Analysis of Erich von Manstein's operational genius: the deceptive Crimea offensive (Operation Trappenjagd) that destroyed three Soviet armies in May 1942, and other masterpieces of misdirection.
Key Takeaways
- Deception about the location of the main attack can neutralize a numerical disadvantage.
- Air superiority and concentrated artillery were decisive in turning a breakthrough into encirclement.
- Timing and terrain conditions, such as drying ground, must be exploited precisely for armored operations.
- Manstein's operational method repeatedly produced large victories against superior enemy forces.
What the video covers
- Erich von Manstein's operational brilliance earned him praise from Heinz Guderian as the finest operational brain of the German army.
- Manstein's method centered on deceiving opponents about where the main attack would fall, then striking where they were weakest.
- Soviet amphibious landings at Feodosia and the Kerch Peninsula in early 1942 forced Manstein to abandon his plans against Sevastopol.
- Soviet forces under Kozlov's Crimean Front enjoyed a numerical advantage but failed to break through through winter fighting on the Parpach Isthmus.
- Operation Trappenjagd (Bustard Hunt) in May 1942 used feigned build-ups in the north while secretly concentrating forces in the south.
- German forces exploited dried swampy terrain, Luftwaffe dominance and a massive artillery bombardment to break the Soviet front in hours.
- The 22nd Panzer Division cut off the Soviet 51st Army while the rest of the corps drove the 44th and 47th Armies toward Kerch.
- Within roughly two weeks, Manstein destroyed three Soviet armies, eliminating nine divisions and reducing nine more to ineffective remnants.
- The video goes on to cover later operations, including a Soviet counteroffensive in August 1943 and the Third Tank Army's destruction in March 1943.
- The narrator argues Manstein's ability to read the battlefield and use timing made him one of the greatest operational geniuses of the war.
Chapters
- 00:00Introduction: Manstein's Operational Genius
- 01:25Soviet Landings and the Crimean Front
- 02:52Winter Stalemate on the Parpach Isthmus
- 05:19Sponsor Segment: FreeCash
- 05:26Operation Trappenjagd: Deception and Concentration
- 06:41Breakthrough and Encirclement at Kerch
- 09:37Later Campaigns: Kharkov and the Dnieper
- 21:21Conclusion: Assessing Manstein's Legacy
Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown
Speaker A
By the autumn of 1941, Operation Barbarossa had carried the German army deep into the Soviet Union. And among the commanders spearheading the advance was Erich von Manstein, a Prussian officer whose operational brilliance had already played a crucial role in
Speaker A
Germany's rapid victory over France the previous year. With Heinz Guderian referring to him as our finest operational brain.
Speaker A
Time and again, he would deceive his opponents into concentrating their forces in the wrong place, strike where they were weakest, and exploit the resulting breakthrough before they could recover. It was an approach that he mastered to such an extent that it would
Speaker A
continuously produce some of the most remarkable operational victories of the war. One of which he perfectly demonstrated in Crimea after taking command of the German 11th Army in September of 1941.
Speaker A
By the beginning of 1942, most of Crimea had been overrun by the Wehrmacht with only the heavily fortified port of Sevastopol continuing to resist.
Speaker A
But after breaking the German Blitzkrieg at Moscow, Stalin was determined to regain the initiative and launch a series of counteroffensives against what he now believed to be a severely weakened Wehrmacht.
Speaker A
Among the territories Stalin intended to reclaim was Crimea. As the Germans appeared to be closing the pocket of Sevastopol, the Soviets launched a major amphibious operation at the opposite end of the peninsula.
Speaker A
The Soviet 44th Army landed in Feodosia, while the 51st advanced rapidly across the Kerch Peninsula.
Speaker A
The landings forced Manstein to abandon his immediate plans against Sevastopol and rush reinforcements eastward to contain the new threat. And after fierce fighting, the two sides eventually stabilized along the narrow Parpach Isthmus by February. But, the Soviets continued pouring men and equipment
Speaker A
across the Kerch Strait, and the buildup of forces on both sides gradually transformed the peninsula into a major new front. Three armies, the 44th, 47th, and 51st, were eventually assembled under General Dmitry Kozlov's Crimean Front, giving the Soviets an enormous
Speaker A
numerical advantage over the German forces opposing them. Kozlov's objective was clear. He would break through Manstein's defenses, advance westward across the Crimea, and relieve the besieged fortress of Sevastopol.
Speaker A
Before we continue, however, a quick thanks to the sponsor of today's video, FreeCash. FreeCash is a free rewarding platform where you can earn money by completing mobile games, app offers, surveys, or cashback offers. And if you want to try it, use my link at the top
Speaker A
of the description or scan the QR code on screen, and you'll get a $10 bonus after completing your first offer. Now, I know what you're probably thinking.
Speaker A
Getting paid to play mobile games sounds a little too good to be true, but the business model actually makes quite a lot of sense. Game and app developers spend a lot of money advertising to find new players, and FreeCash connects these
Speaker A
companies directly with you. The companies pay FreeCash for bringing them new users, and FreeCash shares part of that money with you through rewards.
Speaker A
Now, this isn't some get-rich-quick app. Rewards are limited, vary depending on the offer and where you live, and obviously aren't going to replace a salary. Once you've downloaded FreeCash, make sure you enable app tracking so it can properly track your progress and
Speaker A
credit your rewards. You can then choose from the offers available to you. I decided to try Balloon Triple Match, a fun game where you match three identical balloons from a large stack, with the levels getting increasingly difficult.
Speaker A
FreeCash currently have over 70 million registered users, has paid out more than 300 million dollars, and has a 4.6 star Trustpilot rating. You can cash out your rewards through Visa, PayPal, or crypto.
Speaker A
So again, that's my link below or the QR code on screen and you'll get a $10 bonus after completing your first offer.
Speaker A
Throughout February, March, and April, Kostelov repeatedly attempted to do exactly that. But despite their numerical superiority, the Soviet attacks achieved little.
Speaker A
The difficult terrain and the appalling winter weather, in combination with a narrow battlefield, made it difficult to exploit their greater numbers. And with three entire armies crowded into such a confined and open area, the far superior German artillery and air power continued
Speaker A
to inflict devastating casualties on the densely packed Soviet formations. And by May, the Soviet offensive had ground to a complete halt.
Speaker A
As the summer [music] approached and the weather conditions started to improve, however, Manstein decided that the time was right for an offensive of his own.
Speaker A
His plan, codenamed Operation Trappenjagd or Bustard Hunt, was ambitious, to put it mildly. The Soviet Crimean Front still possessed around a quarter of a million men, substantially outnumbering Manstein's available ground forces. A straightforward battle of attrition was therefore an absolute
Speaker A
non-starter. Instead, Manstein intended to deceive the Soviets about where his main attack would fall.
Speaker A
Up until this point, the fighting had been fiercest in the north, and Manstein continued to gradually build up his forces there to encourage the Soviets to do the same. After all, the south [music] had swampy terrain and was
Speaker A
unfavorable for offensive operations. Or so it seemed. German forces in the northern sector continued to make conspicuous preparations for what appeared to be a build-up for a large attack, and the Soviets responded with heavy defensive countermeasures. Meanwhile, however,
Speaker A
under the cover of darkness, Manstein quietly concentrated the real striking force in the [music] south. German units were pulled away from the siege lines around Sevastopol and transported across Crimea to reinforce the coming offensive, while only just enough troops
Speaker A
were left behind to contain the fortress. By the time the operation was ready, the balance of force at the decisive attack point in the south was in favor of the Germans, with as little as two Soviet rifle divisions holding the immediate
Speaker A
front line there. The swampy terrain had also begun to dry up with the warm weather, just enough for tanks to roll through without getting stuck.
Speaker A
Manstein had calculated everything to perfection, and Kozlov had been utterly duped as heavy German forces began moving forward in the morning of the 8th of May. The German Luftwaffe swept over the Soviet positions, striking artillery batteries headquarters airfields and
Speaker A
communications, while a massive artillery bombardment devastated the immediate Soviet defenses. The German 30th Corps then attacked with a relentless speed, crashing into the Soviet southern front line, which quickly began to collapse. And within only a few hours, the front had been
Speaker A
kicked open. The German forces then split as the German 22nd Panzer Division suddenly turned north toward the Sea of Azov to cut off the dug-in Soviet 51st Army, while the rest of the corps continued east toward, along with dominating air
Speaker A
power, pushing the demoralized 44th and 47th Armies towards Kerch. Kozlov attempted to withdraw the 51st Army, but the German breakthrough had developed too quickly. By the 11th of May, the German spearheads had reached the northern coast, severing the retreat
Speaker A
of the Soviet 51st Army and completing the encirclements. Above them, the Luftwaffe maintained complete control of the skies. Aircraft relentlessly attacked the Soviet columns and evacuation routes everywhere, shattering Soviet morale and making it impossible for Kozlov to restore any coherent
Speaker A
defensive line again. By the 16th of May, organized resistance on the peninsula had rapidly begun to break down and the German forces entered Kerch.
Speaker A
In less than 2 weeks, the entire Soviet Crimean Front had been virtually destroyed, with Manstein having annihilated three Soviet armies, wiping out nine divisions and reducing nine more to ineffective remnants.
Speaker A
It was a brilliant demonstration of combined arms warfare, as deception and maneuver were combined with artillery and air power to annihilate a Soviet force twice its strength.
Speaker A
With the freed up German forces, Sevastopol would eventually fall as well, but Manstein wouldn't stay in Crimea for long, as he would soon be required hundreds of kilometers to the north to deal with another major Soviet offensive.
Speaker A
Following the fall of Sevastopol in July 1942, Manstein was promoted to Field Marshal and ordered to transfer much of his 11th Army hundreds of kilometers north. His next objective was Leningrad.
Speaker A
The city had now endured almost a year under a brutal German siege, but despite catastrophic losses from starvation and bombardment, Soviet forces continued to hold out.
Speaker A
Adolf Hitler now wanted the city taken in a large-scale assault, and Manstein's newly arrived forces were to join Army Group North in the operation, which was set to begin on the 14th of September, codenamed Operation Nordlicht.
Speaker A
But the Soviets were preparing an offensive of their own, which was set to begin on the 19th of August. Their objective, on the other hand, was to finally break the siege by attacking the narrow German-held corridor east of the
Speaker A
Neva River. A massive operation which would come to be known as the Sinyavino Offensive.
Speaker A
The Volkhov Front Soviet 8th Army was to spearhead the attack with the 2nd Shock Army and the 4th Guards Rifle Corps in the 2nd echelon. The Leningrad Front was also going to make localized attacks and secure bridgeheads across the Neva
Speaker A
River. Funnily enough, up until the final day of preparations, neither side had even the slightest idea that the other was building up forces for major offensives, ultimately leading both sides to be caught off guard in some way.
Speaker A
On the 19th of August, forces of the Leningrad Front began attacking across the Neva, drawing a few German troops away from where the hammer would ultimately fall the hardest.
Speaker A
Then, on the 27th, the main Soviet offensive began. The Soviets smashed into the German defenses from the east, catching them by a complete surprise as the Soviets advanced 3 km on the first day alone. Over the following days, more
Speaker A
Soviet formations poured through the breach, overwhelming the local German defenses and driving the salient more than 7 km deep by the 29th of August, eventually getting between just 5 km away from linking up with the Leningrad Front, and thereby threatened to isolate
Speaker A
the entire German force in the north. The situation could quickly spiral out of control, and Manstein had to constantly funnel in units to slow down the Soviet spearhead.
Speaker A
An interesting side note, by the way, the 29th of August saw the first ever combat deployment of the Tiger tanks as the 502nd Tank Battalion had just received four of them. Upon deployment, however, three broke down immediately and the impact of the fourth one was
Speaker A
minimal. The region around Sinyavino consisted largely of dense forests and swamps, making it difficult to move tanks and supplies through the narrow breakthrough. And with the rapidly mounting German reinforcements, the Soviets were eventually forced into a stalemate by the 10th of September. As
Speaker A
the 14th Soviet Air Army began to lose air superiority as well. Hitler now placed Manstein in charge of eliminating this salient.
Speaker A
The solution appeared obvious. Rather than push the Soviets backward through kilometers of heavily contested terrain, Manstein intended to strike the narrow base of the penetration and cut the entire force off from behind.
Speaker A
He launched the attack on the 10th of September, but the Soviets expected such an attack and pushed it back again through dense defenses and heavy artillery fire.
Speaker A
Manstein then decided for a pincer attack instead. And for the next 10 days, he concentrated additional forces around both shoulders of the Soviet salient.
Speaker A
On the 21st of September, the counteroffensive began with six divisions participating in the attack.
Speaker A
Their goal was to link up near Gaytolovo. Heavy lift off and German artillery bombarded the Soviet defenses before rows of German armor rolled forward. The fighting was extremely brutal. The same swamps and forests that had slowed the Soviet advance was now hindering the
Speaker A
Germans. While Soviet troops desperately defended the narrow corridor to the last man. But the German pincers steadily pushed forward and four days later on the 25th of September, the two forces met near Gaytolovo as planned. The corridor had
Speaker A
been severed and the Soviet 8th Army and 2nd Shock Army were now trapped inside of the salient.
Speaker A
The Soviets immediately attempted to break the encirclement from both directions, but Manstein refused to allow the pocket to reopen. German artillery and aircraft relentlessly bombarded the trapped Soviet formations, while the 12th Panzer Division defeated any Soviet attempts to expand the
Speaker A
bridgeheads from the west. And gradually, the pocket began to collapse. Some Soviet troops managed to escape through the forests and swamps, but all of their heavy equipment had to be left behind, as German forces systematically continued to squeeze the
Speaker A
pocket. And by the 10th of October, the front had returned to where it stood before the Soviet offensive began.
Speaker A
The Soviets suffered more than 100,000 casualties, while the Germans lost around 26,000 men of their own.
Speaker A
Considering the surprising element of the attack of Ever, Manstein had once again demonstrated his ability to turn a severely dangerous situation completely on its head by funneling in just enough force to hold the advance before eliminating the entire salient with a
Speaker A
massive pincer attack. The battle had however consumed the very forces and ammunition intended for Operation Nordlicht, and the planned assault on Leningrad would therefore never take place.
Speaker A
A few months later, however, Manstein would face an even greater crisis in the south.
Speaker A
In November of 1942, the Soviets launched Operation Uranus around Stalingrad, devastating the Romanian defenders protecting the German flanks, and ultimately leading to more than 250,000 Axis troops getting trapped inside of the city.
Speaker A
Manstein was now placed in command of the newly created Army Group Don. His attempts to relieve Stalingrad ultimately failed and on the 2nd of February 1943, the remnants of the German 6th Army surrendered. The disaster now appeared to have left the
Speaker A
entire German Southern Front on the verge of collapse as well and Stalin was determined to exploit the opportunity.
Speaker A
Believing the Wehrmacht to be exhausted and incapable of mounting another major offensive, the Soviets launched Operation Star and Gallop sending several armies on a friends and onslaughts westward.
Speaker A
The advance was swift with Kursk falling on the 8th of February and Kharkov on the 16th.
Speaker A
Further south, Soviet mobile formations under General Popov raced toward the Dnieper threatening to cut off huge portions of the German forces still retreating from the Caucasus.
Speaker A
The Soviet advance was dangerous, but it also presented an opportunity. Rather than attempt to hold every kilometer of ground, Manstein wanted to continue withdrawing and allow the Soviets to advance even further because for every kilometer they moved westward,
Speaker A
it would become more and more difficult for the Soviet supply lines to keep up, which would quickly lead to a shortage of fuel and ammunition. And only then would Manstein put his own units on the offensive. A concept that would famously
Speaker A
become known as Manstein's backhand blow. Instead of meeting an enemy offensive head-on, Manstein would first yield some territory, draw the enemy forward, and then advance with powerful armored units into the exposed flanks once momentum had begun to fade.
Speaker A
By the 18th of February, the Soviet spearheads had severely overextended themselves while Manstein's forces stood ready to strike back.
Speaker A
The operation known as the Donets campaign was launched on the 19th of February. In the west, the 2nd SS Panzer Corps turned south against the flank of the Soviet 6th Army. The SS Panzer Grenadier Divisions Das Reich and Totenkopf
Speaker A
advanced so rapidly that when they reached Peter Shapinya, the Soviet troops there thought they were friendly forces, allowing the SS Divisions to drive straight across the bridges before the Soviets had any chance to demolish them.
Speaker A
From the south, the 48th Panzer Corps advanced with the same lightning speed, eventually linking up around Pavlovgrad and encircling large chunks of the Soviet 6th Army.
Speaker A
At the same time, further east, the 1st Panzer Army attacked mobile group Popo, which tried to fall back. But severe fuel shortages and low ammunition allowed the German Panzers to basically roll right over them.
Speaker A
The Soviet casualties were now mounting rapidly as the Panzer armies continued in a relentless blitzkrieg with heavy Luftwaffe support.
Speaker A
Manstein didn't give the Soviets as much as a single minute to recover, and by the beginning of March, mobile group Popo had been virtually destroyed and the Soviet 6th Army had suffered catastrophic losses, especially in tanks, as many of them quite literally
Speaker A
ran out of fuel one by one. Even the Soviet Major General Vasily Kopsov was captured while sleeping in a German night attack on the 2nd of March.
Speaker A
The Soviet leadership now began to understand why the Germans had given them so much space to begin with and that Manstein had in fact been five steps ahead of them the entire time.
Speaker A
The spectacular advance he had allowed them to take had now turned into nothing but a devastating liability.
Speaker A
The 3rd Soviet Army now finally had enough fuel to mount a counterattack, but this was also just them playing right into Manstein's plan as he wanted to destroy the Third Army before advancing on Krakow. And now the Soviets
Speaker A
handed him his wish on a golden platter, as the Third Tank Army advanced straight into the SS divisions. The aerial attacks by Luftwaffe Stuka bombers inflicted horrific casualties before the ground fighting had even started. And once they met the German SS divisions on
Speaker A
the ground, the situation quickly turned into a disaster. The Soviet 12th and 15th Tank Corps were thrown onto the defensive by an overwhelming juggernaut of SS armor.
Speaker A
Their flanks were pierced, and yet another unbreakable encirclement had closed around an entire Soviet spearhead in a rapidly tightening pocket. And just like the many other Soviet pockets created since the counteroffensive began a couple of weeks ago, this one feared
Speaker A
no better. Unable to break out, they surrendered. A mere 2 days later, by the 5th of March, the entire Third Tank Army had been virtually destroyed, with only a fraction of the forces managing to escape up north. But Manstein wouldn't
Speaker A
give them any chance to breathe. And on the 7th of March, he ordered an advance on Krakow, with the full might of the Fourth Panzer Army advancing on the city from the west.
Speaker A
The Das Reich division, along with the Totenkopf and Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler, pressed forward with intense power, eventually semi-encircling the city in a massive right wheel maneuver.
Speaker A
By the 15th, the city was once again in German hands, eventually recapturing the city of Belgorod 3 days later, as well.
Speaker A
In less than a month, the situation in southern Russia had been completely reversed, as Manstein had played the Soviet advance to perfection.
Speaker A
The Soviets had begun the campaign believing Army Group South was collapsing, but they had gravely mistaken and their overextended spearheads had now been annihilated and the front had been restored along much of the Donets River.
Speaker A
Manstein's rare ability to read the battlefield, deceive his opponents, and use maneuver and timing to turn what seemed like desperate situations into brilliant victories over and over again is why Manstein was, in my opinion, one of the greatest operational geniuses in
Speaker A
all of military history. He survived the war and lived until 1973 and was buried with full military honors.
Speaker A
Thank you for watching. What is your favorite tactical masterpiece by Manstein and which commander should I cover next? Let me know in the comments and if you enjoyed the contents, why not subscribe? See you again soon.
Topics:Erich von MansteinCrimea 1942Operation TrappenjagdSevastopolKerchEastern FrontWWII operational warfareSoviet Crimean Frontmilitary historyBlitzkrieg











