way. Proxy wars are the formula used by the US to continue warfare, without getting itself directly involved.
51:09
Speaker A
It has been used in proxy wars, not just in in Ukraine. They used proxy war in Syria.
51:15
Speaker A
Even even even Libya was a proxy war. Remember Barack Obama saying we beat from behind.
51:23
Speaker A
We lead from behind. Why is that? It's because the experience the the experiments in in Iraq and and Afghanistan were a complete fiasco, total total failure.
51:37
Speaker A
And they learned from the the West learns from it makes mistakes and it sometimes not always, sometimes learns that it shouldn't go that way. It should use other means to to apply force.
51:49
Speaker A
And that means is using others. This is not a new method. This is what Britain did throughout the 19th century, the 20th century.
51:59
Speaker A
The US is a very is much is is is a very is a much larger model of what Britain has done in the past.
52:05
Speaker A
Britain could not control the world by itself. It had to use others to do its work.
52:13
Speaker A
So the proxy system is not an American invention. They're just applying what Britain did.
52:19
Speaker A
And it's a system that is is is a way of of resolving the problem of lack of means towards the ends the ends that that that there are sought.
52:34
Speaker A
The US wants total control of the world, but does not have the means. So it's using others.
52:39
Speaker A
It has is this method is failing. It's failed in the in it's failing. It's failing in the most obvious way in in Ukraine.
52:49
Speaker A
So the alternative now for the US is either to bow down or to go to war openly.
52:59
Speaker A
This is why this period is is extremely dangerous to the world because the US is faced with the dilemma of continuing on a path that is leading it to to to you know the disintegration of the system.
53:13
Speaker A
Or going all out toward war to to make war in order to reestablish itself.
53:24
Speaker A
So it's very dangerous. Yeah, that is very dangerous. I mean what you are describing is basically you're arguing the United States is now literally faced with an existential threat not because the continental United States is threatened by weapons
53:38
Speaker A
but because the imperial global imperial system that they build is about to collapse and Correct.
53:46
Speaker A
When we know in realism we know what what states do when they're when they're when they're threatened with with when their existence is threatened they go all in because anything else makes no sense.
53:57
Speaker A
Yes, but in this case US existence is not is not threatened. It's US ambitions that are threatened.
54:02
Speaker A
The imperial system System correct. It's imperial system. Not the US state but the the the system as a as a is the question then is who who controls the nukes? Is it the United States as a as a country or is it the the US as an
54:17
Speaker A
imperial system? Let's hope the state [laughter] It's it's an awful question. I don't have an answer but it it's obvious that a system has to translate itself has to transform itself into a state into political means Yeah.
54:36
Speaker A
of exercising power. And that's these are these means are are a state. So the US state controls the nuclear weapons of the imperialist system.
54:46
Speaker A
It's if one needs to establish a clear line you know it that would be it.
54:55
Speaker A
So I'm here that that that that almost makes me shiver because it's it's a scary thought but I I do I do think you have a very valid point with this analysis of of how imperialism works.
55:06
Speaker A
It is it is dangerous, extremely dangerous, but then there are slivers of hope. It's not just a completely dark pessimist. Like sliver of hope for example comes from the US itself.
55:20
Speaker A
From within the US the American American population is not a warmongering population population. They're not seeking war.
55:30
Speaker A
And as the thick layers of propaganda dissipate it starts seeing things. It understands things better.
55:41
Speaker A
We see this for example with the in the war against Iran. At the start of the war we were told the US is going to conquer everything and it's going to be easy.
55:53
Speaker A
Iran is a backward state so. Public opinion usually goes along with what governments say when they launch a war. That's a very one of these historical facts that are extremely troubling but it's a fact.
56:04
Speaker A
But public opinion can open its eyes as events unroll. As events show them that the explanations given to them by the official explanations don't apply.
56:16
Speaker A
So there's hope in the US. There's also hope in in in the fact that other countries will not go along with US aggressive policies. You know may may back off because what the US would be demanding of them is their total
56:34
Speaker A
destruction. What is going on in in in in Ukraine should be a lesson to all.
56:39
Speaker A
Ukraine is is is being wiped off the map. Its its population is cut down you know to 50 percent.
56:47
Speaker A
And and it's the kind of future that might actually be on the cards for the entire European continent if these if this waking up doesn't doesn't happen but you're absolutely right. The biggest the biggest chances are the political
56:57
Speaker A
processes inside to actually oppose this kind of imperialism. I have unfortunately a hard stop but this was a fascinating discussion. Thank you so much Samir.
57:07
Speaker A
People who want to find your book where should they go? Uh, the publisher is called Baraka Books.
57:14
Speaker A
B a r a k a Baraka and he's in Montreal. Publisher is in Montreal.
57:23
Speaker A
So just type Baraka Books and uh it's there. It will be available, you know uh I will I will of course put the links to to this book into the description box below. Is there any other place where
57:36
Speaker A
you sometime where you publish your work or or or something? I often publish in a in the international bulletin called Presenza uh along with my colleague Michelle Seymour.
57:52
Speaker A
We publish a lot of articles on events as they go along and what we write corresponds largely to what you know this analysis of imperialism that we that I put forward.
58:04
Speaker A
I will put the links into the description box below and we will certainly have you back. Professor Samir Saul, thank you so much for your time today.
58:11
Speaker A
It was a pleasure. Thank you very much.
Topics:imperialismLeninfinance capitalglobalizationUS hegemonycolonialismMarxisminternational historySamir Saulgeopolitics

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →