Skip to content
Get App

King of the County: The Power of Sheriffs | CBS Reports

CBS investigation into Oklahoma sheriffs' abuse of power, centered on a recorded McCurtain County meeting where officials discussed plotting against local journalists.

Key Takeaways

  • Sheriffs in small counties often operate with minimal accountability, and existing removal mechanisms are rarely used.
  • Local journalism is critical for exposing abuses, and journalists in rural areas can face serious intimidation.
  • Electoral remedies alone may be insufficient when voters remain uninformed or institutions fail to act.
  • Federal civil rights oversight may be needed when local authorities are implicated in misconduct.

What the video covers

  • A CBS News investigation examines how sheriffs in small-town America hold significant, often unchecked power over residents.
  • The Gazette, a family-run newspaper in McCurtain County, Oklahoma, reported alleged misconduct in the sheriff's office under Sheriff Kevin Ccarty.
  • Publisher Bruce Willingham secretly recorded county commissioner meetings, capturing officials discussing violence, including plots against journalist Chris Willingham.
  • The recording went viral, prompting one county commissioner to resign, but the sheriff refused to step down and the state attorney general found no violation of law.
  • Oklahoma's sheriff removal process is so bureaucratic that it almost never succeeds, leaving voting as the only practical remedy.
  • The investigation documents abuses including jail beatings, deaths in custody, mishandled evidence, and suspicious deaths left uninvestigated.
  • Former White House and DOJ civil rights official Chog Baines calls the alleged plotting a potential federal crime and says such officials must not remain in power.
  • The report notes that sheriffs in America carry more law enforcement power than most elected officials, with minimal oversight.
  • Law enforcement killings by county sheriffs rose notably in 2023, according to the report.
  • Residents describe fear and a sense that corrupt officials cannot be challenged through ordinary channels.

Answers

Questions about this video

What did the secret recording reveal?

A recording made by Bruce Willingham at county commissioner meetings captured officials discussing violent acts, including hiring hitmen and plotting against journalists Chris Willingham and the regional prosecutor. The tape caused public outrage nationwide.

Why was the sheriff not removed from office?

Oklahoma law allows sheriffs to be removed for certain misconduct, but the process is so bureaucratic that it almost never happens. The state attorney general declared the sheriff broke no law, leaving voters as the only option.

What broader problem does the report highlight?

The report argues that sheriffs in small towns across America have significant autonomy and minimal oversight, enabling abuses such as jail beatings and uninvestigated deaths, and that existing accountability systems often fail to address them.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00
Speaker A
[Music] he planted a recording device and we had no idea what we were going to get if you're talking about burying two journalists two wellknown journalists well imagine what you can do to me do you have the power to call
00:31
Speaker A
Hitman in I don't know a murder plot discussed on tape implicates a County's Top Cop if you call 911 that's who's coming to your house you're talking about the sheriff that should provoke a lot of questions and reveals a problem
00:45
Speaker A
in small towns Across America horrific video of an inmate beaten while in the custody of deputies a CBS News investigation finds sheriffs abusing their power I never knew that the sheriff had so much power when you see a
01:00
Speaker A
pattern of things that's not a coincidence and there's little in place to stop them they have to feel Untouchable they're Above the [Music] Law More than 70% of America is rural and kind of looks like this small towns
01:26
Speaker A
dotted across the US where over 3,000 shares shiff have dominion over people far away from the national Spotlight sheriffs were America's first law enforcement their gold star is Iconic in Hollywood portrayals of US history from the wild west to Mayberry
01:47
Speaker A
and today sheriffs still operate with significant autonomy and influence in almost every state what does the Sheriff's Office do well you're going to get a lot of answers patrolling the streets managing the jail maintaining Court security providing resource
02:02
Speaker A
officers Patrol crime scene investigations what we call a full service agency you're also everybody's friend and sometimes everybody's enemy a sheriff is elected by the people to police the people and keep Law and Order we don't have a boss we have more power
02:19
Speaker A
than any elected officials in our County and probably in our state but nobody recognize that I can take you off the street put you in a solitary confinement cell restrict your ability to reach out and call a family member when our
02:35
Speaker A
constitution guarantees your rights I have the ability to limit your rights your Liberties countless sheriffs hold themselves to a high standard but little is in place to hold Sheriff's accountable when they don't a CBS News investigation found chronic abuses in
02:52
Speaker A
Sheriff Offices and systematic failures that can enable many of them to get away with it to understand how this happens we travel to corner of Oklahoma known as Little [Music] Dixie The Gazette has been serving MC curton County since 1905 it precedes
03:16
Speaker A
statehood the publisher is Bruce Willingham that's my father-in-law his wife is the bookkeeper Chris my husband is the investigative reporter and I'm the editor November 2021 Chris Willingham wrote a story in The Gazette about alleged misconduct inside the
03:33
Speaker A
local sheriff's office under Kevin clarity's Administration I received some pictures of the evidence room it was in complete disarray there's biological bags Spilled Out on the floor what appeared to be drugs Spilled Out on the floor some of these are murder cases
03:50
Speaker A
that haven't gone to trial yet so if you have tainted evidence you don't have a case these things just continued to happen in the weeks and months that followed the Willing hams continued to uncover new ations it just looked like
04:01
Speaker A
completely unchecked corruption let's talk about the tape mhm the county commissioner meetings take place every Monday my dad has covered them for more than 40 years and he noticed over about a 2-month period that these guys are breaking open meeting loss he planted a
04:17
Speaker A
recording device on March 6th and we had no idea what what we were going to get they caught County leaders talking about how they wanted to commit hate crimes and look back today When Alan Mary take a damn Blackjack
04:32
Speaker A
whoop their ass and throw them in the cell run chair yeah it's not like that I know take down Mud Creek and hang them up with the damn rope but you can't do that thing about it they got more RS
04:45
Speaker A
than we got they also discussed acts of violence against the regional prosecutor but they had special plans for the Willingham I've know two or three hit men that were very Qui guys yeah and would cutting no mercy in Louisiana cuz it was all Mafia around
05:04
Speaker A
L I know where two big deot are if you ever needed I got an escavator these are are free d one of you days I'm going to bounce his ass in order to protect Chris we had to make this public it went viral overnight
05:21
Speaker A
Across the Nation people are outraged lynching hiring Hitmen the audio is just terrifying it is horrifying I was just going on my Merry way and just thinking everything was perfect with the county and and then when this came out I'm like
05:35
Speaker A
wow you have the highest law enforcement power in the county talking about killing people if you're talking about burying two journalists two wellknown journalists well imagine what you can do to me do you have the power to call
05:53
Speaker A
Hitman in I don't know it's a very surreal thing to hear a table full of community leaders laughing about and plotting the murder of your husband if you live in the county if you call 911 that's who's coming to your house if
06:12
Speaker A
you're in an emergency what's going through your mind we've got to contact someone who can do something about this I knew idel police they would do what's right so we took the tape to them I told him I would take the report but I felt
06:27
Speaker A
it needed bigger eyes on it than mine and I went to the mccurtain County district attorney Mark matloff and Mark said we're going to put that in the mail to the attorney general my name is darl Blakeley worked for almost every law
06:42
Speaker A
enforcement agency in southeast Oklahoma I don't have a jurus doctorate I've never been to law school but I can tell you what I heard on that tape was crimes surely a murder plot would force some kind of change you would think so
07:00
Speaker A
in the immediate aftermath of the tape's release County Commissioner resigned and the governor called on the sheriff to do the same but he won't and neither will his captain no one in power will even try to make them he's not going to
07:14
Speaker A
resign he's not even going to acknowledge that this happened state law says that sheriffs can be removed for certain misconduct but the process is so bureaucratic that almost never happens the State Attorney General declared the sheriff broke no law and he left
07:29
Speaker A
residence with only one option vote in the next [Music] election in saying that the voters left thinking oh well there's nothing here so I may just go and cast my vote for him this whole episode exposed just how difficult it is to
07:47
Speaker A
unseat somebody in that position and what you're describing is a failure of democracy it's one of the vulnerabilities of of the majority rule my name is chog Baines I was deputy director of the domestic policy council at the White House for President Biden
08:02
Speaker A
from 2021 to 2023 I also served as a prosecutor in a career capacity of civil rights crimes including police brutality I want to get your reaction to this tape sheriff is still in power it's extremely serious and extremely disconcerting
08:17
Speaker A
going just based on what you told me those allegations somebody plotting to kill someone else using their government Authority that's a federal crime you're talking about the leader of the Sheriff's Department the sheriff that is enough to Warrant uh
08:34
Speaker A
scrutiny into the whole office because this person's at the top in terms of whether someone like that should be in power absolutely not nothing has happened to them I mean they they have to feel Untouchable they're Above the
08:51
Speaker A
[Music] Law we had some really really dark times here for a while I had a gun inside my my waistband and I had an air tag in my shoe if I was to get nabbed or picked up there'd be some evidence for for my wife
09:13
Speaker A
to try to find me how are you feeling right now my stomach's pretty tight if the people who are protecting you are corrupt what do you what do you do to try to answer that question a group of
09:24
Speaker A
concerned citizens rallied together when you first heard the tape what did you think I could not believe what was being said I never knew that the sheriff had so much power and it's not locker room talk it's not it's
09:39
Speaker A
not it's not locker room talk this stuff has been going on down through the years public safety issues here started long before the tape and even the current Sheriff there's a history of violence and residents feel that too many
09:52
Speaker A
suspicious deaths have gone un investigated we're dealing with people that probably wouldn't care one bit about taking our lives and if God forbid something happened to any of your loved ones may not even be investigated well just like just
10:11
Speaker A
like Cory Carter there was video it video we saw the video how they killed him we saw the video no accountability that's 9 years ago 9 years ago and it's just a cover of according to court records in 2015 Cory
10:29
Speaker A
Carter a mentally ill man was booked into the mcer county jail and 4 hours later he had no pulse now officers brought Carter into the shower room and there was a physical altercation one Jailer strangled him while others tased
10:43
Speaker A
him multiple times then surveillance video shows that they dragged his naked limp body into a restraint chair as he slowly died no criminal charges were ever brought Carter's family sued claiming wrongful death the county denied the allegations but agreed to pay
10:59
Speaker A
settlement we found that there's a long documented history of misconduct allegations under the Sheriff's Office another inmate in mccurtain County alleged civil rights violation several years later he says mcc's former Sheriff conspired to lock up his daughter's teenage boyfriend in the county jail
11:17
Speaker A
where officers and inmates were sent to beat the boy up and caused permanent injuries his lawsuit is ongoing he was abused in the shower precisely the same spot where Cory Carter was abused in the shower that's not a
11:34
Speaker A
coincidence if they want to tune somebody up they know right where to go to do it Mitchell Garrett is a civil rights attorney who represents victims including that teenager who sued the mccurtain county sheriff's office for excessive force when you see a pattern
11:49
Speaker A
of things it really makes you wonder is it incompetence or is it this is the way they do business and this is not the only case no it's March 2022 well this interesting Sheriff deputies are called to a crime
12:07
Speaker A
scene this is Bobby Barrett stop please don't don't kill me stop please don't kill me stop please don't kill me he won't survive help help help they're murdering me help they're coming me baric is still handcuffed when four
12:26
Speaker A
officers wrestle him into submission and one deputy stuns him with a personal taser this is where it all went down and Bobby baric was tased twice by sheriffs according to their own reports and he later died of those injuries Bobby
12:44
Speaker A
Barrack's death doesn't show up in any crime statistics as if it never happened and that's because according to the mcer county sheriff there was no crime what I was told is he was tasered while handcuffed would that ever happen
13:00
Speaker A
at the idel PD that is against the use of force continuum that is not allowed no what were the findings of the investigation well that's where it gets super interesting there was no investigation doesn't Oklahoma state law require it does an investigation it does
13:19
Speaker A
you would think that someone would have called the OSBI someone would have called maybe the FBI maybe they would have called his wife I don't know call someone no one got called federal law also requires law enforcement to report
13:32
Speaker A
when a person dies in their custody but most of the time it doesn't happen nowhere is worse than in Oklahoma law enforcement killed people at a higher rate here than in any other state but in 84% of those deaths officers don't
13:46
Speaker A
report the use of lethal Force you just did the nut and shell game if I don't report the crime I don't have to report it to the OSBI and the OSBI doesn't have to report it to the FBI you think that
13:59
Speaker A
these citizens are now less safe yes and crimes go unpunished or or not even investigated it's awful hard to prosecute or investigate something when um it's not being accurately reported is that being done my opinion no we found that last year three4 of
14:25
Speaker A
crimes here went unsolved by the Sheriff's Office seems like the problem problem is bigger than the sheriff I mean there's a system that allows this to continue to Fester curious our office called numerous times the state Bureau of Investigation
14:43
Speaker A
nothing the state Bureau of Investigation nothing the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation declined to [Laughter] comment according to the map the M Curtain County Sheriff's Office is the uh is right up here hidden behind storage facilities and the lumber
15:10
Speaker A
[Music] yard so we've reached out repeatedly and all we've heard is from the sheriff's personal attorney declining comment so uh we just decided to come here to try to get some aners can't even get in can I help you
15:32
Speaker A
uh yes hi my name is Adam Yamaguchi with CBS News and we've been trying to reach uh the office here repeatedly and haven't heard back we're just hoping to uh to be able to speak to a representative here hey hi there how are you hi Adam
15:52
Speaker A
Yamaguchi with CB nice to meet you Mike nice to meet you we are here because we have spoken to so many concerned residents who who who have questions who have asked us they they haven't asked us anything I really don't care what
16:05
Speaker A
somebody's accusing somebody of or anything else know uh everything is handled we'll talk to you you know through the attorney we just want to make sure that you get a fair Shake because there's been a lot that's said
16:17
Speaker A
about the sheriff's department in the press and I completely understand like to lie to you I'm really glad yall actually try to get our side of things too we to tell you whatever whatever we could tell you but you know
16:32
Speaker A
unfortunately you know all the attorneys are saying hey no comment right you know and I mean you do what your attorney tells you to do but across town the local district attorney has been quietly documenting potential crimes inside the
16:45
Speaker A
sheriff's office we obtained a trove of Insider law enforcement documents and court records and I'm looking at letters that the da sent to the state attorney general and he points to numerous allegations involving criminal behavior and corruption in May of 2018 the da
17:02
Speaker A
writes to recuse himself from a possible investigation into the mcar county sheriff in these documents we can track a federal criminal investigation but the FBI won't tell us either way what they found or whether they're still investigating if laws were broken surely
17:18
Speaker A
something would have happened by now the fact that there's not a criminal charge doesn't mean there was not misconduct what are the practical limitations of the doj the justice department has to be willing to bring these cases and to be candidate that has varied from
17:32
Speaker A
presidency to presidency there is a relatively small team at the justice department to do this work how many would you say it's probably a couple of dozen people with the expertise and the depth of experience to do this work so
17:45
Speaker A
just a couple dozen that are dedicated to overseeing policing across the country 340 million people 178,000 law enforcement agencies I mean doj can't remedy all the wrongs that's absolutely true there's responsibility ility all along the Spectrum local officials State
18:02
Speaker A
officials you feel like the system let you down I just don't think the system is designed to protect against something like this even after the scandal of the audio tape The Gazette continued to document misconduct allegations these people could do anything and based on
18:20
Speaker A
all that's happened seemingly Untouchable mcarton county is the sheriff's Little Kingdom and he's all powerful nobody's above we're not supposed to be in this country above the law not even your highest ranking officials there has to be accountability
18:37
Speaker A
there's been none zero the curtain county is not alone stories of sheriff misconduct are playing out Across America and you don't have to go far before you find other people falling victim with virtually no accountability this is just next door in
18:55
Speaker A
mcer County Oklahoma this County Sheriff deputies pulled the car over for an obscured license plate the driver is unarmed but they shoot eight times and kill him the deputy went on to work Patrol in another small town his record
19:14
Speaker A
is clean and there was no criminal charge like 99% of all fatal police violence we're just talking about deaths here there are many other forms lesser forms of violence that cause significant harm to people which is just to say the
19:29
Speaker A
scope of the problem is much bigger than the public probably perceives I think that's right yes that information is critical for accountability and in a democracy don't we all have a right to know how force is being used in our
19:44
Speaker A
names American law enforcement killed more people in 2023 than any other year in the past decade and increasingly it's happening at the hands of county sheriffs the majority of the cases I represent are under sheriffs I mean vast
20:01
Speaker A
majority it's like 10 to one the impact of sheriff misconduct is almost everywhere Meg County Frank County Sheriff County deput Fredick County Sheriff shiff we're not looking at where we need to be looking we should be scrutinizing Sheriff's offices as much as we are at
20:21
Speaker A
police departments I think you're right that they don't get enough scrutiny our team analyzed data all across the us we found that County Sheriff Offices are three three times more lethal than City police departments are you alarmed I am
20:34
Speaker A
I am alarmed by that I mean that should provoke a lot of questions it's not just a situation of bad apples there are systems that need attention in this country police officers Deputy sheriffs agents are believed when they make a
20:49
Speaker A
statement that's why not everybody can do this job and we have to be the advocate we're not perfect but you got to believe that we can do better we can be better better everybody should be held accountable all I tried to do the entire
21:05
Speaker A
time was tell the truth and I could be killed for doing this did the sheriff win my children asked me the same question they said dad do the bad guys win and I I said maybe sometimes but this isn't over yet
21:29
Speaker A
[Music]
Topics:sheriffsrural policingpolice accountabilityMcCurtain Countylocal journalismOklahomaabuse of powerCBS Reportspress freedomlaw enforcement oversight

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →