Luke Gromen and Jeff Booth discuss free markets, deflation, debt-based money, and why Bitcoin-style hard money could change incentives for producers.
Key Takeaways
- A free market's natural tendency is falling prices driven by innovation and abundance.
- Debt-based, controllable money enables centralized control and erodes productivity gains.
- Hard money changes incentives for producers and may force a shift toward decentralized systems.
- Current economic and monetary debates often lack shared definitions, leading to confusion.
What the video covers
- The conversation argues that the natural state of a free market is deflation, as productivity and abundance push prices down over time.
- Hard money (gold or Bitcoin) changes producer incentives: instead of forming cartels like OPEC to defend prices, producers are incentivized to maximize output.
- The speakers note that a truly free global market has never existed; the closest proxy was the early US under the Constitution before central banking.
- Terms like 'capitalism' and 'socialism' are often used loosely and debated without shared definitions, obscuring what people actually mean.
- China encourages citizens to buy gold while maintaining centralized control, illustrating a paradox between state control and decentralized ownership.
- Scarcity produces pricing signals that drive both attempts at control and innovation; more control tends to create more attack vectors and chaos.
- Debt created as money allows a control system to form, with productivity gains flowing to the currency issuer over time.
- Fiat systems stretch until regulatory or market bumpers are hit, and the speed of change relative to indebtedness of the incumbent system is key.
- The speakers discuss Bitcoin's early history (2009-2012) and the risk that stored-value assets get centralized like gold unless they keep circulating as money.
- Stablecoins tethered to the dollar are critiqued as not truly stable, since they import the dollar's ongoing value loss.
Chapters
- 00:00Opening and Format of the Conversation
- 05:00Natural Deflation in a Free Market
- 16:40Debate Over Capitalism and Socialism Terms
- 30:00Control, Scarcity, and Debt-Based Money
- 43:20Fiat Systems and Regulatory Limits
- 55:00Bitcoin's History and Monetary Design
- 66:40Stablecoins and Dollar Dependence
- 78:20Closing Reflections on Monetary Systems
Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown
Speaker A
for thanks for the idea of this. I you just want to like have a conversation basically. I think that's kind of the best way to I think that's the point. Yeah. You and I you and I had a really good
Speaker A
conversation and thought we should do this in in a format that can other people can listen to it.
Speaker A
Sure. Yeah. Sure. So where do you want to dive in? Why don't you why don't I I I'll I'll give the floor to you and then and then just kind of start pulling on threads and Yeah. So or or maybe what what we can
Speaker A
start with or at least the where we agree on different kind of different Yeah, that's perfect.
Speaker A
And uh and then why this would be confusing uh why this would be really confusing time for anybody right that we go through. So I think we both agreed to poke back if the if you don't the the
Speaker A
natural state of free market is deflation. Yep. Right. So we can we we constantly create more value uh for each try to create more value for each other and the output of that is we use the things that give us
Speaker A
more value and prices should fall. they should fall. And and also when you get paid in a money that preserves value over time or you when you get paid in a hard current a hard currency that should incentivize
Speaker A
producers to maximize production so that they can have access more quickly to the better currency before the deflation happens and so it ends up being a virtuous self. So in other words, a simple example, if I'm an oil producer
Speaker A
in in wherever, the Middle East, if I'm getting paid in bad currency, then I need to form a cartel. I need to make sure that everyone's maintaining supplies are high because we need to maintain the value of our oil in the
Speaker A
ground relative to those paper dollars, which are infinite. That's why you need an OPEC. If you're getting paid in gold or Bitcoin, your incentive changes entirely. All of a sudden, you're like, "Run those oil fields flat out because
Speaker A
we want to produce as much oil as we can and invest as much we can to produce oil to get the better currency because we want to have that better currency today before prices fall. We'll get more for our money than that way
Speaker A
versus less for our money. Yeah, similar. But I would say even where I go from there there first and um is well I absolutely agree with everything you just said. Well, I go the first thing I go to is how would you
Speaker A
know if you've never lived or there's never been a recognition of a free market, right? Because we've never had a global coordinated free market. We had a the best proxy to what we're talking about is the US from the constitution on
Speaker A
until like the central bank, right? Yep. But that was that was a local idea of this with people flocking to the US so the their ideas could matter which created the the most prosperous nation the world has ever seen.
Speaker A
Yeah. No, I totally agree with that. And never but we've never had a different we've never had a global free uh framework. We don't actually know what that would look like.
Speaker A
I agree. And which means which mean which now going back to the other stuff that when we keep on kind of introducing what it would look like through a currency that's always been debased or or controlled like gold is only you you
Speaker A
once you've once you have enough of it you change the rules. Yeah. Yeah. Right. Because even in those situation, gold was fixed to a a unit of currency which then is which which it's it's challenging right you you're
Speaker A
you're you're fixing one variable while you're not fixing population you're not fixing ingenuity invention you're not fixing money supply per se. um you are but you it's it's at least constrained but land production like all those things were
Speaker A
wildly un those were free and floating and that leads to ultimately what you get to with a fixed unit of a or you know fixed gold peg is it it breaks it enforces bad deflation and breaks.
Speaker A
Yeah. you know, and and maybe inside that, you know, bad deflation, good deflation, like these these terms, what why why I wanted to do this or have this conversation with you is these there's so nuance these terms we use, right? And
Speaker A
we think we're saying one thing and we're saying another. When I when when I when I see people driving a debate on Twitter and the nonsense on both sides of the debate, all the nuances missed.
Speaker A
like like in capitalism and socialism right right now right what are they actually saying when they in invoke these words what do they mean underneath that because I I my belief is they mean the free market but if we've never lived in a free
Speaker A
market then they must mean something else completely agree I I see that perfect example in terms of you know when you try to distribute for example the chi the the Chinese communist party they encourage their people to buy gold and have for 25 years
Speaker A
that's a very paradoxical thing is this government with centralized control of the economy blah blah blah and yet they are at the same time encouraging what is a very capitalistic decentralized dynamic within a centralization is is we want
Speaker A
you to own gold, but it by the way it can't leave. Yeah. Under our rules.
Speaker A
Right. Under rules. You can you can do this under our rules. Right. Right. And that's Yeah. To your point, it it's it's supports your point to both points. A we've never lived in a true free market and B
Speaker A
the um what do people mean when they call something something the label? Yeah. Exactly. And fight. so feverously about the thing that they can't explain.
Speaker A
Yeah. Right. Against the other people who can't explain it. I think socialism from what I experience here in American politics is is the this the free stuff that the government gives somebody else and capitalism is when the government gives me stuff.
Speaker A
But it's it's wild to kind of poke on those those nuances and and see ourselves in. Right. So if you if you just go back to what do we agree on? We agree never lived in the in in the free
Speaker A
market. The natural state of that would mean falling prices or more abundance forever because because the the output of that would mean we were competing with 8 billion people on Earth, right?
Speaker A
And and the way things get solved and have always got solved is is the scarcity produces a pricing signal which which drives two different outcomes.
Speaker A
One, I try to control it, right? Um and two, I innovate around it and both coexist at the same time. But for us to live on top of the innovation that's always happened, right? When Mouth said we all starve to death
Speaker A
because 90% of the population is is in farming. We can't support any more farming. The innovation comes out of our mind and we innovate to create right abundance out of what the scarcity what was there before that we can't even see
Speaker A
we're doing and that's the thing that shows up in the freedom. That fair yeah I think that's fair. So the more control. So a different way of saying that is simplifying. The more control you have the more attack vectors, more scarcity,
Speaker A
the higher pricing signal, the more attack vectors come from us all over the world trying to get out of the control.
Speaker A
Fair? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, but that would create lots of chaos on the way through, lots of cycles on the way through. And we've never lived in a money that would allow that to h that would happen. So So we've
Speaker A
always lived in the control system because everything that was in it was tethered to the money.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. And then the debt is created in the money which creates the control system.
Speaker A
Exactly. So, it's it's a it's a pretty good trip, like the devil's trip, if you can lend money into existence and get an interest rate on it and everybody everybody in the world believes that's that's money, right? Because because because if they
Speaker A
believed that was money and what they would do from that money is they would remove the productivity gains that should naturally flow to them.
Speaker A
Yeah, it would go it would go to the currency issuer over time. Go to the currency issues which would be more and more control.
Speaker A
Yep. Okay. So, we agree on all of that. Never existed before the the other thing we you came up to Vancouver. I introduced you to robotics company and we we had some like great dinners and talks and everything else. So the uh um but but we
Speaker A
should be seeing globally explosion of productivity right that from AI and robotics and that and that that will over time remove remove a bunch of labor right yep we would we agree on that yeah and that's arguably accelerating
Speaker A
meaningfully right whether we talk about the Microsoft headlines that have come out since we since we talked I mean, even literally we talked 10 days ago and you know, American Express, etc., Barclays.
Speaker A
Yeah. And it has to because if you tried to push prices up against that and there was now technology or AI, we name it AI.
Speaker A
You can create robots using the same name or whatever. The more you push prices up, the faster companies face they have to remove labor. Otherwise, people can't afford their products and services anymore.
Speaker A
So the consumers wouldn't show up for their products unless they remove the labor at a at a really fast rate. So the faster you push on one labor to force prices up, faster you're driving companies just acting in their best
Speaker A
interest, in your best interest to stay alive after we get very Yeah. And I I would argue we're seeing that in the real economy as we speak, right, with a lot of what we're seeing with China is not them. Yes. Are they
Speaker A
overproducing? We're calling they're overproducing, but that's that's abundance. And it is it's not because their currency is strengthening against the dollar, not weakening. Should it be stronger? Of course, probably should.
Speaker A
But the prices are falling so much because they've invested so heavily into these technologies that have automated things all along the supply chain where you're they the sort of the AI abundance the robotics abundance that is theoretical still here in the west is
Speaker A
not theoretical over there and it is leading to massive deflation internally massive export volumes and it is creating the political issues by virtue of what you just said which is the consumers aren't going to show up for your product. I mean, if BYD showed up
Speaker A
here in America and sold their cars or Xiaomé sold their cars here in America for what they're selling there, every automaker in the West would be out of business by, you know, next next summer.
Speaker A
If you see some of the dark factories and how that production looks compared to production here, it's just night and day.
Speaker A
That That's exactly right. And that's So, you're seeing that happen in real time. It's not It's not spec it's no longer speculative.
Speaker A
Yeah. And and we can expect that just from the free market. We should we should expect that to accelerate. It has to accelerate because we only choose things that give us more value, right? Yeah. You see the Chinese EV
Speaker A
sales, you know, or electric scooters, right? They're up like 40%. Well, why? Well, when you jack up the price of oil by cutting off the straight of Hormuz, you know, Trump is like the the the Chinese EV and scooter salesman of the
Speaker A
year globally. Um, and then and then we're let's let's not get into the financial, right? Let's let's let's save that for uh for for a second. But that but but but that that framework of of of we've never lived in
Speaker A
a free market, although we think we have and we think it's those other people who don't. They don't know how to build theirs. We And we we do, right? We um but we've never lived in the free market
Speaker A
either. We don't have a pattern recognition for what it should look like when when the free market because the free market is an infinite game. We have to create value in somebody else's term terms.
Speaker A
They have to accept it and then everything else has processing. Yeah. You have to protect your own monopolies.
Speaker A
you have to drive drive regulation whatever that's in this. So um so from that um how could you fix that uh how could you fix that problem from credit money I don't know that you can right I mean
Speaker A
it's it is a it ultimately leads to it's sort of the van misuses choice right either the the abandonment of the system itself or the destruction of the currency involved yes and so yeah and and and I think that's where you see
Speaker A
as you do right very often through this p through this path you're playing out what's happening in currency and and different currencies as is all over the world balances into bounces into each other but but even even that bond meases crap the
Speaker A
you can't the currency itself if you have if you allow the natural state of free America, the currency itself would fall to zero. There would be nothing left.
Speaker A
No, that's exactly right. Because because of the debt that's there. Yeah. Yeah. The debt and and and because the debt is money.
Speaker A
Yeah. Right. And the debt Yeah. It's just a promise of future money, right? Yeah.
Speaker A
Exactly. And so so then so so if there's no so and then the other side of that resolve um what would happen from debasing currencies more which is what seems to be happening right now what what would be the outcome of that
Speaker A
you're going to see secular inflation you're going to see secular political instability rising you're going to see um you will see and the political inst stability will come because you you may be able to make prices rise but you can't reorder
Speaker A
economic priorities right so ultimately food and oil and energy and net needs healthcare will rise faster than wants or luxury goods in most cases and that leads to margin pressures that leads to political instabilities that leads to all those types of things
Speaker A
That's sort of what we're living through, right? Which is the periodic injection of currency units to try to slow down or offset the deflationary impact of both the technology but then also the drag of high levels of debt
Speaker A
which also Yeah. Great. Naturally push deflation as well. Exactly. So now but but again keep going on that I think because I think that's really important. Um the because it's not it's not like when people think about inflation they think about should
Speaker A
it be two or three or or one or four what's the percent what's the rate essentially what's the rate of theft is really really yeah what percent yeah purchasing power theft instead of saying is theft okay right what is the rate of theft this I'm okay
Speaker A
I have no vote in it so so the democracy I live in there is no vote on the rate of theft. But the rate of theft doesn't start at zero. If the natural state of the free market is
Speaker A
inflation, the rate of theft starts at whatever the productivity rate of the world is, which might be -5 orgative -6, meaning if you were doing nothing, if you didn't have a job, you'd be getting 65 or 6% richer.
Speaker A
And if you if you were if you were measuring it from this other system, that would be the centralization that was happening for you.
Speaker A
That would be the surveillance that had to happen for you. That would be the the that would be the division for making you believe it had to be somebody else other than you that it was at fault that
Speaker A
was happening for you. All of those things would be a construct from a system that could not allow the natural state of free market has to extract at a faster pace.
Speaker A
Yeah. No, that's exactly right. So, so and if you increase the rate of theft a lot more which which okay would there be any safe asset inside that system? Ultim in extremist no right there are safer assets but you would have to hold that
Speaker A
you would have to hold a bearer asset out of that system. Yeah that's the part that I really want to dive into like that bearer asset and for a long time through through these crisises through long history of time
Speaker A
it's always been gold. Yep. Right. Yeah. It's gold. It's Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And it can be anything but gold is sort of forever was the best in terms of portability, most moneylike, most convertible, most right um you know
Speaker A
value to storage, value to storage to portability, right? It's, you know, it's a pain in the butt to take a lot of silver, but silver can work. But it's, you know, but the and I think the same thing when
Speaker A
you when you play on that, you keep on playing on on that, you you said something really critical. It has to be outside of the system.
Speaker A
Yeah. And and all of these assets, the very nature of an asset is the very very nature is it's tethered to the system because you're pricing it in the other units, right? In fact, holding an asset with very when you say asset, it it's because
Speaker A
you you're holding something because you know the currency is being devalued. You you know you're playing in a rigged game. So you're trying to collect tokens in that rigged game hoping that the game board doesn't change.
Speaker A
Yeah. And I think there's a critical reason that's the case, right? Which is you only can pay your taxes in those in those currency units, right? If you could pay your taxes in other things, goats or gold or bitcoin or whatever,
Speaker A
then that starts to change that changes that dynamic a lot. The ultimate enforcer of that I think is that you know that's a sort of a monetary modern monetary theory construct that I think is is is accurate which is if you owe as long as you owe
Speaker A
taxes in that currency then you've got to then you're in that system and you've got to get you have to that's that's why you think in those terms.
Speaker A
Yeah. But I think they're all the reasons you think in your bathing in this thing.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. every single thing reinforces. You're in this system and all the exit doors. Even when you say taxes, right? You think it's an exit door, it's there's like all these doors saying go into the same room with the
Speaker A
walls closing on. Yeah. Because because there is no and and it's not bad people. It's a fundamental incompatibility between systems.
Speaker A
Yeah. Right. It's a credit money can't allow the free market. Correct. Yeah. Isn't that a wild thing, right? Credit money can't allow the free market. And most people's perception of capitalism is the free market.
Speaker A
Yes. It It's quite the paradox. Quite the paradox. So, uh, okay. Where do you want to go?
Speaker A
Where do you want to go now? I I think we we're we're we're agreed on a lot of these different things. Principles, first principles of what we're dealing with. We have a we have a a change so big, right? Tied with
Speaker A
technology, how fast technology is moving, we've never seen before. How fast monetary system that we've always lived in is breaking or buckling. um how fast uh surveillance is coming at all these things, how fast control is coming, how
Speaker A
fast division is coming, all of these things. From the very from a very simple principle, we're not living in a freedom.
Speaker A
Yep. It is. And it's the it's the speed of the change relative to the size and indebtedness of the incumbent system.
Speaker A
That is the that is the it's the problem and it's also the source of the volatility and it implies the volatility is going to keep getting bigger and bigger as the change happens faster and faster. So as you know I just saw something
Speaker A
AI 8 months ago it could do I don't know 2.8% 8% of jobs, projects, professional projects at a professional level. And that number is doubling every 3.7 months. And so that the pace of the exponential technology deflation that
Speaker A
you highlighted in your book all those years ago, as fast as that was, and I mean, I'm not telling you anything you don't know, but it's again because people are looking not looking at it through that lens, they don't see what's
Speaker A
happening here, which is the game is moving so fast. None of us can catch up.
Speaker A
There's there's and it is so fast that they can't they can't print the currency units fast enough because it's too obvious to to fight the deflation.
Speaker A
Yeah. And by the way, if you see the same but on both on both levers they're both structures of a foundation. Why use the paper folding analogy? I'll just say it again really quickly for people who haven't heard it.
Speaker A
Sorry. What's that? Why use the what that paper folding analogy I used? Oh yeah. Yeah. That's a great Yep.
Speaker A
That's a great analogy. Yep. But fold a piece of paper on itself 50 times and it'll reach the sun. You can only fold it seven, but if you could fold it 50 times because the early folds doesn't feel like anything and then the later
Speaker A
folds. Yeah. That's like you're probably still 90% of the way from the sun on like the last five folds and then the last five folds you're like bang my bang there.
Speaker A
Yeah. And that's what we're we're getting to like the 45th fold here. And now but think about that premise from so when I when I started use that analogy to say where we were going and how fast AI
Speaker A
would come in the in the book I started at Moors law let's say 1965 and when I wrote the book we were on fold 32 fold 33 and why I knew how fast AI was coming was because I knew what
Speaker A
the bigger steps would look like but but where we are right now moving from fold 37 to 38 there there when you say we have no no possible way to understand how fast this is. It's it's the same
Speaker A
thing. We're in this seat steps. But if you go backwards before that paper folding is an means all history wheel books printing press electricity all the way up to the first fold happened in that thin piece of paper before that.
Speaker A
all of human history that doubling right happened before it felt full at once and that's now we're in this this um this what feels exponential to us because it's moving at such a rate and means the world's moving the slow world's moving
Speaker A
the slowest it ever will by such a radical degree. Yeah. So, so now let's wave a magic wand. We fix the monetary problem with $365 trillion of debt is automatically solvent. Everything's fixed out of the same system and this keeps marching on.
Speaker A
Could you solve this with credit money? No, you can't, right? Because it's the same.
Speaker A
It's fundamentally you cannot have free market and credit money together. Yeah. It's impossible. And it's so it's fascinating, right?
Speaker A
Because the way you and we kind of talked about this and you stop me if I'm jumping ahead, but we we talked about this offline that generated this call, which is part of the way, you know, if Bitcoin
Speaker A
was still just Bitcoin, let's call it it was 2009 to 2011 Bitcoin or 12 Bitcoin, something right?
Speaker A
It would probably be some enormous number already. But the way you dilute this or the way you try to maintain the sanctity of the credit system is by you know the same way they did with gold, right? With credit gold,
Speaker A
right? Credit you you you've got to do you you create some sort of you you have to create proxies acceptable proxies of the bearer assets that allow people to escape the system to maintain the system. And that's what
Speaker A
paper gold was about. That's what unallocated credit and out of London, gold credit out of London was about.
Speaker A
Um, I don't want to get too much on the on the, you know, the the the Bitcoin side of doing that, but when you see credit proxies broadly speaking for it, that's how you manage it, right? Like that's how you try to dilute
Speaker A
that's how you try to buy yourself time. Yeah. System time. Or not not even time. You You you consume the thing that was outside the system from the system.
Speaker A
You bring it into the system and then you can then you can strangle it in the crypt.
Speaker A
And you can strangle that and strangle it. You and and if you were and if you understood these two systems, you would understand that that game would have always been a play. And what gives the what gives that game power?
Speaker A
Us. us operating inside the system that we say that we're different from all the other people operating inside the system.
Speaker A
Okay. And we always have and lose and so so you know in my in my work with Bitcoin that's what I like the you had to to is it truly outside? How could it stay decentralized and secure against this
Speaker A
overwhelming force that was us good bad and nature of of what we say we'll do versus what we do.
Speaker A
That's what we Yeah. It's just comes down to like the you know the political side of it essentially right of of broadly speaking I'm not Democrat or Republican but simply I don't even think it's political side at all. I honestly don't I think it's I
Speaker A
think it's it's way deeper than that. It's a it's an emerging phenomena of of us and so so the and I think this is where Bitcoin or gold or the fight between Bitcoin and gold and all of those people and you have to defend your
Speaker A
territory. The same thing is being used against all of us, right? Y most members are hard money advocates.
Speaker A
They know everything we just talked about. Yep. Not know how they make the system stronger. they're measuring the hard money in the thing that's weakening and saying they're a hard money advocate. So, they might not know that part, but but uh but they uh but they're
Speaker A
generally aligned. Um and they're generally aligned that that gold has served really well at this purpose is setting putting brakes on government spending but always get in the end gets co-opted.
Speaker A
Yep. Now, could Bitcoin resolve that without getting co-opted? And if you looked at stable coins or all of what's happening, which is just a CBDC when I said it was surveillance state, all it is is CBDC disguise.
Speaker A
Um that um which is a totally natural byproduct of the control system that you be trying it could come in and and a lot of people wanting to use that Bitcoin couldn't resolve this paradox.
Speaker A
It would be impossible for Bitcoin to resolve this paradox. say decentralized and secure unless it unless it became a money as well.
Speaker A
Unless it became what? Money as well. Yeah. Because because it has to keep moving because otherwise it can get collected and gets collected centralized just like gold did. Right. Yep. And um and you could see in incenting that to happen by
Speaker A
offering higher interest rate to collect it just like gold just like banks did with gold. And that for a time driving more money supply which drove a boom bus cycle that then needed you don't have enough of you. You went for the highest
Speaker A
interest rate from your bank because they were leveraging your gold the most and then wanted protection from your own actions.
Speaker A
Yeah. So, so that same game has to play out in Bitcoin, too. And and and to to But it has to be money to be able to survive.
Speaker A
Yeah. Which is a sobering thought. Which is a sobering which is sobering thought. I don't think it is. I I don't think it is a sobering thought. It's just enough people need to know that enough. The way I say I don't think it
Speaker A
doesn't matter one iota what governments do. It matters what people do. Governments get the power get get their power from the people and as long as the people are willing to give all of their rights away to the government,
Speaker A
governments have all the power. As soon as people shift and say individual rights and freedoms are important that the the government is supposed to serve its people, not pray on them. And a government that prints money has to eventually pray on its
Speaker A
has to eventually what? prey on its people. Yeah. Because it's a control system and it's not it's not a democracy. At some point can't be a democracy as more of the more of the more of the control comes from
Speaker A
printing than a vote. Yeah. So, so for for me in this if the and maybe this is a this is a term thing on Bitcoin or or something, but seeing this fight play out or seeing what had to
Speaker A
play out, right? And you have to think in in layers and what happens. So when I think Bitcoin and I think of it as the first layer of a protocol like the internet that is expanding and doing more and more um but when I think
Speaker A
about that when when so Paul Baron's work that was the early internet but was was essentially decentralized secure communications that couldn't shut down at PARPA, the NRNet and BARPA took that took that over because because in a nuclear holocaust you had to retain
Speaker A
communications. That nugget that was the beginning of the entry was so secure and decentralized that the market started building on top of it in layers. Um and and that part of the internet is still completely decentralized and secure and
Speaker A
then layers on top were until it took 20 years until Tim Berners Lee and the worldwide web right HTTP 20 years of evolution and the same battle for the internet that's happening in Bitcoin exact same things different companies wanted their
Speaker A
own internets wanted to control the thing but the open network open protocol kept driving the inflation on top of it. So when I see Bitcoin now and what's happening is is both things are happening at the same time. You have
Speaker A
a whole bunch of people pricing Bitcoin in terms of the currency that they noticed it's losing value and falling into a trap of a control system.
Speaker A
And I would say that's the majority of Bitcoiners and the majority of uh and not bad pe not bad people just like majority of people who aren't in Bitcoin aren't bad people. They're trying to uh they're trying to make sense of a crazy world
Speaker A
and trying to make the best decisions for themselves and their families in this crazy world. It's hard to put your finger on the issues we're talking about, especially when you're trying to put your fingers on the issues we're
Speaker A
talking about through the reference system of a currency that's always been theft, right? So, so what would this new system look like or what would this new protocol merge merging look like? And it and it would need privacy.
Speaker A
It would need it would need easy payments. It would need um it but it would it would require privacy to be able to escape uh escape the centralizing system.
Speaker A
That fair? Yeah. Yeah. Like it would have to it would have to be it would have to look like the free banking system and private banks.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. You basically let Yeah. Yeah. Free banking. But yeah, it would it would have to look like that on top of Bitcoin in a completely private way, right?
Speaker A
Otherwise, there's no way it can stay decentralized and secure because eventually it would then there's there would be lots of other risks too along the way. But as long as there were enough people in the world moving that
Speaker A
version of reality uh forward, that's the version about reality that would win because it would just be bounded by energy and we have a decentralized secure protocol.
Speaker A
Why is repricing the world while everybody was pricing it from the centralization? Yeah, I think that's exactly right.
Speaker A
Yeah, it would just Yeah, it just the iterations and and again within that wild volatility, right? Because of the technologies pushing down while the debt keeps getting bigger and bigger and so you're yawning like that. So the volatility of that trans system
Speaker A
transition gets what we get which is volatility across assets, across geopolitics, across domestic politics, across all of it.
Speaker A
Yeah. And let's let's go into the volatility for for a second. was something you and I talked about when we had the conversation that the the marked market of the existing system. We both know right now that if you marked the
Speaker A
assets to the actual asset value inside existing system, you would cause great depression on steroids.
Speaker A
Yes. Right. So, so a lot of the money that's already gone into data center bills against companies the It's not the the S&P 500, it's the S&P 7, which is the same trend to the AI companies that that is underlying this whole thing
Speaker A
that's extracting and the amount of money that's going into that. if it were what is a reasonable return on the money because I think what's happening is people think these companies are network effects like Amazon and Google and
Speaker A
they're building all of these companies like it's winner take all but it looks more like electricity it looks more like what like electricity it doesn't look like Amazon doesn't look like a network effect looks a utility. You're saying
Speaker A
it's a utility price because prices in a free market prices fall to the margin of fast production the marginal right and that's what we're seeing with tokens.
Speaker A
Exactly. And you're saying the trend that's so fast. So you have this you have this belief in capital structure caused by the same belief in what is money taking bigger and bigger bets in these bubbles just like they did in 2008
Speaker A
in the housing market. This is just a new one. Just like a 99 in in fiber, this is just a new one. And the bets have to be bigger and bigger and bigger to support the existing financial structure.
Speaker A
Yep. And and they never get marked to market. Well, and it's crazy, right? Because if you if they got marked to market, you you put in a utility, right? You're going to be generating with that nuclear core, you're going to be generating
Speaker A
electricity for 30 years, 50 years, who knows, right? And in these cases, the models are moving so fast that they're almost obsolete within months.
Speaker A
I I I run a local model that would have been a frontier model four and a half months ago and I don't need the internet for it. Um so uh so so I know for sure how fast this is moving. And so how the
Speaker A
the capital going into these do you have to pay it back in four months?
Speaker A
No, you don't. No, that and that's right. That is and that's that's exactly right. The fiat model of it is just like what you said. You can stretch that and the first bumper you hit are the regulatory bumpers of the system
Speaker A
itself, right? And we're hitting those. You're seeing that whether that be um uh what's the saturation numbers, right? So insurers can only have 15% in any one industry and and um and it's interesting I hadn't thought about it in those terms
Speaker A
till you just framed it like that but these bumpers that they are hitting they're the regulatory bumpers within the own the the system is the symptom of actually what you described which is saturation like the just the capital that has been wasted
Speaker A
and or wasted or or burnt up however you want to say it I don't I don't want to say wasted that's judgmental but the capital that has and uh consumed.
Speaker A
Yeah. Uh to use a in a more objective term, um they've consumed enough iterations of it and they're still needing to borrow more to fund more of the capex that you're bumping up against the existing constraints of the system in terms of
Speaker A
its ability to absorb. So, you're either going to have to pull off the bumpers, in which case you start to put the entire system at risk, but but not just the not just the AI system. And you can't let the AI system
Speaker A
fail because then what about China? You move up to the geopolical game and China move moving to open source models really fast to remove the capital from the US game right?
Speaker A
And and spent the last 20 years building a grid and is and is building electricity all over the place. So they actually have the grid to support they have essentially free electricity there already by basically it might be a
Speaker A
penny. It might be but it's but it is all for intents and purposes free whereas we don't have the so we are we have regulatory constraints we're bumping up against we have physical world grid constraints we're bumping up
Speaker A
against we have geopolitical constraints we're bumping up against on all of this so so from that what would you expect to see from a system that needed to do that you'd expect more control more fear that AI is going to kill you right
Speaker A
AI is going to kill you we're going to regul we're going to regulate deepsek got of the market.
Speaker A
Data designers of bad the the the the all of the things that you would expect to see from a system trying to drive your fear into it. Get your person elected to drive more control.
Speaker A
You would expect to be you'd expect to be being played by the very same control system that you think you're you're you're inside you're right. You'd expect all of this. He doesn't he has no idea and the system would actually in theory
Speaker A
support that view because all the lenders would look at this and go oh all the creditors lenders etc broadly speaking oh my god yeah this my money's gone my capital is gone I need a exactly I need and we go back to free
Speaker A
market free market for who right I make a mistake in the free market I lose I make a mistake in crony capitalism everyone else loses. I I win. And and and so the version of of of capitalism most people think they're living in is
Speaker A
not the version at all. And that's so all of the same thing around the regulators around everything else is is is driving just say yeah it's the same iteration or different iteration of the same game at the core.
Speaker A
Wow. Yeah. That's a problem. and and and and and if we're if if we're on two exponential curves, right? One should be driving productivity and prices lower and lower and lower. the other if you go back to the 80s and then
Speaker A
the savings loans crisis and then then do collapse and then 2008 then co these are just order of magnitude extra crisises that have to debase money of such an order of magnitude more than the last one. Oh, it's just this. It's just this.
Speaker A
It's just this. and and each one has to be literally an order of magnitude bigger to protect you. So, so from that you can see what's coming.
Speaker A
Yeah, it is it's fast. I was just reading an article this morning in the FT uh and there was a portfolio manager talk the private credit and high yield stuff and they referred to it as a blood bath. Blood bath flat is the new up.
Speaker A
And it was funny. I I actually called up uh the uh option adjusted spreads, high yield high yield spreads on my computer.
Speaker A
Show my wife. I said, "This is really interesting, hun. Look at this." And one-year chart. And on a one-year chart, it does look like a blood bath, right?
Speaker A
The option you high yield spreads are like boom, like almost back to where they were at the start of the war. Oof.
Speaker A
Yeah, that looks terrible. Five-year chart. It's it's still a pretty big bump, but it's, you know, it's No, it's it's a little bit below earlier this year when the war started and it's way below liberation day.
Speaker A
Then I go to an alltime chart and show her one more. I'm like GFC is like the Empire State Building.
Speaker A
The European Crisis is like the Chrysler building and like COVID is like, you know, terminal tower in Cleveland. And then like 22 is like the Eiffel Tower and then 25 is and this latest bloodbath that everyone is you know it's wiping
Speaker A
guys out. It looks like a little molehill and and it's the inverse opposite of what you just said right which is the more the leverage goes up the more this a tiny little molehill becomes a blood bath. Like the system
Speaker A
couldn't tolerate a 22 type question problem let alone GFC like forget it. It'll never get there because they'll have they will be forced to print the currency units just to maintain forget about maintaining the solveny of AI or
Speaker A
whatever. They will have to print currency units just to maintain the functioning of the collateral markets the treasury markets the western sovereign bond markets that underpin this whole thing.
Speaker A
So if there's no and and so if you now landscape this what gives us us each of us all of us are our like for and forget about us you and me because we're going to be gone it's
Speaker A
going to be our kids that inherit this right and what what what does it look like for them and and can you think about a path that you would want like what that what that looks Like you think
Speaker A
about the because we've already said one system is getting worse and worse at an exponential rate. Can you imagine in that system trying to stand up in that system with with with if you if you already knew how much
Speaker A
you're surveiled today about like the bank what they see you pay for what you're able to buy what you what the tech companies know from you. If you knew that today, how much more that is and what that bleeds into, what does
Speaker A
that look like with surveillance drips, drones, and dogs and who controls in that one system.
Speaker A
Um because I think that's where we're go. I think that's where we're going. We're going there really fast. And I and my my belief is most people are are are inside that system fighting within it, making it stronger against them. And and
Speaker A
the ones that aren't fighting within it are collecting assets tethered to it, thinking they're safe.
Speaker A
Yeah, I think that's probably fair. I You can see right was friend of mine who's in the uh a private military contractor. He said, "Listen, anything we see over here, over here being, you know, in foreign military engagements
Speaker A
shows up on the streets of America in T plus 5 to 7 years, right?" Totally.
Speaker A
All right. And so when did the when did the drone war start in Ukraine? 22 23.
Speaker A
You know, you can see, you know, the flat cameras, the you know, there's been some push back, right? It's but you can see when when you see the setup the the the the fundamental tension between the exponential growth
Speaker A
of currency units needed the exponential growth of the debt and the exponential deflation that is moving just it it's it's too fast now.
Speaker A
Yeah. They're opposites, right? You just it's either free market prices fall Yeah. or it's not.
Speaker A
Yeah. You're you're increasingly living in a control system where you're going to have to ask for what you get to eat and what you're going to have to ask for permission forever. That's Yeah. And it comes down whether that's US or Chinese version of
Speaker A
the control system is still a control system. Yeah. No, that's that that's right. And you can see that tension in the you know, home prices in America are at all-time highs despite higher mortgage rates, much higher mortgage rates,
Speaker A
but they're at all they're at 50-year lows in gold terms. They're at they're at all-time lows, you know, near all-time lows in Bitcoin terms, right?
Speaker A
Um yeah, which is interesting, which which makes me think that more people would would actually start like waking up and moving their time, right?
Speaker A
Waking up and moving their time. Moving their time. Because it's really the they both systems feed on us. It's our Yeah. It's all at the end of the day, time is money, right? So, it's it's it's it's our time
Speaker A
if we're if we're if we're strengthening the system um that we know is broken and yelling at the other people they don't know better, but we're still in it.
Speaker A
What are we doing? Yeah. What are we doing? We might be we might be trending on social media, but uh what are we doing?
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. That's right. Yeah. So it just so fascinating such a time to be alive and what's h what's happening the uh so let's where do you want to go next? You want to go uh where wherever you want to go?
Speaker A
Yeah. Um you want to go into some of some of the uh the people in Bitcoin who have attacked you?
Speaker A
Sure. Sure. Yeah. Yeah, we were laughing about that, right? Cuz it was a week or a half, you know, I think we talked a week or 10 days ago or something offline and I made the comment to you. I I made what I
Speaker A
thought was a throwaway comment. I didn't think it was particularly controversial at all. I mean, I literally it was one of those like nightmare situations on on X, right?
Speaker A
Where you like you like you make an off-handed comment, you think it's somewhat piffy, but not not particular like like not particularly controversial, and you come back to your computer like 2 three hours later and you're like, "Oh crap, I'm going viral."
Speaker A
And and it's like, I didn't mean to go viral. I didn't think I and it was just around that essentially the expansion of credit Bitcoin in my opinion and in the con for forget my opinion in the context of the
Speaker A
framework that we've just spent the last 45 minutes or so discussing the expansion of credit Bitcoin runs contradictory to sort of the Bitcoin as a freed as a freedom type of as a decentralized money.
Speaker A
Yeah. expand on that a little bit just so so I'm I'm fully aware and I totally agree with you by the way. Um but expand on that and why you believe why you believe that we I know we've talked a lot about
Speaker A
it already but just you than I am. So from a first principles basis, I've seen it happen in gold, right? I' I I I I only started buying gold in 2008 after the end of the crisis and and am
Speaker A
self-taught in it and have seen enough of that, right? Where when you marry when you have an asset with a very high stock toflow ratio, in other words, it's not consumed. high stock toflow ratio.
Speaker A
All the all of the gold that's ever most of the gold that's ever been out there is still out there relative to the flow of new gold every year. The high stock toflow ratio, a commodity with a high
Speaker A
stock toflow ratio is moneyike or one could even say money. Uh when you have a money like commodity, the second you introduce anything that is priced off of it as a derivative, but cash has the op option.
Speaker A
It doesn't even have to be cash settled, but the second has the option of being cash settled as opposed to physical settled. Right? So instead of gold futures, if they were settled in gold, whatever, no different cash settled.
Speaker A
Gold futures when you have a high stock toflow and when in stock to flow investors should just think about it as your stock toflow ratio is the number of shells under which you can hide the P in a
Speaker A
shell game. So in oil right let's let's you know oil when oil markets are overs supplied it's maybe 1.4x 4x stock to flow. And when they're very tight inventories, maybe they're 1.1x stock to flow. And so there's not a lot
Speaker A
of shells to hide the oil P under when you you you can't separate the price of physical oil from the price of paper oil for very long until you start getting shortages. And then the mar in contrast high stock toflow ratio assets and
Speaker A
there's three in particular. It's silver at like 30x. It's gold at like 65x and then it's bitcoin. I think bitcoin's probably now over gold stock to flow. I haven't checked it recently but it's it's either a little below or it's it's
Speaker A
above gold. I it's not important. The importance is that it is one of if not the highest stock toflow ratio commodity shall we say. It's very moneylike.
Speaker A
When you attach a cash settled option, you begin to transfer price discovery power from the underlying to whoever has the biggest cash printing press. That's just the mechanics of it. I saw it with gold. And so when now there's not nearly
Speaker A
the there there's really not an unallocated credit Bitcoin dynamic like there was in London and gold. There are things that look a little like it, but for our purposes here, when you have an ETF, when you have an a
Speaker A
cash settled futures ETF, when you have a, you know, the spot ETF, again, I think is I think that brings up centralization issues and we can talk about that in a second, but at least you're still like for like, right?
Speaker A
There's a cash spot. When you pair that though next to a futures Bitcoin, now you're you have to think of yourself as somebody sitting in a control room in front of a computer and given the task of managing the price
Speaker A
of Bitcoin of this of this money against the fiat currency and if you want to manage that because Bitcoin is so unique in terms of its properties of of its you know its portability and its its transparency etc
Speaker A
and how hard it is as a currency finance supply very predictable with the with the block sizes and the block you know every 10 minutes you and and the same is true of gold less less true less extreme but those
Speaker A
same things in just pure physical gold they're very they're directionally similar you sitting in that control room tasked with managing the price movement you would want more levers number one, right? So, if I could have a futures ETF, great. If I could have futures,
Speaker A
great. If I could have a a spot ETF in the system, because then you there's there are things you can do. Again, if you're the system and the system is interested in managing itself, the system is going to look the other way.
Speaker A
If you take a spot bitcoin, somebody who calls delivery over here out of this and you replace it for a moment with a futures bitcoin there, right? They're they are not going to be the system is not going to be draconian or rigid in a
Speaker A
way that Bitcoiners think the system will be rigid because again that's not that's not what the guy behind the screen is going to want to do. And so I start to look at all of these different options that are like Bitcoin but not
Speaker A
Bitcoin that are priced it's like that are priced off of they they the more options you have the more levers you have the more you expose all of the shells under which you can hide the P. And then
Speaker A
it also allows you to inject volatility in that. And you know, I always tell my friends like, I want to I want to day trade. Be like, would you go down and play against the, you know, I don't know
Speaker A
who's who's the the the the Kansas City Chiefs, you know, would you go down there and jump on the field and play a Turkey Bowl? Like, no, I'd get killed.
Speaker A
Like, now imagine trading against somebody who's been playing twice as long as all the Kansas City Chiefs. And they get better, not worse, as they get older. That's what you're doing, right?
Speaker A
So, that is the volatility. And again, when you have a printing press, volatility is much more your friend than when you don't have a printing press. So, um, that is a long- winded way of saying, but it really
Speaker A
comes down to that stock to flow and then think that's that stock toflow ratio because that is your how many shells are there under which I can hide a P and the more levers I have to manage to more
Speaker A
and when I say levers every everything that is priced with Bitcoin that isn't Bitcoin is another lever that I use to manage the actual price of physical Bitcoin.
Speaker A
And then a lot of people that saw Bitman as something different would eventually stop seeing some as something different and get consumed by the system and get what?
Speaker A
Consumed by the system is what you're saying, right? That's what Yeah. Yeah. That's exactly right. is hey you know and then oh by the way if I if I could hack some exchanges and you know too that would help too right
Speaker A
a lot of people that saw gold as something that would hold governments in check and then didn't because gold gets fractionalized and left out a whole bunch of times and they're still talking about what gold could be rather than
Speaker A
what it is same thing is what you're yeah exactly and there's you know the I think a big part of the price discovery of gold over the last 15 years in particular, 20 years has been one simple factor
Speaker A
which has been China going the price you say gold is is BS. It's, you know, the old the old car game we play get bull.
Speaker A
You know, it's And so they say, "Oh, okay. We'll take it. We'll take it. We'll take it." and some you know they are willing to keep there's no in theory that that could have been you know there's certain big players the sort of
Speaker A
the treasury strategy company uh or the treasury uh the bitcoin treasury company strategies could have uh driven that if they were running big enough surpluses that's the magic of what China has done is every here the world and America send the Chinese a
Speaker A
trillion dollars fresh and new. They never run out of money and it's free capital basically and the ch the difference is is the cost of capital for that strategy of calling BS and taking it on is is rising meaningfully uh for a
Speaker A
lot of those players and that then changes the economics meaningfully. Right. So let let let's go into that for kind of human nature because we should expect it. We saw it in gold. We see it in Bitcoin. We see it in in in the human
Speaker A
nature that's driven from that is operating in in a currency and measuring Bitcoin from the currency that they know for sure isn't stable isn't re isn't real. Like it's a it's isn't being not able to be paid back,
Speaker A
right? It's all of the things that that is an illusion that it has stability.
Speaker A
You're saying that the the fiat currency exactly the fiat currency has stability by stealing more from you and and and against Bitcoin the stability comes from tethering it to a dollar that's stealing more from right so it shouldn't be called a stable coin
Speaker A
because a guaranteed loss coin against Bitcoin but you can see why why people would follow that path because it seems like just like in gold a derivative instrument of the thing that's easier to use. It's regulated. It's on top right
Speaker A
seems simple. It matches my pattern of what I think the world should look like. Those for my they're helping me right now. I have faster transactions and it's all on Bitcoin. So, it's all going to be on top of Bitcoin. So, it's
Speaker A
right where where it can't look like that. These are incompatible systems. So then we get back into which one wins, right? Because if you had this truly private money that was decentralized, secure and more and more people were
Speaker A
using it as money, then at some point if you couldn't break that, it would have a margin call on an existing system.
Speaker A
Correct. Right. In other words, there cannot be two winners in the short term. It looks like they're compatible, they cannot be compatible.
Speaker A
I mean, one one takes the other. Correct. And and and and should Bitcoin survive this, then then then all of the money and all of the smart money that's always got bailed out before from taking won't Yeah.
Speaker A
And that's, you know, then you get into questions of who's been centralizing, right? It's been some of the smart money that has been bailed up before, right?
Speaker A
It's all the smart money, right? It's all the the like I can't help thinking of if you had a game that was based on theft, right? And that game you had you were throwing dice and there was only you
Speaker A
would win on each dice throw, right? You could win for sure, right? You take big bets and then then if you lost, the taxpayer would would lose. You would still win. If you had that bet, wouldn't you drive more and more people, the
Speaker A
smartest people maybe into that same bet? Into what? Same bet? The into the same bet of the centralization.
Speaker A
Oh, yeah. Because they would all be playing the they would be playing a zero sum game.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah, because you're going to have access to the you're going to have access to the exit card when it's done, right? Because there'll be somewhere, you know, some sort of cash settlement surprise at the end of it or whatever
Speaker A
the case might be, right? But what if there wasn't here? What if there what if truly and and and we could we could play this game out, right? But what if what if Bitcoin was this protocol that's happened and
Speaker A
there's more and more people using it as a currency? It is now private. It's moving moving faster and faster and it's expanding that way. What if what if the exit that everybody's building to that they thought they were protected from
Speaker A
they didn't have they didn't have this money that was and everything else was it it is just really interesting because these are playing out in real time on both on both sides.
Speaker A
No, that's exactly right. It it's cuz that's how it would that's ultimately to your point. It has to be it has to move. The currency has to move.
Speaker A
And and by the way, this this whole thing on both sides and all of the different things and all the different bets has to look exactly like this.
Speaker A
If we're if we're going through a state change from one system to another and we're part of the state change, right?
Speaker A
Because we you would you would think that inside all of our actions, what we thought the world looked like would just kind of reinforce. We would look for patterns that matched our our patterns and it would keep looking like that. And
Speaker A
it wouldn't be until we moved as part of this emerging phenomenon that that was the creation of something that something new, right? had it this be so confusing across so many different dimensions that the easiest for us to hold our own
Speaker A
biases. Yeah, that's right. Such a fascinating time to be alive. It really is. It really is.
Speaker A
So when are you going to uh um just but I do believe that inside this there are a couple options that people can move their time into something that actually has has a has a huge impact on themselves and everybody else and I
Speaker A
think this is one of them from a not as a you know what I'm talking about this I'm not talking about an asset tethered to an existing system. I'm not talking about how do you get rich fast? I'm
Speaker A
talking how how do you what how do you get rich fast? Oh yeah. Talking about something very very different from Yeah. No, it's more about preserving it almost becomes a time machine, right?
Speaker A
Because in theory your your the value of your time saved here if the value of that rises relative to the cost of your time in the other system you've created.
Speaker A
That's what it that's what it is. A time machine of sorts, right? Time machine. You're see you're you're you're early in a few that Gibson quote future is already here. It's just not evenly distributed.
Speaker A
Yep. That's that's what I think this is. I think it's just we're so early in this what the world would look like under these new conditions that are being imposed and people are measuring the what the world would look like under these new
Speaker A
conditions that are being imposed against what they think the world should look like. Yeah. And I think it's moving so fast.
Speaker A
It's, you know, it's it's it's like another great quote, the uh the um Albert Bartlett's quote about the one of the the greatest shortcoming of the human race is the inability to understand the exponential function or to comprehend the exponential function.
Speaker A
And that's we're witnessing this in real time, which is and I part of me thinks that's part of the process of getting from one side to the other, which is I think the a real way it looks is a
Speaker A
transition is literally the, you know, sort of the deflationary crisis that they can't get out of because it is just and that then forces policy makers who will have no other choice other than okay, we have to move
Speaker A
to something that is not a credit based money. Yeah. And let's let's go let's spend a couple minutes there before because I actually don't see that that happening.
Speaker A
Well, well, that would provide a like and you know you talk about sometimes that you could revalue gold and get rid of the depth, right? Stroke of a pen and you could do that or you could or like
Speaker A
they did from the petro dollar in the petro dollar system, you could make oil way bigger and put your money in that, right? Um you could do the same thing with Bitcoin. You could drive it up and put it in that. And by the way, by doing
Speaker A
so, you would also checkmate China who's put it in gold, right? If you uh if uh if you did that. So you start to see the global repercussions of what this is.
Speaker A
But it still doesn't resolve. So it resolves the short term and a whole bunch of people would I think a lot of people would do now Bitcoin or multi-millionaires, they would sell their Bitcoin, go back to the existing system, right?
Speaker A
They would forget that this was a protocol. The same rules under the free market still exist. Prices should fall if we lived in one. And and the game would start again after you resolved it and people would go back to I think a new form of credit
Speaker A
me because it's what they're used to. Yeah. I think that's it's very po and it's it's where my brain kind of breaks on it because right in theory if we did you know a bitcoin to China's gold end of the day China still makes
Speaker A
everything for us and so they're going to end up with all the bitcoin maybe to be at a higher right but they would they it would be but I think but here here's I think that let's let's poke on that I
Speaker A
thought a lot about this is a lot of this is happening out of you need a neutral reserve currency Correct. Yep.
Speaker A
You need a neutral or asset which is the currency and you need a neutral reserve currency. This owned for a long time.
Speaker A
Yep. Games played on all sides to try to stop that. And and and China by having low labor costs and and production, right, doesn't have consumer spending or as much consumer spending.
Speaker A
It's all the US driving it. On the other side of that, we'd have to have high labor cost. So the the jobs never come back here. They're constantly going to going to China. China builds its industrial base against this. And that
Speaker A
becomes a geopolitical football because we can't even you know this too. You can't even arm your military without the supply chain from China, right?
Speaker A
Yep. But but what would it look like if that persisted for any time? What would happen is our purchasing would be buying China stuff and China would be collecting more Bitcoin and the currency would be rising as rising and rising and rising and it
Speaker A
balances. You would have you you would have you would have a neutral reserve currency constantly do this all over the world.
Speaker A
Yep. Wouldn't be allowed to have these imbalances that you were trying to fight these imbalances through different structures of tariffs and nonsense and everything else. That would be the global free market.
Speaker A
finding the best labor, materials, capital everywhere else and fighting to to drive the best decisions for the global free market. And it would just be natural. China would wouldn't have a choice. They wouldn't be balanced automatically.
Speaker A
Yeah. It would just come down to the to the motivation and competitiveness and the the the energy of the people.
Speaker A
Totally. Like if if I wanted to buy something from China and it was a good enough deal and I used my Bitcoin, then that would be the trade. And if bunch of people and then and then and and nobody else had any Bitcoin, they
Speaker A
wouldn't be selling anymore. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, that's right. So, so this is a way this is a this is a really interesting way because it's outside the system that being imposed on the system and being imposed on every
Speaker A
policy globally China US everything else being imposed across every citizen that we are moving to that neutral reserve currency right whether we like it or not.
Speaker A
Yeah. Right. And it's you can see a version of this actually with what China's done with gold right on some level which is is if the world's creditor is buy is is no longer buying bonds and is buying gold
Speaker A
instead the world may not like it but the world is on a gold standard of some description until they either devalue their currencies relative enough to compete with and then the question becomes how do you devalue your currency and there's
Speaker A
that because that's the problem on gold They can't devalue their currency too, right? Because if the currency it gains, they won't do it on gold.
Speaker A
They won't. No, it has to be against a commodity, right? It has to be against oil or basic or energy. Basically, gold has to keep rising against energy over time in the same way that Bitcoin rises against energy over time.
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. Because otherwise, currency to currency, it doesn't. Gold to currency, it doesn't. You just keep doing it back and forth. just keep do keep doing it back and forth. Yeah, it it comes down which is fascinating then is what has
Speaker A
China invested so much in right while we've invested we have well we have subsidized wars for 25 years we the US China has subsidized you know I read an article this week that's complaining that China has subsidized their chemical
Speaker A
industry and then you read how much they've subsidized it and they said it is uh $75 billion over 10 years last 10 years sounds like a lot it is a lot and then you realize that we're spending $3
Speaker A
billion dollar a month in Iran right now. And that's just Iran. That's just one little conflict zone. And you kind of go, who's smarter? Are we just mad because they're subsidizing smarter?
Speaker A
Like what? Imagine if we were sub and I'm not a big fan of subsidies anywhere, but if they're going to be a fact, right, the fact of life.
Speaker A
Yeah, it is uh um it's ma it's it's maddening to watch it play out in real time because it it is just the inefficiency and the and then that leads to the you know the need for more inflation.
Speaker A
That's why I can't even talk about the dollar version of these things anymore because the dollar version of these things are such a misrepresentation of our time. We have $365 trillion of debt in the world that will never be repaid
Speaker A
and every asset in the world is tethered to the same 365 trillion. Yeah. So, how do you think about it? Like when you say that what do you how do you in your own mind like what is what is are
Speaker A
you just thinking about it in Bitcoin terms like hey this is that money doesn't mean anything to me right it doesn't like because the house tethered to that I I realized it that number has to keep growing at a faster
Speaker A
and faster rate because it has to stop the free market and and so these numbers that we we're spending this and this if we weren't spending that money in all of this misallocation capital the system wouldn't when when when feloning came in and said
Speaker A
we're going to rip out Doge and and then there's more there's more waste the minute afterwards it's impossible to rip out the waste the waste is a waste of the regulation in the system I said that I don't know if you ever heard me say
Speaker A
that people said why can't they do it I said think about it as a re corporate restructuring I said you may have 20% of your customer base, you're losing you're losing profit dollars on, but they're paying the bills on time, so
Speaker A
they're revenue positive. And let's pretend you've got a bunch of debt that you you like you you're you're really levered. You can't fire an unprofitable customer if they're cash flow if they're if they're generating cash because you need the cash just to keep paying the
Speaker A
debt. You have to do an order of operations was you got to go to the banks first and you call the bank and say, "We need to restructure. we need to term it out and lower the rate and lower
Speaker A
my payments. And then once you do that and lower your nuts, so to speak, can you go back, look at your customer base and go, okay, these 20% are unprofitable. I'm going to fire them. My profits are going to go up. My revenues
Speaker A
are going to come down for a bit, but I can afford that now because my nut was lowered by renegotiating in terming out the debt with the banks. Now I can do this. And I was saying at Doge, there's
Speaker A
an order of operations. You just start slash. It might be inefficient. It may be fraud. It might be all of it, but it's cash.
Speaker A
All of it. And if you take cash out, levered where we were, the whole it's like pulling the bottom jangle block bottom two jangle blocks. The whole thing comes down.
Speaker A
And what about now? It's just more levered. It's Yeah. What about Iran? It's more lethuh what about uh what about the the AI stack? It's more lever.
Speaker A
It's more levered and it's and the and it's the capital is being destroyed faster, right? It's being consumed even faster than it was. You're having to find more and more bubbles and more and more people shellgating to get people to
Speaker A
believe that it and and this is why this normally ends in war because because people get so so much anxiety so much fear of so much everything else really easy to divide those people against those other people right and and that's what I mean both
Speaker A
doors enter the same room yeah and you might already be seen it right I've seen very credible, you know, some acquaintances of mine saying part of the logic of the whole Iran war was scare capital out of the Middle East.
Speaker A
Get rid of UAE as a competing capital hub for parts of the world and send it back to the US.
Speaker A
Yeah. And when we see like when when when he like said you were overt target on the Bitcoin thing that you came up like you would expect inside um inside a control system you would expect if you were either over the target to be uh to
Speaker A
be either ignored completely so no voice at all or shut off the voice right that's what happens in these countries that if you were people are following you and you're a voice against the stage. You're shut off, your bank
Speaker A
account shut off. So, you could expect you to and everything else to get either shut off or ridiculed by the very same thing because the very same thing and the power of that ridicule to make you look small, right?
Speaker A
You might feel like, wow, what's going what's going on? That's what's going on, right? That's what it's happening everywhere. And you and I'm watching people go into these isolated silos and silo and silo and silo and silo and
Speaker A
their feedback on their on the Twitter feed is the same people feeding the it's wild.
Speaker A
Yeah, I can see it. You know, having the size of account I have, I can see I can see when I'm over the target on something. I can see when it's I can see where sentiments are. I can say like it
Speaker A
is it is fascinating in real time to watch and I actually said that to my wife because it's become a much more toxic place X has in um even in the last six months but it feeds off of that it has right
Speaker A
but the same but it's the same thing you just said it's kind of layers all the way down if our system of of of how we organize labor in the world is based on theft, right?
Speaker A
And credit money is based on theft, then it has to look like that all the way up. And the way you keep people in it is thinking they have a righteous voice against the other people in it.
Speaker A
Well, interesting. It's exact. It would be the greatest manipulation ever that you thought that both people thought that they were they were right or wrong and both people um were making that system stronger over them. So if you if you know that and and
Speaker A
there's nothing we've said we can but I'm sure you and I can agree on all of this. True.
Speaker A
What's that? We we we agree on everything so far here. Yeah. Yeah. Then the only then the only possible way out of that thing is from another system that reprices the whole thing spending time the more time you
Speaker A
spend spending. Um, and but once you see it, once you see kind of how how it looks, how the sausage is made everywhere, you want to spend less time feeding.
Speaker A
Ain't that the truth? This was awesome. Yeah. No, I I really appreciate you doing that. We We We should do it again.
Speaker A
And like I said, I'll uh I'll have my team edit up. I'll take the uh the fbomb. I dropped the star with the beginning of it.
Speaker A
This is uh and and you know what I'm I'm now going to get attacked from supporting you on your thesis. You're going to get attacked from me on everything else. But it's um this is also if you if you just tune out that
Speaker A
noise because it's probably going to happen. Um there's this is this podcast what we just said. probably didn't help a lot of business and that's ultimately I think very very important uh these days it is very much a uh I take that mission to heart uh
Speaker A
every week I write it is really just I I don't see it all I don't know it all but I feel like I have a lens that can possibly help people and I write out of that energy of just like here's what I'm
Speaker A
seeing and so this is in that same energy of just like yeah talk through it I love you to and how you are as a family man and what you're Oh, thank you.
Speaker A
But but seriously, but just just I think you're just just a super bright light and all of this the stuff that's happening and I think these nuance conversations about kind of how do you I think they're really important.
Speaker A
Well, thank you very much and I feel the same way about you. So, let's uh let's not wait too long to do this again.
Speaker A
Okay, sounds good. All right, my friend. Okay, see you. Have a great night.
Topics:free marketdeflationBitcoinhard moneyfiat currencycentral bankingdebtgoldstablecoinsLuke Gromen











