Skip to content
Get App

Boomer Jedi vs. Zoomer Sith | with Jordan Hall

Benjamin Boyce and Jordan Hall discuss Star Wars, Disney, AI and the Boomer-Zoomer Jedi/Sith discourse as signs of cultural decline and a fading post-WWII liberal consensus.

Key Takeaways

  • Fantasy can convey transcendent reality more truly than science fiction, which remains bounded by modernity.
  • Modern franchises and AI can mimic aesthetics but lack soul, which lives in the human author.
  • The post-WWII liberal consensus is eroding, leaving authority reduced to power.
  • Healthy communities require a transcendent, shared identity beyond procedural neutrality or ethnic essentialism.

What the video covers

  • Host Benjamin Boyce welcomes returning guest Jordan Hall for a deep discussion on culture and identity.
  • They distinguish fantasy, which points beyond modern understanding, from science fiction, which stays inside modernity's frame, citing George MacDonald, Tolkien, Lewis and Herbert.
  • The Star Wars franchise is examined, including the prequels, the extended universe, and Disney's handling driven by merchandising, ideology, and storytelling skill.
  • J.J. Abrams is criticized as a virtuoso with no soul, producing pastiche that absorbs aesthetics without substance.
  • AI is presented as a soulless virtuoso: it can reproduce affect and style, but soul resides in the human creator, not the tool.
  • The Boomer/Zoomer Jedi-Sith inversion is used to discuss the erosion of the liberal/modernist consensus governing the West for about 80 years.
  • They argue that authority has collapsed into raw power, with a single world power replacing a nation's transcendent sense of belonging.
  • Nationhood is framed as requiring a transcendent, shared bond rather than blood and soil, and they distinguish America from England.
  • Coolness is critiqued as a form of power-seeking detached from authority and the vocation of a knight who seeks to be governed.
  • The conversation warns that rising violence, identity conflict and loss of purpose could follow if a wise course is not held.

Answers

Questions about this video

What is the main argument Jordan Hall makes about fantasy versus science fiction?

Hall argues that fantasy accepts a reality beyond human understanding and lets viewers participate at the edges of mystery, while science fiction stays inside the frame of modernity. He cites George MacDonald as a model for this approach.

How do the speakers view AI-generated creative work?

They argue AI can perfectly reproduce style and affect but has no soul, since soul comes from the human creator who uses the tool. They compare AI to a paintbrush that is only as meaningful as the painter behind it.

What does the video say about the Boomer/Zoomer Jedi-Sith discourse?

The conversation treats the meme as a symptom of the eroding liberal/modernist post-WWII consensus and the decline of shared transcendent authority. The speakers see it as a sign of rising conflict over identity and ownership that needs a wise response.

Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:01
Speaker A
Hello and welcome to calm conversations with the voice of reason. I am your host Benjamin Boyce and today's conversant is returning guest Jordan Hall who's been on the show several times and every time he comes on we get deep into the issues
00:17
Speaker A
very deep. And in this conversation we talk about the Anakin Skywalker boomer zoomer tradeoff or inversion that's going on currently. And I've seen a lot of videos about this issue. And in this conversation, we take a little different
00:34
Speaker A
tact and drill into what that says about the eroding liberal slashmodernist/post war II consensus mythology that has governed the United States and most of the West for going on 80 years now. and how the rumblings within the mimemetic
00:54
Speaker A
discourse are heralding the end of an era and some troubling outcroppings of violence, of difference, of ownership, of individuality and identity that could be very worrisome if we don't hold on to the proper wise course. You can find
01:16
Speaker A
links to Jordan's work down there in the description, as well as links to support this channel. Without further ado, here is Jordan Hall. We take things these things so seriously.
01:29
Speaker A
It's funny. I was actually thinking about how uh fantasy, as it turns out, was more realistic than science fiction.
01:36
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. What what's an example? Well, the the the principle is something like um science fiction pretends to be realistic, but it is only actually participating in the frame of modernity.
01:52
Speaker A
Mhm. Whereas fantasy accepts the the bigger reality that is beyond our understanding and allows us to kind of like participate at the edges of the mystery which trickle through in a variety of different images, but you're actually living in that level of the fantasy. I
02:07
Speaker A
guess uh have you read George McDonald? Uh that sounds very familiar. What was his work?
02:14
Speaker A
He was the gentleman who was the uh both the inspiration and mentor for both Tolken and Lewis.
02:21
Speaker A
Yes. A bunch of fairy tales, the red book, green book, blue book. Yeah. Yeah.
02:25
Speaker A
and uh fantast. So when you read those you you get because that's of course the precursor to everything that we would know as fantasy and you get the feeling of exactly what he's doing which is that he's putting you in the in that place
02:40
Speaker A
just at the very edge of your understanding where things there's something going on that's more than you can understand. It trickles through and then and then you can kind of begin to embody it. Whereas science fiction pretends that everything is inside that
02:55
Speaker A
bubble of your understanding and we can you tweak a few things but at the end of the day it's all it's all pretty straightforward very very Dawkins right science fiction is very living inside Dawkins mind.
03:04
Speaker A
You think even Herbert would you say Herbert does that too? Does he straddle a line?
03:10
Speaker A
Yeah. Uh Herbert is is you know at the very age of fantasy isn't he?
03:16
Speaker A
Yeah. even is very explicitly trying to do fantasy through a more science fiction lens and he's playing at those at those levels. But yeah, ultimately he is ultimately standing on the science fiction line which is why so many of the
03:29
Speaker A
parts of what happens in Dune play out as u something like politics or something like that.
03:34
Speaker A
Yeah. Shakespearean. Yeah. And then there's uh Yeah. I guess there's the difference between Star Wars and Star Trek.
03:42
Speaker A
Star Wars. And it's hard to encapsulate what Star Wars is because there's the original trilogy and then there's the tons of material they produced over the 80s and the 90s, the extended universe.
03:53
Speaker A
Yeah. People just ran with it and then it was recapitulated by Disney. Well, no, he did this the prequels which are now lighting people on fire, oddly enough, or maybe not so oddly, which is why we were gathered here today
04:08
Speaker A
for content. And then the and then of course the Disney thing tries to go in and I don't know what they were actually thinking.
04:15
Speaker A
Let's just call it the Disney scup. I mean they're doing there's like three forces that play with Disney at all times. You've got like the the hand of the merchant the merchandising guys for like look I need three video games 17
04:27
Speaker A
action figures stat. You know don't don't don't uh don't give me this plot [ __ ] You know what really who butters the bread on this machine.
04:36
Speaker A
Yeah. Uh and then you got, you know, the the the the ideological folks who just feel like every story is has to be exactly the same story told. So they have to recapture whatever narrative they own and turn it into the um rainbow
04:51
Speaker A
slop. Yeah. Um and then you actually have some number of storytellers who are trying to figure out how to do something usually at the level of the salient. Right. So JJ Abrams is to the point, right? He uh
05:02
Speaker A
the first 15 minutes of the first I guess it would be the seventh movie where Ren is you know on the planet Tatooine is really awesome like superbly put together. Um and and they have that they have that capability. They're like
05:15
Speaker A
virtuosos. Um who would really be a really great example of a musician who is simultaneously an absolute virtuoso and has no soul.
05:25
Speaker A
Oh no soul. No soul. like remarkably skilled at playing the instrument, but there's no heart.
05:34
Speaker A
Yeah. Well, I was Yeah. I didn't know the second half of your your question, so I was going to say Trent Resner, very profession and very like walking pushing the line of of some sort of liinal space.
05:47
Speaker A
Yeah, he's got soul. Fry's got soul. Um who works with Trent Reser, but that's movies. Um got so much so AI. You could just say AI.
05:57
Speaker A
There you go. It's perfect. Yeah. AI AI is remarkably skilled. It can really make. It's actually, you know, it's J.J.
06:04
Speaker A
Abrams perfected. It's the ultimate the ultimate soulless virtuosa. Yeah. It's literally uh J.J. Abrams is famous for doing this TED talk about a mystery box where he doesn't want to know what's in the mystery box, but all of his movies end up being hollow
06:18
Speaker A
because there's nothing actually in that mystery box. Nothing that he cares to find out about. And so you get that with AI with uh what SURL John Surl talks about how AI can't be conscious and I can't remember his thought experiment
06:34
Speaker A
but he he's basically there's this there's this box that's doing all these outputs but there's nothing inside of the box.
06:39
Speaker A
Yeah. Whatever that thing is. But maybe we say that about AI because we don't want to not be special. We don't want to be just thinking machines.
06:51
Speaker A
Oh, there's a there's a better way to do that one. But, uh, yeah, it's really interesting. I actually remember during Lost Mhm.
06:58
Speaker A
having having an an insight of my way of putting it. I love Lost. You feed you feed the 70s and the 80s television into a machine and the machine takes the affect of those elements and just bolagages them
07:18
Speaker A
together and continues to produce pure affect you. So it's like oh I remember very specifically a particular scene pretty late in Lost. I'm like, "Oh [ __ ] that's Macgyver." Like, I don't actually remember this scene. Even like the
07:29
Speaker A
angles, like the shot, the whole shot was like pulled straight from MacGyver, convert it to new characters, re reinsert. Um, like, wow, that's exactly what's happened. Like, Abrams absorbed the aesthetic. Yeah.
07:42
Speaker A
And then has the ability to produce the aesthetic and but that's all there is to it.
07:47
Speaker A
Yeah. Is Pastiche uh like one notch up from just recapitulation or regation? That's a good question. That's a good question.
07:59
Speaker A
Yeah. But to to take the conversation one step further, people are using AI to regenerate the Star Wars that resonates with them, right?
08:10
Speaker A
And it seems like it does have so or it's touching a nerf. Well, the there the soul is not coming from the AI. That's the whole point.
08:15
Speaker A
It's like it's like trying to look for soul in the in the paintbrush. The paintbrush doesn't have a soul. The painter has a soul and the painter when he in uses his instrument for the purposes of using his soul to express
08:24
Speaker A
into the world. Great. Mhm. Um, and you can that's kind of like the that's how the the uh the whole thing flips one way or the other. If you if you're looking for soul in the AI, you will be seduced more and more deeply. If
08:35
Speaker A
you're looking for the AI to act as an instrument to express soul into the world, great. It'll be very powerful for that.
08:40
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. What's your take on the Anakin reversal? It's not really a reversal. It's not an inversion. It's there's something different. I mean, I see a lot of people being worried about like the woke right, you know, like just a right flavored
08:55
Speaker A
wokeness, victim politic, but I think that there's something else being expressed in there. Yeah. I mean, I I've always taken issue with that as a a tagline because it's so obviously marketing. The notion of woke right, it's just sort of a simple way to try to
09:11
Speaker A
produce something that has an effect. It's pure rhetoric. It doesn't describe what's going on on the right. Honestly, there are things in the on the right that you could use to kind of tag that way, but it's more of a distraction than
09:21
Speaker A
a useful tag. Um, well, the my my my primary interaction with that movement, the Anakinization, you know, dark Anakin, I'll call it that. Um, was actually through that Substack article by the Canadian guy who was sort of he
09:39
Speaker A
wasn't in the very beginning of it, but he was not too far from the beginning of it. There's a handful of folks who were beginning to create dark Anakin memes that had just a very simple as effect to
09:48
Speaker A
them. Then he wrote this crazy really really good Substack article. Then I I actually responded that I it was good enough that I actually felt I responded to it.
09:56
Speaker A
Yeah. Um and then and then the Dark Anakin thing went haywire. It went off like crazy. And then the third wave happened which is where all the uh you know I don't know who the right people are what
10:04
Speaker A
the what the term is to describe them but the the extremely unself-aware of people reacted in a fashion that exemplified the essence of the narrative in the effort. It's like pouring or they poured oil on the fire by thinking they are
10:20
Speaker A
pouring water. Hey you guys are nasty. You don't either a you don't actually what was it the scene of uh oh yeah that you want to worship or think the guy who killed all those little kids is a good guy.
10:32
Speaker A
Yeah. Um you know maybe that's a bad idea. Like please don't apply that that issue was already dealt with in the second phase of this thing.
10:40
Speaker A
There's something deeper going on and the thing that's deeper is interesting. Um and simply engage with it honestly as opposed to trying to um how do you say it right?
10:50
Speaker A
Put the genie back in the bottle. If that's the right way of putting it is is the instinct of must control narrative at all times.
10:57
Speaker A
Yes. Um has the the consequence of actually creating chaos. That's not the right word. It's not chaos.
11:04
Speaker A
Putting pressure on it, facilitating or or ramping up. Yeah. It the more the the the the harder you squeeze, the more star systems slip through your fingers.
11:14
Speaker A
Mhm. Mhm. You know, that as you try to control the narrative more and more and more, the fact that you are controlling the narrative is the primary counternarrative that begins to emerge and that just reinforces those who are
11:25
Speaker A
pointing at, oh, this is a controlling narrative. And by the way, that controlling narrative does not have my best interest in mind. And so now I'm just able to more and more feel the truth of that. So it just sort of fires
11:36
Speaker A
the the polarity. Mhm. Um, but I personally thought that at least that particular, I don't know, say young man, I have no idea how old or male this particular individual was, but the vibes were maybe late 20s, early 30s
11:51
Speaker A
guy was very insightful. I thought his his his take on it as a Do you recall his name?
11:57
Speaker A
Um, he was Canadian something. Okay. I think I could probably I can find it.
12:02
Speaker A
Canadian Hitler or something like that for 2069. Not quite that straightforward. Uh, let's see. Give me seven seconds. I'll just because I quote tweeted it when I responded.
12:15
Speaker A
Just find the quote tweet. There it is. His name is Upper Canadian Cavalier and his Substack is Upper Canadian Cavalier.stack.com.
12:24
Speaker A
I'll link it in the Getting Sith Pilled on the Boomers. Okay. Yeah. So when I started um so my trajectory was evergreen happened which was this absolute uh vilification of of well no like it it showed to me that
12:44
Speaker A
academia is completely captured by weak administrators and radical teachers that are using canon fodder to to reorganize the system. and they're both working together to tighten the system to make even more bureaucracy even though like they're giving lip service to justice
13:01
Speaker A
and racial justice, but it always goes in the direction of increasing bureaucratic extension and control no matter what. Um, and then I then I started to examine liberalism as a lot of people that came out in that first
13:17
Speaker A
wave, Brett Weinstein, James Lindseay, the IDW guys were saying, you know, real liberalism hasn't been tried. You you guys are straying from the path of liberalism.
13:28
Speaker A
There's the marketplace of ideas. There's free speech. There's these basic rudimentary philosophical and ideological pillars that allow for this whole thing to work. And somehow it got infected. and James Lindsay went through and did the genealogy of wokeness and
13:41
Speaker A
stuff. But when James and Brett would give the answer to it, let's just go back to liberalism, something didn't quite sit well with me.
13:50
Speaker A
It seemed kind of pabum to me. I'm like, I'm that doesn't seem quite right. I I would I was leaning more towards, you know, we have to get back to a precursor to liberalism, which is uh Greco Christian values. Um, but then I started
14:07
Speaker A
going into the right who had been developing all these dissident views and I turned a corner and I just saw Nazi stuff right away. I'm like, "Oh no, the racists are here." Like and um personified by uh what's his
14:22
Speaker A
name? Thomas Kerr. Thomas 777. He's he's a super super edgeelord guy. Um, and I was put off by that. And I started talking to these guys more and more. And one guy told me, this super anonymous guy said, you know, I'm not racist, but
14:38
Speaker A
I'm not allergic to racism. And I started to see that they were using racism to push people out of the conversation so they can talk about deeper ideas. They were using 4chan like crazy. I think they have even
14:52
Speaker A
discovered that because 4chan because it didn't have any way to create boundaries at a technical level.
14:58
Speaker A
Everything was hard anonymous. They learned how to create boundaries at a mimedic level. Yeah. Yes. Exactly. And if you could look past that, then you can actually start seeing deeper critiques of liberalism.
15:09
Speaker A
Just like some people will say, you know, Marx didn't have any solutions, but he he does have some critiques about capitalism that do have some play to them. And these these dissident guys do have some play.
15:22
Speaker A
But you start seeing these ironic Hitler edits and Stormtrooper edits. You're like, there is a force here. There is a force, a fascistic aesthetic or force going on here. And my first reaction as a good liberal was to be disgusted by
15:40
Speaker A
that, to see the end of my career in that and the end of all ties to polite society and that. But then I started to see something beyond that. But I still did get but you do have a lot of
15:52
Speaker A
resentment there especially with the um what people call anti-semitism which I think is kind of a trick word but this this definite pattern of deeply disliking Jewish people period and and that's tied into the Israel uh kind of
16:09
Speaker A
conglomerate. But if you get if you go further and further and further this is the conversation we've been having for a few years now. You get to this post-war consensus. you get to this mythology that's being eroded, being attacked by
16:21
Speaker A
this counter ideology. And I think that Jonathan Pjo is he he he responded negatively to the Anakin thing. He's saying, you know, we don't want to go down there. We don't want to go down this dark path, which kind of is missing
16:33
Speaker A
the joke, but he's not being insincere by pointing out that there's something dangerous that's happening here. So that's the landscape that this is arising in. I mean, there's so many pieces there. So, um, if we pluck at the the strings on the
16:48
Speaker A
postw World War II narrative, I think that's probably the the the ripest way to begin. Um, so you've got at least three different things that are going on there.
17:04
Speaker A
One is, you know, imagine that you're in a a maze like the what are those called in the amusement parks? Hall of mirrors.
17:15
Speaker A
Mhm. But in this case, it's just like it's like the room you're in, but the and the walls are invisible. They're glass.
17:21
Speaker A
Um, so you're trying to figure out how to how to make your way out of it.
17:24
Speaker A
You're walking along and you're kind of feel and you feel a wall like okay there's a wall there there's a wall there and you're beginning to notice that there's some kind of maze or some kind of labyrinth by virtue of simply
17:32
Speaker A
feeling the invisible invisible boundaries and that of course is to to discover the trick the texture of the postworld war ii narrative and you you walk forward until you run into racism you're like okay that's a wall there's a
17:44
Speaker A
wall there the racism wall has some boundary level that is real in the world that I live in huh you walk over here you feel the the anti-semitism Okay, that's interesting. That's a real thing.
17:55
Speaker A
So, you're beginning to notice what is these the structure that is binding the culture by virtue of just running forward until you hit the wall. And they're like, "Okay, what happens, by the way, if I turn off my allergy? Can I
18:06
Speaker A
walk through that wall? What's on the other side of it?" And of course, you start finding all these sort of secret rooms that other people who have learned how to turn that off are in, and they're saying, "Hey, guess what? We're in a
18:14
Speaker A
labyrinth. There's a maze here, and we need to figure out how to navigate through this maze." So, that's one piece. Kind of all video game metaphors.
18:22
Speaker A
kind of very millennial. Um, so then the next one is kind of like the loot boxes or the veins of gold which is, you know, Nick Fuentes for example.
18:31
Speaker A
He's like kind of you walking along. I don't mind he may just be a pure a pure sciat but let's just assume he isn't. It doesn't matter. There's a character that fits this identity.
18:42
Speaker A
Um, saying, "Hey, how do I get more likes? How do I get more attention? How do I kind of win this social media game?" What he notices is that if you touch that third rail and you don't die,
18:52
Speaker A
something positive happens. He's like, I mean, Tate did the same thing. He's like, "Hey, [ __ ] the the old uh the old narrative that used to just exterminate you if you pushed in this area doesn't hold as much anymore, which means
19:04
Speaker A
there's a huge amount of unmined potential for those who are willing to step into it." Again, it's the same basic idea. So the first group is sort of trying to understand the nature of the reality that they're actually living in.
19:14
Speaker A
Noticing that things have been uh distorted tremendously. The second group is trying to figure out I mean just very simply how do I mine this for more potential and noticing that there's just these huge reservoirs of potential. And
19:26
Speaker A
of course you can see the the degree to which the 15 different typologies of grifter naturally gather around everything.
19:33
Speaker A
Yeah. Um, so the second kind is just a grifter who has discovered that there is a seam of grift by playing counternarrative to the collapsing narrative. But because the narrative is collapsing, you're seeing it. If you want to flip to a more historical frame,
19:48
Speaker A
you can do this in terms of the collapse of Rome, right? There was there were um as you begin to notice like as you know as the as the Goths start moving through uh Europe and they notice that the like
20:01
Speaker A
the Romans aren't stopping them like hey wow there's just more opportunity. I just I keep going forward and I'm not getting slaughtered by the Romans anymore. Take more territory until eventually all Eric's like let's just go sack Rome let's see what happens. Um, so
20:13
Speaker A
that's kind of that category. And then there's the third which is a little bit like the first but it need I think it's worth bringing out separately which is something like um well what is real? Like what do we
20:24
Speaker A
not not just what is the nature of the trap or the distortion but rather what is an actual way to grasp reality itself? Like how do we respond to the reality that we're in in any meaningful way? And of course, you've got these
20:35
Speaker A
terrible tricks, which is somebody will get some degree of light and then they'll try to use that light to project the entire story. So, this would be kind of a a classic. It's the Jews TM TM after that.
20:48
Speaker A
Um, I pushed through a wall called anti-semitism. I got into the room of everybody who pushed through that wall.
20:54
Speaker A
We're pretty sure we figured out the truth. And by the way, we can we can explain things that are happening in the world more effectively by virtue of this narrative. So, we're going to stop there.
21:05
Speaker A
Yeah. Same thing with misogyny, the long house, the tape. Exactly. Yeah. Exactly. You know, like the long house. It's like, wow, that's a really useful idea that explains things really powerfully. I think we'll stop there. Um, and so that's like that
21:18
Speaker A
third, but of course the third continues to go like more and more people like, okay, well, this is it's useful to pull some of these things through these boundaries, but there's a whole reality we have to actually deal with and
21:28
Speaker A
there's a lot more to it. Um, so anyway, so there's we can go on like crazy with that, but the Anakin story was one of saying, hey, there's a think about how powerful it is to say we're going to reinterpret the
21:43
Speaker A
narrative. Um, I think actually the whole thing kicked off because there was an argument about whether or not the first the trilogy and the second trilogy was, you know, my generation's like, "Yeah, the sec the movie four, five, and
21:55
Speaker A
six just sucked." And all the millennials are like, "You guys are out of your mind. They're really interesting." And all of a sudden these, you know, these guys rush in and like try this on like what happens if we
22:03
Speaker A
actually get Sith pills. Um, and something like saying the entire narrative is a secret code to explain to you Boomer mythology.
22:13
Speaker A
Yes. And once you see through that, you can you can see how boomer mythology works in real life. And then you can actually use that to jettison yourself from the traps of Boomer mythology, which then means you start thinking
22:25
Speaker A
about what does it look like to step into, you know, step out of their mythology and into maybe creating your own mythology. And here we are. We're going to create our own mythology images of uh of Anakin.
22:38
Speaker A
We should let talk Oh, go ahead, please. There's an interesting parallel between what Amazon has done with the Lord of the Rings with their rings of power.
22:46
Speaker A
They're reinterpreting it according to how they uh they want the narrative to go. Basically, orcs are misunderstood.
22:52
Speaker A
It's the same old trope like the every villain is misunderstood eventually. Um and that is from the regime is pushing that or at least whoever is in charge of the regime is producing that story with tons of money. like they're just sinking
23:08
Speaker A
tons of money and power into that re uh redressing the narrative according to their worldview. But the Anakin thing is ground up. So it's it's from people that are not in a position of power. And that's the the other interesting or the
23:23
Speaker A
the taking poking the sails of the woke right uh definition of what's going on on the right is that these people don't have any power and they're longing for power but power itself is not wrong. And I think an aspect of the Boomer
23:39
Speaker A
mythology, two things that have been decaying rapidly over the last 10 years were was the the Jordan Peterson uh equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome.
23:52
Speaker A
That kind of binary doesn't really work because eventually you need equality of of uh opportunity. So we have to have communism at the very beginning to set everybody up at the right level and then they can go wherever they want. And then
24:07
Speaker A
the other one is uh is that that one? Oh shoot, I lost the I lost the thought. It'll have to come back to me. Um Oh yeah. Yeah. Uh uh power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts.
24:22
Speaker A
Absolutely. this absolute allergy that the centrist classical liberals have to any sort of open discourse around power and just the realism of power. And that is just that is not a contention anymore for the dissident right. They're like no
24:38
Speaker A
power exists. It's going to be exerted in certain ways. And we've known this since Aristotle. Like we we understand that there are forms of government and not every monarch is a tyrant. Not every democracy is is a good thing, you know,
24:52
Speaker A
and oligarchy is always going to be operating in the shadows every single time. Y and those two those two kind of uh cliches.
25:00
Speaker A
I think the you know that that particular essay very specifically says look it's increasingly self-evident that the people who are pushing the power corrupts narrative are the ones who are holding power. Mhm.
25:12
Speaker A
Um, and all they're really trying to do is is to continue to hold that power by making everybody else actively push it away, which then the next is be Sith pill, which is literally just take power. Be willing to take and hold
25:25
Speaker A
power. Um, so let's see. Let's let's uh Oh, this is great. So, um, should we go Yarvin? You know, Jarvin has Oh, yeah. Yeah. So Yarvin's biggest the thing that's most bad about him is that he does not understand monarchy at all.
25:47
Speaker A
Um and this is evident in the fact that he collapses the idea of monarchy and the idea of say the CEO of a company.
25:54
Speaker A
Yes. Particularly the CEO of let's say Apple like Tim Cook. Um but that's not Monarch. And the reason why I think is because he has no access to the transcendent. um he he still operates entirely in the same flat world of other
26:09
Speaker A
communists. So logistics and this produces the same image that you see in the being Sith pill and it's you've accepted the man polarity. You've accepted the boomer mythology. You just keep trying to flip back and forth like okay well the rebels are actually the
26:29
Speaker A
bad guys and it's the empire who are the good guys now. Well all right fine.
26:33
Speaker A
you're going back and forth. And if you think about it, that false dichotomy, because that's what happens when you're living in a flat environment, a non-r environment doesn't have access to the transcendent.
26:42
Speaker A
Think about it from the terms of the historical emergence of actual Nazis in actual Germany in the 30s.
26:48
Speaker A
Mhm. Which is, and we're witnessing it right now, so we could just look at it like we have a perfect case study, which is actually the conflict back and forth between an increasingly polarizing discourse that is stuck in a flat. Uh,
27:00
Speaker A
and I think in many ways we could just take the image of the feminine and the masculine, which is I remember actually thinking this in like 2013.
27:09
Speaker A
There was somebody on Facebook who was making an argument. I'm reading the argument and I'm going, well, if I choose to accept your argument, what that just means is that I am extinguishing myself. Like if I if I
27:21
Speaker A
accept your argument, I am removing all of my ability to participate in reality in any way. And you know, in some cases are very explicit. Hey, white man, be don't say anything. the only proper thing you can do is to give your power
27:32
Speaker A
to somebody who's less like well everybody who chooses to to drink of that beverage is just removed from the conversation. They no longer exist.
27:40
Speaker A
They're irrelevant. Um so what's happening is that that if you run the tape forward, what that does is that just produces a polarization. Those who continue to benefit from that narrative and those who reject that narrative are now actively opposed to it. And of
27:53
Speaker A
course what that does is that moves you into the dynamic that we've seen already which is a increasingly polarized left which is dominated by a certain um what does Peterson call it? The dark feminine the mauist right the dark feminine
28:07
Speaker A
and an increasingly polarized right which is is dominated by the dark masculine. And you're like okay well is there any way not to have the dark side be the dominant force on either side of these equations? And of course that's
28:17
Speaker A
how it worked out in in Germany. You actually had a reality that produced the Nazis. It wasn't like a a magic it wasn't a magic thing like you actually look at the real conditions on the ground and people increasingly move to
28:29
Speaker A
the position of well if I have to do this in order to avoid this I will and you know certainly you hit a you hit a point like well it's much better to live over here and be in a world where we
28:40
Speaker A
have um an affirmative idea of who our people are and produce something where we can actually feel something like positive the vision of the thousand-y year Reich has a notion of the thousand years as a notion of our our values
28:54
Speaker A
perpetuate over time as opposed to we actually all just degenerate into complete disgusting nothingness in a generation. Okay, if my choice is nihilism and maximally degenerate what I mean like negative values, right? Values that I detest dominating and then nothingness
29:12
Speaker A
or a thousand-y year Reich. I guess I'll choose thousand-y year Reich, something like that. Obviously, the details matter, but that's what's happening and that's what's happening now. We can see the same thing happening when I look at the narrative on the right. What they do
29:23
Speaker A
is they look at the left and like well those guys are obviously evil, obviously degenerate, obviously not going to be building anything that lasts for 20 years. Like as soon as they have consumed all the life that was put in
29:36
Speaker A
there by previous generations, it just dies. What do I have to do to fight that? And then anybody who chooses to go in that direction becomes increasingly willing to do whatever they need to do to fight it. Oh, there we go. Right? You get you
29:48
Speaker A
get you get to that energy of Dark Anakin. You start seeing like the what are the virtues of the Empire? Well, you notice actually when you watch like the Empire is well, it seems pretty clean.
29:57
Speaker A
Like the everything's very, you know, orderly. Everybody's very serious. They actually seem pretty talented, very dedicated.
30:04
Speaker A
You know, the people are sitting around the room. Unless you're a Stormtrooper trying to Unless you're a Stormtrooper. Well, remember the Stormtroopers have this crazy thing. It's actually a perfect example of the Boomer the Boomer mythology. You're supposed to fear the
30:15
Speaker A
stormtroopers as being dangerous and competent, but then when you actually witness them, you see them as being clownishly incompetent. Interesting, right? Both both can't possibly be true.
30:25
Speaker A
If they actually behave in reality all the time like you see them happen when when you actually watch them on screen, then nobody's scared fair the the name doesn't fit. Yeah.
30:34
Speaker A
Um so it's a you know great example of how the narrative can't possibly be right.
30:39
Speaker A
So, but if we go back to the notion of the breakdown of the World War II narrative, I think we actually get a deeper deeper insight. Um, which is narratives proceed. It's like I want to say world.
30:54
Speaker A
You create a world with a narrative and sacrifice. So, you have to sacrifice to create a narrative. I think we've actually talked about this.
31:02
Speaker A
Yes. And then and then once an adequate sacrifice and an adequate narrative has been produced then a world exists and and people can occupy that world and they can kind of live relatively clearly about what's what's right, what's wrong, what's true,
31:15
Speaker A
what's false. You can make those decisions and people can coordinate. Mhm. But of course those kinds of narratives, I call them pagan narratives, um wrote they aren't actually able to produce something which is enduring over a long period of time. Even if they
31:32
Speaker A
continue to make sacrifice, there's a whole bunch of reasons why they begin to devolve. Mhm.
31:37
Speaker A
And as the uh the the value of countering the narrative, the value of crossing through the the boundaries of the maze begins to build up, as more and more people begin to see um or defect see the the falsalseness or
31:51
Speaker A
defect against the edges of it, it starts to corrode. And of course, as you said, with regard to the the intrinsic de facto conspiracy between the bureaucrat class and the activist class, as more and more weight of pure
32:04
Speaker A
corruption is put on top of the structures, you got both are happening. Corruption putting on top of the structures, the fragility and falseness and the the uh some presuppositions that don't actually make sense that are found in the structures, it begins to wne. And
32:19
Speaker A
then you enter into a period where there's an accelerating process, the breakdown of the narrative. Um, and then you enter into a kind of a new opportunity to either try to create a new world by pagan sacrifice or enter
32:31
Speaker A
into creating a new world in a different version. Yeah. Um, and I think that's probably the best meta narrative to describe where we are.
32:39
Speaker A
And you can see use that to fit a lot of of characteristics of what's happening.
32:45
Speaker A
facilitating that is the uh rapid demographic shift that's occurring the the importation of a lot of people from a different culture pagan cultures I guess Catholic from the south and then pagan from the east are coming in and
33:04
Speaker A
supplanting a lot of the heritage Anglo American the European uh the people who who produced the conditions that are now leading to rapid demographic shift. And so facilitating the anxiety of the young white man right now is that they're seeing the UK, which
33:28
Speaker A
is where our country comes from, becoming a third world country. At least that's what they see. I don't know if that's exactly what's happening, but it is rapidly deteriorating. They see Israel being able to carve out a place
33:38
Speaker A
for their own ethnicity and and just absolutely wreck every every Philistine around them and then drag us into wars that we don't want to be in. And then and then at home we don't have any claim from from their point of view. they
33:53
Speaker A
don't have any claim to this is my country and I can say no and I can look up to my leaders who have my best interest at heart and the system is using is one attacking my heritage and
34:05
Speaker A
then and then liquidating the resources that I have and so they're they're looking for somebody to stand up for them and Trump kind of wore that mantle a bit baron mimemetically kind of did um but that's what they're they're longing
34:20
Speaker A
for somebody to take them to take their side. Well, we've got at least again there's always always a number of things to look at. Um, one is let's just make a a distinction between nation and state.
34:41
Speaker A
So, we have notions of nation state, but let's make a distinction between nation and state. And a nation is something that has an onlogical reality to it.
34:50
Speaker A
Let's say it's transcendent. is a transcendent characteristic that allows a plurality of people to bind together in some way that is real. Um transcendent. So not not blood and soil.
35:05
Speaker A
No, not blood and soil, but perhaps uh a transcendent identity that that is an expression of blood and soil. Blood and soil are ways that we can identify it.
35:14
Speaker A
But the point is that it's actually an ontological reality in just the same way that you're a real person and that I can put to Funny, we talked about the AI piece a moment ago. There's something about you that is real and that holds
35:26
Speaker A
you together as you that is clearly not like your hat is not you. Your glasses are not you. You know, if you if you had a disfiguring uh burn, you wouldn't look like you. You're still you. This is a
35:36
Speaker A
sort of very straightforward philosophy 101. And the point is there's something that is the the binding agent that we could call this your your spirit. The binding agent that holds the pieces together in a unique fashion that is not
35:50
Speaker A
explainable by them individually or collectively but is supervenient on top of them. And that's how identity works in general.
35:58
Speaker A
And that identity is true for uh a couple. Like when you and your wife get together, there's something about your couple that has a reality to it that is more than just you and her or even the two of you. There's something going on
36:09
Speaker A
that is bigger and it's real. The key thing is it's real as a top- down causation. There's something that happens where you're participating in something that is real and larger than yourself. In just the same way that your
36:18
Speaker A
organs participate in something that is real and larger than than themselves by virtue of being you.
36:23
Speaker A
Obviously, I'm saying something that somebody like Dawkins wouldn't get. I would simply posit that he's an idiot in a very profound profound way. M um and if you'd like I can adopt this a snoody English accent so I can affect uh
36:36
Speaker A
a higher degree of of I can get more currency for being smart. Um so as a nation so these things scale up as families have the same kind of thing communities if they're real. If you if you notice
36:48
Speaker A
like if you drive through a town that has been fully drastinated and it's nothing but Starbucks and gas stations there's no nothing there. It has a name.
36:56
Speaker A
It used to be a place but there's nothing there. maybe like a few holdovers probably on fentanel now sadly enough but there's no reality but on occasion particularly in certain areas of kind of like the certain parts of the
37:07
Speaker A
northern southern like the appalachins certain parts of the Midwest it's actually a real town that you can actually tell you you drive okay there's a real place there's a real people and there's a real place so the blood and
37:17
Speaker A
soil is real but it's secondary it's an artifact it tells you something it does not create something it is created by something um or it's in dialogue Okay, pardon it.
37:29
Speaker A
It's in dialogue. Yeah, there's a communic there's a there's a relationship horizontally or vertically both in both directions. But the key thing is you can't fake it. You can't just identify and create a narrative and say, "Hey, we're now going
37:41
Speaker A
to be, you know, blood and soil people." That's what ideology is. Ideology is an effort to simulate a real ontology on the basis of powerful narrative constructions. That's what when I say pang pagan narrative, that's what a pagan narrative is. It's a golem.
37:55
Speaker A
pretends that it's creating a real being. It uses magic spells, narratives. It produces significant sacrifice which moves things, creates a hierarchy of values that people are willing to invest in. And then you might imagine that you're in a real thing, but you're not
38:09
Speaker A
because it'll begin to corrupt and corrode on its own basis. Is that why it's a circle pattern is a circle. It has to re constantly restart itself. Restart itself. Restart itself.
38:19
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, in some sense, it's a spiral because you're moving. there's still a movement that reality is changing but you will return to the beginning of that moment a loop okay um so then the nation right a nation's a
38:32
Speaker A
real thing there are real nations they're they have real identities if you're in a nation and by the way you could do the same thing with like a football team like just being part of a of an actual sports
38:40
Speaker A
team particularly one that's has vitality to it um not one that's been fully drastinated by marketing um we should we can go on that in a second in terms of a good way of understanding what liberalism and how it works. But
38:56
Speaker A
you participate in something that is real, has an ontology that is vital, has a top- down causation, and has its own aesthetic, ethical, moral, even um ontological characteristics of what it means to participate in it. There's like rules of of how you of of of how it is,
39:12
Speaker A
the beingness of it. And so that's nation, right? And then state is operating system, right? It's the it's the the technical characteristics that enable something to actually just logistically move through reality. Um, and we can modulate state. State has a
39:27
Speaker A
we can moving into a whole new model of state with AI. It's a different way of way of modulating reality, different way of doing logistics. It solves a bunch of problems that were the um the kinds of technical problems that made the
39:40
Speaker A
constitutional republic a state-of-the-art state machine in 1787, but is effectively been obsolete for at least two generations. And now we're going to actually have an entirely new technical approach. And that technical approach will produce some new order, some new political order that will fall
39:55
Speaker A
out of it. And just the same way that the printing press did the same thing to the medieval state machine. You you have a you have a technical means for prosecuting the logistical characteristics necessary for governing people in the context of physical
40:08
Speaker A
reality and in relationship with each other horizontally. That gives you a state and various equilibrium and different versions of states. Okay. The Nazis have one version of modern state. United States is another version of modern state. The communists, the Soviets have a different
40:21
Speaker A
version of modern state mid-century technology, blah blah blah blah. They fight each other. We see which one wins.
40:27
Speaker A
Okay, now we live in the kind of liberal version of it. But they're all versions of the same, you know, they're modern. They're modern states. So we're we're exiting that. Um, so when we think about the notion of of
40:38
Speaker A
nation, shoot, sorry, that was a huge digression. Why was I making that distinction? Do you remember? Well, is if people live in So, there's this little town that I worked for. It's about 15 miles up the road and I was a bus driver there and it
40:54
Speaker A
it's just nestled in this little pocket up the Spokane River. And I I noticed the first few months I was there like this is its own people and this land creates the people. They have they have a certain way of walking and they have a
41:06
Speaker A
certain look in their eyes. You know, the the teenagers have this kind of way about them that's very particular. And then I I'm in Spokane, too. I moved from the west side and Spokane's just very like normal or average. Everybody just
41:18
Speaker A
looks really normal. It's just a normal place. And it's got problems, but Spokane's this big city. It's like the second biggest city in in Washington.
41:26
Speaker A
It's got a homeless problem. It's got all the problems that are going on. It's got these weird like places that are no place in it that used to be a place, but then not. So, it's interesting to see
41:36
Speaker A
that as an example like like the people that live in 9M that they're actually their people and it's a small enough community that that the land there's just this one time I was driving over the uh on this mountain and the sun was
41:51
Speaker A
coming up and Spokane means people of the sun and I saw the sun in a way I've never seen it. I'm like this is actually a very powerful psychic force like my relationship to the sun is very clear
42:02
Speaker A
here and that's why it's it it there's a there's a there's a psychological reality going on here. So that's that's uh to extrapolate what you were saying about the nation and how how that reality of relationship forms that ontological
42:17
Speaker A
being and that you if you're an outsider you can kind of see it. Um, but if if people if we design states and then people live their whole life in states, doesn't the state, even if it's a little
42:28
Speaker A
removed from reality, become its own nation, have its own characteristic, have its own people? Not at all. It's a golem. It's not. It doesn't have a nation at all. It's incapable. It's back to our AI. It has no soul, brother. There's no soul to the
42:39
Speaker A
state. But when you interact with people in the deep state, they have their own ontology. They have their own way of hating. Let's just let's use like Starbucks as an example, okay?
42:51
Speaker A
Um Starbucks hath no soul. Um corporate culture. I remember working for them and they're like, "We have corporate culture." I'm like, "You guys are designing something that's fake." That's great. Exactly. And you can design something that's fake, but you
43:03
Speaker A
have this is again we're sort of I'll repeat this is the golem, right? This is the the temp the in in the the ability to use magic spells and sacrifice to produce something which is a pseudoontology. And that pseudoontology
43:16
Speaker A
can bind people together for as long as the energy that flows into the sacrifice is potent. In other words, as long as the company is profitable enough to continue to upgradient the bribes that are given to people to do things that
43:28
Speaker A
they don't have any real interested in doing, then it will continue to move forward through space and time as a bound entity.
43:34
Speaker A
Right? That's how it works. That's how corporations operate. Why am I working here? Well, I get paid more to work here. Do you like it? That's not even a valid question. What kind of question would that be? What would it mean to do
43:44
Speaker A
the things I like? Well, one thing it would mean is to be poor. I'd rather be rich than poor, so I'll go do that, right? Okay. Welcome to how modernity operates. And that's the whole story.
43:52
Speaker A
Why am I living in Spokane instead of living in the town that I grew up in?
43:55
Speaker A
Because I can make more money in Spokane than I can make in the town. But what about your family? Well, you got to make sacrifices. Aha.
44:01
Speaker A
Oh, okay. Yeah. What did I just slaughter? Well, I slaughtered all possibility of familial meaning. And the fact that my grandparents, who created something that was real, has just been slaughtered on the altar of mammon in this particular
44:12
Speaker A
case, right? You're slaughter. making a sacrifice to a particular pagan god which dominates most of modernity and that gives you the ability to produce idols. You can produce things that are not ontologically real but nonetheless bind people together as long as the
44:26
Speaker A
sacrifice is maintained. Okay. All right. I see it. So then you know your your people who have lived in something, right? They they lived in something that may have been a nation. It's very hard for me to tell because you know I'm Texan and of
44:40
Speaker A
course I'm American and I have California too. you you spend time well I've had I' I've drunk of the water of California so I get the I get the the vibe of of temptation very effectively in the last every time I go back to
44:52
Speaker A
California I'm like wow and now I can see it so much more clearly of the the the uh absurd chaos of the continuous necessity of a flux of temptation in every direction like every everything has to be increasingly obviously
45:09
Speaker A
superficially beautiful but it has to be that level of thin layer of of aesthetics and you have to be able to sort of saturate yourself with various forms of uh sort of sens sensualism to just maintain just to be there just to
45:22
Speaker A
continue to want to be there and that's I remember when I was in Hawaii for a while and I came back to San Diego I was walking around I was like oh this place does not want people here this is
45:33
Speaker A
not a place where people are supposed to live there's no root soil there's no way to put deep roots into this soil um there may be a good reason to come that maybe this place is a place to come
45:44
Speaker A
and visit for particular purposes but its purpose is not to have millions of people live here permanently for example that's a I can go deeper on that but it's a bit of an aside I got you yeah so what you notice
45:56
Speaker A
and those of us who are old enough actually remember feeling this very specifically in the transition into the early 80s by the way what you notice is that there was something about a real maybe nation and this is why I want to
46:11
Speaker A
be careful because it may have always been a golem. America may have always been the work of pagan sacrifice of some sort one over and over and over and over again. Um, but at least the feeling of participation in something that had
46:25
Speaker A
something like a spiritual aliveness that was more than just the logistical machinery and more than just the obvious um uh bribery of the the the state. And so that's waned, right? has waned enormously and anybody who feels that
46:44
Speaker A
they notice it. They're like, "Wow, this doesn't feel like I'm living in a nation anymore. It doesn't feel like that." So, when you're saying about the white person saying, "Hey, where's my nation?" It's something, well, there's a reality
46:56
Speaker A
that whatever thing that was a nation before, regardless of what we actually thought it was, that is definitely no longer as real as it has been. It may be completely evaporated. A long time ago, I made a distinction and I'm in some
47:09
Speaker A
sense playing with CS Lewis's idea from uh that hideous strength uh between we call Lorz and I think Britain. I think those are the two.
47:19
Speaker A
So Lor is kind of like the mysterious deeper essence of the actual beingness of of of that nation.
47:30
Speaker A
And Britain is in fact precisely the uh uh the kind of the pagan or the uh sorcery instantiation of that same nation and characterized by all the various forms of of pillage that are associated with it. And it may and in
47:45
Speaker A
that story he goes back to like Arthur, King Arthur as an archetype of Logres.
47:50
Speaker A
Um, and the way that that uh, Brave New World shows up, like the way that Huxley describes Brave New World is also a really beautiful image of Britain in that distinction. So, I thought, hey, is the American Republic and the American
48:04
Speaker A
Empire those different ways of making that same distinction? Was there something was there something going on in the founding of this nation that was a real nation? Is there a real nation here that periodically we've were able to participate in? And when we do so,
48:19
Speaker A
we're doing so for real and that we're entering into a point right now where that's at a low web, maybe even near near terminus.
48:26
Speaker A
Um, but if it's true, actually, by the way, I actually wrote an essay on this recently which got me into meaningful trouble because I used uh bad words in it.
48:34
Speaker A
Um, the title of the essay was toward a truly Christian nationalism. Yeah. Okay. Because like you, I noticed like, hm, why is it when I see the see the words Christian and nationalism next to each other, the people who have high
48:49
Speaker A
allergies to lots of things react, huh, let me delve into that. And I didn't really research the stuff that is tagged as Christian nationalism. That's not particularly interesting. I want to say, what's, you know, what's what's in that
49:02
Speaker A
room? Let me just kind of go through me accept me, drink the poison, go into the room, what's in the room.
49:08
Speaker A
Yeah. And what I came to was a conclusion that and I can think about this in two different ways that if the United States is to be a nation, it can only be a Christian nation.
49:23
Speaker A
Now, of course, those who are challenged with emotional reactivity or midw IQ will react to what I just said before even contemplating it.
49:36
Speaker A
Yeah. Um, but that's that's the argument. The argument is there's something to the question of what is the American nation?
49:45
Speaker A
What would it mean for there to be an American nation at all? Is it viable? It may be that there just isn't one.
49:50
Speaker A
Okay, that's plausible. It definitely doesn't look like a fascist theocracy. No. No. That's kind of like the the wet dream of the of the James Lindsay crew.
50:03
Speaker A
Yeah. Um there's no there's no ashwitz. Maybe there's reservations. I just don't see any of that actually happening. It's just there's too much land for one thing.
50:14
Speaker A
Well, there's it's just it's not that doesn't that's not the n that's not a nation. That's the point. That's not a nation. That's a state, right? So as soon as you're looking through the lens of the state simulating a nation,
50:27
Speaker A
then you're already in fascism. You're already in communism. You're already in liberalism. By the way, all three, all of modernity is looking through the lens of a state simulating nation. If you're looking through the lens of a nation
50:37
Speaker A
articulating itself in the world by means of instruments, then you're in a completely different environment. Not something we maybe haven't seen. Modernity has sort of been uh what's that called? Stripmining those kinds of things to feed its own engine
50:52
Speaker A
to make sacrifice and sacrifice and sacrifice nation and community and church and family and individual soul to keep itself alive. Um but it's a very different way of looking at the world altogether.
51:03
Speaker A
Um and this I think is the key point I want to make. What it's a completely different way of looking at the world altogether. Like the the prime one of the primary errors that I see of our current moment is that
51:14
Speaker A
everybody is fighting over the dead body of modernity. If you if you if you pick liberalism versus fascism, you're just fighting over two dead bodies. Now those are the exactly the same person. It's just a different version of the same
51:26
Speaker A
person. And modernity itself is dead. It's not a thing anymore. Um, and it could never be a living thing. It wasn't alive. It was a golem, right? It was a sacrifice. It was a thing that was produced, a simulated ontology. So, the
51:38
Speaker A
question is, what does it look like to step outside of that far enough to notice what would what what is reality?
51:45
Speaker A
Like, what's actually real here? Where are the real beings? And how do they really operate? And how do we participate on the basis of that reality and those real beings? And by the way, the real normativity. Um, and this is where the question comes up.
52:00
Speaker A
I I get the feeling and and I said it in the essay. I get the feeling that in fact there is an American nation. Um, and that American nation is very interesting because we can't tap into any other kind of
52:15
Speaker A
nation as being the nation we are. We'd like to say, hey, there's an Anglo source. Yeah, there's definitely an Anglo source, but that's definitely not what America is. America is not England.
52:27
Speaker A
In which case, if it is, we need to immediately just retcon the the revolution and return back to the to the king because that's the right maybe a different king, but whatever.
52:36
Speaker A
Yeah. Um, and more to the point, if you actually look at it, you can see that even in the very beginning of the American nation, like the Germans played a big part in the American nations and different flavors of the Anglo played a
52:48
Speaker A
big part. I mean, as we know, if you if you know England, like the West and the East and the North and the South, they're very distinct. M you know the the Cavaliers were a meaningful part of the Americans and the Cavaliers were not
52:58
Speaker A
you know in a strong position. They fled. So what's going on? What's happening? And a way of thinking about it and I really had to bring bring the image of the new Jerusalem. Okay, what is this story from the esqueological
53:09
Speaker A
point of view is America may be the unique nation that has as its essence as its calling as its vocation as the thing that is central to its being that it is able to achieve a proper communion between and among other
53:26
Speaker A
nations. So this is true. This would be a mac micro macro. At a micro level, what holds America together is in fact a participation. And in this case, I have to be very explicit. A participation in the body of Christ because I'm now
53:39
Speaker A
having to use a a kind of metaphysics that allows the notion of what is it?
53:44
Speaker A
What is it that which holds nations together, right? What holds people together? A nation. What holds nations together? Well, it turns out the only thing that can hold kingdoms together is a king of kings. That idea. And so
53:55
Speaker A
participating at the level of the king of kings locally, domestically, right, in this particular territory, right? But also because of that fact, it can also represent and resolve those kinds of questions at the level of the entire globe. So, as a kind of a practical
54:09
Speaker A
example, if you could really figure out how to have Japanese Americans be Japanese Americans and Korean-Americans to be Korean-Americans, and they could really be held together in true communion in America, that then becomes a vehicle for supporting that same kind
54:23
Speaker A
of holding together in true communion with Japan and Korea. I'm using examples of folks who really don't like each other, but nonetheless hang together.
54:30
Speaker A
Yeah. Now, I will point out that this is the utopian vision of liberalism. Yes. Yeah, I was going to say but liberalism is just an inversion of this reality. Liberalism is an effort to achieve the result on the basis of a
54:47
Speaker A
completely different approach to means and as a as a consequence is entirely a slight of hand and that's the kind of the key problem. Um liberalism how can can we drill down into that? Let's define liberalism on the ground.
55:02
Speaker A
Well, let me see if I can say right now. protocol uh the the the tenants of it free speech uh private property that's a pro that's a protocol by which difference can unite as long as there's a gentleman's agreement between the
55:16
Speaker A
different commons to not we can use the the language we've already produced liberalism is if you look at it through the lens of the state first so it says hey we're going to create a very uh kind of minimum viable
55:28
Speaker A
state structure that sits on top of and governs relationships between nations nations and we're going and that is then going to allow nations to occupy space with a minimum amount of conflict. We can avoid major conflict if we're all
55:43
Speaker A
living under the protocol of liberalism. Yeah. And that is that's utopia. Like that's the the benefit our our kind of Star Trek future is that every single human on on the planet Earth is occupying their particular nation, right? Well, in
55:58
Speaker A
Star Trek, they're brief species, but Vulcans and and uh I don't know, Kardashians and humans can all be on the same starship and they govern they operate under a protocol. And the protocol is the sort of a thinnest
56:11
Speaker A
possible state. Yes. Um and we have a diff couple of different mechanisms. We have feedback mechanisms to try to avoid it being corrupted. We have tripartite structures. We have judicial like it's a very kind of a classic systems design
56:24
Speaker A
approach. We're going to do a really effective systems design on state that becomes the primary lens and that allows us to solve a bunch of problems that are known issues in regards to how nations work out.
56:35
Speaker A
Yeah. And of course we know that Go ahead. Ironically enough uh Star Trek most of it takes place on a starship that's ordered by naval British naval values.
56:45
Speaker A
Very strict hierarchy. Very strict hierarchy. Yeah. And and much of the much of the intrigue is actually the conflict of the vertical strict hierarchy. we're going to violate the law and the body of the law and the spirit of the law versus the letter of
56:56
Speaker A
the law and like how you know um and we should say by the way also governed because it's a show by the law of narrative which is more fundamental.
57:05
Speaker A
Um which we can't escape is that there isn't actually a real law of narrative that that drives everything.
57:11
Speaker A
So so that's like that's the way of thinking about it. And now the key thing there is that the what liberal the way liberalism is able to operate as a machine is through this method of sacrifice. Right? So to power it you can
57:24
Speaker A
think of it the word machine is very good. It is a machine. It's a machine that produces certain kinds of goods. It enables the um conglomeration of groups of people in populations of relatively large uh density. Yeah.
57:39
Speaker A
More people in places. It enables transactions and it converts market creates marketplace level coordination very effectively. It enables people to transact in goods and services with enough order for those transactions to operate that contracts can be enforced in fact are enforced effectively if
57:58
Speaker A
liberalism is working well. Um it it keeps intergroup conflict at the level of organized crime. um and let and as it absorbs there's always a big conflict as it absorbs a particular group into it but once it's absorbed that group that
58:12
Speaker A
group is now ordered which is to say it's a kind of Roman Empire running um modernity operating system.
58:18
Speaker A
Yeah. Um that's exactly the Roman Empire running modernity operating system. As long as you pay taxes to Caesar and you recognize that the Romans are in charge, we will maintain peace and everybody can kind of like do their thing except for
58:33
Speaker A
those troublesome Jews who never are willing to to kind of bend the knee to a a god below or or certain demographics that uh are prone to violence that don't seem to be uh not lawful in Rome.
58:49
Speaker A
In America, inner city. Oh, I was thinking about Rome at the time. Oh, okay. Oh, the Jews were the Jews were a thorn in Rome's side, too. Is that what Jews were a huge thorn in Rome's side.
58:57
Speaker A
They were they were the like the biggest thorn. Like imagine emperors getting just losing their minds about this tiny group of people way over here who are kind of super irrelevant. But the key thing was like everybody else in in the
59:08
Speaker A
empire really understood the language of power pretty cleanly. It's like, well, if we don't do what Rome says, they're literally going to kill everybody and burn our city to the ground. So, let's just do what they say except the Jews. And you know,
59:21
Speaker A
periodically you'd get some local, you know uh uprisings, adventurous young people who think they can throw off Rome's yoke because they're adventurous people. Rome comes in, beats the [ __ ] out of everybody.
59:31
Speaker A
Everybody's like, "Oh, yeah, I forgot Rome's the big guy in the block. Do what they say." The Jews are like, "Hey, no, sorry. We can't do that. We've got to we got to deal with the supreme god." So, you know, [ __ ]
59:41
Speaker A
you. You know, let's crucify 2,000 people next generation. [ __ ] you. Crucify 7,000 people next generation.
59:47
Speaker A
[ __ ] you. Destroy Jerusalem next generation. [ __ ] you. fine, the entire nation has to be completely obliterated.
59:54
Speaker A
No Jews can live within the boundaries of what had been the kingdom of Judah.
59:57
Speaker A
Complete diaspora. They're like, you know, that level. That's what the story. And they're still [ __ ] you.
60:02
Speaker A
Yeah. Still same thing. Um, which is but that's a whole other story. So it's plucky. That's what it is.
60:09
Speaker A
Plucky. That's the thing. So that that's what liberalism is. And and and the key thing is the the surplus value of liberalism is what fuels the machine.
60:18
Speaker A
Yes. So because you can get these kinds of benefits from it, it enables a bunch of characteristics that has a surplus value. We we do live in a richer world because we have more people participating in relatively fair trade
60:30
Speaker A
across larger populations. There's a straightforward network effect that that produces exponential value production. Yeah. Until until uh corruption uh overtakes, you get you you you run into three problems. Uh it it's like Taco Bell.
60:46
Speaker A
Taco Bell is my my favorite image of liberalism. Tacos were not invented by Taco Bell.
60:54
Speaker A
Tacos come from a nation. They come from an an alive culture connected to a real place with real people who are being driven by a real ontology. Taco Bell takes tacos and then immediately initiates the gradient descent that is
61:09
Speaker A
built into liberalism, right? It converts it into slop. Everything that liberalism plugs into starts with something that is real created by something that is not liberalism connects to it and then cannot help but go through a gradient descent towards
61:24
Speaker A
slop. Starbucks, National Football League, rock and roll, anything you want. Exactly. Anything you want because that's how the machine operates. It can't produce reality. It has no aliveness. It just has a machine that is able to extract value and
61:44
Speaker A
produce surplus value to feed itself. That's how it operates. So it runs into a boundary condition where can it consume more value? This either has to expand uh globally. So let's we have to include China, we have to include
61:59
Speaker A
Africa, we have to include all of you know India everything all all of the world has to be included because it's just consuming right. It needs to form more territory to consume and it has to consume vertically. We have to strip
62:08
Speaker A
mine the human soul all the way down to the bottom. We have to actually take every story and convert it into slop.
62:14
Speaker A
This is why Star Wars has to go to slop. This is why Lord of the Rings has to go to slot because the underlying logic of liberalism is only that gradient descent. And even the actual lived experience. This is why families have to
62:26
Speaker A
go to slop. This is why villages and towns have to go to slop. Why individual human identities have to go to slop because that's just the logic. It can't not do that. If as long as it's only liberalism, if you're looking through
62:37
Speaker A
the lens of liberalism first, if that's your primary mode of operation, if it's if you're allowing it to be sovereign, then that's the logic of the world that you're in.
62:47
Speaker A
Um, so that's what I mean when I say that that's the that's the machine we're talking about.
62:52
Speaker A
It has the advantage of producing a very significant number of different things that produce surplus value. most notably at the level of sensuous material. You can create more things that the body uh perceives as valuable. But it does so at
63:07
Speaker A
the cost of producing more and more and more slop particularly those things that are the most meaningful and valuable but are not uh salient. So more relevant less salient things get converted into more salient things and the salient
63:19
Speaker A
things devolve to slop. H. So that's the machine. Um, and that machine has consumed whatever portion of the American nation that we've been living in. Um, certainly since World War II. So you've got the breakdown of the postw World War II narrative, but you
63:36
Speaker A
also have something like the the felt um nadier of of the living American nation, what it means to actually participate in that. And if you notice, almost all of the arguments that are trying to fill that hole, they are arguments that come
63:52
Speaker A
from the language of modernity. They come from the language of procedural neutrality. They come from the language of temptation. Well, here's all the good things that you that you get by giving up the life of a nation. And aren't
64:09
Speaker A
those great? Don't we prefer those things? Don't we like the rules-based international order that keeps peace happening at a at a global level?
64:16
Speaker A
Keeps peace happening at a global level. Very warrior like peace. But um and you know we can we can have a a practical argument. It's it's useful.
64:27
Speaker A
It' be useful to kind of have an honest argument and say, "Hey, well, the liberalism is many ways born out of the real breakdown of the medieval order." And it was a response to the fact that at that moment in time, the church and
64:42
Speaker A
the the orders of monarchy were no longer able to maintain order and things were beginning to devolve into absolute had weren't beginning had devolved into absolute chaos and something had to be done. Mhm.
64:54
Speaker A
Uh but we should be mindful that this is also post the birth of modernity. We had already begun to move into the a new regime like a new world was being built at a technical level. Remember I talked
65:06
Speaker A
about the state has an order and what we were witnessing at the moment of the 30 years war was the breakdown of the order the technical order of the medieval state structure and that led to a bunch of conflicts in
65:19
Speaker A
terms of the interregnum between that and different state structures. And what ended up happening is we adopted a new state structure. In this case, you know, the nation state with largely governed by liberalism, but still very much living in the middle,
65:34
Speaker A
assuming all of the underlying realities of the nation, which just got replaced over and over and over again over time, like you know, World War I shattered big pieces of that, etc., etc.
65:42
Speaker A
Yeah. Uh but we're living now at the point where we're in an interregnum at the end of modernity. And that's a key insight.
65:50
Speaker A
This is very difficult for people to grasp that the same kind of transition that occurred back in the 1500s is the kind of transitioning that that's occurring now. So the medieval world which is a which is a world not just a
66:03
Speaker A
state an entire world an entire metadarrative was breaking down in the face of of new lived conditions like new ways that human beings could participate in reality for example technically.
66:15
Speaker A
Yeah. And that gave rise to just a whole new set of possibilities that hadn't existed before and didn't weren't governed properly or even plausibly in that structure. And that created a breakdown effect and then a reformation of something.
66:27
Speaker A
Mhm. We're now living at a moment that is equivalent and probably several orders of magnitude larger in terms of transformation, possibility, etc. And a big part, maybe even the whole part of what's happening is just that we can't
66:43
Speaker A
govern the reality that we're actually living in using the tools that were built to govern a reality that is no longer vaguely uh valid. You can't use modernity to govern the world that we're moving towards because modernity itself
66:57
Speaker A
is obsolete as a governing mechanism. the whole category, every version doesn't matter whether you're choosing fascism communism socialism liberalism, every category inside modernity is obsolete in relationship to the moment that we're moving into and we're sort of stuck in the middle of
67:11
Speaker A
that. So, we're seeing the the reality of it. Well, if if if modernity was preceded by modern affectics like different pressures and different ways of of interacting with reality, as you say, and then it kind of becomes modernity
67:25
Speaker A
and then modernity seeds to something else. Is there a way to see what's on the horizon? I guess that's what I'm trying to do. I'm trying to look where are we going? And so so that's why the an Anakin thing is salient. It's just
67:39
Speaker A
like there's something here and the Yarvin is very uh important because he goes he tries to make this preodern view of liberalism. He tries to get out and see liberalism as this strange country. when I interviewed him, he's like,
67:56
Speaker A
"A liberal is just as weird as a Mormon if you're outside of that liberal world order." So, what is this? Where where is it that these these motions, these movements, these anxieties are pointing towards?
68:10
Speaker A
And why is it there's something about Anakin? There's something about this is the thing about the liberals deep down they one I think they just want to [ __ ] whatever they want to do. They just want to do whatever they want to do, but they
68:25
Speaker A
want it to be maintained in a way that it doesn't lead to chaos, right? They want liberty, maximum liberty without it devolving into chaos. And they have this real deep I have it too issue with authority.
68:41
Speaker A
And that's why the image of a king or a tyrant. Oh, is or Hitler. It's like, whoa, whoa, whoa. We don't want that. We don't want somebody telling us what to do.
68:52
Speaker A
But every pre previous order had somebody who made a decision. That's why they have such a problem with Schmidt.
68:59
Speaker A
It's like no, there's just a state of exception. Somebody's going to decide. If you look at CO, people decided where we could walk, where we couldn't walk, what we had to wear, what we couldn't wear, where the children could go, where
69:11
Speaker A
they couldn't go. They made the exception under a state of emergency. All right. Ready? I'm going to throw I'm going to try to throw something out.
69:18
Speaker A
Let's see if it works. All right. Um, so I'm going to go back to my my critique of of Yarvin.
69:24
Speaker A
Um, and I'll and I'll just I'll use a two concepts, power and authority. Yes.
69:32
Speaker A
And the key thing is that they are distinct. They are completely distinct order. Um, that fact is very confusing to those who live within modernity. You know, to modern authority is he who wields power. Simple as that. And if
69:51
Speaker A
you're anti- athoritarian, you have some allergy to have somebody have power over you. Hey, you can't tell me what to do, man.
69:59
Speaker A
Yeah. Okay. So, the point I'm making or the argument I'm making is there's been a collapse that authority has been collapsed into power. We live in a single world power and that authority is just sort of a ve a piece of the power
70:12
Speaker A
structure, for example. But that's not how reality works. reality actually consists of power and authority and authority is qualitatively distinct. This is a completely different uh nature of reality, completely different metaphysic. And this is what by the way what I would say is a good
70:29
Speaker A
way of seeing what's going to come because what we will witness is a reestablishment of authority. And by the way, let's just go ahead and use Odysius, the most recent movie, as an example of that, right? because we had
70:41
Speaker A
at in um Odicius's house right in his kingdom we had the absence of authority and we had a the queen was holding as best she could something the son was not in a position that he could assume authority properly and so the suitors
70:57
Speaker A
were there and they were presenting power and they were seeking a way to anoint their power as legitimate power but we were living in a world entirely dominated ex by power and power dynamics and notice by the way the tension of a
71:10
Speaker A
constant game of where at what point does this just evolve to somebody knifing somebody else? Like there once you're playing in the game of power at the end of the day, it's who gets to who kills who first, right? It's the light
71:19
Speaker A
of the long night of the long knives. But Odicius represents a completely different characteristic. He represents the actual presence of true authority.
71:27
Speaker A
There's something about him as being the actual king. He's literally actually the king of that land. And I don't mean that in the sense of he's the most powerful tyrant. I don't mean by that that he is somehow the most effective warrior who
71:38
Speaker A
just killed the other guys more effective and they can kill him. What I mean is he is literally anointed. He is part of the spirit of that people. He's part of the spirit of that place that has been selected by a transcendent
71:49
Speaker A
power that is more than the simple power games happening horizontally between all these various players. It is coming from a higher location. And when he occupies that role of authority, things change, right? people can orient themselves more effectively in reality.
72:05
Speaker A
Tmicus knows what to do. The servants know what to do. The body of that actual place begins to be reorganized in a fashion which is what happens when it's a living real thing. Right? The life of the being of that place kicks back into
72:20
Speaker A
gear. So when the when the proper authority is in place, the being is actuated properly. Think of it like the difference between being um you know when when they inject novacaane into your face, you can't move your mouth.
72:32
Speaker A
The proper authority has been has been inhibited by an external agent that makes that no longer functional. When the novocaane wears off, you're back into proper authority and you can actually govern things. Well, notice, by the way, that authority is intrinsically
72:44
Speaker A
hierarchical. Yeah. You don't govern the muscles in your in your in your face directly from your cerebral cortex, right? You there's a hierarchy. You hand things off. And by the way, it's a very powerful multiple feedback loop kind of hierarchy. The
72:58
Speaker A
premise, the point is something like there is actually real authority. That reality is actually a real hierarchy.
73:04
Speaker A
That there are authorities that transcend humans by many orders of magnitude. That we are actually given particular locations in reality. That if we can orient ourselves towards them and occupy them properly activates the life and the beingness that is the thing for
73:19
Speaker A
which we have proper stewardship. Think about Aragorn now going into Gondor. And that produces a a qualitatively distinct way of living. And so a monarch, a true king, which is not at all again a dictator or a CEO, is
73:34
Speaker A
somebody who is called. There's a calling from a higher place. Think about just the art the the art and image of a king. A king has a crown and a king has a a staff and the staff usually has a
73:44
Speaker A
globe on top and the globe usually has something on the very top. What is that saying? Well, the king represents the divine entering into the world, giving energy, life, direction, and order. And the king then brings that out from the
73:58
Speaker A
divine. And on behalf of, by the way, the entire body that the king has responsibility for the wholeness of the living kingdom on the basis of the kingdom itself. It's a being, a person who has that given responsibility. And
74:08
Speaker A
by the way, that given power, the actual power. And I don't mean this in terms of mean power, the power of machine guns and the machine. I mean that in terms of like divine potency. the transcendent itself. It allows the entire thing to be
74:21
Speaker A
ordered. Like the spirit of the people becomes awake, aligned and ordered properly. Now that doesn't mean necessarily, by the way, that the United States would be governed by a king, but it would be someone who holds that proper authority, which maybe who knows
74:35
Speaker A
exactly what that is. I have, you know, lots of interesting possibilities. That freaking problem of scale.
74:44
Speaker A
And we could do this, by the way. Yeah, scale is a huge one. Let's flag that in a second. We could do the same thing with AI, right? You if you try to think about how do we work through AI, super
74:53
Speaker A
intelligent agents, you know, many orders more intelligent than us, billions, quadrillions of agents, all running at IQ is well above 110. Um, perfectly skilled in all things. That is power. And we are not going to govern that power with power
75:11
Speaker A
because it's a more powerful power. Yeah, that's kind of a simple way of putting it. You cannot govern a power with a less powerful power. It doesn't work. Um, at a certain point, intelligence at a high enough level
75:22
Speaker A
produces more power. That's why we why war machines work the way that they work. It's why we're in a race to build these things, right? Why why why are we racing to build AI? I assure you it has
75:32
Speaker A
nothing to do with more efficient Starbucks. Um, if we don't, the Chinese will. Well, why do we care about that? Well, because if they do, they'll be more powerful than us. Duh. Yeah, that's pretty straightforward, right? Um, but
75:45
Speaker A
authority when you recognize that authority is real, that there's a transcendent dimension to reality and that there's an actual proper authority, proper authority can govern power by its very nature. Power seeks to be governed by proper authority. Power seeks to be
76:00
Speaker A
directed. You can think of it in terms of like uh a knight uh a knight acting or a samurai said ah interesting as well. A knight acting on his own is is no longer under proper authority. He is
76:12
Speaker A
just a warlord. He's he's moved out of the hierarchy. He's moving at the level of just warlord. A knight seeks to be directed. He seeks to be governed by an authority that is coming from a higher place that him so his power can fit into
76:25
Speaker A
the order of reality with maximum beauty. And like that's just a story about how reality works. It's a story about how monarchy actually is, what monarchy truly is. And by the way, how we proceed forward. The way we preede
76:38
Speaker A
forward is we begin to try to seek those who have actual authority and allow them to participate in that authority properly.
76:45
Speaker A
Which means first in our minds we have to separate power and authority. Most people have encountered this in their lives. Not often but on occasion, right? Most people have had a teacher who is truly living their vocation or a
76:59
Speaker A
coach who is truly living their vocation or a mentor. somebody who was by with living their vocation I literally mean the thing to which they were called by God that you're like wow I remember that teaching there's something about the
77:10
Speaker A
experience of being in that classroom that was qualitatively different than other environments the reason for that is because that's the experience of being under authority and if you're the kind of person like I am who's profoundly anti- athoritarian
77:23
Speaker A
when you're under proper authority you notice that there's a beauty to it like oh this is what it's the reason why I'm so anti- athoritarian is that I'm anti see people occupying authority improperly. Like the steward should not
77:37
Speaker A
pretend to be the king. The bureaucrat should definitely not pretend to be the king. And when he does, I feel the wrongness of that so deeply that I can do nothing more than rebel.
77:46
Speaker A
There's there's nothing about that that I can't not rebel against. Uh but when you encounter somebody who's acting under proper authority, their authority is real. Their invocation, they're doing the thing they're supposed to do. It's funny. You actually see it all the time.
78:01
Speaker A
Like it you sometimes you go to a restaurant and there's a you know a chef, you just feel relaxed.
78:09
Speaker A
This person is doing the thing they're put on this planet to do. Yeah. And they're doing it with real commitment. This is a beautiful thing.
78:15
Speaker A
You can see it. Sometimes you'll be walking around there just somebody just singing. You can hear the tone of their voice that they're they're they're there.
78:21
Speaker A
And that's a a completely different metaphysic. And it's a critical metaphysic because if you don't have that distinction, then the logic of power put you in a box and there's no way to escape from that box. Like the the game
78:34
Speaker A
theoretic logic of power leads you to absolute destruction. It's mutually assured destruction does not mean we don't do it. It means in fact it's mutually assured destruction. We are mutually assured that we will be destroyed um inside power. And there's so many
78:48
Speaker A
different ways of talking about it, but that's a critical thing to be grasping. So what happens now is as we're moving out of the kind of the false world, the false ontology of the World War II narrative, as the blood sacrifice of
79:03
Speaker A
World War II finally begins to lose its magic power and the various forms of corruption, exploitation, and even just agency begin to awaken in the field of the disorder of that particular structure, we essentially have a fork. We can try
79:20
Speaker A
to make a bigger nastier false narrative with more intense sacrifice. There's maybe two versions of that that are available. Or we can try to seek authority. We can try to seek what is the actual nature of reality and what is
79:34
Speaker A
the hierarchy that we can participate in. Um it's but it's the key thing is it's very available because it's forced right there. We can't there's the the world that we have been living in is just going to go away. So you can try to
79:47
Speaker A
defend the kind of the liberal post-war order, but you're defending something. It was a line from the Matrix.
79:55
Speaker A
Lieutenant, your men are already dead. You're defending something that is obsolete, and that obsolescence is just continuing to process more and more violently. You know, it's like a a blown tire on a semi. Like the rubber is just
80:06
Speaker A
going to start flying all over the place. Yeah. Um Yeah. And again, that's just because the nature of the thing. Like I don't hold any animus against it. It did it did its thing. It played out in certain way.
80:14
Speaker A
We're we're both products of the thing. I mean, it's it's our world. It is our world. And you know what?
80:20
Speaker A
Here's the thing. I used to kind of like Taco Bell. There's this uh a part of the prequel trilogy where Padme, who's a senator, and Anakin, who's this Jedi Padawan still, he's a teenager. They're sitting on the lawn and he does a little spiel
80:38
Speaker A
about, you know, you you senators don't get anything done. She's like, well, we come together. we talk about our decision and you know we decide on what's the best idea and he's like but you guys never make any decisions you
80:50
Speaker A
know this is kind of the Schmidian like liberalism is just a infinite discourse uh and then he says you know somebody should force them to to do the right thing somebody wise and she's like well that sounds like a tyrant he's like well
81:03
Speaker A
if it works so there's a few things going on in there but what you're pointing to is this lost sense of what is the wise man and I guess a part of the trilogy if I have to go back and
81:13
Speaker A
watch it is setting up Palpatine the emperor as a wise man but somehow not that wise. I don't know why he's and Yoda just just go just go with wise guy and you've got exactly the right architecture.
81:24
Speaker A
Wise guy. Yeah. And then but the wise guy in in the other trilogy Yoda was the wise man. He's this uh this secluded maybe silent generation guy who who basically puts Luke through the ringer and uh but he's still divorced from
81:39
Speaker A
power. He doesn't have any power. Yoda like gave up his seat of power. like in the swamp lands. Um, and Luke has to find his own way, but he Luke never takes the mantle. I guess that's what the uh the final trilogy was
81:51
Speaker A
supposed to be like what does it look like if Luke does get the power and and the what Elon Musk about Anakin posted is like look what they took from us like Anakin and Padme and Luke and Leia were
82:04
Speaker A
all a royal family and Scon and a royal destiny and and uh I mean it was dark and like kind of edge lord gothic stuff you know like like tinges of evil um but it was that was what we were looking
82:16
Speaker A
for. or the Boomer myth didn't give us that. It gave us the hero's journey without the king actually taking any sort of responsibility. And then the the the last trilogy was actually Luke didn't deserve the power and we're going
82:30
Speaker A
to give it to a girl who, you know, like the Ray kind of Mary Sue archetype thing, which is the the response. We can't have anybody ruling us. We can only have infinite rebels and infinite uh uh empire. and and with the with the
82:44
Speaker A
Finn character, which was going to be interesting, a stormtrooper that joins the rebels was never really explored, but I'm that that line like like developing the insight of true authority, developing and we we have it with the influencer class. There are people who
83:04
Speaker A
are certainly talented. Fuentes, you brought up, Tate, you brought up, Tate's got some weird stuff going on. Russell Brand's got some weird stuff going on.
83:11
Speaker A
Even the guys who were on our side, Jordan Peterson, he was he was given this mantle, this mandate, and it seems to have like been too much for that guy to handle, right? But he was a great example.
83:22
Speaker A
He's somebody who has exceeded his proper authority out of out of good intent. Yeah.
83:28
Speaker A
But that doesn't matter. Doesn't matter for pushed him to as soon as he started carrying more than was proper for him to carry, then the burden starts to destroy him.
83:38
Speaker A
And that's just that's how it works. Like that's the that's a very key thing is you have to actually be operating at a very high perfectly high level of humility because you don't choose the domain over which you have authority.
83:53
Speaker A
It's not a strategic question. Right? As soon as you're trying to figure it out and strategically decide what it is that you're going to do, even if that is voluntary self-sacrifice, you are endeavoring to take authority for yourself. That's not how it works.
84:09
Speaker A
What you have to do is simply accept the authority that is given to you. By authority, I mean literally responsibility.
84:15
Speaker A
Those two words are perfectly symmetric. You have a particular responsibility. Accept the responsibility that is given to you. Support other people in discerning what is their responsibility and holding the responsibility is given to them. That is a kingdom. And so we
84:28
Speaker A
have already in the image of Star Wars, we have three images. We have the image of the of the perpetual rebel. We have the image of the empire. But I would point out that we have also the image of
84:37
Speaker A
the kingdom and that's not something that we've seen in the I I I produced an AI version of the image that Elon Musk quoted just saying, "Hey, give me a a higher thorian aesthetic." And and by the way, the first one he
84:50
Speaker A
gave me, they still they were dressed differently. I said, "No, no, their faces need to reflect that they are anointed by the living God. That's what it means to be a kingdom." And their faces changed, right? They're actually
85:00
Speaker A
happy with what they're doing. And there's a beauty. There's something, you know, there's there's something about the kind of aesthetic of of let's just say Nazis, right? The Nazi aesthetic, the Hugo Boss aesthetic, which is the empire aesthetic, right? The same one,
85:12
Speaker A
the imperial aesthetic that has a a quality to it which you can it can be appealing. There's a quality there's an appeal to that quality. It is is clean.
85:24
Speaker A
It's got clean lines, right? It has has well, I mean, it's the it's just the quality of the masculine moving towards the dark masculine. And there's a beauty to that in a certain way.
85:34
Speaker A
Interesting enough, if you flip it and you look at the perpetual rebel, you get the you get the cat lady, right? You get the and I don't mean the old lady who has cats. I mean the lady who's done so
85:44
Speaker A
much work that she starts to look hideous through the lens of something that's supposed to look beautiful. I actually use Jennifer Lawrence as the as the absolute epitome of that right now.
85:54
Speaker A
Yeah, that's the image that pops to mind. She's no longer actually fulfilling her proper calling. She is seeking to take under her own power an image of beauty which anybody who looks at her is good. Well, anybody who looks
86:06
Speaker A
at her who is honest will say actually no, you don't look anywhere near as good as you used to look.
86:10
Speaker A
Yeah, you do look maybe more like an image of beauty, but that image of beauty we all kind of intuitively know you're going to end up just being a crazy cat lady in not too long from now. It's it's
86:19
Speaker A
actually precursor to absolute hideousness. And we're all those of us who like ah that feels really terrible to see somebody make the choice to go in that direction. But you can get why. So if you Jennifer Lawrence is the
86:30
Speaker A
aesthetic on one side and I don't know like the the Imperial Stormtrooper is the aesthetic on this side or the star destroyer. I'm trying to figure out what's the exact Yeah.
86:38
Speaker A
Right. One there's a there's a there's a introduction of intentionality into into the production and a little bit of it is cool like the Hugo Boss like the the design there's a designer thing to it and it's actually cool in the most
86:53
Speaker A
fundamental sense of that word. Huh? Remember remember cool was coined. Cool is a term.
86:58
Speaker A
Yeah. Right. Cool. Cool. And and think about cool in terms of cold. Yeah. Cool. Cool is detached.
87:04
Speaker A
Yes. Cool is cool is not connected to the the biological the cycle. Biological. It's not connected to the yman. It's not connected to the soil.
87:13
Speaker A
It's not connected to the mother. It's not connected to the um you know the the happy family. It's not a wholesome cool is kind of stepping back. Yeah. looking at it and being able to use that remove to reinject something that conveys
87:27
Speaker A
something that produces more power. That's what cool does. So, you got to be cool. Why do you got to be cool? Because by being cool, you can be more powerful in a really subtle way, right? You're more sexy. You have more ability to be
87:39
Speaker A
intimidating. There all, you know, that's what cool is. That's why cool is invented. Yeah.
87:42
Speaker A
Um Yeah. Yeah. Which leads us to to your massive tweet about the Gen X. Um, what the Han Solo aesthetic cuz he's cool. I mean, he's literally like the coolest guy. I mean, in both sense of the word, he's like, "Wow, the
87:57
Speaker A
adventure guy, but he's also detached until he gets frozen in carbonite." Yeah. Well, what happens? What's I mean, what's what is the hero's journey of Han Solo? What is his journey? What what what calls him to move from the image of
88:10
Speaker A
being the cynical, disaffected rebel, the rogue, is in fact love. He feels actual love. Not just for Leia.
88:18
Speaker A
He feels love for Luke, right? There's a there's an actual human relationship that is created that binds Hold on, man. I got to call him.
88:28
Speaker A
Cat or cell phone. Okay. Um, sorry about that. That's fine. And that's what changes. That's the transformation, right? The the the narrative transformation is the saying is a is an ability to participate in something that is transcendent, right?
88:41
Speaker A
He actually lifts up from a position in the world of power where he's like, I will not participate in the world with power. I will simply play within the edges of it. I will make my I will be
88:52
Speaker A
free. I will have my own choices, my own and I I'll play in the gray area, but I will I'll be neither black nor white.
88:58
Speaker A
Play in the gray area because I'm not playing the game of power. Mhm. And he doesn't choose to enter into the game of power from a position of securing power. He actually participates in the transcendent. And by virtue of
89:08
Speaker A
participating in the transcendent, he allows that transcendent to actualize itself in reality more and more fully in his own life, right? He actually gets the girl. He he you marries. So now, of course, the uh both the boomers and the
89:21
Speaker A
Gen Z can't help but try to destroy that narrative, right? The the third trilogy is remember he he and Lee are now uh divorced, angry at each other. The son is turned against the father. Like that's just you have to destroy that
89:35
Speaker A
character in the in the current narrative. can't allow a true you can't allow Adysius to return home. Now, you can't allow Aragorn to become the king.
89:43
Speaker A
Um, that's where that's the character arc of Han Solo is the restoration of proper authority. And what's interesting about it is that he's more he's Catus, right? He's not he's not supposed to be the king. He's not supposed to be the
89:55
Speaker A
emperor. He's the one whose simple ordinary human decision to actually allow proper authority to flow through him and to just believe in the transcendent and act that out at whatever level of sacrifice he's called to make.
90:11
Speaker A
Allows the rest of the world to begin to reorder itself properly, whatever that may be.
90:16
Speaker A
Um, so that's his character. And and by the way, in in my massive tweet, I point out that there's like a a a profound basic mythology that's in the the Anakin story, the the Boomer Gen Z or probably
90:30
Speaker A
millennial boomer story, which is the story of the the Titans. And you have the basic dynamic, which is the dynamic of power. Once you're in power, this is how the dynamic works.
90:41
Speaker A
The father as he grows older, he sees his son as a threat to his power because he's waning and the son is growing. And at a certain point, the son will take over. And when he does, he will be
90:52
Speaker A
usurped. His power will be taken away. And so, what does the father do? The father tries to destroy the son. He tries to trap him or kill him or neuter him. And so, there's a a rebellion. The rebellion is the rebellion of the titans
91:04
Speaker A
against Kronos. The Titans then, of course, know that the rebellion is coming for them. And so you now try to take the the Olympians and prevent them from being able to do their thing. The Olympians escape. They attack and
91:14
Speaker A
overthrow their fathers. And just a cycle of that dynamic. And that's the story that's being told in the Sithpilled narrative.
91:22
Speaker A
The sons of the boomers, the children of the boomers see for real finally. Oh, you were just playing a power game. You usurp the power of your parents, your fathers, by characterizing them as the evil authority, man, clownishly evil bad guys, the
91:38
Speaker A
Nazis, the only image your poor impoverished mythology even has. Therefore, casting yourselves as the good guys, establishing your power, and then you're telling a narrative that tells nobody else's the power is actually bad. Don't touch power, but we
91:50
Speaker A
actually have the power. We're never going to give it up, but yeah, it's bad.
91:53
Speaker A
Don't worry, we'll we'll take care of it for you. And as we rise up, we have a choice. We either have to be powerless and simply suffer the consequences of being powerless, which is to say in Anakin narrative, our mother's killed,
92:05
Speaker A
our wife is our wife dies. Like we actually suffer the inability to live just an ordinary life. Or we choose to step back into the cycle, usurp, take that power back and and conquer you.
92:16
Speaker A
And and what I say in that in that in that post is there is another story. The story does not come from paganism. The pagan cycle and many different pagan mythologies has basically the Kronos Titan Olympian story. Um the Christian
92:30
Speaker A
story has the story of the prodigal son and the story of the prodigal son.
92:34
Speaker A
You have a father who didn't usurp power. The father simply is the source of power and that power is a is a is a power that flows outward in continuous self-giving planitude. That's the actual anchoring mythology. There's no
92:50
Speaker A
narrative in the in the Christian story of a father who had to kill his father to take power. God did not struggle with anyone. He just simply created out of self-giving plenitude.
93:00
Speaker A
And then the prodigal the father in the prodical son obviously an allegory. His son betrays him. Right? It's not the father trying to impose himself on the son. The son chooses to leave proper order. He he becomes a rebel. A rebel
93:14
Speaker A
against a a well-ordered reality. He, you know, he takes the inheritance, which is effectively saying kills his father. That's how you get an inheritance is your father dies. Yeah.
93:22
Speaker A
He breaks his relationship. He leaves. And then, of course, what does he do? He wastes it like the boomers, by the way.
93:28
Speaker A
He spends it on complete selfishness. He clads himself in any any amount of of sensual uh salience. And then he ends up living in the pigsty covered in filth.
93:38
Speaker A
Finally, when he reaches a level of humility, he returns with nothing. He returns with no power. the absolute uh lack of power. But the father does not impose himself on him at all. Instead, the father welcomes him with love has
93:52
Speaker A
him, you know, completely cleaned, wrapped in purple robes, and fed a feast like a fattened calf because that's completely the inverse of the pagan story, right? In the in the Christian narrative, the the love is the ground of
94:04
Speaker A
reality and that love needs nothing other so it can give and it does give.
94:10
Speaker A
And that's a wholly different story arc. And that's, you know, I said that's if you look at what's governing the story of Han Solo who's so interesting in the story because he's not a main character.
94:20
Speaker A
He kind of fits in this interesting gap where a lot of it, you know, the deeper reality, the narrative that is not the narrative that George Lucas or Disney can control has can break through. The light comes through the cracks
94:31
Speaker A
and you see, oh, that's right. As soon as his life becomes governed by love, it begins to become move moves towards proper order. And he can now provide that proper order back out into the field of of the reality he's engaged in.
94:42
Speaker A
And that does things like saves Luke's life so Luke can then fulfill his proper role as being the one who destroy, you know, the pieces all start coming back together.
94:51
Speaker A
Yeah. Yeah. The uh prodal son story, like most of Jesus's stories, has a little hitch with that. The brother who didn't go away, the resentful one.
95:02
Speaker A
Resentful brother. Yeah, that's right. What's up with that? Where does that fit in into our story?
95:09
Speaker A
This is very much like the distinction between the state and the nation. The resentful brother is resentful because he plays the game according to the law.
95:20
Speaker A
He plays the game according to the letter of the law and he thinks therefore that he should be the one who is rewarded. It's like, hey, I did the thing you're supposed to do. Think about this in terms of you of operating under
95:33
Speaker A
your own understanding. Saying, hey, I am assuming authority on the basis of my power. I have played a role. I played the role of the beautiful son and I played that role. Well, this guy over here, this Yahoo did not play the role
95:48
Speaker A
of the beautiful son. He violated the role of the beautiful son. And what's the what the narrative is saying is that it's never been the letter of the law.
95:54
Speaker A
It's always been the spirit of the law. M it's always been what's the underlying reality. So because the son himself at the very bottom had assumed two things.
96:04
Speaker A
One his power was what mattered. Him dotting the eyes crossing the tees playing the state looking through the lens of the state that he was therefore deserved. He was owed stuff as a consequence of playing the game by the
96:19
Speaker A
rules that he understood and then also adopting an attitude of resentment when that was violated. Now, this is a very complex thing. This is also playing a little bit in terms of the energy of what's happening in the Anakin story.
96:30
Speaker A
It's like, hey, and they even say it explicitly, we played the way the game the way it was supposed to be played. We followed the order of the law and we were not given the rewards that we were
96:38
Speaker A
promised. We are now resentful. They are literally fulfilling that character almost letter by letter. But what what the story is telling you is think about like you constantly see in scripture the idea of like Jacob and Asa where you have the
96:52
Speaker A
the law says the first born should be the inheritor of the father but God selects the second born. What that's telling us is there's the continuous story that there's a deeper narrative that you get to when you understand and
97:05
Speaker A
surrender to the spirit of the law and you can actually be governed by that.
97:10
Speaker A
Right? Back to deeper humility. Imagine if the if the if the second brother was just humble and he just went to his dad with contrition and said, "Father, I'm confused.
97:20
Speaker A
My heart is broken. I'm sad. I don't understand. Like this feels very wrong to me. Please help me understand." Yeah. If if we all act like if he took the canteen with imperatives like if everybody acted like my brother, it
97:31
Speaker A
would destroy everything. Why are we celebrating that? Exactly. He took the contain approach which is to say he took the there is a law an objective law tries to fill the space of the transcendent with the objective and he said hey there's a law it's very
97:47
Speaker A
clear he violated it what are you doing rewarding him you're violating the law yeah and the father's saying no the law is more fundamental than the letter there's something much deeper than that from which the letter of the law is an
97:58
Speaker A
artifact back to our story about blood and soil blood and soil is not the nation if you have a nation you will have a place, you will have a people. Yes, they that would be they'll be there, but
98:09
Speaker A
we'll see them as the consequence like the the data exhaust of a nation, not the constituency. And the same thing is happening here. There's something going on with the governing of love and the recognition of, for example, everything's particular.
98:21
Speaker A
You know, the father would go to this the first the second son and say, "Yes, I love you and you've been given my love continuously in our relationship because you're you. He's him." Love plays out the way it plays out. Do you can you not
98:34
Speaker A
see that everything that's happening is governed fundamentally by the nature of love? The second time I go like maybe yeah okay I get that that's true. Can you now love your brother? Now this is a very difficult thing to do obviously.
98:48
Speaker A
Obviously this is why it's the you know one of the foundational stories that keeps showing up.
98:53
Speaker A
Um but I think that's the key to that to that piece of the story. I'm trying to I'm trying to I'm trying to find answers here, Jordan, which I'm joking because you can't find answers, but I'm thinking in
99:06
Speaker A
terms of certainly not in the podcast. No, not one. Maybe maybe with the course. Like and subscribe, please. Um maybe if you made a subscription podcast. Maybe if you made a subscription gated it and really increase the production values,
99:19
Speaker A
then answers would flirt. Come on. You don't like these production values. Um, if if we're reaching the end of modernity, we're looking for the father. We really are. That's what I've been what I've been seeing with the reaction to the
99:35
Speaker A
dissonant right and what the dissonant right are look what what the right is looking for is authority. What the the neocons or whatever th those guys who just are reacting to the words Christian nationalism, they're basically feminists. They just react to words um
99:50
Speaker A
on a visceral level. you're like, you're not even seeing what's going on. But they're reacting, too. They they don't they don't want authority. They think that power is bad and authority and power are the same thing. And so, if we
100:01
Speaker A
just have procedure, then then that will figure the whole thing out. And that that's a byproduct of of a missing God. It's a my it's a byproduct of a disconnection to that father figure in our past somewhere like like we as a nation as as
100:18
Speaker A
a as a culture as a civilization think of of thinking the west as a whole is going further and further into the pigsty. We don't even know if we have a home. That's what these guys these kids are looking for with these memes.
100:32
Speaker A
They're looking for like that that looks like home. like it looks like a dark home and it's funny but it looks like home. I want home again, you know, and and what you're trying to say and what we're trying to say, what
100:43
Speaker A
we're trying to emulate. I think it's like no, there's there's a me as somebody's older than you, I can I can spend all day like like clutching pearls about Nick Fuentes and he'll just react more and more in his direction.
100:58
Speaker A
Whether he's fake or not, he's going to react more and more in that direction.
101:01
Speaker A
But if I love him, if I say that's funny guy, but are you thinking about this way and that way?
101:07
Speaker A
You know, if you come alongside him and if you take him, if you're a rather, if you're more of an uncle and you're not trying to impose anything on him and you're like, well, look at the landscape's much greater than you. Like
101:20
Speaker A
Nick Nick's story is really interesting and I think he I don't know if he's fake or not but like he he ran into this Israel thing with Ben Shapiro is just that Nick was nobody and Ben Shapiro just like started going after him and
101:32
Speaker A
made him somebody and so Nick just went in and then over the past year with Tucker and everything like everybody reacts to Nick. But if you listen to him, he's supremely gifted and like if he just had if he had
101:44
Speaker A
a home, he wouldn't need to be reactionary. But he's a comedian, so he's going to be reactionary whether you like it or not, you know? But like he's comedy is a real thing.
101:53
Speaker A
Yeah. He's emomatic of these young men. There's a reason why he's got so much traction with these young men and they're looking for fatherhood. They're looking for for us to step in. Us meaning like our generation to emulate
102:06
Speaker A
them. Yeah. Well, this you know it's um or to lead them to that house of God.
102:16
Speaker A
We you can go back. We have to create a a kingdom. And by that I mean because if we don't there's only two possibilities. Either they will create a empire or everything will just go away. That's it. There's like the the thing that's on
102:34
Speaker A
the other side of empire is just death. Um, empire is the use of power to produce something that prevents death. I think maybe that's what Teal's talking about. I'm not sure.
102:46
Speaker A
Um, but there's a kingdom. That's a real thing. Now, this has happened before. There there have been moments in the in the history of the West where the West was faced with existential threat. You I'm thinking about like Martell, Charles Martell, and
103:01
Speaker A
the, you know, the the Muslims coming up. They just tore through North Africa. They tore through the all of the ancient Roman kingdoms all the way through Spain. They came to southern France and then it was stopped. And then an entire
103:14
Speaker A
700 years is a long [ __ ] time. Uh an entire capacity to respond was produced and that response began to actually mature and develop and push back. Right?
103:24
Speaker A
So for example, um or the the emergence of the the crusader archetype, the notion of hey, we have a an archetype, a mythological archetype of a knight. We have a mythological archetype of a monk. What does it look like if we try to combine
103:41
Speaker A
those two together? And I don't mean like the the crusading armies at large. I mean specifically the crusader knight, the templar for example. And the point being that that's it. That's kind of like onlogical discovery. There are there are archetypes or possibly even
103:57
Speaker A
more fundamental things than that that exist in reality that we can identify and participate in that are available for moments such as these. Certainly the basic model of the you know the different forms of the king. You know I
104:10
Speaker A
think Yarvin is correct in the sense that we need to have kings. We just need to know what kings are know how to operate kings properly.
104:17
Speaker A
That's a really powerful thing to discern. We say okay what does that look like? you know, how how do we begin to orient towards, well, this person right here seems to be more able to wield authority correctly?
104:30
Speaker A
Yeah. What would it look like if we could pour more authority into that person recognizing that it's coming from from our own willingness to like a knight bowing the knight bends the knee to the queen in fact and then serves the king.
104:44
Speaker A
Mhm. It's a voluntary choice and it's not a strategic choice. Again, it's not a warlord. It's not a it's not a a thug binding himself to a warlord. It's something completely different because it's a recognition of proper authority.
104:57
Speaker A
And the recognition is reciprocal, right? The king binds the the the oath of filty goes both ways.
105:01
Speaker A
Yeah. The king has as much responsibility even more than the knight has going in that direction because he's responsible for the whole kingdom and would die to defend it. Right. So there's the kingdom is an extension of the king
105:13
Speaker A
and the king is an extension of the kingdom. They are they are body and soul. They are bound. If if God is with us yes nothing can stand against us.
105:21
Speaker A
Yeah, that's that's the key. That's the key thing. It's like, look, you don't get there by trying to figure out how to build a more effective war machine on the basis of a more effective strategy.
105:30
Speaker A
Many people are out there playing that game. And I assure you, young Padawan, they are more effective at every variation on that theme than you are.
105:38
Speaker A
But there is a whole different story. There's a story where you participate in something that is governed by the actual authority of reality. And once you're governed by that, which by the by by the way might lead to you dying, in fact
105:50
Speaker A
quite possibly will lead to you dying, but that's irrelevant because you're doing something that is so much more important and more meaningful. You're fully in service to to the king and that becomes nobility, right? You're actually able to participate in proper nobility
106:04
Speaker A
with proper valor, right? Just think about the the enobling of all of the different virtues as soon as they enter into that characteristic. You're no longer um governed by uh a berserker.
106:17
Speaker A
You're no longer a berserker. You have courage and valor, but you also have the ability to deploy mercy properly, which doesn't mean, by the way, stupidly you don't allow yourself to be exploited so that your mercy now becomes a way to
106:28
Speaker A
murder you. Yeah. Um but you have the ability to allow to allow mercy to be deployed. So it requires a radically higher level of nobility than I think is currently being looked for. But this is the weird thing.
106:42
Speaker A
That's the only real solution. Like you're not going to get to where you want to get to by operating through this mode. Like just playing again, trying to become a more effective player of the power game. The best you're going to
106:53
Speaker A
become is kind of a relatively influential grifter. Yeah, that's the best you're going to get to.
106:58
Speaker A
You're going to be feeding on the second or third uh track. May maybe you'll be able to find an exploit where you can become a really effective grifter like an investment banker or like the head of a you know major NGO or something like
107:08
Speaker A
that but that's not that's that's you're still serving a power that is more powerful than you buy a lot and ultimately it's a power that has no love in it right again it's a machine so you're serving a machine
107:22
Speaker A
that's a completely you've lost even though you may have won something local you've lost something globally so that's the as far as I can tell that's what's happening We we go through these cycles when a when a world ends.
107:34
Speaker A
We enter into a new moment, a new possibility. And in this particular case, there's at least two and maybe three worlds that are ending, each at an order of magnitude bigger. You've got the World War II world. It's ending. But
107:46
Speaker A
you got the modernity world. It's ending too. That's a lot bigger world. That's an entire half a millennium of of time. But we may actually be, for example, just call it like the literacy world, right?
107:56
Speaker A
The world of civilization built on the notion of writing. Yeah. And and all the other things that are downstream of that, there's lots of other things that are downstream. Like say accounting, there's a lot of stuff in that structure, but just call it like
108:06
Speaker A
there's a a hundred-year world, a thousand-y year world, maybe it's a 10,000-year world. And I think it's it is that's ending. So, you know, sometimes you Sunday comes every week, but some Sundays are Easter.
108:19
Speaker A
There's a bigger vertical that's that's happening on that day. So, you know, we've got a a century mark, a thousand-y year mark, and a 10,000 year mark. And it's kind of all coming to do on this moment.
108:32
Speaker A
And so if you if you're kind of tapping into that, that changes the landscape.
108:36
Speaker A
Like, well, if we're just kind of like having a four-year political cycle and we're just kind of struggling from moving deck chairs around, that's one thing. But it's like, oh, I'm actually facing a 10,000-year moment. That's a you got to think differently about that.
108:48
Speaker A
That's a whole different register of how to behave. Jordan, I'm going to let you go. Uh, thank you so much for picking up uh conversation. talk about memes and the deeper things behind them. Um, where can people find you? What are they going to
109:03
Speaker A
find when they get there for definitely don't look for me, please? You always say that, but you you make just like the rest of us.
109:12
Speaker A
I really don't want you. I mean, I'll just I'll say this. I'll kind of like do the 4chan thing. Most people are very annoyed, right? So, all that happens when they come is they just annoy me.
109:23
Speaker A
What's the value of that? Like, I don't I don't want to interact with anybody. I don't want anybody interact with what I do. I don't really do anything. Like I'm I'm not like thinking about anything.
109:31
Speaker A
Sometimes I wake up when I write an essay and usually it's like 45 minutes like I didn't to you know whatever. If I hit publish you see typos in these things. I don't edit them. I just put them out there. Um if it's of value then
109:44
Speaker A
share it with other people that you think actually should would receive value from it. Like really think is this something that would orient like is this a a thing this this other person should have? like really governed by
109:56
Speaker A
relationship. So if if you find me, you're supposed to have found me and that's great. And then enter into that slowly and find out and and feel free to take anything that I have produced, but only try to actually use it to move
110:11
Speaker A
things more in the direction of the good as governed by proper authority. Um I have very little authority. That's not my role in this thing. My role in this thing is very much of a transition. Like I'm holding a space and helping people
110:24
Speaker A
move across as far as I can tell. Um and so please for the love of God do not point any attention at me.
110:31
Speaker A
How's fatherhood? Really hard. Fatherhood is beautifully beautifully hard. It's like the hardest thing you can possibly do. Particularly when you take it seriously.
110:39
Speaker A
Yeah. Like when you really know every single every single interaction you have with your children. I don't know if the world knows but I have an 18-month old son now. um is is is eternal, right? It it leaves a real
110:53
Speaker A
trace and you'll never be equal to the responsibility that's been put on top of you and you have to continue every day to just like endeavor to step into that reality and receive the beauty of it and also receive the unbelievable harrowing
111:06
Speaker A
of who you are continuously. Um but it's the weirdest thing, right? Uh I feel really really really sad for people who have not participated in fatherhood.
111:19
Speaker A
It's you're not actually participating in life. It may not be easy, but that's not the gig. My life is not supposed to be easy.
111:30
Speaker A
Jordan, God bless you. Thank you very much for coming on. You're good, brother. See you next time you call me.
111:36
Speaker A
Yeah. Oh, I will.
Topics:Star WarsJordan HallBenjamin BoyceBoomer ZoomerAnakin Skywalker memeJ.J. AbramsAI and artfantasy vs science fictionmodernitynationalism

Get More with the SozAI App

Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries and speaker detection. 30 minutes free.

Or transcribe another YouTube video here →