Speaker A
The Virginia Supreme Court has just struck down a new congressional map that was passed by voters last month.
Virginia Supreme Court blocks new congressional map, dealing a major blow to Democrats' redistricting efforts ahead of midterms.
Key Takeaways
- Virginia Supreme Court ruling halts Democratic efforts to redraw congressional districts.
- Redistricting remains a highly contested and strategic battle ahead of the midterm elections.
- Republicans are aggressively pursuing redistricting to gain more House seats across multiple states.
- Voter-approved referendums and legislative actions represent contrasting methods of redistricting.
- The outcome of redistricting does not guarantee election results but significantly impacts political strategies.
Summary
- Virginia Supreme Court struck down a new congressional map approved by voters last month.
- The map was designed by Democrats to flip four Republican-held House seats.
- The court ruled the referendum violated the state's constitution, halting the new map.
- Democrats aimed to leverage suburban Washington DC areas to create favorable districts.
- Republican-led states like Florida, Tennessee, Louisiana, Alabama, and South Carolina are also redrawing maps to gain seats.
- Virginia’s referendum was voter-approved by a narrow margin of about three percentage points.
- Republicans have targeted 14 additional seats nationwide, while Democrats could pick up six.
- The redistricting battle reflects differing approaches: voter referendums in some states versus legislative control in others.
- The ruling is a significant setback for Democrats who invested heavily in persuading Virginia voters.
- The decision has drawn immediate political reactions, including from the President praising the ruling as a Republican win.
Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown
Speaker A
Democrats have proposed a new map with the hopes of flipping four Republican-held House seats.
Speaker A
And this is the latest battle in what's become this nationwide redistricting war. CNN's
Speaker A
Arlet Signs is here in the Situation Room. And Arlet, this is a big blow to Democrats.
Speaker A
Yeah, it really is. As Democrats had been hoping to shore up their efforts to try to reclaim
Speaker A
the majority, but this ruling from Virginia's state Supreme Court is a significant derailment of
Speaker A
those Democratic plans. Now, the Virginia State Supreme Court ruled that the creation of this
Speaker A
referendum that happened last month violated the state's constitution. Our team is still reading
Speaker A
through this opinion, but this certainly will be a major setback for Democrats going forward.
Speaker A
Democrats had drawn this map hoping to create an additional four seats for Democrats in next year's
Speaker A
Congress. They had kind of sliced up the more Democratic suburban areas of the
Speaker A
Washington DC area to make these districts that pinwheeled out into more rural areas.
Speaker A
But now, for the time being, this is prevented from going forward. This is made even more
Speaker A
complicated by the fact that we have seen so many Republican states swiftly moving over the
Speaker A
last week to redraw their maps. We've seen Florida and Tennessee pass measures to try to or to draw
Speaker A
their maps and gain more Republican seats. There are other efforts underway in Louisiana,
Speaker A
Alabama, and South Carolina as well. And so that really can potentially shift the way
Speaker A
that some of these House races are going to look heading into November. You know, Democrats are
Speaker A
really hoping that they can reclaim the majority. They feel that they have a lot of the political,
Speaker A
economic headwinds working in their favor. But certainly, this is a major setback in this
Speaker A
redistricting race as we've seen states across the country, Republican and Democrats, trying
Speaker A
to redraw their congressional maps to acquire more seats in what's going to be a
Speaker A
very close midterm election. And you're seeing a difference in how some of the states are doing it.
Speaker A
Like in Virginia, it was the voters, right, who voted for the redistricting. In other states,
Speaker A
you're seeing the legislature take the reins and do it themselves, right? And that's one thing the
Speaker A
Democrats have tried to argue is different from what they are doing compared to what some of
Speaker A
these Republican states have been doing. We saw California and Virginia come out with referendums
Speaker A
where their voters had to decide if they actually wanted to move this forward. And this was a very
Speaker A
close race that happened just a little over two weeks ago. I think that this passed by about
Speaker A
three percentage points. So, it's something that Virginia voters were very torn up about
Speaker A
but had decided to move forward with. But then we have seen more Republican-led states really
Speaker A
turn and try to just do this through their state legislators with Texas being the state that
Speaker A
really kicked off this whole redistricting battle last summer. It's a huge loss for Democrats who
Speaker A
spent tens of millions of dollars persuading Virginia voters to approve the new map. And it
Speaker A
comes one day after Tennessee's governor signed into law a new Republican gerrymander that breaks
Speaker A
up the only majority-black district in the state. Louisiana, Alabama, and South Carolina may soon
Speaker A
pass their own last-minute maps. So here's where that leaves the redistricting wars nationwide
Speaker A
right now. Republicans have targeted 14 extra seats. Democrats could pick up six. Theoretically,
Speaker A
it would be an eight-seat GOP advantage. But here's an important caveat. Just because a seat is
Speaker A
redrawn by Republicans or even Democrats doesn't mean it automatically goes that way, especially in
Speaker A
a year like this one. I'm joined by a terrific group of reporters here at the table. The
Speaker A
president did not waste much time crowing about this Supreme Court decision in Virginia. He said,
Speaker A
"Huge win for the Republican Party and America in Virginia. The Virginia Supreme Court has just
Topics:Virginia Supreme Courtredistrictingcongressional mapDemocratsRepublicansmidterm electionsgerrymanderingreferendumHouse seatspolitical strategy
