Family Dinner Ends in Brutal Massacre | True Crime Docu… — Transcript

[Music] Easter Sunday in 1975 started off as a normal Easter holiday for the Ruppert family but soon turned into a nightmare that is now dubbed the deadliest family massacre in American history. Stay tuned as we uncover how a seemingly harmless man managed to murder 11 members of his family. James Urban Ruppert was born on March 29th, 1934, to his mother Charity and father Leonard Ruppert. He, along with his older brother Leonard Jr., grew up in Hamilton, Ohio. However, their small family was far from normal, as Leonard senior, who was known to have a violent temper, made his children's childhood traumatic. To make matters worse, Charity picked her favorites when the boys were still young, always favoring her brighter and more confident older child Leonard over her younger son James. He grew up in a hostile environment and was often told by his mother that she wished he was never born since she wanted a daughter in his place. As expected from a child who grew up without parental affection, this negatively impacted Ruppert's self-confidence, and he grew up to become a loner. His parents' carelessness constantly cost him, including his father's insistence on keeping chickens around their house, causing him to develop an allergy to the feathers. Despite his allergy, his parents showed little to no concern for his well-being as they continued to keep the chickens around. When Ruppert turned 12 in 1947, his father became deathly ill and soon died of tuberculosis. However, his days of torment were far from over, as his older brother quickly took over their father's role and went out of his way to harass his younger brother. As a result, Ruppert's performance in school was severely lacking compared to his brother. With no friends to offer him any support, Ruppert found himself dealing with everything on his own as Charity continued to ignore his existence. The constant bullying at home and school got so bad that at the age of 16, Ruppert decided to end things once and for all. He took sheets from his home and tried to hang himself; however, he failed to succeed in his suicidal attempt. This marked an important event in Ruppert's life, as he stopped making any effort towards improving his life and accepted his fate as the inferior son. This became Ruppert's first and only suicide attempt. Not surprisingly, Ruppert grew to hate both his brother and mother. By the time he reached college, he stood at 5'6" and only weighed 135 pounds. He spent two years in college before giving up on it as well, while his brother once again surpassed him and graduated with a degree in electrical engineering. It helped that Leonard Jr. had his mother's full support. His resentment towards his brother grew to a dangerous level when Leonard Jr. married one of Ruppert's former girlfriends named Elma, a girl that he never lost feelings for. This would later be cited as a motive for his rampage. Ruppert began to feel as if the entire world was against him and resigned himself to an unremarkable life, accepting defeat. He trained to become a draftsman but remained unemployed for the majority of his life, leaving him with no choice but to continue living with his mother, often borrowing money from her and Leonard Jr. While his brother not only managed to get a job with General Electric, he also bought a house in Fairfield where he lived with Elma and their eight children: 17-year-old Leonard III, 16-year-old Michael, 15-year-old Tom Thomas, 13-year-old Carol, 12-year-old Ann, 11-year-old David, 9-year-old Teresa, and 4-year-old JN. Perhaps because he was so frustrated with his life, Ruppert developed an affinity for guns. Among his collection, he had a .357 Magnum, two .22 handguns, and a .22 rifle. Two things became ritual for Ruppert: drinking and target practicing. Ruppert had turned to drinking to deal with the toxic environment at home as well as to numb his feelings of inferiority. As he got older and remained unemployed, Charity, tired of his drinking, threatened to evict him unless he paid rent. However, since he had lost all of his money during the stock market crash of 1973 to 1974, Ruppert had no way to pay his portion of the rent. Although Charity intended for this threat to motivate him to get his life back on track, she unknowingly pushed him towards his breaking point. As the threat of eviction loomed over his head, Ruppert began to approach his breaking point. While purchasing ammunition one day, he inquired about silencers but did not end up going through with the purchase. On March 29th, 1975, Ruppert turned 41. On his birthday, he was seen at the Great Miami River in Hamilton shooting cans, and this became pivotal in helping the prosecution build their case against him. It can be argued that he was possibly preparing for one of the deadliest nights in Hamilton, Ohio. That night, Ruppert stumbled into a bar called the 19th Hole Cocktail Lounge. He met 28-year-old mother of five Wanda Bishop, who worked at the cocktail lounge, and confessed that his mother was threatening to evict him if he failed to find a job to pay for his portion of the rent. Charity had told him that if he could afford to pay for his drinks, he could pay her rent as well. Wanda recalled that Ruppert insisted that he had to find a way to solve the problem. Ruppert stayed in the cocktail lounge until 11:00 p.m. before leaving but soon returned and continued drinking until the lounge closed at 2:30 a.m. When Wanda asked him if he had managed to resolve his problem, Ruppert replied, "No, not yet." The next morning, Charity, who was not feeling well, called Leonard Jr. and his family for Easter dinner instead of an early lunch at their house, 635 Minor Avenue. Once Leonard Jr. and Elma arrived, their children participated in an Easter egg hunt outside while Ruppert slept in late, nursing a hangover from the previous night. By the time he got up at 4:00 p.m., everyone had moved inside to continue the celebration. While Charity prepared sloppy joes for the family and Elma helped put them together, Ruppert stayed with the family for a short while before returning upstairs to retrieve a .357 Magnum, two .22 handguns, and a rifle. He intended to head to a shooting range to spend his day, but as he was leaving, his brother asked him, "How's the Volkswagen?" Ruppert took this as an insult, as Leonard Jr.'s comments reminded him of his own failure to lead a successful life like his brother. Instead of leaving for the shooting range as planned, Ruppert made a split-second decision that not only altered the trajectory of his life forever but also robbed 11 people of their lives. At 6 p.m., Charity, Leonard, Elma, their son David, and daughters Teresa and Carol, who were in the kitchen, became Ruppert's first victims as he fired off several shots in rapid succession, hitting all of them in the chest except for his mother, whom he shot in the head as she jumped at him to try and prevent him from killing anyone else. He then moved to the living room where he shot his niece Ann, Leonard III, Michael, and John. After his initial shots, Ruppert went around and shot everyone several more times to make sure that they were dead. After the initial shooting, if people were moaning and groaning still, he shot them in the head. The entire ordeal took less than five minutes, with Ruppert only stopping in the middle to reload. All in all, he fired 44 shots, out of which 40 hit the victims. After making sure that everyone was dead, Ruppert sat with his family's dead bodies for three hours contemplating suicide but decided that since it was a mortal sin, he did not want it to be his last act. After three hours, he decided to make a 911 call. He told the 911 dispatcher that there had been a shooting. As his relatives took their last breaths around him, Ruppert sat on the couch. He waited there for three to four hours before he called police to tell them someone's been shot. When officers arrived at the scene a few minutes later, Ruppert greeted them at the front door. At first glance, the officers did not suspect that anything sinister was waiting for them beyond the front door since Ruppert, with his short stature and thick black-framed glasses, did not...

seemingly harmless man managed to murder 11 members of his family James Urban Rupert was born on March 29th 1934 to his mother charity and father Leonard Rupert he along with his older brother Leonard Jr grew up in Hamilton

Ohio however their small family was far from normal as Leonard senior who was known to have a violent temper made his children's childhood traumatic to make matters worse charity picked her favorites when the boys were still young always favoring her brighter and more

confident older child Leonard over her younger son James grew up in a hostile environment and was often told by his mother that she wished he was never born since she wanted a daughter in his place as expected from a child who grew up

without parental affection this negatively impacted Rupert's selfconfidence and he grew up to become a loner his parents' carelessness constantly cost him including his father's insistence on keeping chickens around their house causing him to develop an allergy to the feathers

despite his allergy his parents showed little to no concern for his well-being as they continued to keep the chickens around when rert turned 12 in 1947 his father became deathly ill and soon died of tuberculosis however his days of Torment

were far from over as his older brother quickly took over their father's role and went out of his way to harass his younger brother as a result Rupert's performance in school was severely lacking as compared to his brother with

no friends to offer him any support Rupert found himself dealing with everything on his own as Charity continued to ignore his existence the constant bullying at home in school got so bad that at the age of 16 Rupert

decided to end things once and for all he took sheets from his home and tried to hang himself however he failed to succeed in his suicidal attempt this marked an important event in Rupert's life as he stopped making any effort towards

improving his life and accepted his fate as the inferior son this became Rupert's first and only suicide attempt not surprisingly Robert grew to hate both his brother and mother by the time he reached College he stood at 5' 6 in and

only weighed 135 lb he spent two years in college before giving up on it as well while his brother once again surpassed him and graduated with a degree in electrical engineering it helped that Leonard Jr had his mother's

full support his resentment towards his brother grew to a dangerous level when Leonard Jr married one of Rupert's former girlfriends named Elma a girl that he never lost feelings for this would later be cited as a motive for his

Rampage Rupert began to feel as if the entire world was against him and resigned himself to an unremarkable life accepting defeat he trained to become a draftsman but remained unemployed for the majority of his life leaving him with no choice but to continue living

with his mother often borrowing money from her and Leonard Jr while his brother not only managed to get a job with General Electric he also bought a house in Fairfield where he lived with Alma and their eight children

17-year-old Leonard III 16-year-old Michael 15-year-old Tom Thomas 13-year-old Carol 12-year-old an 11 years old David 9-year-old Teresa and 4-year-old JN perhaps because he was so frustrated with his life rert developed an affinity for guns among his collection he had a

357 Magnum two 22 handguns and a 22 rifle two things became ritual for Rupert drinking and Target practicing Rupert had turned to drinking to deal deal with the toxic environment at home as well as to numb his feelings of

inferiority as he got older and remained unemployed charity tired of his drinking threatened to evict him unless he paid rent however since he had lost all of his money during the stock market crash of 1973 to 1974 Rupert had no way to pay his

portion of the rent although charity intended for this threat to motivate him to get his life back on track she unknowingly pushed him towards his Breaking Point as the threat of eviction loomed over his head Rupert began to

approach his Breaking Point while purchasing ammunition one day he inquired about silencers but did not end up going through with the purchase on March 29th 1975 ruper turned 41 on his birthday he was seen at the great Miami River in

Hamilton shooting cans and this became pivotal in helping the prosecution build their Cas against him it can be argued that he was possibly preparing for one of the deadliest nights in Hamilton Ohio that night Rupert stumbled into a

bar called the 19th Hole cocktail lounge he met 28-year-old mother of five Wanda Bishop who worked at the cocktail lounge and confessed that his mother was threatening to evict him if he failed to find a job to pay for his portion of the

rent charity had told him that if he could afford to pay for his drinks he could pay her rent as well Wanda recalled that rert insisted that he had to find a way to solve the problem Rupert stayed in the cocktail lounge

until 11:00 p.m. before leaving but soon returned and continued drinking until the lounge closed at 2:30 a.m. when Wanda asked him if he had managed to resolve his problem Rupert replied no not yet the next morning charity who was

not feeling well called Leonard Jr and his family for Easter dinner instead of an early lunch at their house 635 minor Avenue once Leonard Jr and Alma arrived their children participated in an Easter egg hunt outside while Rupert slept in

late nursing a hangover from the previous night by the time he got up at 400 p.m. everyone had moved inside to continue the celebration while charity prepared Sloppy Joe's for the family and Elma helped put them together Rupert stayed with the family for a

short while before returning upstairs to retrieve a 357 Magnum 222 handguns and a rifle he intended to head to a shooting range to spend his day but as he was leaving his brother asked him how's the Volkswagen Rupert took this as an insult

as Leonard Jr's comments reminded him of his own failure to lead a successful life like his brother instead of leaving for the shooting range as planned Ruppert made a split-second decision that not only altered the trajectory of his life forever but also robbed 11

people of their lives at 6: p.m. charity Leonard Elma their son David and daughters Tessa and Carol who were in the kitchen became ruppert's first victims as he fired off several shots in Rapid succession hitting all of them in

the chest except for his mother whom he shot in the head as she jumped at him to try and prevent him from killing anyone else he then moved to the living room where he shot his niece Anne Leonard

iiii Michael and John after his initial shots Rupert went around and shot everyone several more times to make sure that they were dead after the initial shooting and if people were moaning and groaning still he shot them in the head

the entire ordeal took less than 5 minutes with Ruppert only stopping in the middle to reload all in all he fired 44 shots out of which 40 hit the victims after making sure that everyone was dead Rupert sat with his family's

dead bodies for 3 hours contemplating suicide but decided that since it was a mortal sin he did not want it to be his last act after 3 hours he decided to make a 911 call he told the 911

dispatcher that there has been a shooting as his relatives took their last breaths around him rert s sat on the couch he waited there for 3 to 4 hours before he called police to tell them someone's been shot when officers

arrived at the scene a few minutes later Ruppert greeted them at the front door at first glance the officers did not suspect that anything Sinister was waiting for them beyond the front door since Rupert with his short stature and

thick black framed glasses did not fit into the usual description of a murderer as the officers entered the house they were in for the shock of a lifetime one of the responding officers also reported that he had never seen anything like the

crime scene before him and that he had to rush to the side to throw up there was so much blood on the floors that it had seeped through the wooden floorboards and was Dripping into the basement there was no sign of struggle

inside the house except for an overturned trash can indicating that because the family had not expected this they did not have enough time to react as the Hamilton Police Department was made aware of the shocking Discovery they immediately covered the area with

police tape as people began to gather around the small community that had known the Rupert family as a loving family was taken by surprise at the tragedy and was even more horrified to find that the helpful and modest man

they had known their whole lives was behind the murders the first body to leave the house was of little johon with his sneaker peeking out of the sheet drawn over him dread began to fill everyone as one by one 11 stretchers were brought

out of the house all carrying the now dead members of the Ruppert family will site was in two rooms of a modest two-story Hamilton Home where James rert lived with his mother in two rooms 11 bodies including Rupert's mother

Rupert's brother his brother's wife and their eight children the oldest 17 the youngest a four-year-old boy Rupert was arrested on the counts of 11 aggravated homicides Des despite being known as a demure but helpful man Rupert remained uncooperative with the officers and

refused to answer any of their questions investigators struggled to find a motive since the suspect in custody refused to say anything during the initial questioning it was made clear by Rupert that he planned on pleading Insanity the prosecutors

believed that Rupert planned on taking advantage of the $300,000 worth of inheritance left by both his brother and mother in the form of their properties and assets by pleading guilty he would serve time at a courta appointed facility before being

released and getting hold of The Inheritance this case led to two high-profile trials during the initial trial Rupert admitted to killing his family but pleaded Innocent by reason of insanity Rupert was represented by Hugh D Hol Brock who became so dedicated to

the case that he even personally funded the hiring of psychiatrists and psychologists from all over the country to testify in favor of Rupert's Insanity plea two psychiatrists who were brought on by his defense team concluded that Rupert suffered from paranoia and

delusions of persecution that were brought on by the beatings he had endured during his early life at the hands of his brother this is why they argued he had been unable to control his actions at the time of the crime Havard University

psychiatrist Dr Lester grinspoon supplied his expert opinion claiming that if more people were present in the house Rupert might have killed them as well pushing the narrative that Rupert did not have a solid motive other than Insanity after the slaughter James rert

changed his clothes and called the cops he was charged and tried for 11 murders his attorney said he killed during a psychotic rage they said he was insane along those same lines doctor isn't it true that you have no way of telling the

court what Mr Rupert's ability to rationally discuss the case with his attorneys to rationally assist in the preparation of a defense would be if he were not under the effect of either a major tranquilizer such as thorine or

trilon at this time isn't that right uh I have no specific way of telling that other than to say that on during the course of my examination with him he was able at that time and under that condition with that dosage of

medication to rationally confer with me and talk to me about what had happened at the same time the prosecution argued that Rupert planned to misuse the insanity plea to inherit the $300,000 inheritance he murdered his family to collect his brother's

$300,000 or so in life insurance that's what I think it's what I think the evidence should that's what I believe instead of having his case presented in front of a jury Rupert decided to have his case tried in front of three judges

however he was incorrectly told that all three of the judges would have to agree unanimously on a decision two out of the three judges found Rupert San and convicted him on 11 counts of aggravated murder he was sentenced to serve 11

consecutive life sentences during 1975 the United States had banned the death penalty saving Ruppert from being given a death sentence the third Hamilton County Judge Fred Kramer however found Ruppert insane between the years 1977 and 1978 the Supreme Court of Ohio ruled

that there had been a mistrial since the judges did not know whether they needed to unanimously agree on a decision or have a majority rule Rupert was granted another trial that was determined to be held in Finley Ohio since it was deemed

that he could not receive a fair trial in the city of Hamilton on July the 23rd 1975 the new trial began where Rupert and his defense team once again argued for the insanity plea however the prosecution led by John hulum brought

forward 29 Witnesses and presented 200 exhibits in court successfully building a different line of reasoning he argued that his inquiry into the silencers practicing his shooting and talking about his mother as a problem that needed to be resolved were all pointing

towards the fact that this mass murder was a carefully plotted crime especially given the fact that the shooting had been carried out at a time when the church bells had begun ringing hence drowning out the noise from the gunshots

preventing anyone from calling the authorities he went on to say that Rupert planned on aiming for the insanity plea because that would ensure that he would be sent to the Lima a state mental hospital where he would eventually be declared

sane this would allow him to easily inherit the $300,000 worth of inheritance left behind by Leonard and charity which he would not be able to do if he was convicted of murder based on the prosecution's convincing argument Rupert

was once again sentenced to 11 consecutive life sentences a few years later in 1982 on appeal Rupert was granted another trial where his defense attorney was able to convince the jury to Grant him an insanity plea Ruppert was charged with two counts of

first-degree murder for his brother and mother but found not guilty for the remaining nine counts of Murder By reason of insanity the only family member to attend the trial was Alma's mother Edna algy she blamed Rupert for 13 deaths

including her husband who took his own life three years after the incident on Easter day as well as a juror who collapsed during the trial and died of a heart attack when Edna passed away her headstone proclaimed that she was

preceded by eight grandchildren at the age of 48 Rupert was incarcerated by the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and correction at the Franklin Medical Center in Columbus 13 years later at the age of 61 Rupert was granted another parole hearing by the state parole board

but was denied release he was granted two more parole hearings one in 2005 and another one in 2015 during all of these parole hearings he was denied release during his last Hearing in 2015 the Allen Oakwood Correctional institutional parole board released a

statement that indicated that Rupert was not suitable for release due to his negative institutional conduct as well as a strong Community objection to his release 7 years later Rupert died at at the age of 88 of natural causes having

spent 47 years in prison a man who shot and killed 11 family members on Easter 1975 has died James rert died over the weekend at Franklin Medical Center in Columbus at the age of 88 the Hamilton Journal news says that he died of

natural causes the Ruppert family was buried in Arlington Memorial Garden in Cincinnati Ohio a year after the heinous mass murder the house was opened up to the public the Ruppert family's belongings were auctioned off and the hardwood floors

were covered with a carpet in places where blood stains were harder to remove the house was rented to a family who was unaware of The house's history as soon as they found out they moved out complaining of hearing strange voices

and other unexplained noises to this day the house remains occupied even today the Easter Sunday Massacre is remembered as one of the deadliest family massacres in America a book called the Easter Sunday Massacre a prosecutor's diary the true story of mass murderer James Rupert

written by the lead prosecutor John's daughter-in-law Karen hulham was published with the help of his notes left behind after his death Karen hokom first became familiar with this case in the 1990s when she was a reporter for The Journal News she didn't know at the

time that her coverage would lead to her marrying the prosecutor's son and and decades later taking her late father-in-law's words and crafting them into a book that details the trauma Left Behind after this tragedy what did you think of the case do you think Rupert

was eligible for the insanity plea or do you think that this was an elaborate plan that he had come up with after deciding that he was finally done accepting the abuse he had endured his entire life share your thoughts in the comments

below if you want more videos like this please be sure to like the video subscribe and hit the notification Bell so you don't miss out on more true crime videos see you in the next one