A trader tests trend-line strategy claims by Tori Trades, finding the edge mostly comes from one market (NASDAQ) and that real trading discipline lapses matter more than gender.
Key Takeaways
- The trend-line strategy's apparent edge is largely explained by market exposure (especially NASDAQ) rather than skill in the rules themselves.
- Simple buy-and-hold on the same markets outperformed the strategy on a risk-adjusted basis in most years.
- The most valuable feature of the strategy is crash protection in down markets, not returns in bull markets.
- The guru's self-described filter is subjective and cannot be systematically taught or verified.
- Gender is not a meaningful predictor of trading competence; both men and women show similar behavioral mistakes.
What the video covers
- The creator tests the trend-line breakout strategy taught by Tori Trades (Victoria Duke) by coding its rules across 10 futures markets from 2020 to 2026, with costs included.
- On the 1-hour chart, the strategy performs about as well as random entries, with random entries matching it roughly one time in six.
- On the 4-hour chart, the strategy made $348,000, but the creator attributes most of this to the NASDAQ, which nearly tripled during the test period; excluding it, random entries match her results far more often.
- Changing swing point sensitivity from three to five candles changes the match-rate of random entries substantially, showing the result depends heavily on parameters.
- Simply holding the same 10 markets produced higher returns ($1.24 million) with better risk-adjusted returns in most years, except 2022 when buy-and-hold lost heavily and the trend rule was a hedge.
- The creator questions the 'A+ setup' filter, which is subjective and cannot be systematically coded, meaning its claimed performance is hard to verify.
- The video critiques the guru's risk management: she advises risking 1-2% per trade but was observed risking about 12%, and in July 2025 she removed a stop-loss on a double-sized platinum position, suffering a $250,000 drawdown before recovering.
- The creator argues the guru's 2025 goals (a million in profit, a Porsche, four properties) were largely unmet, and that she sells courses with an unclear price structure.
- The video frames the gender question as a red herring: female and male traders are judged by the same standards, with both showing overconfidence, poor risk discipline, and reluctance to admit mistakes.
- The creator promotes a paid community offering code, analysis infrastructure, and educational videos.
Chapters
- 00:00Introducing the Trend-Line Guru's Claims
- 00:39Why Test a Female Trader's Strategy
- 02:00The Trader's Background and Strategy Rules
- 03:09Backtest Results on 1-Hour and 4-Hour Charts
- 05:31Market Breakdown: The NASDAQ Effect
- 08:06A+ Setups and the Subjective Filter
- 09:32Risk Management Failures and the Platinum Trade
- 12:00Goals, Subjectivity, and Final Verdict
Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown
Speaker A
I will have a fat ass. All right, that one we don't have yet. This is Tori Trades. Her trendline video has 2 million views and she sells the strategy as a career. And in a video with 50,000 views, she says this.
Speaker A
If you did take every trend line break, you just probably wouldn't be super profitable. You'd probably be close to break even.
Speaker A
A trading guru admitting her own strategy doesn't work. I've waited years for this. So, I had to check if she was lying about being honest. She was. I coded it and it made $348,000.
Speaker A
A guru underelling her own strategy. That never happens until you look at where the money came from. But first, why I'm doing this at all? What if the mentor is a she? Are they to be trusted to have profitable strategies? I get
Speaker A
where it's coming from. Men have always been sure they're the better traders. Men are sure about a lot of things. One in eight men think they could win a point off Serena Williams. Serena [ __ ] Williams. Almost one in four
Speaker A
think they could land a [ __ ] passenger plane with a bit of help from the tower. And 7% think they could beat a grizzly bear with their bare hands.
Speaker A
I'm pretty sure that 7% trades crypto on 100x leverage. Someone actually checked the trading part. Two finance professors went through 35,000 brokerage accounts.
Speaker A
Men traded 45% more than women and made less money doing it. The paper is literally called boys will be boys. So yes, the data says men are better at something. It's paying commissions. And when the account is finally gone, he
Speaker A
doesn't quit. Obviously, he sells a course with a lion on the thumbnail. Probably because the bear won. So, my hypothesis was simple. She can't possibly be worse than that. Well, hold that thought. Her real name is Victoria Duke. She learned the strategy from her
Speaker A
uncle who taught her for free and then put it in a course for $2,000.
Speaker A
Now she has one, too. Other families pass down jewelry. The rules fit in one breath. Draw a line through the swing points. A candle closes through it, you're in. The line on the other side is your stop and you
Speaker A
drag it along as price moves. No indicators, no target. I coded exactly that on 10 futures markets from the NASDAQ to gold, oil, bonds, and currencies, 2020 to 2026 with costs. on the 1 hour chart, the one she traded for
Speaker A
years. She's right. Random entries do just as well about one time in six. A trading guru telling the truth. First time for everything. On the 4hour chart, the one she uses today, $348,000 and only 2% of random entries kept up.
Speaker A
For about 10 minutes, I was drafting an apology to every woman a man has ever explained trading to. That's a long letter.
Speaker A
Then I split it by market. The NASDAQ made 224,000 of it. The S&P 500, which moves almost exactly like the NASDAQ, lost 28,000.
Speaker A
Take the NASDAQ out, and 15% of random entries match her. changed the swing points from three candles to five, 30%.
Speaker A
So, the edge is mostly one market that nearly tripled while she was long it, which takes about as much skill as a man taking credit for the sunrise because he set an alarm.
Speaker A
And just holding the same 10 markets made 1.24 million, even scaled down to her risk, 513,000, with a better risk adjusted return in every year but one. remember that year.
Speaker A
It's the most useful thing in this video. Now, she'd say, "I tested the wrong thing." The real money is in her A+ setups, and her proof is 2024.
Speaker A
17 trades, 76% winners, plus 180%. I drew random 17 trade years from my rebuild 10,000 times. A 76% win rate came up three times. So, either her filter is the strongest edge I've ever seen or it isn't coming from rules.
Speaker A
Here's how she counts touch point. Now, this part is fairly subjective when it comes to how many touch points. If we want to be incredibly particular and count every single candle touch point, then we got quite a few over here. We've
Speaker A
got 1 2 3 4 5 six touch points on this. But I consider this a two touch point trend line break.
Speaker A
Six touches are two touches when it feels right. Horoscopes have stricter rules. Most of those showcase trades are platinum, and I wanted to test platinum, too. But this month, I've already spent hundreds of dollars on data just to
Speaker A
prove gurus wrong. And for once, I'd like to end a month in profit. So, if you like this kind of work, support it and join my community. It keeps the data budget alive. Back to her, her students learn never to risk more than 1 to 2% of
Speaker A
the account on one trade. Here she is breaking down one of her own. My beginning balance when I got into this trade was 123,000. So, Alexa, what percentage is 15,000 of 120? Dude, I've been heavy on the risk.
Speaker A
12%. Six times her own rule calculated live by a smart speaker. And honestly, still more humility than most men I've tested.
Speaker A
They'd rather blow up the account than ask anyone for help with the math. Least of all a woman who lives in a speaker.
Speaker A
And that was one of the careful ones. July 2025, platinum, 40 contracts, double her usual size. Her exit signal comes and she doesn't take it.
Speaker A
And I didn't didn't exit. removed the stop and was married to this position. Price went against me. $250,000 worth of draw down.
Speaker A
Platinum came back. She closed at plus 90,000. And that trade is part of the 114% she shows for 2025. To her credit, she made a whole video about it and called it a bad trade. Then she added this.
Speaker A
This is a bad trade. It in no way means that I am a bad trader. I've heard that sentence from at least a dozen men. A man will lose his savings, his marriage, and the dog before he admits the
Speaker A
stop-loss was a good idea. Ladies and gentlemen, equality. So, what do her students pay for? Her website doesn't show a price, just a button that says, "Book a call." And then there's this clip from a video about what gurus
Speaker A
don't talk about. It's not something you can teach. You can't, you know, have somebody sign up for a course and teach them intuition.
Speaker A
Follow the chain. Every break is break even by her own words. The filter that makes the money is subjective.
Speaker A
Subjective means intuition. And intuition by her own words can't be taught in a course. She's also very open about her ambitions. Her 2025 goals were up to a million in trading profit, a supercar, and four investment properties. her year-end review.
Speaker A
I made six figures. Way to go. Amazing. Not a million. I said that I would buy four investment properties this year. I didn't. I said that I would buy a Porsche GT3 RS. I didn't do that either.
Speaker A
Zero for three. About what the back test predicted. Then she reads her manifestation list.
Speaker A
I will earn a passive income of $5,000 a month. I do much more than that now. I will have a fat ass. All right, that one we don't have yet.
Speaker A
Tori, I watched 99 of your videos for this. On that one, I have to respectfully disagree. Now, that one year, 2022, stocks and bonds crashed and buy and hold on these 10 markets lost $251,000.
Speaker A
Her rule made $13,000. When a market falls, the line flips. The long gets stopped out and the rule goes short. You pay for that in every bull market. But as crash insurance, the trend line idea genuinely works. And now
Speaker A
you have it for free without a call. So can women be trusted with trading strategies? After 6 years, 10 markets, and 99 videos, exactly as much as men, she sizes up like a man. She removes her stop like a man. She calls it a bad
Speaker A
trade, not a bad trader. Like a man, the glass ceiling in trading education is finally gone. Unfortunately, the floor went with it.
Speaker A
Want the code behind all of this? Join my community. You get the code and infrastructure for this analysis and hundreds of others, plus 50 plus hours of educational video material, including this exact test. Links in the description.
Topics:trading strategytrend linebacktestfutures tradingrisk managementTori Tradestrading educationalgorithmic tradingNASDAQstop loss











