**Without this you CANNOT be saved... — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/without-this-you-cannot-be-saved/

Joe Schmid, Nomi McKay and Matthew Adler discuss effective altruism, distinguishing its minimal core (give generously and effectively) from controversial views like utilitarianism and insect welfare.

## Key Takeaways

- Giving to highly effective charities is a widely shared moral platitude, even among people who disagree on deeper ethics.
- Controversial EA moral views should be separated from the practical act of effective giving.
- Preventing disease deaths and reducing animal suffering are cheap, high-impact interventions with broad support.
- Christian and utilitarian perspectives can converge on prioritizing effective help for people in need.

## What the video covers

- The hosts (two Catholics and a utilitarian) disagree on many moral questions but agree God exists and that effective giving matters.
- Matthew Adler argues that if you can save more lives at similar cost, you should, e.g., malaria charities saving a life for about $5,000.
- The speakers distinguish a minimal claim of effective altruism (be altruistic and effective) from the social movement's contested positions such as utilitarianism and high moral weight for animal welfare.
- They argue disagreements over controversial EA views should not stop people from donating to effective charities for global health and animal welfare.
- Nomi McKay notes EA's concrete work (preventing disease, cage-free and humane slaughter reforms, pandemic prevention) is fairly uncontroversial.
- The discussion references recent news in which the US Department of Defense tweeted that the US will never be an effective altruist country, tied to foreign aid cuts.
- The hosts consider whether conservatives risk conflating EA with a package of policy priorities they dislike.
- Catholic sources are cited on almsgiving and the duty to help the poor, including the idea that those in extreme necessity may take what they need.
- Analogies such as doctor triage and drowning children are used to explore duties to strangers versus kin and nation.
- Christians are described as sharing the view that humans are divine image-bearers, implying a priority for helping humans in need.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Introduction and hosts
2. 01:45 Points of agreement and disagreement
3. 03:32 Why give to effective charities
4. 05:30 Distinguishing effective altruism from its movement
5. 09:00 Defending EA's practical work
6. 12:00 News coverage and political reactions
7. 15:00 Catholic teaching on almsgiving and the poor
8. 18:20 Triage, kinship, and duties to strangers

Answers

## Questions about this video

Why do the hosts say everyone should give to effective charities?

Matthew Adler argues that when options do different amounts of good, you should choose the one that does more good, and some charities save a life for about $5,000. The speakers call this an almost uncontroversial moral platitude.

What is the difference between effective altruism as a principle and as a movement?

The minimal principle is simply to be altruistic and effective with your giving. The movement adds contested views such as utilitarianism and high moral weight for animal welfare, which the hosts say can be debated separately.

What recent news prompted the discussion?

The hosts mention that the Department of Defense posted a tweet saying the US will never be an effective altruist country, connected to the administration's cuts to foreign aid.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00

Speaker A

Hello everyone. Welcome back to The Majesty of Reason. I'm Joe Schmid, your fearless host. And today I'm joined by Nomi McKay, my fearless compatriot. I guess you're both my compatriots. And the fearful Matthew Adler.

00:16

Speaker A

Why am I fearful? The Holy Ghost, Holy Ghost. We disagree on a lot of stuff, don't we?

00:57

Speaker A

We do. Yes. What are some things you disagree about? Well, you guys are Catholic.

01:02

Speaker A

We are indeed Catholic. No, I'm a utilitarian. Oh gosh, you are utilitarian. We're not utilitarian.

01:06

Speaker A

I'll take the self-indication assumption. You guys are sort of wishy-washy fence sitters about the self-indication assumption. They say things like, "I don't know what I think about anthropics.

01:15

Speaker A

I have to do more reading on the subject." Lame, weak, low energy. Um, well, I've got the right view. Yeah. Sneaky Joe, they're calling me. Um, uh, so but yeah. And you also think, you know, animal welfare and agreement matters

01:29

Speaker A

more than human welfare. Yeah, I think a lot of you, we both very much strongly disagree. We strongly disagree with utilitarianism.

01:35

Speaker A

We strongly disagree with, um, yeah, the non-capitalism. But amidst our disagreements, we agree on some very important things. Don't get me started.

01:45

Speaker A

We do agree that God exists. There's an afterlife, and yeah, I mean, psychical harmony is good despite all the manifold terrible criticisms that are out there. Um, but there's another big thing, Brian. What is that?

01:58

Speaker A

You should give your money to effective charities. This much is true. I mean, why is that the case, Matthew? Well, so I mean, it's almost like a trivialism that if you have different options that do different amounts of good, you should pick the one

02:18

Speaker A

that does more good rather than less. If you have the ability to save five lives or to save two lives, you should save five lives. Unless you're, you know, John Taurek, where he had this view that saving more lives wasn't better, and like

02:29

Speaker A

no one agrees with him, you know, assuming there are no deontic constraints that would prevent you from saving the five, right? You might have special obligations as we think, like family members and whatnot.

02:39

Speaker A

If you have multiple permissible options, you have a really good reason to do the one that's going to have the best consequences, right? And then it just turns out that there are lots of ways of doing very large amounts of good at

02:53

Speaker A

comparatively minor personal costs. There are charities like the Malaria Consortium, which save lives for just about $5,000. So if you give $5,000, if you give a fraction of the median income of the average American, you will save someone's life every single

03:10

Speaker A

year. And whatever we disagree about in the other domains, I think it's pretty uncontroversial that if you can save people's lives routinely without giving up anything of comparable value, that's a really, really valuable thing to do, and that's the kind of thing that you should

03:23

Speaker A

consider doing. Speaking of our disagreements in other areas, I think it would be helpful to draw some distinctions.

03:32

Speaker A

So, the sort of view we need to distinguish between two different types of formal distinction, real distinction, disting— so, take this minimal claim: you should be generous with your money, and when you're generous with your money, you should be generous in ways that are

03:49

Speaker A

more likely to do more good for more people. Okay, so that's, as Matthew put it, almost trivial, right? It's like a moral platitude. Almost everyone's going to agree with that claim when they hear it. Now, that minimal claim sometimes

04:04

Speaker A

goes by the name effective altruism. It's just the view that you should be altruistic, and when you're altruistic, you should be effective, right? You should have higher impact if possible.

04:15

Speaker A

Now, the term effective altruism is also a name for a social movement full of people who are committed to that very minimal claim, that moral platitude, but who are going to cash it out in ways that are sometimes very controversial.

04:29

Speaker A

So a lot of them are, like Matthew, utilitarians. So they think that basically you should do whatever maximizes utility. So there are no deontic constraints. It's just all about doing the most good, right? And then there are also people who think

04:46

Speaker A

that the welfare of nonhuman creatures matters a lot more than intuitively it seems to. So, for instance, Matthew here has gotten in trouble lately for claiming that the welfare of insects in aggregate matters more than human welfare. Now, we're not here to debate

05:06

Speaker A

that topic. And if you want to see my defense, go on my blog, Google "insect welfare matters more than human welfare" and the EA Forum or something.

05:15

Speaker A

But the point right now is just to draw a distinction between those claims. Claims like utilitarianism is true, there are no absolute moral constraints, and insects matter more than people in the aggregate, versus this very minimal claim

05:30

Speaker A

that you should be generous with your money, and when you're generous with your money, you should be generous in ways that are more likely to do more good for more people. Right. So, um, I think our disagreements that I just flagged, these

05:43

Speaker A

are really disagreements about what constitutes an effective charity, or maybe disagreements about which charities are morally permissible to donate to in the first place. Uh, but we can agree that it's good to donate to the most effective of the permissible

06:01

Speaker A

charities while still disagreeing about which charities are permissible to donate to and which of those charities are the most effective. That's just something that we want to flag. Effective altruism has been in the news for a long

06:14

Speaker A

time, including recently. We just don't want people to be dissuaded from being generous in effective ways just because they're averse to these very controversial moral views like utilitarianism, insect welfare, and so forth.

06:28

Speaker A

Yeah. I mean, it would be totally irrational to not give your money to prevent children from dying of malaria because some of the other people who do that have moral views that you disagree with. I mean, that would just be like

06:39

Speaker A

crazy. Um, you shouldn't refrain from doing something good because some other people who do the good thing have other views that you don't like. I will just say briefly, with respect to what you were saying: it's true that lots of

06:53

Speaker A

EAs have controversial moral views. I will say that while I think you would have disagreements with them about lots of issues, I think probably the stuff that people that EAs do in their capacity as EAs, when they're trying to

07:07

Speaker A

make the world a better place effectively, well, one can disagree about whether it's the best thing or just some good thing.

07:12

Speaker A

Generally, this stuff's pretty uncontroversial. So, some of it's preventing children from dying of disease. Some of it is very cheaply making it so that large numbers of animals aren't trapped in cages for their whole lives where they can't turn

07:24

Speaker A

around, or that they're not subject to painful deaths when we can stun them prior to slaughter, and so on. Some of it's trying to work to prevent another pandemic from killing lots of people. So, I'll say I do think

07:37

Speaker A

the things EAs do are actually a lot less controversial than just unrelated stuff like lots of EAs think.

07:44

Speaker A

But I agree that whatever you think about the whole core package of things that EAs do in the real world should be totally irrelevant to whether you end up doing good in the way that you, after carefully considering, think is

07:57

Speaker A

most effective. I mean, one of the reasons why we wanted to do this video was because this stuff has been in the news recently. I don't know if one of you guys wants to comment on

08:06

Speaker A

the news stuff about EA and what our government spit out on Twitter. Yeah. So, not to make things political, but my understanding is that the Department of Defense recently sent out a tweet saying that the United

08:21

Speaker A

States will never be an effective altruist country. And and that's also in connection with some policies that they've been instituting. Right.

08:28

Speaker A

That's right. So, this administration is very down on foreign aid. And I think right now um many people especially conservatives in the United States for whom you know I have much love and this is not supposed to be a bash on

08:42

Speaker A

conservatives. Um but I think that uh right now conservatives are in danger of sort of confusing effective altruism modestly construed just with a package of policy priorities that they really don't like. So um you know uh let's say that there's somebody who

09:07

Speaker A

really really wants to slow down AI progress. They want to heavily regulate AI. Now you can disagree with that sort of and I think that's the sort of policy that the Department of Defense is is explicitly like pushing against in these

09:20

Speaker A

tweets. Now you can disagree with the people who want to heavily regulate AI without rejecting the spirit of effective altruism, right? because you might just have disagreements with those people about whether regulating AI is a good idea, right? Especially if you

09:34

Speaker A

think it's very important that a you know a a country with a lot of respect for civil rights like the United States wins the AI race if you if the reason you think that is because you think that

09:45

Speaker A

would make the world better. And that's not contrary to the spirit of effective altruism, right? That's just a disagreement about which policies are actually going to be uh best for the world, best for people. So again, I think it's good to

10:00

Speaker A

take our our political disagreements and sort of just separate those from again this thing that's kind of just a moral platitude when you think about it, which is you should be generous and when you're generous, you should do it in a

10:10

Speaker A

way that's most likely to do more good for more people. Yeah. One of the more tragic things I read is I read I was reading a list of poems that was written by parents who had lost a child. And when you read

10:22

Speaker A

that, I think it becomes really really clear that like like a child dying is this like incomprehensible tragedy of unimaginable proportions if you can prevent this from happening routinely without giving up anything of remotely comparable value. It seems like that's

10:39

Speaker A

the sort of thing that that you ought to do. And so whatever you think about like shrink or whatever should it be totally irrelevant to this yet? Um, so I can encourage people who are listening like actually just like think about this.

10:51

Speaker A

Think about making a commitment to giving some of your money every year to affected charities to charities like the Against Maria Foundation so that children don't need to continue to die unnecessarily.

11:02

Speaker A

Yeah. And I'm going to put the Augusta Foundation link to donate in the description and in the pin comment. So like please seriously consider giving.

11:09

Speaker A

Yeah. And I guess another reason why I wanted to put this together is just to showcase that like yeah, you don't have to be uh like a non-atholic utilitarian shrimp lover in order to favor this this core thesis

11:23

Speaker A

this core thesis of effective alphaism. And in fact, I think there are lots of things that are very convicting from within the Christian tradition from within the Catholic tradition um that I want to share with you guys. So um let

11:34

Speaker A

me just like go on a montage to really try to convict you guys to really feel pretty passionate about this. So u Aquinus and theolog says whatever a man has in abundance is owed of natural right to the poor for their sustenance.

11:47

Speaker A

So Ambrose says the bread that you withhold belongs to the hungry. The clothing you shut away to the naked and the money you bury in the earth is the redemption and freedom of the penniless.

11:58

Speaker A

St. Nebro in uh the year 395 continues, "You are not giving to the poor man anything that is yours, but are rather restoring something that is his." And in similar fashion, Vatican 2 declared that men are obliged to come to the relief of

12:12

Speaker A

the poor and to do so not merely out of their superfluous goods. If a person is an extreme necessity, he has the right to take from the riches of others what he himself needs. Since there are so many people in this world afflicted with

12:24

Speaker A

hunger, this sacred council urges all, both individuals and governments, to remember the saying of the fathers, feed the man dying of hunger, for if you've not fed him, you have killed him. But let's ratchet things up even further.

12:36

Speaker A

John Chrysum said, "It is impossible. It's impossible though performed 10,000 other good deeds to enter the portals of the kingdom without almsgiving." Aquinus said that some are punished eternally for omitting to give alls. And our Lord clearly teaches that almsgiving is

12:52

Speaker A

necessary for for salvation. Matthew 25. So I just want to read this for you guys. You probably heard it, but it's very convicting when you listen to it.

12:59

Speaker A

When the Son of Man comes in his glory and all the angels with him, he will sit on his glorious throne. All the nations will be gathered before him and he will separate the people one from another. As

13:07

Speaker A

the shepherd separates the sheep from the goats, he will put the sheep on his right and the goats on his left. Then the king will say to those on his right, "Come, you who are blessed by my father,

13:16

Speaker A

take your inheritance, the kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world, for I was hungry and you gave me something to eat. I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink. I was a stranger and you invited me in. I needed

13:25

Speaker A

clothes and you clothed me. I was sick and you looked after me. I was in prison and you came to visit me." Then the righteous will answer him, "Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you? Or

13:35

Speaker A

thirsty and give you something to drink? When did we see you a stranger and invite you in or be clothed and clothe you? When did we see you sit her in prison and go to visit you? The king

13:43

Speaker A

will reply, truly I tell you, whatever you did for whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me. Then he will say to those on his left, "Depart from

13:53

Speaker A

me, you who are cursing, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels. For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat. I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink. I was a stranger and and you did not invite me

14:05

Speaker A

in. I needed clothes and you did not clothe me. I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me. They will answer, Lord, whenever we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or meeting clothes or sick or in prison and not

14:16

Speaker A

help you. He will reply, truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me. Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal

14:28

Speaker A

life. So this is a salvation issue. That's what grace is telling us. And notice something is very important. The goats here, the ones on the left, the ones that are being eternally condemned.

14:39

Speaker A

They're not being described here as murderers, they're not people who like were mass murderers like, you know, Hitler, Stalin, etc. They're people who omitted to give arms, people who failed to help. That is a damnable sin according to our Lord. Now, can I just

14:58

Speaker A

interject here? So, I agree that's the correct interpretation of the passage, but I just want to sort of like throw a bone to maybe the non-atholics in the audience, especially the Protestants who think there's something very problematic about saying that salvation is based on

15:11

Speaker A

almsgiving. Um, here's something that I I still think you should gather from the passage, even if you're going to, you know, interpret it differently. Giving to the poor is very very important and failing to do so is a like a morally

15:25

Speaker A

grave omission. It's like, you know, walking past Jesus who's like naked and starving in a ditch and not helping him.

15:33

Speaker A

That's what's described in the passage. So, even if you even if you deny it's a salvation issue, it's still an issue.

15:39

Speaker A

It's still a morally grave issue. Um, so I don't think like even if you think the sotiology that Joe just articulated is wrong, it should not affect your assessment of like whether this should be a priority. Yeah.

15:51

Speaker A

Yeah. You can't serve God and mammon as it says, right? And I mean, just imagine that. Just imagine like you're walking by and there's Jesus and he's like dying of hunger and thirst and has no clothes and you just like keep walking. I mean that

16:09

Speaker A

would be so awful. Um and like omitting omitting to give to the poor to help those who are in diar is equivalent to that. So if you can't imagine yourself doing that, then you should ask yourself, you know, how can I

16:24

Speaker A

imagine God giving to effective charities? Yeah. And now, so one thing that people might be thinking at this point is, okay, maybe I should give some of my money to charities, but why should I care that much about effective

16:36

Speaker A

charities? Isn't, you know, just doing some amount of good enough? I I don't think that this is the attitude that we should have. I mean, so imagine you're a doctor in a hospital and there are different patients and you can't treat

16:47

Speaker A

them all and they have different levels of sickness. The thing that everyone thinks doctors should do in a predicament like this is that doctors should do triage. They should treat the people who they can help the most easily

16:58

Speaker A

because if they care about each individual person, then they will care about saving the most lives. Um and so similarly if uh if we are in a position where there are huge numbers of people and they can't save them all we should

17:12

Speaker A

be focused on trying to save people and trying to benefit people as effectively as we can try to do as much as we can in this department. There's a famous argument that Peter Singer gave the drowning child argument. I guess you

17:23

Speaker A

heard some variant of this from Noah the drowning Jesus argument. Um, but imagine you come across a child drowning in a pond and you can pull them out, but pulling them out of the pond would require ruining your two your several

17:37

Speaker A

thousand dollar suit. Of course, you should pull the child out of the pond. But then it turns out there are people who are drowning in the proverbial pond who we can save for just a few thousand.

17:48

Speaker A

The fact that they're far away does not seem to make a difference. When if you're saving someone's life, how proximate they are to you in space doesn't seem to make any difference to how to the extent of your obligations to

18:02

Speaker A

save them. It's not like if you had a button that you would press to save the child from the pond and you were on bullet train as it got farther away, your reasons to press the button would get weaker. Physical proximity is

18:11

Speaker A

obviously not the sort of thing that's directly relevant to our obligations to save people's lives when we can. Now, I think that some of our viewers might think, well, it's not just that I'm spatially distant from them. Maybe I have weaker

18:29

Speaker A

kinship ties to them. Or maybe we're not members of the same nation. And so, maybe I have a duty to prioritize the interests of the people to whom I'm related or with whom I share a nation over the interests of foreigners. Um,

18:42

Speaker A

but I think that we can deal with that objection by just redescribing the case so that the child drowning in the pond is a foreignb born child. Maybe you're on vacation, you know, in I don't know, Nigeria and you're walking by and you

18:58

Speaker A

see a child drowning in the pond. Still seems like very morally urgent in that case, right? Even if saving that child would require ruining your very expensive suit seems like you should still do it. So even if you do think

19:11

Speaker A

that there's some relationship between your obligations to a person and your familial or national ties to that person, it like it doesn't follow that people with whom you don't share those ties don't matter or that you're not morally obligated to help them when you

19:25

Speaker A

can do so at relatively low cost to yourself. Yeah. I one thing that I sometimes think about is like imagine like talking to the parents of the people who whose wives you can save and imagine trying to explain to them your omission where it's

19:39

Speaker A

like the reason you didn't do something prevent their child from dying but you would have rather spent your money on other things. You know it just that seems like such a bad excuse and that seems like the sort of excuse that

19:50

Speaker A

wouldn't fly for the person. uh and um so they wouldn't fly for the per if you were explaining to people affected by your actions then it seems like you it it's just not an adequate excuse for not doing for not doing it. Now, I guess so

20:05

Speaker A

the best objection to the drowning child our age is people say, "Look, there are constantly children drowning." And so, if there was just one child drowning in a pond, maybe you'd be obligated to pull them out, but there are millions of

20:16

Speaker A

children drowning. You're not obligated to spend every waking moment pulling children out of ponds. There are things to say about this, but maybe that's right. But here's what I think would be queer. You'd be obligated to pull some

20:28

Speaker A

of the children out of ponds. Maybe you'll only be obligated to pull them all out.

20:32

Speaker A

Walk by the millions another right. It's like you walk by and you see a child drowning in a pond and you're about to pull them out and then you notice there are more children drowning.

20:39

Speaker A

So you're like, "Ah, screw it. I'm going to, you know, go on vacation." Like obviously that's unjustified. Obviously, if there are lots of children drowning in ponds, maybe you're not obligated to spend every making moment pulling children out of ponds, but that should

20:50

Speaker A

be one of the main things that you do. So similarly, I would suggest that you in the audience who's listening to this should make saving lives effectively one of the major things you do in your life.

21:02

Speaker A

Here's maybe a an elaboration on the argument you just made. Suppose that you come across a child drowning in the pond, but there's a curtain and there's a 50/50 chance that behind the curtain there are like 10,000 other

21:20

Speaker A

children drowning in ponds, but you just don't know. It doesn't seem like that should in any way affect your decision about whether to save the child in the pond who's drowning right in front of you, right?

21:31

Speaker A

Like you shouldn't be uncertain about what to do just because you're uncertain about whether there are more people in trouble behind the curtain, right? The fact that there are more people there might be more people in trouble shouldn't affect your judgment about

21:43

Speaker A

whether to help this person who's in trouble. Yeah. And I guess I just want to say a few things to like the the Catholics in the audience as well. So I mean how much you should give of course depends on

21:53

Speaker A

your state life, right? Like if you're struggling to even feed your family saying um then you know take care of your family first. Um, but I guess it's different if you have like a lot of spare income or if like you really can

22:05

Speaker A

live in ways that are simpler than your means allow. Um, I think like you should really potentially consider that so that you can give more away um to charities.

22:13

Speaker A

And I also just want to like clarify that like one thing that at least Noah and I aren't saying is that like you should give out of all the money that you give away, every single penny of it

22:22

Speaker A

should be going to effective care because like Catholics are obliged to for instance help the church. um Catholics are and also I just think like we do have some kind of um greater obligations toward you know family members other kinship ties and whatnot

22:35

Speaker A

but again as you said that doesn't mean that people who are like starving in foreign nations don't matter at all and as Matthew said I think it's important to include them as at least a significant or main part of your

22:46

Speaker A

charitable giving um there's a reason that the there's a reason that the main character in the parable of the good Samaritan is a Samaritan right because what the parable is supposed to illustrate is that love for neighbor is supposed to cross ethnic

23:01

Speaker A

boundaries. That that's not to say again that you don't have special obligations to your close family members, your close friends. It is to say that your generosity should extend should extend beyond those bounds. Right. So, well, do we have anything else to say before we

23:17

Speaker A

close off? Um I guess one thing I'll just say briefly uh uh so if you're thinking of giving to affected charities so I think the charities in the global health space like against Muer Foundation are a good one to do. I also think animal charities

23:34

Speaker A

are quite good that maybe maybe there's some disagreement about that year or I don't know but I mean the best animal charities spare animals from multiple years in a cage per dollar. If you could spend a dime to free a bird from a cage

23:48

Speaker A

that would otherwise trap it for a year, you wouldn't have to be some like bleeding heart tofu eating vegan to think that would be a good use of a knife. Um, and we all are tofu eating vegans.

24:01

Speaker A

That's right. But then I I I think you know consider giving giving your money to a farm kind to these other effective animal charities as well as well as the human charities. Uh so yeah, that that that would be basically my my two cents

24:14

Speaker A

on it. I'm gonna maybe we should briefly comment about that. So the Catechism of the Catholic Church says that money should not go to animal charities. That should as a priority go to humans. And it also says that we shouldn't be

24:33

Speaker A

showing to animals the affection that's due to human beings who are created in the image of God. Now, I'm no theologian, but my reading of that passage is that giving to animal charities is allowed as long as giving

24:49

Speaker A

to human charities is the priority. Right? If it were supposed to be a blanket prohibition on giving to animal charities, I don't think it would have any qualification at all. But it is qualified. It says you shouldn't give

24:59

Speaker A

money to animal charities that should as a priority go to humans. So I think what that means for Catholics and I think this goes for all Christians because I think the rationale for it right that human beings have a special kind of

25:11

Speaker A

dignity because we're divine image bearsers um that that's something that's held in common by all Christians. I think what this implies is just that your first priority should be helping humans who are in need. But that doesn't preclude

25:24

Speaker A

going above and beyond and also trying to help animals who are in need. Yeah. The way that I understand it is very similar. It's just like so long as you meet your obligations, your your oblations regarding um charity

25:35

Speaker A

towards humans, then it's totally permissible and in fact good to have animal battles. Um and in fact, we have lots of saints who are just like overwhelmingly um generous and loving towards animals. So um taste Yeah. And I think the other reading

25:49

Speaker A

would be kind of implausible where the other reading would be that like you can never get do spend any money helping animals if you could instead use a helping humans. So, like if there was a dog fighting arena where like a thousand

26:03

Speaker A

dogs were like being bred and fighting and brutally dying every day and you could shut it down, but in order to shut it down, you'd have to drive and it would you'd have to spend a little bit of gas money to like tip off the sheriff

26:16

Speaker A

that you shouldn't do that. And it's like, what? That's crazy. Or like you shouldn't free the bird the hundred birds from a cage for like one nickel.

26:24

Speaker A

Like that would be ridiculous, I think. So I don't I don't think that plausible reading of the catechism at least if the false is true.

26:32

Speaker A

Yeah. And again like just even the bare surface level reading of the of the catechism seems to support what we're saying. So anyway that that's at least our take. Again we're not moral theologians but um so anyway I hope you

26:42

Speaker A

guys enjoyed this video. Um thank you Matthew and Noah for joining me and again uh check the link in the description and the pin comment to the Against the Lair Foundation. I would very very strongly recommend you guys

26:54

Speaker A

give some money to them. All right, peace out.

Topics: effective altruism utilitarianism charity malaria animal welfare almsgiving Catholic ethics global health moral philosophy philanthropy

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/?from=transcript&id=95667)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/?from=transcript&id=95667)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/?from=transcript&id=95667)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/?from=transcript&id=95667)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/?from=transcript&id=95667)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/without-this-you-cannot-be-saved/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
