Dr. Ali Ataie examines whether Deuteronomy 18:18's 'prophet like Moses' refers to Muhammad, weighing Quranic claims, Hebrew textual analysis, and historical-critical scholarship.
Key Takeaways
- Deuteronomy 18:18 is the central biblical passage in Muslim arguments for Muhammad's prophetic foretelling.
- Historical-critical dating of Deuteronomy makes direct Mosaic authorship of the prophecy uncertain.
- Interpretation depends heavily on Hebrew wording, pre-literary traditions, and theological presuppositions.
- Christian and Muslim readings diverge sharply on whether the 'prophet like Moses' is Jesus or Muhammad.
What the video covers
- Host Paul introduces Dr. Ali Ataie, a biblical hermeneutics scholar fluent in Hebrew, Greek, and Arabic, for a session on Muhammad in the Bible.
- The Quran (7:157) describes the unlettered prophet as written of in the Torah and Gospel, a claim Muslims often connect to Deuteronomy 18:18.
- Ataie explains the Quranic use of Torah and Gospel in a twofold sense: original revelations and the extant texts believed to be partially corrupted.
- Historians generally date Deuteronomy to the 8th or 7th century BCE, roughly 800 years after Moses, complicating claims of direct authorship.
- Ataie distinguishes the pre-literary oral tradition of a prophet like Moses, a concept associated with Hermann Gunkel, from the written text.
- The discussion covers the Hebrew text of Deuteronomy 18:18 and debates whether the 'prophet like Moses' refers to a future prophet, a line of prophets, or Jesus.
- Christian readings, including the view that the prophet like Moses is Jesus as mouthpiece of the Lord, are contrasted with Muslim readings.
- Comparisons are drawn with other ancient law codes, such as the Code of Hammurabi, to contextualize Deuteronomy's casuistic laws.
- Ataie references Western scholars of Islam and the historiography of the Quran's compilation, noting the standard narrative of Theodor Nöldeke.
- The session closes with a discussion of Christian textual claims such as Luke 22:44, reflecting the broader interreligious stakes of the debate.
Chapters
- 00:00Introduction and host welcome
- 06:26Speaker background and qualifications
- 06:46Quranic claims about Torah and Gospel
- 16:40Dating Deuteronomy and the pre-literary tradition
- 30:00Hebrew text of Deuteronomy 18:18
- 38:20Christian readings of the prophet like Moses
- 60:00Historical criticism and Quran compilation
- 80:00Ancient law codes and closing discussion
Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown
Speaker A
Well, hello again. Welcome to Blogging Theology. Tonight we have back a very distinguished guest, Professor Ali A Thai. You are most welcome back on Blogging Theology, sir.
Speaker A
Thank you so much, Paul. It's an honor to be on blogging theology with you again. I appreciate it.
Speaker A
That's a great pleasure. And uh just for those few people who may not be familiar with um Dr. Tai's uh skill set if that's the right word. He is a scholar of biblical hermeneutics with uh it said I'm reading here from the notes on the
Speaker A
Zetuna College uh website which describes his qualifications uh and which are particularly relevant to tonight's program. Uh so he's a scholar of biblical hermeneutics with specialtities in sacred languages, comparative theology, comparative literature and at Zetuna College which is in California, the USA. Um, Dr. Atai
Speaker A
has taught Arabic, uh, creedle theology, um, the sciences of the Quran, introduction to the Quran, uh, and the ancient texts, uh, such as the Torah, which we're going to looking at today.
Speaker A
And he's a native Persian speaker and, uh, can read and write Arabic, Hebrew, and Greek. Now, this is particularly relevant given the subject today, which will be Muhammad, the prophet Muhammad in the Bible. particular reference to the last book of the Torah in the Jewish
Speaker A
Bible, Deuteronomy. There's a famous verse there in the 18th chapter and the 18th verse. This has often been um alluded to by Muslims as a prediction of the prophet Muhammad. Now, you would not be surprised to hear this has not gone
Speaker A
uncontested um particularly by Christian missionaries who say, "No, it doesn't." And we we say, "Oh, yes, it does." Um so, but um Dr. Aliotai is uh because of his knowledge of the languages of the Bible particularly Hebrew and Greek um
Speaker A
because the Bible comes to us in two languages the the original Hebrew and the Greek translation which is quoted in the New Testament. Here he can read and write both. So he is uniquely qualified uh to speak uh on this. So it's very
Speaker A
much his platform today. I will do virtually hopefully no waffling at all. Um because this is going to be a uh probably a quite intensive uh sophisticated um delivery. Uh I understand. So be prepared for a high level um teaching
Speaker A
experience. Um I will seek to at a future time to create segments from uh this program um more byte-size um so the length of if it puts you off you can come back and perhaps see um smaller segments in the future as well but um uh
Speaker A
perhaps I'll just end it there and hand it over to Dr. Aliotai to introduce the subject for himself and to take us through this fascinating subject. So over to you sir. Thank you.
Speaker A
Thank you again, Paul. Your channel is so incredibly important. Uh I sincerely pray that people continue to support you and your work. Um I think it's indicative uh um of our state as a species that if someone like Little
Speaker A
Nause X has, you know, 15 million subscribers, that's what people are thinking about, I guess. Uh but but there's no greater discipline than theology. Okay. the study of God, the study of ultimate reality. Okay, thorough said, uh, don't read the times,
Speaker A
read the eternities. Uh, which I I love that quote. So, thank you for your great work that you do. Uh, may Allah subhana wa ta'ala continue to uh increase you uh in all good things. So, Deuteronomy 18:18. So, this is this is a topic with
Speaker A
with with several moving parts, okay? It's a bit complicated. Uh, it's a bit sophisticated. So I encourage the listeners to maybe take notes uh to review this uh session uh if necessary and most importantly to do further research. Okay. So this is just the
Speaker A
beginning. I'm just going to lay out the groundwork. Okay. So first of all what does the Quran say about the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam in the Bible. Okay. So the Quran says and this is in the seventh surah of the
Speaker A
Quran verse 157. uh 157 it begins in the Arabic those who follow the messenger okay the unlettered or gentile prophet okay because means gentile as well whom they find uh written often is the uh the passive participle of ka to write
Speaker A
whom they find written of or described uh in the Torah and Gospel that are with them.
Speaker A
Okay. So, the Torah and Gospel that the Jews and Christians have respectively uh contain writings that describe the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam as a messenger and as an unlettered and/or gentile that is to say uh non-Israelite uh prophet. Now in the Islamic
Speaker A
tradition, the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is the prophet of the Abrahamic restoration and universal messenger. And like his ancestor Abraham uh he was neither a Jew nor a Christian but the foremost submitter unto God and the
Speaker A
quintessential monotheist. Now just to remind the viewers, I said in the previous discussion that it seems to me that the Quran uses the terms Torah and Gospel in sort of a twofold sense, right? in the sense of um uh a prototype
Speaker A
sort of the original pristine revelations given to Moses and Jesus peace be upon them but also in the sense of um existing texts in the possessions uh of Jews and Christians that contain something of the true teachings of the
Speaker A
original Torah and Gospel and these are of course you know the pentetuk and the four-fold gospel of the New Testament respectively and of course the dominant opinion is that the Quran intimates uh that the Torah and Gospel suffered a
Speaker A
degree of textual uh as well as exeetical corruption or alteration over time. Right? They heard the word of God then changed it. Uh so this is why the Quran is called alan. Alan means the criterion.
Speaker A
Okay? So that which you know separates the wheat from the chaff as it were with respect to the previous uh scriptures.
Speaker A
So the Jews and Christians have for all intents and purposes the Torah and the gospel. They're just not in their original form. So today as you said I'm going to focus uh on the Torah not the gospel because we're talking about the
Speaker A
book of Deuteronomy. Okay. So according to a general consensus of historians, the book of Deuteronomy was actually written in the 8th or 7th century before the common era. Okay? So that's about 800 years after Moses, peace be upon
Speaker A
him. So keep that in mind. I'll come back to that. That's really important. But what does what does Deuteronomy 18:18 actually say? So let's let's read it in Hebrew and then translate it as literally as possible.
Speaker A
So it says, so God is speaking to Moses here, a prophet I will raise up for them from the midst of their brethren like you and I will put my words in his mouth and he will speak to them everything that I
Speaker A
command him. Okay. Now there are two questions that arise here. Number one, given the fact that according to historians, these words were first written in the 8th century before the common era. Does this tradition of a prophet like Moses truly go back to
Speaker A
Moses, peace be upon him, or did the authors of Deuteronomy invent this idea in the 8th century? The honest answer is that we don't know. But but let's assume for our purposes today that yes, yes, it does. Let's say that the tradition of a
Speaker A
prophet like Moses is a true what's known as preompositional tradition. It's a preompositional tradition. In other words, a tradition that predates the writing of Deuteronomy. Okay? A pre-iterary tradition. This is the term that was coined by Herman Gonkul,
Speaker A
preiterary tradition. A tradition that was perhaps passed orally uh until it uh was written down by the author or really authors uh of Deuteronomy. So let us take the position then that Moses truly spoke of a prophet to come in the future
Speaker A
who would be like him. Now the second question arises given our first position was Moses describing the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. The answer is again we don't know we cannot say definitively. Now one can certainly make the argument that the
Speaker A
Quran seems to indicate this. Okay. And I direct the viewers to 70 chapter 73 verse 15 of the Quran that indeed we sent unto you a messenger to be a witness against you. Kama just as and kama this is the same particle
Speaker A
that's used in 1818 Deuteronomy kam just as we sent to Pharaoh a messenger. So the prophet Moses peace be upon him and the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him are homogenized as it were uh in this verse. Another verse that seems to
Speaker A
indicate this is chapter 46 verse 10 of the Quran. This is called verse 10 4610.
Speaker A
Say, have you considered if it is from God and you disbelieve in it? Meaning the Quran or some of the exedigits say the pronoun could refer to the prophet and you disbelieve in him while a witness from the children of Israel bore
Speaker A
witness to one like him to one like him and has believed. So, Immorti uh who uh was the great Spanish scholar uh who knew the scriptures of the Jews and Christians, he said that the witness from the children of Israel mentioned in
Speaker A
this verse in the Quran 46:10 was none other than uh Moses peace be upon him who bore witness to one like him, the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and thus believed in the prophet. So, so the Quran seems to say that Deuteronomy
Speaker A
18:18 is a true preompositional tradition that goes back to Moses and describes the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. However, according to the vast majority of Muslim scholars, uh, as Muslims, we don't insist that any text of the Bible is absolutely true in its
Speaker A
exact wording. Right? Many of the Bible's concepts are obviously true. Some of its teachings are true, certain traditions are true, but specific texts we don't know for certain. Okay?
Speaker A
Christians, by the way, uh cannot be as uh discerning as Muslims, right? Christians have essentially cornered themselves. They must accept the text of the Hebrew Bible uh from Genesis to Malachi. Uh basically hook, line, and sinker. Okay? They must find the deity
Speaker A
of Christ in the Torah because this is what the Johannan Jesus said. You Moses wrote about me and the Johannan Jesus according to Christians claim to be God.
Speaker A
Okay? So that's been their project for 2,000 years. And quite often uh Christian missionaries and apologists, they falsify the text of the Tanakh to achieve their purposes. And I'll just give you two quick examples, very famous examples. So there are many examples of
Speaker A
this um and many of the viewers uh are familiar with these but it's worth mentioning in in Christian Bibles uh Psalm 2 verse12 Psalm 2 verse12 in Christian Bibles reads like this kiss the son right lest he be angry kiss the sun s o n capital s
Speaker A
o n lest he be angry that's King James as NIV etc etc okay uh the Hebrew render as kiss the sun is nashar. It says nashar.
Speaker A
The problem is that the verb nashak can mean either to kiss or to arm oneself.
Speaker A
Okay, so it's a homonym. Um like in Psalm 78:9 it says it says the children of Ephraim being armed and carrying bows and the verb is nash. Uh secondly, the psalms are in Hebrew. Okay, bar in Hebrew means purity. In Aramaic, it
Speaker A
means son, but this is Hebrew. Okay, so the verse actually says, "Arm yourselves with purity, lest he God be angry." So here uh the uh the Christian translators want us to imagine that David suddenly decided to write a single word in
Speaker A
Aramaic in the year 1000 before the common era, no less. I don't know how he did that but I but I think I think the Christian translators know better. Um, another example, the famous example, right? The the famous royal psalm, Psalm
Speaker A
110, just the first verse. For David, a psalm, the Lord said to my Lord, both both words translated Lord, both capital, right? And so they say, look, there are two lords. You see, the father, God, the father said to God the
Speaker A
son. Here's here's the problem. In Hebrew, the first word translated as Lord is the shem of porash, right? The it's known as the tetra grammar, the yod vave. Okay, this is only used for god.
Speaker A
The second word translated as lord. The lord said unto my lord is the word adon in Hebrew which like kios in Greek or doinos in Latin can be used for human beings for men. So they are two completely different words in Hebrew but
Speaker A
both translated as Lord by Christians. Okay slightly can I just say something on that? I mean I completely agree with your observation. I use the NRSV which is usually seen as the standard academic uh translation of B universities throughout
Speaker A
the West. Looking at Psalm 110, it has the Lord says to my Lord. The first Lord is in capital letters, which traditionally means that it's referring to Yahweh in the Hebrew. The second Lord is in small letters indicating that it's
Speaker A
not Yahweh is as a being a person other than God. That's all fine. So, you know, it's done the right thing here and this is a good translation. You don't get this distinction made in some of the other translations which uhize it
Speaker A
heavily. However, the reason I I mentioned this is that if you look at the when this passage, this verse uh Psalm 110 verse1 is quoted in the New Testament by the same translators, they they don't do that. They don't make
Speaker A
a distinction. And so you get Peter talking about the Lord in in the traditional Christian sense and and there is a slight of hand there in in the New Testament translation of this otherwise very good translation. And I
Speaker A
was shocked when I looked this up and I thought you're not being consistent here. You're quoting from the text and you're you're no longer observing this big metaphysical difference between Yahweh and King or whoever it is.
Speaker A
Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And in the Quran says it's a very very interesting statement. The Quran is just really amazing. So it says they twist their tongues about the scripture. That's the literal translation. But here leis which means tongue can also mean language. Lisan
Speaker A
means language in Quranic Arabic. Just like in uh in Hebrew the word leon which is cognate to leis means tongue. The physical tongue it also means language.
Speaker A
So, so the Arabic language in Hebrew is called Lean Khedar, the tongue of Kedar.
Speaker A
Kedar, one of the sons of of Ishmael. So, the Quran says here they literally say they they twist their translations with respect to their scripture.
Speaker A
Exactly. I.e. the Bible. The best scholarly translation is still doing it. So, they're still doing it. Yeah.
Speaker A
I mean, the ayah continues in order so that you might think it's part of the scripture.
Speaker A
The Quran says, "But it's not part of the scripture." And they say, "This is from God, but it is not from God." Just amazing. The Quran is so succinct.
Speaker A
And they utter a lie against God. And they know it. It says, "They know what they're doing right now." Okay. So now if I'm going to if I'm going to postulate that that Moses peace be upon him was describing the prophet Muhammad
Speaker A
peace be upon him I would need to provide some sort of indirect or circumstantial uh evidence to support this because there's no direct evidence.
Speaker A
But before we get to that, a good question that I should answer is is why isn't it crystal clear that Deuteronomy 18:18 is referring to the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him or why isn't it more clear? This is a good question
Speaker A
and I think the Quran has the answer to this. So in chapter 2 verse 79, okay, the Quran says So woe to those who write the book right with their own or the scripture, the Bible, however you want to translate
Speaker A
that with their own hands and then say this is from God in order to make a poultry gain there from woe unto them for what their hands have written and woe unto them for what they have gained.
Speaker A
So, Imam Tabari and many others they say one of the meanings of this verse is that some Jewish scribes altered the their book okay their kab their scriptures so that the descriptions of the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him
Speaker A
would seem to indicate someone else rather than him. Okay? In other words, they've obiscated the text. They've muddied the waters as they say. they've decontextualized the text. At first glance, this might seem a bit uh far-fetched. Um how would this even be
Speaker A
uh possible? But when we study the history of the penetuk uh the five books of Moses as well as the history of the so-called uh Deuteronomistic books, so that's Joshua to second kings. Okay? As well as a book of Jeremiah. Suddenly,
Speaker A
Imam Tab's suggestion seems very plausible. And I'll come back to that uh as well. Um a Jewish apologist might say to me at this point, just read Deuteronomy 18:18 in the context of the Tanakh and you will see that it does not
Speaker A
refer to the prophet Muhammad. In other words, Deuteronomy 18:18 as it stands now. Okay? and as it has stood for the last 2,000 years in its postco compositional context, that is to say, in its canonical context, does seem to
Speaker A
point to others as being the prophet like Moses. And I actually agree with that. I think that's true. That's exactly what I Tabi said as well. So, I can totally understand why Jewish exits over the last 2,000 years have said that
Speaker A
the prophet like Moses was Joshua or Jeremiah. You see the Jewish exedigits are not necessarily the problem. The authors and editors of these texts are the problem. Those who decontextualize the text. Now the Quran says so this is chapter 5 uh verse 15.
Speaker A
Another extraordinary statement in the Quran. Oh people of the book uh or o oh people of the Bible our messenger has come to you clarifying much of what you used to conceal concerning the Bible.
Speaker A
Okay. Decontextualization is a form of concealment. Okay. The prophet's message peace be upon him prompted or uh you can say provoked this type of critical examination uh of the Bible. The Quran further says, this is chapter 4 verse 46. I know I'm throwing
Speaker A
a lot of verses out, from the Jews are those who distort words from their proper places or you might translate that shift words out of their proper contexts. They have decontextualized the Bible. I think this is also true about the passages that
Speaker A
they claim are describing this future Davidic Messiah who will rule the world. I think in their original context, these passages are actually describing somebody else. But that that's a different topic. But there's something else I want to make clear before we
Speaker A
continue that it is unlike the Jews who converted to Pauline Christianity. Okay? The Jews who converted to Islam converted to a religion that upheld the most important thing about God. Okay?
Speaker A
His radical oneness and utter uni uniqueness. Okay. Islam from a Jewish perspective is true monotheism. Jews are allowed to pray in mosques and Jews allow Muslims to pray in synagogues. In other words, there is a very coherent um
Speaker A
and consistent underlying sort of theological trajectory from Moses to Muhammad peace be upon both of them. The same cannot be said about Moses and the Christian Jesus. No matter how hard Christians want to claim this, Moses and the Christian Jesus are fundamentally
Speaker A
opposed to one another. And this this fundamental opposition is is nearly as great as the difference between Moses and Joseph Smith, I would say. I mean, trinitarianism is veiled polytheism.
Speaker A
Mormonism is an open polytheism. The Mormons admit that Jesus is another god in addition to Elohim, the God of Abraham, while the Trinitarians are still trying uh to convince us and themselves uh that Jesus is the incarnation of the same being as the God
Speaker A
of Abraham. According to a rabbitical consensus, it is forbidden for a Jew to enter a church. Even to enter a church, forbidden. This is the position of, you know, myodities all the way down. A church is a house of of idolatry.
Speaker A
Idolatry. Yeah. So the Quran in one chapter, one surah. Okay. Both confirms the teaching of the of the of the Shama and repudiates Christianity. Okay. So the Shama is Deuteronomy 64, right? Sheldon Adonai. Here, O Israel, the Lord our
Speaker A
God, the Lord is one. Okay. The prophet like Moses predicted in 1818 of the same book, Deuteronomy, must at the bare minimum confirm this theology. If he if he doesn't, he's a false prophet. I mean, it's it's as simple as that. This
Speaker A
is non-negotiable. Okay. The mark in Jesus does quote the schma as you know in Mark 12:29 and explicitly denies being God in Mark 10:18 right when the when the man came to him and said a in the Greek uh good
Speaker A
good master what must I do to gain eternal life and he said why me do you call good there's no one good but one ha Oos the God. All right? Or in Aramaic, Allah, right? That's the word that he would
Speaker A
have used in Aramaic. Now, interestingly, Matthew and Luke, who had access to Mark, did not include these statements in their gospels. Matthew and Luke went out of their way to remove or edit these statements uh in order to make Jesus appear more
Speaker A
divine. So, so the Christian Jesus, not IsaBiam, not Yeshua, the Christian Jesus, the Jesus of Christian confession, the Jesus of the ecumenical councils is a false prophet by the standards of Deuteronomy. He did not teach God's radical oneness. Okay?
Speaker A
He called to another God himself. Uh he said things that did not come to pass and he was hanged on a tree, thus accursed according to Deuteronomy. Paul proudly embraces the latter in Galatians, right? He says Jesus became a
Speaker A
curse for us. Jesus was accursed according to Paul. I mean the Quran says the opposite that he was blessed. Right? So the Quran says he is Allah. Right? Who and so say who is Allah. And the word hua is a pronoun.
Speaker A
It means he is. Uh but it's interesting the two letters here for hua are ha and wow. And and these are the prominent letters of the tetetrogrammatin. That is often shortened in the Bible as these two letters as a hey and vav. So like
Speaker A
the name Joshua in Hebrew is Yahosua, right? That Yahweh is Yahweh is salvation, right? So this this could be um an indication that the Quran is is confirming the the shem Allah. So say he is God. He is the word
Speaker A
in the Quran is exactly the same word as in the right Allah. You know God is independent.
Speaker A
He did not beget nor was he begotten or you can say he did not generate an essential equal nor is he a generated essential equal and there's nothing comparable unto God whatsoever. So this is the entire surah surah 112 of the Quran it and it has
Speaker A
many names. One of the names of the surah is like monotheism. It's also called alsas the foundation of all religion. It's called alas sincerity right? You know, it's it's a little it's it's it's a bit funny. Christian apologists
Speaker A
constantly tell us ad nauseium that their theology is grounded in the Tanakh. That the Jesus of Christian confession was a Jewish rabbi whose message was consistent with the Tanakh.
Speaker A
The Tanakh is our foundation. The Tanakh is our You hear this a lot from them that Judaism just sort of uh I don't know, organically begot Christianity.
Speaker A
They say this over and over again, but here's the thing. Ask them if the message of the Christian Jesus was so grounded in the fundamental theology of the Tanakh, then then why did the Jewish leaders try to stone Jesus in John chapter 8? Now if
Speaker A
you say or if I say maybe they didn't like him, maybe they overreacted to some minor offense, maybe they misunderstood him, they will say no, they tried to stone him because Jesus committed blasphemy by claiming to be God. So there's a big
Speaker A
problem here. Can I can I just interject if I may? I I have the privilege of interviewing professor John Barton who's a professor of the Bible at University of Oxford. is one of these world class biblical scholars on this question and um uh of
Speaker A
Mark 10 where Jesus denies he is God uh and how Matthew for example who uses Mark uh changes the words of Jesus uh to remove uh this denial and John Barton himself said that this was dishonest of Matthew to do. Now John Barton is an
Speaker A
Anglican priest as well as a biblical scholar. the the the top scholars acknowledge this uh and use I mean he used the word dishonest. He's saying that Matthew has been dishonest in changing the words of Jesus to remove
Speaker A
Jesus's denial he was uh God. So that presumably uh what the Jesus then says is in conformity with late first century Christian theology uh that Matthew might hold. So I think that's a remarkable admission and not unique either. Um but
Speaker A
the missionaries and apologists of course will not go that far but their own scholars do go that far and they would agree with you I think.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. As you said it's it's a bit of a of a cover up a cover up of Mark.
Speaker A
It is. Yeah. That's what it is. Yeah. So you know it's it's really interesting. I mean like the Christians will say they're trying to they want to stone Jesus because he's committed blasphemy. So they want their cake and they want to
Speaker A
eat it too. So the Christian apologists are really speaking out of both sides of their mouths. Either the Christian Jesus agrees what the fundamental theology of the Tanakh or he doesn't. So you can't have it both ways. To say it another
Speaker A
way, okay, Christians believe that Jewish law revealed by God says that if a man commits blasphemy, he must be put to death. So that's what they tried to do in John chapter 8. But then Christians want to blame the Jews for
Speaker A
following their law and not accepting a man's blasphemous claims as being true. It's very it's very very strange. What's even more befuddling is that Christians believe that the person who made these blasphemous claims was the same one who
Speaker A
told the Jews in the Tanakh to kill people who commit blasphemy. You know, it it's it's a big paradox. I would say to the Christian apologists, I would I would say just admit that in reality, you are teaching a radically different
Speaker A
theology. Okay? Uh only in theory is it the God of Abraham. Okay? But in reality, one might even go so far as to say that it's a different God. I mean, and I think the Quran implies that if you believe that
Speaker A
Jesus of Nazareth, peace be upon him, was divine, then that is a different God. And Deuteronomy 13 says that even if your brother tries to entice you to worship another god, your hand shall be the first to stone him. Okay? And the
Speaker A
Christians, they say yes. This is why the Jews tried to stone him in John chapter 10. So So then why why would the Johannan Jesus expect anyone in Israel to accept his claims when he's going around committing blasphemy?
Speaker A
It doesn't make any sense. Why did he call the Jews who rightfully tried to stone him for bl According to the Christians who rightfully tried to stone him for blasphemy? Why did he call them children of Satan in John chapter 8? He
Speaker A
calls them children of Satan because they won't accept his blasphemy. You're not supposed to accept blasphemy according to Jesus who revealed the Torah according to Christians. So with with with all due respect this is this is highly with all due respect to the
Speaker A
Christians this is highly incoherent. So I actually respect like Marcon right Marc I mean I completely disagree with his views but at least Marcion was honest enough to admit the truth that the Christian Jesus and the God of the
Speaker A
Tanakh are basically irreconcilable. So Marian, just to point out to viewers who may not know, Marcian was a second century church uh Christian uh in the church, although he was ultimately expelled from the church. He basically rejected the Old Testament and much of
Speaker A
what is in the New Testament because he was quite anti-Jewish and he didn't only exist bits of Paul perhaps and didn't uh so but he he was ultimately expelled from the Orthodox church. But yeah, he he exactly as you say. Yeah. I mean, I
Speaker A
would just I would just tell the apologists just just sort of embrace your Marcianism. I mean, stop trying to tell us that three equals one and that God is a man. We need to drink his blood and you know, God became a human
Speaker A
sacrifice. So, these are beliefs that Christian apologists claim are in the Tanakh. Yes. You know, that's like one of my professors, he said it like this. That's like reading Nichze's book, The Antichrist, and concluding that Nze must have been an ordained Franciscan frier.
Speaker A
I I mean, how off the mark can you be? Is it even possible to be more wrong?
Speaker A
Again, I don't mean to disrespect the Christians that are listening, but I I really hope that they think about these things because I sincerely think that many many Christians have never really considered their own theology.
Speaker A
Okay? You know, in the Quran, we're told that Abraham asked his people like, "Have you really considered what you worship?" And Immazi, he said that this story indicates that Abraham's people committed the error of what's known as theological takological
Speaker A
ted. That's a good uh term. Tucked. In other words, they they blindly accepted what others told them about God without asking for the proofs. Okay? So, I would encourage the Christians just to ask themselves, does it make any historical
Speaker A
sense that 2,000 years ago a Jewish rabbi from Nazareth in Galilee was walking around claiming to be God?
Speaker A
That's number one. Number two, if he was walking around claiming to be God, why on earth would you believe him? Maybe their response would be, "Well, because he could work miracles, but false prophets can work miracles." According to Tanakh, according to Matthew,
Speaker A
according to Jesus and Matthew, fundamental theology is the is the sticking point. If that is off, everything is off.
Speaker A
Yeah. Okay. At least the Jews who came to believe that Deuteronomy 18:18 was a reference to the prophet Muhammad accepted an interpretation of the text that did not violate the very ground of Jewish theology. They did not maintain
Speaker A
that the Jews got it all wrong completely at the most basic level. No, the foundation is solid. Okay. The errors of Judaism according to Islam are in other areas.
Speaker A
Okay. Prophetology in particular. The Quran reprimands Judaism at some level, but it does not introduce a radically new theology that obliterates its foundations. The Quran says that Jewish scribal alterations have misguided them or deceived them with respect to aspects
Speaker A
of their religion that if they critically examine their tradition, their history, their scripture, they will come to recognize the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him as God's messenger. Okay. But let's talk about Deuteronomy now more specifically.
Speaker A
Um, so the toed of God. Yeah. Right. The yehided in Hebrew, the oneness of God, the radical uniqueness of God is established in the book of Deuteronomy like no other book of the penetuk.
Speaker A
The fundamental theology of Deuteronomy is consistent with the theology of the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. And that is the most important thing.
Speaker A
Yeah. While while the fundamental theology of Deuteronomy is antithetical to the Christian Jesus, not Isaiam, the Christian Jesus. However, according to nearly all historians, Deuteronomy was not written by Moses. So, who wrote it? It was written by a rigidly
Speaker A
monotheistic school of Jewish reformers. Okay? a Jewish school of law and theology that historians call the D school, the Deuteronomic school. Okay, I always say the D school got an A in theology, right? This was in the 8th
Speaker A
century before the common era. There is near consensus about this. Even Mossorti rabbi like conservative rabbis accept this. Many conservative rabbis accept the documentary hypothesis. They even assert that Wellhousen's, you know, redactor R or the redactor is was really
Speaker A
Rabenu. They say our Lord that this is how God chose to unfold the Torah because the evidence is just overwhelming. And for the listeners who are not familiar with this, you know, for the uninitiated, look up the documentary hypothesis of Julius Wellen.
Speaker A
Can can I can I just mention a book plug here? Um I recommend this book. Now, this is called uh Introduction to the Bible. It's by a professor called Christine Hayes. I will link to it in the description below. Now, she is a
Speaker A
professor at Yale University, a colleague of Dale Martin, who I've interviewed several times. This is an introduction to the Jewish Bible.
Speaker A
Doesn't mention the New Testament really. There's a whole chapter on Deuteronomy. I' I've read it, a discussion of the Velhausen hypothesis, the so-called documentary hypothesis.
Speaker A
This is an introductory text for first year undergraduates. Um, and I do recommend it. You can get it on Amazon if you want a more scholarly background, an introduction to all these issues as understood from a western historian's
Speaker A
perspective. Right. Um, so I personally would recommend that a readable uh introduction to the subject published by Yale University Press.
Speaker A
Yes. Yeah. Christine Hayes is is excellent. Also, uh, who wrote the there's a book called Who Wrote the Bible? Richard Elliott Freriedman. Okay, everyone everyone needs to read this book. It was published I think in 1987.
Speaker A
Muslims need to know this stuff. Now, now the Orthodox Jewish apologist, okay, uh like Rabbi Tovia Singer or Rabbi Michael Scobach, for example, this is interesting. The Orthodox Jewish apologist has a major advantage over his Christian interlocutor.
Speaker A
So, what is his what is his advantage? He knows that the Christian will not and cannot engage in any historical criticism of the Tanakh, the Old Testament. Yet he is free as a Jew to appeal to the historical consensus when
Speaker A
it comes to the New Testament. So the Jewish apologist will say to the Christian, Moses wrote Deuteronomy. And the Christian will nod his head in affirmation. But the gospel of John was written in the year 100 by an anonymous
Speaker A
hand and the Christian will shake his head in negation. But but uh so so this is a major advantage right however the uneven method of the Jewish apologist I think can be exposed by the Muslim. You know those same historians, the general
Speaker A
historical consensus that says John was written between 90 and 100 also says that Moses did not write Deuteronomy that it was written hundreds of years later. Now the Jew and the Christian, they might, you know, join forces here
Speaker A
and say, well, what about what historians say about who wrote the Quran? Okay, that's good. the the standard academic historical narrative about the the collection and codification of the Quran is still Theodore Nulay okay the history of the
Speaker A
Quran and Nulay in his second volume is basically in total agreement with the Muslim confessional narrative that the the text of the Quran was standardized by the manic committee within 15 years of the prophet by his companions immediate companions who
Speaker A
heard the Quran recited to them directly by the prophet for 23 years on a daily basis. Okay? In other words, the vast vast majority of historical scholars with the exception of some, you know, blue-haired revisionist quacks believe believe that
Speaker A
believe that the text of the Quran we have today originated with the prophet of Islam. Whether he was a prophet or not, he is the historical source of the text we read and recite today. The source and the text of the Quran is
Speaker A
multiply attested. This is never going to change. The general consensus on this is never going to change. So the Torah and the Quran are in different universes when it comes to historical criticism.
Speaker A
the old inter if readers don't want to read all these terms and learn this.
Speaker A
There's a simple way of ascertaining whether or not Deuteronomy was written by Moses and and you can do this even now you can simply open up the Bible look at the first couple of verses of Deuteronomy. Deuteronomy chapter 1 and
Speaker A
the last verses in the last verses you get Moses's own death being reported in the in the in the letter.
Speaker A
Yeah. Something tells me that Matthew Moses didn't write that chapter. At the very beginning, it says um these are the words that Moses allegedly spoke uh to all Israel beyond the Jordan in the wilderness. So, it's talking about a
Speaker A
time in the past when Moses said these things on the other side of the Jordan because Moses of course didn't reach the promised land. So um this is a future uh you know maybe hundreds of years after the Moses someone is saying well that
Speaker A
time when Moses was on that side the other side of the Jordan not the trans Jordan and of course it records his death at the very end. So it's very simple for anyone to ascertain uh that Moses couldn't have written verses that
Speaker A
refer to him in the past tense and his own death. That would be my simple test in the Bible.
Speaker A
Of course. Yeah. Yeah. And the oldest the oldest near complete Torah on earth is removed from Moses by 1500 years.
Speaker A
That's sea scrolls. Is it or Dead Sea Scrolls? Yeah. And it's not complete. So So what I'm going to say now about the Torah, okay, is the standard historical narrative of the vast vast majority of Old Testament scholars. I
Speaker A
will be speaking according to the opinion of a near consensus of historians when it comes to the Torah, Gospel, and Quran. All three, I'm going to be consistent. The near consensus is that Moses did not write Genesis, Exodus Leviticus Numbers Deuteronomy.
Speaker A
The absolute consensus is that Jesus never saw Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. The the near consensus is that Mark was written around 70, then then Matthew, then Luke, and then John around 90, 100, maybe even later. The near consensus is
Speaker A
that the entire text of the Quran we have today was first uttered by Muhammad of Arabia peace be upon him. Okay. So according to a historical near consensus the book of Deuteronomy was written about 800 years after Moses. Yet
Speaker A
throughout the book Moses is quoted by the dchool authors. So the laws of Deuteronomy were put into a framework of a speech of Moses. Okay. Technically this is called pseudapigria from from the Greek pudace and epigraph meaning false escription. This was quite
Speaker A
common practice among the Jews of that period. Okay, among the scribes. So, so this is exactly what we said about the New Testament gospels. From a Muslim perspective, Deuteronomy is not the original pristine revelation given to Moses. And history agrees with us,
Speaker A
agrees with the Muslims that Moses did not write Deuteronomy. So we would say that some of the true teachings of Moses are preserved in the text.
Speaker A
Yeah. But just as we must be discerning with the New Testament gospels, we must also be with the Torah. So the Quran, the the uncorrupted, multiplyattest original revelation of the prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, is the standard
Speaker A
against which uh Deuteronomy must be measured. And you're absolutely right. You you gave us two pieces of evidence from from Deuteronomy itself that do not support Mosaic uh uh composition, the two book ends of the of the book of
Speaker A
Deuteronomy. And these are the words which which Moses spoke to all Israel on the other side of the Jordan in the wilderness. So as you said this implies that the author was writing while on the eastern side of the Jordan. Moses never
Speaker A
crossed the Jordan. In fact Abraham Ben Ezra okay one of the greatest and most respected commentators of the Torah of the Tanakh in history suggested that someone after Moses probably wrote these words. That's Ben Ezra. That's not like
Speaker A
IB or I mean that's their own scholar. Yeah. Right. And then as you said Deuteronomy 34:5 Adonai it says and this and and Moses the servant of the Lord died right in the land of Moav. And the verb here
Speaker A
vamote is cal imperfect with vav consecutive which throws the meaning into the past. He died in the past tense. Now the rabbis and the Christians, they'll say, "Well, maybe this is the prophetic past which is sometimes used in the Bible to heighten
Speaker A
its vividness." This doesn't seem likely, especially when we read verse six. If you read two verses later, it says, "And no man knows his grave even unto this day." Until this day. So you get a sense of historical distance. Even today we still
Speaker A
even until now. Even until now we don't know where he's buried. Clearly this is not historical past in some kind of fictional way that this is the absolute past.
Speaker A
Yeah. Clearly this is someone writing much much you know Baroo Spinosa right who was excommunicated for his beliefs. He famously said something to the effect of it is clearer than the sun at noon that the penetuk was not written by Moses but
Speaker A
by someone who lived long after him. That's a that's a paric impossible on that reading for him to also don't people will know that the rest of the pent the pentituke as a whole never claims to be written by
Speaker A
Moses. It's not as if we're denying what's there in the text. It never claims to be written by Moses. So that this is like the gospels who don't claim to be written by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. So people kind of assume it's
Speaker A
claimed by him, but it's not actually. Nowhere does the pentetuk say it was written by Moses, right? No, it's it's it's taught in tradition. And and here's another important point. Jewish systematic theology was was not really born until
Speaker A
the medieval period. So that's after Islam. Okay? So like Sadia Gion and Judah Hale Levi Mymonades I mean take Mymon's 13 principles of Jewish faith for example.
Speaker A
Yeah. He wrote that in the 12th century. At least two of his principles are in direct response to Islam.
Speaker A
Yes. Okay. So if you ask an Orthodox Jew who was the greatest prophet, he'll say Moses. And if you ask him why, he'll say well my says that. If you ask a Jew why don't why don't you believe that the
Speaker A
Torah can in any way be modified or abregated? They'll say, "Well, because my monades says that." Now, a rabbi might respond to me and say, "But mymonities uses the Torah itself to support his assertions." Now, that's true, but I would offer two points.
Speaker A
Number one, we cannot ignore the fact that anti-Islamic palemics in the areas of prophetologology and scriptural preservation significantly shaped the theological discourse of Judaism. And number two, historically speaking, there is no strong evidence that Moses himself believed that he was the greatest
Speaker A
prophet or that the Torah that he received was intended to be the universal law of God until the end of time. Yes, Mymonities used did use the Torah to support his conclusions. The same Torah that was written hundreds of
Speaker A
years after Moses, not written by Moses, never seen or heard by Moses by historical consensus.
Speaker A
Now with Deuteronomy 18:18, just as we said with Isaiah 53, context is king. Okay? In order to discover the identity of the prophet like Moses, we need to study the context of Deuteronomy 18:18.
Speaker A
However, there's a challenge here. Deuteronomy 18:18 has three contexts, three of them. Okay? And this is a bit technical and I hope people can follow this. So it has a preompositional context, an original context.
Speaker A
Yeah. Because we're assuming that this tradition of the prophet like Moses originated with Moses.
Speaker A
So then it also has a compositional context at the time of its writing. Okay? And then it also has a postcompositional also known as a canonical context. This is in relation to other texts in the canon.
Speaker A
Okay. Uh so it's interesting. Muslims tend to emphasize the original context. Historians tend to emphasize its compositional context. And Jews and Christians tend to emphasize its canonical context. But let's start with the compositional context. It's compositional context. According to
Speaker A
historical scholars, Deuteronomy was most likely written in the north in Israel. Okay. As both a theological and legal reformation.
Speaker A
The authors of Deuteronomy and this is something that you mentioned Christine Hayes makes a point about that the authors of Deuteronomy the dchool believed that their version of the teachings of Moses was the correct version. They wrote it as both a
Speaker A
confirmation and a corrective just as the Quran sees itself as both a confirmation and a corrective of the purported teachings of Moses. So the original core of Deuteronomy was written in the 8th century BCE probably only chapters 12 to 26 in the north. Okay.
Speaker A
And then historians believe that the framing chapters at the beginning and the end were probably added later even as late as the exelic period. So why do historians say this? Well, the reason is because Deuteronomy has has many strong
Speaker A
affinities with prophets of the north like Hosea. uh and the Eloist, right, the author of the E source, right, who emphasized God's transcendence as opposed to the Yahwist who emphasized God's imminence and was very anthropomorphic at times.
Speaker A
Again, I highly um encourage people to to to learn the documentary hypothesis of Julius Bhausen. So, so the home, so the north was home to a struggle against the prophets of Bal, the worship of Bal, you know, the ancient Canaanite uh god
Speaker A
and and Elijah and Elisha were also in the north who were extremely staunch monotheists. And the Quran actually quotes Elijah, right? Do do you call upon Bal and you forsake Allah, the best of creators? So this this very very strong motif of
Speaker A
uncompromising monotheism uh emerged in the in the region in the north. Okay, that's the historical context of Deuteronomy's composition.
Speaker A
Now when the Assyrians conquered the northern kingdom of Israel, so this is in 7:22 before the common era, the book of Deuteronomy, scholars believe, was brought south into Judah by a remnant of Israelite refugees by northerners. Okay? And it was kept in
Speaker A
the uh the temple somewhere um and apparently lost. uh over the next hundred years or so, the Jews in Judah in the southern kingdom now seriously slipped into idolatry by mixing their beliefs with the pagan beliefs of the Canaanites. But
Speaker A
then around 6:22 or 623 during the reign of King Josiah during temple repairs, the book of Deuteronomy is suddenly discovered in the temple by the high priesty.
Speaker A
It's called Sephora. This is what the book of Deuteronomy is called in 2 Kings 22:8, the scroll of the Torah. And then this led to major theological and practical reforms throughout Judah. I mean, these reforms are described in
Speaker A
detail in 2 Kings 23. So this is the main point I want to make clear. You know what did the authors of Deuteronomy do? What did the dchool do? They revised modified cancelled and corrected the previously written covenant code. This was a different
Speaker A
version of the teachings of Moses. Okay. The covenant code would later be placed in the canon in the book of Exodus.
Speaker A
Okay. Today, Orthodox Jews believe that all of these laws were written by Moses around 1500 B.CE. Not a single historian takes this position. The dchool updated and revised previous laws especially those in the covenant code which is now
Speaker A
found in Exodus. Deuteronomy itself modifies and rewrites earlier laws in light of new circumstances. They wanted to replace the covenant code not complement it. You know, the dchool did not know that one day their writing would be placed side by side or
Speaker A
interspersed with the covenant code in a book, you know, called Exodus in a cannon. You know, they didn't know that.
Speaker A
It's kind of like the gospel of Luke. So Luke in his preamble, right? He claimed to have a perfect understanding of the story of Jesus. And yet he rejected or revised many of the stories and sayings found in Mark and Matthew. And and if he
Speaker A
heard the I am statements that would be recorded later by John, he didn't record any of those either. Maybe he didn't hear about them or maybe he didn't believe in them. But Luke meant for his gospel to be the gospel, the definitive
Speaker A
gospel, not one of a quartet. No, he didn't write this gospel expecting that one day it would be placed next to three other gospels in the in the same it's even worse than that because presumably you're right in thinking in
Speaker A
Luke thinking his gospel was the final edition that meant by implication that Mark who he used was now redundant and it was an inferior production because he corrects and amends Luke in certain ways and he adds the nativity and so on. So
Speaker A
Mark actually is is rendered obsolete by by implication of uh Luke's definitive uh you know writing for you dear Theophilus to give you that orderly account. Sorry the pre Yeah. And that's that's exactly what the the D school did. The dchool
Speaker A
the the dchool who wrote Deuteronomy wrote what they believe to be the definitive Torah the law of Moses Deuteronomy. And I'll give you three examples of how the authors of Deuteronomy revised, modified, corrected, and abregated the earlier version of the Torah written by the e
Speaker A
school, the Elohist school. First of all, why is this even important? It's it's important because according to Orthodox Judaism, no one can ever modify any of the commandments. But the irony is this is what the dchool did itself.
Speaker A
Yes. Okay. So, I'll give you an example. The first example, the authors of Deuteronomy gave us a second version of the ten commandments. There's two versions of the ten command. Deuteronomy chapter 5. They revised the ten commandments that were mentioned in
Speaker A
Exodus 20 written about a hundred years earlier by the eloist. There are substantial differences between the two.
Speaker A
Orthodox Jewish tradition has these very imaginative ways of explaining away these differences. But the truth I think is obvious. The D school was correcting what they thought was a corrupted form of the teachings teachings instruction Torah of Moses. You know, is it zakurum
Speaker A
hashbat or is it shamy hashbat? Is it is it remember the Sabbath day or keep the Sabbath day? According to orthodox authorities that this difference is substantial. These are not synonyms.
Speaker A
Okay? You know, and the rabbis really struggled with this. In in the Talmud and in the Midrashim, they say that God said both simultaneously and that Moses somehow miraculously understood both words individually. Then for whatever reason, remember was recorded in in
Speaker A
Exodus and keep was recorded in Deuteronomy. This is how they explain it. I I I don't think it's very convincing. Another example in in Exodus, it says very clearly that those places where God revealed himself can become places of sacrifice. Okay? Wherever God
Speaker A
whenever wherever a patriarch had some sort of experience with God, all you have to do is make an altar there and start sacrificing animals. That's Exodus 20:24. That's the covenant code. In Deuteronomy, these places, they're called the high places, must all be
Speaker A
destroyed. Deuteronomy mandates one centralized place for sacrifices. Okay? So, the dchool completely disagreed with the authors of the covenant code. The dchool prohibited sacrifices at these places.
Speaker A
And for this reason, King Josiah destroyed all of these altars at the high places and only permitted sacrifices to take place in Jerusalem.
Speaker A
I'll give you a third example of how Deuteronomy abregates, modifies, and cancels the previous version of the Torah. Slavery laws. In the covenant code found in Exodus, a male Hebrew slave serves his master for six years and is freed on the
Speaker A
seventh year without receiving any payment upon release. He doesn't get anything. Okay? In Deuteronomy, he serves six years. He's freed on the seventh, but he must be paid with livestock, with grain, with wine. two laws written by two different schools at
Speaker A
two different times that are at odds with one another. Okay? In the covenant code, a a Hebrew female slave is never freed by her master unless she's mistreated. She's never she's never released. In Deuteronomy, it says that she has to be treated exactly like a
Speaker A
male slave. In other words, she she'll serve for six years and then she's freed on the seventh. Totally different.
Speaker A
Deuteronomy is much nicer to women. In in the in the covenant code, it it says that if a slave wants to remain a slave, then he is brought to brought to God, it says, and his ear is pierced.
Speaker A
Meaning he's brought to the local shrine, the local altar. Okay? In Deuteronomy, he must be brought to the door, it says, meaning the door of his slave master's house, and his ear is pierced. Why the difference? because the
Speaker A
dchool is totally against these local altars. And then in Leviticus, check this out. It gets even deeper in Leviticus. So later in the sixth century before the common era, the P school, yet another school, wrote down their own law
Speaker A
code, their Jewish law code. It's called the Holiness Code. The P school disagreed with both the covenant code and the D school and abolished Hebrew on Hebrew slavery altogether. No Israelite may enslave another Israelite. So we have this evolving legislation by
Speaker A
different schools over hundreds of years. This is the general scholarly consensus. And you know what? What else that's interesting is that the author of 1 and 2 chronicles, he's called the chronicler. He as as you know, he restated the history of Israel found in
Speaker A
1 and 2 Samuel and 1 and 2 Kings. He completely disagreed with many of the stories about David that are mentioned in 1 and 2 Samuel.
Speaker A
Yeah. David and Bsheba not there. The murder of Uriah not there. two different schools of history and theology.
Speaker A
Yeah. You know, and that's quite similar to the Islamic understanding because the other understanding has David as a as a criminal, adulterer, a murderer. Uh but the Chronicles has a very different portrayal and and they they sit very
Speaker A
uneasily together in the same scripture, right? That's Yeah. So, so the main point here, and I'll get back to the prophet like Moses, the laws of Deuteronomy were meant to replace the old covenant code laws. The mistake, with all due respect, the mistake of
Speaker A
many of the Orthodox Jews is that they maintain that all of these laws, all of these mitzvot were revealed to Moses on Sinai during those 40 nights or even during the 40 years.
Speaker A
Yeah. And that they're all somehow binding even though they clearly contradict and many of them are obsolete. The Orthodox say that unless the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him confirms all of these 613 mitzvot then he cannot be a prophet
Speaker A
for the Israelites. Okay. uh some medieval rabbis. There was a 12th century medieval rabbi, a Yemenite rabbi, Rabbi uh Nathaniel Alai, his book is called Garden of the Intellects Alul. It's called Gan Ganim or something like that uh in Hebrew. He
Speaker A
says in that book that the prophet Muhammad was a navi emit, a true prophet, but sent to the goim only. He's only sent to Gentiles, not the Yehudim, because he did not confirm all 613 mitzvot. He considers that sort of a
Speaker A
deal breakaker. However, other scholars, Shamuel ben Yehuda al-Mi, okay, Shamuel ben Yehuda al- Mi who was a Jewish scholar turned Muslim, converted to Islam, he argues in his book is called if yahood, the confounding of the Jews. He says
Speaker A
that it would have been impossible impossible for the prophet Muhammad to confirm all 613 mitzvot because many of them deal with the temple, the priesthood and the sacrifices. None of these three things existed at the prophet's time.
Speaker A
So abrogation cannot be denied. It is a reality. I'll give you an example. Mitzvah number 380. So 613 commandments number 380 and this is according to the numbering of my monodities. What does number 380 say? It says the priests, the
Speaker A
kohanim must carry the ark of the covenant, the aron habirit on their shoulders. Well, there's no ark and there's no priesthood. Even the orthodox admit, I mean, go to like, you know, kabad.org, right? There are articles on this. They admit that almost half of the
Speaker A
613 mitzvote have no application today. Yeah. In other words, half of the mitzvot were de facto abregated as a circumstance of history. The we would say the of Allah the the the will of God his in effect abregated almost half of the
Speaker A
mitzvot. In other words, God saw it fit for those mitzvot to be rendered obsolete. And this, in my opinion, is strong circumstantial evidence that God did not intend for the Torah to be the last and universal sacred law. Of
Speaker A
course, the Jewish response to this is, well, when the Messiah comes, he'll restore all 613 laws. Okay, that's fine.
Speaker A
But that that would mean that for the vast vast majority of Jewish history, almost half of the mitzvote had no application. That doesn't make sense.
Speaker A
That sounds like wishful thinking. Now, now Orthodox Jews also believe in something called Gilgula.
Speaker A
Gilgula, literally the rolling of the soul. A lot of people don't know this. This is reincarnation, metam psychosis. Okay. Most of them say, however, that this is only limited uh to people who died as children and therefore never um sort of had the
Speaker A
opportunity to choose good or evil. Okay. However, some Orthodox teach that in order to enter the Olam Habah, the world to come, a Jew must complete a substantial amount of the commandments and that this could take several lifetimes because there are so many
Speaker A
commandments. Mymonities is actually silent on this issue of of uh reincarnation. You know, Sadia vehemently rejects it. He thinks that reincarnation was a deviant belief that infiltrated Judaism from pagans.
Speaker A
Interestingly, the Quran even intimates that many laws of the Jews were invented by the Jews themselves and that this created this huge burden for them. In that same verse at the beginning of the session 7157, right, those who follow the messenger,
Speaker A
the unlettered prophet, the Quran says that the prophet Muhammad relieves them of their burdens and the shackles that are upon them. It's just a beautiful verse. Imam Zamaki, he says that this is a reference to the Jewish law and that
Speaker A
the Quran strips away many of those invented self-imposed commandments. Now, here's something ironic, though. The authors of Deuteronomy, they said in Deuteronomy chapter 4 and chapter 13 that Moses commanded the Israelites to not add or delete anything from the law. Okay? And
Speaker A
this is cited by the Orthodox as the reason for their rejection of Jesus and Muhammad peace be upon him because Jesus and Muhammad they modified they updated they abregated certain commandments. But but the question is the historical question is why did the authors of
Speaker A
Deuteronomy say this? And there are two reasons that I can think of. And this is pointed out by Moshe Weinfeld and Bernard Levenson. These are um you know eminent scholars of Jewish studies. They contributed to the Jewish study bible,
Speaker A
the Oxford study bible. Weinfeld was a highly respected professor of Judaism uh at at Hebrew University uh in in Jerusalem. So they say that the book of Deuteronomy was clearly modeled upon the ancient Assyrian vassel treaty. Okay.
Speaker A
The best examples of these treaties u are the treaties of the Assyrian emperor Esrar Haden discovered about 60 years ago. So this is quite recent. There is incredible correspondence in content and phrasiology and style to these Assyrian vassel treaties. for example, laws
Speaker A
reinforced by curses, but also this nonalteration clause, right? Do not add or delete anything. It's a it's a common feature in ancient Neareastern literature. We find it in ancient law codes, the the code of Hammurabi, uh the Hittite uh treaties. The authors of
Speaker A
Deuteronomy said this because that was a basic feature of these ancient vassal loyalty treaties. Okay, so Deuteronomy is clearly an eighth or 7th century document. But the second reason why the dchool said this is because they believed that scribes from other schools
Speaker A
had falsified the Torah. That's why they wrote Deuteronomy. What does Deuteronomy mean? Deuteros Nomos, a second law, a second version of the law. Right? They were telling these other schools in effect, stop adding and deleting from the law or else God will curse you. And
Speaker A
of course, the other schools would say the same thing to the D school. Now, what's interesting is the the book of Jeremiah is very closely tied to Deuteronomy. Okay, the book of Jeremiah uses the text, the language, the the
Speaker A
themes, the theology of of of Deuteronomy very explicitly. It's a different author, but he adopted the dchool positions. The author of Jeremiah also agreed with the dchool that certain scribes from other schools had falsified the Torah of Moses, the teachings of
Speaker A
Moses. Jeremiah 8:8, what does it say? How can you say we are wise because we have the law of the Lord? The Torah Adon Adonai. How can you say we are wise?
Speaker A
because we have the law of the Lord. For indeed the false pen of the scribes have turned it into a lie. Jeremiah 8:8. Now both Jews and Christians will say, "No, no, no. This means that the the pen of
Speaker A
the scribes have labored in vain because the word sheer in Hebrew could mean to be in vain." Now that's true. But the vast majority of the time in the Bible, sheer means lie, deception, falsehood, fraud, and forgery. You just go to a
Speaker A
concordance. It's in Exodus. It's in Deuteronomy. It's in Proverbs. But also in Jeremiah's own usage several times, right? I mean at one point for instance Jeremiah he warns the Jewish captives about false prophets who prophesy lies to you in my name.
Speaker A
He says can I just um just add in the NI NRSV which as I say before is the the standard the gold standard in academic uh studies of the the Bible when it's read in English that is uh on this verse
Speaker A
uh this is Jeremiah 88 it says how can you say we are wise and the law of the Lord is with us when in fact the false pen of the scribes has made it into a lie. So that's backing up precisely your
Speaker A
position and this ironically is a Christian translation is a particularly it's usually seen as a very fair and objective and scholarly one. So yeah according to that it's a lie as you said.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. So very clearly here Jeremiah is reprimanding certain scribes who did in fact corrupt the text of the Torah with their false writings with their a sheer literally their their false pen.
Speaker A
So the plain truth is that this verse indicates a textual alteration of the Torah did occur prior to Jeremiah's time and that such alterations were significant and widespread enough to warrant a prophetic reprimand. So Jeremiah is probably talking about the
Speaker A
covenant code uh that later made it into the Bible, the Bible cannon, right? It's probably he's probably talking about what Deuteronomy was was correcting the covenant code that made it in Exodus.
Speaker A
Okay. So going back now to the prophet of 1818. Who is the prophet of 1818? Now so I've sort of laid the groundwork according to its compositional context.
Speaker A
Okay. So according to uh the dchool in the 8th century, he will be a prophet of uncompromising monotheism like Moses. He will only speak according to inspiration.
Speaker A
He will be from the brethren of the Israelites. Furthermore, it seems that he will punish the Jews who slipped into disbelief, false worship. Uh in this case, the worship of Bal like like Moses who punished the Israelites for
Speaker A
worshiping the golden calf. This is intimated by the next verse 18:19. And whosoever shall not hearken unto his words that he shall speak in my name, I shall require it of him or I shall take vengeance of him in the in the Catholic
Speaker A
version. Finally, it seems that he will be an Israelite. Okay, so Deuteronomy 34 indicates this which is the dchool talking by way of commentary suggesting that he will be an Israelite who is yet to come. Okay, so by the 8th century
Speaker A
before the common era, he has not yet come. Right? So like Deuteronomy 34:10 it says and there has not yet risen a prophet in Israel like Moses. So the dchool authors they don't propose any specific names.
Speaker A
In 349 of Deuteronomy you can argue that the authors sort of seem to indicate Joshua but in the very next verse they say that a prophet like Moses has yet to rise in Israel. So it seems to me that
Speaker A
the authors were saying that Joshua was the leader of the Israelites after Moses, but not the prophet like Moses.
Speaker A
He's not the prophet like Moses. Okay. So they wrote that Joshua had which means wisdom. He's usually associated with sages. Uh but they don't mention Nauva. They don't say he was a Navi, right?
Speaker A
He didn't give law to people. He wasn't a prophet in not a prophet. Yeah. So according to the compositional context, the prophet like Moses will be a great prophet of monotheism who like Moses will have a special relationship with God. And it
Speaker A
appears that he will be an Israelite. However, again, remember that many scholars believe that chapter 34 of Deuteronomy was added much later. So that's another piece to all this. Now, at this point, the Christian apologist is jubilant, right? Aha, you see it's
Speaker A
Jesus. Uh but the Christian Jesus taught his own deity and co-equality with two other persons who are also God. This is blasphemy according to Deuteronomy. And Christians admit that it's blasphemy according to Deuteronomy. So So that's the that's the compositional context.
Speaker A
Now let's look at the canonical context of Deuteronomy. Okay. So in other words, it's postcompositional context. Okay. So when when the pentetuk, okay, when the five scrolls, when the Torah, the humash were being put together in the sixth
Speaker A
century before the common era, the the redactor, the one who did this, probably Ezra and probably commissioned by the Persians, he placed Deuteronomy fifth after Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers. Right? So he did this because Deuteronomy included a restatement of
Speaker A
many of the laws and stories found in the previous four books, the previous tetratuk, Genesis to Numbers. Um and again this is why Deuteronomy is called the second law. So, so in its in its canonical context, Deuteronomy was a
Speaker A
bridge really. It's a bridge linking the tetrou genesis to numbers with the deuteronomistic history which is Joshua to second kings. So, it's both a conclusion to the tetetroque as well as an introduction to what's known as the dehistory.
Speaker A
Okay, which is Joshua to second kings. Now according to Martin no and this is the standard historical view the books Joshua to second kings called the dehistory was written by one author right the deuteronomistic historian we just we'll call him the deh historian
Speaker A
and he finished working around the time of the exile and he like the author of Jeremiah also adhered to the theology the history and the laws of Deuteronomy that's why he's called the dehistorian okay so according to the dehisto
Speaker A
historian. The prophet like Moses was Joshua. Okay. The dehistorian wrote in the book of Joshua chapter 1 that God said to Moses.
Speaker A
Just as I was with Moses, I will be with you. According to the dehistorian, the prophet like Moses was Joshua. That was his opinion. But there are other opinions. As I said, the book of Jeremiah is very closely tied to
Speaker A
Deuteronomy. The author of Jeremiah thought that the prophet like Moses was Jeremiah. The author of the book of Jeremiah said that Jeremiah said Adonai that the Lord said unto me indeed behold I will put my words in your mouth. So
Speaker A
you see the literary parallel to Deuteronomy 18:18. According to the author of Jeremiah, the prophet like Moses was Jeremiah. That was his opinion. So when it comes to the canonical context of Deuteronomy 18:18, there's a difference of opinion as to
Speaker A
who he is. According to the dehistorian, he's Joshua. According to the author of Jeremiah, he's Jeremiah. This is why the rabbis have said either Joshua or Jeremiah. They're operating under the canonical context of Deuteronomy 18:18.
Speaker A
They believe that all of these books were inspired by God and are therefore seamlessly coherent. So they believe that when God spoke to Moses, he intended to describe either Joshua or Jeremiah. There's a difference of opinion. Then when God spoke to or about
Speaker A
Joshua or Jeremiah, he identified one of them as being the prophet like Moses. So Baha Ibin Pakuda, one of the most famous systematic theologians of the medieval period, he his opinion is that the prophet like Moses is Joshua.
Speaker A
Okay. So he he agrees with the dehistorian. But then realizing that there are other candidates like Jeremiah, he says, well, the word Nav'vi in Deuteronomy 18:18, the word a prophet can also be understood as a plural, right? So, Rabbi
Speaker A
Ra Michael of Jews for Judaism, he says something similar. He says that Deuteronomy 18:18 could apply to multiple prophets after Moses, but the word is clearly singular. Now unfortunately for the Christian okay he the Christian is left in a very very
Speaker A
difficult situation the Christian also believes that all of these books were inspired by God and therefore seamlessly coherent.
Speaker A
Okay. However the Christian is forced to deny the opinion of the dehistorian as well as the opinion of the author of Jeremiah. Yet the Christian still believes that all of these books were inspired by God. Again, a very
Speaker A
paradoxical situation. The Christian believes that the books of Joshua and Jeremiah were inspired by God, but they were both wrong about who they thought was the prophet like Moses. Why is the Christian forced into this position?
Speaker A
Because Luke tells us in Acts that Peter explicitly identified Jesus as the prophet like Moses. Okay? Matthew clearly believed that Jesus was the prophet like Moses as well. Matthew went out of his way, way out of his way to
Speaker A
present Jesus as being the new Moses. Matthew even divided his gospel into five discourses to mimic the penetuk humash. Okay, so that's the that's the Christian dilemma. Now, what about the precompositional context? So, we dealt with the compositional context, okay,
Speaker A
which is kind of a big question mark. We dealt with the um the um canonical context and we said either Jeremiah or Joshua. What about the precompositional the original context of 1818 Deuteronomy? This is we're kind of coming to a a climax here. As I said
Speaker A
earlier, we don't know for certain who Moses, peace be upon him, was talking about. We can only look at circumstantial evidence.
Speaker A
But first, even though the prophecy says, okay, from their brethren, this does not mean, okay, this does not mean that uh this does not limit the candidates to Israelites.
Speaker A
Okay, even the dchool refer to the the descendants of Esau, as being the brethren of the Israelites.
Speaker A
They say that in Deuteronomy 23:7 because Esau was the brother of Jacob. Even Baha even pakuda mentions this. So Jacob's father was Isaac and Isaac's brother was Ishmael and Ishmael was the ancestor of the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam. Ultimately
Speaker A
though Baha says that the prophecy he he he ultimately says that prophecy that no that prophecy in general is only for Israel only for the Jewish people as is also the resurrection of the dead according to him. only Jews can be
Speaker A
prophets and only Jews are resurrected by God. Right? Such ethnic exclusivity. The Tanakh and Talmud, however, mention several non-Jewish prophets, including Adam and Noah, although there is a difference of opinion whether they're prophets. Um, Rashi did not consider them prophets. Many rabbitical
Speaker A
authorities did, and they're they're non-Jewish. but also Job, the prophet Job. Let's not forget Abraham, Lot, and Isaac. Not Jewish. Abraham, not Jewish.
Speaker A
Mana Ibraim the Quran says Abraham was not a Jew or a Christian. Uh, the first person in the entire Torah who is explicitly called a prophet and Nave was Abraham. And the Jewish people refer to Abraham as Abraham Ainu. Abraham our father or
Speaker A
Abraham our lege lord a non-Jew so prophecy is only for the Jewish people while one of the greatest prophets of all time was not Jewish systematic Jewish theologians after Islam decided that only Jews could be prophets sounds very strange but also in Genesis
Speaker A
16:12 okay Genesis 16:12 this is written Yahweh. So this is the J school around 1 B.CE. It says about Ishmael. And by the way, this verse is highly derogatory about Ishmael, but it does reveal something interesting as to how the
Speaker A
ancient Israelites viewed themselves in relation to the IshRaelites. So the end of the verse says about Ishmael, it says, right, that he shall dwell, Ishmael shall dwell in the presence of all his brethren. Or another translation, he shall dwell over against all his
Speaker A
brethren. Or another translation, he shall dwell to the east of his brethren. And and biblical commentators say that brethren here refers to the Israelites.
Speaker A
that the Yahwist refers to the Israelites as the brethren of Ishmael explicitly and Mymones refers to the prophet. How do you know the prophet is a descendant of of of Ishmael?
Speaker A
Mymonades refers to the prophet Muhammad as a as a in the Mishna Torah, an Ishelite. This is just something that is is common knowledge. Now another thing Christians claim that the prophet like Moses is Jesus peace be upon him as we
Speaker A
said because Luke says this explicitly uh but the as we would say so the the reason why the Israelites were given the promise of this prophet like Moses is actually given in Deuteronomy 18:16 so two verses earlier and this reason
Speaker A
completely deflates the Christian claim I mean completely deflates it. So verse 16, the Israelites cry to Moses and they request something from him. What do they say? The Hebrew says it says uh that that let us no longer hear the
Speaker A
voice of the Lord our God. Okay. And it continues nor see this great fire or we will die. So hearing the voice of the Lord directly from the Lord was too much for them.
Speaker A
Yeah. Okay. Now in verse 17, what does it say? It says Adonai vu aeru.
Speaker A
And the Lord said to me, Moses saying, the Lord said to me, they have spoken well or what they said is good. What they said is right. In other words, God accepted their request.
Speaker A
Therefore, the next verse says, "A prophet I will raise up for them from the midst of their brethren like you, and I'll put my words in his mouth, and he will speak to them everything that I command him." So, the prophecy is given
Speaker A
as an acceptance to the prayer of the Israelites. So the prophet like Moses will speak to God face to face like Moses. But the Israelites will hear the voice of the Lord the Adonai through him through this prophet. The Adonai will be
Speaker A
in his mouth. They will not hear directly from the Lord. However, the Christian Jesus is the Lord. According to Christians, verses 16- 18 tell us that the prophet like Moses is not the Lord explicitly. He is a mouthpiece of
Speaker A
the Lord. That's the whole reason for the coming of this prophet. So again, Christians here, they want it both ways, but they want they want their cake and they want to eat it too. They want Jesus to be the prophet like Moses, but they
Speaker A
also want him to be God. The prophet like Moses is not God. Okay, but let's think about Moses for a moment here.
Speaker A
Moses, peace be upon him, and I'm coming down to the end here, was a Moses, peace be upon him, was a champion prophet of monotheism.
Speaker A
Okay, he sort of um like restored monotheism after there was a falling away. He was the founder of a nation, a religion, and an empire. He brought his people out from a very low state physically, spiritually, and mentally to
Speaker A
a very high state. He migrated with his people and God protected him with miracles during his migration.
Speaker A
He was a father, a husband. He was the head of state. He was a warrior. He was a judge. He was a teacher. God spoke to him panim al panim face to face. Meaning he was beloved to God. And and God gave
Speaker A
him his very words, right? The ipsisma verba, not just inspiration with which to form his own words, but God's very words. He was given a law code with which to govern his people. So everything I just said about Moses also
Speaker A
applies to the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and nobody else. Nobody else in history. What I just said about Moses can be applied to the prophet Muhammad and nobody else. In fact, the prophet pe the prophet Moses peace be upon him.
Speaker A
What the prophet Moses did on a small scale, the prophet of Islam did on a titanic scale. The prophet Muhammad is the greatest prophet ever. He's the most successful monotheist of all time. Hands down.
Speaker A
He he has sent to all mankind of course whereas Moses was sent to a particular tribe and and had pretend to been sent to anyone else. So yeah, he had a global reach and that is unique. Yeah.
Speaker A
Exactly. There are Muslims who sayahillah in every country in the world who who live in every country except the Vatican. He He's the prophet of the Abrahamic restoration. He's the vindicator of Jesus Christ and James the Just. He he refined and universalized
Speaker A
the teachings of the teachings of Moses to such an exquisite perfection that it appeals to every race on earth. He vindicated his ancestor Ishmael, the son of Abraham. And he also vindicated like the prophet Jacob, the Israelite prophets, clearing them of the
Speaker A
monstrosities that were uttered against them by the Israelites themselves. Okay. Now, now a common Jewish objection to this Muslim claim is exactly what my monities and baha say in their commentaries that any prophet who permanently abregates any of the 613
Speaker A
commandments of the Torah is a false prophet. He's a navisher. He's not a nie. He's a false prophet, not a true prophet. But that is exactly what the D school did. They modified, refined, and permanently abregated aspects of the
Speaker A
covenant code written a century earlier. As I said, this idea that no one can ever add or delete any laws has its origins in pre-biblical vassal treaties and it was used as a pmical tool by the dchool to condemn to
Speaker A
condemn basically what they believed their theological and rival uh legal rivals had done. The authors of Deuteronomy, right, the dchool wanted their version of the law to be final and immutable. This was a school of law and theology that was in competition with
Speaker A
other schools. Okay. And there there are two verses of the Quran I want to quickly just quote that give us more clarity I think when it comes to what the Quran is doing with the law of Moses. Okay. So the first one is 4610. I
Speaker A
quoted 46 uh sorry 4612. I quoted 4610 earlier that the prophet Moses he bears witness to one like him. Two verses later, it says 46:12. Now, and in the past before this, the book of Moses was a guide and a mercy. And this
Speaker A
book confirms it in the Arabic language in order to warn those who do wrong and give glad tidings to the doers of good.
Speaker A
So that's one verse. The second verse is 7 145 verse 145. So, and we wrote for him, Moses, in the tablets an exhortation concerning all things and an elaboration of all things.
Speaker A
So, hold fast to them and command your people to follow the best of them. Now, in the latter verse, notice the word tablets is in the plural. It's not it's not dual, right? Not just two tablets. The Quran
Speaker A
says at least three. Some of the exigits say seven or 10 tablets. Okay. So, the verse says that the tablets, the original law of Moses contained an exhortation and an elaboration concerning all things, all things, everything they needed to know.
Speaker A
So, it seems to me that the Quran is saying that it confirms all of the um what's known as the apodictic laws of the prototype Torah, the Kab Musa.
Speaker A
Apodictic laws are absolute general commands. Okay. The latter verse commands the Israelites to apply these principles in the best way in the most beautiful way because as as we know both the saint and the terrorist applied to sacred law right law on the other hand
Speaker A
also known as casuistic law scenario law is time constrained but based upon some apodictic principle. So, the last time I checked, we don't have an ox goring problem. You know, like the covenant code of Moses, uh, the and also
Speaker A
Deuteronomy, the code of Hammurabi, they have all of these casuistic laws about goring oxen. I don't know how many times your your neighbor's ox has tried to gore you, but that that's probably not that common, right? That specific law
Speaker A
pretty rare these days. Yeah. Yeah. That that's that's that specific law is obsolete. Maybe unless by analogy it's like a runaway lawn mower or something, but probably not. But the principle behind that law, okay, is transhistorical and immutable. So the
Speaker A
Quran confirms all of the apodictic laws of Moses, the original, the actual original revelation given to Moses. The Quran is a madic in a confirmer in that sense. But individual casuistic laws or statutes, okay, these are subject to change.
Speaker A
They're mutable because conditions change over time. Sacred law is progressive in that sense. Although I I know that the word progressive is a very loaded term nowadays. Today, progressive means that you believe in endless genders and madeup pronouns, right? This assault on
Speaker A
tradition and language and science. But that's what I'm talking about. I I would contend that all of the original Torah's apodictic laws are confirmed in the Quran such as, you know, prohibitions against murder, theft, adultery, drinking blood, eating pork, sodomy, but
Speaker A
also general prescriptions uh to establish prayer, to fast, to give charity. Right? That verse said Musa, right? It said the book of Moses, right?
Speaker A
It didn't say a Torah or something. It's a book, the actual Torah of Moses, right? So, the language here is is very important. I would also add that, you know, since the Quran is the is the final revelation,
Speaker A
it also contains probably a few new universal laws that are unique to it, you know, such as alcohol consumption, although perhaps the Kab Musa, the original law of Moses, also contain that uh prohibition.
Speaker A
And and then I'll also mention a couple more verses here. So chapter 26 this is uh chapter 20 surah 26 verse 196 and 197 okay and I and I'll sort of end with this it says that indeed it or he it could be the
Speaker A
prophet indeed the prophet is in the ancient scriptures and then it says is it not a sign for them that the scholars of the Israelites meaning the Jews knew it as true okay or knew knew him as being a true prophet. Now now
Speaker A
these verses are mechan okay this is surah 2 a mechan surah so the Quran is referring to the pagans of the Qur saying that already some Jewish scholars have recognized the prophet Muhammad. You see, the Jews in Ythreb, which would become Medina, had
Speaker A
heard of the prophet, and many other scholars had converted to Islam before the prophet even got there. And the Quraysh knew about this because they were corresponding with the Jewish community in Ythre. And the Quran is saying, "Isn't that a sign for you?" So,
Speaker A
some of this is important. I think this is very important that some of the earliest converts to Islam were learned Jewish men. This is very important. They did not find the prophet's uh race or his law, you know, to be hindrances. On
Speaker A
the contrary, they saw him as really a fulfillment of prophecy. Okay? Uh and that's why they converted.
Speaker A
Um now, now maybe maybe I'll mention this as as a as a last point. Um there there's there's one popular Christian contention that I think I should probably respond to. Um because Christians Christian apologists are always bringing this up.
Speaker A
Um so so Christian apologists contend that the prophet like Moses, okay, um cannot be the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him because the prophet apparently violates Deuteronomy 18:20.
Speaker A
Okay. So, so just as I said that the Christian Jesus, the Christian Jesus violates Deuteronomy 18:16, Christian apologists will tell me the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him violates Deuteronomy 18:20. So, what does Deuteronomy 18:20 say? It says, "But the
Speaker A
prophet who presumes to speak a word in my name which I have not commanded him or who speaks in the name of other gods, that prophet shall die." Okay. So, what are they talking about with this verse?
Speaker A
They're talking about the story of the satanic verses, right? Of course. So, this was a phrase that was coined by, you know, Scottish orientalist William Mure. Muslim scholars refer to it as or something like that. But, but as you
Speaker A
know, Christian, Christian apologists, they love this story, right? They think it's the greatest thing since theions, right? They think they think it's the greatest thing since slice sliced bread at holy communion.
Speaker A
So as the as the story goes and there and there are multiple contradictory versions of this story.
Speaker A
Yeah. You know when when the prophet was in he was reciting and he recited have you not seen these three and these were considered to be goddesses among the the pagans. And then Satan apparently whispered two false verses to
Speaker A
the prophet which he thought were divine revelation. Um eventually the prophet, the Muslims and all of the idolattors prostrated.
Speaker A
Word then spread that the prophet had compromised with the idolattors and everything just sort of got along. But then Gabriel informed the prophet of And those verses were removed from the Quran. So that's sort of the basic story. Now Christians, they point out
Speaker A
that this story of the satanic verses, it must be true because it fulfills the criterion of embarrassment, right? They say, "Why would a Muslim invent this story? Why would a Muslim invent a story that embarrasses the prophet? It must be
Speaker A
true." So I personally agree with Imm Razi about this story. Okay. So, Imm Razi, he said that this story not only clashes with the Quran and the Sunnah, but also clashes with reason. Uh, Carl Ernst, uh, who wrote a book called How
Speaker A
to Read the Quran, he's professor of Islamic Studies at Chapel Hill, he also rejects this story on strictly historical and literary grounds. He's not Muslim.
Speaker A
A very flimsy basis for the history. Yeah. But but here's here's here's my uh here's my response. Uh first of all, the the criterion of embarrassment is the weakest of the criteria of modern historioggraphy. So we shouldn't really
Speaker A
overemphasize it. And I know that uh Jonathan Brown, as as you pointed out, uh makes that point in one of your videos. Um uh he makes that point in his in his introductory book about the prophet peace be upon him. Now, why
Speaker A
would a Muslim make them? Muslims fabricated hundreds and hundreds of hadith. Okay, Ibenu Josie he actually collected he has a book called right the book of fabricated hadith who fabricated these hadith Jews Christians no Muslims Muslims in the past foisted
Speaker A
lies upon the prophet this is a fact it's a sad fact but it's a fact why did they do this for various reasons people wanted to justify their own theological or political positions people wanted to justify their immoral behavior for
Speaker A
selfish reasons. Muslims in positions of power wanted to keep their power at at all costs. Power corrupts. You know, people had weak faith or no faith. There have always been hypocrites. Muslims fabricated hadith that made the prophet look bad. They made him look like a
Speaker A
racist. At least they tried to do that. They did this for their own selfish reasons. They wanted to justify their practice of cattle slavery, for instance. I mean, we can flip the tables on the Christian here or ask a Christian
Speaker A
who wrote the infancy Gospel of Thomas and they'll say heretics. Well, what was their religion? They were Christian. Why did the Christian authors of the infancy gospel of Thomas write that Jesus as a child killed another child and then
Speaker A
murdered one of his teachers? According to the criterion of embarrassment, this must be true. I mean, why would a Christian invent this story, right? So, I think they would get the point. But but but secondly, in the eyes of the
Speaker A
people who actually fabricated this particular story, did it really make the prophet look bad? Was it really embarrassing in their eyes?
Speaker A
Exactly. Maybe not. I personally don't have a problem with one or the other, but I don't think it's historical because I understand it's flimsy. But what it shows is that that God through his through the angel Gabriel protected the
Speaker A
prophet from Satan's satanic attack. Um so it actually confirms the authenticity of his mission because he was protected from Satan. So for me it's not a problem either way. Only if you it tendentious way to make a political point. Yeah.
Speaker A
Problem. as another way of looking at it and to see it actually as a confirmation of the prophethood because Gabriel intervened and and sorted this out.
Speaker A
Yeah. And that's that's Iben Tamia's position and and it's and it's a respectable position, right?
Speaker A
So yeah, on the contrary, maybe for the people who invented the story, the story demonstrated that God rescued the prophet and the believers from the vile of from the vials of the devil. And the story also had an exogetical purpose. I
Speaker A
mean it it explained chapter 22:52 of the Quran. This idea that you know God cancels out what Satan throws in. So there were strong theological motivations for fabricating the story.
Speaker A
It provided a subabun for 2252 as well as justified this type of intraquranic nusk or abrogation. So it served a hermeneutical purpose. So, but one might ask, okay, what does 2252 mean then when it says God cancels out what
Speaker A
Satan throws in? Was it uh what is it referring to if not the satanic versus incident? Well, according to Immazi, this just means that the prophets are human beings. They're not angels. They have emotions and that they're not
Speaker A
impervious to temptation. Yet, with God's help, they're able to overcome their temptations. So nusk in this verse is used in the linguistic sense of removing or wiping something away, not in the technical sense of a verse abregating another verse. But even with
Speaker A
this said, the story doesn't make historical sense. It it clashes with reason and logic. For one thing, it says that 2252 abregated these so-called satanic verses. This is very strange. Why is it strange? a bit ridiculous because 2252
Speaker A
was revealed in Medina many years later. So were the Muslims praying to Alat and als Manat for many years? These false verses were being recited by the prophet and the companions for eight years. Of course not. This is nonsense. Secondly,
Speaker A
and Dr. Dr. Shabir Ali he as well as some of the study Quran commentators point this out that if the prophet said that it that it was okay to pray to these goddesses then that would have been the end of his prophetic career. I
Speaker A
mean he would have lost all credibility in in the eyes of both his followers and enemies. And we can actually I think demonstrate uh what the fabricator of the story did. He took the historical kernel of this story and he altered it
Speaker A
in order to give the appearance of truth. So there is a hadith in Bkari that says the prophet recited surah Najim and then he prostrated and the Muslims prostrated and the idoltors prostrated but it says nothing about Satan or satanic verses or you know
Speaker A
these are the high-flying cranes whose intercession is to be sought. It just says everyone prostrated. Okay, so the obvious subtext is that the idolattors were overcome with awe at the beauty of the prophet's recitation and so they prostrated when the prophet did. That's
Speaker A
it. But what about what about textual criticism? Right? So were these verses really part of the Quran? So so textual critics look at both external and internal evidence. And I'll just give you a quick example from the New
Speaker A
Testament. Luke 22:44. Okay, it says, "And being in agony, he meaning Jesus prayed more earnestly and his sweat was as if great drops of blood falling down on the ground." Yeah.
Speaker A
When we look at the external evidence, that is the manuscript evidence, the manuscript witnesses for this verse, we notice that the earliest manuscripts of Luke do not contain this verse. P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P69 P75
Speaker A
they don't contain this verse. Okay, internal evidence looks at both the Christology of Luke as well as Luke's style and choice of words. Okay, the Luke in Jesus is basically a stoic philosopher. I mean, he's always in control of his emotions. Aramman calls
Speaker A
him imperturbable, right? He can't be bothered by anything. Even on on route to the crucifixion, he's having this lucid conversation with with women, you know, don't weep for me, weep for yourselves. There's no cry of dereliction in the gospel of Luke. There
Speaker A
isn't no father um my God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? It's not there, right? Even though Luke had Mark Mark in front of him in Luke, you know, father, into your hands I commend my spirit.
Speaker A
He's always in control. So Luke 22:44 conflicts with the Luke and Jesus's personality. That's one thing. Secondly, this verse interrupts a kayazm in the compositional structure of Luke's narrative, right?
Speaker A
Which is really interesting. Thirdly, this verse contains multiple hypoxamoi, like words that do not appear anywhere else in Luke's gospel. So that's a good indicator of a secondhand writing these verses.
Speaker A
Okay. So, both external and internal evidence support the exclusion of this verse. And fourthly, I I'll add this verse served a specific theological purpose. Luke's gospel was beloved to the Gnostics like Marcion, many of whom did not believe that Jesus had a an
Speaker A
actual physical body. So, this verse was added by the protoorthodox to prove that Jesus did have a physical body. He's sweating blood, right? just just interrupt there a second. Uh Bman has written uh a scholarly work called the orthodox
Speaker A
corruption of scripture. It's an investigation into the uh the scribal alterations that were made to the uh the manuscript tradition. And the particular example you mentioned is certainly discussed in in detail and and with that very point. If we just want to uh
Speaker A
explore this further, I do recommend bar it's called the orthodox corruption of scripture. It gives many examples of where later Christian scribes have altered the text of the New Testament.
Speaker A
Um, and we can show this either to further a more so-called orthodox theology or other agendas, adoptionist or patriionist or whatever. So, the text has constantly been fought over by different scribes throughout the centuries. So, we're altering it and
Speaker A
changing it again and again and again. But, but you're right. This this is a good example that Bart Urban also brings up.
Speaker A
Yeah. But now, if we if we apply Yeah. And that's an excellent book, the orthodox scripture in scripture. And if that proves to be too robust, then he did like a simpler sort of dummies version of it called um misquing Jesus.
Speaker A
Yeah, the is an academic work I think meant for other scholars, but you it's readable. You're right. He did a more popular work called I think it's a different type in America than it has in the UK actually.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. So, so what if we applied then uh textual criticism to the satanic verses like I just did to the Gospel of Luke.
Speaker A
And I'll I'll end with this. With respect to external evidence, there are zero manuscripts of the Quran that contain these verses, the satanic verses. You can count them on no hands.
Speaker A
There are zeroat of the Quran that contain these verses. So, these verses get an F. They fail miserably when it comes to external evidence. And Bruce Mezer would give them an F. What What about internal evidence? Do these verses
Speaker A
agree with the style and context and choice of words and message of the Quran? Absolutely not. There is nothing more antithetical to the message of the Quran than these verses. Also the there are certain words in these like is
Speaker A
that's a hypoxon very strange world word. you know these cranes you have this like form eight passive verb which is very strange also a hypoxon so this is clearly not the author of the Quran so these verses fail when it comes
Speaker A
to internal evidence as well so the final verdict is that the satanic versus story from a historical and literary perspective uh does not pass whatsoever the prophet peace be upon him never spoke in the name of other gods he never said
Speaker A
anything that God did not command him to say. And ironically, in the very same surah, how does the surah begin?
Speaker A
The prophet never speaks from his capries, from his desires. Everything that he says is revelation.
Speaker A
He is taught by one mighty in power. Okay. So my final conclusion would be that uh that the best candidate for for Deuteronomy 18:18 is the holy prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam. And I don't think anyone even comes comes
Speaker A
close to him. No. Oh, that's uh that's absolutely marvelous. I I I agree there a lot of a lot of detail there. Some of which I've not heard before. I'm uh so pleased to have this on tape as a resource uh a
Speaker A
study tool even where as you say initially people should go away look up the references check them uh and investigate this uh further and as I said also if you want a a good general introduction to uh the questions of
Speaker A
biblical interpretation the um the documentary hypothesis the deuteronomistic history the history of D the D school as as as it's known this book will tell you everything. It's a good introductory text. Christine Hayes, I'll link to it. Uh she teaches at Yale,
Speaker A
a colleague of Dale Martin who who are having on again in a week or two. Um I read bits of it. It's very readable, accessible, which is why they published it. So um and also uh next week talking
Speaker A
of the satanic verses. Um uh Dr. Shabir Akdar who's an academic at the University of Oxford. Um he's a a towering theologian and philosopher. Um he's going to appear next Tuesday on blogging theology talking about guess what the satanic verses but not the one
Speaker A
not the ones that we're talking about the uh the notorious uh so-called novel by Salman Rashti the British writer and uh Dr. Um Shabbd will be talking about um secularism, freedom of speech um and the way that Muhammad the man is is uh
Speaker A
seen as a uh you know you can insult him and degrade him in the name of free speech and the implications of this satanic versus novel uh in UK um literary history and I know it's perhaps not had a big impact in the states but
Speaker A
for uh the British audience uh I know Shabir Akdar and he's an outstanding intellect and um I'm sure it'll be very interesting. So that's a a short um advert for next time. Um but coming back to today, thank you so much uh Professor
Speaker A
Ali ate and uh for your outstanding um introduction to these issues. Such a um a polygot certainly who is a person who can uh operate on so many different registers linguistically and through various ancient texts, the Bible, the
Speaker A
Quran and so on. It's it's it's a real treat to have this kind of holistic synthesized um exposition of the issues rather than someone who's narrowly focused on just one field. You you are clearly expert on many fields and is that kind of
Speaker A
multiddisciplinary approach we really need when we're talking with Christians and and Jews and Muslims together about all these texts. So um outstanding um uh work there. Thank you so much sir for your and um you you you even suggested
Speaker A
you might come again to talk about other texts like Isaiah 42 um which is another key key text in the Bible much uh discussed today countless YouTube videos about it but it' be good to have um a a
Speaker A
scholarly um assessment of the evidence and really what does it say and uh I think it's a very strong candidate myself for um uh the prophet uh of of Islam and put it that way. A rather strong candidate for that um passage. So
Speaker A
um thank you. Is there anything else you wanted to say sir before we um conclude?
Speaker A
Thank you. Thank you for having me and um you know I again I uh encourage people to uh subscribe to the channel.
Speaker A
Um I mean this is this is uh this is what it's all about, right? It's it's it's God talk. It's theology. Uh may God continue to bless you Paul and uh looking forward to coming back inshallah.
Speaker A
Thank you so much. Certainly be very welcome and and I know there are many many people who will watch this um and and will benefit from anomaly. I know from your last time you were uh on blogging theology the huge
Speaker A
positive uh and almost ecstatic um response that people had to what you were saying. I was quite overwhelmed by it. So I'm sure that'd be the same. And uh anyway, thank you very much. I I'll end it there. I think it's been 2 hours,
Speaker A
but uh uh it went by very quickly. So, thank you very much indeed. Thank you, Paul.
Speaker A
Take care.
Topics:Deuteronomy 18:18Prophet MuhammadBiblical hermeneuticsProphet like MosesQuran 7:157TorahInterfaith dialogueComparative theologyHistorical criticismIslam and Christianity











