**The Social Weapons You Create Will Be Used Against You — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/social-weapons-created-used-against/

Paul VanderKlay reflects on a recent live-stream 'embarrassment,' the role of YouTube titling, and how Constantine-era church-state struggles shaped Western religion, monarchy, and modern 'woke' cultu

## Key Takeaways

- Ideas are best processed collaboratively, and VanderKlay's audience-driven format reflects that belief.
- Church-state entanglement from Constantine onward has shaped Western monarchy, governance, and cultural authority.
- Social and rhetorical weapons are symmetrical: tools built by one faction are typically adopted and turned back by the other.
- The question of who holds judgment and what counts as the chief sin reveals deeper cultural assumptions.

## What the video covers

- Paul VanderKlay opens by reacting to a community live-stream dispute on Luke's channel and explains why he treats his videos as a way to process ideas with his audience.
- He describes the difficulty of titling and thumbnailing videos, contrasting his unpolished process with the curated approach of typical content creators.
- He references Ed West's story of Lucy Connelly, a British mother jailed for inflammatory Twitter posts, as an example of the current dominant cultural religion.
- He traces church-state history from Constantine through ultramontanism and the founding of the United States, arguing that monarchical ceremony and ecclesiastical authority have long intertwined.
- He draws a parallel between the British monarchy's impotence as a safeguard against accountability and his own moderation style on his channel.
- He discusses Versailles and the interwar period as a turning point in modernity and the construction of new legal orders.
- He frames judgment and hierarchy as central issues in the debate, noting how societies choose which sins become 'chief sins,' using Nazi crimes as an example.
- He argues that 'woke' ideology is not inherently left or right, citing the cancellation of Father James Martin as an example of cross-spectrum dynamics.
- He suggests that each side of a culture war tends to adopt the weapons used by the other, so tools deployed against one group are eventually used against its creators.
- He uses a Sacramento school racial-slur incident and the Gideon narrative from the Book of Judges to illustrate how cultural weapons and reactions play out.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Opening and reflection on the live-stream embarrassment
2. 02:18 Process of titling and sharing ideas with the audience
3. 05:05 Lucy Connelly case and the current dominant religion
4. 08:16 Constantine, church-state history, and ultramontanism
5. 16:16 Monarchy, Versailles, and modernity
6. 23:56 Judgment, hierarchy, and the Nazi 'chief sin' question
7. 31:20 Woke culture beyond left and right; Father James Martin case
8. 39:40 Symmetry of social weapons and the Sacramento school incident
9. 51:20 Gideon narrative from the Book of Judges

Answers

## Questions about this video

Why does VanderKlay say he is a selfish YouTuber?

He says he processes his thoughts publicly with viewers, so the videos are partly a way for him to think aloud with the community. He contrasts this with creators who polish ideas before publishing.

What is the Lucy Connelly story he references?

He cites Ed West's account of Lucy Connelly, a British mother who was jailed for inflammatory Twitter posts after believing immigrants were responsible for a child's murder. He presents it as an example of a dominant cultural force.

What argument does he make about social weapons?

He argues that once one side develops a rhetorical or social weapon, the other side will adopt it, which tends to neutralize the weapon. He illustrates this with his own experiences and cultural changes since the 1960s and 70s.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:01

Speaker A

Hi, this is Paul. Just finished listening to what Fleebus quite remarkably labeled our triannual embarrassment that happened over on Luke's live stream when he entitles the stream uh this little corner of the in is this little corner of the internet

00:18

Speaker A

demonic and uh just had uh when when the you know if what is the TLC is it or isn't it yada yada yada but it's just so funny because uh we we sure have our regular their family fights here and uh

00:34

Speaker A

so it was it was it was our trianual embarrassment in full force and uh so I'll put the link below if if you care to watch that. Uh I thought Luke's um I thought Luke's the way Luke does his

00:50

Speaker A

live streams is he sort of wrangles with things initially. I mean, and that, you know, what Luke is doing there is very much what I do with these videos where I I've got I've got to be in my bonnet. I've got something

01:02

Speaker A

in my head and I've just got to get it out and it's unformed and I have to talk about it and, you know, I you know, this started because who who can I talk about this stuff with? And that's so true of

01:15

Speaker A

of many of us. And so then we go to the internet and then we find each other and we talk with each other about it and we might not get to an answer on and on and on and on and on. So it was it was good.

01:28

Speaker A

Now I had um made the Scott Adams video yesterday when um I heard the news and I watched his video and I thought, "Yeah, I want to I want to talk about that. I want to get it out." And I had intended because just

01:41

Speaker A

the way my schedule was going Monday, I thought I'd have time for another video.

01:44

Speaker A

And in fact, I made another video and I made another video on the Pujo video.

01:48

Speaker A

And there's going to be some repetition in this video from that video. So don't feel under any compulsion to pay $3 to become a member. But um you know half of a video is is trying to title the darn thing because trying

02:04

Speaker A

to title the darn thing is to try to first I come to the video with just some angst and then I just vomit it out into the camera through to some of you who watch it and then of course you talk

02:18

Speaker A

back and that's really helpful and then by the end of the video it's like well what do I think and then I have to title it and thumbnail it and that's sort of Okay, I've I've sort of taken it apart. Now I have to summarize

02:30

Speaker A

it and I have to put it Google gives me a hundred characters. It's like even more restricted Twitter and I have to somehow come up with a name that communicates something about the video.

02:42

Speaker A

And and again, this is totally opposite what content creators do. What content creators do is they they have an idea and then they shape and then they fuss and they perfect and they edit and they get it just to the point that either the

02:56

Speaker A

demands of publishing require or they achieve a level of satisfaction and then they present it to the world. And that's why I said I always say I'm a very selfish YouTuber because in some ways I'm just sort of I'm I'm doing all my

03:10

Speaker A

processing with you and and you're doing it with me. And I think that's really what this little corner is about. It's trying to process together, which makes our our trianual embarrassment all the more both understandable and necessary.

03:27

Speaker A

And I'm just thrilled that Luke get Luke got to host it this time. So, uh, for those of you who are members, you can watch that video. And I also struggled as to whether or not to put that video

03:37

Speaker A

out because there's now as we're sort of coming down from see see Jonathan got Jonathan got something really right in this video which is the the postwar this is shaped by the current spirit the current religion the current religion that's not

04:01

Speaker A

a quite a religion the current dominant religion that's pervading either in agreement or opposition almost all Christianity in the west the current religion that's dominating governments Ed West who is a uh a substacker I haven't upgraded to paid

04:22

Speaker A

for him yet um has I think it was Kings North that pointed my way to West and and he has this story about this woman Lucy Connelly who is a rather fierce mother of children. She calls herself just

04:39

Speaker A

ridiculously overprotected. She basically uh came to believe that um well there was there were some uh a child murder that happened and she came to believe that you know perhaps some immigrant men were responsible and so she let loose on Twitter and she's

05:01

Speaker A

serving time in jail in the UK for this and it's it's a it's a gripping story.

05:06

Speaker A

I'll put a and this one this one of his is out in the open. It's not um it's not behind the payw wall and and it gets into so so part of what happens in the American religious experiment. Boy, this is so basically

05:28

Speaker A

you have it all starts with Constantine the 13th apostle as John Ali says. John Ali, distinguished professor of church history and uh Catholic priest who's written these books on Vatican 1, these series of lectures on Vatican 2 and

05:45

Speaker A

history of the papacy. He's sort of been one of my chief sources for information about the Roman Catholic Church and the papacy and the the history of Latin Christendom because of course Protestants, many Protestants, especially sort of magisterial

05:59

Speaker A

Protestants are right there in the line of Latin Christendom. But what happens in the great American experiment of course is that these rebels and of course um you know the Orthodox when they hear that well and and part of what I'm seeing

06:18

Speaker A

with orthodoxy I mean Luke said some things in his live stream this morning that were like wow you're you're you're still a an undeconstructed Protestant on many ways. And I don't think Luke will take offense at that. Luke Luke doesn't

06:32

Speaker A

take offense. Uh so what happens is you have of course since Constantine you have one way to think about the the history of the church between Constantine and the founding of America is this big struggle between church and state and especially when you

06:55

Speaker A

get to ultraontinism which is which is sort of the very high pope. The pope is the bishop of Rome, but he's also sort of a monarch. And that remains today when we watch all of the all of the ceremony

07:09

Speaker A

around the new pope. This is all monarchical ceremony. And so if you watch, let's say, the coronation of Prince Charles and you watch the selection of a new pope, um it's not a hereditary monarchy in that way. Again

07:26

Speaker A

the church is a little different but it is a monarchy and it's intended to be such and the the pageanty and the coding between let's say secular monarchy uh let's say civil monarchy and ecclesiastical monarchy they've been swapping code all along and just to read

07:46

Speaker A

the his Christian history in the Latin west but to a certain degree in the east as well because that they both come from Constantine.

07:56

Speaker A

is this struggle between these two institutions of church and state. And so, of course, at the founding of the United States, you get the separation of church and state. And that's that's a that's a serious trial that sort of begins at

08:16

Speaker A

that point. And in many ways for um for the last couple hundred years has been successful because that way of arrangement very much began to seep back into Europe. Whereas many of these governments let's say they're a constitutional monarchy. They still have

08:37

Speaker A

a state church but the church doesn't really have much power. And what's so interesting about England is that, you know, that there's plenty of critiques of the crown, but one thing is true of the crown that the monarch might in some ways have

08:56

Speaker A

ostensibly some political power yet. But the rule of the monarchy is thou must not use thy power. At least that's what the crown presented with respect to Elizabeth. Because the day the monarch begins to exert political power once

09:15

Speaker A

more is the day the monarchy is threatened and in some ways held accountable. And so the ceremonial titular monarchy of the UK basically maintains itself by being impotent and it might have influential power. You could say that in that way I

09:38

Speaker A

am the monarch of the TLC because with very few exceptions I don't ban people. I'll ban people quicker from a live stream than I will from a comment section. Um, but I, you know, Jacob's critiques of me are, you

09:53

Speaker A

know, have very much have to do with, um, to what degree I either exercise or fail to exercise monarchical power in whatever my relationship with what has sort of happened behind me. Um, I think that gives me way way too much credit

10:10

Speaker A

for what has happened behind me and for what I have done, frankly. and Jacob sort of limits it limits that to Bridges of Meaning and and that whole episode.

10:21

Speaker A

Um, but I I never I never thought that this would all be contained by a Discord server. Um, it's not even it's at this point mostly contained by YouTube, but but not completely, which is why there's estuary and there are conferences and

10:36

Speaker A

and all of these things. So what happens in the United States is that there's no longer an institution. There's no longer an institution that is governing, but there is a spirit. And the spirit is is very much the spirit that holds certain

10:59

Speaker A

Protestant, they were called mainline denominations together. And and it's a spirit that sort of holds that together.

11:07

Speaker A

And and what happens in the 20th century, of course, is you have the first world war and Woodro Wilson has this vision for a new world order, the League of Nations.

11:20

Speaker A

He goes to Versailles. He's he sees the calamity in many ways sort of the end of a certain chapter of modernity that dies in the trenches of the first world war and sees an opportunity to reconstruct a new world of laws. And so if you read

11:37

Speaker A

the history after the first world war of woodro Wilson one of the things that happens is via the league of nation they make they make war illegal. So let's war is a problem. let's pass a law and if we

11:52

Speaker A

pass a law that says no more war, well then there'll be no more wars. But the United States is a really reluctant monarch and is at home with the degree of chaos that quite clearly many European nations are not in agreement

12:09

Speaker A

with. And so, you know, currently we have the most chaotic president that certainly we've had in my lifetime. and he is he is a chaos animal. And it's I I would say that in some ways we're in American Ragnarok

12:24

Speaker A

right now. We're in American apocalypse right now. But one of the ways to understand these large governing spirits that govern civilizations and one might argue that the United States, Western Europe, these these this is Latin Christendom is one large

12:45

Speaker A

civilization and you know another large civilization is obviously China. Another large civilization is what remains of, let's say, what remains of the great Norse civilizations, which one might say is Russia, which still has a lot of Norse roose

13:06

Speaker A

um energy to it. And of course, we have yet to see what kind of civilizations will emerge out of places like Africa and South America.

13:17

Speaker A

um don't seem to be emerging anytime quickly at least on the level of let's say Latin Christristendom Russia China is interesting if you look at last Friday's live stream and a lot of Caleb's contributions and then actually on Sunday in our own estuary there's um

13:40

Speaker A

an individual of Chinese descent um who he's not actually a member of my local church but he's a very faithful uh participant and contributor by virtue of certain particularities of his life and and he could really identify with

13:54

Speaker A

what had Caleb said and we talked a lot about that in estuary and we talked about um I talked about some of those things without you know you know with him on SJ he's followed the channel for a long time

14:05

Speaker A

and you know these these massive religious civilizational spirits that are governing Now I played the beginning of this and maybe I'll play it again here because I think Andrew Doyle So, actually today's trianual embarrassment.

14:36

Speaker A

Today's trianual embarrassment very much, you know, brought up all of these issues, issues of hierarchy, issues of institution, and and one of the biggest ones is issues of judgment.

14:53

Speaker A

One of the main things that happens that that sort of triggered the fight between let's say classic liberalism and sort of the re recession of classic liberalism is the judging someone's racism. You know, that's a deep issue because she's doing she's doing time for

15:18

Speaker A

racist tweets. But as the article goes, there are many reasons to suspect that she's not a racist per se. And I think a go-to think piece on racism is um Slatear Codeex classic post from June 21, 2027 against

15:41

Speaker A

murderism. Because what what you begin to as you sort of peer into this, you begin to see that when you're talking about racism, and I consider anti-semitism to sort of be a variant of racism, at least the way it's leveraged

15:56

Speaker A

today. I don't know that anti-semitism has always been racism. Anti-semitism for me is a very strange dynamic. And and I think in that way it's it's sort of an evil spirit that continues to plague the world. And given

16:12

Speaker A

my Christian predelections and you know I you know I as I've spoken about before on my father's side I have a lot of um and now after Jason Staples I don't know whether to call it Israelite legacy heritage or Jewish

16:33

Speaker A

heritage but my great great-grandfather I think was put out of the Jewish community and the Netherlands, I I suspect, for marrying outside of the tribe. He married a Dutch or a Fian girl. And that then set into motion a course of events which led to

16:56

Speaker A

their immigration to the United States. and as immigrating to the United States, not from Russia or any of these large classic Jewish communities, he and his son and their family just assimilated with the Dutch.

17:13

Speaker A

And and once we learned that via genealogy to discover that I'm related to the Marx brothers of all people, you know, I couldn't be I couldn't be related to Nobel laureates. I had to be related to the Marx brothers. But they

17:28

Speaker A

they go to western Michigan and they assimilate with the the Dutch Calvinists and then my grandfather becomes a Dutch Calvinist minister and my father becomes a Dutch Calvinist minister and I become a Dutch Calvinist minister. So to what

17:44

Speaker A

degree, you know, I I obviously in a matrinal sense I'm not a I'm not a Jew, but I have Jewish heritage. But anti-semitis seminism is a strange strange thing and and in that sense um but I think today partly because racism has

18:07

Speaker A

become the chief sin you know it's interesting that if you look at the many sins of the Nazis it it's telling of us what we imagine their chief sin to be and and so to sort of figure that

18:24

Speaker A

out. But you know what happens in the uh triannual um our triannual meeting of shame and embarrassment that we put on is that someone is labeled by someone else as an anti-semite and other people look at that and say we're not

18:46

Speaker A

sure. Now, part of this has everything to do with the the war in the Middle East, and so much of the woke rights stuff has to do with, well, if you're on this side of the line, then you're this,

18:59

Speaker A

and if you're on that side of the line, then you're that. And so, so then we had this episode of woke and then that word gets coined and I remember before the word was coined, people were sort of flailing about

19:13

Speaker A

trying to find it. and the way it's sort of an emergent property the way that the word and the term gets coined and then of course Andrew Doyle was was quite okay was quite key and instrumental of that and so we've done a lot of thinking

19:27

Speaker A

about it he's done some publishing of it and he he begins with a definition here is dying for every reaction you have an equal and o okay wokeness is dying for every reaction you have an equal and opposite reaction and we're now in a

19:42

Speaker A

backlash Yeah. What do you make of that? Well, what is it you said constantly?

19:48

Speaker A

Because I quoted you in the book on that. You said every retardation has an equal and opposite retardation. It does.

19:52

Speaker A

And every retardation has an equal and opposite retardation. And uh it's very clever and probably trueish. Talking about the woke right, that phrase, the woke right, which I I I've been very surprised at the how upset people get about that

20:08

Speaker A

label. Uh have you? Yeah. actually genuinely genuinely surprised. I'm not surprised at all. Well, may maybe you're more keyed into this than I am because because you know I see the way people talk to you and James Lindsay and the

20:19

Speaker A

people who are using the term and I've tried to outline what I think woke right it mean but to me woke was never about left or right anyway. Like to me woke and and I think I think he's on to

20:32

Speaker A

something right there. woke was never really about left or right because so one of you sent to me uh victory father James Martin cancelled after Catholic protest watch Father James Martin so-called rainbow Jesuit was set to speak at Holy Family

20:50

Speaker A

University 2025 graduation May 17 um until faithful Catholics took a stand after the TFP student action petition gathered 11,000 signatures and a public rosary rally was planned. HFU quietly removed Father Martin from the commencement speaker list. Cancelling was not invented by the woke left. And

21:14

Speaker A

um cancelling has been has long been something that groups have done and it's it's part of activism. Activism says if you don't like something, have a mass, have a petition. And and these things have been around for a long time. In

21:29

Speaker A

fact, the Christian Reformed Church Order actually has a statement that petitions are illegal in the Christian Reformed Church. Um, which which I think is a great thing because what happens often in a church fight is that the council will make a decision and then

21:47

Speaker A

somebody in church doesn't like it. So, they write a petition and they pass a petition around and they hold it in front of the council and the Christian form church said, "None of that, you.

21:56

Speaker A

We're a hierarchy here. we're a weird hierarchy that doesn't have a person at the top but has councils at the top. But that's what kind of hierarchy we are. So no petition. But then of course they sort of rub against American nonprofit

22:09

Speaker A

rules that say well the council and in fact even within Christian form church order that the council is elected by the congregation and on and on we go. So you know Andrew Andrew Doyle's point is important was I mean I define

22:26

Speaker A

wokeness as a short term as the uh cultural revolution that seeks inequity according to group identity through authoritarian means. I think that inequity according to group identity through authoritarian means. But of course, these group identities are tricky because how do you

22:45

Speaker A

manage these group identities? They're they're really really tricky. And of course, the woke left. Well, what was really new about the woke left? That's hard to say. Less than we imagined. And I'm not saying there was nothing new, but the fact, as I

23:03

Speaker A

mentioned in an earlier video, just by virtue of Gerardian mimemetic rivalry, once one group develops a weapon, the other group will work to develop it and employ it. That's that's what happens in conflicts. And once a weapon gets traction and especially in

23:22

Speaker A

sort of a social conflict, not a physical conflict, when someone develops a weapon, what that development is is a revelation that the social dynamics of that weapon will work across the divide.

23:41

Speaker A

So by definition, once one side discovers and implements a weapon, the other side will do it. And what will tend to happen is it will nullify it. For me, who grew up in the 60s and 70s, who grew

24:00

Speaker A

up in a racial reconciliation church, who grew up with Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. as a sacred figure, as a hero who grew up with parents who practiced not just anti-racism in theory or anti-racism as activist or anti-racism

24:20

Speaker A

as project, but grew up with racial integration as a life commitment because that's where I grew up. That's how I grew up. I I didn't know black people as an archetype or an image on the television. I was raised as a minority

24:41

Speaker A

white person in a majority black community by design. That's what my parents chose to do and mission accomplished. And what you learn when you grow up as a child as a minority in a majority other community is you get to

24:57

Speaker A

see that community real close because they probably said and did things in front of me that they wouldn't do in front of my parents because I'm a child.

25:05

Speaker A

But then you begin to realize that so many of these dynamics between people aren't necessarily a function of their cultural group or their ethnic group or their racial group. It's a function of broader human dynamics and and the way

25:22

Speaker A

that mimetic rivalry works in terms of social conflict and structure because again once that weapon finds traction across the board it will be implemented by both groups until it's nullified or it just keeps getting used even as it

25:45

Speaker A

diminishes. And so when I I watched this whole woke thing arise, it was like this is going to set back some really valid critiques and accomplishments that we've achieved with respect to racism. This is going to set this back

26:04

Speaker A

because now someone's going to call someone else a racist or an anti-semite and they're going to say and that's exactly what's happening in the culture now. So once you create that that mimemetic rivalry and you weaponize certain words and you weaponize certain

26:23

Speaker A

identities, I watched a um what was I watching last night? Oh, jury duty. And so you've got these basically it's it's a whole group of actors and there's one guy who isn't an actor supposedly who's in the mix. And so one

26:39

Speaker A

guy, an actor, decides at this fake jury that he's going to try and get out of jury duty by identifying himself as a racist because the one guy said he had seen that on um on Family Guy. And so he tries that.

26:56

Speaker A

And of course, it's but the what what's interesting about this show is that if it's true that the one guy isn't in on the joke, the writers and the creators of the show, it's sort of this giant improv that's happening because the guy

27:14

Speaker A

who comes into the mix says, "I saw this on Family Guy." And so now within the confines of the show and the fake trial and all of that, one guy stands up and tries it. And of course, it doesn't work

27:25

Speaker A

at all. In fact, it's a disaster because here in California, you've got a racially diverse group and of course, everybody looks at them because you've just transgressed the cultural sacred element that defines the culture. And of course, part of what happens in the

27:45

Speaker A

Second World War is very interesting. Well, let's finish. Let's finish this. That covers it. Well, you can be on the right, left, or anywhere in between and still be obsessed with group identity and still be obsessed with imposing

27:57

Speaker A

through authoritarian means your values. So, wokeness was never for me about left and right. And I actually think it went so far because we misunderstood the culture war as a question of left versus right. And it never ever was.

28:08

Speaker A

Authoritarians exist across the political spectrum. They can emerge from anywhere at any time. You know, you can't pin it down to left or right, much as people like to do so. And I think when they do that, there's a kind of

28:18

Speaker A

tribalism there. It's like I don't want my team to be accused of this, right? I think that's partly what's going on there. To say uh that there's such a thing as woke left, people on the woke on the left who are woke and people on

28:28

Speaker A

the right who are woke makes complete sense to me. Of course, there are identity obsessed monoomaniacs on both sides of the political spectrum who want you to shut up, who want to censor you and want to do and you know they they

28:38

Speaker A

follow the same template. This is and I think when it gets down to okay, what he just said there is so important. We'll we'll play it again.

28:47

Speaker A

isn't to that there's such a thing as woke left. People on the woke on the left who are woke and people on the right who are woke makes complete sense to me. Of course, there are identity obsessed monomomaniacs on both sides of

28:56

Speaker A

the political spectrum who want you to shut up, who want to censor you and want to do and you know they they follow the same template. This is the irony of mimemetic rivalry is the more one side focuses on

29:12

Speaker A

defeating something like racism, the more weapons you give to the other side. I've told this story before. I remember someone wrote a racial slur in a Sacramento public school and I just watched the school just go into contortions about

29:34

Speaker A

this and it turned out that when they finally caught the person who wrote the racial slur, it was an African-American female student who wrote the racial slur. And I've seen that again and again in public schools because kids aren't dumb. Many kids are

29:53

Speaker A

starving for attention. If you want attention, what do you do? You pull down the sacred thing. Piss Christ. Same thing. I mean, it's it's it's the it's in some ways the most immature reliable trick in the book to attack

30:13

Speaker A

whatever is sacred in a local religion to to get after it. Anybody who wants to read a great story should read the Bible because the greatest stories in the world are in the Bible. And the book of Judges has amazing stories. And

30:32

Speaker A

if you know, everybody knows about Gideon and the jars and the trumpets, but you really should read the story of Gideon from the beginning because the Israelites did evil in the eyes of the Lord. And for seven years, he gave them into the hands

30:45

Speaker A

of the Midionites. Because the power of Midian was so oppressive, the Israelites prepared shelters for themselves in mountain cliffs, caves, and strongholds.

30:54

Speaker A

Whenever the Israelites planted their crops, the Midionites, the Amalocites, and other eastern people invaded the country. They camped on the land and ruined the crops. all the way to Gaza and did not spare a living thing for Israel. Neither sheep nor cattle nor

31:05

Speaker A

donkeys. Just look at the history of um let's say the the conquest of the Navajo in the West with Kiss Kit Carson. It's basically how Kit Carson conquered the Navajo. Um and they did exactly the same thing. They they they went to canyon

31:22

Speaker A

retreats to try to hide from the Americans and and Kit Carson tried to, you know, basically subdue the Navajo because of a longstanding struggle between the Navajo earlier Hispanic settlers and um and then the new American settlers who were

31:39

Speaker A

coming in. When Israel cried out to the Lord because of Midian, he sent them a prophet who said um this is what the Lord God says. I brought you out of Egypt, out of the land of slavery. I

31:50

Speaker A

rescued you from the hand of the Egyptians and I delivered you from the hand of all your oppressors. I drove them out before you and gave their land.

31:57

Speaker A

I said to you, I am the Lord your God. Do not worship the gods of the Ammon the Amorites in whose land I you live. Um but you have not listened to me. The angel of the Lord came and sat down

32:08

Speaker A

under the oak of um of Oprah that belonged to Joash the Abizerite where his son Gideon was threshing wheat in a wine press to keep it from the Midionites. And that's just an amazing image where okay, I've I've got some wheat

32:25

Speaker A

that nobody's stolen from me yet. So, this is where we can eat. But generally speaking, what you do on a threshing floor is you find a a place that sort of has some elevation. So it gets some wind

32:36

Speaker A

and it's a hard flat surface. So you you can thresh, you know, you use a flail or something to separate the wheat from the chaff and the chaff blows away and leaves the wheat. But you can't do that because if

32:49

Speaker A

if the Midianites and the enemies see you threshing wheat, they'll come and they'll take your wheat and then you're going to starve again. So you find a wine press which is the opposite of that. And so you just get the sense

32:59

Speaker A

because a wine press is basically a an enclosed thing which is small. And so you're trying to thresh your your wheat in the wine press and I mean it's it's just the most ridiculous image. And so here's Gideon and you get the sense that

33:12

Speaker A

Gideon is you know potentially great warrior. This is what's going to call and he's great warrior is threshing his wheat in a wine press. I mean the it's just it's just mindboglingly great storytelling. You know, this is why

33:30

Speaker A

Martin Shaw is returning to the Bible because there's so much material and even Protestants who are more devoted to the Bible than any of the other Christian factions and devote it to memory and make their kids learn it. You

33:44

Speaker A

know, this wasn't a story that was sort of fleshed out for me as a young man, but it's amazing. We're reading through the book of we were reading through the book of Judges in our men's Bible study and and and we've got, you know, at

33:56

Speaker A

least one person in that's never read any of these stories. And it is so much fun reading these stories with someone who has who has never seen these stories. So here he is threshing wheat in this wine press to keep it from the

34:10

Speaker A

Midionites when the angel of the Lord appeared to Gideon and said, "The Lord is with you, mighty warrior." It's the irony there. Mighty warrior, unafraid of the Midionites, man among men, someone who's not ashamed. I'm here in this wine fest trying to thresh a

34:28

Speaker A

little bit of wheat so I can eat a little food cuz I'm so afraid of the Midionites. The Lord is with you, mighty warrior. Who me? Pardon me, my lord, Gideon replied, but if the Lord is with us, why has all

34:41

Speaker A

this happened to us? Where is the karma? Come on, Lord. We're looking at how we're doing below, and we're measuring our relationship with you with how we're doing below. Just like the book of of Deuteronomy says, we're not mighty. We're we're the

34:57

Speaker A

slaves of the Midians, but we're we're we're it's even a worse kind of slavery because they don't even need to make us farm. We just farm in the hopes that we can keep something to eat.

35:12

Speaker A

Did not the Lord bring us out of Egypt? Now the Lord has abandoned us and given us into the hands of Midians. Ah, but you remember the word of the Lord came through a prophet and said, "I've not

35:21

Speaker A

abandoned you. You've abandoned me." So now you have these you have the Lord and Israel and no, you abandoned me. No, you abandoned me. No, you abandoned me. It's sort of an echo of Moses and God in the

35:31

Speaker A

wilderness. No, they're your people. No, they're your people. It's a great storytelling. The Lord turned to him and said, "Go in the strength you have and save Israel out of Midian's hands. Am I not sending you?" Um, and I love it because the Lord

35:49

Speaker A

always comes sort of an incognito in the angel of the Lord and am I not sending you? There he is threshing wheat in the wine press. Little coward that he is. Uh, pardon me, Lord, Gideon said, but how can I save Israel? My clan is

36:08

Speaker A

the weakest in Manasseh, and I am the least in the family. Don't you see me threshing wheat in a wine press? I didn't know this was going to turn into a Bible study, but here we go.

36:19

Speaker A

Why stop now? Gideon replied, "If I found favor in your eyes, give me a sign that it is really you talking to me. Cuz I'm just see kind of seeing a dude. And you angels, sometimes you come in all your

36:32

Speaker A

majesty and your glory and your brightness and we hit the ground and pee ourselves and say, "Get away from me." You just sneak up on me like some old dude and say, "Mighty warrior, the Lord is with you." So, if you really are not

36:47

Speaker A

just some crackpot who came in here, you got to show me you got to show me some divine power because then I'll know. Now, if I found favor in your eyes, give me a sign that you really are

37:04

Speaker A

um you talking to me. Please do not go away until I come back and bring my offering set up before you. Gideon's got his manners. He's going to present an offering. He's going to take a risk.

37:12

Speaker A

Food is scarce, but hey, you know, it's not every day that someone has the hutbah to to show up and say, "This is the Lord speaking to you.

37:22

Speaker A

So, I'll make an offering just in case, cuz yeah, I don't want to offend you, cuz that would go really poorly." So, Gideon went inside, prepared a young goat, and from an epha of flour, he had made bread without yeast. putting them

37:37

Speaker A

the meat into a basket and its broth in a pot. He brought them out and offered them to him under the oak, a little offering. The angel of the Lord said, "Take the meat and the unleavened bread, place them on this rock, and pour out

37:49

Speaker A

the broth." It's like, "Now, wait, wait, wait, wait. I'm I'm I'm threshing wheat in a wine press cuz I'm such a a soy boy and I'm scared to death of the Midians and we have like nothing to eat and I take the chance

38:08

Speaker A

that you're not just some crazy dude walking through town to actually give you some of my precious food which I offer in terms of hospitality andor religious and you want me to what with it? I mean, why don't why don't you let

38:25

Speaker A

me eat it? We're hungry. I'm threshing wheat in a wine press after all. Take the meat and the unleavened bread and place them on this rock and pour out the broth. Okay. And Gideon did so. Then the angel of the Lord touched

38:41

Speaker A

the meat and the unleavened bread with the tip of the staff that was in his hand and fire flared from the rock consuming the meat and the bread. It's this tiny little Mount Carmel situation.

38:53

Speaker A

And the angel of the Lord disappeared. Oh well, maybe I can start believing in myself as a mighty warrior. Gideon beans. It's going to take more signs for Gideon. It's I mean, he's got a lot on the line here. So, you know, we who live

39:10

Speaker A

comfortable, secure lives shouldn't um look too down on him. And Gideon realized that it was the angel of the Lord. He exclaimed, "Alas, sovereign Lord, I have seen the angel of the Lord face to face. And you know

39:21

Speaker A

what? You see God, you die. Ah, but the Lord said to him, "Peace, do not be afraid. You're not going to die." Soy boy Gideon, you know, it's going to take some It's going to take some building up. So Gideon built an altar to the Lord

39:39

Speaker A

there and called it, "The Lord is peace. On this day, it stands that Oprah of the Beeserites." See and again so then the readers of the book of judges could go there and say this is where it happened.

39:52

Speaker A

You see that altar you know the whole high places all all that history but this altar remains because Gideon so you know it's a shrine you know Protestants always tension with that but there it is. It's a holy place sort of like Billy Graham's

40:07

Speaker A

desk in Jordan Hall's house. So Gideon built an altar to the Lord and called to the Lord his peace.

40:15

Speaker A

That same night, the Lord said to him, "Take the second bull from your father's herd." Oo, now you know, before it was a goat. Now we're looking at a bull. Take the second bull from your father's herd.

40:27

Speaker A

The one seven years old, special number. Tear down your father's altar to Baal. See, that's how bad things had gotten. The prophet was right. That's how bad things are gotten.

40:38

Speaker A

And Gideon Gideon's just like this normal human being that's like, "What has what has God ever done for me? My life's tragic. Here I am. I'm I'm beating I'm threshing wheat in a wine press because God hasn't saved us from

40:50

Speaker A

the Midianites. Who who didn't do what the Lord says. But I'm going to stay relating to you even though you're a worthless soy boy and a sinner and unfaithful and have everything wrong.

41:05

Speaker A

I'm going to keep working on you, Gideon. I'm going to make something out of you.

41:12

Speaker A

tear down your father's altar to bail and cut down the asher pole beside it. So, so Gideon, your father has a altar to Baal and an Asher pole next to it and you've got the hutbah to blame God for Israel's mis misery after fully

41:30

Speaker A

understanding what the covenant says. Brazen. brazen but clueless. Then build a proper kind of altar to the Lord your God on top of this height using the wood of the asherupole that you cut down. Offer the second bull as a burnt

41:53

Speaker A

offering. All right, Gideon, we're leveling up here. So Gideon took 10 of his servants and did as the Lord told him. But because he was afraid of his family and the town's people, he did it at night rather than in the daytime.

42:07

Speaker A

He's such a weenie. But God's going to make a mighty warrior out of him. Um, in the morning when the people of the town got up, there was barrel where there was Barl's altar demolished and the aspole cut down and the second

42:23

Speaker A

bull sacrificed on a newly built altar. And they asked, he said, "Who did this?" The people of the down demanded of Joash, "Bring your son. He must die because he has broken down Baal's altar and cut down the ash or pole beside it.

42:37

Speaker A

I love how people read the Old Testament like it's terrible. Oh, this capital punishment. It's like uh capital punishment was pretty much just kind of normal. You know, people read it. It's like that's horrible. Well, it's only horrible because you've had 2,000 years

42:51

Speaker A

of Christian culture to soak in since then. Sorry. Um I think Tom Holland's right.

43:04

Speaker A

But Joash replied to the hostile crowd around her, "Are you going to plead Ba's cause? Are you going to save him?

43:10

Speaker A

Whoever fights for him shall be put to death by mourning. If Baal really is a god," see this a little sort of mini Mount Carmel with Elijah and the prophets of Baal. Um, he can defend himself when someone breaks down his

43:23

Speaker A

altar. So because J because Gideon broke down Baal's altar, he gave him the name Jerub Baal that day, saying, "Let Baal contend with him." Saying, "See, see what God has done now." Step by step by step by step, God is not only building

43:40

Speaker A

up Gideon to save Israel from the Midianites, but he's also contending with Baal by sending Gideon and say, "Deal with soy boy here. I'm taking this soy boy. I'm gonna make him a judge.

43:55

Speaker A

He's gonna be a mighty man. It's gonna kind of be a mess, too. That's because that's the book of Judges. Boy, it's so bad when you just the preacher gets distracted with his preaching. I got to leave soon because I got a meeting. I

44:08

Speaker A

don't know when meeting starts. I think the meeting starts. I think I get there by 11:30. I'll be okay. I got more time.

44:13

Speaker A

So, Andrew Doyle, I think, is right. But, well, let's a little bit more. isn't to me a controversial thing, but I'd also say when you talk about your quotation about retardation, uh, which I know is a very upsetting term for some

44:26

Speaker A

people, but it just means to go backwards, Anyway, um, so no, it does. Um, but but you know, yeah. So, sorry, where was I? I'm talking about this idea of of of wokeness transcending the political uh boundary. Why is that

44:39

Speaker A

so upsetting to people? Well, I I think it's to do with tribe. I think we have I think right and left are redundant at this point. So I don't think talking in terms of I think if you for many many

44:48

Speaker A

years obsessively and I'm talking here about the woke hijgemony those who were in control of all our major institutions when they for many many years go on about how group identity is everything race sexual orientation sect these are the things that matter the

45:04

Speaker A

most gender identity whatever you as an individual matters less than what group you belong to and of course then so I think he nicely shows that this left Right. And of course, remember the left right thing came from the French

45:18

Speaker A

Revolution. That's still with us. You know, before Hitler was the devil, do you know who the devil in Europe was before Hitler? It was Napoleon Bonapart.

45:29

Speaker A

You know where the word boogeyman comes from? Allegedly, supposedly comes from Bony Man, which is Bonapart, which is boogeyman.

45:39

Speaker A

We set up these these these religious spirits just pervade. Now I don't know how long this is going to go. So, so PJO makes this video and there's another dude who made a video, used almost the same thumbnail

46:01

Speaker A

except put put Kanye in it and was making the same points, but he doesn't mention Pujo at all. And I'm like, dude, what are you doing? I mean, he made it like the day after PJO, and it's like,

46:15

Speaker A

is this is this is this some kind of way to ride on Jonathan's coattails without giving Jonathan any credit?

46:23

Speaker A

Anyway, um this this what PJO is getting at here, it isn't obviously just because of Nazis. The point about the altar is once you make something sacred, you've opened it up to attack. And we've seen this in the West with respect to Christianity.

46:44

Speaker A

But Christianity because of how Jesus works is a little bit more difficult to attack. And and this is part of I'm going to I'm going to have to get into this whole thing because it's not just the Nazis because the Nazis are in some

47:02

Speaker A

ways in tension with the Japanese. Um because yeah that's a complex dynamic but it's also the bomb like Stories of Old has a great video that's actually in the I play some of it in the um the membership video on

47:21

Speaker A

the bomb. But it's not just the Nazis. It's not just the bomb. It's also the civil rights movement. And those things sort of come together to create this religion that reached the ascent and is now crumbling. And Donald Trump is sort

47:42

Speaker A

of like that great monster in Ragnarok who is coming and destroying, you know, the kingdom of Odin. Yeah. I I I I sort of I sort of I like the Gideon story. I like the Gideon story.

48:00

Speaker A

Um, oh, stream two minutes ago. I missed a Grim Grizz stream. Shoot. Thumbnail. He puts a thumbnail on the live stream.

48:08

Speaker A

Grizz, you got You gotta love Grizz. Anyway, um, I'm gonna have to figure out what to title this video. I think I know. So, leave a comment. Let me know what you think.

Topics: Paul VanderKlay church and state Constantine monarchy woke culture culture war Western Christianity Ed West Book of Judges free speech

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/#from=transcript&id=94411)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/#from=transcript&id=94411)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/#from=transcript&id=94411)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/#from=transcript&id=94411)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/#from=transcript&id=94411)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/social-weapons-created-used-against/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
