**The Current Orthodox Schism: Russia and Constantinople: Causes and Consequences — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/russia-constantinople-orthodox-schism-causes-consequences/

Eugene Gotwalt explains the 2018 Russia–Constantinople schism over Ukrainian Orthodox autocephaly, its historical roots, and the canonical dispute over patriarchal authority.

## Key Takeaways

- The schism stems from the 2018 granting of autocephaly to the Ukrainian Orthodox Church by Constantinople, rejected by Moscow.
- The central dispute is canonical: whether the Ecumenical Patriarch can act alone or needs consensus of the local Orthodox churches.
- The break has spread beyond Russia and Constantinople to several other Orthodox churches.
- The speaker frames the conflict as a question of Orthodox conciliarity versus papal-style authority, with real consequences for lay believers.

## What the video covers

- In October 2018 the Russian Orthodox Church broke communion with the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople after it granted autocephaly to the Orthodox Church of Ukraine.
- Russia later broke communion with the Churches of Greece, Alexandria and Cyprus (2019-2020), which also recognized the new Ukrainian church.
- The speaker gives a brief history beginning with Prince Vladimir of Kiev's conversion to Orthodox Christianity in 988 and the early subordination of Russian clergy to Constantinople.
- Moscow became an independent patriarchate by 1560, and in 1990 was granted a self-governing status over the Ukrainian church.
- After Ukraine's 1991 independence, Ukrainian bishops sought autocephaly, which Moscow refused.
- The Ecumenical Patriarch argued he held a final appeal court role and authority over diaspora Orthodox Christians, and could grant autocephaly.
- Most other Orthodox primates had accepted Russia's position that only a consensus of the local churches can grant autocephaly, which the speaker says was not obtained.
- The speaker criticizes the Ecumenical Patriarch for acting like a pope with absolute authority, contrary to conciliar Orthodox practice.
- He also notes the practical effects of the schism on ordinary Orthodox faithful, including his own experience attending parishes across jurisdictions.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Introduction: the 2018 Russia–Constantinople break
2. 00:57 Other churches that recognized Ukraine
3. 02:06 Early history: Vladimir and the conversion of Rus
4. 03:50 Russian church growth and Ukrainian self-governance
5. 05:12 Ukraine's 1991 autocephaly request and Moscow's response
6. 06:26 The 2018 decision and the canonical dispute
7. 07:57 Constantinople's claimed authority and the papal comparison
8. 10:54 Personal reflections and effects on the faithful

Answers

## Questions about this video

Why did the Russian Orthodox Church break communion with Constantinople?

Moscow broke communion in 2018 after the Ecumenical Patriarch granted autocephaly to the Orthodox Church of Ukraine, which Moscow viewed as a violation of its canonical territory. The speaker explains that Moscow considered this decision outside Constantinople's authority.

What argument did the Ecumenical Patriarch make for granting autocephaly?

According to the speaker, the Ecumenical Patriarch claimed a final court of appeal role across Orthodoxy, exclusive rights to convene other primates, and ecclesiastical authority over diaspora Orthodox Christians. He also argued that Constantinople had historical jurisdiction over Ukraine.

Which churches broke communion with Russia over this issue?

The speaker says Russia broke communion with the Churches of Greece, Alexandria and Cyprus after they recognized the Orthodox Church of Ukraine, in 2019 and 2020 respectively. Alexandria and Greece acted in 2019 and Cyprus in 2020.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:01

Speaker A

In October of 2018, the Russian Orthodox Church broke communion with the ecumenical patriarch of Constantinople.

00:11

Speaker A

Now, this was not with the entire Greek Orthodox Church, but specifically with the patriarchy of Constantinople.

00:21

Speaker A

This break occurred after Constantinople recognized the altosephil independence of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, a move that the Russian Orthodox Church viewed as a violation of canonical territory.

00:37

Speaker A

And after that, and I'm going to just talk about the break with the ecumenical patriarch, but Russia broke communion with four other Orthodox churches. one being the church of Greece. That was in 2019 after they recognized the Orthodox

00:57

Speaker A

Church of Ukraine. The same thing happened with the patriarchic of Alexandria. They recognized the Orthodox Church of Ukraine. And also in 2020, the church of Cyprus did the same thing.

01:13

Speaker A

Moscow broke communion with them. Now, to explain this, I'm just going to give you a very short history of the Russian Orthodox Church. Now, I do have a video about the situation between Russia and Ukraine right now. If you want more

01:30

Speaker A

details, I'll put a card, drop it in up top, and leave a link below. And we have to start off with Prince Vladimir of Kiev who ruled a domain that stretched from beyond Nogarad to the north and beyond Kiev in the south. He understood

01:48

Speaker A

the importance of religion not only for the spiritual life of his people but also for their political, social and cultural advancement. At first he promoted devotion to the ancient gods and goddesses of the Slavs. But in 986 he began to take interest in the

02:06

Speaker A

religion of other lands. Islam in old Bulgaria, Judaism in Cazeria, Roman Catholicism in the Holy Roman Empire, and Greek Orthodox Christianity in Bzantium.

02:22

Speaker A

In the following year, he sent emissaries to see for themselves these various religions in action. Based upon the reports that he got back, he made up his mind to adopt Orthodox Christianity for himself and his people. Vladimir sent a message to Emperor Basil II of

02:41

Speaker A

Bzantium and his brother Constantine VII asking for the hand of their sister, Princess Anna, in marriage. They answered that Vladimir needed to be Orthodox for this to happen. And he responded saying he had already given some study to the Greeks faith and was

02:59

Speaker A

ready to be baptized. The Greeks replied telling Vladimir to come to Constantinople to be baptized.

03:06

Speaker A

But then he requested to be baptized in Shirzon and they agreed to his wishes.

03:13

Speaker A

Upon his return to Kief, his capital city in the spring of 988. The people of the city and the surrounding countryside joyfully accepted to be baptized in the Niper River in the new faith of their beloved prince. Thus began the history

03:29

Speaker A

of the Orthodox Church in the lands of Ruse. And over the next few centuries, Orthodox Russians were under the jurisdiction of Constantinople.

03:39

Speaker A

Constantinople would send priests and bishops to Russia to teach the faith. Eventually, Russians were chosen to be bishops after confirmation by Constantinople.

03:50

Speaker A

Russia would then develop into what we call an autonomous church led by Metropolitan, a senior bishop. And by 1560, Moscow was accepted to be an independent patriarch, an independent Orthodox church. And as the Russian church grew, they were governing over such a large

04:13

Speaker A

area which had two different languages being used. And October 28th, 1990, the Moscow patriarchic granted the Orthodox Church in Ukraine a status of a self-governing church under the jurisdiction of the Russian Orthodox Church. Then we had the declaration of

04:37

Speaker A

independence from the Soviet Union done by Ukraine on 24th August 1991. Uh national meeting of the bishops of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church was held.

04:49

Speaker A

During the meeting of these bishops and they were joined by other clergy and lay delegates, they unanimously passed a resolution that henceforth the Ukrainian Orthodox Church would operate as an autotophilis church, an independent patriarchic basically. And so they

05:12

Speaker A

submitted a request for autophille to the Moscow patriarch. Moscow said, "No, you are not breaking away from the jurisdiction of Moscow." So the Ukrainian Orthodox Church persisted. So you had this situation where some in Ukraine wanted to break away from

05:32

Speaker A

Moscow, some didn't. And then we ran into the incident that became the genesis for this break of communion. In 2018, the ecumenical patriarch overrode the previous judgment of the Russian Orthodox Church regarding the independence of the Ukrainian Orthodox

05:54

Speaker A

Church while at the same time it reclaimed its canonical jurisdiction over Ukraine. In other words, oh they used to say that Ukraine fell under the jurisdiction of Russia which at one time was under the jurisdiction of Constantinople.

06:16

Speaker A

So what the ecumenical patriarch decided was Russia's still independence but since we used to have control over Ukraine we're going to say we now have control over the Ukrainian church again.

06:31

Speaker A

So on the 15th of December 2018 he granted altophille to the orthodox church of Ukraine. Now prior to 2018 all the Orthodox primates accepted as fact that Russia was an autophilus church an independent church with the Ukrainian Orthodox Church being an

06:59

Speaker A

autonomous church under the jurisdiction of the Russian Orthodox Church. And the majority of the other churches stated that the ecumenical patriarch did not have the power to declare autotophille for the Ukrainian church. And it was in response to this action by the

07:24

Speaker A

ecumenical patriarch, the Russian Orthodox Church broke communion with Constantinople. And you ended up with two Orthodox Churches in Ukraine.

07:37

Speaker A

The Ukrainian Orthodox Church under the jurisdiction of the Russian Orthodox Church, basically the same church that was always there. Then you had the Orthodox Church of Ukraine with at the time only the church in Constantinople considering it a canonical independent

07:57

Speaker A

church. Now I did mention earlier that Cyprus, Alexandria, the church of Greece, they also agreed that it was an independent church. And this was the argument that the ecumenical patriarch put forth. The patriarch of Constantinople claims that the

08:18

Speaker A

ecumenical patriarch had the right to establish a court of final appeal for any case from anywhere in the orthodox world. The ecumenical patriarch had the right, the exclusive right to summon other patriarchs and heads of the autotophilus churches, the independent

08:40

Speaker A

churches to a joint meeting of all of them. Now, this is where it gets a little controversial.

08:49

Speaker A

The ecumenical patriarch has jurisdiction, ecclesiastical authority over Orthodox Christians who are outside the territory of the local Orthodox churches, the so-called dysporia.

09:05

Speaker A

And this basically means the ecumenical patriarch claims that the dysphoria from Serbia Romania Moscow, in other words, Orthodox Christians from those countries who moved to America and are now attending Serbian Romanian Russian etc.

09:28

Speaker A

Orthodox churches. He claims he has ecclesiastical authority over them. And the big one, no new autophilus church, and I keep repeating myself, no new independent church can come into being without the consent of the patriarch of Constantinople.

09:51

Speaker A

And this is the important part. This consent should express the consensus of the local Orthodox churches. Without a doubt, the ecumenical patriarch did not get the consent of the other Orthodox churches. He independently granted independence to the Ukrainian

10:17

Speaker A

Orthodox Church. And as I said, none of the other Orthodox churches except for those few thought this was within the power of the patriarch of Constantinople.

10:32

Speaker A

And I'm sorry, but it looks to me that the ecumenical patriarch is acting like a pope, the pope of Rome, who thinks he has total absolute control over all of orthodoxy. And that's never been the way the Orthodox church operates. It's

10:53

Speaker A

always a consensus of all the independent churches, the patriarchs, the bishops that would be required to grant independence to a church. And that's why even today there's something called the Orthodox Church of America, which is a rather large church. It has

11:11

Speaker A

700 parishes, missions, communities, monasteries and institutions in the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Approximately 85,000 members in the US. And Constantinople has never recognized the OCA, which a lot of the other churches do accept the OCA. So, do I think

11:40

Speaker A

this schism, this breaking communion between Moscow and Constantinople can be settled anytime soon? Well, if we look at a little bit of history, there is a firstism between the ecumenical patriarch of Constantinople and the Russian Orthodox Church. And this is

12:03

Speaker A

when the ecumenical patriarch decided pretty much on his own to form a union with the Roman Catholic Church.

12:13

Speaker A

Basically, Constantinople was being invaded. I think he said, "Oh, we'll join Rome. Maybe they'll send troops to help us." I could do a whole video on that schism.

12:26

Speaker A

that lasted from 1467 to 1560 almost a hundred years. So, well, this current sism lasts a hundred years. Who knows? But I do see an issue. Say the ecumenical patriarch changes his mind or he reposes and they elect a new ecumenical patriarch. And

12:51

Speaker A

what if he says, "Well, the last guy wasn't correct, so no more accepting the Orthodox Church of Ukraine." that's just going to cause problems in the country of Ukraine.

13:06

Speaker A

That that that would be a mess. So, you'd have to find some way to fix that problem.

13:15

Speaker A

And I just don't know how you would go about that. So, what why is this important? Why is it important to us little people, us Orthodox in the United States who are just going to our churches, things like that? Quick little

13:32

Speaker A

story. When I first became Orthodox here in Tucson, we went to services that were jointly held by the local Antiocan church and the local Greek church. The Antiocians were building a new church.

13:45

Speaker A

So, they sold their old building to get the money to build the new one. So for a year or so they had joint services and we got to meet the Antiocian priest of course and we eventually joined the

13:58

Speaker A

Antiochan church and the Greek Orthodox priest Father Earl Condos great guy Father Earl and Father Earl was at St.

14:06

Speaker A

Demetrius and there were a lot of times where we would attend services at St. Demetrius because like on feast days, one church would have the service in the evening, some one church would have it in the morning. So based upon our schedules,

14:24

Speaker A

sometimes it was more convenient because my work schedule to go to St. Demetrius. And let me tell you, Father Earl always made us feel welcome. He actually told me once he considered us members of St.

14:38

Speaker A

Demetrius Greek Orthodox Church, even though we weren't on the rolls or anything like that, but we're all one church. You're welcome here. You're one of us. Well, Father Earl is no longer in Tucson, but up closer to Phoenix, he

14:54

Speaker A

started a mission church up there that's doing really well. And then I started going to the local Russian Orthodox church. And this was before they broke communion with each other.

15:07

Speaker A

But now Russian church doesn't recognize the church in Constantinople. I keep on saying Constantinople. I know it's this damn bowl, but that's just traditionally what we call it. I technically am not allowed to attend services at Father Earl's New Mission Church. And I

15:32

Speaker A

went up to my priest, Father Denil at the Russian Orthodox Church, and I said something. Hey, Father, when we're out camping, if we're up by Phoenix, I'd like to go to Father Earl's church. And he knew who Father Earl was. He says,

15:47

Speaker A

"Jean, no." Said, "Father, Father Earl is my friend, and I I would like to attend services and spend some time with him." And Father Denal begrudgingly said, "Okay, Jean, go to the service.

16:05

Speaker A

Don't take communion." That'd be crossing the line. You can attend. Don't take communion. And that was simply because I made the case, come on, I know Father Earl, we have a relationship. But then again, I think about Father Denal.

16:21

Speaker A

We have a very nice Greek Orthodox monastery up near Phoenix. And any Orthodox male feeling a little stressed, need some spiritual refreshment, you're more than welcome to spend a couple days up at St. Anony's.

16:42

Speaker A

And they don't charge you for it or anything. You're just welcome. It's why monasteries were originally established.

16:49

Speaker A

Well, the purpose of them was to provide hotel rooms basically back before there were hotels and motel for people that were doing pilgrimages to the Holy Land.

17:01

Speaker A

And they still keep that tradition. And I'm quite sure somebody like Father Denil might want to take a few days off, go up there and just spend time with the monks and the priests up there. He can't do it. And there's no way we can have

17:19

Speaker A

joint services between St. Demetrius and Holy Virgin, the Russian Orthodox Church. And technically, I shouldn't be going up to St. Anony's.

17:33

Speaker A

And my wife and I, we camp a lot. And sometimes where we're camping, and it's all over the West Coast, when it comes to Orthodox churches, there's not a lot of them. And sometimes the only option is a Greek church, but technically I

17:48

Speaker A

shouldn't be going to them. So it does have an effect on what I'm calling us little people down here on the ground.

17:56

Speaker A

You know, we sometimes look at and here's the patriarchs fighting with each other. But hey guys, remember that has effects down here too. So that's my thoughts on the current situation between Russia and Constantinople.

18:12

Speaker A

way beyond my pay grade. How or when this will be solved, don't know. I can pray for it to happen, but that's about it. And if you found it interesting, as I always say in these videos, little button right down there, it says

18:29

Speaker A

subscribe. You're already logged in YouTube. It takes you two seconds to go click on there. I would appreciate it.

18:37

Speaker A

And let me know what you think. Can the schism be healed? Or even who do you think's right, Russia or Constantinople?

18:46

Speaker A

I welcome all thoughts in the comments and make the comments so we can have debates, but so people can express their views and I'd really like to hear them and hey, maybe give it a video thumb up.

18:58

Speaker A

I'd appreciate it. Well, thank you for watching. I hope you found it interesting and have yourself a blessed day.

Topics: Orthodox schism Russian Orthodox Church Ecumenical Patriarch Ukrainian autocephaly Constantinople canon law Orthodox Church history communion

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/#from=transcript&id=96201)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/#from=transcript&id=96201)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/#from=transcript&id=96201)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/#from=transcript&id=96201)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/#from=transcript&id=96201)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/russia-constantinople-orthodox-schism-causes-consequences/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
