If someone claims ignorance for an act that someone in their position would typically not be ignorant of, their claim is not accepted, and they are considered a disbeliever. However, if their ignorance is plausible, they are given a chance to repent after being informed.
Yes, if someone grew up in a society where adultery was openly practiced and they genuinely did not know it was forbidden, they might be excused. This is because doubts can prevent the application of religious penalties, and a Muslim is not excommunicated from Islam based on mere suspicion.
People who grow up in environments where scholars adhere to a particular school of thought, like the Ash'aris, and are unaware of other schools like that of Ahl al-Sunnah, are considered ignorant. Their ignorance is a significant issue, and they may be excused because they genuinely believe their school represents the truth.
Transcribe recordings, audio files, and YouTube videos — with AI summaries, speaker detection, and unlimited transcriptions.
Or transcribe another YouTube video here →