**The Lie of “It's Just a Social Construct” — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/lie-of-social-construct/

Jonathan Pageau examines why 'it's just a social construct' is used to dismiss religion and morality, arguing it rests on flawed assumptions about humans standing outside natural order.

## Key Takeaways

- 'Social construct' arguments often presuppose that only universal absolutes have authority, which is a questionable standard.
- Modern thinkers frequently treat humans as outside natural order while studying nature as ordered, creating a contradiction.
- Variation in practice does not prove arbitrariness; reality itself contains variation within underlying structures.
- Meaning and morality are better understood as participatory and embedded in reality than as projections of an isolated mind.

## What the video covers

- The 'social construct' argument is used to claim religious practices, morality, and social structures are relative and arbitrary, lacking universal authority.
- Pageau argues this reflects an Enlightenment-style demand that only universal absolutes can be morally defended.
- The argument is tied to a modern cultural emphasis on diversity and openness, which is often applied selectively to criticize unity or exclusion.
- Pageau identifies a contradiction in new atheist and scientific thinkers who study natural order in trees and animals but treat humans as standing outside that order.
- He critiques the idea that mind imposes meaning onto a meaningless world, arguing humans are embedded participants in reality, not detached observers.
- Pageau notes that the cosmic forces that produced the universe also produced human minds, so human intelligence is part of causality rather than separate from it.
- Variation across cultures does not disprove universal realities; variation exists within natural categories, as with dogs or church buildings.
- He uses examples like the value of gold and the natural cycles of days and hours to show that some human conventions are grounded in reality.
- Marriage and moral practices may vary, but variation has limits and does not make them arbitrary.
- Pageau concludes that humans must attend to what has been given and participate in it toward its purpose, rather than inventing structures from nothing.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Introduction: The 'Social Construct' Argument
2. 01:28 Relativism and the Enlightenment Vision of Morality
3. 02:50 Diversity as the Guiding Modern Value
4. 04:07 Mind, Body, and the Modern Split
5. 05:26 Scientists, Nature, and the Exclusion of Humans
6. 06:41 Critique of Mind Imposing Meaning on the World
7. 07:56 Variation Within Reality and the Limits of Diversity
8. 10:16 Gold, Time, and Conventions Grounded in Reality
9. 17:58 Conclusion: Participating in Given Reality

Answers

## Questions about this video

What does Pageau mean by the 'social construct' argument?

He describes it as a common claim that religion, morality, and social structures are merely relative human inventions. Pageau says this implies they lack universal authority and can be changed or rejected at will.

Why does Pageau criticize new atheist thinkers?

He argues they study natural causes and order in plants and animals but treat humans as somehow outside that order. He sees this as an inconsistent split between nature and human reason.

Does cultural variation prove that morality is arbitrary according to Pageau?

No. He argues that variation exists within reality generally, as with different church buildings or dogs, and that variation within a category does not mean the category is arbitrary.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00

Speaker A

One of the funny arguments you've probably heard against religion, against morality, against all kinds of things is that it is a social construct. This is something you'll hear all the time, you know, in your university classes and in

00:15

Speaker A

the media where when you try to argue for something, you try to argue for a moral position, you try to argue for a religious practice, you know, you try to argue for a, you know, a societal structure, people will say, "Oh, well,

00:30

Speaker A

that's just a social construct." And so, I want to think about this together with you as much as possible. Why is it that people are saying that? What does it mean? And ultimately, you know, why do people think that this is an argument?

00:47

Speaker A

And especially, how do we get out of it? This is Jonathan Pou. Welcome to the symbolic world.

01:07

Speaker A

[music] [music] So you've heard the argument many many times marriage is a social construct right you've heard it many times religion is a social construct and so when someone says that what they are implying is of course that it is

01:28

Speaker A

relative that is it doesn't have a universal claim you know what they seem to be doing is appealing uh in some ways to a kind of enlightenment vision of morality where the only way for something to be defended morally or a

01:44

Speaker A

practice to be to be defended is for it to have a kind of universal reality. And as soon as I can show that there is variation in this practice or variation in the the the way that it's done, then

01:58

Speaker A

it means that it doesn't actually have authority that it it cannot be completely defended and it is up to us, right? It is up to you and me, up to our societies, up to the individual to decide whether or not they're willing to

02:15

Speaker A

practice that and accept that. And there is of course for that reason there is no possibility of imposing this reality on anyone. The government or religion or parents have no claim to impose such things on their children or on the the

02:32

Speaker A

the people that they are in authority over. And why? Well, because it is relative because it is not universal. And therefore it is arbitrary. And this is of course what ultimately is being suggested by these types of argument. And so this is of

02:50

Speaker A

course very u very powerful in our society because in some ways what our society pron is variety. What our society pron is openness. At least in theory we know that that's not really what ends up happening. But at least in terms of

03:05

Speaker A

narrative what we're saying is that we need to allow for variability. We need to allow for difference. We need to allow for allow for diversity. And therefore this is of course the only guiding rule is this notion of

03:19

Speaker A

diversity. And in some ways anything that is moving towards unity or is moving towards exclusion is criticized for being a a social construct. And so now this type of thinking can really only hold in a few places. Of course, in

03:38

Speaker A

this weird idea that the only things that are valuable are absolute universals in the idea of course that everything is arbitrary and that in fact you know nothing has a kind of reality to it that everything is nominal that

03:53

Speaker A

all the structures that we participate could be this way or could be this way and either and all are equivalent and it doesn't really matter which one you choose. And it also at the same time is based on the notion

04:07

Speaker A

that there really is a split between you could say the mind and the body or there's some kind of weird split and this is the problem with so many of the modern kind of systems where in some ways the individual or the person or

04:22

Speaker A

society can somehow act completely idiosyncratically. that is that intelligence authority is is arbitrary in the in the wildest way that it could just be anything and it is only really ultimately will to power that it is only used in so much to control others and to

04:42

Speaker A

dominate over others right and so all of this is kind of implied in when someone says something like oh that's a social construct now one of the problems is the same problem that I see in so many of

04:56

Speaker A

the new atheist scient scientist types is that they always abstract themselves and they also somehow abstract humans out of the system of natural causes. So they look at the world and they see that there are natural causes and they see

05:13

Speaker A

that there are things happening in regular ways that you can identify that you can measure you know that you can point to and you can see the causalities and somehow they think that we are completely uh out of that that somehow

05:27

Speaker A

societies that somehow individuals people are not part of the natural order of things that you see out there. And so when they look at, you know, the way that a tree grows or the way that, you know, a wolf pack organizes themselves,

05:41

Speaker A

they'll see that there is this kind of natural order. But when then when they look at humans, then they will actually use the what they see out there to say, well, look at all these varieties of ways in which things can organize

05:55

Speaker A

themselves. And therefore, there is no way that humans should organize themselves. And in fact, it's completely up to us because we are outside of the system. And this is insane because what's fascinating about it is that on the one hand, it is a kind of weird

06:12

Speaker A

reductionism, you know, by which we just look at material causes and we kind of see how they function and and this idea that there is no God, there is no normative authority, you know, this rebellious kind of attitude towards reality where

06:26

Speaker A

that, you know, none of this really matters. there's a kind of nihilism that's implied. Um and so there's that on one side but then at the same time there's this weird idea that the humans exist in a kind of vacuum that is

06:41

Speaker A

outside of that system and in some ways mind is a is a kind of complete aberration on everything and therefore it has no relationship and so there's a deep contradiction you know about that and I see that you know I was listening

06:56

Speaker A

recently to a a clip of Alex Okconor where he was saying that he had basically come to the conclusion that his metaphysics were basically the idea that everything that we see out in a world is a construction of mind, right?

07:11

Speaker A

That it is not something that is real in itself, right? That it's the mind kind of imposing a structure on the on the world. And therefore, for that reason coming to the kind of the conclusion that meaning doesn't really exist

07:28

Speaker A

because it is a kind of projection of mind. And I'm just thinking why are you saying that? You're saying that only because you think that humans are somehow removed from the system and are not a part of the system of meaning,

07:41

Speaker A

right? That that we are standing in some weird like empty vacuum and we are looking at the world and we are imposing our meanings on the world and that there is this world that could or possibly could exist out there that would be

07:56

Speaker A

separate from us on which we're imposing the meaning. But this is of course a very weird way of looking at reality you know and and it brings about all these kinds of contradictions. Why not say that humans are in fact minds looking at

08:12

Speaker A

the world and is engaged in you know deciphering the categories of reality but they're doing that embedded in the world. They're doing it as they're participating and as they're being formed by what the potential that they're encountering. And this is a kind

08:27

Speaker A

of loop of attributing meaning, evaluating meaning because I die or I don't die because I feel pain or I don't feel pain and then continuing to kind of do that in a way that actually is the only way for reality to exist. There

08:43

Speaker A

can't be another way to kind of imagine that reality just exists out there in in a completely separate way from because the reality that exists out there is also using the same cosmic forces that were for me. No matter how you see it,

09:01

Speaker A

even if you don't believe in God, right? Even if you don't believe in God, you believe that the cosmic forces that the big bang and all of these cosmic forces that made the world what it is are also

09:11

Speaker A

the same cosmic forces that made me. And therefore, the fact that I am an intelligent being that is looking at the world is not something that is outside of the causality of the universe. It is the causality of the universe. Right?

09:25

Speaker A

And so this is of course the big problem when people say that everything is a social construct. Hello everyone. I'm excited to announce that the fourth book in our Tales for Once and Ever series is out, The Violent Little Taylor. This was

09:38

Speaker A

one of my favorite stories as a child. It's a story of trickery and of giant killing. And if you get it now until November 21st, you will get a free copy of the audio book read by myself. So, I

09:52

Speaker A

cannot wait for people to see it. It is beautifully illustrated by Eloise Sher who had illustrated our Jack and the Fallen Giants. And you will see that she did an amazing job. It feels like these illustrations are getting better and

10:04

Speaker A

better at every book. So, I cannot wait for you to have it in your hands and especially to know how your children react to this new story. Let's look at the the argument, right? So, people will say, for example, marriage is a social

10:16

Speaker A

construct. And the way that they will point to it is that they'll show that there's variation that of course there are different approaches to marriage that have existed in civilization from the beginning of time. uh and for that

10:30

Speaker A

reason they'll say well then there is no universal notion of marriage and of course this is this is wrong why is it that I can look at a category like dog and then I can see that there's variation in that category I can see

10:46

Speaker A

that there are different aspects of dogs that manifest themselves differently in different uh species and I can nonetheless because and through that variation see that there is such a thing as a dog. How is it that I can't apply

11:01

Speaker A

that to human things as well? So, the fact that there's variation doesn't mean that something doesn't exist. The fact that there's variation on a theme means that that this is how the world works.

11:13

Speaker A

The world works through, let's say, identities that have variation within them. And so the fact that I see that there's variation in different marriage practices doesn't mean that marriage doesn't exist and also doesn't mean that the version of

11:29

Speaker A

marriage that I am practicing and that not only practicing but that we even impose in our society isn't valid because just for the same reason that the dog doesn't stop being a dog just because they see that there are other

11:44

Speaker A

kinds of dog they it doesn't become an argument to invalidate their participation. in the main pattern. And of course, you'll say, well, this is this biological, you know, this is not the same as a behavior category. But you

11:56

Speaker A

could do the same with behaviors. You could look at animal species and look at their behaviors and see that different animal species that exist in different places have different behaviors regarding different aspects of reality, but it wouldn't invalidate the basic

12:12

Speaker A

notion. you know, because a predator hunts a certain way and this other predator hunts in a different way, you would say, well, it's all relative that it's all up to us. No, there's a reality of how to catch a prey and it has a a

12:26

Speaker A

reason. And then there's a aspect of variability, but there's a limit to that variability. You know, at some point you step out of the variability and you you actually undo the thing that you're looking at. And this is of course the

12:39

Speaker A

same for all the moral practices of a human being. This is the same for the the so-called social constructs of our society. So marriage has some variability to it but there's a limit to that variability.

12:54

Speaker A

At some point if you go beyond that limit of that variability then you start to lead to chaos right and you start to destroy the reason for which the the structure exists. And so, you know, there's now in California, I saw a

13:10

Speaker A

recent article that said that they are, you know, marrying the first thruples. You know, they're marrying three people together. This is something that has never existed before. And, you know, there has been, for example, men with several wives. But this idea that you

13:23

Speaker A

could just marry three people together. This is a complete kind of innovation. And it's not clear what it is based on.

13:30

Speaker A

it is doesn't seem to be based on what it is that marriage uh is aiming towards and there are consequences in some ways to moving away from these these ideas and so it's the same of course for religious practices every single church

13:47

Speaker A

in the world has differences right there is no carbon copy of exactly the same church building with exactly the same lit liturgical tradition and exactly the same you know That's just not that's not how reality works. Reality is variation

14:04

Speaker A

within unity. So there is a bond of unity that binds the the the Christian church together. Um but of course variability exists inside and that variability doesn't uh invalidate the unity of its participation.

14:20

Speaker A

You know it simply expresses it in variation. And this is of course the way of understanding all of the behaviors.

14:27

Speaker A

And so when you say that this is just a social construct and you you seem to imply in that that it has no grip that it has no like real meaning. This is a deep mistake and also you can't break it

14:43

Speaker A

because it actually does have a true real meaning that is held together in a way that no individual can destroy.

14:52

Speaker A

A simple example, you've probably heard people say this all the time, which is that the fact that gold has value is completely arbitrary. That it's just a social construct. It's just a a kind of social thing that we've accepted and

15:05

Speaker A

that, you know, just to tomorrow you could just decide that gold doesn't have any um any value at all. And if we decided that gold had no value, then it would have no value. And by the way, if

15:19

Speaker A

you think that, do I'm serious. Like, call me because then I'll just I'll take your gold and I'll be very happy to take it off your hands if you uh if you actually really think something as ridiculous as that. Um but in practice,

15:31

Speaker A

the reality is that these types of influences, the types of structures, they cannot be changed by individuals.

15:38

Speaker A

They cannot even be totally changed by societies. You see that happening during the French Revolution.

15:45

Speaker A

For example, there is the natural cycle of seven days, right? And the natural kind of cycle of the of the hours. And you know, there are variations on how to maybe calculate those a little bit in different societies. But you know

15:58

Speaker A

through the through I imagine through selection and you know let's say uh looking at the stars and participating in the natural cycles of reality we've come to these patterns of the 24-hour day you know the the 7-day week and you

16:13

Speaker A

simply cannot change it arbitrarily. During the French Revolution they tried to do that. They said no let's just make it all regular. Let's have 10 was it 10 day um 10 day weeks. And they tried to do this crazy thing where they tried to

16:28

Speaker A

make to change the very nature of how we participated in time and it was a very short experiment because people started to lose their minds and go completely crazy. So it doesn't mean that there isn't some variation. We've seen the

16:42

Speaker A

calendar change for example between the Julian calendar and the Gregorian calendar. We've seen changes, adaptations, trying to kind of make the calendar be more uh make more sense and kind of be more participative, but it doesn't mean that it's arbitrary and it

16:58

Speaker A

doesn't mean that it's a social construct and that we could just change it and we could just change it and it would be fine and I can just decide to go on another calendar or decide to practice a different morality and there

17:10

Speaker A

won't be consequences. These all these structures even though there are variations in them are a deep wisdom that has been acquired through hundreds and hundreds of generations of living in the world. And it's actually similar to this idea of of natural

17:30

Speaker A

selection, right? It's actually similar to the idea of natural selection is that there are things that have been developed by humanity over hundreds of generations. And even if you're not, if you don't believe in God, even if you're

17:42

Speaker A

a complete atheist, you should be able to see that these should not be messed with. And if you do mess with them, you mess with them to your peril because they they if you create mutations that are too outside of the mainstream, those

17:58

Speaker A

mutations will be sterile. Right? That's that's the problem with extreme mutation is that they don't yield a future world.

18:06

Speaker A

They are sterile. Therefore, you al always have to be attentive to what has been given to you until now and and participate in it in a way that you know is looking towards its purpose so that you don't create absolute chaos in

18:26

Speaker A

society. And so hopefully this is a little useful um thought on this problem. something that I'm sure everyone has had the experience of, especially if you've gone to college and you've encountered midwitz uh professors who like to propose their ridiculous

18:44

Speaker A

ideas by telling you that that everything you've learned, you know, that the societal structures, the societal bonds of father and mother and family, you know, of communities, of churches, that all of these are just social constructs, right? And the answer

19:00

Speaker A

is they are social constructs, but they're not just social constructs. Just is always the trigger word that as someone who is trying to understand symbolism should you should always be attentive to that word. When someone uses the word just, they're usually

19:14

Speaker A

trying to cover a multitude of sins with that word and they're not doing it appropriately. So even when someone says just, this is actually when your symbolic mind should wake up and you should start trying to pay attention to

19:28

Speaker A

what it is underneath the just. And usually there's a deep symbolic uh natural order that is hiding under the just. And so this is your this is your ultimate weapon against Neil Degrass Tyson and his ilk. I've talked about

19:42

Speaker A

this before, but hopefully this is a more detailed uh vision of this question. And so uh so thank you for your attention. Do not forget I am going to be on a cruise in Alaska next year from July 31st to August the 7th, 2027.

19:59

Speaker A

The places are limited and it's going to be a wild amazing time uh in Alaska. So if you want to come and you want to spend a week week with me, that would be a great opportunity. So I hope this

20:10

Speaker A

whole discussion has been useful to you and I'll talk to you very soon. Bye-bye.

Topics: social construct Jonathan Pageau relativism morality religion natural order symbolism new atheism meaning marriage

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/?from=transcript&id=95576)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/?from=transcript&id=95576)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/?from=transcript&id=95576)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/?from=transcript&id=95576)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/?from=transcript&id=95576)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/lie-of-social-construct/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
