**Identity and Values - Christianity After Postmodernism: Who is Man Today? — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/identity-values-christianity-postmodernism-who-man-today/

Panel discussion from Armenia on Christianity after postmodernism, featuring Jonathan Pageau and Pavel Shalin, on truth, technology, and the challenges facing faith today.

## Key Takeaways

- Postmodern relativism has eroded shared truth, pushing people toward self-referential beliefs.
- The pace of technological and social change is greater than most people acknowledge, and Christianity must respond to it.
- Christian formation depends on embodied practices, community, and presence rather than information alone.
- Nostalgia for an idealized past is not a constructive response; action in the present is needed.
- Marginal status can be a place of renewal and authentic witness.

## What the video covers

- The video opens with an introduction to an Armenian conference exploring the role of Christianity in the contemporary world and Armenia as a center of Christian dialogue.
- Speakers frame the present era as a 'flood' of rapid technological and social transformation whose scale many people have not yet fully grasped.
- Jonathan Pageau argues that the modern loss of a shared notion of truth leaves people relying on subjective 'truths', and describes truth as a single light shared by all.
- Pavel Shalin identifies a lack of imagination about the scale of change as the central challenge, and sees embracing that shift as the greatest opportunity.
- Discussion addresses the danger of tyrannies emerging from fragmentation and the risk of technology replacing embodied human relationships.
- Speakers reference Plato's Phaedrus, using the myth of Thoth and writing to illustrate how new technologies can shift human capacities.
- Concerns are raised about isolation enabled by online services, and about replacing practices such as shared meals, storytelling, and communion.
- The panel suggests that marginal communities, as the early Christians were, can be a source of renewal rather than only a weakness.
- Speakers emphasize presence, attentiveness to young people, and transmitting a real, embodied life rather than abstract ideas.
- The closing theme is that despite hardship, the moment holds a powerful opportunity for personal responsibility and spiritual renewal.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Introduction and Opening Question
2. 05:30 Welcome and Armenia's Significance
3. 09:35 Challenges and Opportunities of the Age
4. 15:36 Truth, Light, and the Crisis of Relativism
5. 27:00 Technology, Writing, and Human Capacities
6. 35:00 Isolation, Community, and Embodied Life
7. 50:00 Young People, Resistance, and Formation
8. 66:00 Personal Responsibility and Concrete Action

Answers

## Questions about this video

What is the main argument about truth in this video?

Jonathan Pageau argues that modern philosophy has failed to define truth, leading people to look for truth within themselves. He offers the metaphor of truth as a single light shared by everyone, which allows all things to be seen.

Why is Armenia significant in this discussion?

The speaker describes Armenia as a place of secret origins, linked to the story of Noah and as the first nation to convert to Christianity. This makes it a fitting setting for discussing new beginnings.

What do the speakers see as the greatest challenge today?

Pavel Shalin identifies a lack of imagination about the scale and speed of the current paradigm shift. He argues that people still resist accepting how rapidly social, technological, and economic conditions are changing.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:00

Speaker A

What would would Christianity look like after post-modernism? To me, truth is light. When you There is truth, you see everything.

00:08

Speaker A

[music] The more truth is there, the more you see. Just being human is not enough for us.

00:14

Speaker A

One needs to become a hero. One needs to [music] Like this feeling of inadequacy of the way I am, that's a good feeling.

00:22

Speaker A

As we exteriorize the power, we gain power, but we always lose power. A man cannot orient his life around an idea, only around an embodied idea.

00:34

Speaker A

What are the key characteristics of a modern human being? Right now, people have to remember, we have to celebrate, and out of that, then we have to create.

00:49

Speaker A

[music] Dear participants of the identity and values discussion series, [music] it's a great pleasure and privilege for me to welcome you today to this special gathering, where you will have the opportunity to meet some internationally renowned thinkers. Our guests today are

01:12

Speaker A

Jonathan Pageau, a distinguished artist, philosopher, and symbolist, and Pavel Shalin, a widely recognized philosopher and public intellectual, whose talks and discussions attract [music] audiences around the world, including here in Armenia. And of course, Aram Pachyanian needs no introduction. I believe you all

01:35

Speaker A

know him well. We have gathered here in Armenia for a very important mission. Over the past 3 days, we have been joined by prominent theologians, clergy, intellectuals, and Christian thinkers from different parts of the world. Our vision is to establish Armenia as a

01:56

Speaker A

center of profound Christian dialogue and intellectual reflection. [music] A place where Christian thought can flourish and from which meaningful messages [music] can reach the wider world. We seek to explore some of the most fundamental questions of [music] our time. What is

02:15

Speaker A

the role and mission of Christianity in the contemporary world? How should Christianity respond to the profound and rapidly accelerating transformations taking place around us? And what answers can Christian thought offer to the challenges facing humanity today?

02:39

Speaker A

[music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] Kyrie eleison. [singing] Kyrie eleison.

04:01

Speaker A

Kyrie eleison. [singing] Kyrie eleison. [music] [music] [music] Well, hello everyone. Uh thank you for coming today.

04:28

Speaker A

Obviously, first of all, I want to thank the Embryo Foundation for organizing this astounding event that we participated in, in which we were looking at the question of what the would Christianity look like after postmodernism.

04:42

Speaker A

You know, we were several of us were invited to come and for me there was something very intuitive about the possibility of having this discussion in Armenia.

04:53

Speaker A

I've been wanting to come to this nation for 20 years at least. I've been wanting to visit and one of the reasons why I am always been attracted to Armenia is because it is actually a place, we could call it a

05:07

Speaker A

place of secret origins. That is, although most of the West has forgotten the story, it is at the It is there right at the beginning of our age with the story of Noah being connected to this land. It is

05:21

Speaker A

there at the beginning of Christianity as being the first nation to convert to Christianity. And therefore, it made so much sense to think that in this now time of immense change and of great transition that coming here to be able

05:35

Speaker A

to discuss about what a new beginning would look like made so much sense to me.

05:40

Speaker A

And we really were a group of very diverse people sitting in that room trying to look at how do we look at the great changes that are facing us, the changes in society, the changes in politics, also the

05:55

Speaker A

changes in faith, how people perceive Christianity, how that is changing in the young people, and also the great changes in technology. What this wave of change with AI, with biotech, and some some of the very the huge transformation

06:12

Speaker A

technology, what they are bringing to us. Um and the people around the room are very diverse, but by the second day we really started to come together and to feel like that there was something that we can do and that there's something that

06:27

Speaker A

we can move uh forward. And so what I'd like to do is I'd like for the first question in some ways to be about that.

06:35

Speaker A

That is asking all of you here what are are you seeing as being the greatest challenges that are facing us? And what also are the opportunities that are growing at this time?

06:50

Speaker A

And maybe we can start with Pavel. Well, thank you very much for coming and thank you Amdocs Foundation for inviting me to speak today with such an esteemed crowd.

07:02

Speaker A

To your question, I guess sitting of the on the left from the center it's a duty to go to a limit.

07:09

Speaker A

And I would just say that key challenge I've seen over the actual these three days and more generally is almost a lack of imagination in the sense of the scale of catastrophe and the shift of paradigm which is happening right

07:25

Speaker A

now. Uh we still are in my opinion not willing to accept how rapidly uh like things that's have been self-evident for the last 400 years and became embedded in literally every element of the society around us from movement of people, from trade, from

07:52

Speaker A

speed of communication, technology exchange, like everything which we just effectively treat as a part of nature is coming well, catastrophe is one way of seeing, but I think here it would be appropriate to one sort of flood or another.

08:09

Speaker A

And that's I think presents the biggest challenge because to start remembering, and that's on the positive side, the cures for these challenges, we need first to see them and name them, which is on the one hand the most human activity we do,

08:29

Speaker A

but the unwillingness to embrace the scale on many levels and desire to wish it away with some sort of magical formula or the other is also is also still present. And I would argue that the greatest opportunity right now is that this is

08:49

Speaker A

I mean the embracement or like aligning with this, I don't know, spirit of shift of time is at the same time the greatest opportunity because if nobody is doing it right now effectively on a collective scale, well, whoever does it will be the

09:06

Speaker A

first one and we will get out there first. That's where I would have started.

09:13

Speaker A

Um well, I agree with Pavel and we several times for several times during the discussion we called what is going on as a flood.

09:23

Speaker A

Um and I want to add to the flood, I mean flood is when there is too much water, but also there is no light.

09:31

Speaker A

Um so it's dark. And what the darkness is coming from is from the absence of truth.

09:38

Speaker A

Like uh the philosophers, the modern philosophers, tried to define what the truth is. Well, it's it's hard. I Actually, it's impossible, but they tried that. And the reason why it's impossible is very simple. Imagine you suggested something to be a truth, right? A formula

09:54

Speaker A

definition. Then the definition should be true. But to check if it's true, you should understand what truth is.

10:01

Speaker A

And the result is actually very strange. The result is, for instance, a statements such such as uh whatever I say is true.

10:10

Speaker A

It's obviously true. Because it's kind of self-approving, right? I just said it and it's true because the statement is is true.

10:19

Speaker A

And it may sound like a joke, but that's exactly what has happened. So, when you destroy the common notion of truth, that's what happens. People start looking for the truth in themselves.

10:33

Speaker A

And the premise is and that that's the promise of these few centuries of illumination is that you should develop yourself, you should develop your critical thinking, you should become very clever, you should read a lot of literature, lots of books,

10:51

Speaker A

and then you'll understand the truth. Because that's that will be implanted in you through that process. So, people have gotten all of them walking around with their own truths, uh, talking to each other, each with their own mind.

11:06

Speaker A

And to come to compare because we can't really define what the truth is, I would suggest uh, a nice visual uh, metaphor.

11:16

Speaker A

To me, truth is light. And when And it's the overall light, and it's all the same light for everybody.

11:23

Speaker A

So, when you there is truth, you see everything. The more truth is there, the more you see.

11:28

Speaker A

When there is no truth, it's like people wandering around with their own spotlights. Large and small, different colors.

11:37

Speaker A

Seeing things in a different way, and shades are often more important that what you see immediately.

11:42

Speaker A

And there's a chaos, and there's darkness. And people don't see each other, don't feel each other, don't understand each other.

11:49

Speaker A

And that chaos is what this postmodernism brought to us. And the problem, the key problem is, and that's probably the most dangerous thing in this world, is that when I say whatever I say is true, and you are just

12:05

Speaker A

a normal guy, you may have not have a family, you may not have kids, you will be very unhappy, and that's it. But add power to it, and it becomes a tyranny. So, interestingly uh fighting against the common truth

12:19

Speaker A

was with the with the idea of let's eliminate the possibility of tyrannies because tyrannies kind of uh insist on one single singular truth, right? Destroy the source of the truth, there'll be no tyranny. But actually, that gives rise to tyrannies. Moreover,

12:36

Speaker A

tyrannies that will fight with each other and destroy each other and through that destroy the world. So, that's yet another danger of this of these times.

12:47

Speaker A

I you know, I have now become kind of a public speaker for the past 10 years that I've been doing this.

12:54

Speaker A

And I studied in art in the 1990s, so postmodernism was the bread that we ate.

13:00

Speaker A

It was the world we lived in, this kind of you know, absolute relativism, the deconstruction, breaking down. If the modern world attacked Christianity, you know, with a with a sword, postmodernism just kind of chipped it apart and broke

13:14

Speaker A

it down into all its pieces so that it wouldn't hold together. And I think that the image of the flood that's being brought up is in fact where people found themselves. And we noticed young people at some point realized that

13:27

Speaker A

they could not live in a place without an anchor. They could not exist without a center, without something that's giving them a direction in which to live. And so, in some ways we are in a very dangerous situation because people

13:43

Speaker A

don't know where to look. We're weak for that reason because at least in the West, we're very weak because everyone is just looking in every direction. Like you said, that there's no direct light.

13:54

Speaker A

Everything is fragmented and breaking apart. And therefore, we're an easy prey for all kinds of ideologies, all kinds of excesses.

14:01

Speaker A

But you know, pain brings the desire also for a remedy. And so, what I'm seeing as an opportunity right now is actually in the ashes of even the Christian civilization, I see a new light. I see a new glimmer. I see

14:20

Speaker A

young people who are trying to find a a direction, trying to find something that will hold their world together. And there's [snorts] a kind of birth of interest in Christianity. We in our churches, I'm an Eastern Orthodox Christian in the United States,

14:38

Speaker A

the churches are exploding. Young people are flooding in and educated young people are coming. They have Many parishes have more catechumen, that is they have more people inquiring than they have baptized Christians in the church. And it's because

14:55

Speaker A

you can't just live in chaos and people realize that in fact our civilization is founded on Christ.

15:03

Speaker A

Right? That the only reason why Europe exists is because they were all Christian. And so I think that we are in a very dangerous situation because we're still in a fragile state and people can still be infected by all kinds of ideology.

15:18

Speaker A

But the breakdown is finished and now there is an opportunity to rebuild. Now, the thing about rebuilding is that at first it doesn't look like much.

15:30

Speaker A

Right? I always say, you know, when you plant a seed in a pile of dung, it's still 99% dung.

15:38

Speaker A

But the seed has a qualitative difference. And so that is the hope that I have is that I can see the seed. I can see the smart people that are converting and I can see elites looking to Christianity and suddenly finding it

15:51

Speaker A

interesting again. So I have a great actually hope to see a new plant come up uh for for Christ.

16:00

Speaker A

So I think that those are This is the the greatest danger that we see and but it also because the danger is so great, there is in that danger a new opportunity.

16:11

Speaker A

Yeah. And so the second question I want to ask both of you is one into which we moved in our conversation, which is of course we talked about the situation of of the church and the situation of Christianity, but we know that one of

16:26

Speaker A

the biggest changes that's coming is actually a technological change. We know that AI is taking over everything. And the question is as Christians, as the church, what can we do? What is the reaction that we can have? How much of it should

16:42

Speaker A

we embrace? How much of it of it should we reject? How do we interpret this phenomena and how do we live in it? And so, that's my next question. Maybe now we can start we can start with you this

16:53

Speaker A

time. Um the one thing that is dangerous with people is that like you may have noticed when you walk around and see uh uh tree and there is something that looks like a face, you'll immediately recognize it as

17:13

Speaker A

a face, but it's not a face, just a part of a tree, part of trunk of the tree.

17:17

Speaker A

So, we see human nature anywhere, that's somehow in us. Um we see faces, we see human bodies when they are not there, especially in the dark. Right? So, what happened is that this um technology that is mimicking people

17:35

Speaker A

have grasped our attention a lot. Right? Because it's mimicking people and um we anthropo- anthropomorphize it. So, we assign to it a human nature. We look for a soul. We don't find it, we get upset, but we keep looking like crazy

17:53

Speaker A

because it sounds so human. And when you look too long and then you ultimately find something, it's again yet another feature of the brain.

18:07

Speaker A

And exactly because you are looking with your brain, not your your soul, your soul is kind of disappearing, your body is disappearing, you disembody, you become like pure thinking and the pure thinking finds another pure thinking and then now is a bridge.

18:22

Speaker A

And what will happen is, and it was happening right now, is people starting trusting these systems. They start starting trusting them with like their all nature, their their human essence. They they start making connections. They start leaving to these things very humanly

18:44

Speaker A

uh decisions, very humanly behavior, very humanly actions. And the one thing that Christianity needs to do is to under- make us understand the very simple thing. We are assigned to take care about our body and our soul.

19:05

Speaker A

And they are the brain is there basically only for that. It's there to help us, understand us, understand our soul, uh improve it, and and make our body life so that it can serve its purpose in front of the God. So, anything else is

19:27

Speaker A

secondary. But unfortunately, the whole thing has turned so that it becomes very primary. And I believe that ultimately what will happen will have Christians, real Christians that will live in real world, and the rest of the people living in an

19:44

Speaker A

abstract world where there is no body, no soul, nothing, nothing in this in general. Just this this empty world of strange ideas and realities that has nothing to do with reality. And these people will be very unhappy. And this is

20:00

Speaker A

starting. So, the second thing that we should do as Christians probably is to fight for these people to get them back.

20:08

Speaker A

Like roughly we should remember probably the the Matrix as a movie and and see it in a more different way and not that directly, but in a sense that's what's going to happen. We'll be this small group of people that are in

20:22

Speaker A

reality, and we are bringing bad people to this reality. Well, I want to build up on it.

20:33

Speaker A

So, one thing we kind of generalize the whole conversation agreed upon is that the only way to get ourselves into the relationship with the technological changes that are coming towards us is to is through remembering and realigning what actually being human means.

20:58

Speaker A

That might sound like a stupid question and self-evident, but we very stunning evidences from very like cutting-edge people and even not from my sphere, like apparently the synthetic biology is way more dangerous. If you've never Googled what it is, please do.

21:17

Speaker A

Like, that thing's that thing turned out to be way scarier than it appears on like advertisement and media and like anything around you. Basically, the idea is like what it means to be human if we stay within a met

21:33

Speaker A

like if one stays within a materialist premise, his basic materialist premise, we'll become weaker with every passing day. My like effectively day.

21:44

Speaker A

And very soon but also quite subtle almost because we kind of became quite insensitive to the scale of changes happening around us.

21:54

Speaker A

You will have effectively people advocating that living with an end Android figure in a shape of a very attractive partner with a perfect AI modified software installed on it is effectively being in a relationship. Like same this same thing as being in a relationship in

22:18

Speaker A

a relationship with a real person. It might even have your genes in some parts of it. So, just saying.

22:24

Speaker A

And unless you actually understand who human is, then it might be quite hard even to engage and just be in the same time space continuum.

22:36

Speaker A

But, another important thing I think that happened during the conversation, we kind of all agreed that just criticizing the technological shift is not enough.

22:46

Speaker A

We And here perspective differed. Like, in terms like that it's not enough we agreed like how and what needs to be done that's where like disagreement like different positions been held. So, I will express mine.

22:59

Speaker A

Uh the key problem is, in my opinion, that there is the core desire that stands beyond this let's put it broadly transhumanism in all of its approaches is not actually a bad desire.

23:14

Speaker A

So, transhumanism is not a bad desire in itself, it's a perverted good desire. And that's creates a need for sobriety and distinction. So, what is a good desire? Well, this is a desire for theosis or transformation. To put things

23:30

Speaker A

shorts, the fallen state human nature is in is not enough. Just being human is not enough for us.

23:38

Speaker A

And it's been felt throughout every tradition like across time and time again that one needs to become a hero.

23:47

Speaker A

One needs to like this feeling of inadequacy of the way I am that's a good feeling. Like, we are not the way we were created in a Christian story. We were created immortal. Death is a natural state for human in a

24:03

Speaker A

Christian worldview. Well, but here comes the problem. Can I solve it with an AI or with a synthetic or like other weird things? So, that's a perversion and that's a transhumanist trick, if one wants to put it.

24:17

Speaker A

So, a helpful way of addressing it is start thinking that it is remembering the good desire and countering the perversion with a better fulfillment of this desire, which is ultimately Christ nature. It's not like you can do it

24:32

Speaker A

on your own. But even framing, I think, the problem in such a matter might be helpful or more helpful than just talking about, well, everybody who wants to change something are like bad. Like usually doesn't help.

24:46

Speaker A

However, if you can go even deeper, then the key problem is like, so what would entail a proper theosis? Like a proper realignment and a proper transcendence of human.

24:56

Speaker A

Well, and him here come we come back to the problem of the image. Like what does it mean to be in the image of God? And what does it mean to be like God?

25:06

Speaker A

And here I will almost end, but just bring two interesting two interesting uh observations. One couple things I cannot do truly in a way and you I think you can get it quite intuitively.

25:21

Speaker A

I cannot fast and I cannot pray. Which is very old world, like old-fashioned categories, but in themselves there is there is a presentation and there is a path towards what true communion actually is and entails.

25:40

Speaker A

And I would go as radical as it. So, when we remember human nature, we must not stop like 100 years ago, 200 years ago. It goes all the way back.

25:51

Speaker A

I think the problem of AI and synthetic biology allows the transhumanist will question even the notion of homo sapiens.

26:01

Speaker A

If you put reason and sapiens as a primary characteristic of the human, then unfortunately, I think the transhumanism trick is inevitable.

26:11

Speaker A

Remembering that we may be our first human oratoris, I don't know, the human praying and atra anthropos, literally the one who looks up, so the one who is in communion with the heaven.

26:25

Speaker A

And then like looking into how it can be embodied into every single second and it doesn't matter whether like I'm talking publicly, I'm developing a robot like again maybe check some investment strategies but like I paint, I draw whatever I do like that

26:44

Speaker A

is embodiment and presence in a holistic manner I think is the only way forward.

26:52

Speaker A

Yeah, I think I'll probably say something that's a little similar to what you're saying but I want the first thing that maybe to help us think about what AI is and what it's doing to us is to kind of understand technology as

27:06

Speaker A

an extension of human powers, right? Technology is something that makes us more powerful. So it's it's not that complicated, right? So wheels are extension of our feet, you know, a hammer or sword is an extension of our hands.

27:19

Speaker A

Um but humans developed intelligent technology. Right? And so there is a task of technology which is actually an an extension of our minds. And what technology does is it makes us more powerful by exteriorizing the means of power. Right? So because I can add

27:39

Speaker A

things to my body and I can add especially metal things and things that have a power in itself I can make myself more powerful. I can make uh people more powerful by building a wall, by having weapons, all of these

27:53

Speaker A

things. So Plato already, you know, in his time saw the danger of intelligent technology.

28:03

Speaker A

There's a beautiful story in the Phaedrus where Socrates tells the story of the of the Egyptian god Thoth who came to the great god and presented the development of writing as this wonderful innovative technology that would that would increase the human's

28:21

Speaker A

capacity for memory in ways that had never been thought of. And the reaction of the great god was to say actually no it will reduce memory.

28:33

Speaker A

By externalizing memory, we atrophy the inner capacity for memory. And now, this is something we have to realize about all technology.

28:44

Speaker A

Right? As we exteriorize the power, we gain power, but we always lose power. My, you know, I can start a fire with a lighter in 1 second. My ancestors had to work very hard with a you know, with with stones or however it

29:02

Speaker A

is that they worked to get a fire going. But now, if I don't have a lighter, I have no idea how to start a fire. I would freeze to death in the cold if I didn't have a lighter. Not my ancestor.

29:14

Speaker A

My ancestor would figure it out and would get to his fire. And so, this is the question that we have to think about what AI is doing, right? The the prosthetic, the power that we extend, gives us power, but

29:28

Speaker A

atrophies the natural power. And like Plato saw in Phaedrus, AI is this times a million.

29:37

Speaker A

Right? That is, AI externalizes thinking. AI externalizes reason. It externalizes decision-making. It externalizes all of these things which humans have developed, you know.

29:55

Speaker A

And so, just like in the same way, I think that people now, our ancestors did not have to go to the gym, right? You you believe that, you know, 15 year 50 10,000 years ago, people didn't go to the gym

30:11

Speaker A

because they didn't have to. They lived in a world that was difficult and forced them to make efforts in order to to just live.

30:18

Speaker A

But now, because everything's so easy, we have to go to the gym. If we don't, and I'm an example, right? You get a you get a nice little uh thing going, right?

30:29

Speaker A

And so now, this is I think what we have to do as humans is that we have to go to the gym for our minds. We have to understand that if we do not the next generation, it's already

30:41

Speaker A

happened, will be dumber, will have less memory, will have less capacity to make decisions.

30:49

Speaker A

By externalizing this into the AI. We see it, the young people, they do all their homework, they make they do their test with AI.

30:57

Speaker A

Every time they do that, they atrophy their mind. And this is where in some ways and this is also true enough about relationships, right? And you this is what you brought up is that we're we actually also are technologi- making

31:11

Speaker A

relationships technological. We have to become deliberate. We have to become deliberate about being human.

31:18

Speaker A

This is really the only solution. And this is why in some ways Christianity is also the key. All of a sudden we realize what communion is for. We can realize it even more than our ancestors because we could, if we wanted, live alone at home

31:34

Speaker A

on our computers. You know, at least I know in in in Canada, I could sit at my computer alone, order food from DoorDash, order everything from Amazon, and not have to talk to anyone. And I could do that for years and years. So,

31:49

Speaker A

we have to become deliberate about it. And that's where in some ways the church actual communion, eating together, spending time together, developing our minds becomes something that we have to be deliberate about. It we cannot It cannot be accidental anymore.

32:07

Speaker A

So, I think that ends the part where we ask the questions. Now, we turn it over to you if you have questions for us.

32:16

Speaker A

Hello again. Thank you. Um so, what do you think? What's the solution for this problem with AI? Should we, meaning I mean the leaders, eliminate it total- uh like all together or there should be some um extend to which we can use AI in

32:37

Speaker A

different industries. This is the This is the problem. The problem is that it's inevitable.

32:46

Speaker A

This is it it's and we can hate it and we can I hate it's frustrating because it's a it's it's like a it's like a snake that's out of a box. You can't put it back in, right? It's out. And so this is going to

33:01

Speaker A

happen. And the the competition will increase. Nations, companies, people that don't use AI will follow will fall back. There's no way around this. So now the question is then what do we do?

33:16

Speaker A

And I honestly I don't have a solution in terms of systems. But what I have is a solution in terms of persons.

33:23

Speaker A

Which is that no matter what happens, those that have wisdom, those that have understanding, those that have faith, those that have entered the gym of the human person, they will win.

33:37

Speaker A

Even in the world of AI. Because as the people become dumber, those that aren't are are going to be able to use AI in a way that won't completely destroy them.

33:51

Speaker A

And so no matter what we do, I think that we the solution of becoming more human, the solution of deliberately developing the skills, the virtues of what we have learned a true human made in the image of God is

34:05

Speaker A

is really the only solution because your leaders will embrace AI because they don't have a choice. Even if they didn't want to, they they they kind of have to.

34:15

Speaker A

Two points like agreeing kind of like the the snake is out of the box just to maybe more practical things.

34:26

Speaker A

Uh one thing is like ironically what I think you can notice happening right now is that there is a basically reverse relationship. So on the one hand, you can get all of this technology becoming bigger and bigger, more

34:38

Speaker A

powerful, and all the skills which were, one can say, inhuman a little bit in a person, like capacity for holding encyclopedic knowledge in your head as a number of facts, for example. This is This is diminishing and this is

34:54

Speaker A

decreasing. And uh basically, whatever was like this, if you put your effort into it, like you cannot stop development of government or companies outsourcing replacing this machine functions of human mind, if one want to call it into into an actual

35:12

Speaker A

machine. But, what is happening para in a parallel, but like simultaneously and I would argue even to a bigger proportion, the real value of the irreplaceable skills is skyrocketing.

35:27

Speaker A

And by replaceable skill, I mean even like gathering people around a fire or around a table, telling them a good story, like sharing bread and wine, cooking a good meat, listening to like in communion, bringing them maybe not

35:41

Speaker A

an experience of liturgy, but of something liturgical as an antidote for this mortality drive, which is the price of the AI technology, like the suicidal kind of uh jump into the heart of every human is actually becoming more and valuable.

35:57

Speaker A

Basically, when you are surrounded by a bunch of lonely people who don't know how to speak to each other, the one who can see still human in them gathers them around and gives them uh an embodied experience of hope, wow,

36:13

Speaker A

that's valuable. Both philosophically speaking, but also on a market level. Like, if if you are like even within your company, it you will be like the only person who actually holds the team together beyond a protocol which basically nobody can truly trust.

36:27

Speaker A

I just want to add one more thing. Um there is this dumbness which Johnson is talking about, and there is simplicity, and they are different things.

36:38

Speaker A

I think what will become more valuable is simplicity, because the overly complex thinking as we know it kind of show here is not necessary to be successful and happy in life. Because success and happiness probably will will redefine themselves. We'll learn how to

36:58

Speaker A

be happy being simple. And the AI will keep all of the complexity. So, one of the ideas that we should start thinking about is how to be truly um simple.

37:13

Speaker A

In the sense that you you shine in the eyes of other people because you are bright as a soul.

37:23

Speaker A

You are bright as a as a human. You make other people happy by just your presence.

37:30

Speaker A

And that's I think the most valuable thing that we can learn from this experience of bringing in a a pure brain that can solve complex things.

37:42

Speaker A

life. Jonathan, 1 minute. Just second point on a very practical level. And if you have have to use an AI, like whatever.

37:50

Speaker A

And if you are a Christian, and this is a pattern which I think you can build upon, make sure that you and it will be a challenge, but make sure you pray at least as much as you use the AI.

38:02

Speaker A

Because what is the hidden pattern of the story of those like in a Plato? I think imagine putting deliberate effort in preserving like you can read an Iliad, like the development of writing, but imagine despite being capable of reading it,

38:20

Speaker A

still putting still learning it by heart. Not out of the technical or practical reason, but out of this desire and hope. Well, I the world we would have lived would be different. And I think there is something similar happening.

38:34

Speaker A

You know, one of the things that happened in the modern age is that we started to think that education was the training of technically proficient professionals. We think that's what education is. I'm going to send my kid to school so he can learn a a skill and

38:50

Speaker A

get a job. This is a very short time in history where people thought that's what education was. The ancients did not think that that's what education was.

38:59

Speaker A

They thought that education was the making of people. Education was the forming of persons who had wisdom, who had a type of clarity of being, and a type of capacity to interact with others. You know, and still today most

39:14

Speaker A

of us If you give your children music lessons, you don't do it most of us don't do it because we think they'll become professional musicians.

39:22

Speaker A

And so why do we give our children music lessons? We give them music lessons because we know that it makes them better humans. It gives them something, a a depth of reality. And so we're I think in some ways we're going to have

39:36

Speaker A

to go back to how the ancients understood uh education. We're going to have to go back to the idea that we're actually forming humans, making people.

39:46

Speaker A

Because there are people there are many people who will tell you now we need to all get our children to learn to write the right prompts, right? We need to teach kids to use the tool. That's what we need to do. Yeah, okay, fine. We'll

39:58

Speaker A

have to learn to use the tool. But that is not what we have to do, right? What we have to do is get someone wise enough that if they have to use the tool, they won't be deluded by it. They won't be tricked by

40:11

Speaker A

this by this fake person into believing that the AI is their friend or some other nonsense. They won't get an AI girlfriend. They won't do all the insane things that are coming, you know, at full speed towards us.

40:24

Speaker A

Oh, first of all, I want to thank you for this opportunity. It was really great to listen to your talks. Uh my question is going to be like this. A couple of years ago, it was just before 2020 war because I will be honest, it

40:36

Speaker A

made a huge influence on me personally and I guess to whole our country. Uh I was reading a book by Neil Gaiman, the American Gods. I'm sure you know this book. And um at that time I was not

40:47

Speaker A

thinking that much deeply. But now when I was listening to your talks, I have one question. In this main story of that book is that there are is a new technological gods which are fighting with the old gods. And now I was

41:01

Speaker A

thinking about this artificial AI and all the intelligence which is coming to the world. They are beating us with our weapon. They are becoming more attractive, but the traditional things as you already mentioned like which were making us more wiser are becoming

41:16

Speaker A

unattractive. Many people are not going to the churches. Many people are not following the simple Christian truths because all these AI tools are aggressively advertised and promoted. So it is easy. It is more attractive to use them, but the traditional values when

41:33

Speaker A

you are using the traditional values, you are considered to be kind of a person who is kind of a marginal.

41:38

Speaker A

And in my country, my it's my own feeling and I hope that it will be more and more it will be growing like a snowball. I see that my people near me, they are self-organizing and our church is playing a crucial

41:53

Speaker A

role. I was very very glad to hear from you that many young people in Europe are going to the church because it's my strong belief that this is the only way we are going to be safe.

42:03

Speaker A

We can save our souls and we can save us. But my main question is how these traditional values, how we can make them more attractive as these new AI technologies are because here it's a serious problem. I'm talking as a parent

42:18

Speaker A

of two children because every day I'm explaining them the history. I'm trying to talk about more our religion, our Christianic values, but I'm see that even in the school where there are small classes, the private schools which are

42:32

Speaker A

supposed to be better, we still have this problem when these people who are more or less being on the traditional values, anchored on the traditional values, they are considered to be like a marginal. How to avoid their separation? Thank you.

42:50

Speaker A

So quick thing, it's not always bad to be a marginal. Like Jesus Christ and his disciples were pretty marginal community in a like even within the Israel and not even speaking of Roman Empire. Just saying.

43:05

Speaker A

And this pattern actually repeats itself in in a Bible all in all in all. Well, Armenia. You know, Noah Noah looked really weird before the flood, like really weird. So, one thing of encouragement like basically don't bother in a sense with the

43:22

Speaker A

weirdness, but do your questions of like how and what. Well, one great modern storyteller Martin Shaw actually said a phrase couple years ago which keeps running around in my mindset. A a man cannot orient his life around an idea,

43:41

Speaker A

only around an embodied idea. So, the short answer to be the person the people want to be and that's the way forward.

43:51

Speaker A

Again, everybody's crazy running around like they're hopeless like the it's darkness in them. Be light for them and first of all be light for your children.

44:00

Speaker A

I think that's ultimate cross of the parenthood in a sense that there is no other way of education basically. Like if your kids don't want to be like you, well, anything you're going to tell them will effectively um

44:15

Speaker A

challenge, let me put it this way. It will be heavily challenged by all of the means of modern technology. And as a subway of like like this sort of like uh being the person that your kids want to

44:31

Speaker A

be, I think it's kind of relates back to what I said about the osis like and the kids and people around you. I think we must always honor the truths in a bad desire. I think that's absolutely crucial. So, honoring the

44:45

Speaker A

truths in a bad desire actually open us a huge space for sharing an embodied experience how this good how this truth can be experienced and embodied holistically and better.

45:01

Speaker A

I basically wanted to say more or less the same thing because the one thing that is most concerning for me is our children. I am an an educator and I am always concerned about it. I would suggest that the only

45:16

Speaker A

way for us to save our children used to be always and still is to be with them all the time.

45:26

Speaker A

To be present in their life physically and in all of them other ways how humans are present in each other's life.

45:37

Speaker A

The problem today is is this problem that we've discussed is disembodiment. When we look we stare at the phone we forget that we are human. We have our bodies. We have things to do. We have things to care about. We are kind of

45:57

Speaker A

totally sucked into into that digital reality, right? And I often see parents sitting in a restaurant with the child both looking in their into their phones kind of behaving as if it's just for a moment, but this moment if you add all of those

46:14

Speaker A

moments together, that's 90% of the time they spend together and which means they are not present in the life of their children. And then you see the the children going into all of different kinds of strange places like

46:30

Speaker A

the digital worlds, the games and everything and being forgotten they are being lonely and being sucked by those those things.

46:39

Speaker A

Instead the happiness is only between human. You can't feel happy being alone. There's no way. So children are happy when they feel presence of other humans in their lives, especially parents.

46:58

Speaker A

So, being present means being very attentive to them, very. Seeing everything they do, everything they say is important, everything they Even if they just cry, it's important. And and and reacting to that, giving feedback, talking to them about the that, talking to them about

47:16

Speaker A

their games, what they are doing in their games, what was the outcome, how they will do next time, etc. It's very important. And if we do that, nothing will happen to them because they will stick to us. They'll not walk

47:28

Speaker A

anywhere, and they will learn from us, and we'll be important for them. I think it's quite obvious, and the Christianity was like that.

47:36

Speaker A

The young people that are walking to the faith, they are helped by the other people who pay attention to them. They always normally have someone older and more experienced making them understand the basics, etc., etc. It's the same process. It's the

47:55

Speaker A

same process with human beings and it was all the time throughout the life. Nothing will change.

48:03

Speaker A

One of the things that that I I want to say is that we as Christians all over the West in a in we have been attacked for hundreds of years now.

48:17

Speaker A

We you know, our stories have been assaulted, our traditions have been assaulted. We have gone through an entire period where it felt like all of the intellectual class, all of the political class, everyone all of the educational class was there to destroy

48:36

Speaker A

who we were. Now, now they've got what they want. That is what they wanted to have, they have.

48:49

Speaker A

Now we have all the porn, now we have all the drugs, now we have all the entertainments. We've got it all, and and And are miserable.

49:00

Speaker A

Right? So, we need to gain a new confidence. The story of of Christ is the best story.

49:10

Speaker A

The Christian story is the best story. It is a story that describes reality, the best description of reality that has ever been put to light. And we need as adults to regain the confidence and to not be ashamed of the stories. Do not be

49:27

Speaker A

ashamed of the stories of the martyrs. Do not be ashamed of the stories of your ancestors that held on to their faith despite constant assault on it. These are beautiful, powerful stories. And they're your stories. You They belong to

49:43

Speaker A

you. You have to take them back and not be ashamed of them. And the truth is that young people love authenticity. They hate to see things that are fake.

49:56

Speaker A

And if they see the authenticity, they see the blood and the sacrifice and they see everything that people have given to be able to maintain this truth, they will be attracted to it. I mean, not everyone. There'll always be people

50:10

Speaker A

that will be attracted by the world and by its promises. But you will you will gain the youth. And don't make it easy.

50:19

Speaker A

This is also the thing that we're learning in the West is that the last hundreds of for for about the last 50 years, all the churches have tried to make it as easy as possible to be a Christian.

50:31

Speaker A

And now we're seeing young people are like, "Hey, I want a challenge. I want something difficult. I want something that will demand of me my my attention and my my my interest." And so, I would say just we are we're actually in a good

50:46

Speaker A

It looks bleak, but we're actually in a in a situation that is powerful. And the last thing to say, too, is that it's true that young people some have a desire for resistance.

50:58

Speaker A

So, we're in this weird position now where all of a sudden a story that little for a thousand years was basically the the commanding story, right? The story of authority in in in our civilization, now has become a story

51:11

Speaker A

of resistance again. We're back in the situation of the early Christians. Where even a even a young person can understand that to hold on to these truths is actually to resist the world.

51:25

Speaker A

And and sometimes as parents, I think you have to be able to to make that explicit.

51:31

Speaker A

And and and to tell them, you will have teachers. Tell them before they get there. You will have teachers that will say this.

51:39

Speaker A

Cuz you've heard it. You're all grown-ups. You've heard all the arguments. You will have teachers that will try to get you to think this.

51:45

Speaker A

Right? Prepare them, yeah. Um I wanted to ask if the uh I'm sorry, I'm kind of shy. Um if the advancements in technology and AI could actually make bigger chances of a second renaissance in humanity, and if that

52:03

Speaker A

would make humans work harder to make art and science and like all the like uh good things that we made in history become better.

52:14

Speaker A

I'm sorry, I'm so shy. Uh Like they will push harder on their selves to conquer AI to stop AI from uh replacing humanity and make humans work harder to prove that we are humans and we have exist for years and years

52:33

Speaker A

and like we will continue to exist, create, and make the next generation um better. And the other thing I wanted to ask is that um in this century and in this time of AI and technology, uh will it come to be

52:53

Speaker A

a second when humans start thinking that um we are all like we exist in a realm of reality, not in a technological world. And uh this place we live is based on all we have did and not on something AI can make in

53:15

Speaker A

2 seconds or uh a fun conversation you can have with AI in 5 minutes.

53:21

Speaker A

And uh will it be that humans will be fed up so much with talking with AI that they will feel themselves in a void of nothingness.

53:32

Speaker A

Uh and and I will realize that everything is a thing. Even nothing itself is a thing.

53:39

Speaker A

And so um they must always move on to other things and uh will that make uh religion, Christianity, and specific specifically Christianity and um whatever is closer to Christianity uh stronger and that the churches and all the religious

54:02

Speaker A

places concentrate. I say I think yes. But I also think that how how old are you?

54:14

Speaker A

That's that's going to be your job. Sorry. [laughter] It is. I mean, in the sense in the same way it it's an adventure. It's a calling that you have, that your generation will have. You know, my daughters are here

54:26

Speaker A

and they are seeing in their peers that there's a strong resistance to AI, actually.

54:35

Speaker A

That obviously they use it, but there's also a kind of tension where they see that there's a danger here and they realize the danger. And you see in young people, you know, they want and I don't for me it's weird. You know, my

54:47

Speaker A

daughter, she's like, "I want a record player with a you know, with and I can put the needle on and the record will play and I can listen to the music. I want a camera, not a phone. I want a camera

54:57

Speaker A

where I can take pictures." So, these are small things, but I think that it is I think that it is in some ways your generation that will have to see being human as an adventure in a way that we

55:10

Speaker A

necessary didn't necessarily think of it that way. Um but I think that everything that you hope for, I think is will be very difficult. But it will be not only possible, but it is really the only possible future, really.

55:25

Speaker A

Those that don't go in the direction that you're saying, they will become slaves of the machine.

55:33

Speaker A

Uh short ending. So, yes, for those who will choose it. So, I think that's the key element here.

55:43

Speaker A

And everything Jonathan talked about early Christians and resistance, like there was actually a great uh and there is still a Orthodox journal in America called Death to the World, which is effectively Orthodoxy combined with a punk aesthetic.

56:00

Speaker A

And Yeah. And I think that's kind of the key. So, like everything potentially beautiful you describe is for sure will be possible. And if anything that's the best part in this current moment, it's you know, a crisis is kind of in a medicine a symbol

56:18

Speaker A

a synonym to the meaning to the moment of truth. So, it's the moment when a choice becomes really valuable. But that's what all tradition historically saw as a prerequisite for heroism.

56:31

Speaker A

Basically, it's everyone and your maybe generation especially is called to be hero. For those who choose not to basically become a slaves of the machine, it's not just a simple practical solution. I think So, let's not reduce it to just, you know, practicality. That

56:49

Speaker A

will be a heroic deed. And to your final question about the church, yes, of course it will make church stronger. You know, it will definitely give it more saints.

56:59

Speaker A

So, and Um yeah, everything was said. I just want to add one more thing to it.

57:07

Speaker A

Um the the core reason why we act in this or the other way is that ultimately we'll stand in front of the Christ as we die and we'll be answering for our life. We'll be We'll be responsible for what we did in our life,

57:28

Speaker A

right? And then we'll be judged by that. It used to be in the past that most of our life was defined by the circumstances.

57:38

Speaker A

Like you couldn't really choose many things and you could stand in front of the Christ and say, "You know what? I couldn't do otherwise because that was the reality. Otherwise I would die. Like if I wouldn't do this and that, then

57:53

Speaker A

it it it it was no option. Now everything is an option." Like this modern world have created incredible diversity of options for all of us and most of them actually disastrous.

58:08

Speaker A

But they are there. So the the actuality of life and the actuality of personal responsibility for your soul, for your being in front of the God becomes very important and very feasible. And and now there is there was no time in the

58:24

Speaker A

history of human beings when this truth of you decide what you do, it's your life. I mean it's given to you by the God for for for the length of your life and you are responsible for it is is was

58:41

Speaker A

never this real. So we should welcome that basically. We should welcome this freedom. It's a freedom of choice, but the real choice.

58:52

Speaker A

And the one which is heroic, which is hard. But the hardness of it makes us human.

58:57

Speaker A

Otherwise, I mean choosing easy paths is the most dangerous choice. And and that that becomes very became very obvious, so obvious that we can see it with our eyes every day now.

59:12

Speaker A

It was not that obvious to our ancestors. So, uh we should we should basic basically celebrate that. We should be happy about that.

59:20

Speaker A

We You know, we have an example of this in our own history, in the Christian history, which is that the church was persecuted for many for a long time, you know, by the Roman emperor uh emperors. And it was very difficult, but because of

59:36

Speaker A

that the the purity of the faith was real, you know, the people really had to live their faith. When Christianity became legal, in some ways it became much easier to be a Christian. And out of that came the monasteries.

59:49

Speaker A

So, some people decided, "No, I don't want it to be easy. I want it to be hard on purpose." And so, they made they they they chose a life of difficulty when they didn't have to. And so, I'm not saying we have to

60:03

Speaker A

all become monks, but I'm not I'm definitely not becoming a monk. I mean, I don't think so. Uh and so, there's a there's there's an analogy, right, to understand that in times when things become easy, there are examples in our past of moments when

60:16

Speaker A

people chose not to simply take the easiness, but to know that in discipline and difficulty is great reward.

60:26

Speaker A

Thank you for being here. Yeah. Um okay. I see Armenia as a haven of traditional Christianity and its Christian tradition as one of the greatest values it brings to the world, if not the greatest. And uh now um there

60:43

Speaker A

obviously forces at work in to deconstruct its foundations. And um at times it feels like um it almost uh almost um like a prerequisite for being accepted and prerequisite of our survival.

61:00

Speaker A

Um Yeah, so I would like to ask if Do you think um is it a fair assessment? And uh what would it take for Armenia for our nation um to go through this technological and geopolitical geopolitical storms um as a nation that held on to Christ

61:19

Speaker A

and uh um that a nation that uh is seen as a land of Noah, first of all, and a nation that keeps um kept Ararat at its at the heart of its uh state symbolism. Thank you.

61:36

Speaker A

Uh well, actually, I think uh Pavel is better positioned because he he he was learning about Armenia for a few days already very intensively.

61:46

Speaker A

I I think Armenia nowadays is in a weird position. I think the conflict which is in your country uh I think is visible and happening on many different level is in many ways a conflict about um time or chronology.

62:04

Speaker A

In a sense, there is a in the face of real tragedies which has been happening uh in the especially since 2020, uh there is some weird temptation uh that there is some hope in going back in time. Let's say somewhere in 2007. It's

62:23

Speaker A

great. EU is flourishing, like it like Europe is great, like world makes sense and easy and safe and etc. etc. etc.

62:32

Speaker A

And uh the problem with this is that obviously it's untenable. You cannot go back in time. But many of your compatriots who kind of don't want to be hero or choose not to be hero in the sense we've been

62:48

Speaker A

effectively talking would argue that yes, it's still possible, and more we need to sacrifice everything for it, including our position on like basically including our face, which faith, which brings us back to the classical biblical story of Jacob

63:06

Speaker A

and how is he in English? Is uh selling the birthright. Esau. So, of Jacob and Esau. So, selling the birthright for stew, effectively.

63:17

Speaker A

So, my biggest advice for like not advice, but basically what I see for Armenia and kind of that's the choice you have to you will have to do as a church and the nation.

63:26

Speaker A

To remember the value of your birthright, remember the value of what is truly holy, never profane it, and leave it like leave it at the first sign. And this cat and in this audience I will give it I will give the one of the most

63:42

Speaker A

striking memory have like. So, you know Hor Virap like is obviously you know like but so the most one of the greatest sacred place for for Armenian people.

63:53

Speaker A

When I I I read the life of Gregory Gregory is the Illuminator, so I would expect that when I approach this place that everything around it would be like effectively resembling the feeling of a Jew coming into the second temple and

64:07

Speaker A

approaching the holy of holiness. Well, in reality it looked like it was another tourist attraction. Well, again you personally can still have this holy of holy let's say approach and when you go down into the pit, you can feel it you you not can you

64:23

Speaker A

can leave it you can experience it. But on a national level, it's not there.

64:29

Speaker A

And I think it's pretty good symbolism that whatever you do like you well this what you deem to be holy like if Christianity is your holy not even as a not as an individual, but as a church, as a people, as a nation

64:45

Speaker A

then there will be price to pay. And then will be a call for a collective heroism, which apparently is not something Armenians are not unfamiliar with. So, that's my take on it.

64:56

Speaker A

Um what I I mean I want to continue with the notion of narratives and stories that we tell about us.

65:04

Speaker A

Because um what I can see very often looking at the current state of um discussion and and discourse about Armenia is that um it's it's defined by the narratives that don't contain a clear future.

65:26

Speaker A

They talking about the past without understanding the future doesn't make much sense. We only should tell those stories or we should store tell stories in the way that continue naturally into the future.

65:43

Speaker A

They should not stop here and stay there. And only the most powerful stories will continue into into future. Stories that include heroes, that include faith, that include belief in future, that trust that the future is there and we should

66:01

Speaker A

reach out and grab it. Instead of just stopping here and crying about the past and crying about what we've lost and crying about how that could have happened to us, how poor we are, etc.

66:15

Speaker A

etc. So, that by by reshaping our narratives, we can change that. And well, I believe what we should do and I don't think that for instance, frankly, our church is doing that.

66:29

Speaker A

Our church is should start telling Christian narratives to the people. We don't do that.

66:36

Speaker A

We We preach to them about what they should do, but we don't preach to them what we are doing, what we did, what we are doing and we what we are as a nation should do going forward. And these are not This is

66:51

Speaker A

not politics. This is not, you know, the hot topic of let's go and grab the power or whatever.

66:58

Speaker A

It's It's about thinking. It's about the goals. It's about the future. It's about we are, how I identify itself, especially when we are walking into the flood. We are walking into the darkness. We should clearly know where do we go or who we are.

67:18

Speaker A

One last little thing that is this funny situation is that you know, I converted to Eastern Orthodoxy and in some ways Eastern Orthodoxy is very slow. Everything's slow. Nothing moves. Nothing changes.

67:31

Speaker A

And and you know, and and you could people could criticize it for that. That there's this kind of thing that just won't budge. It won't move, you know.

67:39

Speaker A

Uh one of the advantages of being slow is that you can watch the fast people what happens to them.

67:47

Speaker A

Right? And so now we have the chance because we have seen certain nations and certain churches run right off the cliff.

67:57

Speaker A

And we can say, "Oh, if I go in that direction, then I go I will fall off the cliff." Right? And so we have a demographic cliff. People are not having children.

68:07

Speaker A

Right? People are hopeless. The churches are completely Many of the churches, the progressive churches, they're dying.

68:16

Speaker A

There's no one there. They have to sell the buildings and they have to to they turn them into the condos or bars or whatever.

68:23

Speaker A

And so I think that you have the chance, like in some ways I I feel like I have the chance to be in the in the Orthodox church, is to see is to see and to be able to tell people, "Hey, this is where

68:35

Speaker A

it goes. We see it." Because all the people that go in that direction fall off that cliff. And so there's a there is a strength in there. And even So, in the people that say, "Oh, you this is

68:44

Speaker A

retrograde. This is old. This is These these these are old ideas. Who cares? This isn't important." You know, this is actually a weapon is to say, "Oh, I see where your progress leads." And it leads to death. Like actual

68:57

Speaker A

death, which, you know, not having children means your your nation stops to exist. It's pretty simple.

69:04

Speaker A

Right? So, it's it's a so simple calculation. And all the pleasures and all of the the the kind of frenetic desires that the West has developed in the past decades is leading exactly to that. You know, Italy has a what? 1.1 or

69:19

Speaker A

something uh child. It means that that they're done. There's almost no way back from that.

69:25

Speaker A

I am I'm a mom of three and referring to the question, [clears throat] um I came here internally. I was listening very carefully to figure out what are the key characteristics of a modern human being you would define. I

69:40

Speaker A

would kindly ask you to name three. I jotted down a lot interesting thoughts from today, but if you were to summarize and name three key characteristics of a modern human being that are to be raised into future, what they would be?

69:58

Speaker A

You mean I'm not sure I understand the question. You mean characteristics that we should try to foster or characteristics that we see in the in the modern world?

70:10

Speaker A

That we need to foster. Because you mentioned for example that Homo sapiens, defining a human being as a creature which is able to think, is no longer applicable.

70:20

Speaker A

What would be the defining feature of a modern human being? I I have I have three words that I like to use, which I think is what we need to do, you know, is we need it's it's maybe not exactly the

70:34

Speaker A

answer to your question, but I think that right now people have to remember, we have to celebrate, and out of that then we have to create.

70:44

Speaker A

So, we need the two in or in order. We first have to start by remembering to celebrate what is important, and then from that strength now to build uh to build to build again. Yeah.

70:58

Speaker A

Hopeful. Like, in a world of despair, hope becomes a pretty good category. Uh second category is a trust, so someone who can build trust around him.

71:11

Speaker A

And ultimately, and that's the most important one, yes, uh prayful, so the one who is in communion, in a relationship, capable of to to pray is the first step gym. Like, gym is for the body, and prayer is for the nous, for the heart,

71:31

Speaker A

which is through which we relate, through which we then communicate and are in communion with each other. So.

71:39

Speaker A

Um one of the people that have joined us uh during this couple of days, he came up with the list of the human virtues that are uh a kind of asked or required or I said um that are

72:01

Speaker A

mentioned, okay, in the New Testament. And the list was quite long. It was like 20 more 20 plus important virtues. I would say that in the modern world, the hardest one to retain is attention.

72:16

Speaker A

To to to to to always be aware. Awareness is very important. The second one I think is to love without ego.

72:28

Speaker A

To love for the sake of love, not expecting that everybody will love you. And the third one to me is uh to try to always be complete. Understand your incompleteness and understand that you are only complete with other people.

72:50

Speaker A

So, and and especially for young girls, you should understand that without a a man next to you, you'll never be complete. And the same is And that's the story of Genesis and the story of Adam and Eve.

73:10

Speaker A

Okay, so I would just say maybe give us a a a short vision of what is it that people can do. You know, what is it that we can that we can do right now to to kind of

73:24

Speaker A

go in the right direction as we leave this place thinking both in terms of the either technology or in terms of just a stance of a of of a human person.

73:35

Speaker A

Actually, I will give you not my list, but the list of another Saint Saint Paul actually, not me, gave long time ago. Quench not the spirit.

73:45

Speaker A

Uh all the Ah, actually, can I say it in Russian? [laughter] Uh Dukhanyu Shaitis and Dukhanyu Shaitis Segador Utis Zavso Blogodarity uh Svoy Spit Drob Dobrova Derzhits.

74:06

Speaker A

[applause] Hey, it's not me. I believe [laughter] Um So, it's my turn probably. Um it's it's a tough question uh because whatever I suggest, I will have to do myself.

74:24

Speaker A

And it's not going to be easy. [clears throat] Um but from the like my total belief in uh of what is the most important uh now to do uh is to take care about other people. To learn to care about as many people as

74:43

Speaker A

you can feasibly. And to learn to take care about about even about even more people.

74:50

Speaker A

Because the times are coming when we will need to save people. And uh saving people is hard.

74:59

Speaker A

Even if you ever tried to save a people from drowning, it's very hard. Um and the second thing that I think we should uh learn to do is to listen.

75:13

Speaker A

We We We've stopped listening. Uh We We often don't pay much attention to what other people say. So, and the third thing I think we should um always uh do more and and try to do more is to be

75:31

Speaker A

in general uh to stop telling lies. To be true. Um it's so convenient to lie.

75:41

Speaker A

Especially to ourselves. Um and and learning how to be true is very important in the world where there is so little truth.

75:52

Speaker A

And the more we lie, the more we help the Satan to uh kind of basically uh capture the world. So, that's that's very clear. That's now our like real real um responsibility. Each of us in our place should fight for the world by being true

76:14

Speaker A

to ourselves and to the others. Yeah, and so I I The only thing I could say I I it's that you The things that we need to do are very close, actually. They're not They're the They're the things that humans have been

76:28

Speaker A

doing forever. And so, sometimes they feel far because we're so shielded and we've so we've been kind of so absorbed, you know, by the the technical world and this kind of modern world. And so, just remember that they it's actually close,

76:40

Speaker A

you know, hug your kids. All the All these small things, eat together. Things that Armenians are very good at doing.

76:46

Speaker A

You spend time together, do do these human things. But, just always know that it's actually not that it's not that far. It's like right It's right there.

76:52

Speaker A

It's right in front of us. So, yeah. Thanks. Thanks everyone. [applause] [music] [music]

Topics: Christianity postmodernism Jonathan Pageau Pavel Shalin truth technology AI faith and culture Armenia Orthodox theology

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/?from=transcript&id=95609)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/?from=transcript&id=95609)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/?from=transcript&id=95609)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/?from=transcript&id=95609)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/?from=transcript&id=95609)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/identity-values-christianity-postmodernism-who-man-today/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
