Skip to content
Get App

Talkin Torah w/ R. L. Solberg, Raymond Hoefs & Xavier Putnam

A panel discussion on the Torah-observant movement among Messianic and Hebrew Roots believers, covering definitions, motivations, and theological debates over law, sacrifice, and covenant.

Key Takeaways

  • The Torah-observant movement is diverse, young, and lacks centralized structure or a single denomination.
  • Participants frame their practice as a return to the roots of the faith and a desire to obey God rather than a rejection of Christianity.
  • Central debates concern how the Mosaic law relates to the New Covenant, grace, and the moral versus ceremonial categories of Torah.
  • The panel aims at mutual clarification between Torah-observant and mainstream Christian perspectives.

What the video covers

  • Host Tyler Fowler and co-host David Russell introduce a panel on the Torah-observant community, with a planned guest (Dr. Egal German) rescheduled for the following Monday.
  • Panelists Rob Solberg (theologian and author of a book on Torah observance), Raymond Hopes, and Xavier Putnam (a registered nurse) introduce themselves and their journeys into the movement.
  • Raymond and Xavier define the community as believers in Yeshua who seek to return to the roots of the faith, using labels such as Messianic, Hebrew Roots, and pro-Torah.
  • The movement is described as non-monolithic and young, with no firm denomination, and its most common areas of observance are the festivals, the Sabbath, and dietary laws.
  • Key influencers named include Dr. Tim Hegg, Rico Cortez, Eddie Chumney, and David Wilber.
  • Participants discuss why they left traditional Christian denominations, citing a desire to critically test inherited teachings against Scripture.
  • The panel debates the distinction between the Mosaic covenant and the New Covenant, and how Torah applies to believers after Yeshua's sacrifice.
  • Discussion covers whether Torah laws distinguish moral commandments from ceremonial or holiness laws, and the meaning of uncleanness versus sin.
  • Participants examine textual evidence, including Paul's statements in 1 Corinthians and the Torah of Moses versus the Torah of God in Ezra and Nehemiah.
  • The conversation includes disagreements over historical sources and the identity of groups like the Nazarenes and Ebionites.

Answers

Questions about this video

What does the panel say the Torah-observant community is?

Raymond and Xavier describe it as believers in Yeshua who seek to return to what they see as the roots of the faith. They note it is not monolithic and uses varied labels such as Messianic, Hebrew Roots, and pro-Torah.

Which Torah practices are most commonly emphasized?

According to the panelists, the most widely shared practices are the biblical festivals, the Sabbath, and dietary instructions. They say there is considerable disagreement about which other commands apply.

Why did some panelists leave traditional Christian denominations?

Participants said they wanted to critically examine what they had been taught and test inherited denominational teachings against Scripture. Several described this as a gradual process of seeking truth.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:02
Speaker A
[Music] [Music] so [Music] what is going on ladies and gentlemen boys and girls children of all ages this is the complete center's guide i am your host tyler fowler and with me a special guest co-hosting for this evening mr
01:35
Speaker A
david russell from poro what's going on brother how you doing tonight it's the same as i was this morning brother nothing's changing good to see you again good to see you sir yeah for those who haven't seen it uh david and i did a
01:48
Speaker A
kind of a pregame to this episode we was going to have dr egal german on uh but unfortunately he came down uh with a with a sickness and he wasn't able to make it tonight good news is we've got
01:59
Speaker A
that rescheduled for monday next monday is that right david 3 p.m eastern so looking forward to talking to dr germa but we have got a panel as you can see with us tonight rob solberg raymond hopes and xavier putnam gentlemen how
02:16
Speaker A
are you all doing tonight we'll go ahead and just introduce everybody uh we'll start with rob and then we'll hit raymond and xavier but if you guys want to go ahead and introduce yourself i'm excited to have you all on to talk torah
02:28
Speaker A
tonight we'll be discussing concepts of the torah observant community what what it is defining terms and really getting a good intro level uh conversation for those who don't know about the movement maybe discussing some content concepts about the movement but rob go ahead and
02:46
Speaker A
introduce yourself please great rocking intro that was awesome thank you thank you uh so i'm rob solberg i'm a i'm in nash based in nashville i'm a an author an apologist a theologian um also a professor of theology and philosophy at
03:04
Speaker A
williamson college here in tennessee and uh one of the things that connected us tyler was my book tourism so that's kind of what led me into the torah observant movement and i'm still very much in a posture of learning and growing
03:19
Speaker A
in understanding what that's all about amen amen i think that's that's one thing that the people i talk i know i've talked to raymond about this and i know that we are truth seekers all of us here i believe are seeking truth and i'll be
03:32
Speaker A
the first to admit if i'm wrong about something i want to know it so i can be right about it right fair enough so raymond we'll go ahead and let you introduce yourself brother man how are you doing tonight and what is new since
03:43
Speaker A
the last time i talked to you i'm doing well uh past couple days i've been fighting off a bug but praise the lord i'm here and healthy awesome i'm really excited to be here um you know i've uh i've been in this
03:57
Speaker A
understanding of tour observance and trying to uh obey what we understand to be the law of god uh since about 2015 and it's been a growing process you don't learn everything overnight and as rob's book lays out it's it's
04:14
Speaker A
far from a monolithic system uh there's a lot of different swirling veins of thought and hopefully we can discuss that a little bit uh later tonight but um just me uh i go to a small church outside of atlanta georgia and conyers
04:32
Speaker A
and uh you know i've been going there since about 2019 and uh yeah that's pretty much for me right on oh sorry no go ahead brother my name is xavier i am a registered nurse and um i moved from california recently to
04:50
Speaker A
alabama to marry the most beautiful and amazing woman in the world rebecca who's peeping in and listening i'm a disciple of yeshua i have been since i was a child i would say in my late teens which that would be about
05:06
Speaker A
seven oh wow gosh eight nine years ago now wow i began to kind of pray for just further clarity on the roots of the faith and um i just as raymond said it's a journey but that's how i kind of
05:23
Speaker A
grew into the understanding of torah observance right on right on so both of you have been in this movement then for a while then it would seem so i'm glad to have you guys on to answer some of my
05:33
Speaker A
questions i know david's got some questions and just to get both sides i i really like and and to be honest guys i haven't done it a lot but i really like it whenever both sides can set down at
05:44
Speaker A
the same table and to actually interact with one another so there's no misconceptions and if there is any misconceptions we can correct those like i said we're all searching for truth here and so i want to begin just with
05:56
Speaker A
definitions so raymond xavier i'll give you guys the floor define for us really what it is that the torah observant community holds to i know you guys said it's not monolithic and i know for a fact after engaging with multiple people
06:09
Speaker A
in this movement especially on tick tock it is not monolithic at all so i will go ahead and let you guys define what it is that you believe and then rob will hand it over to you to really figure out what
06:21
Speaker A
it is uh what is it about the torah observant community that you see as maybe even a danger to to this but raymond and xavier i will let you guys uh take the floor yeah so the torah observing community is a
06:37
Speaker A
group of believers in yeshua jesus who are trying to return to what we see as the roots of the faith and we go by tons of labels and some people don't want some of the labels but some labels
06:51
Speaker A
you might hear are the way right that's a scriptural term okay messianic you might hear hebrew roots uh some like to be called pronomian in the sense that we're pro-law right as opposed to anti-no man right right and
07:05
Speaker A
we are christians at the same time and uh we are tourists as well [Laughter] although not quite as rob defines or might be we might be a different flavor than he's interacted with so yeah so um [Music] within the tor observant community
07:25
Speaker A
the central grounding thing that you're going to have pulling people together is going to be a fervent desire to obey god and even within the movement uh there is a collage of which commands they think apply and don't
07:45
Speaker A
the most monolithic commands are probably going to be the festivals the sabbath and the dietary instructions those would be this that would be the big three groups that i would put them in um there's a lot there's there's a lot of disagreement even in
08:01
Speaker A
that though there's there's no firm denomination although there is the messianic jewish denomination and uh there's a lot of key teachers and uh movers influencers in that community there's people like uh dr tim head who i think i've mentioned to you before tyler
08:20
Speaker A
he's written some commentaries on galatians hebrews et cetera people like rico cortez eddie chumney um david wilber other people like that uh who contribute and and write and that are trying to pull together uh a more centralized movement
08:44
Speaker A
on the same page and you know this movement is pretty young like you know in the in the full spectrum of the church we're talking about uh probably over the last 50 years or so that people have been
08:59
Speaker A
getting back to the roots of the faith so we shouldn't expect to see the same amount of structure and solidity that we see in you know the you know the churches that came out of the reformation where they've had
09:12
Speaker A
hundreds of years to get their stuff in order and stuff like that you guys are pioneering through it then it sounds like so david do you got anything to ask uh raymond and xavier just clarify anything so so what what is
09:26
Speaker A
it about the church that made you guys kind of like shift gears i mean that's just one of the things that i've always wondered why why why this versus what has been established for hundreds of years you know
09:39
Speaker A
that's a really good question i think i mean it's different for everyone but for me i i wanted to kind of critically examine christian denominations i was raised baptism in assemblies of god and oh that's why nope [Laughter]
09:57
Speaker A
i'm just kidding so but you know as a teenager you're thinking who hasn't really thought about some of these things critically i was thinking like well how do i know that that's the most accurate denomination obviously they all have some truth um i
10:10
Speaker A
found it on the bible and so but for me it was just like how do i know like i can't i want to at least test what i was taught you know sure yeah yeah um let's see for me
10:24
Speaker A
there were certain things that they seemed to contradict uh you know growing up i grew up baptist as well and uh we ended up transferring the entire church kept the same name building everything they just became non-denominational over time
10:42
Speaker A
but you know they're real big on preaching on tithing right uh tithing being a you know old covenant practice so to speak but if you were to talk about other things that are typically considered quote unquote holy covenant uh those
10:57
Speaker A
things aren't anymore so there there seemed to be a disjointing there growing up that that i noticed and um now that i have an issue with tithing but it just didn't seem to line up and as i grew up who went to college and you
11:16
Speaker A
know started challenging things on my own um you know i i started questioning a lot of things and uh evaluating you know why why do we do these things why don't we do these things and when i was reading through the
11:31
Speaker A
scripture you know i i didn't i found uh validation for doing things that most people consider old covenant and i didn't really see a lot of justification to move away from it sure no i completely understand that so the i i did say danger a while ago
11:50
Speaker A
and i'm going to be honest with you guys there are some people that i've talked to in this movement there's two things that i see that really stand out to really get into this and rob i want your
11:57
Speaker A
comments on this um as well but actually david and i are debating two uh two gentlemen uh brad and sheamus from altered media next or well february the 24th on the deity of christ and that's really a trend that i have been seeing
12:11
Speaker A
coming out of this movement the denial of the divinity of christ now i don't want to misrepresent you guys so i'll let you guys speak for yourself but you would both affirm the divinity of christ i know raymond you do
12:20
Speaker A
xavier uh do you do as well or yeah we affirm the duty of messiah and also that they're you know yahweh manifests in three persons three distinct persons co-equal co-eternal so on and so forth um i now to tie it to the movement yeah there
12:37
Speaker A
are a lot of people questioning the deity of messiah no doubt something that we might find interesting though is that in the only polling data that i've ever seen done of what's called the messianic torah spectrum it's a 2019 paper by ben frost that he
12:52
Speaker A
graduated from horror resource which is tim heggs um cool and we can send this information to you guys yeah absolutely i'm just gonna i was just gonna ask for that that'd be great i'd love to see that sure yeah for sure now
13:04
Speaker A
obviously like we're not saying this study is perfect but at least there is a study because i think it's the only one so you know obviously what would they say in science you know more research must be done but sure so
13:17
Speaker A
out of 16 699 total responses now these range from your messianic jewish association of america to your hardcore hebrew roots fundamentalists me and my bible type of thing right so of those responses 75 strongly agreed with the deity of yeshua
13:35
Speaker A
nine percent somewhat agreed six percent neither agreed nor disagreed so about ninety percent are not opposed 75 at least strongly agree with that and really i think this is a crisis due to lack of proper teaching in churches and
13:52
Speaker A
congregations and we find similar data in christianity actually right so uh there's a there was a poll that was done by ligonier that lifeway put out and they did a pull of evangelicals and they were trying to just get a pulse on
14:11
Speaker A
what people believe within christianity christian what do you believe is essentially what the survey was and they told them about the uh the deity of christ and the trinity and almost everybody in the evangelical movement was all for the trinity but
14:26
Speaker A
then they asked them if uh jesus christ was the first and greatest creation of god the father 78 of them said yes jesus you know the first and greatest creation of god the father so in the evangelical movement we're seeing a similar
14:43
Speaker A
confusion about the person of the sun we don't think that this movement specifically lends itself towards aryanism we think arianism is unfortunately on the rise due to lack of proper teaching yeah yeah i just don't think it's inherent to this
15:04
Speaker A
movement but it's a legitimate concern anywhere absolutely and we we do our best to address it and you know we're not teachers elders we're students we're just sure we're late members really we're two bros you know but now uh
15:19
Speaker A
and most of the prominent teachers in this movement actually affirm the deity of your show and we could get at least 10 examples but we rest our case well fair enough yeah i've seen that so i've seen in
15:31
Speaker A
certain strains and of course the first people that i uh encountered the hebrew roots concept with were very much i came to learn over time that they were very much on the more radical end of the spectrum so
15:46
Speaker A
um you know they would say things like jesus said you know worship the father so i'm the door so why stop and worship the door when you should move on and worship the father kind of thing but i would
15:56
Speaker A
agree with you guys that's that's a minority view in overall in what i call tourism or hebrew roots right i am honestly happy to find that that yeah that's what i was gonna say i'm so thankful to hear that um because like i
16:10
Speaker A
said whenever i get on tick tock and i ask the question you know question for torah observers do you uh affirm the deity of christ and honestly guys 75 percent said no right and now it's it hits my heart and that's honestly how
16:25
Speaker A
this debate uh kind of got uh started really but is there anything uh anybody else wants to add before we move on to the next david maybe that tells you more about tick tock than hebrew yeah but you know what's scarier
16:39
Speaker A
and i think for me is that the these social media platforms gain huge followings right and you know lies can travel halfway around the world before you know truth has a chance to put its boots on but like that's that's the
16:53
Speaker A
nature of the game these days and that's the nature of of the world we live in with all this uh you know mass media so i see it growing and i think the growth and i think you guys mentioned that you
17:04
Speaker A
see it growing too that that rise in arianism and uh and i don't even know if it's just pure areas it's just out there sometimes but it's like almost uh a subset of it but yeah it's bad and it's growing and i think we
17:18
Speaker A
all have the right to be concerned and stuff like that so yeah that's all i could add to it one thing i would say that i think we would all agree on is that biblical literacy needs some love
17:30
Speaker A
in this world right now i mean there's so much many churches are not teaching um solid biblical and whether or not you know which side of the spectrum you're on as far as torah observance i think we would all
17:41
Speaker A
agree that there's there's a need to improve that you know i feel like um in general some of the more highly influential churches have become sort of like pep talk psychologist kind of discussions rather than you know exegeting scripture
17:58
Speaker A
right yeah absolutely i did a i did a research paper not too long ago on scriptural literacy and oh well it was actually a long time ago uh probably when i was doing my associates and uh it was over like 80 at that time so i can't
18:12
Speaker A
even imagine where it is now yeah when i first came into this movement just a little bit of a testimony um one of the things i ended up testing which i talked to tyler about this uh in private message was
18:26
Speaker A
the trinity the deity of christ things like that and there was a a spell of probably about a year or so where i really didn't know how to make heads or tales of it people had come to me
18:38
Speaker A
with some like anti-catholic rhetoric stuff that you talked about in your book rob um not specifically protour rhetoric but more so like anti-catholic rhetoric trying to line up the the trinity with you know the corruption of the early
18:55
Speaker A
church the corruption of the pope the corruption sometimes paganism too there is some uh pro-torah paganism stuff put in there with the with the trinity uh and it was in really researching the the true origins of the trinity and how
19:13
Speaker A
the how the act the matter actually was ruled on and they came to terms on that particular topic that i understood that almost all those claims were completely false right that it's based on scripture and it's a it's a scriptural thing
19:32
Speaker A
uh so just the whole question in and of itself at least in my own personal anecdotal experience wasn't posed in a if you if you believe the trinity you're breaking the torah specifically it's like bundled up in this weird
19:52
Speaker A
conglomeration it's like an emotional thing sometimes too like i don't know but it took me a while of research and prayer and humility and to eventually you know come back around and realize okay this is what i believe this is why
20:06
Speaker A
i believe that uh you know the church really didn't teach me well when it came to the deity and the trending i joke about this but when i asked questions about the trinity growing up i literally was shown something like this i was
20:19
Speaker A
showing something like that you guys ever seen this thing oh my god i haven't yeah yeah i've seen it yeah it's ridiculous and you know what i told people i i said you know what i said you know
20:31
Speaker A
kudos to the catholics because if you go there and you actually listen to the mass you're definitely going to know what the trinity is they they recite it they sing it you know and it was it was awesome to
20:43
Speaker A
actually and i'm not catholic by any stretch of the means but like just listening to that and listening and being like okay you know that's part of oral tradition that that probably is historical that is just you know uh uh
20:55
Speaker A
past been passed along and passed along and they've kept it alive but you know i i always say you know the protestants we have done a bad job at really relaying our fundamental doctrines [Music] yeah yeah i think so i really do all
21:11
Speaker A
right gentlemen uh let's uh let's go ahead and transition i i really want to get into whether or not one fundamental aspect of the torah observant community is really a salvation a salvation issue or not and and though most in the torah observant
21:28
Speaker A
movement don't come out and say we're required to keep the law of moses for salvation right i do hear a lot that the law of moses is still binding and required for christians to keep for obedience when the rubber meets the road
21:41
Speaker A
guys it and and i've seen this in a um one of rob's videos that he did on christopher enoch he had played a clip of him saying real christians don't eat pork right and so if a true christian it
21:54
Speaker A
keeps the law of moses honestly is is this not just semantics i mean aren't those in the torah observant uh movement implying that if someone doesn't keep the law of moses they really aren't saved raymond is xavier how would you guys answer that
22:09
Speaker A
uh the first thing i want to say is there's a reason james says not many are supposed to be hookers uh some people do not have the spiritual uh humility and acumen to approach topics like this and there's a lot of people out there
22:25
Speaker A
and i'm not i'm not shooting any shots at you guys because you guys mentioned tick tock but there's a lot of people starting tick tock ministries youtube ministries they don't have the credentials uh you know they they're just not qualified
22:40
Speaker A
uh sadly they launch a lot of statements that uh are more hurtful than helpful so that's the first thing that that i wanted to say sure sounds like a little john macarthur there you know not qualified oh gosh okay
22:57
Speaker A
cute david very cute leaving that aside yeah so it is it is a problem within the movement like we won't sugarcoat it um it's basically a problem in the church too though if you really press people various denominations believe
23:15
Speaker A
that you need to maintain some sort of obedience to make it to the end and so this this gets into calvinist versus armenian this gets into one saved always saved right so this is really just an extension of that is how i think it
23:28
Speaker A
should be seen but yeah there are people uh now as far as like people i've met i don't i can't think of any that i've met that really believe they can earn their salvation but answer your question in regards to you
23:42
Speaker A
know if a true christian you know obeys the torah moses you know might it reflect a state of salvation the answer is that there are different sins different types of sins there are sins of ignorance there is sinning with a high hand
23:55
Speaker A
sinning defiantly and i mean let's be honest like in the dark ages people weren't doing everything right during the catholic church right so when things are revealed then yes we are responsible for them but no obedience is the is the
24:13
Speaker A
uh fruit of our salvation it's not the root so yeah you know this sort of thing comes up it's it's not exclusive to the torah movement we try to deal with it when we can and yeah we must never
24:23
Speaker A
forget that we are saved by grace through faith so yeah yeah i wouldn't that's common i mean again i've had the same issue where the minority of folks will actually outwardly admit uh who are torah observant that that's
24:37
Speaker A
where the torah or that's where salvation comes from is from obeying torah um but again i kind of um echo what tyler was saying is what i what i end up hearing is that so that that not keeping torah
24:53
Speaker A
is excuse me it's sinful and it's lawless and it becomes a evidence that maybe you're not really maybe your faith isn't real so there is a subtext of a salvation link there um whereas i think on the surface and what
25:10
Speaker A
i think honestly what i think happens is a lot of times you guys correct me if i'm wrong but i think a lot of times what i see in the torah movement especially when it's not um what did you call it qualified teachers
25:22
Speaker A
uh they'll make statements that they don't realize have additional implicat implications so they'll make a statement about something regarding torah not intending to insinuate that salvation's required but that does become a natural outworking of what they're teaching and they just hadn't seen it
25:38
Speaker A
through to that end yet yeah i'm sure i'm sure there are those people i would kind of look at it more so like let's pick an example that we all hopefully should agree is a sin right like i don't know online how about
25:50
Speaker A
online pirating like downloading things illegally that's something we probably agree is akin to stealing to some extent sure so is somebody not a true christian because they pirate music well you could look at it from a couple different angles
26:09
Speaker A
you know it's certainly not good fruit but perhaps they're ignorant uh what happens when you show them and they you know refuse correction or accept correction and so it's the same sort of thing just there are additional commandments
26:22
Speaker A
we believe are applicable but if you boil it down to that example it should make sense that obedience is the you know the fruit of our salvation so yeah it might indicate something about the person but we don't
26:34
Speaker A
think of you guys as any less of believers now yeah like we do believe breaking the commandments are sin period but i mean we believe there's widespread ignorance on this issue just like there was in the dark ages until the
26:47
Speaker A
reformation oh yeah there's always been with fallen humanity you know so so does the classical definition of sin if we look at the classical definition of sin i mean even down uh pre-augustinian um about you know it corrupting form so to speak
27:06
Speaker A
um where do you guys stand on that that could sin cover a wider range of things besides what's specifically outlined in torah so i think that's a really good question so this is where it kind of comes down to
27:23
Speaker A
how do you how do you view uh the torah my understanding of the torah is that it's given in what's called case law this is how my pastor describes it often is that it'll use specific examples to teach general
27:39
Speaker A
principles sometimes it'll use general principles to teach specific things as well one of the early rabbis hillel i think was the one who came up with seven rules of interpretation uh and he he coined those two rules which the apostles and uh christ used
27:57
Speaker A
all throughout the apostolic scriptures um so when we look at a command in scripture uh there's there's some interesting ones out there right uh so let's let's you know let's you know don't let me find one that's kind of like
28:15
Speaker A
extreme and kind of weird and now good idea i like it oh well how about this one uh yes yeah you know your your uh your neighbor's ox falls into a ditch right you could look at that and say well if my neighbor's ox
28:28
Speaker A
falls into a ditch you know i help him get his ox out of the ditch but if i see his horse in there well the law said his ox yeah right this is a this is this is a case an
28:39
Speaker A
example right my neighbor's animal practice thing is in danger right so mimi is a good neighbor i'm going to help him with what that task is that precious thing is right that's that's the principle right so that allows it you know the torah to extend
28:56
Speaker A
to lots of things including some things that you know i know rob thinks might be new commandments we wouldn't see it that way it comes down to the shema as well hear o israel yahweh our god yahweh is
29:08
Speaker A
one you shall love yahweh with all your heart soul and strength the heart is the inward part which includes the mind so if there's a commandment that says uh you know not to murder well as yeshua extrapolated really observing the shema you also
29:24
Speaker A
would have not hated that person in your heart now is that a new commandment absolutely not it's in the shema he's just extrapolating it yeah it's also it would also be represented in the tenth commandment well sorry that's a
29:37
Speaker A
different one yeah i was thinking about when he goes later on he says if you desire the woman in your heart that's adultery yeah that would also fall under covetousness right that's in the tenth commandment so it's it's it's far more flexible far more
29:49
Speaker A
far-reaching than i think a lot of us ever realized so yeah it's it's far beyond what's just like written there if that makes sense it's in the mind your heart soul and strength that really yes i think sums it up i
30:03
Speaker A
think we see that paul gives a perfect example of that when he talks about how the ox gets it shouldn't be muzzled when it's eating the grain and he quotes the old testament law about that to teach that
30:14
Speaker A
the apostles and disciples should be allowed to get some financial help with their ministry so he's applying the principle which was expressed under the law of moses as don't muzzle your ox when it's treading out the grain he's applying that in a
30:29
Speaker A
different way but it's the same principle and the principle is unchanging so so let me if you don't mind if i could use that as a springboard um yeah i would extrapolate what you're talking about i agree with everything
30:41
Speaker A
that you said so far but i would actually zoom out a little bit with that concept of principle and expression to say i think there's something to be said um with within that framework again uh that can speak to the issue of torah
30:57
Speaker A
observance today for christians so let me give you a quick example the idea of principle and expression like we just talked about so a good example just you know in modern times would be a parent who has a principle that they're trying
31:12
Speaker A
to instill in their child and maybe that principle is um be kind to others so when the child's a toddler all you can really say is don't hit your brother right but as they get older they'd be able to they start to be
31:23
Speaker A
able to speak you can say hey don't speak unkindly to other people and as they get even older you might be able to say not just a prohibition of negative things but you might be able to say hey be kind serve other people help
31:35
Speaker A
them so the principle remains unchanged but it gets expressed in different ways so let me pose this to you i'd love to get your feedback on it what if the principle the law of god the unchanging cosmic rule that's been in
31:49
Speaker A
place since creation is expressed differently to god's people over different eras so you've got an expression that we might call the mosaic expression of god's law given to israel fresh out of slavery what they needed to understand to obey their to obey his law
32:06
Speaker A
and this is why in the old testament we can talk about meditating on your law and loving your law and you know thinking on a day and night and all that and then fast forward to the new covenant and it becomes a new expression
32:18
Speaker A
of the same unchanging law so just to apply a quick scriptural example suppose think about atonement so you've got atonement which we get a glimpse at in the garden of eden when god gave gave adam and eve skins of animals
32:35
Speaker A
because they sinned so that was kind of our first hint at a at an animal sacrifice a blood sacrifice and then you fast forward and you see god requiring a blood sacrifice at passover to rescue egypt out of israel and then later we
32:49
Speaker A
see god instituting ritual uh animal sacrifices in the temple so repeated animal sacrifices and then that same principle and the principle is that atonement for sin requires the shedding of blood now that's expressed under the new covenant as jesus who shed his blood
33:07
Speaker A
for us once for all and when jesus shed his blood for us we no longer the expression changed from animal sacrifices regularly to a once for all so in that sense we could say christians today we still have a sacrifice that
33:21
Speaker A
that law has not been abolished or put away or anything we still have a sacrifice today but that sacrifice has taken the form or the expression of christ's once for all sacrifice what do you guys think of that
33:34
Speaker A
so uh i think we're going to kind of divvy up uh how we respond here the first thing that i'd like to bring up is that your analogy that used with the child where the principle is you could say
33:48
Speaker A
maturing over time and the expression is is also maturing uh i don't i don't think that's it one quick correction i said the principle never changed i mean i mean the expression was maturing yeah gotcha i misspoke um
34:08
Speaker A
yeah so i think that that that picture is appropriate i think that the the concern that we have is that the supposed new law of christ that governs the new covenant seems to have things which contradict those other
34:27
Speaker A
principles which are in the law of moses so our view is that sure uh so uh a really a simple one would be uh the you know the freedom the christian liberty to eat whatever you would want to eat
34:53
Speaker A
that's in the new covenant versus reflecting god's holiness in the law of moses right so we see a principle in the law of moses which is be holy as i am holy it's staked on yahweh's holiness so we don't think that principle
35:11
Speaker A
changes we don't think any of these expressions will ever be done away with right the child that grows up should also never hit his brother again right even though that's the first expression that's expression should be maintained as he grows in age
35:27
Speaker A
so the principle stays with us and with its integrity intact our our working principle is this our our understanding through jude 5 and through acts 7 38 is that the son of god is the one who gave the law of moses on mount sinai
35:48
Speaker A
as such the law of moses is the law of christ and when he came in the flesh and he taught during his ministry he expounded upon and exposed his own law in the flesh teaching humanity as god in the flesh
36:09
Speaker A
fulfilling prophecy and he he taught exactly what it should be um and we also uphold that when he sent out the apostles uh in matthew 28 and he said you know command them to obey everything i have taught you
36:31
Speaker A
part of what everything i've taught you is is the law of moses which is the law of christ so that's that's our word pulled um and i don't know if you're done if i could respond real quick uh do you want to respond to that first
36:47
Speaker A
or do you want us to tackle your atonement question first uh well yeah you know what we could be here six hours so yes that was literally the number i threw out to xavier before we got on the
36:59
Speaker A
call i know this is great and if i could just let me just insert one thing and then i'd love to hear the response to the atonement but um there are a number of people in what i call
37:11
Speaker A
tourism the hebrew roots movement torah observable christianity who are kind and friendly like david wilber's a great example and you two guys are a great example um one of the large problems that i run into is a very divisive aggressive tone
37:27
Speaker A
like christopher enoch kind of thing so i just wanted to pause and thank you guys for being so uh christ-like in our discussion so thanks oh much appreciate it right back yeah right back we appreciate the way you actually
37:41
Speaker A
really you really attempt to engage the arguments in this community and you go out of your way to say you know i'm not saying this person isn't saved you know so yeah thanks for now yeah okay beautiful yeah i really the spirit i really
37:57
Speaker A
appreciated the spirit of your book uh i know i said that in the group message but i just wanted to say it again time and time again you say not to think tourists or enemies or anything like that treat them with grace
38:11
Speaker A
uh i'd love to see that sort of unifying language even though we we disagree you know yeah thank you i appreciate that i even get people on my side of the of the torah observant question who tell me i'm
38:23
Speaker A
too nice observant friend why do you call him a friend you know it's like well because i can be friends with people i disagree with that's right that's right um did you guys want to tackle that atonement or i i do have something uh
38:43
Speaker A
that i want to say about eating just eating things in general but but i want to give you guys a floor to uh answer that atonement yeah sure okay so regarding atonement it's a long complicated subject but the
38:55
Speaker A
essence is this there are two temples two places of worship um and that first place is on earth that's the earthly tabernacle which later becomes the temple and the purpose i'm heavily like summarizing this okay but the purpose of that earthly venue
39:14
Speaker A
with its earthly priests and its earthly high priest is so that believers can draw near in worship to a god that would consume them otherwise that is basically why the essence of why the sacrifices are required now there
39:27
Speaker A
are different sacrifices right so hebrews says that the sacrifices especially on yom kippur they actually serve to cleanse the flesh present tense not past tense when the author of hebrews is writing they purify the flesh okay now you have it reflected
39:44
Speaker A
in the temple above in heaven where yeshua is our heavenly high priest and in that temple his blood cleanses our conscience so you have the realm of the flesh and the realm of the conscience you have our our earth suits which would
39:58
Speaker A
be consumed by the almighty yahweh if not for the animals and likewise in the heavenly temple you have almighty yahweh and we could not hope to approach him in our fallen state without an intercessor so we see it more
40:11
Speaker A
comparable to an example of like a president and a governor so certain laws are going to differ but they're going to kind of mirror one another so we would not see it as any new way of being atoned for now i know
40:24
Speaker A
rob in your book and i have a quote somewhere but you say that something to the effect of you correct me if i'm wrong that the sacrifices sort of served to kind of atone for our sins until yeshua
40:36
Speaker A
came that's not how we see it we see that yeshua always atoned for everyone from the beginning of time he was the lamb slain from the foundation of the world now if there were an earthly temple today we would
40:48
Speaker A
need the sacrifices to draw near but not to cleanse our conscience that's yeshua's job so two temples two priesthoods two different jobs i would like to say is that the restrictions on the aaronic priesthood that govern the earthly
41:07
Speaker A
uh sacrifices and stuff like that they wouldn't apply to the heavenly yeah the heavenly office right so so yeshua's office as high priest can't be disqualified by the first century non-believing audience that would have been grappling with the issues in the book of
41:26
Speaker A
hebrews because they would have been trying to say he can't be a high priest because he's not from aaron he can't be a high priest because xyz but the whole argument the whole point of the book is that he's got a superior office that
41:41
Speaker A
office is not restricted by the same restrictions of aaron because he wouldn't even be a priest on earth right yeah right he wouldn't qualify as an earthly priest right exactly let me ask you this then in which realm earthly or heavenly was
41:58
Speaker A
jesus blood spilled oh interesting question good question it was spilled in the earthly but i would say its effects are in the heavenly because its effects are in the aroma of the conscience and that's not earthly um are you think are you suggesting that
42:17
Speaker A
jesus blood only atones for conscience not for actually for sin well no no well yeah no i mean i think the point is that it's a different location it's a different venue the earthly sacrifices according to hebrews chapter 10 never took away sins ever
42:34
Speaker A
right yeah it's not like it's not it's not like they covered us until he got here that's not correct they allowed us to approach him in his earthly dwelling place because actually only the priests could make the sacrifice so we could only get
42:49
Speaker A
as close as the priest and they were allowed to go go make the sacrifices they were allowed to go sprinkle the blood on the altar the average joe wasn't allowed behind those curtains you know into the holy places
43:01
Speaker A
sure so i think the reason that jesus blood was spilled in the earthly realm and as a human being he died and then was resurrected was because his blood atoned in that earthly realm for our fleshly sin and all because he died
43:17
Speaker A
uh god sees us with the righteousness that that jesus bought for us with that blood and then another question to tie in i'm just making sure i'm understanding what you guys are saying yeah jesus was the lamb slain from the beginning
43:32
Speaker A
do you do you do you understand that to mean that he was messiah and his blood was shed from the beginning no it's more of like a if i had a predestination statement is that fair um like he was always planned for that
43:51
Speaker A
since the beginning yeah and you know we believe that people in the tanakh were saved in the same way as us grace through faith looking forward to the promises the concept of the eternal present past and future are pretty mysterious they're kind of
44:05
Speaker A
overcrowded but the way i understand it uh and it may be simplistic but past present and future are all kind of the same reality in eternity so the the time that the way we understand time and the way
44:26
Speaker A
that things are in eternity are they're not they're just not the same so he can he can both be slain before the foundations of the world and slain in time and space in history and both of those two things can
44:43
Speaker A
can be reconciled in my in my brain even though i don't understand how it works just like the guy yeah just like the godhead you know yeah i i would agree god at least sees things that way there's there's no new news to him in
44:55
Speaker A
terms of time passing yeah but so i guess i'm still trying to get at the what is the efficacy of jesus blood being spilled in the first century in the middle east in a very physical geographic location at a very specific
45:09
Speaker A
time in history um do you do you see there's a s do you see any significance in that yeah i mean we can go so many directions with that um like are you do you want to kind of know
45:24
Speaker A
like what we think yeshua's blood does or are you asking if it had ritual significance in the shedding of his blood um now i guess what i'm saying is [Music] if i'm understanding what what you're saying correctly it seems to me that
45:41
Speaker A
there would be a case to be made that when and if a temple gets rebuilt and maybe we could avoid eschatology for now would with the with the blood sacrifices the animal sacrifices then continue gotcha okay yeah that's that's a pretty
45:56
Speaker A
direct question well we were actually really thrilled to read your book and and hear your confessions that you are still working out your eschatology because we're in the same boat um so yeah i'm still in that boat i think everybody's
46:09
Speaker A
still working there's a reason it's heavily debated subject so that's right um if ezekiel's temple vision is to be taken literally if i said if you know and all the other prophecies um then yeah there will be sacrifices again
46:25
Speaker A
and there will be sin sacrifices according to ezekiel specifically to purify the flesh it's a sin purification offering might be a better overall word um now that's going to depend on your view of the end game though see if the next thing is not the
46:41
Speaker A
millennium but the new heavens and the new earth and all rules are off so right okay okay oh and so but we would just purify the flesh i just want to get some clarity what do you mean by that
46:51
Speaker A
uh so for example a woman during her menstrual cycle or after having a child i was required to give a sin offering a sin offering she committed no sin some people might try to speculate that she brought sin
47:04
Speaker A
into the world well i think the point is as stated in leviticus 15 i think i'm a about 31.
47:14
Speaker A
do these things make these sacrifices so that i don't consume you so um just like the woman had to purify her flesh after having childbirth i just want that's just one example of how a sin offering really a better term would be
47:29
Speaker A
purification for ritual impurity so and i promise i'm not trying to be i'm just really trying to probe to understand so that seems to be a a a cleanliness you know the mikvah that they would do before going into the temple and all
47:45
Speaker A
that to be that ritual purity process and there's all those purity laws in the torah are you when you're calling sin and purity the same thing it feels like you're uh suggesting that there may be okay let me say a different way in my
48:01
Speaker A
opinion from my theology and i i could be wrong but it feels to me like you're conflating actual sin with dirtiness or uncleanness ah how are you seeing this separate oh yeah so the we'll just call them sin slash
48:17
Speaker A
purification offerings they wipe away the stain of sin but they could never take away sin as hebrews says so our sin in the realm of the earthly temple just for example creates a stain on the altar it it
48:31
Speaker A
it creates a strain in the in the fellowship that we're supposed to have you know in whatever degree we were allowed to in the in the earthly venue and so what has to be done is that stin has to be that stain has to be wiped
48:42
Speaker A
away so the sin offerings can take care of the result of sin but they could never actually like deal with the root issue that's what yeshua does so the core offerings when when the high priest kills the bull
48:58
Speaker A
for his own sins and then kills one of the goats for israel's sins and all that you don't see that as uh atonement for sin it is it is an atonement in the earthly venue as it relates to the earthly altar
49:11
Speaker A
for his manifest presence so it takes care of the result um the stain that was smeared on the altar but it did not deal with the root problem so it wouldn't it wouldn't have cleansed anyone's heart yeah right so let me know
49:26
Speaker A
i'm sure go ahead go ahead no go ahead and finish it i'm just gonna say that uh you know when we sin we don't just transgress against our flesh we also transgress against our mind it's both material and immaterial
49:40
Speaker A
the offerings at the earthly temple they only handled things that were material they could only do material cleansing they could not cleanse our mind our soul uh our conscience so while they served in their function they were never meant to do
50:01
Speaker A
what i think some people in the christian church think they were meant to do they were never they were never meant to stand in the place or hold a place until christ came they were simply to teach the principle
50:17
Speaker A
the principle of holiness and the principle that this is the method of being cleansed but this specific uh framework of the levitical priesthood levitical temple that's not that's not the that's not the mechanism the mechanism is christ but the temple and the priesthood taught
50:43
Speaker A
the method and showed the method and christ is he uses the method in the ultimate way and the ultimate temple and the ultimate temple i hope that kind of makes sense yeah i mean i agree to disagree but yeah it does make sense
50:56
Speaker A
thanks for explaining that yeah absolutely i mean if there was this anything that i could because i'm still kind of confused on it but i don't want to spend all night on this subject obviously we could be here six hours for sure but
51:09
Speaker A
i just want to read one john 1 7 and just try to understand what you guys are where you guys are coming from uh first john says this uh but if we walk in the light as he is in the light we have
51:19
Speaker A
fellowship with one another and the blood of jesus his son cleanses us from all sin and so it almost sound and please correct me if i'm wrong guys but it almost sounds like you're saying that jesus sacrifice cleanse the
51:34
Speaker A
inside the spiritual sin i guess if one could call it that and then the the blood or the animal sacrifices back under the old covenant uh did with the material is that am i missing what you guys are saying or
51:47
Speaker A
is that pretty close [Music] well no it's it's um the rehashing everything everything i said you got any thoughts um the only thing i would say is you know yeshua himself uh i'm going to kind of you know
52:06
Speaker A
mention this he talks about how the inside of the cup is what needs to be cleaned right and then the outside can be clean he's always pointing towards the inside of the cup the inside of the cup the inside of the cup the heart
52:19
Speaker A
right this cleansing cleanses that which is eternal that which is going to grow old and pass away that's under a different system it's that's that's not hmm well and the inside of the cup being planned leads to the outside of the cup
52:39
Speaker A
as well i think that's the common theme of of jesus teaching i mean it's the pharisees and the evil comes out of the heart you know that kind of yeah i agree with that yeah right here's here's what's my concern
52:50
Speaker A
and we can jump to i apologize tyler i mean that no no no you hit the buzzer but the one thought i'd throw out there is here's my concern and i don't quite know how to articulate it well so i'll just say this
53:04
Speaker A
my concern is that we are skating around in a theology in which christ's sacrifice was not sufficient that it other things were required beyond his sacrifice no no that that is not what is being said it's okay hebrews 8 4-5 you know if
53:22
Speaker A
yeshua were on earth he would not be a priest right they're already present tense present tense there are already priests who offer sacrifices according to the law so the law the torah the author of hebrews is saying that would actually still keep
53:40
Speaker A
yeshua from being a priest on earth they're they're two different job descriptions this is the best probably the simplest crudest way to put it you know it kind of kind of makes me wonder how you look at the prodigal son
53:53
Speaker A
right i mean doesn't the father welcome the son back and before the son can pretty much even do anything i mean the father restores him completely i mean completely i mean from the inside and the outside he throws his clothes upon
54:08
Speaker A
him and gives him the signet ring back and they go back into uh and have a party you know so obviously the inside is clean but the outside is also clothed in the righteousness of that father oh yeah we would affirm that you know yeah
54:26
Speaker A
because i think i have the same problem as as uh dr solberg and it doesn't seem like he's the perfect sacrifice at that point you know he is he is the perfect sacrifice but but what we also have to
54:38
Speaker A
keep in mind the stated goal of the sacrifice right so if his goal is not to transform into a physical lamb and be sacrificed on a literal altar for passover that wasn't his plan we're not devaluing him by saying
54:55
Speaker A
by saying that is that yeah of course yeah yeah i'm not saying i'm not saying yeah i'm just trying to understand it yeah yeah i hope that kind of yeah makes sense though but yeah so in hebrews 8
55:06
Speaker A
the book of hebrews was written while the temple was still standing so that's i think that tells us why there's a present tense there but i think the way that maybe we're approaching that slightly different is i agree it says
55:18
Speaker A
christ wouldn't even be qualified to be a high priest but as i read that it means under the law of moses because in hebrews 7 14 he says with the new priesthood comes a new law and so that means in my
55:32
Speaker A
opinion that means that there's a new not a brand new law and got everything changed but that god has given jesus has given us a new expression of the law of god in which the method of atonement shifted from
55:44
Speaker A
temporary animal sacrifices to a permanent one-time i mean it was a human sacrifice jesus laid his own life down because he had to pay or redeem human flesh that's why he lived perfectly in the flesh so i see that as a to me it's a
56:00
Speaker A
pivot point now i get what you're saying i've never actually heard that before that's really interesting the way you're kind of describing that yeah it's uh we got some resources we can throw your way and likewise we'll you know try to take whatever resources
56:12
Speaker A
you throw our way it's a vast fast discussion but yeah oh yeah absolutely that's the six-hour discussion hey we can go as long as you all want i don't have a time limit tonight we're just getting up on tyler
56:27
Speaker A
so one note on the priesthood hebrews does not say that there is a new law it says that there is a change or a transfer in the law so when we're speaking about the priesthood of yeshua there's a change in
56:41
Speaker A
the law that actually applies it's the heavenly law that's the law in focus and so in that sense there's a change in the law it does not say there is a new law no i agree yeah it says a new it says a
56:51
Speaker A
change in the law but in your book you did say with a new priesthood comes a new law correct yeah i suppose yeah that maybe that was poorly worded okay in fairness yeah but in essence if you have a law
57:07
Speaker A
that's now changed it's kind of a new law it's not the it's not and it's not a total change i i don't think there's any total change god is unchanging and perfect but i think the expression is what
57:17
Speaker A
changed not the principle yeah i get you i do sense yeah yeah um and dr solberg i got a question for you uh is that based off of your idea of objective i know your philosophy uh teacher and i'm a philosophy a student
57:33
Speaker A
going for my master's in it but is is it based off your idea of that the uh objective moral values and duties uh do progress as we discover them would that be fair i i believe objective duties and morals have been the same
57:49
Speaker A
forever i believe they're grounded in the person absolutely yeah who god is and those things yeah yeah but as but we discover them i'm not saying they change but we we are i you know how we discover them you
58:02
Speaker A
know i think you would you said it really well with the idea of uh what is it uh a child you know expressing it differently yeah yeah so like you know we discover morality we discover you know these things that have always
58:21
Speaker A
been there but right you know so that i feel like there's a sense of like paul talks about you you were given milk because you weren't ready for solid food yet right over time so if you if you look at the
58:34
Speaker A
growth of a child over time they're ready and cognitively able to understand more and if you look at the people of god they follow the same trajectory so at the beginning god speaking directly to adam that was that
58:47
Speaker A
was the right right right word trajectory uh and also like what i was thinking was like i use the same thing with people when uh um i'm talking about like you know you want to put an infant behind the wheel of a car
59:01
Speaker A
it doesn't work you know what i mean so yeah anyways i just wanted to clear that up too so tyler do you want to go on the breach the next subject yeah yeah we can go ahead and transition i do want to go
59:14
Speaker A
back to what you guys were saying about eating food so let me just ask this question uh from the rip and then we'll go on from it from there but what is it about eating certain foods that makes that sinful that practice
59:25
Speaker A
sinful is it because god said so in love leviticus 11 or how would you guys word that exactly i'll let you guys go first for it yeah yeah sorry raymond xavier sure so it it stems back to that same
59:43
Speaker A
uh frame of mind i was trying to lay down earlier which is when the law of moses was given by the son of god uh it's his law it was staked on his essence and his nature which we all agree doesn't change
59:58
Speaker A
when he says be holy as i am holy that standard of holiness changes only with his standard of holiness right so um he's he says that it is unholy to eat these things it is holy to eat these
60:15
Speaker A
things okay and um you know that didn't change when he came in the flesh as as the son of god as uh yeshua of nazareth um and it's it's consistent all the way through we never see him specifically
60:32
Speaker A
uh set that aside now one of the things we'll end up talking about i'm sure is mark 7 where he does speak on this topic but one of the things that's really important is that there is no statement in the torah that eating
60:51
Speaker A
something unclean makes you ritually unclean there is no prescription to cleanse yourself of eating something unclean nothing like that so whether what you ate was clean or unclean the torah does not say that your ritual state of purity has
61:11
Speaker A
changed okay now when someone start going sorry go ahead go ahead i apologize i was just gonna say when someone digests that food right and then right the the torah does talk about that and it says that what comes out of the
61:29
Speaker A
person after they eat can defile them ritually in mark 7 yeshua is taking that physical principle of the torah and he's taking it to a new level he's found it on the truth of the law of moses saying that nothing that
61:43
Speaker A
goes in your body makes you ritually unclean or not that which comes out does likewise it's what comes out of your heart that defiles you and he's taking it to a higher level that doesn't mean that it's not a moral
61:59
Speaker A
requirement to manifest god's holiness in what we eat our bodies are the temple he made us to be holy and to be in his image and you know since he is holy and the call is be holy as i am holy
62:15
Speaker A
like peter says like peter says and is reiterated in the you know the apostolic scriptures uh we'd love to see that be included in the new covenant law uh you know um we we think it's morally binding so
62:32
Speaker A
so whenever you said that there's no and i'm paraphrasing this i should have wrote it down but whenever you said that eating there there's no how did you word it there's no prescription in the torah that would that would basically if you
62:47
Speaker A
eat pork there's nothing that you can do to be cleansed from that correct so you guys would see a difference between something that's sinful and something that it makes you unclean like your example with a woman on a menstruation
63:00
Speaker A
right that makes her unclean but that's not necessarily sinful correct yeah it would only be sent if she decides to boldly waltz into the earthly temple then that would be sin uh okay but yeah and uh just a one quick note to add to
63:15
Speaker A
what raymond was saying yeah the closest you can kind of get is that you know a carcass can make you unclean ritually and clean but it should be noted that that goes for clean animals as well so that's true
63:28
Speaker A
that's interesting so what oh sorry go ahead yeah if i could toss in something here yeah um there are um holiness laws in the torah so there are so the concept of holiness and maybe we all already understand this but just to be clear is
63:45
Speaker A
the idea of separateness of being set apart of being held as sacred you're not it's as opposed to being profane or common you're holy you're set apart right so there are holy holiness laws in the torah um if you're familiar with jewish
64:02
Speaker A
categories so they've got something called chikem which are they use this to refer to the commandments that were established that make no sense basically these are what they call super rational so the idea that we have no idea why god asked this but
64:17
Speaker A
because he did it's in the torah we do it that kind of a thing and they include um the kosher food laws in that as well as like mixing fabrics like there's no obvious moral reason why uh kosher food the unclean food based on
64:32
Speaker A
the kosher list would be wrong but because god says it's wrong it's wrong and it's a sin and so they hold to that which i think is a it's really cool that they just admit we don't know why but
64:41
Speaker A
god says it so we're doing that i think that's cool but there's another category called mishpatim which is um that talks about obvious logical moral basis for the law so these are the laws against adultery and and honoring
64:56
Speaker A
your mother and father and against murder and all these sorts of things that very clearly serve a moral purpose especially in a society so the idea of the shakim which is the um the non-rational laws so to speak these are
65:12
Speaker A
sometimes called the holiness laws and so when you look at those laws they would include the kosher food laws the feasts circumcision is a big one um those sorts of things right so if in antiquity if you were walking through
65:27
Speaker A
the desert and you came across a tribe of people who let's say the males were circumcised they didn't work on saturday they didn't eat pork etc you would go those are israelites you would know they're not egyptians they're not
65:40
Speaker A
babylonians they're not assyrians that's the that's because israel was set apart got in 19 exodus 19 god says i'm i'm calling you the house of jacob the descendants of jacob to be a nation set apart a holy nation for me
65:53
Speaker A
um and so those laws were given to set israel apart so i think we all agree that we are called to be holy so my argument would be that principle that is god's people are to be set apart and holy that principle
66:08
Speaker A
never changes it was expressed under the mosaic law through those holiness laws prior to that well we can have that discussion later under the new expression i would propose that the way that we're holy and set apart from the
66:21
Speaker A
world is expressed differently now so we don't we don't have to eat because there is no jew and gentile in christ we see that a lot so so the idea that the things that set jews apart from gentiles under the mosaic
66:36
Speaker A
expression have now become under the new expression things that set christians apart from non-christians and that means christians whether jew or gentile and those would be things like the evidence of the holy spirit in our lives uh by our love they will know you they
66:50
Speaker A
will know you belong to me by your love for one another that kind of thing by our confession of faith that's a big one so i think the holiness principles still exist but they're expressed totally differently now that we're under a new
67:01
Speaker A
covenant so we would all agree that holiness is definitely far more than just what you eat right but we're saying what we're what we're saying is it it certainly isn't any less than what you eat whatever you do whatever you eat or
67:16
Speaker A
drink do all for the glory of god yeah all of it should be for the glory of god so uh you know i'll i'll let you step in for a second yeah so you it's kind of a common
67:29
Speaker A
argument that maybe certain commandments are are given to israel ethnically people will say to kind of set them apart from the nations uh even some within the the messianic torah spectrum as frosted calls it his paper such as first fruits of zion for example
67:45
Speaker A
would say that certain commandments like tassels circumcision the sabbath the dietary instructions those are specific ethnic markers of the jewish people and so they even have their own category you can see how vast this spectrum is i think my problem with that
68:01
Speaker A
there are a few um all of the torah was given for israel to be different than the nations and we can see this in leviticus chapter 18 when we have the laws of sexual morality and he says the nations i'm casting out do
68:13
Speaker A
these things you do not do them right in leviticus 19 what's known as the holiness code he starts out by saying i am yahweh be holy for i am holy and he goes on to list things about honoring your mother and
68:28
Speaker A
father keeping the sabbath then he switches to planting and the types of things you plant and it's just kind of like it's it's a hodgepodge of stuff in there but all of it is to be set apart deuteronomy 12 also goes into that zero
68:41
Speaker A
12. and the the third thing i would say is that you mentioned the statutes and the judgments and we've we're familiar with jewish categories of laws as well we agree with them to various extents depending on the subject but ezekiel
68:54
Speaker A
chapter 36 prophesying of the new covenant says i will take my spirit and put it within you and i will remove the heart of flesh i mean heart of stone and put in your heart of flesh and you will
69:04
Speaker A
observe my hakim and my mispatient so ezekiel 36 says that in the new covenant the statues and judgments are to be observed okay so my response to that would be that what we see in the torah by way of by way of holiness laws
69:24
Speaker A
god judges the let me ask it a different way let me ask you a question because i don't i'm about to make an assumption instead of that i want to ask if you guys know if there's anywhere in the torah or the
69:35
Speaker A
whole tanakh that uh god judges other nations for eating non-kosher food in the same way that he judges them for sexual sins and murder and all that kind of stuff i don't know that i can think of i mean
69:50
Speaker A
maybe isaiah 66 although he does talk about his people um isaiah 66 you have a judgment on uh what i i could be wrong but it seems like people who are eating swine's flesh but i think the premise might be flawed because there's
70:04
Speaker A
lots of other things as well that he doesn't judge the nations for which we would all agree are moral and we could dig into that but i don't think the premise is correct if we're just talking about my premise was that the kosher laws are
70:15
Speaker A
not laws of morality that those other ones are laws of objective morality the kosher laws the kosher food laws are laws of obedience and holiness so they're only immoral because god said don't do that they're not immoral in other words god didn't
70:33
Speaker A
impose on babylon or assyria or any of these other nations these food restrictions but he imposed it on israel larger things the mishpatim the the murder the adultery the sacrificing of your children god judged other nations for those
70:48
Speaker A
things because those are objectively morally wrong that's that's kind of i was getting at it well yeah but remember the premise the thing that you're trying to prove is that certain laws are moral and some are not so i could be wrong but
70:58
Speaker A
it kind of seems like a circle a bit that's that's the point of debate yeah i'm just saying that the kosher food laws the morality is not inherent to the activity of eating pork the the morality lies at the level of obedience
71:14
Speaker A
that that's all i'm trying to get out and so that that's why i believe under the new expression of god's unchanging law that the way his people are set apart is different now it's the expression has changed but the principle
71:27
Speaker A
of the law of god has not we still need to be holy as he is holy so just like in your analogy with the young child where you know when he was young don't hit your brother when he goes to school
71:40
Speaker A
don't say mean things when he goes off to college say nice things right or maybe it's when he gets married say nice things to your wife you know just like in that analogy you know he never turns away from not hitting his
71:57
Speaker A
brother sure right yeah and i i would i'll admit that's a flaw of that analogy it can only only be pressed so far because that part's not congruous with with my larger um let's call it a theory about the
72:10
Speaker A
unchanging principles of god i like it sure yeah so um i would say that uh in deuteronomy i'm the passage is failing me but uh god says something along these lines he says when you keep this law the nations
72:28
Speaker A
will look at you and say wow what a wise and prosperous people right um so god did give this this law the son gave this law to the nation of israel it was designed to incorporate more than just an ethnic group it was designed to
72:47
Speaker A
take in people just like it did in its inception with the mixed multitude it was designed to have people come in and become part of the people of god was situated where it was at right at this crossroads in the ancient world so
73:05
Speaker A
that when people traveled from africa to asia from from ethiopia to you know the hittites they would pass through this land they would hear about this god right and they would join themselves to the god of israel including passages like you know
73:21
Speaker A
isaiah 56 where you know he says that if you would turn from doing what you want to do and you would delight in me that even the foreigner will be able to worship with me right that the aim of
73:34
Speaker A
the covenant uh with at sinai was more broad than just israel right so um while are you saying that there were that that covenant was made with more than just israel well it was it was made with the native
73:53
Speaker A
born and the stranger and and even those uh such as caleb the quezonite right caleb was from the tribe of judah but he was not an ethnic israelite so it is certainly included in internet you see him how could he not be an ethnic israelite
74:11
Speaker A
if he's from a tribe of israel gotcha let me let me rephrase what i said that wasn't the best way to say it his lineage is not of israel is that is that better it's jeans so there's a whole group of people that
74:23
Speaker A
came out of egypt in the exodus caleb is one of those mixed multitudes he's a kazonite he's he's he engrafted into the tribe of judah so gotcha after that point he's part of judah by his current identity but in terms of his ethnicity he was you
74:46
Speaker A
know he was a cousin but just a player it seems to me the cove because i know about the mixed multitude and i think it's exodus 12 somewhere 38 maybe that when they left israel after the passover a mixed multitude
75:02
Speaker A
joined them and i think it's very reasonable to conclude or suggest that that mixed multitude was still with them three or four months later when they got to mount sinai and the law started being given so that part i get but it seems to me that
75:16
Speaker A
in exodus 19 3-6 actually one through six it god is telling moses i'm making a specific covenant i'm pulling you out of all the other nations of the earth i'm pulling you israel which he defines as the house of jacob
75:30
Speaker A
which would of course would be a term meaning the physical descendants of jacob uh that the covenant was just with what we would call the jews or the israelites and the if there were others at present a mixed multitude they
75:44
Speaker A
weren't under the covenant they weren't bound by it or you know what i mean well the the torah says over and over that the the guerre the stranger who sojourns among you um we see them present at the feasts
75:59
Speaker A
uh we see that there's one law for the native born and the stranger now judaism and other people would say that maybe they had the option to join um there's different types of strangers in the hebrew text as well so it can get a bit
76:10
Speaker A
confusing but uh but clearly um maybe the best way to tie this to to the relevance for today would be the fact that paul says that we are we too are grafted into the olive tree which jeremiah 11 defines as israel so
76:26
Speaker A
we don't see a change in in that regard that was always the plan yeah yeah i agree yeah and so but we do see that there is no slave or a free male or female jew or gentile and that and that in ephesians 2
76:41
Speaker A
one of the reasons god did away with the ordinances jesus did away with the ordinances is to drop to break down that dividing wall of hostility because there was that separation i i which i would suggest is based on
76:52
Speaker A
those holiness laws between jews and gentiles now there might be some gray area in between what we what they call in the new testament the god fearers so the gentiles who maybe wanted to come to synagogue and they began
77:03
Speaker A
trying to they were attracted to and began worshiping the god of israel um but they were not it's my understanding they weren't considered part of the covenant itself and they weren't even subject to the entire law of moses there were the the
77:19
Speaker A
noahide laws for the gentile believers that traveled with um with the exception of when they were literally in israel then of course just like you're when you're in france you obey french laws when you're in israel you obey the law of moses because
77:33
Speaker A
that's the reigning law but even then there's differences like they could give things to to strangers like the rest of their food and things like that which in israelite couldn't eat but they're free to give it the others in their
77:46
Speaker A
midst but they could never give them anything unclean to eat yeah they could grab that for themselves right so the only thing that they could give them was there was a certain standard of holiness for people within the covenant and outside of the covenant
78:02
Speaker A
but we're talking about clean meat in both cases so the fact that they weren't allowed to just give them unclean meat should should kind of fill in that hole i think but um man there's another thing i wanted to
78:15
Speaker A
mention well can i quickly mention that the the noahide laws i would strongly push back and there's scholarship for this as well that that is a later invention of rabbinic judaism okay yeah also the terms the term jew and gentile in the first
78:30
Speaker A
century i there's a lot baked into those two terms uh specifically with jew being an ethnic marker uh people who either had completely proselytized and gone through a ritual conversion according to the tradition of the elders or people who of course are born within
78:53
Speaker A
uh you know an as an ethnic jew right and this strict boundary line of being a jew according to this strict tradition uh is no more neither is gentile anymore because in ephesians chapter two later on down it says that we're all one in
79:18
Speaker A
the commonwealth of israel we're all one in christ right so there is no jew there is no gentile there is israel in christ or as you said in your book israel of god and i think that's the appropriate
79:29
Speaker A
term paul talks about it this way he says not all who are israel are israel right but there's israel according to the flesh there's israel according to the faith and israel of god is israel according to the faith
79:42
Speaker A
my understanding is if we are grafted into israel then we are full partakers in the covenants of israel plural covenants is plural yeah it's it's plural covenants here so we're a full partaker in the noetic covenant right we can still look at a rainbow and
80:00
Speaker A
we can see that sign of the covenant and we can take hope he is not going to flood the world again we're still we're still a partaker in the abrahamic covenant we have faith like abraham we are sons of abraham we are full
80:13
Speaker A
partakers in the cyanidic covenant as well so um what do you think what do you make of hebrews 8 13 that tells us when he said this the new covenant became obsolete but the old covenant became obsolete when he spoke about the new covenant how
80:29
Speaker A
do you read that even hebrews 8 13. let me pull it up really quick let's see phrase it i'm sorry i'm really bad with what's happening yeah i got you so actually the word covenant is not in the greek theory um
80:47
Speaker A
in that he says a new he made he has made the first obsolete now what is becoming obsolete and growing old is ready to vanish away it hadn't vanished away yet and i think you're probably right in saying that hebrews was written
80:59
Speaker A
before the destruction of the temple i would actually say he's talking about the priesthoods here and not the covenants uh why would you suggest that because the context is real quick where are we at hebrews where 8 13. hebrews 8 13 okay
81:19
Speaker A
the whole chapter is talking about jesus is is a high priest of a better covenant and so it would make sense that on the final verse there he's saying and speaking of a new covenant he makes the first one obsolete
81:32
Speaker A
and so what's becoming obsolete which at the time this was written was becoming obsolete and in my argument it's not in scripture but my argument would be that where it says it's growing old and ready to vanish away well at the destruction
81:43
Speaker A
of the temple in a.d 70 i think that's when god put a period at the end of that sentence and vanished and just ask real quick just ask a clarifying question do you guys know of any bible translations that would
81:56
Speaker A
translate priesthood there instead of covenant no the subject is assumed right uh yeah the subject has to be assumed by the side right by the context so a couple things on that because number one when the author of hebrews wants to use
82:11
Speaker A
the word covenant he does use the word covenant that's the first point now that doesn't mean it can't mean the word covenant but it does mean we're going to have to show by context why that's the best fit and right the reason
82:22
Speaker A
i think the priesthood is the best fit is because that's actually the context of chapter eight entirely better high priest there's this entire government between between aaron and yeshua and using melchizedek it's a it's a complex argument that takes place
82:42
Speaker A
over multiple chapters and the focus seems to be more so the priesthood than it is the covenant well in verse 8 he starts quoting from jeremiah who's talking about the new covenant when i will establish a new covenant with the house of israel in the
82:58
Speaker A
house of judah not like the covenant i made with their fathers etc did not continue in my covenant there's all that covenant language and then so you're right it starts with some priesthood discussion at the beginning of chapter eight but then you know he
83:12
Speaker A
actually quotes from it might be the septuagint here but the old testament quotes from uh jeremiah the prophet and then wraps it up with the comment and not only and sorry rob just just to add to that in verse seven we see i mean word for
83:27
Speaker A
word it for if the first covenant had been faultless there would have been no occasion to look for a second so just to kind of reiterate what rob said there is pre-said language within those first six uh verses but then it seems like there's
83:40
Speaker A
a switch and especially with the quote from jeremiah yeah it definitely talks about both um i think based on the context of chapter eight and the whole book really though the focus is the priesthood specifically uh it's not a book it's not a book about
83:55
Speaker A
just all of the different aspects of like or commandments in the covenant that's why i agree but it does talk about jesus is a superior priest who made a superior sacrifice and a superior temple under a superior covenant so all those things are in view
84:11
Speaker A
when you look at holistically kind of how hebrews lays out and uh in in chapter eight here he does actually use the the literal word for covenant um throughout that whole text and so at the bottom you're right it is a bit up to the
84:28
Speaker A
translator what was he talking about it's a little bit of a almost like a pronoun situation he didn't say the actual subject so the so the translator says has to determine what i'm going to put in there yeah no you could definitely you could
84:43
Speaker A
definitely make a case for either i think that perhaps the the verse he cited should give us some clarity jeremiah 31 says the torah will be written on our hearts and of course we believe that is the torah of moses which is the torah of
84:58
Speaker A
messiah so if it's written in our on our hearts context would would demand that it's not going to pass away yeah i agree i don't think the torah passed away and i would actually see it as the law
85:10
Speaker A
of god with our hearts but but it does but it does make sense that the covenant would pass away we see in galatians 3 that it says it was that the law was given till christ came and we're not
85:20
Speaker A
under that guardian anymore so there's a sense of saying that the and also we see the law and all the sabbaths and food and drink and all these things referred to as shadows in several places here in hebrews 10 1 i
85:33
Speaker A
think it is and and paul does it in colossians 2 so there's this sense that the law of moses which paul says is perfect and just and righteous and all that stuff but it was not the final thing
85:45
Speaker A
that the shadowing that they talk about would would to me suggest what they mean is foreshadowing there's a time element there rob congratulations you have now multiplied it six hours times two with those kind of words okay i'll go ahead and call into work
86:00
Speaker A
now right you guys are awesome man thanks this is like i don't often get a chance to go uh chat back and forth like this with folks as knowledgeable as you and passionate as you who have different views than me this is great really
86:15
Speaker A
generous thank you um okay well let's see what we said okay one quick note on the torah of moses versus the torah of god uh ezra and nehemiah use the two interchangeably um if you read through nehemiah i think eight when
86:29
Speaker A
they're rediscovering the torah they celebrate the feast of tabernacles they're used exactly interchangeably now in your book you say actually no not your book sorry in your video on second corinthians 3 you do make a distinction between the law of god and the law of
86:42
Speaker A
moses however that's i would argue that's not a distinction scripture makes okay that's the first point and then what was next um the tutor oh yeah the tutor yeah so um not being under the the school master anymore
87:01
Speaker A
um tyler might be familiar with this analogy i think i've used it a couple times but uh here's here's how i understand that passage in galatians chapter three so you've got a student who's going to let's say uh engineering school uh this will make
87:20
Speaker A
my parents proud since i graduated anyway uh so you got a student who's going to engineering school and he's got to go to calculus class right he's got to go to thermodynamics he's got to take english for some reason even though he's an
87:35
Speaker A
engineer he's got to write papers so he's got to go to all these classes right uh well the school forces them to go to these classes the school forces them to do homework the school puts all this pressure on the student to perform right
87:48
Speaker A
now after the school gets to a certain after the student gets to a certain point in this process he graduates right and he becomes service certified as an engineer he no longer has to do calculus homework he no longer is forced to do
88:05
Speaker A
thermodynamics uh write english papers so on and so forth right he goes out he gets a job he's an engineer well he doesn't just cease listening to the teachers that he learned from in college right he applies those things from a place of
88:24
Speaker A
being he's now an engineer now he does calculus because he's been taught those things he does thermodynamics because he's been taught those things not because he's being forced to i think paul's trying to show us the difference between
88:38
Speaker A
somebody who has uh the law from outside themselves pressuring them versus someone who has the law inside themselves living it freely and it doesn't it doesn't do away with the teacher right or what the teacher taught he's still going to use
88:57
Speaker A
everything he learned along the way right so are you saying that maybe it's the torah's function as a tutor has may have ceased but that does not mean it's not a moral code yeah exactly well you know what
89:09
Speaker A
raymond you're are you the one with the gray shirt i forgot i got it mixed up yeah raymond all right that's a great analogy so i i like that i mean it's just like mine we can't press it too far
89:18
Speaker A
but it really does a good job and i think it actually ties in with my with my theory because under the mosaic expression of the law we have the 613 under the new expression jesus said you know what you can keep all of them by
89:33
Speaker A
keeping these two that you know and paul said the same thing if you're if you're taking care of your neighbor you're fulfilling the law so i think you're right that he nothing gets thrown away this is the reason that we paul could
89:44
Speaker A
tell us that the law or scripture and to him that would have been the old testament to us is still useful for reproof and correction and righteous living and all those things we can affirm that because the mosaic expression of the ultimate
89:58
Speaker A
unchanging law of god points us to the higher law it points us to the heart of god actually that's why that law shows us god's heart but now under the new now that we've graduated from engineering school we we understand or we're free to then
90:16
Speaker A
exercise those laws and we really can fulfill them by just keeping two love god and love love your neighbor that's what that's that's how i would read what you just said if i could jump around the back of your analogy
90:29
Speaker A
and try to hijack it sorry um let's see i guess we could go in the direction of the the two on which the torah hangs um and that is the language that is used upon these two commandments depend hang
90:43
Speaker A
the law on the prophets right it's those are a summary they're not a replacement they're a summary and so it'd be the guiding force that whenever we keep these commandments right that we're not just looking at laws in the
90:55
Speaker A
letter and trying to find some way i can help some guy with his oxen but not his horse right i should i should see that commandment through the lens of love my neighbor as i love myself right uh or as or as yeshua said in matthew 7
91:11
Speaker A
verse 12 uh whatever that is that you would have done unto yourself doing to others this is the law and the prophets right he summed it up just into one if we want to and uh habakkuk summed it up into one the just
91:23
Speaker A
shall live by faith you know so if if i i see i see those as lenses through which we should see the commandments not that this is a new law right um but all the commandments could every commandment could roll up to one of
91:40
Speaker A
those two if we kind of brought it back to its foundational principle either absolutely yeah sure absolutely now i have a question for you um if we're are we allowed to shoot back questions yeah we're about an hour and a half
91:59
Speaker A
okay um so in in your book you talk about a new covenant with a new law so uh rob would you say that matthew through revelation constitutes the new covenant that the that the apostle matthew no like the books the books and and
92:21
Speaker A
oh matthew through okay brought you through revelation would you say that that is the new covenant i turned i i heard you totally wrong would i well no not necessarily because revelation begins to look towards the future well so in my opinion
92:40
Speaker A
the new covenant was inaugurated by jesus through his blood and so under that uh going with my theory again that was when we got a new expression of god's unchanging law because i i don't think well there could be disagreement i don't
92:59
Speaker A
think it's possible to say that nothing changed between the mosaic covenant and the new covenant we know we know there were changes so though those changes now everything expressed under the mosaic covenant 95 was included in the new covenant
93:18
Speaker A
and all of the law of god principles were obviously included but there were some changes so so i i don't know if i exactly answered your question i think uh matthew i think the new testament gives us the
93:34
Speaker A
scope of the new covenant okay i think that's in real quick room let me jump in on that i think that that's an interesting question because matthew mark luke and john were all written after jesus died right after the new
93:50
Speaker A
covenant had been inaugurated but at the same time they're still giving a depiction of what happened during jesus's life so the state or so what happened during that time i would see and if jesus fulfilled the mosaic law
94:04
Speaker A
for us right i believe that the old covenant would still be in place during matthew mark luke and john if we're reading it like that does that make sense yeah up until the resurrection i would agree with that and
94:16
Speaker A
that would make john the baptist our final old testament prophet or covenant prophet so rob you um you would say if i understood your book correctly that for a okay you said that yeshua kind of took like some most
94:36
Speaker A
commands from the law of moses and then he added some new ones and then that is the law of christ did i understand that correctly um he restated some and then yeah he restated many and not only him i
94:52
Speaker A
i do believe that the epistles are part of helping us understand the new covenant they include they're included in that as well not not just the i mean the gospels i agree with tyler up until christ was or crucified we were still under the old
95:08
Speaker A
covenant that's why jesus had to keep the law perfectly okay yeah as far as the new the the laws and the change um under the new expression i would in my opinion i would say that the principles of god never changed the
95:24
Speaker A
expression changed but a lot the expression did add some new stuff yeah it did and it also elevated the mosaic expression to be more like the true pure principle so i have an additional question for you um so when we see different covenants
95:41
Speaker A
given in the tanakh or the hebrew scriptures we see that god lays out the covenant he lays out the conditions the terms and conditions of the covenant some people call that the covenant law all right and you know those seem to be
95:57
Speaker A
coterminous events right well it seems to me they get they kind of are an addition so you have the abrahamic covenant that didn't go away that actually we are heirs of under christ you have the noah covenant you have the
96:13
Speaker A
davidic covenant uh i don't see them terminating other covenants no no but when i'm saying when i say coterminous i mean that when the covenant is made a law is given that gives the guidelines of that covenant right so
96:29
Speaker A
that all covenants come with laws or prom or we can say in case of like davidic covenant promises are specified right yeah so for example when god came down on mount sinai to establish the covenant with them he gave them the law
96:45
Speaker A
when god established the covenant with abraham with circumcision he established the law with circumcision right well yeah that was given as a sign though wasn't it but it was a commandment for him to circumcise suppose yeah yeah so our question would be
97:01
Speaker A
where is that law clearly given in the apostolic scriptures with the new covenant where where is that relayed and mount a sermon on the mount is a good spot to look the sermon on the mount matthew 5-7 yeah the sermon on the
97:21
Speaker A
mountain details all things in the law of moses right totally reaffirms the law of moses and it takes place during that old covenant period that you guys were talking right during which you said yeshua had to be under the old covenant
97:32
Speaker A
so if he was under the old covenant before his death and resurrection we we can't have him teaching against torah or teaching you can eat whatever you want you would have to at least extend your logic until resurrection then that would
97:44
Speaker A
be consistent well actually i i don't think god works in those very specific binary ways i think scripture does scripture shows us that there are these um liminal spaces these these it's kind of like what i described in
98:01
Speaker A
the changeover box there's a 40-year period between christ and the in the in the temple's destruction to give god's people time to switch over there's a 40-year period between rescue from egypt and getting into the promised land to give
98:15
Speaker A
people time and interestingly in exodus 16 god's giving a sabbath commandment about the manna before they've even gotten to mount sinai and so he's almost i believe we're in a a crossfade of sorts so god doesn't say on this day at this time such and such
98:34
Speaker A
i think with christ we have maybe the most articulate version of that in terms of hey he died the temple veil was torn apart all this stuff happened but even then there's overlap so i wouldn't personally i wouldn't want to be so
98:48
Speaker A
um black and white or binary about exactly when the new covenant came in uh because for that exact reason you got you got matthew 5 7 jesus he said right before he gave all the you have heard it
99:01
Speaker A
said but i say to you right before that he tells us hey guys just so you know i'm about to say some really radical things i want you to know that i didn't come to abolish the law but to fulfill it
99:14
Speaker A
then he goes on and gives us changes to the law of moses uh not changes additions to the law of moses so you heard it said this i'm going to elevate it to the new expression which is even more uh even
99:26
Speaker A
higher you know what i mean so there was new concepts introduced okay so i think hebrews tells us that the new covenant began upon yeshua's death um the covenant starts with the death of the one making the covenant in yeshua's
99:45
Speaker A
case he was also the covenant sacrifice and so in his blood right yeah right so for that reason that's when that's where i would have to pin the inauguration of the new covenant because that's what hebrews says sure um
99:59
Speaker A
now i guess we're trying to figure out like the reason we asked you know is matthew through revelation you know do they detail the new covenant because it's kind of nebulous like i mean would you be would you say that
100:12
Speaker A
if the command is not reaffirmed in the apostolic writings that it is not binding if a man is not reaffirmed no no if um if a man if a command in the torah of moses is not reaffirmed in the apostolic writings by yeshua or
100:31
Speaker A
the apostles if it's not reaffirmed would you say that that commandment is not binding not necessarily i think we'd need to look at it as a case-by-case basis so but it seems i could be wrong but it seems to me that the goal posts
100:43
Speaker A
are being moved we have maybe it's the resurrection when it's inaugurated maybe some of it trickled in earlier maybe it's 70 a.d um and it's just it's kind of hard i wouldn't think no i i wasn't saying that 70 a.d was
100:56
Speaker A
when the new uh the new covenant was inaugurated so that's kind of the end of the changeover box that concept for those of you who don't haven't seen my book there's the idea of when you're running a relay you have your baton there's a
101:09
Speaker A
small section of track called the changeover box where the new runner gets up to speed hands the baton to the old runner or maybe i do have the way around yeah right the old runner comes in with the baton the other guy gets up to speed
101:21
Speaker A
they're running together for a little while and then the new runner takes off so in my that's just the simple analogy that i use to show that there's that it's not a straight cut uh that there's a god allows i think in my mind he's
101:34
Speaker A
condescending for our human limitations he's making these paradigm shifts in the way he's relating to people um and so i mean not even just those 40 years i mean it took us how long to figure out the trinity that's mind-blowing
101:50
Speaker A
stuff which is really cool because who would want to worship a god that you can totally understand that wouldn't be very cool but so i think i think there is and and big ambiguity it's clear that the covenant was
102:03
Speaker A
inaugurated on jesus death because he says yeah my blood contains the covenant here's the you know so but i do think there's uh some ambiguity there just like we see in the old testament why is the sabbath given before the
102:18
Speaker A
sabbath is given you know okay i guess that's a biblical precedent okay i think i understand what you're saying i guess um it's important for any any theory to be testable right like oh yeah no none of us we we don't we don't
102:34
Speaker A
want to make our theories unfalsified um unfalsifiable like right yep you have to show like this is how it would be proven wrong right and so i because it really seemed like in the book maybe i just read it wrong but that
102:48
Speaker A
something had to be refirmed reaffirmed to be part of the new covenant but when i think of bestiality cross-dressing kidnapping you know none of which are reaffirmed and you have a solid writings that that hermeneutic would say it would seem problematic uh but then
103:04
Speaker A
now you're saying it doesn't necessarily have to be reaffirmed some i'm having a hard time pinning down what what to address because okay yeah i got you that's fair that's a fair question and i may have i was just a kid when i wrote that book
103:17
Speaker A
just kidding it was uh three years ago but um i have actually come a long way in my theology because for the raise you just said if a theory needs to be challengeable and where i find it falls
103:30
Speaker A
short of biblical standards i have to change i have to go with scripture not i don't want to force anything onto text i need to understand what it's telling me so so in that regard if you're talking about things that are
103:43
Speaker A
let's call them grossly moral issues some of that maybe is addressed by paul you know in romans 1 where he talks about we kind of know and especially now that the law is written in our hearts we know those things are wrong and i
103:56
Speaker A
actually think that a lot of those things were known to be wrong by other nations even in under the mosaic expression you know they're objective moral issues so okay many of many of those to put a label on it if i can help categorize
104:12
Speaker A
what you're i think what you're asking that no all the moral laws do not need to be restated for a christian to be expected to obey the moral laws okay i would at least go that far okay that's
104:26
Speaker A
that's definitely helpful um i guess to some to sum up uh how how we see the issue and whether we don't believe matthew through revelation is the new covenant you know we believed it's inspired scripture it's inspired commentary as well it's
104:39
Speaker A
drawing out principles we think that the reason we don't have a moment where he says now this is the new covenant and these are the commands of the new covenant is because the same torah is written on our hearts so
104:52
Speaker A
for us what changed at the death burial and resurrection was simply the location of the torah it's no longer on tablets of stones and so i guess perhaps we're overly simplistic in our thinking but that we don't we don't have to wade through
105:05
Speaker A
like some of that stuff i guess that's a ton of sense actually i get where you're coming from yeah i i got a question to raise real quick for you guys i'm talking about the overlap of the covenants you guys would both agree that
105:16
Speaker A
jesus declared all foods clean and matthew i'm sorry mark 7 19 correct well it depends on which manuscripts you go with no we don't favor the critical texts we do favor the texas receptus and stones can start you know oh man that's
105:29
Speaker A
that's bad all right here we go david's been silent now so what does the texas receptus say in in mark 7 19 uh it's eliminated kind of like through the idea is that it's eliminated through feces you know
105:47
Speaker A
purging purging all means is how the kjv puts it we would get stoned even by our own um that's the hebrew poop laws right just kidding sorry a little joke there's a rock no we don't accept that reading but even if
106:00
Speaker A
we did accept it it still doesn't disprove the dietary instructions because food is defined as what is clean sometimes people in the torah not in that not in that passage though yeah so the greek word there is broma am i
106:20
Speaker A
mistaken no that's right yes it refers to any kind of food yeah so broma if i'm not mistaken in the septuagint is what is uh is what spoken of in leviticus 11.
106:34
Speaker A
um so it's already yeah it's already defined and i could be mistaken but uh my understanding is that brahma has already been defined as those things which you can put in your mouth that have already been made clean
106:52
Speaker A
by scripture god has already declared that clean it's been sanctified regardless of whether or not it's your hands are clean or you've gone through a certain ritual or not that which god has said is clean broma according to his word
107:07
Speaker A
he's clean yeah right jesus cleaned something that was already clean yes because so because the issue was one of ritual purity so in the mishnah which is um people debate its finalization but it's a kind of a jewish oral law
107:23
Speaker A
um written well some people say third century you know i don't know for sure but um i'm not saying everything in the mishnah is present in the first century that would be probably mistaken but it's the closest thing we have there's actually a track
107:35
Speaker A
tractate a section called yada i'm probably mispronouncing it but yada yim it has to do with the washing of hands and later jewish tradition went to great lengths to make sure the hands were ritually pure i mean some of them even
107:49
Speaker A
said like it has to be a certain amount of water uh you gotta immerse a certain amount of your arm in it and that really i'm not saying word for word that's what yeshua is addressing but mark 7 and matthew 15 do
108:01
Speaker A
say to eat bread with unwashed hands does not defile a man so we are talking about the traditions of the elders and that is actually juxtaposed in mark 7 with the torah of moses there are two things that's interesting
108:17
Speaker A
that jesus is talking about i mean that was the first question they asked right and that there is a discussion about that about these man-made uh requirements the traditions of manny what he calls it so yeah that's definitely part of that conversation
108:31
Speaker A
so like extrapolating from that a little further what's going on is the certain pharisees we can't paint them all with a broad brush that research now shows there are many different types of judaisms but certain pharisees had kind of extended the priestly law
108:48
Speaker A
like the priests have to wash their hands right they sort of extended that to the people is what it seems like and now when you eat just bread something that's already defined as food now they're saying no that's impure
109:01
Speaker A
and yeshua is saying it's not what goes into a man and raven laid out the example of the excrement later but so that's why he would have to say that all food is clean because they were making defined food ritually and pure by their
109:12
Speaker A
tradition that's why he had to do that now i have i have another question for rob if if i'm allowed to no well real quick raymond before you go there sorry i was muted um so that's interesting that you guys say that
109:28
Speaker A
because so is paul contradicting what jesus taught then in first corinthians 10 23 let me just read it for listeners that don't have their bibles all things are lawful but not all things are helpful all things are lawful but not all things
109:40
Speaker A
build up let no one seek his own good but the good of his neighbor eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience for the earth is the lord's and the fullness thereof if
109:52
Speaker A
one of the unbelievers invites you to dinner you are and you're disposed to go eat whatever is set before you without raising any question on the ground of conscience so it seems like if you what you guys are saying is true paul seems
110:04
Speaker A
to be contradicting what jesus saw go for it so um we can we can logically understand that paul is not saying no matter what anyone puts in front of you you're supposed to if they'd have put if they were cannibals
110:21
Speaker A
and put human flesh in front of you you're not he's not saying you can eat it right well human flesh wouldn't be sold in the meat market right i'm talking specifically about you're sitting here you're sitting at somebody's house right sure what part of
110:34
Speaker A
that was if you're sitting at somebody's house and they give you something to eat so i'm specifically referencing that not in the marketplace at the moment okay so obviously there's there's some limitations here obviously not everything here is lawful right because
110:48
Speaker A
we're not going to eat human flesh at somebody's cannibal house somewhere you know maybe in i don't know i don't want to even disparage africa because there's a lot of really good people in africa uh but uh you know obviously there's some
111:01
Speaker A
limitations here if somebody was to serve any sort of wild and exotic thing is not an excuse for you just to eat it there is a thing going on in the first century in the marketplace when it comes to meat
111:15
Speaker A
that's been sacrificing pagan temples and then later that same meat is being sold in the marketplace so we're talking about meat that and we all agree the early christians were mostly jewish right these mostly jewish christians would have been
111:32
Speaker A
buying in the marketplace and during the changeover period if i just use that term i'm not yielding the point uh but even in his book rob says that the jews were practicing a lot of the same things they were practicing from
111:46
Speaker A
the old covenant era they wouldn't have been buying unclean meat in the marketplace right so we're talking about whether or not it is okay to buy clean meat in the marketplace or not whether when it's doubtful if this thing had
112:03
Speaker A
been strangled slaughtered to a pagan altar and all this other stuff so uh in first corinthians chapter 10 what paul is saying is that if you if you don't know then don't let your conscience become defiled when you're buying me in the
112:20
Speaker A
marketplace now that's not excusing you to go down to the pagan altar and go pick some meat off the plate and partake in a covenant meal down there different things revelation chapter 2 explicitly forbids that and paul in another place explicitly forbids it
112:37
Speaker A
as well we're talking about meat that is of unknown use within a pagan offering and we're talking about clean meat in the marketplace so if i could ask where do you see in the text support for that those restrictions
112:54
Speaker A
you're putting on it that it means certainly kosher meat and that then when they sit down for a meal it's at a another jewish person's house guys just to real really quick just to piggyback on that because the greek i'm
113:06
Speaker A
i'm looking here it says uh eat pond whatever is set before you and we all know that that's from the greek word posh right meaning everything and so yeah just to reiterate that so there's a saying that sometimes
113:19
Speaker A
calvinists tell their armenian friends and it's kind of they would be wrong what was that i thought they would be wrong david's just a heretic don't mind him it's kind of a um not a mocking phrase don't misunderstand
113:37
Speaker A
but it's like all means all and that's all it means so all has to be qualified by a certain context when this is shown time and time again in scripture when there's a decree that goes out to all the world did it go to
113:53
Speaker A
new zealand right or was that it was so the fact that it says every or all in the greek would not be the question to resolve i mean if it was that simple then well that would there would be all kinds of absurdities
114:08
Speaker A
yeah so i i don't disagree that those words are present in the text but it's all within a certain context and that context is what we're debating right right and in that context you you go even to verse 28 but if someone says
114:21
Speaker A
to you this has been offered in sacrifice what you guys have brought up earlier then do not eat it but for whose sake for the sake of the one who informed you and for the sake of conscience i do not mean your conscience
114:32
Speaker A
but his so what paul is talking about is don't do something that's going to make your brother stumble right but for your sake it's perfectly fine to do those things so i'm just going to kind of echoes that in romans 14 through 15 too
114:44
Speaker A
right correct yes and we would actually connect the two passages romans 14 with the the discourse on idols in first corinthians we mention of the weaker brother or week a week conscience okay so in areas where there is um
115:00
Speaker A
christian liberty as people call it it is up to your conscience there is no commandment this will be a little controversial even for some in our movement but there is no commandment in the torah that says that you cannot eat
115:13
Speaker A
food sacrifice to idols in any context there is a prohibition in exodus 34 which we see in numbers 25 if there's a covenant meal and especially if you sleep with a temple prostitute that's also really bad so but that's not the same thing as um
115:30
Speaker A
eating something that might have been maybe was offered to an idol one's explicitly condemned in the torah one is not since it's not condemned in the torah it becomes a matter of personal freedom david you got anything you want to add
115:46
Speaker A
you've been pretty quiet over there buddy well i've just been listening i mean you guys have been been rocking it man so uh yeah i don't have anything right right at this present second i really i still have my question for
115:57
Speaker A
rob yeah absolutely i just wanted to finish that up but i appreciate uh raymond and xavier your guesses awesome christ likeness thank you so much for that but yeah raymond go ahead with your question hey we're so grateful
116:08
Speaker A
to be here yeah pleasure to have you guys so uh two two questions really first rob are you familiar with theonomy are you familiar with reconstructionism and theonum theonomy as in the greg bonson yes okay yeah i'm generally familiar with
116:27
Speaker A
the concept okay so i'll just briefly state it for other people who may not be familiar with the term theotomy is not just the restoration of the moral law but also the civil law within the scope of what
116:40
Speaker A
would be binding for the christian right uh so my question for you would be do you think that theonomy would be equally dangerous and maybe heretical as the torah movement i feel unqualified to speak intelligently my gut tells me my gut
117:02
Speaker A
makes me very leery of theology what i've what i've seen and i generally like liked bonson but that that struck me as odd and unbiblical at first blush but i'll if you don't mind i'd like to put an asterisk next to that
117:18
Speaker A
in case i ever study it deeply sure i guess so the reason we asked is just because i guess with what we believe you you see that there are a lot of ceremonial laws right with theonomists there are a lot
117:29
Speaker A
of civil laws and so we're just kind of wondering if you would hold them to the same standard of heresy or not uh well so my opinion about the commandments that might fall under civil and ceremonial well ceremonial
117:47
Speaker A
i believe those laws for a christian today someone in christ are permitted but not required right so if someone wants to keep a ceremonial law like a shabbat or a circumcision or the kosher food laws i have no problems with that i don't think
118:01
Speaker A
there's i think we're free to do that now civil laws if you want to talk about things like the death penalty for the sabbath and and uh all that kind of stuff some of the civil laws are great you know don't loan that
118:12
Speaker A
at interest and all that kind of stuff right pretty good yeah yeah i would love that one um you know and and just so these are the laws that show the heart of god i mean he says leave the edges of your field
118:26
Speaker A
on on uh you know harvested so that anybody walking by and it seems to be anybody like not just a fellow jew but i mean what a beautiful law to say look we need to give back to society those kinds of things but if we
118:40
Speaker A
want to talk about reenacting civil laws i think i'd be a little nervous about that um and maybe i would pull out the heresy word at that point okay hey that's hey no fair enough we you're you're if nothing else you're but
118:52
Speaker A
you're consistent okay good absolutely you made me nervous with these questions so thanks that was our fun question well ladies and gentlemen and raymond xavier uh rob sober dave russell you guys have been absolutely amazing i do want to start uh winding down a little
119:11
Speaker A
bit um but i just wanted to do that i want to give everybody kind of one last thing to say and uh rob we'll start with you on that what do you think about this entire conversation i think honestly
119:23
Speaker A
like i love having raymond xavier and you dialoguing back and forth i honestly think we need to have a part two on this uh at some time in the future and so but i'll let you guys start winding down uh
119:33
Speaker A
with these last comments so rob if you would go ahead um man i learned a lot this is this to me has been a i feel like i owe you guys tuition because this is very helpful for me to see things through a different
119:46
Speaker A
lens um and so and i like i mentioned in my book i believe even our hebrew roots friends their brothers and sisters in christ right if you're confessing jesus as your lord and you're and you're acknowledging that salvation comes through him then
120:03
Speaker A
we're all brothers and sisters in the same family so i would say that the other thing i would add is just the general idea from my point of view that nothing that we could ever do in terms of torah
120:16
Speaker A
observance or jewish tradition adds a single thing to what jesus did for us so from that perspective as long as we're all agreed then this can be an uh what we call it's an inter-family discussion that's right about what's going on and again i
120:32
Speaker A
appreciate you guys being so uh so graceful about everything yeah yeah raymond xavier go ahead and give your final thoughts on it sure um yeah i'm just really grateful for the opportunity uh you know this is my first time ever
120:46
Speaker A
doing anything like this so it's uh it was a big step you guys were on point big step out the door i really appreciate the platform you guys giving us the time of day and the freedom to engage i thought you guys did a really
120:59
Speaker A
really good job um i want to offer some encouragement to some listeners out there for me when i was in the church uh you know and had more of a new covenant way of looking at things i felt
121:12
Speaker A
i felt kind of lost in how to please god i knew that i knew that i needed to be obeying him and i knew there was this there's this burning desire to obey him but i didn't feel a lot of direction
121:28
Speaker A
and what i want to encourage some people to do is go to the front of the book read the front of the book read some of those things that he says to do and don't do and you know at the very worst they're
121:39
Speaker A
permitted to do you're free to do them uh the very best you know god commands you to do it and uh just know that those are things you can practically do that it says they please god he's given us clear things
121:54
Speaker A
that please him know that there's things you can do that makes him happy that you know you don't have to beat yourself up um so i just want to encourage people that you can't obey god and you can do that through christ
122:09
Speaker A
well said um uh tyler david and rob it's been it's been great i hope there are more opportunities like this i appreciate the fruits of the spirit that this conversation was conducted and robert means a great deal to me that you
122:26
Speaker A
would categorize this as a sort of in-house debate um i wasn't so sure reading the book sometimes but i think i've got a better um better understanding talking me over video good good well let me now i'm not saying
122:40
Speaker A
you're not wrong i'm just saying you're my brother of course [Laughter] now uh i guess i was confused at first because it seemed like some statements were saying that like tourism like denies the gospel but then you were saying that kind of on
122:58
Speaker A
the heels of rejecting the deity of the sun so i kind of didn't know where that left us in your eyes if that makes sense sure yeah and like you said there's so many strains of this that it's very
123:09
Speaker A
difficult to make a sweeping statement right that's why i even had to come up with some sort of a creed in my book because there was nothing standard and even that creed i said not everyone will agree yeah so yeah so just so so just uh
123:24
Speaker A
just just to be clear you don't while you would strongly disagree and maybe you would even call it heresy if we're defying the defining heresy as any incorrect theological belief i don't know you would you would not say that we are
123:37
Speaker A
um antithetical to the gospel the position that you've described today now okay okay okay that's that's good to hear i think it's important for for listeners to know that and then just one real quick um i don't know um
123:53
Speaker A
i know it's been a couple years since you wrote the book i they're on when you talk about the nazarenes and eb and it's just just really quick the early uh sects of of the way who held to you know some various aspects of
124:06
Speaker A
the torah right you may have already corrected this maybe it's not even an an error maybe i'm just i'm misreading it but you there's a reason i'm bringing this up so you talk about uh the ebia knights who rejected you know
124:24
Speaker A
the virgin birth of yeshua um among other i think some of them throughout paul and the but the citation you give from epiphanius is not about the evianites it's about the nazarenes and this is a different group and
124:39
Speaker A
people like uh jerome and epiphanies actually tell us that they uphold the virgin birth you know they uphold the deity of the sun and so i think you may have mixed up the two at least in a citation it's on um
124:53
Speaker A
i i don't know maybe you've already caught it no i have not let me make a note of that thank you it's just it's just a small minor point yeah but but it's important because you sort of have those two
125:03
Speaker A
flavors in the torah movement today that's why i mention it you have your modern day ebia knights who do start to question too much and fall out too much um but then you have the nazarenes right who epiphania says look like they
125:19
Speaker A
basically believe what we do but they believe that you're still you know fettered by the law of moses and so that would i guess make the nazarenes more orthodox if we want to throw around um that term so
125:30
Speaker A
that since the distinction still exists today that's why i think it's important to make sure we get those two groups properly distinguished yeah thank you for that now i have to add an editing feed to my tuition payment
125:44
Speaker A
i appreciate you i appreciate your yeah uh russell well you know i was gonna uh start off by saying that you know as soon as i heard you guys affirm the deity of christ i was just gonna shut off the
125:58
Speaker A
computer and walk away and be like yeah they're brothers you know but uh yeah so i yeah i affirm everything dr solberg said too on this uh uh about you guys you guys are great uh it's it says something when a
126:12
Speaker A
co-host and a host don't have to do much talking because you guys are just flowing with everything and bringing out the questions and we don't have to do much you know we don't have to interject and especially interject when people get
126:24
Speaker A
hot-headed you know hey this is great conversation we've had people in the comments section here telling them telling us how nourishing it was you know so it was a great job and i am going to offer you guys a part two um if
126:37
Speaker A
you want to do it within the next month or so on my channel uh proselytize or apostatize we do these type of conversations all the time usually between believers and unbelievers but we also do interfaith discussions as well
126:51
Speaker A
so it's up to you guys and i'll be uh be willing to do that anytime um again since since uh me and tyler were having a debate earlier between coke and pepsi uh i'm from the south i like coke
127:08
Speaker A
and what do you guys like is [Music] hey they have they have kosher coke okay they got they got caffeine free coke one more question this is the last question well uh uh is it is it pop or soda oh
127:39
Speaker A
well it's coke i'm originally from minnesota it's pop it even says it on the grocery aisle yeah that's right not even south it all says coke or soda yeah exactly what kind of coaster thing we noticed when we came i know right yeah
127:59
Speaker A
what kind of coke yeah i hear you all right interesting anyways just to break the uh the crazy ice there uh that we have been skating on for the last two hours uh but yeah guys again thank you
128:09
Speaker A
so much uh for coming on man you know i always appreciate talking these things uh thanks for correcting my uh misuse of the moral argument there real quick uh dr schulberg but yeah that's i was trying to go somewhere else with that
128:21
Speaker A
but uh yeah uh again guys great love to have you yep beautiful uh robert will find you uh just real quick if you want to plug your website uh yeah rlsulberg.com is the website and if you click on the
128:35
Speaker A
video link in the menu it'll take you to my youtube site which is called defending the biblical roots of christianity it's my youtube channel also if you can make one suggestion rob yes please david wilbur is a good friend
128:48
Speaker A
of mine oh is he i've gone to church a couple times uh outside of uh charlotte and i i know that he would love to talk to you uh about some of this stuff and if you're willing to i would say it
129:00
Speaker A
would be very beneficial and he's actually a qualified teacher he's a qualified teacher he's spiritual he's a good man he actually reached out to me after one of my videos and he was very kind and we had a great exchange so yeah
129:12
Speaker A
so that would be something i would love to you know learn from you two guys discussing yeah so if you guys would want to uh to do that on here i would love to have that discussion anytime uh
129:23
Speaker A
any any time but gentlemen thank you so much for our listeners thank you for tuning in for two hours we really appreciate it you can find all of our episodes completecenters.com is our podcast website you just click the episodes that
129:38
Speaker A
will lead you to the episode archive of the website uh also we are on tick tock youtube as in facebook as everyone who's watching on here now knows uh but but gentlemen i really appreciate the christ likeness i really appreciate both of
129:53
Speaker A
just this whole conversation it's been so edifying and so enlightening and yes i'll i'll state it as well i affirm both of you as brothers in christ any day of the week i would stand side by side with
130:05
Speaker A
you all affirming the deity of christ justification by faith alone and all the other things that go into that so gentlemen i we are off of here good night god bless and stay christ-like we will see you next time
Topics:Torah observanceMessianic JudaismHebrew RootsYeshuaNew CovenantMosaic lawsabbathdietary lawsChristian apologeticstheology debate

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →