Speaker A
So, let's summarize what we've learned today.
Prof. Jiang Xueqin explores Western decline, attributing it to demographic shifts, economic policies, and the influence of wealthy pensioners on societal trends.
Key Takeaways
- Western societal and economic decline is multifaceted but heavily influenced by demographic changes.
- Rich pensioners benefit from and potentially drive many negative economic trends.
- Pension systems are under severe stress due to longer life expectancy and poor investment outcomes.
- Current economic policies and demographic shifts create growing inequality and threaten future stability.
- Understanding who benefits from systemic trends is crucial for analyzing societal problems.
Summary
- Western decline is marked by rising property prices, inflation, inequality, low economic growth, and bureaucratic gaslighting.
- Multiple theories explain these trends, including neoliberalism, techno-feudalism, world government conspiracies, population replacement, and bureaucratic incompetence.
- A key analytical approach is identifying who benefits from these trends, with rich pensioners identified as the primary beneficiaries.
- Older wealthy individuals benefit from rising property prices, stock market valuations, and mass immigration providing cheap labor.
- The aging population is unprecedented in human history, leading to increased resource accumulation and inequality.
- Pension systems were designed with outdated mortality assumptions, causing financial strain as people live longer.
- Pension funds suffer from poor investment returns and volatility, often losing money to more sophisticated financial actors.
- The ratio of retirees to workers is worsening, threatening the sustainability of pension systems globally.
- Young people are advised against relying on pension funds due to their declining value and insolvency risks.
- The demographic and economic challenges posed by an aging population have broad societal and financial implications.
Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown
Speaker A
Let's look at the signs of Western decline.
Speaker A
You've got higher property prices.
Speaker A
This happened throughout the Western world, inflation and lower quality of life.
Speaker A
Higher stock market valuations, which means greater inequality.
Speaker A
Less real economic growth, less and less people are doing real jobs.
Speaker A
Euthanasia for the poor, this killing off the poor people.
Speaker A
Mass immigration, population replacement.
Speaker A
Lower birth rate, greater public and private debt.
Speaker A
Bureaucratic gaslighting, when the government no longer acknowledges problems, it just lies to you directly.
Speaker A
And privatization, asset stripping, okay, so all this is happening in the Western world.
Speaker A
The question now is, why would this happen?
Speaker A
And there are different theories, okay?
Speaker A
And we'll go over some of the major theories.
Speaker A
Professor Jang is shifting from listing the visible symptoms of Western decline, like inflation and inequality, to exploring the competing theories that attempt to explain why these structural failures are occurring.
Speaker A
There's lots and lots of theories.
Speaker A
We'll go over the major ones, and there's some overlap between these theories.
Speaker A
And, um, some of these theories make a lot of sense.
Speaker A
So one major theory is the idea of neoliberalism.
Speaker A
The idea of neoliberalism is the belief that all that matters in society.
Speaker A
All that matters in life is economic growth.
Speaker A
If your society can generate more economic growth, all the problems will be solved.
Speaker A
Okay, so, so if your economy runs really fast, then everyone will be happy.
Speaker A
That's the idea of neoliberalism.
Speaker A
Then you have techno-feudalism, which is the idea that some big corporations.
Speaker A
Usually these tech companies, they want to control the world.
Speaker A
And so they want to turn everyone into slaves, and if you don't have a house, you don't have your own property.
Speaker A
Then you can be controlled by these companies, techno-feudalism.
Speaker A
World government, where the United Nations has this has this conspiracy to control the entire world.
Speaker A
To distort national sovereignty and create a world unified government, okay?
Speaker A
Uh, population replacement theory.
Speaker A
And the idea here is that the problem for governments in the Western world is that white people are opinionated.
Speaker A
They believe in democracy.
Speaker A
They believe in freedom.
Speaker A
And they're hard to control, so it's replaced the white people with Chinese and Indians and Filipinos.
Speaker A
Because Asian people are more obedient.
Speaker A
Right?
Speaker A
That's the idea.
Speaker A
And again, these are just theories, I'm not saying they're right or wrong.
Speaker A
And we'll go into these theories later on this semester.
Speaker A
Now, the last reason is bureaucratic incompetence.
Speaker A
It's just stupid.
Speaker A
Now, there is no overlap among these theories.
Speaker A
And there's some validity to all these theories.
Speaker A
But what I want to show you is that there's actually a much better way to analyze this.
Speaker A
Whenever you have a problem, you always ask yourself.
Speaker A
Who benefits?
Speaker A
Who is benefiting from this?
Speaker A
So we're talking about housing prices.
Speaker A
Well, clearly property owners are benefiting from this, right?
Speaker A
So if we took all the groups, okay, and there's like millions and millions of different groups in society.
Speaker A
We just analyze who benefits from all these trends that we discuss.
Speaker A
The answer you would get is rich pensioners.
Speaker A
These are the people who benefit the most from these trends.
Speaker A
And therefore, we can suspect that they're the ones behind these trends.
Speaker A
Okay?
Speaker A
So let's go over them.
Speaker A
Property prices make sense, right?
Speaker A
Because they're old, they have houses.
Speaker A
They probably have two or three houses.
Speaker A
So they want to see the property prices go up.
Speaker A
Higher stock market value just makes sense.
Speaker A
Because they own the most stocks.
Speaker A
Uphignation for the poor makes sense.
Speaker A
Because they want good medical care.
Speaker A
If poor people are standing in line, that's a problem for them, right?
Speaker A
So just kill the poor people and they'll have better access to health care.
Speaker A
If that frees up the health care system.
Speaker A
Mass immigration means cheap labor.
Speaker A
If they're old, they're seven or eight years old, they need gardeners.
Speaker A
They need cooks.
Speaker A
They need nurses.
Speaker A
Right?
Speaker A
Immigrants.
Speaker A
Do you guys want to be cooks and laborers?
Speaker A
You don't want to be.
Speaker A
So we have to bring in immigrants.
Speaker A
And everything else, okay, inflation, economic growth, lower birth rate, gaslighting.
Speaker A
It doesn't really affect them.
Speaker A
Doesn't make sense.
Speaker A
So all these trends, some of them are really good for these pensioners.
Speaker A
And the rest doesn't really affect the pensioners.
Speaker A
And that's why we can assume for analysis that's a rich pensioners who are most responsible for what's going on.
Speaker A
This doesn't make sense, you guys.
Speaker A
All right.
Speaker A
So how can we understand this?
Speaker A
Well, the problem that we're facing is never in human history have we had so many old rich people before.
Speaker A
Okay, and you can see these trends where in the year 1900.
Speaker A
People who are 75 and older were just a small fraction of society.
Speaker A
But you can see how fast they're growing.
Speaker A
Okay, 60, over 60 years old, really growing really fast.
Speaker A
There's a problem because if they keep on living, they accumulate more and more resources.
Speaker A
Which creates a lot more inequality.
Speaker A
Now, I'm not saying that all old people are rich.
Speaker A
In fact, that's not the case.
Speaker A
If you just look at statistics, you will find that wealth is pretty much evenly disputed.
Speaker A
Distributed among demographics, okay?
Speaker A
So there are young people with a lot of money, but there are more old people with money.
Speaker A
So there are lots and lots of old people, the purple are old people who are poor.
Speaker A
I'm not saying that old people are the problem.
Speaker A
I'm saying that old rich people are the problem.
Speaker A
They're problem because they want their pensions.
Speaker A
The pension systems in all societies made assumptions about old people.
Speaker A
The major assumption that they made is that old people would die, right?
Speaker A
So, for example, in Canada, when they first created the pension system, the retirement age was 65.
Speaker A
And they expected people to die when they're 72.
Speaker A
So you have five to seven years of a good pension.
Speaker A
Okay, guess what, guys?
Speaker A
They're not dying.
Speaker A
Right?
Speaker A
And that creates a huge problem with your pension plan.
Speaker A
And you can see how these liabilities are going up over time.
Speaker A
These are teachers and as you can see.
Speaker A
The liabilities are going way up.
Speaker A
Why is this happening?
Speaker A
It's happening because it's called assumption changes.
Speaker A
Okay, so two assumptions are being made.
Speaker A
First is that old people will die.
Speaker A
Well, they're not dying.
Speaker A
The other assumption is that if you put money in the stock market, it will year by year improve, right?
Speaker A
The problem is that there's volatility in the stock market.
Speaker A
It goes up and goes down.
Speaker A
And the smart people make money off dumb people.
Speaker A
Guess what, guys?
Speaker A
Okay, I'm going to ask you a question.
Speaker A
In finance, where do the dumbest people work?
Speaker A
You guys know?
Speaker A
In finance.
Speaker A
The dumbest people work where?
Speaker A
They work in pension funds.
Speaker A
Why?
Speaker A
Because it's a boring job.
Speaker A
You just sit there and do nothing all day.
Speaker A
So these pension funds are constantly getting ripped off from investment banks where the smart people are.
Speaker A
So if you look at all investment vehicles, pension funds have lost the most money.
Speaker A
And this has created huge issues within government pension funds throughout the world.
Speaker A
Okay, so as you can see, there's volatility in returns in the pension fund.
Speaker A
Okay, when you put the money in, the returns will differ year by year.
Speaker A
And that screws up your model.
Speaker A
If you're a young person, do not put money in the pension fund.
Speaker A
Why? Because the value of the pension fund is going drastically down.
Speaker A
When you grow up, when you mature and you retire, guess what, guys?
Speaker A
There's no money in the pension fund for you.
Speaker A
Because all that money is gone.
Speaker A
Why?
Speaker A
Because there are too many retirees and not enough workers.
Speaker A
Right, so back in the year 2001, you had a problem.
Speaker A
You had 7.6 retirees for every 12.7 workers.
Speaker A
This is you basically the idea is one to three.
Speaker A
So one pensioner, three workers.
Speaker A
That's a healthy pension system.
Speaker A
Now you have more pensioners, okay, than you have workers.
Speaker A
This is a huge problem.
Speaker A
These pensions will all go bankrupt in five to ten years time.
Speaker A
At the same time, as I said, all people are not dying.
Speaker A
In fact, all people are coming to dominate society.
Speaker A
This is America.
Speaker A
You can see how people are who are 85 and older.
Speaker A
Whoa, look at this.
Speaker A
Look at this.
Speaker A
The aging crisis in America is huge.
Speaker A
But this is not just America, it's everywhere.
Speaker A
Right?
Speaker A
He highlights a massive demographic inversion where the elderly population is rapidly outpacing the young globally. Do you think this shift inevitably leads to economic stagnation or is there a way out?
Speaker A
Drop your thoughts in the comments below.
Speaker A
So by the year 2040, you'll have 65 million people in America.
Speaker A
Who are over 65.
Speaker A
You have 15 million Americans who are 85.
Speaker A
And guess what, these 15 Americans, most of them are the ones who control America.
Speaker A
So they dictate policy.
Speaker A
And again, this is happening throughout the world, okay?
Speaker A
It's particularly stark in Japan and Germany.
Speaker A
But this is happening throughout the world.
Speaker A
And this leads us to the idea of gerontocracy.
Speaker A
Okay, this is Joe Biden, President of the United States.
Speaker A
And this is Mitch McConnell, who is head of the Senate.
Speaker A
They're both retired now.
Speaker A
Okay, but they're both in their 80s and they were the two most powerful men in America.
Speaker A
He can't walk straight, okay?
Speaker A
Whenever he walks, he trips.
Speaker A
This guy is even worse because.
Speaker A
Look at this.
Speaker A
The guy's brain dead.
Speaker A
The guy is literally brain dead.
Speaker A
In public.
Speaker A
Okay?
Speaker A
The guy's, this is a brain freeze.
Speaker A
The guy should not be one of the most powerful men in America, but he is.
Speaker A
That's the world we live in.
Speaker A
Because he will not give up power.
Speaker A
This is Diane Feinstein.
Speaker A
She died in office.
Speaker A
She was 90 years old.
Speaker A
She was 90 years old and she was still working and she died in her office.
Speaker A
And she was a senator in the United States.
Speaker A
These people are literally fighting for life.
Speaker A
Okay?
Speaker A
They refuse to give up power.
Speaker A
You they only give up power if they die.
Speaker A
This is the US Senate, again, the most powerful political institution in America.
Speaker A
These are people who are above the standard retirement age, which is 62, okay?
Speaker A
This guy's 90 years old and he's still working.
Speaker A
90 years old and he's still working in the Senate.
Speaker A
And he doesn't want to retire.
Speaker A
Chuck Grassley.
Speaker A
What does it mean to have a world run by old people?
Speaker A
Now, maybe in school, maybe at home you've been taught that old people are wise.
Speaker A
They're tolerant.
Speaker A
They're generous.
Speaker A
They're benevolent.
Speaker A
No, no, no, guys.
Speaker A
No.
Speaker A
The difference between these three generations.
Speaker A
Young, mature and elderly are pretty stark.
Speaker A
If you're young, you're rebellious.
Speaker A
You want to change the system.
Speaker A
If you're mature, you want things to move slowly, okay?
Speaker A
But if you're elderly, you're reactionary, meaning you don't want anything to change.
Speaker A
If you change anything, they get upset and slap you.
Speaker A
That's reactionary.
Speaker A
Young people are creative.
Speaker A
Mature people want growth.
Speaker A
But elderly people care first and foremost about safety.
Speaker A
Young people are open-minded.
Speaker A
Mature people want consensus, meaning they want everyone to get along.
Speaker A
But old people are stubborn.
Speaker A
They want things their way.
Speaker A
So we are now living in a gerontocracy.
Speaker A
Professor Zhang defines gerontocracy not merely as rule by the old, but as a political system paralyzed by their specific psychological traits.
Speaker A
A refusal to compromise and an obsession with maintaining the status quo at all costs.
Speaker A
Which is ruled by elderly people.
Speaker A
So we're going to live in a reactionary, stubborn system.
Speaker A
Only concerned about the safety of these people.
Speaker A
And so what does that mean?
Speaker A
Well, it means that the world will go into lockdown.
Speaker A
Whenever there's a virus, guess what, we're all going to have to shut down.
Speaker A
Because old people are afraid of catching germs.
Speaker A
It will also lead to a police state.
Speaker A
Now, police state does not mean that there'll be terrible police.
Speaker A
Coming to beat us up.
Speaker A
In fact, you know, in real life.
Speaker A
Most police that you meet are really, really nice people.
Speaker A
But you have no individual freedom.
Speaker A
So let me give you an example of this.
Speaker A
So in Canada, a Chinese moved to Canada.
Speaker A
And she, uh, she bought a house.
Speaker A
And her son was very naughty.
Speaker A
And her son was so naughty that she wants to slap him.
Speaker A
But she knows that in Canada, you can't really slap children.
Speaker A
Even in private, right?
Speaker A
So she goes on online and asks everyone, can I slap my child?
Speaker A
And everyone's like, you can't do that.
Speaker A
Because if you do that, your neighbor will report you to the police.
Speaker A
But what you can do is report your child to the police.
Speaker A
Tell the police your child is naughty and they'll come and help you discipline your child.
Speaker A
In fact, you can get the you can come get the police to come every single week.
Speaker A
They like that.
Speaker A
This is what we call a police state.
Speaker A
Okay, intrusive government interference into your personal lives.
Speaker A
Oh, and lots and lots of surveillance.
Speaker A
Okay, wherever you move, you'll be tracked.
Speaker A
Whatever call you make, you'll be tracked.
Speaker A
Um, in 2003, Britain passed something called the Online Safety Act.
Speaker A
And the idea is if you say anything bad online, you could get arrested.
Speaker A
Okay, so the freedom of expression is being limited.
Speaker A
This passed in 2023 in Britain, but I assume it passed everywhere in the Western world.
Speaker A
Digital currency.
Speaker A
The idea of digital currency is the idea of financial repression.
Speaker A
So they're trying to eliminate cash.
Speaker A
Because with cash is freedom.
Speaker A
You can do whatever you want with cash, you can buy whatever you want for how much you want with cash.
Speaker A
But with digital currency, all your transactions will be limited and monitored.
Speaker A
Okay?
Speaker A
So in the future, you will not be able to buy video games because that's bad for you.
Speaker A
Oh, microchip implants, guys.
Speaker A
Right, isn't that great, you before you had cell phones.
Speaker A
Then you had a fixed recognition.
Speaker A
And in the future, you have implants, microchip implants.
Speaker A
Immigrants.
Speaker A
Lots and lots of immigrants because poor people, sorry, rich pensioners need help.
Speaker A
They need nurses.
Speaker A
They need laborers.
Speaker A
They need gardeners.
Speaker A
They need people to mow their lawn.
Speaker A
So you have massive immigration coming into the country.
Speaker A
Oh, but good news, okay?
Speaker A
It'll be easier for you to study in America from now on.
Speaker A
Right?
Speaker A
Today, Trump announced he wants 600,000 Chinese students to go to the United States, right?
Speaker A
Before you guys were worried about not getting your visas and getting denied at the border.
Speaker A
Don't worry, guys.
Speaker A
They want you to go to the United States because you guys are the best labor, okay?
Speaker A
You're cheap, you're obedient, and you're studious, and you're young.
Speaker A
Okay?
Speaker A
So this is the plan to let in more Chinese students into America.
Speaker A
So you guys can take care of elderly people.
Speaker A
Isn't that great?
Speaker A
Good news, right?
Speaker A
Oh, lots and lots of prisons, guys.
Speaker A
Okay, because elderly people are afraid of criminals.
Speaker A
And also, prisoners are free labor.
Speaker A
Isn't that great?
Speaker A
Oh, and one more thing.
Speaker A
The lecture concludes with a dark prediction that a society obsessed with the safety of its elderly rulers inevitably descends into authoritarianism.
Speaker A
Demanding surveillance, mass incarceration, and perpetual war to secure their comfort.
Speaker A
War after war after war.
Speaker A
All right?
Speaker A
Okay.
Speaker A
Pretty depressing.
Speaker A
But don't worry, things will get even more depressing as we go along.
Topics:Western declineeconomic inequalitypension crisisaging populationneoliberalismtechno-feudalismpopulation replacement theorypublic debtproperty pricesmass immigration
