**Weimar America: Totalitarianism Is Coming | Rod Dreher — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/weimar-america-totalitarianism-coming-rod-dreher/

Rod Dreher and John Anderson discuss totalitarian risks in America, Europe and Israel, finding hope in friendship, faith, beauty and everyday joy amid cultural decline.

## Key Takeaways

- Hope, joy and everyday camaraderie are essential for sustaining the struggle to defend civilization.
- Cultural and institutional trust breakdown creates conditions where authoritarian appeals gain traction.
- Historical parallels to interwar Europe suggest warning signs should be taken seriously rather than dismissed.
- Faith and transcendent meaning are presented as the deepest source of endurance under suffering.

## What the video covers

- Dreher argues that young men on the far right openly calling for a strongman ('Caesar') is a warning sign that must be taken seriously.
- Dreher, drawing on his experience with Soviet-escapee émigrés, contends that current American cultural trends echo the conditions they fled.
- The conversation opens with the idea that facing hard times requires hope and joy, illustrated by the Louisiana 'hurricane party' metaphor.
- Dreher describes moving from Budapest back to Birmingham, Alabama to be near church, Southern culture and serious friends.
- Israel is presented as an example of a society where constant seriousness coexists with confidence, joy and high morale.
- Dreher recalls New York after 9/11, when kindness and awareness of life's fragility briefly transformed daily life.
- Both speakers cite C.S. Lewis and the idea of keeping ordinary routines during crises as a source of normality and resilience.
- Australian polling showing 68% believing the country is headed the wrong way is raised as evidence of widespread pessimism.
- Discussion touches on loss of trust in institutions, the decline of civic associations, and historical parallels to Weimar Germany.
- Totalitarianism is compared across Orwell's fear-based model and Huxley's model based on pleasure and distraction.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Warning signs of a far-right strongman appeal
2. 03:31 Hope, joy and the hurricane party metaphor
3. 07:31 Moving home to the American South and finding friends
4. 16:40 Leadership, institutional trust and social decline
5. 28:20 Weimar parallels and totalitarian models
6. 43:20 Relativism, the left and the center right
7. 55:00 Race, the Western tradition and faith

Answers

## Questions about this video

Why does Dreher say young men are a key concern?

Dreher notes that some young men on the far right are openly calling for a Caesar-like leader. He argues this must be taken seriously, since the stability of a society depends heavily on whether its young men are doing well.

How do the speakers suggest people cope with difficult times?

They suggest finding simple sources of joy such as friendship, beauty, good books, food and worship, and keeping routines normal. Dreher compares this to a Louisiana hurricane party, where preparation is followed by celebration with neighbors.

What does Israel illustrate in the discussion?

Israel is presented as a society where constant awareness of danger coexists with confidence, strength and high morale. Dreher links this to the country's founding through struggle and the memory of the Holocaust.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00

Speaker A

Now in America, you're starting to hear some young men of that demographic on the far right openly call for a Caesar.

00:10

Speaker A

This is not going to end well if we don't listen to what these young men are saying. When people in America who had escaped Soviet communism to come to America, when they started telling me at the beginning of wokeness around 2015 or

00:23

Speaker A

so, the things happening in this country now remind us of what we left behind. I laughed. I thought, where's the KGB?

00:31

Speaker A

Where are the prison camps? By the time I got to be 15 or so, it's the 80s. I decided Christianity must be bunk. I was the only young person on a coach full of elderly American tourists. I walked into

00:45

Speaker A

that cathedral and that's where I met God. I wanted to know instantly who is the God that inspired men whose names have been lost to history to build such a temple to his glory. If the societyy's going to do well, it's young men have to

00:59

Speaker A

be doing well. The fact that this is controversial for you to make that claim is a sign of how how much trouble we're in.

01:20

Speaker A

Well, Rod, you from America, me from Australia. Here we are in Jerusalem. It's a great honor to talk to you uh and really appreciate the work that you're doing.

01:30

Speaker A

Thank you. It's very kind. Now, I'd like to begin in a slightly different place. You and I are going to talk about some of the things that are going wrong and they're very serious.

01:38

Speaker A

But before we do that, if you're going to cope with tough things, you got to have a bit of hope. You got to have a bit of joy. You got to feel that there's a reason to carry on. And you've walked

01:48

Speaker A

that journey. You've written about it. You've talked about it. any useful remarks you can make before we start to talk about the things we need to worry about on how to hold your life together and make sense of it all personally.

02:03

Speaker A

You know, it's it's funny. Uh in a lot of my writing, I'm pointing out the the doom and gloom things, things that are true. I never exaggerate things. I I I look out at the culture around us. I see

02:15

Speaker A

things falling apart and I talk about why we have to pay attention. But when people meet me personally, they'll they'll often say things like, "You're a lot more cheerful than I expected." Like, "Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I'm from Louisiana, you know."

02:30

Speaker A

I think there's something to that. You know, we have hurricanes in Louisiana and when a hurricane is coming, everyone gets very serious and they they batten down the hatches. You get the food in and all that. And once the preparations

02:43

Speaker A

are made, you get out the gumbo pot and you make gumbo or jamballaya our food and you ice down the beer. You invite your neighbors over and you have a hurricane party. And I I'm serious. I think there's something to that. That

02:58

Speaker A

the only way to get through really difficult times is to have that joy. And it's usually a simple thing. you know, the joy of friendship, the joy of beauty, the joy of uh a good movie, a good book. For me, that's one of the

03:14

Speaker A

reasons I moved back earlier this summer from Europe to the United States. I love living in Budapest. Beautiful place. I love Europe, but I missed church. I needed a good church and I needed friends that I could really talk to. I

03:31

Speaker A

ended up moving to Birmingham, Alabama, a city I've never lived, but because I wanted to be back in my home culture, the American South, and I needed friends who were serious about the Christian faith, but who were my age with whom I

03:44

Speaker A

could have serious talks and it's been great for that. And you know, for me, as an American from the South, and that's my culture, to simply go to a simple barbecue place, have barbecued ribs, cornbread, black eyed peas, mustard greens, and

04:03

Speaker A

talk about politics or talk about Jesus or, you know, just everyday things with my friends. That's what life really is for me. And you know I I think that if we are going to continue this fight for our civilization this broad struggle

04:20

Speaker A

that all of us who care about our countries and the west and the faith going to carry that on. We have to have know why we're doing it. It can't just be abstract.

04:32

Speaker A

And this love of country, this love of place, this love of life comes down to the everyday things that we experience in our bodies. Uh I on the way to Tel Aviv, the plane was landing and I just

04:45

Speaker A

finished a novel that a friend had recommended to me called The Sunset Places. It was written by a Frenchman in 1950 but wasn't published until 2014. He wasn't a religious man, Julian Grock, who wrote it. But it's about a fictional

05:02

Speaker A

late medieval civilization, a kingdom that is decadent and the barbarians are just beyond the borders. And uh the narrator gets sick of the decadence in the main city. A decadence which includes the leadership, the elites, not wanting to talk about the bad things

05:21

Speaker A

might happen. And punishing anybody who notices, hey, hey, there are barbarians over there. We'd better get ready. So he leaves with some friends to go to a distant outpost of the kingdom, which has been essentially cut off from the

05:34

Speaker A

main body of the kingdom. And this is a city, a besieged city that barbarians all around. But this man and his friends want to help fight. And it's not a book about victory and war. In fact, it's an

05:48

Speaker A

unfinished novel, so we don't know how it ends. But it's a book about how to live well during suffering, how to be happy and to celebrate life even when you might die.

06:00

Speaker A

And uh and it all comes down to camaraderie friendship beauty song all the things that ma make up a life, a full life. And I thought as I I'm not making it up. The plane was landing.

06:13

Speaker A

When I finished the last page, I thought this is Israel. You know, the the people in this country because they know each day could be their last. Probably not, but it could be.

06:25

Speaker A

there's a certain joy of life that they have and a certain strength, a confidence, a high morale that we have lost in my country. And um I think that someone was talking about this today at our conference. So you said that, you

06:42

Speaker A

know, maybe it's the fact that the Israelis know that they they reclaimed this land in 1948 through bloodshed and war. And if you want to go back to losing 6 million in in Europe in the Holocaust, that's what gave them the

06:57

Speaker A

impetus. And they'd had to fight for everything they have. Things are serious here. But because they're serious, it's also joyful and people are confident.

07:08

Speaker A

The only time I've ever experienced something that intense was living in New York City in the autumn of 2001 after 9/11. There was something about that that tragedy. I I saw it with my own eyes. I was standing by the Brooklyn

07:22

Speaker A

Bridge as a New Yorker and watched the South Tower fall. As horrible as that was, it was like every day was enchanted in a weird way because we knew what we could lose. People were kind to each other. People helped each other. People

07:38

Speaker A

smiled at each other on the street. And we knew it wouldn't last forever, but this was the unexpected blessing in that horrible tragedy. Would I rather it h didn't happen? Of course. But it showed me how things can be when people suddenly get

07:57

Speaker A

real and realize how precious life is and how precious all of us are to each other if we saw things rightly. So to answer your question, I I find hope in the discovery of new books, in my friends, and simple Sunday worship at my

08:14

Speaker A

church. Little things like that remind me that life is worth living. You're in good company. I think CS Lewis wrote during the Cold War when people thought a nuclear war would break out and all would be lost. That simple normality

08:33

Speaker A

was really important. get on with your daily lives. Do the things you enjoy. Do the things that are make a life normal, routine. Hang out the washing as he put it in the way that you would any other

08:45

Speaker A

day. So, I'm sure that there's a lot to be said for that. Um, you talk about morale. Uh, Reagan identified the great problem. I think u after the dreadful 1970s, another grim period. We forget we've been through these times. Um, and you're

09:06

Speaker A

seeing that again now in my country. 68% of the Australian people think the country is headed in the wrong direction. It's pretty staggering.

09:14

Speaker A

The numbers must be similar in the US. They would be right across the anglophere, I suspect, and probably much of Europe.

09:20

Speaker A

And and I understand why. But in fact, I was at dinner earlier this week in Nashville, and one of the men at the table was Peter Robinson, who had been a Reagan speech writer. He's the one uncommon knowledge.

09:33

Speaker A

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He's a great guy. He features in the new Reagan movie. Really?

09:37

Speaker A

Yeah. This Californian comes in in his sort of floral outfit Hawaiian shirts and what have you and they don't like him in Washington.

09:45

Speaker A

But of course he he was quite a guy came up. He wrote the Mr. Gorvich tear down tear down this wall.

09:51

Speaker A

Anyway, Peter and I were talking after we had this big dinner. Peter said, "You know, a lot of these people at this table are young and they weren't even alive in the 70s." He said, "I remember the 70s. It was bad." And then Reagan

10:04

Speaker A

came, so this could happen again. Now, I'm just old enough to remember the 70s and how tense they were with the Cold War and inflation and all the things. I think the difference is Ronald Reagan had a different country to work with. We

10:21

Speaker A

Americans weren't so divided as a country. We still had a general social cohesion. We all shared not everybody shared the same values but there was a center there and the decades since then especially with the advent of the

10:38

Speaker A

internet which has accelerated this that has caused so much social atomization that uh I don't know if a new Reagan came if he would even have the solid ground to stand on anymore and that's what worries me.

10:52

Speaker A

I understand exactly what you're saying. We're all crying out for leadership. who is going to lead us out of this mess.

11:00

Speaker A

But I really wonder whether we would currently recognize such a person if they were to emerge, let alone support them.

11:07

Speaker A

That's true. I because we don't know who to trust. Yeah. And uh so much trust has been lost. I'm sure it's the same in Australia, but in the United States, you ask people about their trust in institutions. The only institution that

11:24

Speaker A

still commands a majority of the trusts of the American people is the US military.

11:28

Speaker A

Yeah. And uh how do you run our democracy when people don't trust the institutions? And it was it's been trending this way for a while, but co really really knocked the supports out.

11:41

Speaker A

Same in Australia. Yeah. And um and you can't force yourself to trust. We don't talk enough about trust.

11:47

Speaker A

Yeah. Yeah. You just can't force yourself to do it when you've seen the institutions and the leaders of those institutions fail so badly. And how do you build that back up? I we we had better find out and figure out because

12:04

Speaker A

one of the reasons and I know we'll get into this later but one of the reasons Hitler found a way in to the minds and the hearts of the German people was because they had been through so much in

12:17

Speaker A

the 1920s with hyperinflation and the after effects of losing World War I that by the time the late 20s came and the Great Depression hit they had lost the capacity to trust any institution.

12:30

Speaker A

ution, but they were so desperate for deliverance from the chaos and the hopelessness that they were willing to follow anybody and they did. Do you know that in as late as 1928, John, the Nazi party was still on the fringes. It got

12:45

Speaker A

only 2.6% in the national elections. The next year came the great depression, the crash and the great depression and that's when the bottom fell out for the center. German society had been so atomized and so filled with distrust,

13:01

Speaker A

suspicion, anxiety and conspiracy thinking that suddenly the center collapsed. People ran either to the communist or to the Nazis.

13:11

Speaker A

Interestingly, the group, the demographic that ran first and fastest into the arms of Hitler were educated middle class men in their 20s because these men had been too young to fight in the Great War and they grew up they were

13:27

Speaker A

formed in the chaos of the 1920s where all morals fell apart, the economy fell apart, institutions that there was no trust left. So they were desperate for anything to give them hope for the future. When the Great Depression hit,

13:41

Speaker A

they said, "That's it. We're done." And so they they awaited a Caesar. Now in America, you're starting to hear some young men of that demographic on the far right openly call for a Caesar.

13:56

Speaker A

This is not going to end well if we don't figure out some way for the institutions that give meaning, the churches, families, other institutions to find a way in to listen to what these young men are saying, but to give them

14:10

Speaker A

an alternative and not just push them aside and say, "Oh, you're just a a whining snowflake." which is the sort of thing you do hear from some old school Republicans, older people usually, people of my generation, the baby

14:25

Speaker A

boomers above me, who just we don't recognize the not only the material struggle that these people have, these young people to try to build a life with housing costs and things like that, but the inter interior and internal struggle

14:41

Speaker A

they have to find meaning in a world that tells them there is no such thing as meaning. There is no truth. There's only narrative.

14:49

Speaker A

Uh so you know you've written about this. I want to explore this in some depth.

14:53

Speaker A

Okay. Uh but just before we do, let's tease out this idea of trust a bit more.

14:58

Speaker A

Um I've done a bit of thinking about this. I gave a talk a few years ago, it it hit me that when two or more are gathered, trust becomes a central issue.

15:08

Speaker A

You got a group of people, especially if they're people you don't know well, you're going to be thinking to yourself, can I trust these people or can I not?

15:15

Speaker A

If you can trust them, you can work cooperatively and the sum of the parts becomes greater uh than than the obvious total so to speak. To the extent that you can't, you're looking for the escape clause. Where can I flee to? If I can't

15:29

Speaker A

trust these people, we can't cooperate to build something better. I've got to go for security ahead of if you like freedom and cooperation.

15:40

Speaker A

Yeah. But I thought about it since then and I think it's not just the trust that's broken down within our society. Not even what just what you touched on then. Uh breakdown of trust in the institutions.

15:54

Speaker A

It's is it primarily a simple lack of knowledge of the thinking behind those institutions, the thinkings and the beliefs that drove them or is it a rejection of them? Because it seems to me that trust is broken down in the very

16:08

Speaker A

thinking, the philosophies, the underpinning um beliefs, right, that gave rise to those institutions of freedom and prosperity. So, we've got a real problem.

16:21

Speaker A

We don't know what to believe anymore. Yeah. Or am I missing? No, no, I I think you're right. Um, you know, one of the best books I ever read is called Secondhand Time. It's by a Russian journalist who won uh I think

16:36

Speaker A

she won the Nobel Prize for it and her other work and it secondhand time is a history of Russia after the fall of the Soviet Union basically in the 1990s and if you want to know where Putin came

16:50

Speaker A

from read that book because everything fell apart for these people their visible structures of life but everything and they were s they suddenly found themselves in a completely chaotic society.

17:02

Speaker A

a society where gangsters ruled and they were desperate for law and order and that's what Putin gave them. I'm not defending Putin here, but I'm just saying to echo you, this this is the sort of thing you will have in a society

17:15

Speaker A

where trust breaks down to a great extent along those lines. Um, you know, the Harvard political scientist Robert Putnham, he's famous for his book Bowling Alone.

17:26

Speaker A

About 20 25 years ago, he published a study that made him very uncomfortable as a liberal.

17:34

Speaker A

The study found that the more diversity you have in a given community, the less social trust there is and less of what he calls social capital. And it makes sense. You know, we don't wish it were so, but if people because people carry

17:51

Speaker A

their own cultures with them, and it's just human nature to want to live around people who are more or less like you because you can relax among them. I mean, I I noticed this when I moved back to the US after four years living in

18:03

Speaker A

Hungary. I loved living in Hungary, but there's a certain inner release that comes when you're back among your own people and you know how things work. I think that that's a general principle that's true about society. And now uh it's so bad that I

18:21

Speaker A

earlier this summer I had lunch with a young man from Alabama who works on Capitol Hill in Washington for a congressman and he he's 27 years old. He told me that he and his friends who are on the same political side, they won't

18:37

Speaker A

text each other. Like why Arnod? He said well because you don't know if somebody might screenshot it and use it against you. said, "Wait, you're telling me that you're afraid you people are afraid to text people in your own circles for fear

18:52

Speaker A

that one of them will find personal advantage to roiding you?" He said, "Yeah." I said, "Guy, that's how totalitarianism works. You can't trust anybody." He just blinked. It hadn't occurred to him. This is the the legendary frog in the boiling pot. This

19:09

Speaker A

young man, 27 years old, he's never known any world other than the digital world where everything is fluid and the digital world valorizes and and incentivizes clicks. And if you can get more clicks and up your own media profile by selling

19:29

Speaker A

out a friend, you'll do it, you know. And how do you repair that? How do you repair? How do you teach a a young person who's been raised in that culture? No, you have to trust. You have to learn to trust. You can't manufacture

19:44

Speaker A

it. You trust has to be earned. And then you get this sort of thing where people flee for um for safety and worry less about freedom. So in a sense, I think the Soviet people cried out for freedom before the collapse of

20:02

Speaker A

the war. But then the result was such chaos. Constantine Kissen makes this point that they want wanted security and Putin opposite offered it.

20:14

Speaker A

You know, there's a line there that's a real warning, isn't it? Yeah. And they they may have said if this is what democracy and capitalism are, we don't want it. And I think we're starting to hear there is a very perverted democracy.

20:25

Speaker A

Very corrupt capitalism. But that's what they thought. They were told, "You've got them, aren't you?" And uh we're starting to hear the same thing coming from Americans in their 20s, both on the left and the right.

20:38

Speaker A

They see the cost of housing through the roof. See, they're job there's no job security for them. They've gone deeply into debt for a college degree that may be worthless because the economy is changing so fast. So um you know

20:53

Speaker A

AI AI and do you know that uh you may have seen this earlier this year Dario Amodi the founder of Anthropic said that within 5 years half the white collar jobs in America could be wiped out by AI. Now this is a guy who's

21:10

Speaker A

trying to sell you on AI. If that happens that's 1929 all over again. And um Peter Turchin he's a historian. Yeah.

21:20

Speaker A

Uh he his theory is he studied revolutions and upheavalss throughout history. He said the main factor they have in common is what he calls elite over production which is simply to say a society that produces too many educated

21:35

Speaker A

elites to fill the jobs it has. And these disaffected educated young people, they're the ones who organize the masses into revolution. Well, if you have white collar workers, half of them without work, without the possibility of getting work, you have a revolutionary

21:54

Speaker A

situation on your hands. So, to go back, you've you've got a book coming out on this. Let's give it a good plug. Uh, it won't be out till May.

22:02

Speaker A

I know, but plug in advance. Uh, so look out for a good book. You order it on Amazon. I don't There you go. Um, because given your past writings, a lot of people are going to enjoy it and we're all going to learn

22:14

Speaker A

quite a bit out of it. But this is a pretty radical idea. You think of the young people in Germany in the 20s and the 30s. They had been through a disastrous war. You know, an incompetent Kaiser and his team uh allowing an

22:28

Speaker A

appalling situation. I mean, it's just incredible that so-called Christian Europe would have let that happen, the first world war. Um it much harder for me to understand how that happened than the Second World War. They're both horrific, but um so that happens. uh

22:42

Speaker A

you've got the sort of factors that you've touched on. Um their country's been smashed. There's hyperinflation.

22:49

Speaker A

They seem then the the global great depression hits it. It almost smashes America and does smash Germany really.

22:57

Speaker A

Uh and and and you see this this outcome of angry young men, often educated men placing their confidence in a evil figure like Hitler.

23:09

Speaker A

Now, I know that you would not argue for a moment the uh those sorts of parallels exactly, but you're saying in the book that some of the same sort of discontents not driven by a war, not driven by

23:24

Speaker A

hyperinflation, but driven by other factors are leading young men who after all traditionally have been incredibly important that if a societyy's going to do well, it's young men have to be doing well.

23:34

Speaker A

Yeah, I think we can say that even in an age when You know, a lot of feminists would argue, "Oh, well, men are almost dispensable." Yeah. The fact that this is controversial of you to make that claim is a sign of how how much trouble we're

23:50

Speaker A

in. The societ I recognize that. I mean, as Warren Farrell puts it, it's time we recognize that if one sex is not doing well, neither sex is reaching its potential or doing as well as it ought to be.

24:02

Speaker A

So, that's dispensed for that. You're focusing on these young people and it's going to be particularly men. We know that already. Young men, it's already happening. You know, the new emerging job markets tend to favor young women.

24:15

Speaker A

So, you got more young men by definition who are left aimless, ruthless, feeling that they're discarded.

24:21

Speaker A

Yeah. um that conflicts with their again, it's amazing that you got to be careful when you say these things, but their better instincts as protectors and providers who want to fight for something and slay dragons and do good

24:34

Speaker A

things uh and look after their loved ones and they left. So what's the case? Well, and they were they were raised to believe that all their natural instincts, which do need to be refined and controlled, they were raised to projected all this shamed as

24:50

Speaker A

toxic masculinity. Well, I'll tell you what the idea for the book came from. I uh I went to Washington DC from Hungary last November and just before I left a friend of mine who's involved at a very high level in conservative activism but

25:06

Speaker A

doesn't live in DC he said you know I'm hearing really disturbing things from Washington that between 30 and 40% of the young men that is to say in their 20s who work in conservative politics not only directly in politics but in the

25:22

Speaker A

think tank world that they're followers of Nick Fuentes. Now, Fuentes is, you know, the far-right neo-Nazi controversialist on the internet. And my friend said, "That just seems shocking to me. See what you can find out." So, when I got to DC, I spent a week there.

25:40

Speaker A

And uh every time I would meet a young man, conservative man in his 20s, I would ask them, "Is this true?" 30 to 40%. They all said yes. The last conversation I had about this was with a a young man I happened to know

25:53

Speaker A

personally. I don't think he's part of it that group, but he travels in those circles. And I said to him, "What do they want?" He said, "They don't want anything. They want to tear it all down." I thought, "My goodness, this sounds a

26:08

Speaker A

lot like VHimar Germany." uh VHimar Germany for the viewers who don't know that's the term we give to the German Republic that emerged after Germany lost the first world war was Germany's first experiment with democracy and it lasted

26:23

Speaker A

from 1919 until Hitler took over in 1933. Thanks for explaining it. But that says something in itself. Our generation leed about that because it gave rise to the horrors of the Second World War. Young people are probably not taught anymore.

26:37

Speaker A

No, of course not. would have been people would have automatically understood what you meant by references to the Vimar Republic.

26:44

Speaker A

Well, in fact, I had a an argument with my publisher of this book. They didn't want to use Vimar in the title. I'm like, come on, we got to do that. But they were afraid people wouldn't understand it. Anyway, uh so after that

26:57

Speaker A

specific conversation, I went back to Budapest and I spent this past winter and early spring immersing myself in the history of 1920s Germany to see if there were any parallels. And it was shocking what I found.

27:12

Speaker A

Hannah Arent in her great book, The Origins of Totalitarianism, she was a German Jewish refugee from Nazi Germany. She identified the things that led to the rise of totalitarianism both in Germany and in Russia. And she said they had several things in common.

27:29

Speaker A

By far the most important she said was social atomization. Meaning individuals felt disconnected from their history, from their community, from their friends, from any sense of past and future. they became like uh elementary particles just bouncing around with no sense of purpose

27:49

Speaker A

or meaning and well we have that in America for sure you know the internet has just accelerated that she also said and this was also true in my studies of primar Germany that people had lost faith in institutions because the

28:04

Speaker A

institutions had failed so badly in the first world war the the Kaiser had all of leader of Germany had all of the churches claiming all the Protestant churches anyway because they were under the state telling the Germans this is a

28:20

Speaker A

holy war you know against uh against France and Britain and when they lost it shocked their sense of who can we trust God can we trust the church and other institutions failed too you also had in 1920s Germany a a chasm growing between

28:39

Speaker A

men and women you know some of these men had Another parallel. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Another parallel. Uh some of these young men came back from fighting the war and they found that women while they were gone had moved

28:51

Speaker A

into the workplace. They called it in Germany the new woman. Um this was our their equivalent of what we in the Englishphere called the flappers. You know, very liberated young women. And uh they didn't necessarily need a man. and

29:07

Speaker A

young men who didn't fight in the war, but they found it very difficult to relate to them because they didn't know what it meant to be a man anymore when the sex roles had changed so radically.

29:17

Speaker A

Morals fell apart. Whenever we think of Vimar, Germany, we tend to think about the movie Cabaret and the the sexual decadence of Berlin, transgenderism, homosexuality. All of that is true and all of that is true for us today. and

29:32

Speaker A

the economic procarity. Of course, most people know that that was part of it. But and we don't we haven't had a great depression here. So why does this seem relevant? Well, when you talk to people in their 20s, yes, we haven't had a

29:48

Speaker A

great depression, but they're so terrified that they will be precarious economically for the rest of their lives. So to put it all together, what I found is we have so many psychosocial parallels between 1920s Germany and 2020s America and broadly the West. We

30:07

Speaker A

have gotten to the same state of general psychosocial procarity that Germany did without us having suffered the major traumas of losing the war, hyperinflation, and then the depression.

30:19

Speaker A

We got there the roundabout way. Now what's interesting, I didn't realize this till I finished the book. My uh bestselling book ever was called Live Not by Lies in which I drew the parallels between Soviet totalitarianism and wokeness. Initially people thought

30:35

Speaker A

it was a joke. I did too when people in America who had escaped Soviet communism to come to America when they started telling me at the beginning of wokeness around 2015 or so the things happening in this country now remind us of what we

30:50

Speaker A

left behind. I laughed. I thought you where's the KGB? where the prison camps. It turns out that the more you talk to them, the more you realize they were sensing something in their bones that we could not see because our idea of

31:04

Speaker A

totalitarianism was based on Orwell 1984 and based on the cold war. But it turns out you can have a softer form of totalitarianism within a liberal democracy. If people in the institutions start abandon liberalism, classical liberalism, the rule of law, the belief

31:28

Speaker A

you should judge people on the basis of their character, not their skin color. If people become afraid to say what they think, you can have a form of totalitarianism. And I argued that that's what we were we were dealing

31:39

Speaker A

with. That book ended up it came out in 2020 in September in the US uh during COVID and after the summer of George Floyd. It got zero media attention because I say the media is part of the problem. But it sold uh 250,000 copies

31:58

Speaker A

on word of mouth because it gave people who were confused by what was happening in in America a way to understand it. In a similar way, this this next book um takes what sounds on the surface like a

32:12

Speaker A

ridiculous proposition that liberal democratic capitalist America in the 2020s is like 1920s Germany. But what I try to do with the book is say look you know don't make the direct comparison you know in if go going back to George

32:28

Speaker A

Orwell his is the best known totalitarian fiction book about totalitarianism of the 20th century but brave new world was also one too those are two very different totalitarianisms but one was based on fear and terror that's Orwell's and the other was based on a total

32:47

Speaker A

managerial state in which people voluntarily gave their freedom over for comfort and safety and entertainment.

32:53

Speaker A

And that's more like the totalitarianism we have today. A soft totalitarianism. Soft totalit. In a similar way, I hope to convince people who might think it's a ridiculous idea to compare America and the West today to 1920s Germany. I show

33:08

Speaker A

them with the facts to say we better take this seriously because we know where this led in Germany. Uh, people also forget that the Communist Party was very strong in 1920s Germany. It could have gone either way. It just happened

33:21

Speaker A

to go Hitler's way. But I don't want a Hitler or a Stalin. I'd like to keep the liberties we have now and the freedom and the normality. But if we don't wake up to the threats arising from the

33:34

Speaker A

discontent of the young and not just the young but especially the young and take concrete measures to address it which include not just material benefits to help them buy houses and things but also more importantly their spiritual lives then we're going to see

33:51

Speaker A

the emergence of something may not be Hitler may not be Stalin but it's not going to be good. Um, final point.

33:59

Speaker A

Toward the end of my research, I read a fantastic book that I had never heard about called Hitler in Ourselves.

34:06

Speaker A

It was published in 1946, right after the war, by a German Swiss Christian philosopher named Max Pecard.

34:14

Speaker A

And in it, he tried to explain how did this happen to Germany. And his core explanation was that German people experienced what he calls disjointedness. In other words, chaos everywhere. Nothing made sense. Nothing related to the other. The whole world

34:31

Speaker A

was turned upside down economically, culturally and otherwise. And they also lost in that destroyedness a sense of logos. Now he was a Christian. He meant d logos, Jesus Christ, the collapse of religious faith, but also logos in a philosophical sense,

34:49

Speaker A

which is the the unreflective consciousness or belief that there is an order, a hierarchy built into existence and that we should live by it. They came to believe in Germany of the 1920s there was no such thing as big T truth. There

35:07

Speaker A

was only narrative. And uh because people couldn't trust in or stop trusting institutions, they started believing the things that made them feel good. Now this is something that we have observed on the left for at least 20 years and now it's hit the right. We've

35:23

Speaker A

got to try to stop it now. Unpack that. That seems really important to me.

35:28

Speaker A

Yeah. See, I mean, you think of an hersi warning that we're turning our democracies into democracies.

35:35

Speaker A

you think of a traditional approach which I think you might endorse. Uh Jamie Kirk I think I heard say this that the Christian tradition has said that truth matters and you arrive at truth through a combination of revelation

35:53

Speaker A

uh and reason. Yeah. We've said truth doesn't matter. It's all relative. It's whatever's right for you. And we've emotionalized everything.

36:02

Speaker A

We've made everything about feelings. But in the end, facts are more important surely than opinions. Wilberforce said that.

36:12

Speaker A

Wilberforce wrote to a young admirer, the famous anti-slavery campaigner, and he said, "I I notice a great competition in the community between opinions and facts, but I find it generally better to go for the facts." That's not what we do

36:27

Speaker A

anymore. No, you believe that and I believe that, but that's not the way of the world today. The American conservative activist Chris Christopher Rufo published a really interesting essay a couple of years ago called the cluster B society. A cluster B is a term that

36:44

Speaker A

psychologists use to describe various personality disorders that typically involve narcissism, an overly emotional approach to the world where one comes to believe that emotions are the only sure guide to what is real and other things like that. And Rufos says that what was

37:04

Speaker A

once seen as a sign of a disordered mind, a diseased mind, has now become very general in society.

37:13

Speaker A

Uh couple weeks ago, I read a book called American History Z for Zoomers, the kids in their 20s. It was written by a far-right activist of that generation, explaining why we've all gone to the far right. On the first page of the book, he

37:30

Speaker A

says in the first paragraphs, "We don't know anything about history. We don't know anything about philosophy, but we do have feeling." Yeah. And feeling is all we need. Like that's how he got Hitler because people in 1920s Germany,

37:47

Speaker A

conservatives, they didn't believe anything anymore. They just trusted their gut instinct. And Hitler knew how to appeal to that. I believe that today whoever controls the algorithm uh or algorithms has a direct line into the reptile brain of the young who are so dependent on it

38:08

Speaker A

and who have never known any reality outside of this manufactured digital reality. Uh Ian McGill the great writer and psychiatrist in Scotland says that our sense of reality is whatever we pay attention to. I he wasn't making a

38:26

Speaker A

metaphysical claim. He was making a psychological claim that if you don't see something then it or hear it or aware of it, it doesn't exist for you. I think this is one reason too why it's so difficult for people nowadays to talk

38:41

Speaker A

across generations or even talk AC across different social groups among your own generation because everybody's following their own particular media feed. When I would go back to America from Europe to visit, I would talk to my family, my friends back there about the

38:58

Speaker A

migration crisis in Europe and the rise of anti-semitism and Islamic violence and so forth. They knew nothing about it. And I knew why they didn't because sitting there in Budapest, I was reading the American newspapers, watching American television reports. It

39:14

Speaker A

wasn't reported by the media. They had no way of knowing about it unless they happened to be on Twitter. So, uh, this is a long-winded way of saying that we have entered into a time in which everything seems fluid and when you

39:29

Speaker A

don't know what you can trust with your reason, you give yourself over to your gut, to your feeling. Um, this is one reason why Hannah Arent also said that the rise of anti-semitism is a sign of a society that is preparing itself for

39:44

Speaker A

authoritarianism or totalitarianism because it means that people have become susceptible to conspiracy theory. And it's not just about the Jews. It's about a mind that is so desperate for meaning that it grabs hold of anything that can seemingly give order to the chaos no

40:03

Speaker A

matter how crazy it sounds. So like you, I've been concerned for some time that I've tended to see this as a particular disease of the left, but now we see the center right at least that the far the

40:17

Speaker A

further extensions of it falling into the same trap. There's the same lack of commitment to evidence, to reason, to history, to tradition. It's all feelings. And you'll end up with a a looney right that's as nasty as the looney left.

40:35

Speaker A

It's it's starting to emerge. And some of my readers say to me, "Well, why are you focusing on these people on the right? Look at the left. You know, the loonies have have real power there. They don't own on the right." Like, that's

40:49

Speaker A

true. But we would be in a much better place as a country and as a civilization if 20 25 years ago the sensible leaders of the left had stood against these illiberal woke leftists and said no we're not going to have any part of

41:03

Speaker A

this. And so part of your message is the sensible right has got to address yeah the looney right. We owe it to ourselves and to our community.

41:12

Speaker A

We'll destroy ourselves in the same way the Democrats have destroyed themselves in my country um by losing control of the activist group and surrendering to them. There's still time to do it. And I you know there there's a temptation now

41:26

Speaker A

and I hear this with some people in Washington. Well, we can't alienate them. All of the political energy among the young on the right in the US now now that Charlie Kirk is dead is going to the the Nick Fuentes types the radicals

41:42

Speaker A

and we can work with him. This is the mistake that I'm with you. Yeah. France von Papen. He was the conservative a conservative adviser made he was might have even been the vice chancellor of Germany in the early

41:55

Speaker A

1930s. He advised the president Paul Hindenberg. This Hitler fellow. Yeah. Yeah. He sounds a little crazy and he is crazy, but we could control him. You know, make him the chancellor and we'll control him. Well, you could see what

42:08

Speaker A

happened. I learned that as a 16-year-old in history classes at school. It's not taught anymore.

42:12

Speaker A

Not taught anymore. Uh but but what you're saying is really interesting and you touched on Charlie Kirk.

42:18

Speaker A

Uh I was talking to some young people at home who are very perceptive and they were saying look at the danger here will be that young conservatives who might otherwise have sought to be reasonable people and interact reasonably will say

42:32

Speaker A

well the so and so left's declared war on us. Look what they've done. They've shot a good man who whether you agreed with him or not was behaving in a civilized way and tried to use reasons.

42:42

Speaker A

So so let's they declared war on us. This is open warfare. Let's go for them.

42:47

Speaker A

Let's use the same tactics. That will be a disaster. It just rips everything apart.

42:50

Speaker A

It will. Charlie Kirk himself, I'm sure, and his widow made it very plain that no, we've got to learn how to behave perhaps strongly, but out of love, not out of revenge, not out of we'll play them at their own game. Do

43:08

Speaker A

you know? Uh, am I missing something? Yeah. Yeah, you're exactly right. But look what happened. I remember remember Charlie Kirk's funeral. There was such a a good feeling that came out of that suffering. A feeling his funeral was an

43:22

Speaker A

open celebration of God, of Christ, and the best side of us. And it was torn apart by the podcaster Candace Owens, this looney woman who accused Erica Kirk, his widow, of having a hand in his assassination.

43:40

Speaker A

How can people do that? Oh, and and she is one of the most popular on the right.

43:44

Speaker A

And uh and so it just all came apart, you know, by these online bad actors.

43:51

Speaker A

And uh and the gropers, as they call them, these farright, they're infiltrating TPUSA, Turning Point USA, Charlie's group. I just saw this week reports that uh several four local TPUSA chapters in the US have invited this guy James Fishbach to speak. Fishbach ran

44:12

Speaker A

for some office in Florida. Is an open anti-semite pro- Hitler. They're inviting him, you know, and TPUSA leadership has tried to say no. The first time it happened, they said this was a one-off. They didn't have permission. Well, now you've got Ford

44:27

Speaker A

doing it. I don't think this is what the leadership wants, but it's what they it's wanted at the local level because that's where the energy is. It makes these young men feel empowered to hate.

44:38

Speaker A

I talked to when I was in Washington for that trip I told you about at lunch with an evangelical friend, very serious evangelical who works at a high level in politics in his 20s. He told me he was

44:50

Speaker A

thinking of leaving politics because the the anti-semitism, the Jew hatred has become so prevalent among his generation. He said, "I'm just sick of it." And um I said, "Even among Christians?" He goes, "Yeah, even among young Christians." And that's very distressing.

45:07

Speaker A

It is. And and I don't think that the pastors of my generation and older really even know this is happening. One of my good friends back in the US is a an evangelical college professor. He teaches at an elite evangelical college,

45:24

Speaker A

50 years old. He said that every one of the young men in his classes are deeply involved with online conspiracy theory with Nick Fuentes with anti-semitism.

45:35

Speaker A

And uh he said you can't talk to them about it. They have not been reasoned into it. They've been meme'd into it.

45:42

Speaker A

you know that that these lunatics on the far right speak to the sense of a genuine and often justified anger, dislocation, loss of purpose, dispossession that these young men feel.

45:58

Speaker A

And they're not getting any pl these young men are not getting any plausible reason to hope from the churches or institutions because so many of the pastors and the late leaders in the churches don't even know this is

46:10

Speaker A

happening. So, they're turning to the loonies online who are speaking to them. There's a point I'd just like to test you on here. You're a historian. Um, I'm a historian, but probably not a very deep I'm a journalist, so I'm self-taught.

46:26

Speaker A

Um, but, uh, I think there's something there's a challenge that needs to be thrown out here. I think you and I would agree that the rise in anti-semitism is truly troubling for anybody who believes in freedom. Uh, it really is. The the

46:41

Speaker A

basis of western freedom surely depends absolutely on the tree trunk of recognizing the dignity and worth of all. We of all people ought to be the ones who are against racism. And it comes from the Hebrew Bible. All men are

46:54

Speaker A

created in the image of God. Exactly. And it's the most ancient form of hatred of all anti-semitism. But the question I just wanted to put to you because it was put to me the other day and I I had to concede the point because

47:06

Speaker A

I'm sure it's right. Nowhere in history, whether it's and anti-semitism is, you know, as old as mankind, so to speak, has anti-semitism worked out well for Jews or for the perpetrators. Yeah. It's a disaster for everyone.

47:23

Speaker A

No one wins. History tells you that. It's almost a mathematical equation. You you go down that bunny hole and you end up buried. You know, some of these uh people uh say people on the far right will say,

47:38

Speaker A

"Well, look at all the most of the leaders of the of the Bullshurik revolution or Jews." That's true. But you know how they got that way? They got that way because Christians, Russian Orthodox Christians, and I'm Orthodox, persecuted them so horribly that um they

47:58

Speaker A

turned some of the intellectuals turned to the left seeking relief. I remember being in Moscow in 2019 when I was over there researching Live Not by Lies and I'd spent the previous three days talking to people who had survived the

48:13

Speaker A

goolag and just heard horror stories. On my last night in town, I uh was having dinner with a normal Russian Christian family and I made the mistake of saying, gosh, after all these stories I've heard, I think how could people have

48:28

Speaker A

been so foolish as to have ex believed the Bolsheviks? The father at the table.

48:34

Speaker A

Yeah, again, these are Christians. He said, "You want to know? I'll tell you that he went through a 400year history of how the wealthy and around the monarchy had ground the poor so horribly under the burdens of their servitude and

48:52

Speaker A

that no one got ground down more than the Jews that people were desperate for anything to deliver them from that system. And of course what they got was something even worse. And the man wasn't defending communism. He just thought it

49:06

Speaker A

was important for his American visitor to know that these things don't come from nowhere. In a similar way, when I finished reading all doing all my historical research about VHimar Germany, I thought what would I thought or felt feeling is more important in

49:22

Speaker A

this case. Had I been a 26 year old man in Germany raised in the chaos of the 20s and then finally you think we're coming out of it, the bottom falls out in the depression. Would I can I really

49:35

Speaker A

say that I would have been able to resist the charms of Hitler? No, I can't say that with any Tom Peterson.

49:41

Speaker A

Jordan Peterson makes that point. He he told an audience once, "The truth is that if you'd lived in Germany in the 1930s, overwhelmingly you'd have joined the Hitler Youth." Yeah.

49:52

Speaker A

And that's pretty confronting. You've just admitted it's confronting for you. It's confronting for me. Well, I grew up in a small southern town on the Mississippi River and I didn't learn till I was an adult that the Klutz clan

50:05

Speaker A

had been quite active in our we call it parish in Louisiana. It's a county been quite active there until just before I was born in 1967.

50:15

Speaker A

And uh it was shocking to me to realize that some of the older men that I grew up respecting in a small town, they these are respectable middle class churchgoing men had been in the clan.

50:29

Speaker A

And then I thought later, you know, that if I had been in that town then as an adult, I might not have joined the clan, but I wouldn't have spoken out against it. Because in that town in those days

50:42

Speaker A

to have spoken out against it would have required such immense courage. Yeah. And it might not have occurred to you. I I realized when thinking about the racism of my parents and grandparents generation, they grew up in a media

50:55

Speaker A

environment in which white supremacy was never challenged. You know, my my dad grew up at the radio. He was born in 1934.

51:04

Speaker A

Uh my mom, same thing. The only time I ever heard anything that race saying racism was wrong was watching television in the 1970s. Now, it wasn't like my parents and the culture around me raised me to think, you know, we're superior to black

51:20

Speaker A

people. You know that, right? You didn't have to. It was an ambient and TV brought in the challenge. Uh, but I had to think with more mercifully about my parents and grandparents' generation because if I had lived back

51:35

Speaker A

then, it would have happened to me too because I wouldn't have known any different.

51:38

Speaker A

It's an important principle that when we judge those who have gone before us because we don't teach our heroes anymore. We cast judgment on them. We tear down their statues. We cover them with red paint. We do whatever. We don't

51:50

Speaker A

contextualize it. We don't try and understand them in the context of their times. and they're stripping out of the story of our heroes, I think, as being part and parcel of the loss of our history and the fact that we're now so

52:04

Speaker A

easily persuaded. Yeah, you're exactly right. And it's part of the the atomization because you know at the conference today here in Ncon Paul Coleman from London talked about how the British people his people have been stripped of their history in

52:22

Speaker A

the last 30 years or so have been taught that your history is shameful. You know there's nothing to be proud of. Well, history is neither a a story of, you know, butterflies and bunny rabbits, nor is it hell on earth. It's it's a

52:37

Speaker A

mixture. But Paul said that when these people, the people, the young people raised in a culture in which you were told that everything that is part of your inheritance was bad and must be rejected if you're going to be a good

52:49

Speaker A

person. You atomize them. You alienate them. You think they have no past to be proud of or to build on and therefore no future.

52:58

Speaker A

One thing I like about Israel is this this is a people with historical memory and they've passed on the story.

53:06

Speaker A

They passed on the story. Even this was a surprise to me when I first came to Israel was to find out that even secular Israelis have respect for religion because they know that this is an inextricable part of their journey,

53:20

Speaker A

their 2,000 more than 2,000 years journey as a people. uh people that came out of Egypt were sent into Babylon then later sent into diaspora around the world. These are people who were formed by the journey. Part of our problem in

53:36

Speaker A

the west for us gentiles is we have lost that sense of journey. Uh one of my favorite sociologists is actually a Marxist. He died a few years ago, Ziggmat Bowman. It's a Polish Marxist, but he had a lot of really interesting

53:51

Speaker A

insights into how modernity works. He said that in the in past generations people experienced life ordinary life as a pilgrimage as a journey of meaning.

54:04

Speaker A

Everyone was going on it together like pil religious pilgrims you're going on it together. It has meaning. You're going to a particular place and you're passing familiar landmarks on the way in modern times. So the whole idea of a

54:19

Speaker A

pilgrimage has been destroyed. Now people are tourists. They can go where they want to go or not go there. They do it alone or with their chosen friends.

54:29

Speaker A

And they only go as as their desires take them. There's no shared journey. There's no journey to their lives.

54:36

Speaker A

There's no meaning, no logos to their own lives, much less the common life. So, uh, we have gone from pilgrim to tourist. And in so doing, I think we have lost a sense of purpose and meaning. The good news is, and it's time

54:52

Speaker A

for some good news, don't you think? I went to France last year to write a story about the annual pilgrimage to from Paris to Shatur, the cathedral town. It's a three-day walk from Paris.

55:06

Speaker A

43 years ago, 43 or 44, some Catholics there decided to revive the old tradition of taking the three-day pilgrimage. They gather in Paris. They walk for three days, camping on the way, singing hymns and other songs, s stopping to camp and celebrate mass and

55:24

Speaker A

just being together and talking about their faith. It culminates when they arrive at the cathedral, the medieval cathedral with a big mass. Well, uh, and it's been growing and growing. It it has especially grown in recent years. So, I

55:39

Speaker A

go there to write a story for the free press in New York about it. I arrived there in the most atheist country in Europe on the day of the pilgrimage starts. There are 20,000 young Catholics, mostly French, but some from

55:53

Speaker A

Canada, uh, and other parts of Europe. Average age 19. They're all there to spend three days walking and camping for Christ. And I stopped to ask these young people, "What brings you here?" You know, and I got a version of the same

56:08

Speaker A

answer every time. Our parents' generation gave us nothing. We're looking for meaning. We're looking for purpose. We're looking for community.

56:18

Speaker A

We're looking for God. And they I can't really express it strongly enough. They didn't seem goon like Jesus camp people. They seemed like perfectly normal kids. But they had realized that their society, their secular society had reached a dead end. If they weren't

56:38

Speaker A

going to be gone into nihilism or consumerism or convert to Islam or some form of political radicalism, they had better go back to Christianity, traditional Christianity, and they were doing it. It was the most hopeful thing I've seen in years because if it can

56:55

Speaker A

happen in France, it could happen anywhere. So on that slightly more optimistic note, because I share it with you, um I think two things are happening. One is that you're seeing and we're at a conference now where there are a lot of

57:13

Speaker A

wiser older people who are not only seeing what's happening but are starting to mount the arguments to change course and I think understanding which is the second part of it that the best of our young people are beginning to recognize the need to

57:34

Speaker A

change course. They are looking for better answers. You've outlined the real dangers of disaffected young people, young men in particular. The upside is that the best the cream of our youth after all they're the same genetics.

57:47

Speaker A

Yeah. We built great and free societies. Not perfect. Nobody argues that. But everybody's wanted to live in Western societies. They must have got something right.

57:57

Speaker A

Nobody's getting a dingy to go to Saudi Arabia or India or Morocco. So you got this line of genetics. It can't passes through us. May maybe we baby Burmers didn't pass the story on well enough, but our kids are of that

58:10

Speaker A

same line. There were heroes in the past. They can be heroes now. And you're talking about what you saw in France.

58:18

Speaker A

Uh I'm saying that we're seeing here a recognition now of the need to mount the arguments effectively. And I think that there are a lot of young people who really are beginning to see it. Is that what you're

58:32

Speaker A

Yeah, I I'm seeing that too. not enough yet, but there is reason for hope and we need to help encouer people of the older generation need to encourage these green shoots. But I think it's going to require more than arguments. You know,

58:47

Speaker A

Pope Benedict the 16th, not a Catholic, but he is one of my heroes of the faith.

58:53

Speaker A

Um, he said something really interesting once before he became pope. He said that in our time, reason is not enough. a sort of apologetics that's logical.

59:03

Speaker A

There's no reason not to do it. But people just today don't have the capacity to to take reason as people in the past did. He said the best way to reach out to people with the faith is through beauty and holiness through the

59:20

Speaker A

art and architecture the church has produced and through the saints. And the deeper point he was making is that you can't say no to beauty. You can't deny the experience of beauty whether it's a a painting, a a cathedral,

59:38

Speaker A

uh music, etc. That the simple normality of life that we started with and as well.

59:45

Speaker A

Exactly. As well. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. you it just if you have to slow down enough to take it all in and not be distracted. You also can't deny real holiness. Not just somebody being nice to somebody being holy. And

59:59

Speaker A

if you can plant those seeds in the heart of a searching p young person or person, then you can open their minds up to the arguments for the gospel. Well, I think the same principle could be applied to anything to our our attempt

60:14

Speaker A

to try to save what's we can of our own civilization. Take some take these young people on a tour of the battlegrounds or take them to to the great cathedrals of Europe or anywhere, you know, just but make it

60:30

Speaker A

concrete, open their hearts up because that's how I became a Christian, right? I had been raised a sort of Eastern Christmas Methodist in smalltown Louisiana. And by the time I got to be 15 or so, was the 80s, I decided

60:46

Speaker A

Christianity must be bunk. It's either the tepid middle class at prayer, which is what we had, or it's TV evangelist, and I don't want any of it. So, I spent two or three years as sort of a strong

61:00

Speaker A

agnostic. And then when I was 17 years old, my mother won in a church contest, a trip, a guided tour to Europe. She didn't want to go, but she knew that her son, me, that I was interested in seeing

61:13

Speaker A

the art museums of Paris, so she sent me. I was the only young person on a coach full of elderly American tourists.

61:20

Speaker A

I didn't care. I was going to Paris. On the road to Paris, we the coach stopped to go look at an old church. I almost didn't get off the bus because I didn't have any interest in an old

61:30

Speaker A

church, but I did. I didn't want to sit on the bus for an hour or so. This was the cathedral at Shatra. I walked into that cathedral. Not I've never heard of this place. And that's where I met God.

61:42

Speaker A

I was so overwhelmed by the beauty of this temple. I wanted to know instantly who is the God that inspired men whose names have been lost to history to build such a temple to his glory. I didn't walk out of there as a Christian, but I

61:58

Speaker A

walked out of there on a search. And the search I I read books. I struggled with myself for years. It ended with me about gosh almost eight years later, eight or nine years later as a young journalist going to interview him as my first job

62:14

Speaker A

as a journalist to interview an elderly Catholic priest who was nearing 100 years old uh who had left his career as an artist and an art professor uh to become a priest in the middle of his life. And I didn't know anything about

62:29

Speaker A

him. I sat down and asked him to tell me the story and manior Sanchez was like a little Yoda figure. short just light coming off of his face. And he told a story about how he had left he had grown

62:42

Speaker A

up in Guatemala. Parents were rich planters. They sent him to the Ivy League in America to get his education.

62:49

Speaker A

He lost his faith. He experienced two miracles that brought him not only to the faith, but convinced him in midlife to become a priest. Now, that's an interesting story. But here's the thing.

63:01

Speaker A

As that old man recalled these events of 50 years ago that caused him to abandon everything and give his life to Christ to serve as a priest, he was crying as if these events had happened last week.

63:13

Speaker A

I realized sitting there as a journalist, this man is a witness. He's telling me the truth. God is real and it's time for me to stop debating this in my head and make a commitment, make that leap of faith. So later when I read

63:28

Speaker A

what Ben, Pope Benedict, Joseph Ratzinger said about beauty and holiness being the gateways to accepting the gospel, I said that's what happened to me.

63:40

Speaker A

Well, in an age of despair, of low morale, of people thinking their country is going in the wrong direction, would it be fair to say that your message is, well, bring it back to the personal. Make your life a journey. Go

63:55

Speaker A

in pursuit of truth. There is peace to be found. There is meaning to be found.

64:00

Speaker A

It's not hopeless. It's not hopeless. You know, one of the great books people can read is called Man's Search for Meaning by Victor Frankl, a Jewish doctor who survived the death camps. And in it, Frankle said that when people have a sense of

64:17

Speaker A

meaning, of transcendent meaning, they can endure anything. I once had a conversation in Paris about 10 years ago with a well-known Jewish secular intellectual, a man I really respect who's taken strong stands against the far left. And I said to him, "Where do

64:37

Speaker A

you find hope?" And the poor man said quietly, "I have no hope." And I looked at him and said, "I do have hope, and my hope is in Jesus Christ. But I don't want you as a Frenchman to think I'm

64:49

Speaker A

saying that to you like some naive, you know, uh, TV evangelist. I believe things are going to get a lot worse before they get better. But hope for a Christian is not the same as optimism. You know, I'd like to be

65:04

Speaker A

optimistic, but sometimes living in reality means you can't be optimistic. But to be hopeful is to believe that no matter how much we suffer that our suffering has meaning if it's united to Christ and it's united to serving Christ

65:19

Speaker A

and serving Christ's people. Otherwise why would we value the martyrs those who gave their lives for Jesus and who are giving their lives for Jesus every day in Nigeria in China and other places. Um that's what Christian hope is. I said we

65:35

Speaker A

may let to see the fall of the west. I hope not, but it might happen. But I'm not going to lose hope because I'm I believe in a resurrected Christ. And that is that is what gives me the reason

65:47

Speaker A

to get up and keep going and to keep serving him to keep rejoicing to When had a great the poet had a great line, stagger on rejoicing. That's how I live.

65:59

Speaker A

The Frenchman looked at me and said he he was respectful. He said, 'Well, that's good for you Americans, but here in France, we don't believe in God. End of conversation. And I thought, that poor man, he really doesn't have hope.

66:13

Speaker A

Once you have closed off the possibility that God exists and that you can know him and allow him to know you, then what do you have? You have the despair I saw sitting across from me that day at a

66:25

Speaker A

cafe on the left bank in Paris. The young French have had enough of that.

66:30

Speaker A

They know they can't live on that. And so they want something better. That's why recently we saw on TV hundreds of thousands of French people lining the streets of Paris to welcome Pope Leo. It warmed my heart. I thought now will all

66:46

Speaker A

those people be in church on Sunday? Probably not. But in this time of great despair and darkness and chaos in France, the fact that the French people had three days of that joy, that joy that was there by

67:00

Speaker A

this man who came as a representative of Jesus Christ, it reminded them of who they were. If we are going to save what we have, not only save it, but renew it and make it grow again, it's going to

67:13

Speaker A

have to be an act of collective memory. And it's not going to come easy.

67:17

Speaker A

Nobody's going to do the remembering for us. We have to do it ourselves. For ourselves, for our families, for our friends, and for our communities.

Topics: totalitarianism Rod Dreher Weimar America Christianity cultural decline young men hope Israel Western civilization populism

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/#from=transcript&id=96531)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/#from=transcript&id=96531)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/#from=transcript&id=96531)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/#from=transcript&id=96531)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/#from=transcript&id=96531)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/weimar-america-totalitarianism-coming-rod-dreher/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
