Skip to content
Get App

So...performative reading has become a status symbol?

Charli Chats examines the rise of 'performative reading' as a status symbol, linking celebrity book posing, Substack growth, and falling literacy to phone addiction and digital detox culture.

Key Takeaways

  • Performative reading signals taste and intelligence, but may not reflect genuine literacy gains.
  • The surge in physical books and long-form content reflects a broader desire to escape phone addiction.
  • Access to offline activities like digital detox is increasingly tied to wealth and socioeconomic status.

What the video covers

  • Celebrities such as Kaia Gerber, Kendall Jenner, and Harry Styles are increasingly photographed with books, creating a performative reading aesthetic.
  • Print book sales in the UK hit a record 69 million copies in 2023, with Gen Z favoring physical books and libraries seeing rising visits.
  • The host argues that reading, even performative, is a positive step away from phone use, but questions whether it truly improves literacy.
  • Literacy rates are declining while phone addiction rises, raising concern that reading is becoming an aesthetic rather than a practice.
  • Substack grew to 35 million users and 3 million paid subscribers by October 2024, reflecting demand for long-form content.
  • Oxford University Press named 'brain rot' its word of the year, a term with roots in Thoreau's 1854 Walden.
  • Experts compare short-form video feeds to slot machines through random reinforcement, which drives compulsive use.
  • Digital detox has become a commercial product, from six-week courses costing $600 to detox holidays and camps.
  • Reading is linked to social status and perceived intelligence, so it functions as an identity marker in consumer culture.
  • Students' shrinking free time due to economic pressures makes deep reading harder to access, reinforcing class divides.

Answers

Questions about this video

What is performative reading according to the video?

Performative reading refers to being seen with books to project intelligence or taste, often without actually reading them. The host notes that celebrities like Addison Rae appear to hold books for the image rather than the content.

Why does the host question whether reading trends help literacy?

Literacy rates are declining even as reading becomes fashionable, so the host asks whether the trend encourages real reading or merely promotes an aesthetic. She points to struggling readers being left behind as a concern.

How does the video connect reading to class and wealth?

The host argues that offline activities like reading and digital detox are increasingly accessible mainly to people with money and free time. Courses and retreats cost hundreds of dollars, and students facing financial pressure have less spare time to read.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00
Speaker A
Timothy shalamay is reading feminist literature Kaa Gerber just started a book club and your ex just sent you a Joan didan quote all of your favorite influencers are seemingly moving from Tik Tok and YouTube to substack and quite frankly your phone addiction is
00:15
Speaker A
becoming more and more embarrassing long form content seems to be the new cool but only for the elite and people who have the time and effort to be able to engage literacy rates are at an all-time low it feels like we're all struggling
00:29
Speaker A
to spend time offline more so than ever Mental Health crisis we're facing a loneliness epidemic and we can pin pretty much all of these crisis to social media as a result the appearance of those who can engage in offline
00:43
Speaker A
activities seems to carry an almost aspirational and Out Of Reach coolness quality is it showing oh I hate when my feminist literature is sticking out of my back pocket in this episode we're unpacking the Rising desire to engage in
01:03
Speaker A
reading and long form content despite declining literacy rates and increasing phone addictions across the world from the diving board is a show hosted by me Charlie chatz dedicated to decoding digital Culture by unpacking the hidden politics behind the
01:21
Speaker A
screen and we're back yet again she's back if you have been watching my videos you would know that we're in a slightly different location today which was for number number of different factors first of all the lighting in my other location
01:33
Speaker A
needs some serious work some serious issues were happening there it was flickering not the vibe I am using natural lighting again though so this time round if there is a lighting problem still I apologize that's a you problem not me I just can't fix it this
01:49
Speaker A
time we're on a tight budget ladies and gentlemen so none of this crazy business with the lighting things okay we're in a comfy position today in these lovely chairs and I have my performative books for my performative reading episode
02:03
Speaker A
because I just thought that would be fitting anyway today we are talking about a really random topic I came across this Tik Tok on T and it really inspired the video I think not having an online presence will
02:16
Speaker A
be one of the biggest signifiers of wealth and somebody's socioeconomic standing over the next couple of years we're already starting to see signs of this but two recent news articles or things that I've heard recently really have sparked that one was a recent thing
02:31
Speaker A
that I heard on NPR a couple of days ago where it was talking about how a lot of Legacy Media Outlets that previously dropped their print media are now slowly coming back albe it in still a very reduced form second thing that I just
02:45
Speaker A
read today was a Caitlyn Tiffany article from the Atlantic where she talked about how she went to essentially like a deprogramming a reclaiming of your attention but this was a six- week course that she took in Brooklyn that
03:00
Speaker A
the course cost $600 and the gist of the course was essentially just like how to not be on your phone how to reclaim your attention let's dive in in February of this year Kaa Gerber told British Vogue that reading is so
03:19
Speaker A
sexy in relation to her new book club called Library science in an article by the guardian journalist Khloe mcdonal relayed that in 2023 6 69 million copies of physical books sold in the UK which is the highest rate ever
03:37
Speaker A
recorded she continues in the article to say that research from neelen book data highlighted that it's print books that genz are favoring accounting for 80% of purchases from November 2021 to 2022 libraries are also appearing to have an
03:53
Speaker A
optic in genz users who are favoring their quiet over noisy coffee shops in the UK in-person visits are up 71% and coincidentally it really feels like Harry Styles Jacob AI Kendall Jenner Addison Ray Timothy shalam to name a few
04:08
Speaker A
are all really jumping on this reading and book bandwagon as well it feels like it has a slightly disingenuous air to it I mean come on that photo of Addison Ray walking down the street holding Britney Spears as the woman in me appearing to
04:23
Speaker A
read it as she was walking down the street I love it iconic imagery but Addison we are seeing right through that and what I think is so interesting is I think Addison knows we know she's not reading the book the appearance of
04:36
Speaker A
performative reading it almost has this added layer to it that we're all in cahoots we all know that it's performative and yet it still has this aesthetic attraction to it now I've got to give Kendall Jenner her credit where
04:49
Speaker A
it's due that picture of her on a yacht reading a book where it's got green Post-it notes all throughout it I think we can all say that probably was read by her but after seeing all of these celebrities really start posting photos
05:01
Speaker A
and get papped with books in hands and in pockets and wherever else you can accessorize with a book this discussion of performative reading really took hold of the internet for a little while being a bookworm has become a sort of
05:13
Speaker A
aesthetic a marker of identity an indicator of intelligence which funnily enough doesn't really carry the same strength when it's obvious that you're not actually reading the book but alas I digress significantly it also suggests a propensity to be offline it indicates
05:32
Speaker A
that you've managed to break your phone addiction and opt for an activity that provides you with way less doine for the first 5 minutes of consumption in an article for the New York Times Terry Newan who's a contributing editor for
05:44
Speaker A
the dirt on the topic of performative reading said the following books like the clothes you wear or the car you own are symbols of a person's tastes of their aesthetic and intellectual sensibilities in the digital age there is more social value a person or a
05:59
Speaker A
celebrity can cultivate in appearing well read or knowledgeable about bestselling titles or popular authors and it's not only books that seem to be causing this online craze right now it seems that long form content and reading in General on platforms such as substack
06:17
Speaker A
are also becoming really really really popular I mean it was only a few months ago that I actually learned what substack was and I'll admit I was very very late to the bandwagon but it really felt like there was this intellectual
06:29
Speaker A
club happening with all of my favorite YouTubers and Tik tocker and influencers it's kind of like a blogging app substack writers basically send newsletters to subscribers in October of 2024 substack had 35 million users and 3 million paid subscribers I'm of the camp
06:47
Speaker A
that any reading whether performative or not is great if you're inspiring people to pick up a book inste of your phone I think that's a wholly good thing but what I find really really interesting is the fact that this phenomenon is
07:00
Speaker A
occurring when literacy rates are genuinely declining at a rate that no one really expected and phone addictions are on the rise as well are we promoting reading and by default improving literacy rates by encouraging the younger generation to opt for a book
07:16
Speaker A
instead of their phones or are we simply promoting the aesthetic of reading and leaving kids that are struggling to read by the wayside if it is an aesthetic why is it catching on so much so let's talk about brain Rock culture this year brain
07:32
Speaker A
rot was actually named the Oxford University press word of the year which it just feels kind of sad however the reason I bring this up is because it actually has kind of interesting Origins definition of brain rot before I get
07:45
Speaker A
ahead of myself is the supposed deterioration of a person's mental or intellectual State especially viewed as the result of overc consumption of material considered to be trivial or unchallenging so contrary to popular belief the word actually has origins in
08:02
Speaker A
1854 when author Henry David thorough wrote a book called Walden in it he discusses this propensity for British culture to oversimplify and devalue complex ideas the president of Oxford languages actually said the following about the word brain rot I find it
08:21
Speaker A
fascinating that the term brain rot has been adopted by gen Zed and gen Alpha those communities largely responsible for the use and creation of the digital content the term refers to these communities have Amplified the expression through social media channels
08:36
Speaker A
the very Place said to cause brain rot it demonstrates a somewhat cheeky self-awareness in the younger Generations about the harmful impact of social media that they've inherited and I think that's pretty on the nose we're experiencing brain rot due to the Absurd
08:53
Speaker A
and ridiculous level of content that we're seeing on our feeds that are only on our feeds because we're the ones created it promoting it and sharing it with each other but it's not just the fact that the content we're consuming is
09:06
Speaker A
particularly bizarre according to USC Professor Dr Julie alright she says that Tik Tok shares the same principles that make gambling on slot machines addictive it's called random reinforcement in a study that looked at brain scans looking at Chinese students who were using a Tik
09:24
Speaker A
Tok equivalent it actually found that the same part of the brain that is linked with addiction was engaged when they were using this Tik Tok equivalent app the article continued as a result the average Tik Tok user spends 95
09:38
Speaker A
minutes per day on the app in 2022 the optimal level of Tik Tok videos to maximize user engagement was between 21 and 34 seconds now stay with me for this cuz this is wild if we take the 95
09:52
Speaker A
minutes of screen time per day and divide it by the optimal length the average Tik Tok user could be consum ass uming between 167 to 271 Tik toks per day if not more how increasingly short attention spans perpetuated by apps such as Tik Tok are
10:12
Speaker A
leading to an underc consumption of nuanced information our for you Pages seem to be so heavily aligned with what we like and what our interests are that when we see things that are outside of our Echo chamber we almost get mad this
10:27
Speaker A
reminds me of a story that Hannah Fergus of cheek media often refers to which is called the bean soup theory stay with me on this one essentially someone posted this Tik Tok on oh my God I keep saying
10:41
Speaker A
that someone posted this Tik Tok on Tik Tok someone posted this Tik Tok where they basically showed a recipe for a bean soup it had like 15 different types of beans in it or something anyway much to the Creator's dismay this recipe
10:56
Speaker A
somehow found itself into the ultimate Bean haters algorithm who decided to then comment on the video what if I don't like beans what this reaction to this video shows is not only is it like hilarious but also it shows the sheer
11:12
Speaker A
level of expectation that we have for our algorithms to give us exactly what we want to the extent that we genuinely expect our algorithm to know the foods that we like and dislike now obviously many people would have simply scrolled
11:27
Speaker A
on but I think this highlights a sort of almost level of entitlement that we have over our algorithms when our algorithm starts showing us content that doesn't fit in our General Echo chamber it feels like a betrayal it's not only our
11:43
Speaker A
attention spans that are suffering but also our literacy rates Jonathan hate wrote an article for the Atlantic which was called end the phone-based childhood now in it he quoted the following statistics in the US according to the nation's report card scores in reading
11:59
Speaker A
and math began to decline for us students after 2012 reversing Decades of slow but generally steady increase Pisa which is the major International measure of educational Trends actually shows that declines in math reading and science happened globally also beginning
12:17
Speaker A
in the early 2010s which just so happens to link with the rise in social media as well and it's not only that young people can't read but they don't want to in November of this year the Australia National ly trust published that only a
12:31
Speaker A
third of 8 to 18 yearolds actually want to read in their spare time or choose to read in their spare time this has actually been the lowest that has been ever recorded in the literacy trust's 19 years of surveys and it has halved since
12:48
Speaker A
2016 so in 2016 23ds of kids still chose to read in their spare time only 8 years on only a third I mean oh I wonder why it's kind of obvious right and of course these statistics are also way more
13:01
Speaker A
significant among marginalized communities as well if we're spending 95 minutes per day on apps like Tik Tok we don't exactly have the time to opt for a book either terms such as chronically online and brain rut highlight that
13:16
Speaker A
social media users are hyper aware of the dangers of being on social media and being online currently it almost feels like if we had the choice we wouldn't be online as much as we are if at all online discourse about Doom scrolling
13:32
Speaker A
and its negative effects have engulfed apps like Tik Tok and yes it's great to raise awareness on these apps but it shows that the users are really concerned about their own welfare and well-being because of being on the app
13:45
Speaker A
many of us are logged on but desperately trying to log off and find something that will give us the same level of satisfaction and enjoyment as the crazy levels of dopamine that an app like Tik Tok gives us in the short term and I
13:59
Speaker A
also think we're just starting to catch on to the sheer level of nuance that we're missing out on and knowledge that we're missing out on by just consuming short form content I mean I know many of us do consume other forms of media as
14:12
Speaker A
well I mean you're watching a video essay so you must be at least interested a bit in Internet culture and Trends or just more nuanced takes on things in general I think we're starting to catch on on what just consuming short form
14:25
Speaker A
content misses out on and that is more nuanced conversations greater knowledge experiencing perspectives other than our own in a constructive and well-balanced way we seem to be craving substance over fleeting dopamine hits and I think what adds to this is the way that we've seen
14:44
Speaker A
how this lack of nuance and lack of deep understanding for various topics can seep negatively into our real lives for example the way that online oversimplification of the election and different C candidates points of view really affected the overall outcome of
15:04
Speaker A
the election and although we are all kind of aware that one of the main pieces of advice that healthc Care Professionals are giving us especially when we're struggling with mental health is to get offline it's not that simple
15:15
Speaker A
when our lives are so intertwined with the digital world it feels really Out Of Reach the digital detox and all things associated with it including reading seem to carry this aspirational quality due to the sheer level of difficulty
15:32
Speaker A
that it is to get off our phones when I was researching for this video I kept coming across the term pseudointellectualism and I think it's quite an interesting way of looking at this topic as well essentially it refers
15:45
Speaker A
to the act of positioning yourself as highly knowledgeable or intellectual in a given area of knowledge without necessarily having the qualifications to be so so an example would be people positioning themselves on Tik Tok to be an expert in a given field when they
16:03
Speaker A
don't really have the experience or qualifications to speak on it now I don't mean that anecdotal evidence or just giving your personal opinion on things is bad I mean look at me my whole experience online is just giving my
16:18
Speaker A
opinion without you know I'm researching but I don't have like an academic PhD in what I'm talking about I think there's value in that too in a video by oie sunia she spoke about how in the Science World and in Academia there is a major
16:32
Speaker A
lack for anecdotal evidence because usually scientific evidence is prioritized and so consuming information and opinions from other people online simply based on their personal experiences can be really really valuable to understand different concepts but it does become a problem
16:49
Speaker A
when people are pretending that they have more knowledge than they really do and not really highlighting that they actually don't have sufficient knowledge to be telling people what to do or to be giving advice for example I mean how
17:02
Speaker A
many times has someone said in conversation oh I read this article and they're actually just referring to a Tik Tok or how many times do you just kind of absorb information on Tik Tok without factchecking it first on Google I do
17:13
Speaker A
both of those things all the time and writing these videos essays has really made me highly criticize every piece of information that I receive because I feel like I have this responsibility to make sure what I'm saying has some
17:26
Speaker A
backing that's why I have so many references in videos because I never want to say something that's not backed by research but the way that Tik Tok is designed means that we're not going to go and check the references we're just
17:37
Speaker A
going to take it and move on we're bombarded with so much information think of those potentially 271 videos we're consuming every day means we kind of experience this information overload right like We Come Away with all these random facts and we don't retain all of
17:51
Speaker A
it but it's really hard to remember whether or not that fact that you just leared about came from Tik Tok or Google or a journal article or a friend the line starts to get really blurry I feel like short form content means that we
18:05
Speaker A
kind of cut out the important parts of logic and theorizing when we're talking about complex topics and it can lead to the oversimplification of complex topics like good old mate thorough was talking about back in 1854 he knew what was us
18:22
Speaker A
one of the most valuable pieces of knowledge that I learned at University is to make what you're saying and make what you're writing legible to the general public to the average person because otherwise what's the point if you're just trying to impart knowledge
18:38
Speaker A
on other people that have this really higher level understanding of the world and Academia and big words you're you're not actually really doing much right like it's only going to other people who already think like you so the only
18:52
Speaker A
reason you're using these crazy big words is to mark yourself to everyone else that you are are an intellect this to me feels really similar to performative reading it's foremost an aesthetic but why is this aesthetic gaining so much traction right now why
19:11
Speaker A
is it so popular to appear smart and intellectual so to unpack the attraction of this kind of reader aesthetic or offline aesthetic you might describe it as I've split it into three different sections firstly we're talking about literacy rates secondly we're talking
19:29
Speaker A
about class and Leisure Time and thirdly we're talking about health and the wellness industry so let's have a look at literacy rates reading is undeniably cool right now arguably way more so than when I was a kid in the early 2000s I
19:44
Speaker A
was such a bookworm I genuinely thought that I was going to write a book by the age of 11 I remember my teacher I must have been 10 because it was when I was in year four and my teacher gave us this
19:56
Speaker A
book to read clearly trying to inspire us and it was written allegedly by an 11-year-old now at the time that was like oh my God an 11-year-old fully published that she edited that girl an 11-year-old wrote a book and I was 10
20:10
Speaker A
and I was like who [ __ ] I only have one year before my time is up like I'm not even I'm not even being dramatic that was genuinely how I felt so as a 10-year-old I started trying to write
20:21
Speaker A
books which were basically almost copies of what I was reading like I would read some crazy fantasy novel and then my book would be like in erad I don't know it would be like almost the exact same which is funny anyway the reason I bring
20:35
Speaker A
this up the reason I went down that tangent is because being a bookworm and writing these books and being so obsessed with books definitely was not cool and I don't know whether it was because I was trying to hide it but I
20:47
Speaker A
did not show the same enthusiasm for books at school like at school I was pretty sporty I cared about fashion I had loads of friends I wanted to fit in with certain people I definitely did not show just how obsessed I was with
21:02
Speaker A
reading and this seems to be similar to the experience of kar Carter I read his essay on substack he said the following as a lifelong reader myself I still remember the days when I hid the fact that I read and wrote books I grew up in
21:15
Speaker A
the '90s when being called a nerd wasn't as celebrated as it is today in fact being a nerd dampened your social experience and without any social media to escape to back then if your direct environment was chaotic or anxiety
21:28
Speaker A
inducing you were trapped in nerd hell in relation to performative reading he said as much as I appreciate this shift in perception much of it feels aesthetic instead of intellectual we've arrived at a place where appearing to be a reader
21:41
Speaker A
has overshadowed reading and although I can relate to this experience as I said before I do want to caveat that I think that reading may have had sort of an uncool flavor in school but the connotations of being a bookworm have
21:57
Speaker A
never been holy negative I mean you can look at the media even back then and TV back then where you've got characters such as William Thacker from nodding Hill Rory Gilmore from Gilmore Girls and then kind of on the other end a sort of
22:11
Speaker A
more maths obsessed Persona like Goodwill Hunting all of these characters it was an intentional choice for them to be heavily intellectual or obsessed with books or obsessed with maths it almost adds to their character as endearing and also not that being a reader necessarily
22:29
Speaker A
indicates intellect I think that the mainstream perception is that being a reader does mean you have some sort of academic intelligence and academic intelligence and Excellence are certainly not frowned upon in capitalist Societies in fact they're highly valued
22:45
Speaker A
and from this perspective I think that the declining literacy rates suggests that being perceived to have this academic quality is perhaps a little bit harder to achieve these days and because it's harder to achieve it's sort of got
22:59
Speaker A
this more aspirational quality in Carter's essay he goes on to quote an article for the Atlantic which was written this year entitled The Elite college students who can't read books essentially the article outlines that us College professors from Elite schools
23:16
Speaker A
such as Colombia are finding that their students are less willing and able to read books than previously professors are asking their students to read books within a week or two and students are outright refusing saying that they never
23:28
Speaker A
had to read books before in high school the article quotes 20 years ago Professor Dam's classes had no problem engaging in sophisticated discussions of Pride and Prejudice one week and crime and punishment the next now his students tell him upfront that the reading load
23:43
Speaker A
feels impossible it's not just the frenetic Pace they struggle to attend to small details while keeping track of the overall plot now while this article is really fascinating and definitely highlights an inability to maybe grasp these Concepts due to lower literacy
24:00
Speaker A
rates personally I think it also speaks to the lack of time that many students are experiencing so this takes me to my next point class and Leisure Time as a law graduate I totally understand the experience of being allocated hundreds
24:17
Speaker A
and hundreds of pages of reading from different classes and I'm noticing that a lot more of us are also working full-time or part-time jobs to support ourselves I was working fulltime in my last year of study and part-time almost
24:31
Speaker A
the whole way throughout so being allocated this reading was quite frankly impossible I got to the point in my final year where I really could not tackle most of the material simply because I did not have time in a cost of
24:45
Speaker A
living crisis the number of students who are having to take on part-time or full-time jobs while they're studying is increasing significantly and the level of spare time that we have as students is De increasing as well time is more
25:00
Speaker A
scarce so the ability to engage in an activity that requires lots of spare time is basically reserved for less time precious people and generally speaking people with more time on their hands in a cost of living crisis tend to be
25:15
Speaker A
people who are less financially strained the notion that reading is reserved for the upper class or people with large amounts of leisure time does seem a little bit dramatic It's actually an idea that's been floating around for a
25:28
Speaker A
little while in fact if you have a look at Vin's theory of Leisure Class it unpacks this concept that flexing your spare time and trivial activities that you might do in your spare time such as taking a Latin class which is a language
25:46
Speaker A
that you can't really use anymore is an indicator of wealth the theory of Leisure Class states that lavish expenditure of scarce and valuable resources such as money and time can act as a sign of status and wealth in the
26:00
Speaker A
eyes of others so returning back to tick tocker notes from Kayla's video which sparked my whole interest in this topic so thank you so much I'm going to leave her um credits down below she made a video arguing that not having an online
26:14
Speaker A
presence is going to be more of a flex in the next coming years to back up her argument she spoke of this article that she read in the Atlantic which was written by Caitlyn Tiffany essentially it's called a radical approach to
26:27
Speaker A
reclaiming your attention and it follows Tiffany's decision to take a 6 week intensive digital detox Course in New York it teaches parents and other caretakers how to ReDiscover the joy of undivided attention and help your family to do the same now Tiffany disclosed she
26:46
Speaker A
didn't have any children and she was actually just going to see whether or not it would benefit herself personally but most strikingly from this article was the detail that the course cost $56 6 to attend um and obviously as a result
27:03
Speaker A
a very specific class of person was attending the courses and another class of people was not now what I think is really interesting is this whole concept that being able to detox from your phone and detox from the digital world
27:19
Speaker A
requires something as significant as a six we intensive course that costs hundreds of dollars a very Black Mirror world is if only the elite can access a world offline this concept was then built on by Zara from taboo on the bus
27:36
Speaker A
where she spoke about the value in Rarity she essentially said that having an online presence is losing value as it becomes more and more accessible having like a big presence online used to be a rarity it used to be
27:50
Speaker A
really only accessed by like the elitist media presences therefore that was so valuable but now we pretty much all have access to Internet Fame to having a platform online that I think the new value will be derived in being like an
28:06
Speaker A
accessible like we're even starting to see this and how it is becoming like a luxury to be off grid offline like you'd get a cabin in the middle of the woods on Airbnb that had no Wi-fi no service
28:18
Speaker A
and they would use that as like a luxury selling point they oh it's an unplugged cabin it's as it's become accessible as even just like the internet has taken over all of our Lives it's become a luxury to be unplugged and this is
28:30
Speaker A
exactly why I decided to make this video because while there does seem to be this underlying Trend favoring long form content and maybe more nuanced content through performative reading or reading in general it doesn't really seem that short form content is declining it seems
28:46
Speaker A
these two things are kind of happening side by side but different groups of people get to occupy the different spaces and particularly where we've got celebrities overtly reading books whether or not they're actually reading them we'll never know well we can guess
29:01
Speaker A
but we've also got these really serious declining literacy rates and phone addictions it does create this weird dichotomy and this brings me to my last point which is health and wellness I think that one of the attractive qualities of being offline and reading a
29:20
Speaker A
book is its link with the digital detox which as we all know is linked to mental health and well-being as I've spoken about being chronically online we all know it's not good for us genz is hyper aware that it's not good for them most
29:35
Speaker A
social media users are aware of the dangers of social media gen Zed is one of the most healthc conscious Generations at the moment in fact in research by an organization called McKenzie which was a study of 5,000 people across China the UK and the US
29:52
Speaker A
they found that gen Zetas and Millennials are now purchasing more wellness products and services than older Generations and I think this speaks to the commodification of the wellness industry it's not necessarily actual Health that we care about it's
30:06
Speaker A
the markers of Health it's the appearance of Health and Wellness that has Jen Z said hooked on this idea it's aesthetic green smoothie powders instead of eating broccoli or spinach it's red light masks detox teas it's raw milk
30:23
Speaker A
trends like that girl which idolize women who go to Pilates then go for a hot girl walk then Journal all before 6:00 a.m. then eat their salads their green smoothies switch off all technology by 900 p.m. and have a 10
30:36
Speaker A
step skincare routine demonstrate this idolization of the appearance of Health without necessarily showing whether or not that person is actually healthier than another person who just kind of goes about their day without being so fixated on the aesthetic of appearing
30:53
Speaker A
healthy I think also the pandemic has a lot to do with this I mean the entire world was health conscious for a number of years there and those years also just happened to coincide with Gen Zed's formative years so I do think there's a
31:06
Speaker A
big link between the pandemic and health Consciousness among gen Zed but I have to question why reading and the appearance of being offline would be any different to this trend we all know that being online is seriously damaging our
31:21
Speaker A
mental health being offline therefore holds connotations of being healthy even if it's just an aesthetic of doing so the digital detox even has been commodified through expensive Retreats and digital detox tourism I came across this journal article which basically
31:39
Speaker A
described digital detox tourism as follows in the tourism context tourism products have rebranded offline status during vacations as digital detox holidays and digital detox camps it has become a growing marketing Trend that promises to provide tourists with a rich
31:56
Speaker A
sensory emotional cognitive and relationship experience through digital free activities in digital free environments I've never said digital so much in my life I'm not necessarily saying that the publishing and book industry is one and the same with the
32:10
Speaker A
wellness industry but I do think the attraction to both especially the appearance and aesthetic side of things have a very similar undertone summing up this video I really want to reiterate that the appearance of reading and the aesthetic of reading and performative
32:26
Speaker A
reading whatever you want to call it isn't necessarily bad if it genuinely is bringing more people to reading I know that the effect of book talk has seen significant increase in people choosing to read instead of going on their phones
32:38
Speaker A
and I didn't really talk about book talk much in this video because it didn't quite fit but I think that's a really positive takeaway from seeing more people reading online I think we have to have this conversation together with
32:48
Speaker A
declining literacy rates and phone addictions and dependence though I think that as we see more and more celebrities performatively reading and being offline and it does raise these really interesting questions about who gets to be offline and who gets to participate
33:04
Speaker A
in those activities I just find it fascinating when we see celebrities adopt behaviors like holding a book and pretending to read or reading it highlights some things about our culture such as our chronic online and it highlights just how bad the problem
33:20
Speaker A
actually is anyway I think that's kind of all I have to say I would absolutely love to hear what you have to say about this because I think that it's a really inter in topic there are so many things
33:30
Speaker A
that I didn't talk about in this video I wouldn't be opposed to continue on this trend of kind of reading I think it's really fascinating as always if you enjoyed this episode and you're listening on Spotify please rate my
33:42
Speaker A
podcast it really really helps and if you watch this on YouTube please give it a thumbs up and subscribe because I'm going to be posting a lot more frequently from here on in if you want to see more videos from me I have a
33:52
Speaker A
playlist of video essays that you can go and check out enjoy the rest of your day and I will see you in my next video from the diving board is a show hosted by me Charlie chatz dedicated to decoding
34:03
Speaker A
digital Culture by unpacking the hidden politics behind the screen [Music]
Topics:performative readingdigital detoxbrain rotliteracy ratesSubstackphone addictionbook clubGen Zsocial mediastatus symbol

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →