**The End of Hebrew Roots? w/ Professor R. L. Solberg — Transcript & Summary | SozAI**
Source: https://sozai.app/transcript/hebrew-roots-professor-solberg/

A debate between host Shawn and Prof. R.L. Solberg on whether Torah-observant Hebrew Roots teaching holds Christians to Mosaic law, centered on Yom Kippur atonement sacrifices.

## Key Takeaways

- Solberg holds that Mosaic ritual and sacrificial laws were terms of the Sinai covenant and do not bind Christians under the new covenant.
- Solberg maintains that moral obligations and God's commandments still apply to all Christians, distinguishing them from lawlessness.
- The host argues that dietary and holiness laws were meant as universal or continuing instructions, creating the core point of disagreement.
- Both parties agree on Christ as Savior and Son of God, but differ sharply on how Torah obedience plays out for believers.

## What the video covers

- Host Shawn introduces Prof. R.L. Solberg, returning for a second discussion on his theological challenge to Torah-observant and Hebrew Roots adherents.
- Solberg explains his original 60-second video question: are Christians still required to sacrifice animals to atone for sin, scoped to Leviticus 16 Yom Kippur sacrifices.
- Solberg denies being antinomian, affirming the moral law and obedience to God's commandments while arguing Mosaic ritual laws were part of the Sinai covenant, not the new covenant.
- Dietary laws are discussed: Solberg argues they were purity/holiness laws given only to Israel to distinguish them from surrounding nations, while the host disputes this reading.
- Debate over whether Ecclesiastes' 'whole duty of man' applies to Mosaic commands, with Solberg insisting scripture must be read as a whole.
- Discussion of Isaiah 66 and Nineveh, with Solberg arguing judgment on nations was for general wickedness rather than breaking Mosaic law.
- Exchange on Melchizedek, Christ's high priesthood, and whether Christ serves as priest in the heavenly sanctuary under the new covenant.
- Dialogue touches on the Trinity, substitutionary atonement (PSA), and Leviticus 17:11 regarding blood and atonement.
- The conversation is marked by sharp disagreement, with the host pressing Solberg on his theology and Solberg defending his Augustinian/Reformed framing.
- Overall the discussion is a long, interpersonal theological debate rather than a formal lecture, with shared commitments to Christ as Savior and mutual efforts to stay civil.

## Chapters

1. 00:00 Introduction and moderator welcome
2. 00:55 Guest introduction and background of the debate
3. 05:30 Explaining the Yom Kippur sacrifice question
4. 17:40 Antinomianism, Mosaic law, and the new covenant
5. 30:00 Dietary laws and Ecclesiastes debate
6. 45:00 Isaiah 66, Nineveh, and Melchizedek
7. 70:00 Christ's priesthood and atonement theology
8. 100:00 Trinity, PSA, and closing exchanges

Answers

## Questions about this video

What is Solberg's central challenge in this video?

Solberg asks whether Christians are still required to sacrifice animals to atone for sin, scoped to the Yom Kippur sacrifices in Leviticus 16. He uses this question to argue there is a theological flaw in Torah-observant and Hebrew Roots teaching.

Does Solberg consider himself antinomian?

No, Solberg rejects the label. He says he still upholds God's moral commandments, such as not worshiping other gods, honoring parents, telling the truth, and not coveting, and only argues that specific Mosaic ritual laws are not binding on Christians.

Why does the host disagree that dietary laws were limited to Israel?

The host questions Solberg's view that dietary instructions were only purity laws given to Israel, pointing to Leviticus 20 and the idea that God's instructions set his people apart and reflect his holiness. The two go back and forth on whether these laws were universal or specific to Israel.

## Full Transcript — Download SRT & Markdown

00:55

Speaker A

Hello and welcome to Kingdom of Content. I'm Shawn and I want to thank you for joining here today. We're going to have a wonderful discussion with Professor R.L. Solberg um on his uh theological challenge, if you will, his proposition

01:05

Speaker A

he's putting forward to Torah Observant and Hebrew Roots uh adherents. So, we're going to bring him on. Before we do though, I just want to say a big shout-out and thank you to all the moderators that are here. Um you guys

01:15

Speaker A

are awesome for being here. Thanks for keeping the live chat civil. Uh as always, if if someone gets out of hand, you know, try not to ban them, just put them on a on a mute for 24 hours. Hopefully, they'll get it together, come

01:26

Speaker A

back next time with a better attitude. But as always, thank you guys for being here, being so faithful, and uh hopefully this will be a um a lively and fun conversation that edifies all.

01:38

Speaker A

All right, so without further ado, let us bring up Dr. Solberg. Hey, Shawn. Hey there, how are you today? I'm doing great. Thanks for having me on. Yeah, yeah, thanks for coming back. Uh so, we got together last year and uh we talked

01:53

Speaker A

about a wide variety of topics through the scriptures. Uh we disagreed on a lot of them. I think we agree that Christ is savior, he's the son of God, sent to be the savior of the world, and uh and that

02:03

Speaker A

we're supposed to be his disciples. How that actually plays out, I think, is where you and I run into some disagreements, but I'm glad we at least get together to chat it up and discuss our disagreements in peace. I think this

02:13

Speaker A

should be the standard that most people abide by. I agree. So, you put out a video recently, um it's called The End of Hebrew Roots, and you put forward kind of a challenge towards Torah Observant and uh Hebrew

02:25

Speaker A

Roots adherents. Would you like to explain real quick what that is? Sure. Yeah, I mean, so, what happened was I originally put out just a 60-second video, and I asked uh a yes or no question, a simple question,

02:38

Speaker A

and it's kind of carefully worded. The question is this: Are Christians still required to uh sacrifice animals to atone for sin? And that that, you know, uh kicked up a little dust, so I put out I followed that up with a longer video,

02:56

Speaker A

not real long, 20 minutes or so, where I just kind of unpacked that. And the one thing that I added to the question was a scope. I scoped it specifically to the Leviticus 16 Yom Kippur sacrifices for atonement. So, that's kind of the

03:11

Speaker A

question I put out there and and it's designed to go kind of to the heart of what I see as the um theological flaw in the the theology of Torahism, or some people know it as Hebrew Hebrew Roots or or Pronominism or whatever it might be.

03:26

Speaker A

Okay. But you don't want to be called antinomian, right? I don't think I'm antinomian at all.

03:33

Speaker A

Because you still don't worship other gods, you still honor your mother and father, mother, you still tell the truth, you don't lie, you don't covet.

03:41

Speaker A

So, you still abide by the instructions for righteousness. I think where we differ is you don't think certain certain aspects of God's law, like the Sabbath, the feast days, and the dietary instructions, you don't think those apply to Christians. Yeah, so to to put maybe a finer point

03:56

Speaker A

on it, uh I'm in no way opposed to the Torah. I I the Torah is the first five books of my Bible, right? So, it's a foundational and beautiful part of the Christian faith. I don't think it's done away with, I don't think it's abolished,

04:08

Speaker A

I don't think it's been set aside, any of that stuff. What I what my belief is is that the specific laws given at Sinai were were part of and and in encapsulated in that covenant that God made. They were the

04:21

Speaker A

the terms of that covenant. So, under the new covenant, which I believe we are under right now, we still have commands to obey. Obedience is of utmost importance to God. So, I don't at all promote lawlessness or disobedience or

04:35

Speaker A

rebellion toward God. I mean, I do my best, I'm not perfect, but I do my best to obey as I understand what the Bible says, all of God's commandments that apply to me. So, and and I think that's what everyone

04:47

Speaker A

should do. All Christians should do that. They should they should obey the commands that that apply to us. And I Yes, you're right, I don't think that many of the Torah, what I what I've come to call the Mosaic rituals,

04:58

Speaker A

um which would be sort of the temple system issues, right? Things having to do with the priesthood and the sacrifices, the the the kosher diet, the and these are some of the purity laws that were intended to separate Israel

05:09

Speaker A

from the nations around them. So, Wait, so you think that the dietary instructions were part of the temple instructions? No, I think they're part of purity, the purity laws. You don't think it was a general admonition for all mankind? Sorry. Ho- holiness laws. No, I don't,

05:22

Speaker A

because it was only given to Israel. You think so? Well, I mean, I don't see anywhere in the Bible where where uh Besides the laws Babylon wasn't ever uh demanded or commanded not to eat certain foods.

05:36

Speaker A

Neither was Egypt, neither was Assyria, right? No one else was commanded those things, only Israel was. And actually, that's kind of what it says in in uh uh Leviticus 20, I No, 25, I think. But it says that that these laws were given to set you apart,

05:51

Speaker A

to make you holy. You're set apart from me, God said. And Leviticus 20, 25 and 26 is the one you're thinking about. The Yeah, that's right.

06:00

Speaker A

Yeah, to to be holy as he is holy. So, that means he does the things he instructed Israel to do, right? No.

06:07

Speaker A

He's not Israel, he's God. He's the instructor. Okay. Okay. So, you think He is holy, absolutely. He is absolutely holy. So, what what he's doing, I think, in those laws, in those food laws, is giving giving Israel a way to

06:21

Speaker A

distinguish Israel from all the nations around her. Right? That's, you know, that's how Yeah, that's how they're set apart, you're right. So, they don't have crazy uh rituals at the temples to Pan and Baal and Molech, and they don't offer their children to the fire, they don't

06:35

Speaker A

destroy themselves and pollute their land and their bodies. I get it. What do you think about a verse like this when it clearly tells us that the commandments are for the whole duty of man?

06:49

Speaker A

What do I think about that in terms of what? What are we in Ecclesiastes? All of mankind is expected to keep God's commandments. Yeah, I agree.

06:57

Speaker A

Okay. But not But that I don't think I would read that as the Mosaic commands.

07:01

Speaker A

I wouldn't read that as the Mosaic commands. The there is no distinction here. The the writer of Ecclesiastes is uh living in the days of what you're calling the Mosaic commands.

07:11

Speaker A

Sure, but I I uh There's no distinction. I read that in the context of all of scripture. Okay. So, we need to look at the entire witness of scripture to understand. And so, if you want to go actually go back

07:24

Speaker A

to the Torah, but this is a little bit off topic of my question, but I don't mind, we can go wherever you'd like, but Well, it's it's going to play into it because we're going to be getting into the idea of, you know, is Christ

07:35

Speaker A

actually what's he doing right now? Are sacrifices still required by Christians? And if so, well, you know, why aren't they doing them? And there's a lot of very easy explanations for these things that scripture tells us.

07:48

Speaker A

Um what about though when he's when he's talking about the nations and he's reprimanding them here? Right.

07:54

Speaker A

Isaiah 66. And he tells them that, you know, these are these people are wicked. They offered pig's blood, they sacrificed they they break the dog's neck. These are the occult practices instead of you know, they're eating the wrong things, they're they're in the groves,

08:11

Speaker A

they're eating the rats. Yeah, God has always judged other nations for general wickedness. That's what happened at Nineveh. But this wickedness is specifically described as the dietary information. But Nineveh wasn't wasn't uh threatened with destruction because of any Mosaic laws

08:28

Speaker A

they were breaking. It was because of their wickedness. So, so here's my here's my belief Well, but how do you know what their wickedness is wasn't included in them dishonoring God's fullness of his commandments? I'm I'm not following the question. So,

08:43

Speaker A

if you're claiming you know you're you're claiming that Assyria or Nineveh was going to be judged, had they not listened to Jonah, because of their wickedness, but you're already presupposing a definition for that wickedness outside of God's commandments.

08:59

Speaker A

So, what wickedness were they actually doing that Jonah told them to repent of? Well, do you know what do you know what the wickedness that's described in the book of Jonah? Yeah, I I know that they're the the

09:10

Speaker A

kingdom of Assyria, it's also given to us in Isaiah as far as the wickedness they engaged in. So, it's it's mass idolatry, it's the eating and drinking of bloods, the very things that we're told as Christians not to do in Acts 15, uh 19 and 20.

09:22

Speaker A

Is that in the book of Jonah? No, I'm saying there's a continuity as far as the instructions for what Christians are told to avoid as part of God's law from Exodus, Deuteronomy, and Leviticus that we see other nations are

09:33

Speaker A

being reprimanded and judged for as well. Yeah, well, so so if you're talking about Isaiah 66, is that what is that the one you just had up? I I did. I also just was going to ask you real quick

09:43

Speaker A

before we jump into the concept of sacrifices about why in the future in Revelation it's still calling things unclean.

09:54

Speaker A

Talking about dietary. It's still labeling animals as clean and unclean in the future when Christ returns at the second coming. Well, if you want to take a big side tour into biblical uh prophecy, we can do that. I I don't

10:07

Speaker A

know if the prophecy will come up because we're living in fulfilled prophecy now. The Old Testament is still playing itself out right now, right? No, the old covenant's over.

10:17

Speaker A

So, you're telling me that Isaiah 65 has already happened? Isaiah's chapter 61 has already happened? Zion has already happened? The priest that the nations are going to bow down to the priests of God who serve under Christ?

10:29

Speaker A

I'm not saying that everything has happened. I'm saying the new covenant has begun. So, okay. So, it's what I'm getting at though is there's prophecy in the Old Testament that hasn't come true yet. It hasn't happened yet. The second

10:37

Speaker A

coming, Zion, Zephaniah 1 hasn't happened yet. Yeah, I mean, obviously we we believe there's a second coming of Christ when all these things will be fully inaugurated, right?

10:48

Speaker A

Inaugurated eschatology, that's kind of what I subscribe to. It's what I believe the Bible teaches. That there are, as Jesus says, the hour has come the hour is coming and has now come. There's this sort of both and sense of the new

11:00

Speaker A

covenant that it's been inaugurated but it hasn't been fully consummated. So, so there's still awaiting. There's still things for God to do. There's still promised prophecies that have not been fulfilled. This is the same argument that that I hear from Jewish rabbis. Why isn't there peace out when you look

11:16

Speaker A

out your window? Why isn't there peace everywhere? Jesus wasn't the Messiah. He couldn't have been is the is the is the argument that that that would be a straw man cuz Jewish messiah Jewish rabbis they they don't accept the son of God. They don't accept the prophecies of him in

11:28

Speaker A

the Old Testament. They don't accept Psalm 110 about him becoming a high priest. It's not the same argument. The eschatological fulfillment of what Christ brings at the second coming, they would reject anyway because they don't believe in the first coming prophecies of Christ. Right, but what I'm saying is

11:41

Speaker A

the argument that they'll put out is that the the Old Testament, the Tanakh, doesn't say anything about two comings of Christ. So, Oh, absolutely it does. I I agree with you, but I'm telling you what you're you're what what you're pointing out as a as a perceived flaw,

11:56

Speaker A

the fact that all the prophecies have not been fulfilled yet isn't actually accurate to what I believe the New Testament teaches about the new covenant. It doesn't say that all those things will happen all at once.

12:06

Speaker A

Okay. So, help me understand We have a video on my on my channel called understanding the end times biblical prophecy. And we look through it and what I did, it's an interesting study and it kind of impacts what you're

12:17

Speaker A

talking about here. We look through prophecy that was given and fulfilled on the pages of scripture. So, we see where it was given and then we see how it played out and the big takeaway from this is that you can

12:30

Speaker A

almost never guess how it would have been fulfilled. It's all it's always different and other than we might have expected.

12:37

Speaker A

So, I think the same thing's happening with the prophecies as you're reading them uh in in the Old Testament, I think what what you're seeing is that you're expecting a certain outcome. And the biggest problem I see, personally, is when we look at the old covenant prophecies in Isaiah and of

12:53

Speaker A

Isaiah and of Ezekiel and we expect some sort of one-to-one literal correlation. That almost never happens in scripture. Right? And we we miss the fact that even sometimes prophecies are conditional. They're not always the same things.

13:06

Speaker A

Peter on in Acts 2 would disagree with you when he's quoting Psalm 16:10 about Christ's body and soul. example because it Who else is quoting Acts 2? He he he quotes Joel. Yeah, in the latter days of Joel. In the latter days the spirit will pour out, sons and daughters will

13:22

Speaker A

prophesy and dream dreams. Yeah, that that is happening through the gifts of the spirit. We understand that. This falls within the latter days, but there is a specific foretelling of what Christ would would live, die, and resurrect. Those things we can we can see a one-to-one parallel.

13:37

Speaker A

This is uh widespread Christian apologetics. This is how we show the one-to-one parallel. You stopped a little short. He he actually goes on to say the sun shall be turned to darkness and the moon to blood Mhm. before the day of the Lord comes, a great and magnificent day. So,

13:53

Speaker A

what that tells us is that that prophecy wasn't intended to be understood as a one-to-one literal correlation that the actual literal sun is going to, you know, turn to darkness and the moon's going to turn to literal blood, right?

14:05

Speaker A

So, we So, we need to understand that the prophecies, and this is what I'm I'm not saying you're wrong, but what I'm doing is issuing a word of caution. I I really strongly believe that we need to approach, especially end times

14:15

Speaker A

prophecies and the Messianic prophecies need to be approached with some humility and prayer. And if anyone Brother, you don't think that I've approached scripture with humility and prayer? Come on now.

14:26

Speaker A

I'm not saying that at all. I'm just saying sounds exactly what you just said though. Okay, well, let me correct the record. Uh I'm not saying you're guilty of this. I'm saying this is a general not even rule of thumb. I think it's an important guideline to follow. And so,

14:39

Speaker A

if any of us with our modern minds read 3,000-year-old ancient text and we think that the first images that pop into our mind are exactly what that old prophet meant in the other languages in a in a culture removed from us, I think that's

14:52

Speaker A

a mistake. We we need to we need to press in and then harmonize what we're reading with all of scripture. Yeah, that's what we teach as well. Look up the definitions. Try to find correlating context of what's being spoken

15:04

Speaker A

so that you're not taking things out of context and isolating a passage. Yeah, so yeah, that's that's important for sure when you're studying the scriptures. Um but I'm saying specifically there is scriptures about Christ that is that we've very clearly we can see

15:19

Speaker A

they've been fulfilled and then there's other passages like his second coming where all nations are drawn to Zion to learn the law of God like in Isaiah 2. That has not happened yet. Right.

15:32

Speaker A

So, So, wait. So, just I'm saying that because Are you saying because that hasn't happened we're not yet under the new covenant?

15:40

Speaker A

No, I've already I've always said that the new covenant applies when you get your glorified immortal resurrected body. That's the new covenant that your is the laws are put on your heart and mind. That's how your the sin has been

15:51

Speaker A

removed from you. You have a new incorruptible body and heart and mind. His laws are on it. You never sin again. You will always be subject in in peace with God. There's never a chance for enmity ever again.

16:03

Speaker A

So, right now in faith and belief, we disciple, we sanctify right now. We walk in the behavior of Christ, which I'm hearing you say we don't do the fullness of. So, it kind of concerns me. Well, I'm not saying

16:14

Speaker A

tell us we walk in the behavior of Christ like 1 John 2 talks about. This is how we know that we're not liars, that we actually walk in his behavior.

16:21

Speaker A

So, then that's how we sanctify ourselves in this life awaiting perfection at the resurrection. This is what Paul preaches in Philippians 3.

16:29

Speaker A

Paul also preaches that we are ministers of the new covenant. The new covenant has clearly begun. I mean, I that's a little bit surprising that you think it's still off in the future. So, Jeremy, we I think we may have been over this before, but you know it says in Jeremiah

16:42

Speaker A

31 that the the new covenant promises you that you'll have God's laws on your heart and mind so that you obey them. Yep.

16:49

Speaker A

So, are you obeying them? I'm doing my best empowered by the Holy Spirit. Which laws are those? All of the laws that apply to new covenant Christians. If you If you're looking for the word law, which I kind

17:02

Speaker A

of reject that concept, I think we're under grace, not law, but doesn't mean we don't have anything to obey. But if you like the word law and you want to adopt a legal sort of construct, the law of Christ is what I obey. Is what all

17:14

Speaker A

Christians should obey. The law of Christ? Is the law of Christ different from his father's law? Well, I'm talking about the specific term law of Christ that's used in Galatians.

17:25

Speaker A

Uh You mean 1 Corinthians? What? No, he says in Galatians 2, doesn't he? Is the law of Christ different from his father's law?

17:37

Speaker A

That's an interesting question. Is it different than his father's law? Okay, let me to answer that, if you don't mind, let me take a step back and and explain my view of of the law in the Bible. I

17:50

Speaker A

believe that there is a eternal, unchanging, morally perfect set of principles grounded in God. Not even grounded in God. I think that it is God. God is this moral perfection that never changes. Right? And that's And from the beginning, and I'll I'll make this quick. From the beginning, I

18:13

Speaker A

believe that has been in effect. God can't go against his own character. So, he's always the same. He'll never change. His moral perfection is is is the standard at all times for all people. Psalm 119 says the thing. Let me finish up the thought. So, the the idea is that

18:28

Speaker A

he has expressed those principles differently at different times to his people. Not because he changes, but because of his mercy, he's willing to condescend to what it takes to help human beings move closer. Can you give me a quick example of how you think he expresses his moral character

18:46

Speaker A

differently? Yeah, when Jesus says uh Moses let you get divorced because of the hardness of your hearts, but from the beginning it has not been so. So, do you think that God's moral standard, his perfect moral standard is no, we don't get divorced. That's not

19:01

Speaker A

part of God's universe. God looks down and he sees the knuckleheads that humanity had become because of our sin and says, "Look, I'm going I'm going to make a concession for you." Here's another example, Hebrews 7. He talks

19:12

Speaker A

about, I think it's verse 18 or so, 25, somewhere near the end of Hebrews 7, he talks about the law that was given was set aside because it's weak and useless.

19:21

Speaker A

God God appointed weak human beings as his high priests. I see that as a as a holy, beautiful, merciful concession on our part.

19:31

Speaker A

That he allowed these sinners to actually even deem to to represent him or come close to him. That's that's God's allowance for mankind's flaws. And it does not at all diminish the holiness of God. What it does this is it shows us his mercy and his love that he's willing to do

19:48

Speaker A

those things. And do you think you think that he allowed sinners to approach his tabernacle?

19:57

Speaker A

Sinner Well, I mean everyone's a sinner, so yeah, but there was obviously ritual cleansing that needed to happen. There's also a circumcision of the heart that was required by the for any other priest that approached him. That's actually a part of what makes atonement. From the the manly the human

20:11

Speaker A

requirements for atonement, there was he had to have the right lineage according to the Levites on the earth anyway. We're talking about on the earth. You have the right lineage, you have to have a clean body. You had to have um

20:23

Speaker A

circumcised heart. These are like some of the basic requirements, right? So therefore, if his heart wasn't circumcised and he approached, this is where Yahweh starts chastising them for their duplicitousness and their their hypocrisy. This is this is the the conversation of

20:37

Speaker A

Malachi for the priests robbing him. This is the conversation in Isaiah 1 where he says, I I don't like your feasts, right? He's not talking about the feasts he instituted. He's talking about them doing it duplicitously while worshipping other gods. Yeah, no, I agree there was absolutely

20:53

Speaker A

ritual purification required to approach God in in the tabernacle. I said, brother. That's not what I said at all. Did you hear me?

20:59

Speaker A

I think I heard you. Uh maybe I misheard. Did I use the wrong word? What did I miss? I'm talking I said their heart has to be circumcised to Yahweh. Okay. Okay.

21:07

Speaker A

Not just the outer body. Their outer body could be clean, but their heart has to be circumcised. So where is that in scripture? This is the requirement for a priest who ministers to God. He has to be devoted to him with sincerity.

21:19

Speaker A

Where's the where's the scripture that says they have to have a circumcised of this. In 2 Chronicles chapter 30, this is Remember what I said, but the body and the heart have to be ready and prepared to step before the father. I

21:31

Speaker A

agree with that. we see an example of this to the inverse not happen. I'll I'll give you a Leviticus 17 then I'll Let me give you a 2 Chronicles 30 first. Okay. So we see in Hezekiah's Passover, 8 and

21:43

Speaker A

1/2 of the tribes reassembled to celebrate his Passover. The ones that came down from Samaria wasn't called Samaria yet, but the ones that came down from the the scattered northern remnants um they did not prepare their bodies, but they but Hezekiah said they did prepare their hearts. So the plague

22:01

Speaker A

broke out and they needed to be healed. Hezekiah prays for them, God heals them and forgives it because he says they did prepare their hearts, right? So that's one example where one of those two qualifiers needed to be done. They didn't do the body part, there's an

22:14

Speaker A

issue, it gets taken care of. Sure. Leviticus 17 example of God's mercy. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. God is very merciful. He sits on the the mercy seat, right? He's He's a wonderful God. So I'm just talking about the actual requirements for what he says. And so

22:29

Speaker A

this is a is kind of important because the none of this applies for Christians cuz we don't have a temple that we interact with today, right? So when in the case of Aaron, we see that Aaron in Leviticus 10:17 where his Nadab and

22:41

Speaker A

Abihu had just been killed because they brought strange fire. Right. the sin offering is not Moses sees the sin offering and it's not being eaten by Aaron. So he goes to Aaron and says, why haven't you eaten the sin offering? And then Aaron replies, I didn't think

22:54

Speaker A

it would be right on this day. And then Moses says, it was a good answer. He understood.

23:01

Speaker A

Right? So Aaron didn't fulfill his requirement as high priest to eat the sin offering because he was mourning his two sons. He was his heart was not circumcised to Yahweh. Who knows what he was thinking about Yahweh at that

23:14

Speaker A

moment, right? He just watched his two sons get killed. Right. not held guilty for not eating doing his part of the sacrifice and eating the sin offering. Right. And then Jesus said even they would they would do circumcision on the Sabbath because they

23:27

Speaker A

wanted to uphold the law. So there are all these little uh you know, That's not what I'm talking about, but I'm just I'm just saying we don't need to follow exactly everything perfectly. That we need to uphold the

23:39

Speaker A

law. Clearly there's grace. I'm just expressing to you this idea that when it comes to making atonement, there's all these factors that go into making atonement. And here's the here's the part me stipulate to you, maybe it'll move the conversation forward. I stipulate to

23:52

Speaker A

you that that that the high priest or any priest that was making an offering need to have needed to have his heart right with God before making the the sacrifice. Now I think it would help us if we could keep

24:03

Speaker A

our topic or our scope of our discussion to specifically the day of atonement topic or our scope of our discussion to specifically the day of atonement sacrifices because we can get off into all the different sin offerings and all

24:12

Speaker A

those other things. It's it's all pointed I mean I don't know why you're going to stress about the day of atonement, but it's all pointed to that's the specific day that's referred to in Hebrews 10 and that's this is the

24:22

Speaker A

core of my question that I'm posing. Leviticus 16, read all of that. Read Hebrews 10. This is where my question comes from. And so since the Hebrews scoped his conversa or his comments in the Hebrews 10 to to the day

24:37

Speaker A

of atonement Yom Kippur, that's I think that's where we need to go if we want to get to the crux of what I'm trying to determine. Christ doesn't have to make sacrifices for himself and his family because he's without sin. This is what

24:47

Speaker A

Hebrews 10 is explaining to you. Yep. Well, actually Hebrews 9 and 10 is kind of going you through the motions comparing him Yeah, but it's comparing you how he's greater than the Levites, right? Cuz he's without sin. The Levites were weak and frail beset in their weaknesses.

25:01

Speaker A

They also had a lineage requirement based upon that succession of the priesthood where the Melchizedek does not. The Melchizedek The Melchizedek has a righteousness requirement. Uh so they're selected by God.

25:12

Speaker A

So Christ being the chosen high priest from before he became a man prophesied to become a high priest forever is selected because he was faithful unto death. This is what Hebrews 5:7-10 tells us because he even though he's a son, he learned obedience through what he suffered. And having

25:28

Speaker A

been made perfect, he became the source of eternal salvation to those who obey him. And God made him a high priest forever in the order Melchizedek. So he's a high priest forever. What do priests do? What do What do priests of Yahweh do?

25:43

Speaker A

They minister on behalf of the people. What is the definition of minister in scripture? Which part? The way the way Melchizedek definition? I mean, Melchizedek ministered to Abraham in a different way than the Levitical priests ministered. He didn't. There's Yeah, but he gave

25:57

Speaker A

bread and wine. That's there was no temple. There was no altar. It says the Melchizedek brought out the bread and wine. Abraham brought him the first fruits, which is a part of God's law for bringing sacrifices to a priest. Yeah, well as as Hebrews says,

26:13

Speaker A

Melchizedek could not have even been a priest under the Levitical priesthood. So Well, I'm not saying that. I'm talking Wait wait wait wait wait. We got to slow down here. You just you just conflated a big concept here. Okay. The

26:24

Speaker A

Melchizedek in Genesis 14, he brings out the bread and the wine as a greeting to Abraham. He does not sacrifice the bread and the wine in that moment. It does There's no There's no moment there. What is being

26:36

Speaker A

sacrificed is the offering that's being brought as a tithe to the Melchizedek and this is in the this is found in the law of God.

26:43

Speaker A

Hold on, let me pull up Genesis 14 unless you want to do that. I think it's only like three verses long.

26:52

Speaker A

Yeah, Melchizedek, king of Salem, brought out bread and wine. He was priest of God Most High and he blessed him and said, "Blessed be Abraham by God Most High, possessor of heaven and earth, and blessed be God Most High who

27:04

Speaker A

has delivered your enemies into your hand." And Abraham gave him a tenth of everything. That's right. Who do you give a tenth to? Why do you give a tenth to a priest in God's law? To to to recognize and acknowledge that

27:17

Speaker A

God owns everything. It's a it's a it's a Just like Jacob did in Genesis 30, Abraham abided by the same law. Just like Genesis 26:5 tells us Abraham was faithful in his the charge, which is the priesthood in the Hebrew,

27:31

Speaker A

the statutes, ordinances, and the Torah. So all the things instructed in God's not just the commandments that you're saying only apply to Israel, but the statutes and the ordinances, those are specific instructions for feast days, Sabbaths, priestly duties. Wait a second.

27:47

Speaker A

We might have talked about this before. Are you saying the law existed before Sinai? The law of Moses that's what we talk about and teach, brother. The old covenant law you're saying existed before the old covenant. Yeah, we've talked about it in depth, so we're

27:58

Speaker A

not going to get stuck there, but I want to just address your idea of Hebrews 7 through 10, which is you think that this is a this is a change that's happening, but that word in the Greek in Hebrews 7:12 literally just means to transfer.

28:11

Speaker A

It's a transfer of the priesthood. Literally in the Greek it does. It's a transfer of the priesthood.

28:18

Speaker A

Okay, well, hold on. I got to look this up cuz I don't think that's the case at all. And I'll admit it if I'm wrong. I'll put it on the screen for us. How about that? What would you say as far as the um

28:31

Speaker A

the the commandments later in Hebrews when it says an a commandment has been set aside? Is that a change? Well, hang on. Let's let's deal with Hebrews 7:12 first. Okay.

28:42

Speaker A

It's a transfer of the priesthood. This is why Christ is now Do you believe that Christ is now high priest in heaven's temple?

28:48

Speaker A

Hold on. Okay, I'm pulling up the I'm pulling up that word. Okay. Um I'm sorry, I missed that question. Do you believe that Christ is a high priest in heaven's temple? Yes. He's our high priest. He's the high

29:05

Speaker A

priest of the new covenant. You know, I'm getting a little bit confused and I feel like in one sense, we are talking past each other. Oh, what do you got there? Oh, thank you. Yep. So there's two definitions and what

29:21

Speaker A

we need to do is determine the definition based on the context. You can choose the first one if that makes you feel better, but guess what?

29:28

Speaker A

I asked you the question, is Christ a high priest in heaven's temple? When something gets transferred, it doesn't change? No, the behaviors for a minister in God's temple is the same definition throughout scripture.

29:41

Speaker A

But the transfer of who gets that authority is what we see prophesied for Christ to become high priest in heaven's temple over the Melchizedek order. We It was prophesied for the Levitical temple on the earth because of their rebellion,

29:52

Speaker A

because of their faithlessness to be destroyed. And it's not coming back until the second coming. Thank you. You've just admitted that the Old Covenant law is not in effect. Thank you. No, I didn't, brother. Yeah, you you just you're conflating Hang on now. You're conflating the prophecy for the

30:07

Speaker A

temple in the Levitical priesthood on the earth to be done away because of the rebellion only to be reinstated at the second coming. You're equating that for the entire Old Covenant law to be done away with. No.

30:19

Speaker A

That's what you just said. And let let me let me back it up a little bit then. What I'm saying when I say that you're admitting that the law is no longer in effect is based on the assumption, and we can set this aside if

30:29

Speaker A

you'd like, that if you break one law, none of them or you're breaking all the laws, right? So, if you want to just say, "Okay, let me let me update this. I don't want this to be a a point of contention cuz I think we're getting to

30:41

Speaker A

something important." I'll just say this, you're admitting that some of the commandments under the Torah, given under the Torah, have ended.

30:49

Speaker A

No, they're not ended. They're not available. This is why I keep telling you No, but you just Isaiah 66:19-23 literally tells you that he's going to reinstate new Levites and new ministers and priests to himself in the earth. want to take that all literally. I mean,

31:02

Speaker A

if you look at Isaiah Why wouldn't you take it literally? Well, look at Isaiah 66:4 about the second coming of Christ. Why wouldn't you take it literally? Okay, let me apologize.

31:13

Speaker A

I'm getting caught up in my fleshly desire to argue, and that's that's one of my character flaws, and I apologize. I'm not I don't want to win an argument. I want to get to the truth. So, I I apologize,

31:24

Speaker A

but what I'd like to do is stick with Hebrews 7. I think we were on a good track. You pulled up the you pulled up the Greek. Brother, just like you said at the beginning even in the studio before we started this this uh show

31:35

Speaker A

it's all connected. Yeah, I agree. It's all connected. I can't I let you do this last time. I cannot let you get away with it this time. I cannot let you say prophecy is up for interpretation, and is not

31:45

Speaker A

literal, and is allegorical, and we're just going to ignore it. If you're claiming you're you've made a lot of large claims in your channel in the last year. You're claiming even to me personally you think that I teach

31:56

Speaker A

dangerous things. You've talked about other Hebrew roots Torah observant people teach dangerous things. You've also taught, whether you agree with it or not, by definition you teach antinomian principles in your teachings.

32:10

Speaker A

Not even close. Which I could easily turn that around on you if I wanted to and say, "You're teaching dangerous things." In fact, because you think the Old Testament and the New Testament are dissimilar I could pull up against heresies chapter book three directly from Irenaeus and

32:25

Speaker A

put his words in your face and say that he would call you a heretic in the second century AD. I only Because they're not dissimilar. They're exactly the same covenants. Christ is now bringing us into the new covenant at the resurrection. Did you say they're

32:38

Speaker A

exactly the same covenant? No, I said it's the same Christ is and if I did I that's not what I meant to say. I'm talking about the the covenants are not dissim- they're this is what Irenaeus argues. And he's

32:49

Speaker A

arguing against the Marcionites, the antinomianites. He's arguing against people who claim that the Old Testament was somehow just for the Jews, and now as Christians we do different behavior. That is completely repudiated throughout the early church fathers and the apostles. I

33:03

Speaker A

don't agree with Marcion, and I don't agree with what you're saying. You're mischaracterizing my position. I'm not trying to mischaracterize you.

33:09

Speaker A

I've studied you for a year now, brother. I've watched your videos. Well, I'm not saying that they're dissimilar anymore than the Bible says they're dissimilar. Okay, so all I'm trying to get at is I do want to stick in Hebrews

33:19

Speaker A

7 through 10 with you, but it is connected. If Christ is still a high priest forever, that means he's still a high priest at the second coming. Do you agree? Yeah, he's our high priest eternally.

33:30

Speaker A

So then he's still high priest when new Levites are chosen on the earth to minister on the earth. If new Levites are chosen.

33:37

Speaker A

Okay. So, is he still a high priest in Zechariah 14? He He wasn't made high priest until he until the incarnation. You said so yourself. Hebrews 5 is how where he was appointed as a high priest. Let's read this together,

33:53

Speaker A

brother. Okay. Okay. So, we And then let's get back to Hebrews 7. Yeah, because this is we're in Hebrews 7 because he's a high priest forever, right? Hebrews 7:25. So, look look here in this is forever part of that forever part. are you reading Hebrews 7:25 as

34:10

Speaker A

retroactive? He's a high priest forever. No, this is the future second coming of Christ where Christ is still high priest because he's high priest forever.

34:20

Speaker A

Okay. He doesn't lose that position. So, when he comes and you and I get resurrected, Christ will still be high priest.

34:27

Speaker A

Amen. Okay. So, in this passage here when the survivors of the nations that came against Jerusalem on the day of the Lord at the second coming of Christ they go up year after year to worship the king Lord of hosts and celebrate the

34:40

Speaker A

Feast of Tabernacles. Christ is still high priest over this Feast of Tabernacles that all nations are required to go observe. And do you know that in Numbers chapter 28 and 29 there are atonement offerings done at the feasts of God? And and where is that?

34:59

Speaker A

Have you Have you checked out Numbers 28 and 29? Uh not recently. Okay. So, I I have had Numbers, yeah. At the Feast of God there are atonement offerings performed by the priesthood at the Feast of God. This

35:12

Speaker A

prophecy in the future where in Christ is reigning over the earth as king and high priest Right. that all nations will come and celebrate the Feast of Tabernacles. Right. Okay. Is that literal?

35:25

Speaker A

Yeah, 100% literal, bro. Listen. All nations There is no There is no symbolic reference for this. This is all nations go to Jerusalem to worship the king, to worship God. This is the story of the kingdom come.

35:38

Speaker A

Yeah, but this is the error you're falling into, if I may be so bold, is that you're reading everything it with a one-to-one literal correlation from the prophecies to the to the end times. You're assuming it's going to come true

35:49

Speaker A

in exactly the literal way that it's said. I'm not saying this is not a true prophecy. No no I Lovingly Lovingly, brother, not today. We can't do that today. I If you think that this is If you think this isn't literal, you've got to you've got to

36:04

Speaker A

stand on business today and actually give me your interpretation of this. Uh I have a three-part article on Zechariah 14 on my website.

36:11

Speaker A

this is? Can you give me a short summation? Uh Do I Do I think Well, I think that it's open to different types of interpretation as all prophecy is. What do you think it is, sir?

36:22

Speaker A

Do I think it's literal? What do you think this is saying, sir? Oh, what do I think it's saying? I think it's talking about in the last days everyone will worship God and glorify him, and he will be the the source of all the nations bowing down. Every knee

36:38

Speaker A

shall bow before God. Okay. I don't I have I have a three You think that You think the first part of the sentence is correct. They're going to go to Jerusalem to worship the king Lord of hosts, but you don't think the second part of the sentence is

36:52

Speaker A

correct. Well, no. I mean, look at the whole Look at the whole sentence. If then all the survivors So, these are the survivors of that big battle, right? We're assuming that these are all the the other nations. Not just that, but Revelation 16:18 where there's a massive earthquake

37:05

Speaker A

and all the cities of the earth are destroyed. So, here we have the survivors who somehow sur- survived this wicked Day of the Lord, right? It's not It's not wicked. It's a blessing for us. It's only doom for the for the wicked. Lovingly.

37:19

Speaker A

Okay. The scary, awesome, use your adjective, Day of the Lord, there have been some survivors, and this says that those survivors from the nations, so this would be Gentile survivors, right? That's what That's why they're calling it the nations. Would you agree with that? Well, that that word is synonymous

37:36

Speaker A

with Gentiles. Yeah. So, in other words, not Israel. Yeah, cuz Israel's been resurrected. That's the first first resurrection.

37:44

Speaker A

that came up against Jerusalem. So, these are people that fought against either Jerusalem or Israel. Sometimes Jerusalem is used to refer to to the people of God. Uh will go up year after year to worship the king the Lord of

37:57

Speaker A

hosts, okay? And to celebrate the Feast of Tabernacles. Now, does that mean literally celebrate the Feast of Tabernacles? I don't know. I I'm not prepared to say that. I am. Because Okay, look at it this way. And I And I don't know if

38:09

Speaker A

no other symbolism in this passage. The The angel given the vision Zechariah, nobody tries to reinterpret this or say this is a metaphor for this or that.

38:18

Speaker A

Leviticus Leviticus 23, the Feast of Tabernacles is called an eternal ordinance for all generations.

38:24

Speaker A

So, whenever the Tabernacle is there so that people can go observe this in the way that's instructed you see God himself overseeing this activity that all nations are required to do. And it even says if they don't they're not

38:37

Speaker A

going to get rain on their land. So, there's even a consequence. This is no allegory. This is no metaphor. think that's allegory? So, you think you've got some families that'll have rain, and then the next door neighbor who didn't go up there won't have rain? Do you know why? Because this is

38:50

Speaker A

Leviticus 26. This is promised in God's law. This is a part of if you rebel against his law, your sky will turn as bronze and your land as iron. Just for you, right? You inhabit famine.

39:00

Speaker A

Yeah, so I'm saying All due respect, we can agree controls the wind and the weather, right? I think you're suffering from a hyper-literal interpretation of prophecy. We talked about this the first time. literal. I Hear me clearly. I'm not

39:12

Speaker A

saying that isn't literal. I'm saying I don't know. Okay, so this is where It's dangerous to take it as a literal one-to-one correlation. dangerous to for me to take God's word seriously, brother. I'm not saying don't take it seriously. Don't don't put words

39:26

Speaker A

in my mouth. I said it's dangerous to take it as a one-to-one literal correlation. I'm going to take the nations that are forced to worship Yahweh at his return, him and his son. I'm going to take that very literal because that's the promise of all the prophets and

39:38

Speaker A

Christ himself. He's going to come back and rule with a rod of iron. So, that yeah, so with a literal rod of iron You know what that You know what that there are idioms used in scripture, right? Exactly my point.

39:50

Speaker A

the ruling is not an idiom. You should understand that. Right. No, I get that.

39:54

Speaker A

Yeah. Right. Okay, so then we're in agreement. The ruling is not a metaphor. The ruling is a literal thing. Who's he going to In Revelation 24 through 6 at the resurrection the saints, who do we rule and reign over? Okay, Sean, we're way off a far field

40:08

Speaker A

from Hebrews 7. So I feel like we're pulling we're walking down a rabbit trail. So We're not because your your claim is that Christians should be sacrificing today if they want to be Torah observant, right?

40:20

Speaker A

I didn't claim that. I asked a question. I think I think that your your question is a is put forward as a debate claim, brother.

40:28

Speaker A

Well, okay, so I'll I'll answer it this way. I know that many Torah observant Christians believe that if the temple existed today and if the priesthood existed today, Christians should be sacrificing animals to atone for their sin today. Do you think that's accurate?

40:44

Speaker A

If there was a standing temple, they would. Okay. Well, then great. We're at the heart of my question. Yeah. So then why No, no, let's logically walk through this. So then therefore why can't Christians do that? It's not why can't. My question has

40:59

Speaker A

nothing to do It absolutely does, brother. No, I cleared that up in my larger video, my 20-minute video.

41:04

Speaker A

Okay, I I respectfully the audience we have to pretend for this discussion like they haven't seen every word you've said about this. You've got to give me a summary. Update Update people. Okay, so let me let me clarify what I said in my

41:15

Speaker A

second video for those who haven't seen it. I said the question is are sin sacrifices animal sacrifices still required to atone for sin today? I didn't say can we make sin sacrifices? I didn't say what do those sin sacrifices

41:31

Speaker A

accomplish? I just asked one question. Are they required, right? Yes. That's the only question. Is is the requirement still exist? Is that still the way God requires sin to be atoned for? Yeah, that's why Yes. So let's go to Hebrews.

41:47

Speaker A

And so your answer is yes, we still do need to No, who does the sin sacrifices for the sin of the people?

41:55

Speaker A

If you're talking about Leviticus 16, which I am, it's the high priest. That's once a year. Who does them daily? Every Sabbath, every 7 days, every feast day, every new moon Who does there's this weird there's a weird

42:05

Speaker A

passage in Hebrews, I think it's 7, where it says that the high priest offers sacrifices daily. First for his own sins and then for the rest of the people. So 9 and that's why I'm not sure if he's

42:15

Speaker A

talking about literally daily or if he's just kind of using that as a as a vernacular or if he's including other things besides the Leviticus 16 sacrifice. But the high priest sacrifice once a year, the annual Yom Kippur, where where he made sacrifices the high

42:31

Speaker A

priest made a sacrifice for his own sin, for the sin of his household and for the sins of Israel. That was once a year. Right. So Hebrews 9 explains to you that Christ doesn't have to make sacrifice for himself or for his own household.

42:43

Speaker A

Right. That's why he's superior. Because it doesn't apply to him cuz he's without sin and he doesn't have a family in heaven that he has to to bring into cleanness with him to the to the temple, right? It doesn't apply to him.

42:54

Speaker A

But what does apply? about that little family part, but yeah, I agree it doesn't apply to him cuz he's sinless.

42:59

Speaker A

Christ Christ doesn't have a wife and children that he's bringing to the tabernacle in heaven in Hebrews 8. Yeah, that's that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant. It doesn't say anything It's clearly why it's being brought up in Hebrews 9 how he's different from the earthly priests because there's certain

43:14

Speaker A

things that don't apply to him because he's in heaven's temple. Well, no, it's not because he's in heaven's temple. It's because he's sinless. Okay. He doesn't He didn't have a wife and kids is all I'm trying to say, man. I think we both agree with that. I agree

43:27

Speaker A

he didn't have a wife and kids. And therefore he doesn't have one in heaven with him either. As he's ministering in the temple in heaven. Because Hebrews 8:1 tells you he's ministering in heaven's temple. That's what a high

43:37

Speaker A

priest does. So here's here's what I'm concerned about, Sean. Is that when you add little phrases like that that are found the concept found nowhere in Hebrews No one's adding a phrase. I'm explaining to you why Hebrews 9 is juxtaposing the

43:51

Speaker A

Levites with Christ and how they're different. That's all. I'm not adding phrases. Can you show me the verse where it talks about the families of the priests? Brother, you just mentioned it to me.

44:00

Speaker A

You just repeated it to me that the verse that for the high priest has to do a sin sacrifice for himself and for his own family. I have to throw a red flag and say let's watch the tape. Uh because I didn't mention families. I

44:13

Speaker A

don't No, that's to me that's a foreign concept. And I'm not going to get wrapped around the axle about it if that's not a big deal, but I just wanted to point it out. I'm not sure why you added that in

44:22

Speaker A

there. What Why I added what in there? That the part about bringing families in to the tabernacle. Because this is what Hebrews is talking about. Okay. About how he doesn't have to make He doesn't have to make uh propitiation uh for himself and his families like the

44:38

Speaker A

Hebrew like the Levite priesthood because Christ is without sin and he doesn't have a family in tow. Yeah, where's the word family? Where's the concept? I'm I'm giving you a summary idea of what is talked about in the law about Leviticus 16 about the high priest who

44:55

Speaker A

I really kind of feel like you're being obstinate right now, brother. You know better than this. Well, hold on. I think you're I think it's almost like you're trolling me. This isn't sounding good faith right now. No, I I don't mean to,

45:05

Speaker A

but but I do I am trying to drill down to understand Okay, let's I'll set it aside. Let's see if this concept of family comes up later again in your theology because it's really it's foreign to the text. What

45:15

Speaker A

are you talking about? Leviticus 16. Do you Are you Are you familiar with the law for the high priest Leviticus 16 how he had to sacrifice for himself and his family? Yeah, I just said that. Yeah. You just said that. Exactly. So I

45:28

Speaker A

repeated what you just said and I'm talking about how it's different from Christ cuz Christ didn't have a family. Okay, yeah. Okay, so we agree Christ didn't have a family and the Levitical priests well, it says household, so I

45:39

Speaker A

don't know if that means wife and kids or I'm assuming it does. But yeah, the Levitical priest was a sinful person who had to offer sacrifices for himself and his household. Okay, are we tracking there?

45:50

Speaker A

Christ is a sinless high priest and whether or not he has a family is irrelevant, but okay.

45:58

Speaker A

What do you see on What do you see on screen here, brother? Uh let's see. I need my readers. Verse 22. According to the law Yep. Hebrews 9:22. According to the law in fact nearly everything must be purified with blood. Without the shedding of blood there's no

46:11

Speaker A

forgiveness. Yep. So it was necessary for the copies of the heavenly things to be purified with these sacrifices, but the heavenly things themselves with better sacrifices than these. For Christ did not enter a man-made copy of the true sanctuary. He entered heaven itself now to appear on our behalf in

46:28

Speaker A

the presence of God. So the copy It says the copy twice in these three verses. What is the copy on the earth patterned after?

46:39

Speaker A

What is the Oh, the the tabernacle's patterned after heaven. Specifically, is it patterned after heaven as a whole or the tabernacle in heaven that Christ is in?

46:52

Speaker A

That's a great question. What does Hebrews 8 tell us? Where's Christ right now? Where's Christ right now? He's in heaven. He's sitting down at the right hand of the of God Almighty. What does this verse in front of us say?

47:04

Speaker A

The point of what we're saying is this. Hebrews 8:1. We do have such a high priest who sat down at the right hand of the throne of majesty in heaven who ministers active present tense who ministers in the sanctuary and true

47:14

Speaker A

tabernacle set up by the Lord, not by men. Right. So again, you're taking that literally.

47:21

Speaker A

Holy moly, brother. Maybe it's literal. Maybe maybe So I believe heaven's a physical place and I believe Jesus is there physically. In Psalm 112 when it says God reigns from his temple in heaven and looks down on the earth amongst to to see mankind, is that literal?

47:36

Speaker A

Well, what do you mean by literal? Is it Here's the Here's what I'm getting 5 when when Yahweh is sitting on the temple in his throne in the temple, is that literal? Is it a physical structure temple? I don't know. I You're You're

47:48

Speaker A

forcing me to to try to give uh very specific No, it doesn't, brother. It's very specific. Revelation 21 says there is no temple in the new heaven and the new earth. There is no temple because We've been over this. I'll go over with you again real quick. In Revelation 21,

48:04

Speaker A

that word in the Greek is naos. That word is specific to the holy of holies, not the actual tabernacle of God. Look at this.

48:14

Speaker A

The tabernacle The tabernacle of God on the We We need to stick on one topic and if I sent us off course, I apologize. We're literally talking about Hebrews 8.

48:22

Speaker A

We're talking about Hebrews 8 and Christ ministering sacrifices because of your sin right now. Right. And you're you're trying to tell me he can't be doing that because it's done away with and there's no temple in heaven.

48:34

Speaker A

offering sacrifices right now for us. says in in Hebrews 8 he's ministering in temple in heaven. This is what they patterned the one on the ground after in Hebrews 9:23. I just just 1 second. I just had it on

48:44

Speaker A

screen for you. Just 1 second. So in Hebrews In Revelation 21 Forgive my passion here, but I but I've got the same passion. That's fine. Yeah.

48:51

Speaker A

They are. So this concept in Revelation 21:22 where it says there's no temple in heaven, you look up this word naos Strong's 3485 go back to Hebrews 8. Let's not follow the rabbit trail I just sent us down. Yeah, well, we're going to because you

49:06

Speaker A

asked about this and I'm going to bring it up for you real quick, okay? So this is literally the the shrine room. It's the shrine room, brother. This word in the Greek means the the in the holy of holies. It's the shrine room. It's not

49:18

Speaker A

the actual building of the temple itself. Why did you skip the first two words of that of that usage? A temple.

49:24

Speaker A

A A temple. Literally a shrine. Look Look at it. The part of the the part of the temple where God himself resides. That's the holy of holies.

49:31

Speaker A

that, dude. What does it say? Definition. A temple. Brother Look Definition. 21 What is What comes down out of heaven? Revelation 21 says a temple and you just proved it. Can we jump back to Hebrews 8 now? What comes down out of heaven

49:47

Speaker A

in Revelation 21? Okay. I'm telling you Sean, I we're running down rabbit trails and I'm I think we're confusing the issue by doing so and and I apologize for my part in it, but No, it's not. We're we're on the same topic because that all matters to your

50:03

Speaker A

premise. No. What is the tabernacle of God that comes down out of heaven? Revelation 21:3.

50:12

Speaker A

Did you ask a question? Sorry, I missed it. What is the tabernacle of God that comes down out of heaven? I don't know. It's a temple. It's the tabernacle of God. Ezekiel 37, the promise for him to tabernacle in the earth in his house

50:23

Speaker A

where his his authority resides. This is the So let's go back to Hebrews 8. Okay.

50:28

Speaker A

Yeah, all right. I felt like I was when you're like you're watching a YouTube video and then the commercial comes on and you get all bored. You want to get back to the topic. Yeah, that seems a little bit

50:37

Speaker A

disingenuous and insulting, brother. You don't have to do that. all right. I I hereby remove that comment. I take it back.

50:43

Speaker A

Yeah. But let's try to stay on course because I think this is on course. I don't know how you think we're not. Because we were over in Revelation 21, that's why. So this is Hebrews chapter 8. The point of what we're saying is

50:54

Speaker A

this, we have a high priest who sat down at the right hand of the throne of the majesty in heaven who ministers in the sanctuary and true tabernacle set up by the Lord. Right. And are you familiar with what the language uh of sitting

51:06

Speaker A

down at the right hand of the throne of the majesty what that communicates in biblical categories? Yeah, it's the same thing in Hebrews 1:2.

51:15

Speaker A

Yeah, it's where the it's the position of the high priest. It's the it's the position for the Kohanim Gadol. The the the language about sitting down at the right hand of the throne is language of completion of ful- of fulfillment. That's your interpretation, brother. We

51:29

Speaker A

have a literal We have a literal words in front of us here that that that contradict your interpretation. What does he actively presently do in verse two in the screen right here? He ministers in the sanctuary and true

51:39

Speaker A

tabernacle. What does minister do in in the sanctuary to God? Under the new covenant or the old covenant?

51:46

Speaker A

There's only one definition in scripture unless you have a different scripture. There's only one definition of minister? That I disagree. I think I think priests have different roles and responsibilities under the under the different covenants. For example, we have the priestly duty to to yield up

52:02

Speaker A

our bodies as living sacrifices for God. Right? These That's priestly language. These are the thing This is the way we minister the new covenant. What are these better sacrifices? praising God.

52:12

Speaker A

What's that? As as it re- reaffirms the idea that Christ is in the heavenly tabernacle, that's not a copy, that's the actual original one. What are these better sacrifices that he's doing?

52:24

Speaker A

I think Well, okay. There's some some scholarly debate about the plural sacrifices there. But if you look at the preeminence of the entire book of Hebrews where he's talking about the once for all sacrifice of Jesus that that's never to be repeated that put away sin. You can't

52:41

Speaker A

read that and and read it as him saying there's still sacrifices going on plural. So I believe how I how I interpret that is that he's talking about all the sin sacrifices that were required under the under the old

52:52

Speaker A

covenant are are consumed or were satisfied or fulfilled in the once for all sacrifice of Christ.

53:01

Speaker A

So I think he's talking about the sacrifice of Christ there. Yeah, I grew up hearing the same interpretation and respectfully, brother, that's just not what the words say. So I know that we disagree.

53:11

Speaker A

Yeah, I didn't leave the truth, brother. I I You you can't give me a definition for minister. You can't give me an actual understanding. You can't You can't definitively tell me that Zechariah 14 is literal or allegorical.

53:22

Speaker A

Like I I can't It's hard for me to take seriously your critique on this topic when I'm having to like pull teeth just to get you to give me a definitive answer on very basic concepts and words. So help me understand this. Help me

53:37

Speaker A

understand this, right? So in his in Ezekiel 40 through 48, it talks about the temple Whoa, whoa, whoa. Can we please river of life. We are Christ is ministering forever.

53:47

Speaker A

You keep saying that while you change the topic. Christ is ministering as our high priest forever. Do you agree with that statement? Yes, he's our eternal high priest.

53:54

Speaker A

So when he comes back at the second coming and rules over the earth and literally lives on the earth in the New Jerusalem, is he still going to be high priest? Yeah, we we've already went over this. We've already

54:04

Speaker A

a high Okay, so what comes out of the New Jerusalem and waters all the all the rivers of the earth?

54:14

Speaker A

Instead of leading me this way, why don't you just tell me your theory? So do you do you understand that in Revelation 22, it talks about the river of life that comes out of the throne of God? Okay, so we

54:25

Speaker A

understand the throne of God is in his tabernacle, right? His temple? In In Revelation 22? In all of eternity.

54:35

Speaker A

So So my view is that what we had in Eden, the Garden of Eden was a temple. Right? And so I believe in the end times in the end of Revelation, God is going to restore us to that Edenic vision. So

54:48

Speaker A

a temple that that word keeps throwing me off because I think you're meaning a physical structure in which only priests are allowed to enter and only the high priest is allowed to go through the veil to the most holy place and all that. But

55:00

Speaker A

that's not the kind of temple that I believe the Bible teaches. I believe it teaches the same natural create temple of creation that we had in the in the in the garden is going to be returned restored. All creation is going to be

55:12

Speaker A

restored. It's literally I'm in I agree with you, brother. It's literally called the paradise of God and that word paradise in the Greek literally means a garden. Yeah, okay. So yeah, so I do believe that there's going to be Edenic restoration of all creation in

55:26

Speaker A

the end times. And because Revelation 21 says there'll be no more pain, there'll be no more death. Yeah, human God, right?

55:33

Speaker A

more sacrifices. You don't think we're going to eat thankful and full of death. You think uh you think we're not going to eat food?

55:40

Speaker A

I I think we To be honest, I think we might be uh vegetarians by then. I think we might return Cuz this says that God made animals for food.

55:49

Speaker A

Yeah? Before or after the fall? Eternally. Like this is why we see in the Zechariah 14, we see the first fruits being brought. We see the idea of food that the wedding supper of the lamb, he's slaughtering the the ox and the calf to feed to the resurrected

56:05

Speaker A

saints in robes of white. Okay. And back to Hebrews. So Christ is still reigning when all those things I just mentioned happen. So I Here Let me I'll try to fast forward this because I think what you're getting

56:17

Speaker A

to is that Jesus is our high priest forever. He's a high priest in the temple. What do high priests do? They offer sacrifices. So Jesus is offering sacrifices on behalf of Your sin. On Oh, oh. Yikes. Okay.

56:32

Speaker A

Your sin. So you don't think I gave you what what would you need to see what kind of scripture would you need Would you need to see like some sort of scripture that says like after the resurrection Christ is you know,

56:43

Speaker A

ministering for your atonement? Would that help you? I Oh, hold on. I'm I'm getting confused. I'm just asking like what would cause you to understand that the the the very premise is is By the way, your your challenge, your end of Hebrews movement video challenge,

57:01

Speaker A

whatever, I actually agree with you. I think that you have come to the logical conclusion of the scriptures by posing this challenge to Torah observant in Hebrews communities. I think that they're wrong to say that sacrifices for atonement have done away because the scriptures

57:15

Speaker A

clearly tell us Christ is still doing them on our behalf. No, it does not. Oh my goodness. Watch this.

57:20

Speaker A

I'm trying to process what you just said if I know. get into that. You said he's still in heaven making sacrifices for my sin? Here's a direct verse that tells you this, too. Read this with me. Sure.

57:31

Speaker A

To Hebrews 2:17, for this reason Christ had to be made like his brothers in every way so that he might become merciful and faithful high priest in service to God in order to make atonement for the sins of the people.

57:42

Speaker A

Wow, yeah. That's true. He did that. It's done. No, listen. He had to so that he might become When did he become Have you read all of Hebrews? When did he become He uses the word for ephod. What? When When did he become a high priest?

58:00

Speaker A

When did he become a high priest? When? He became a high priest after being incarnated and resurrected. So after the resurrection when he ascended to heaven, he became a high priest.

58:11

Speaker A

Yeah, that's how I read it. To do what? He makes intercession. in service to God in order to make atonement for the sins of the people. Dude, unbelievable. No, that How can you not see that verse is clearly talking about the sin sacrifice that he made. So

58:28

Speaker A

it's Hebrews 10 is full of this of this idea of once for all. So he made the sin sacrifice after he became a high priest? Hebrews 7:27, once for all Jesus made the sacrifice. the death of his body. Hebrews 10:10.

58:42

Speaker A

That's the death of his body. This verse on screen right here says he became a merciful and faithful high priest in service to God. That's active present tense in order to make atonement for the sins of the people. And he he did that.

58:54

Speaker A

That atonement's completed. He said just said to me that he would became a high priest to God Yeah. after the resurrection. That's when he ascended to heaven, Hebrews 4:14 and 15. And now what? What's he doing up there

59:06

Speaker A

in the in the tabernacle where he ministers? Well, the book of Hebrews says he's offering intercession for us.

59:11

Speaker A

What does the Bible define as a high priest offering intercession? Uh where are you finding that definition?

59:18

Speaker A

In right here in front of you. In order to make atonement for the sins of the people. Dude, no. No, that You're conflating two things. Look at what it says. Let's look at what it says. For this reason he had

59:28

Speaker A

to be made like his brothers in every way. So Jesus became Philippians 2, right? Not counting equality with God anything to be grasped. He He humbled himself and became took on the form of a human servant, right? And became

59:41

Speaker A

obedient I'm not going to complain that you're mentioning Philippians 2 and going away from Hebrews.

59:46

Speaker A

I I said that uh Well, nice try. Uh so it says that he he was made flesh, right? And in Hebrews 2 also talks about how he he can he can identify with us because he understands I think it's the last couple verses of

60:00

Speaker A

Hebrew 2 how he can identify with us because he became human. He took on flesh, God incarnate, right? And so he be and he became a merciful and faithful high priest in service to God. We both agree he's a high priest. Do you agree

60:12

Speaker A

that Jesus is took on flesh and became a human being? Of course. Do you believe he's the son of God? I think you said it up front. Of course, right. He died, resurrected, and then became priest. This is what Hebrews

60:24

Speaker A

says in order to make atonement for the sins of the people. It doesn't say in heaven continually. That's where he is, brother.

60:31

Speaker A

You know that. You know that. I know he's in heaven right now, but that's not where he made atonement. His atonement was made on the cross.

60:37

Speaker A

That's not what this verse says. says that. Hebrews 9:26 You're going to have to come to hard grips with this passage.

60:44

Speaker A

Dude, I'm I'm completely comfortable with that passage. I think you need to take a closer look at it. comfortable What I'm What I'm seeing is that you're comfortable reinterpreting it. No, no, sir. I'm reading what the words say. So the words say a chronological events,

60:58

Speaker A

right? He the fleshly part the part where he became incarnate was when he had to be made like his brothers in every way. We both agree that's when he became incarnate, right? On the earth.

61:07

Speaker A

So that he become a merciful faithful high priest. We know that's said after his resurrection. We both agree on that. In service to God, I read that from Hebrews 8, also Hebrews 5. That's when he's a high priest ministering in the

61:18

Speaker A

true tabernacle. And then it gives you the result of why. Right. So in in which So you're saying that this verse says the way he makes atonement is by continually sacrificing in heaven. Is that right? God calls his law his way of life eternal.

61:36

Speaker A

He has ministers who minister in his eternal tabernacle, the temple in heaven. It's an eternal place where the his his ways are carried out. His law, his behaviors are carried out. Right. But so atonement for sin happened once for all, one time for all people, right? Romans

61:53

Speaker A

6:10, Hebrews 7:27, Hebrews 9:26, Hebrews 10:10. They all say one time. Hebrews 9:26 says he came in these last days to put away sin once and for all.

62:05

Speaker A

And the Greek word is ephapax, which means one time never to be repeated. What does it mean to put away sin? It means to achieve ultimate forgiveness for us. It's what was promised in the new covenant. It's Jeremiah 31. Yeah,

62:18

Speaker A

exactly. Just exactly. This is what I said earlier. At when you get your new body, you have no long There's no ledger of sin on your on your body anymore. You have a new body, a new body. Yeah, you get a new resurrected glorified body

62:30

Speaker A

like Christ at the resurrection. But no, forgiveness of sins happened at the cross. It It doesn't happen in the future.

62:37

Speaker A

We're not We're not So let me get this right. Do you still sin today? Yes. Okay. So do you still have to confess your sins and ask for forgiveness? I do confess my sins and ask for forgiveness daily. Okay. So was You're saying and I've heard this all my

62:50

Speaker A

life, right? That Christ death at the cross before and after took care of all sins. Um So that's what you're Is that what you're putting forward? Is that Yes. before the cross and after the cross because of his death on the cross,

63:04

Speaker A

he he took the punishment that you should have received. Therefore, okay. So you do you do ascribe to PSA atonement theory?

63:13

Speaker A

PSA? Penal substitutionary atonement. Oh, yeah. I mean that's what the Torah sacrifices are, right? No.

63:20

Speaker A

What do you mean no? No. Are you saying that the bull that was killed for sacrifices actually committed his own sins and he was getting killed for his own sins? No. No, animals animals were made for food and the process of making food as a part of atonement was given to the priest who

63:34

Speaker A

serve in God's house. There's also the drink offerings which are not food, which are not animals, the grain offerings which are brought even a handful of flour if you were poor. So no, it's not about the substitution of

63:45

Speaker A

life from an animal. It's PSA is not Leviticus 17:11 disagrees with that. So how does the Old Testament tell you that atonement is made?

63:55

Speaker A

On the day of atonement, Yom Kippur? What? That's That's once a year. How do the all the other instances where it explains to you how atonement is made? So on in Leviticus 16, which I'm going to stick with, that's the high priest has to sacrifice a bull, has to

64:10

Speaker A

sacrifice a goat, and then there's a second goat on which he places his hands and and and symbolically puts the sins of Israel on that what's called the scapegoat, right? Leviticus chapter 1 verse 4.

64:21

Speaker A

Hm? Leviticus chapter 1 as it explains the idea of burnt offerings. Well, I'm I'm sticking with Leviticus 16. I know you are, but we're not ignoring scripture today. We're taking scripture ignoring it either. I'm asking you Dude, we could read the whole Bible and that would take us forever.

64:33

Speaker A

got it on screen right here. Hebrews Leviticus 1:4, he's to lay his hand on the head of the burnt offering Dude, that's why we have to make atonement I'm on topic. We're defining atonement right now. Let's not obfuscate.

64:44

Speaker A

Atonement is described for us, right? is Leviticus 16, Sean. I didn't We did not agree to talk solely about Leviticus 16 today, brother. We talked about your premise, which is the idea of ongoing Christian sacrifice.

64:56

Speaker A

We're going to be running around in circles for hours if we don't stick with the topic. The topic is right in front of us. It's about atonement. And I'm telling I asked you a very simple question. How does the Old Testament

65:05

Speaker A

define how atonement's made? The sacrifice of animals by the high priest. A burnt offering is an atonement sacrifice. The feast day offerings are atonement sacrifices. Burnt offerings about. Burnt offerings happened morning and evening every single day. be I'm not I'm not sure why you're pushing this so hard and and unwilling to

65:23

Speaker A

Because I'm I'm I'm on the topic of how is atonement for sins made? Well, we're talking about the atonement that Hebrews 10 talks about.

65:32

Speaker A

And it's not talking about this. It's talking about the high priest, Yom Kippur, the day of atonement. Hebrews 9 Hebrews 9 talks about better sacrifices plural. This is what I'm saying that this There's more than one instance where atonement is made in

65:46

Speaker A

God's law. It's not just the day of atonement. if you guys are watching, I would say look up Hebrews 7:27, Hebrews 9:26, Hebrews 10:10. Look at all the instances of once for all.

65:56

Speaker A

Yeah, it's the death of his body. He sacrificed his the death of his body once for all so he could become high priest.

66:02

Speaker A

one time for all sins. So let me ask you this. Why is he a priest if his death on the cross covered all this action?

66:10

Speaker A

Why is Okay, there's been Okay. Feel free to rein me in cuz I've been trying to rein you in. So if I'm going off topic, let me know. But there's been a couple of comments like that that have

66:21

Speaker A

really kind of thrown me for a loop. So I have to ask this question if you're willing to answer it because I cuz I don't understand totally your theology. So you believe that Jesus physically literally died on the cross and shed his blood, right?

66:37

Speaker A

Yes, brother. And And you believe that he was literally physically bodily resurrected after that? He's given a new glorified body and bodily resurrected. Okay. So is it your position then that Jesus is divine? How are you defining divine? Is it

66:52

Speaker A

through a trinitarian lens? God incarnate that he's the second person of the of the triune God? We Here we go. We don't We don't subscribe to the Trinity. Whoa. Okay. Yeah, there it is. And you realize that that the greatest obfuscation of all. Let's

67:06

Speaker A

get back to the text. It's not an obfuscation. Absolutely it is. It has nothing to do with all philosophy. The homoousios is all philosophy. It's gnostic. It has nothing to do with scripture, brother. Let's move away from that. everything to do with scripture.

67:16

Speaker A

It does not. According to your lens, I'm not afraid of it. I've done debates on it. Have you not seen There's a reason There's a reason that the that the church for centuries has used the Trinity as a litmus test for

67:24

Speaker A

heresy. Professor Solberg, are you seriously saying that you've you've never seen any emails come up where I've debated trinitarians?

67:32

Speaker A

Yes, I'm seriously saying that. I don't have time to watch other people's stuff. I'm I'm in the middle of school work right now and and writing a book.

67:39

Speaker A

you then you should know that all the creeds that developed the Trinity over a 200-year time span and the argument about homoousios at Nicaea, you should know that all that is from a philosophical pretext.

67:51

Speaker A

No. It's not actually stated in the scripture. But let's not Like you said, let's not derail this and get off into some other tangent.

67:58

Speaker A

Let me Let me make one comment and then that's your hermeneutic. But if you if someone comes to the same topic of like sin atonement and the work of Christ, who he is in that atonement process makes all the difference. And if

68:11

Speaker A

you come to it saying he was I don't know what What do you think he was if he wasn't God incarnate? If he wasn't of God. He's the son of God, brother, sent from heaven. What does that mean?

68:20

Speaker A

He's the son of God. So he's not God. He's the son of God. So he was created?

68:24

Speaker A

I don't define the word God with a homoousios of consubstantiation. I don't I don't I'm not worried about that. That's vain philosophy that's built off the traditions of men influenced by unclean spirits. We don't subscribe to that.

68:38

Speaker A

Okay. So So I'm trying to you're again leaving out I don't really care about homoousios and all those other your pretense. So the word God the word God again, the trinitarian pretense. Your assumptions of what you think it is

68:53

Speaker A

and what you think God is. That's not what I think God is. Let me just I'll I'll answer your question very quickly so we can get back to Hebrews. The word God Can you at least acknowledge that if one person

69:03

Speaker A

doesn't believe God Jesus was divine and another person does, they're going to have radically different views of what the atonement The word divine by technical definition means ultimate righteous character behavior. It doesn't mean homoousios. I don't I not even bringing up homoousios. But that's your

69:18

Speaker A

inferred meaning when you said Oh, wait, you don't believe in the Trinity. That's exactly what you said. No, no, no. Listen for 1 second, brother. The word God is the word Elohim, theos in the Greek. It means for rulership. There's

69:30

Speaker A

the almighty God, there's God the Son, there's angels who refer to as gods, both good and bad, and even rulers of men are referred to as gods by Christ himself in John 10. The word is a semantic range of use. It

69:41

Speaker A

does not mean a triune essence of being. Well, okay. Well, that's good to know that you reject the Trinity and Jesus' divinity.

69:51

Speaker A

All right. So, that at this point, brother, you're just turning it into an ad hominem situation. Dude, no. I I think this is foundational. So, this is why I'm asking. And I'm asking this honestly, Sean. Do you Would you agree that if someone

70:03

Speaker A

has two different views of who Christ is, they would end up at two different conclusions about what his atonement accomplished?

70:10

Speaker A

If you, brother, you know, if you believe that someone has to share your view of consubstantiation before they can understand who Christ is, and therefore that.

70:20

Speaker A

I didn't say that, Sean. what you're saying, brother. No, no, don't jump ahead of me. Just listen to my words. Would you agree that Well, then instead of trying to lead, why don't you just say what you want to say?

70:28

Speaker A

I did. Would you agree that people who come to Yes, I think you have a very poor view of Christ and a very poor definition of who he is. Okay, and I think you're I think you're up to your neck in heresy.

70:40

Speaker A

But Irenaeus Irenaeus would say you're the ultimate heretic who should go hang out with Marcion. So, I'll ask it again.

70:47

Speaker A

Hopefully you'll answer. If people have one person views Christ as divine, part of the Trinity, and another person views Christ as something less than divine, would you agree that they would How about if one person agrees with the

71:00

Speaker A

scriptures that say Christ is the Son of God who is without sin, who is now our ultimate high priest and savior, and the other person tries to put him into a consubstantial essence of God from philosophy? I would say that person

71:12

Speaker A

needs to be removed from teaching position cuz they don't understand scripture. Okay. Well, so if you're not going to answer, I'll answer for you. I've answered you multiple ways and multiple times. dude, the answer is yes. They would come

71:24

Speaker A

to a radically different view of what Jesus' atonement of sin accomplished. So, it's very simple, brother. If you believe that Christ is still high priest on your behalf, what's he doing for you? So, do you believe Jesus was merely

71:35

Speaker A

human? Because that's That's how I see it. We don't subscribe to the hypostatic union, brother. It's a It's an invention by men in the 4th century.

71:46

Speaker A

Okay, I'll ask you Let me ask it again in a different way. Do you believe Jesus was merely human? Jesus showed up in the flesh as a man.

71:53

Speaker A

He was not a spiritual nature. He showed up as an earthy man in the flesh. Okay.

71:58

Speaker A

So, you have Now resurrected and glorified, he's a life-giving spirit, as 1 Corinthians 15:45 tells us.

72:05

Speaker A

Okay. So, you have kind of like a You have sort of a like a concoction of heresies going on that's really quite impressive.

72:13

Speaker A

And and I don't care about Okay. So, let's let's let's just move away from this, brother, because I can play the same game with you. You have a concoction of heresies from different philosophers from the 2nd to the 4th

72:23

Speaker A

century. You probably You probably think Augustine has something valid to say I didn't mention Augustine. I'm just saying to you I could easily play this game with you. Do you want to get back to actual Are you trying to just troll, or do you want to get back to the actual conversation?

72:37

Speaker A

Well, well, here's the thing. I don't want to waste your time or mine if it's going to be unproductive. it for 10 minutes by trolling this Trinity topic. You want to get back to This is not troll. You can't see the

72:46

Speaker A

absolute connection between who Jesus was and the atonement he made for us. You don't see any connection there? May the Father break the spell of this Trinitarian doctrine off the minds of believers. This is madness.

72:59

Speaker A

This is madness, guys. Everyone watching, this is madness. We trying to have a conversation, it gets to This is exactly what happened with the other professor from Chicago that came on. Halfway into it, he starts to realize Does this guy believe in the Trinity?

73:12

Speaker A

And then suddenly he can't get back on topic. Wait, so what is the is a huge problem for your hermeneutic and for your for your heart. It's a heart issue, brother, if you think that this is an interpretive lens to

73:22

Speaker A

scripture. And I'm just trying to share with you if you can't agree with the definitions of the words on screen, then let's at least discuss that.

73:30

Speaker A

Right? As opposed to me saying you've got a pre-sup that's causing you to view all this through this really skewed philosophical lens of deity that that causes you to ignore the actual function or role of Christ because you think he's on par with the almighty. Right, and that makes sense

73:45

Speaker A

from within your world view. But we're talking about two radically different world views. And yours, with all due respect, Sean, it's a very fringe position. It's not. reject the Trinity. It is Unitarians are in the past.

73:59

Speaker A

Every Everyone that Everyone that that's in my audience, they understand what we talk about. They support it. They see the scriptures we use for it. They don't understand the Trinity. They don't believe the Trinity is a real thing. Oh,

74:09

Speaker A

that's so sad, dude. You're leading so many people astray. No, you know what? You know who led people astray was the Roman steel that stamped down with the Roman sword and said, "Hey, you must believe this or you're out." That's what

74:20

Speaker A

was said. okay, for the record, I agree. I I'm not a fan of Christianity getting the endorsement of the Roman Empire. I wasn't a fan of that at all. So, But But that said, I'm not coming at this from a philosophical perspective.

74:31

Speaker A

I'm coming at it from scripture. And and to me coming at it from scripture cuz you just diverted for 15 minutes to talk about the Trinity. Dude, the Trinity is pivotal. It's foundational. And the divinity of Christ is is foundational.

74:44

Speaker A

It's not. It's all your presupposition. It's all man's traditions of men. It's pivotal. You're not seeing it. No, it's Well, if you can agree to disagree taught So, when you came to faith in Christ, did someone tell you that you had to believe in the the triune

74:56

Speaker A

consubstantial essence of God? No, I don't think anyone talked about the Trinity for years. There you go. It doesn't matter cuz the Holy Spirit gave you the deposit without all that nonsense. It doesn't matter. The Trinity matters.

75:10

Speaker A

The The Even more You're You're just going to ignore what I just said, basically. You just ignored me.

75:14

Speaker A

What kind of response were you hoping for? You came to Christ without understanding or knowing anything about the Trinity, and Christ accepted you, brought you and gave you the deposit of the Spirit, prompted you to start learning his word and changing your behavior. Nothing to do with the

75:27

Speaker A

Trinity, brother. Well, yeah. This is a This is a very important point. We don't need to know perfect theology in order to come to faith in Christ. I I'll I'll stipulate that point, absolutely. Matter of fact, I'll bet heaven is going to be full of people who

75:42

Speaker A

got theology wrong. And I'm for one I'm glad that my my any of our ticket to get in is only faith. It's not having perfect theology.

75:51

Speaker A

Do you Do you think that Do you think that Irenaeus was a church father with good doctrine?

75:58

Speaker A

I don't know. He has some He had some really good stuff to say, sure.

76:01

Speaker A

Do you know that he said I'm not I'm interested in scripture, not the the church fathers. Oh, I'm Well, hey, then reject the Trinity because they're the ones who created it. They didn't create it. The I find the

76:12

Speaker A

Trinity on the pages of scripture. You read it in the scriptures. Oh, so now you want to set it aside. You don't want to talk about Irenaeus and what he thought about the Trinity. No, I don't want to talk about I will if

76:22

Speaker A

you want, but I I don't want Okay, I see. I see. What? Yeah, you're inconsistent, brother.

76:27

Speaker A

You're vastly inconsistent with your theology. What's on screen here? How am I inconsistent? That's That's ridiculous. You've called me a heretic with a concoction of heresies. Let's just move on, brother. Yeah.

76:38

Speaker A

Let's just move on, okay? I love you anyway. Okay. we don't agree. All right? Fair enough.

76:44

Speaker A

I'm glad I'm glad that this is spirited. I really held back a lot with you last time because I wanted to give you a chance to speak your mind and ask questions and push back. But this time I have to hold your feet to the fire on

76:55

Speaker A

some of these things. And one of them is your insistent refusal to pin down actual eschatological concepts because you refuse to acknowledge that God's law still being operated on the earth by all nations.

77:08

Speaker A

So, Christ is reigning as the king and high priest over those operations forever on the earth as all nations learn his ways and peace is on the earth. So, I cannot subscribe to this idea that you think that the sacrifices are done away with, and we have tons of

77:25

Speaker A

prophecies that tell us they're they're not only going to be reinstated when he returns, but he in requires all nations to abide in them.

77:35

Speaker A

I'm I'm not sure what to say. I'm still kind of processing what we went through because it's I'm Now I'm looking for a way I can bridge what I believe the Bible says with the theories that you're espousing here. I'm

77:46

Speaker A

not espousing any theories. I'm just I'm reading the scriptures to you. we we both are. Do you believe that Hebrews 40 through 48 is talking about the uh kingdom come, the millennial reign? You mean Ezekiel?

77:59

Speaker A

Ezekiel 40 through 48, you think it's talking about kingdom come, millennial reign? Yeah, I think it's talking about probably the millennial reign, yeah. Some sort of eschatological future era.

78:11

Speaker A

All right. So, I'm going to read this passage real quick. You tell me what you think. Ezekiel 45:16, "All the people of the land must participate in this contribution for the prince of Israel, and it shall be the prince's part to

78:20

Speaker A

provide the burn offerings, the grain offerings, the drink offerings for the feasts, new moons, and Sabbaths for all the appointed feasts of the house of Israel. He'll provide the sin offerings, the grain offerings, the burnt offerings, and peace offerings to make atonement for the house of Israel."

78:35

Speaker A

Christ is reigning over this process. So, you think the prince is Christ in that? Nope. I'm saying Christ is reigning as the ultimate high priest over this process. Oh, that's interesting. I haven't heard that one before. Okay. No, I mean, that's the logical entailment of him

78:50

Speaker A

being high priest, king of kings, lord of lords over all things heaven and earth. This is the kingdom come. God's tabernacle comes down. The kingdom of heaven connects to the earth.

79:00

Speaker A

Touches down on the ground. All nations come to the Mount Zion to learn his ways, and they're required to do these things in front of us on screen.

79:10

Speaker A

Okay. So, what's your point? Sin atonement's being made through sin offerings, grain offerings, burnt offerings, everything that you think that is no longer applicable in Christ's death on the cross did away with.

79:21

Speaker A

Uh where is the Leviticus 16 offerings? Can we deal with the text Can we deal with the text in front of us? Sure.

79:32

Speaker A

Grain offerings, drink offerings for the feasts, burnt offerings. Uh, oh, brain I'm sorry. Drink offerings for the feast, new moons and Sabbath for all the pointed feast of the house of Israel. He will provide the sin offerings, grain offerings, burnt offerings, and peace offerings to make

79:46

Speaker A

atonement for the house of Israel. Okay. So, your position is that the house of Israel has not yet been atoned for or that it requires eternal atonement continually forever. I'm I'm asking We just qualified this question and why I brought this this on

80:03

Speaker A

screen on Ezekiel 45. Millennial reign context, kingdom come, Christ is reigning over heaven and earth. All nations are required to learn his ways and provide in these sacrifices for feasts, new moons, and Sabbaths. Okay.

80:18

Speaker A

Right. And so, you're you're taking this again as a literal your premise that Christ died on the cross got rid of this entire process is false, brother. You've been taught false doctrine.

80:28

Speaker A

Uh, well, obviously I disagree otherwise I wouldn't believe it. I How do you square this with the idea that Hebrews 18 says there is no longer any offering for sin? Hebrews 18? You You got a better better verse for than that? There's no Hebrews 18. I said I

80:44

Speaker A

corrected myself. Hebrews 10:18. Yeah, let's look at what Hebrews 10:18 says. The Holy Spirit testifies this first. This is coming on "I will make them those days cuz I will put my laws in their hearts, scribe them on their

80:53

Speaker A

minds." That means we'll do them. He adds, "Their sin and lawlessness I remember no more. And where these have been forgiven, an offering for sin is no longer needed." So, again, what is the promise of the new covenant? When does this actually take place?

81:06

Speaker A

At the death of Christ. We all enter the new covenant. We become Yeah, we become We become the children of God. We become the sons and daughters of God. We become the heirs of the kingdom of God. We become the inheritors of the kingdom of

81:15

Speaker A

God. We become the inheritors of the kingdom of God. We become the inheritors of the kingdom of God. We become the inheritors of the kingdom of God. We become the inheritors of the kingdom of Oh, it has disappeared. It hasn't.

81:23

Speaker A

That's not what the word say. It is what the word say. I'm I'll put them on screen for you, brother. Look. go back to 10:18, I didn't get your response. How do you Look. Is your response simply that this hasn't

81:33

Speaker A

happened yet? And will soon disappear. What happened the And he's quoting the same passage from Jeremiah 31, "Laws in your hearts and minds." Right. "Scribed on your hearts." At the resurrection, you get the perfect righteousness, the laws of God put on you so that you never sin again. Right

81:49

Speaker A

now, we still struggle. John First John 1:7 and 8, he says without sin is a liar. But if we confess our sins, he's faithful and just to cleanse us from all unrighteousness cuz he's our high priest meeting atonement for us. It's that simple. It's that simple.

82:02

Speaker A

Look. So, where are you getting this idea that no one will ever sin again?

82:06

Speaker A

Because that is the promise of the covenant that you It's right there. You'll never have enmity. You He'll forgive your And remember your sins no more forgive their iniquities and remember their sins no more. at the resurrection when you're

82:18

Speaker A

glorified that you'll be able to sin? I don't think so. I know I won't sin if I'm glorified. I don't know about that.

82:26

Speaker A

Therefore, therefore, you'll never sin again. This doesn't say you'll never sin again. Look at the words. It says "For I will forgive their iniquities and will remember their sins no more." Hold on, this is an important I'm digging in

82:36

Speaker A

with you. their iniquities and will remember their sins no more. Right. How does God forgive their iniquities? Through the sacrifice of Christ. Why does he remember their sins no more? Because Christ put away sin for all time. E phapax.

82:49

Speaker A

their sins no more because he gives them a new heart and a new body. There's no more You know, atonement is different from the removal of sins. Are you familiar with that? Yeah. Uh, well, Atonement covers over.

83:01

Speaker A

Yeah. Atonement is a covering where the removal of sins is actually when you get a new heart and a new body at the resurrection. Right.

83:06

Speaker A

That's what Christ has been given the authority to raise us to life and give us a new heart and new body. The bulls and the goats, their blood never atoned for sin as I think you might have mentioned earlier

83:17

Speaker A

from Hebrews no. No, no, no. It says the bulls' blood and goats' No, no, no. Hang on. Let's go to that passage. You're misquoting it.

83:22

Speaker A

Well, well, you're jumping away from that one. It says the bulls' blood and goats do not remove sins.

83:27

Speaker A

It cannot take away sins. Exactly. There's a difference between covering There's There's covering sins and there's taking away sins. Right. I mean, that's the covered for only a year, right? Until next The atonement covers The resurrection is when you have them

83:43

Speaker A

taken away from you. And you have a new heart and a new body, incorruptible.

83:47

Speaker A

Incorruptible. So, you asked me for a specific You asked a specific question. You said, "Where Where does it tell you that you'll never sin again?" First Corinthians 15, your new body is called incorruptible. You cannot sin again.

83:59

Speaker A

Why? Because you get his laws in your hearts and minds to do them. The same ones that he says in millennial reign we're all required to observe his feasts, Sabbaths, new moons, all of it. Well, going back to what I was getting

84:09

Speaker A

at when I asked that question, Jeremiah 31:34, which is the same thing as Hebrews 8:12 that we just looked at, says that I will forgive their iniquities and remember their sins no more. It doesn't say they won't sin. It

84:22

Speaker A

says I will forgive their sins. Their sins have been covered eternally. So, so, I read that and I really believe this is what the the whole book of Hebrews is about when you read it in context.

84:33

Speaker A

It's saying that Jesus, the sacrifice of Jesus once for all Again, Hebrews 9:26, he came to put away sin once for all, one sacrifice for all sin, it's gone.

84:43

Speaker A

We're under the new covenant. God already has forgiven our iniquities. Yes, we sin, but they're already forgiven.

84:50

Speaker A

He remembers them no more. That's what it says. So then you Do you ascribe to free grace, once saved always saved?

84:58

Speaker A

Uh, I have a video about that. I'm I'm on the I'm on the fence about that. I I don't actually subscribe 100% to that. Can a Can a person come to Christ and then through sin be weighed down by their sins and lose their salvation,

85:08

Speaker A

their promise of salvation? I don't think anyone can out-sin the grace of God. So then you're once saved always saved. But I do believe that they can willfully choose to walk away. It seems to me like that. Oh, here

85:20

Speaker A

Here's my opinion. What is What is it How can How are you not walking away if you perpetually abandon the behavior of Christ and start sinning the rest of your life and forget who Christ is? Well, here Here's my answer and I

85:30

Speaker A

realize it's a mystery, but that's kind of what the Bible leaves us with. It's not It's not a mystery, brother. You're just conflicting your own theology. No, the Bible is a mystery. If you think you understand the entire Bible, you might

85:39

Speaker A

be a cult leader. No, no. How about we just go through the scriptures and we believe what they say instead of trying to reinterpret them?

85:45

Speaker A

Dude, every time you read, you're interpreting. You mean because I apply the definitions of the words in the past? I'm I'm doing the same thing. Reading is interpreting. There's no way you can read and not interpret. It's part of the process of communicating written

85:58

Speaker A

didn't even answer the the scripture on the screen, Ezekiel 45:16. Okay, let me go back to the question you just asked before this one about once saved always saved because I believe there's a mystery in the Bible that says we are

86:08

Speaker A

expected to obey God and that we're told that we will be held accountable if we don't obey, right? So, we're expected to There's some level of expectation of doing that. And at the same time, we're also told that no one can snatch us from

86:21

Speaker A

God's hand. So, there's this sense of both and in my opinion in terms of once saved always saved. I think that I think in some sense it's true. No, not Calvinist. But so, I think I think it's generally true

86:35

Speaker A

that once we're saved a genuine faith What's What's the thing the reformers like to say? Uh, if you were Calvinists?

86:43

Speaker A

Reform If you were saved, I forget how they had a cool little saying about if you're you know, if you're saved, you can never lose it and if you lose it, you were never saved. I think Yeah, that sounds also viable. That's

86:54

Speaker A

nonsense because he Colossians chapter 1 tells us we'll be presented to Christ if we continue in the faith. Yeah, so I'm I'm on the fence about once saved always saved. I think when you take it as this little bumper sticker,

87:06

Speaker A

it's completely misleading. Because I feel like it gives people the license to step into sin and wickedness and disobey God and all that and that I'm completely opposed to that. But But when you If you're talking about it in

87:17

Speaker A

terms of the security of our salvation, God will never let us go. The question that I have, and I don't think the Bible quite answers, things like Hebrews 6 kind of uh, tease at it, but the question I have

87:29

Speaker A

is, yeah, God will never let us go, but will he allow us to go?

87:34

Speaker A

Is he Is he going to entrap you like the moment that you profess faith in Christ and now he entraps you even if you don't want to spend forever with him at some point later in your life? No, I would love I would love to be entrapped.

87:46

Speaker A

I I don't even care. I would Sometimes I wish he would just take So then you are a Calvinist. You don't believe in free will.

87:51

Speaker A

I believe in limited sort of free will. You mean limited atonement like Calvinism? No, not limited atonement. Free will. So, this is so interesting. Limited atonement Limited atonement is negating the free will of other people because it says that some people,

88:04

Speaker A

regardless of their will, can never receive atonement from Christ. Well, I'm not steeped in Calvinist theology, so you can put whatever label you want, but here's what I believe is that the the free will that we have When

88:15

Speaker A

we talk about free will, we didn't choose when we were going to be born. We didn't choose our gender. We didn't choose our hair color or our ancestry or the country we would be born in or the period of history that we

88:27

Speaker A

would be born in. We didn't choose our personality. We didn't choose our family. Brother, we're talking about our putting in our faith in Christ and living our lives all those things All those things were chosen for us. That That's a nonsense. that Within that,

88:40

Speaker A

then we I do believe we have freedom within those pre-chosen conditions. So, you don't think that we have the freedom to choose Christ or reject Christ?

88:47

Speaker A

I think we do. The Bible seems to make that very clear. I mean, why would it Why would they admonish us to press on in the faith And that's that's my argument. Is it also says if you reject him, he'll reject you. That's very

88:56

Speaker A

simple. Right. If you deny Christ, he'll deny you, right. Yeah, it's very simple. So, And And why I mean, why would we be warned consistently to keep strong, to finish the race, and and and to hold fast to our faith

89:08

Speaker A

if it wasn't possible at some level to let go of it? That's kind of my question. Yeah, in that same passage in Philippians 3 that you're quoting from, Paul goes on to say in verse 12 that he has not attained what he strives to

89:18

Speaker A

press on to hold for, but he has not been made perfect yet. And this is what I'm talking about here with this passage on screen about the difference between the the covering over of sin versus the removal where you at

89:29

Speaker A

the resurrection you're are made perfect. This is what he's waiting for. I'll actually go to Philippians 3 because this is literally what Paul's teaching and he even uses the word resurrection in this passage.

89:39

Speaker A

we're going to be glorified and perfected. I agree. Yeah, so the point is you're not there yet. You have not attained the resurrection yet.

89:46

Speaker A

yet. None of us are. You have not obtained it from the dead. You're not perfect. Christ still Uh Paul still presses on for this. This is why I say you're incorruptible at the you're incorruptible at the resurrection. That's when you get his

90:01

Speaker A

heart his laws in your heart and mind so that you professionally do them. This is the promise of Ezekiel 37 or 36 that he'll sprinkle you clean and give you a heart of flesh that is ordinances and statutes. That's pertaining to his feast

90:13

Speaker A

days and observances. It is ordinances and statutes that you will obey them. This is the promise of the new covenant. So you're obeying his ordinances and statutes in forever in the at the after the resurrection, right?

90:25

Speaker A

I'm obeying the commandments that I'm under as a new covenant Christian. I asked you specifically after the resurrection will you be obeying the feasts of God forever? After the res- final resurrection I'll obey whatever he commands of me. Whether that's going to include literal

90:38

Speaker A

feasts, I don't know. Okay, brother. Do you have any questions for me? Do you think that's a cop out or Yeah. Okay. Why is that a cop out? So let me ask you this. It's a big old cop out, brother. You got to make it you got to

90:51

Speaker A

you got to stand you got to stand on some sort of conviction here with what you're teaching. Dude, I'm convinced at what I just told you. That is my conviction. That how does it affect my life today? How

91:00

Speaker A

does it affect the walking out of my faith, the things that Jesus commanded me to do and expects of me? How how does saying that after the resurrection the feasts might be restored and I'll celebrate them then connect that to my life or your life today?

91:16

Speaker A

So the life today is that we're told to practice the behavior of God, the commandments of God, that they're eternal statutes and that's a part of our sanctification and righteousness. Yeah, but the commandments that are only applied to us. I mean you'd agree you only need to obey the commands that

91:31

Speaker A

apply to you, right? Yeah, so I can I can obey the Sabbath and it's blessed my life ever since I started doing so. I can obey I've seen a big blessing in my life, too, when I started doing that. You started obeying the Sabbath on the

91:42

Speaker A

seventh day. No, I I I take my day of rest on Sunday. Okay, that's not the seventh day. Of course it's not the seventh day. The day doesn't matter. That's not the Yes, it does. It's specifically the seventh

91:53

Speaker A

day in scripture. This is what I'm talking about. You're just reinterpreting stuff, brother. No, I'm going to have to go with scripture on this which tells me don't let anyone judge you based on food or drink or Do you know that Colossians 3 he's literally talking to converts and

92:05

Speaker A

they were receiving persecutions from other people in Colossae? Yeah, I did a whole study on Colossians Do you understand that he he's already taught them the Old Testament? He didn't teach the Colossians from Galatians. He's already taught them the Old Testament. How could Paul say don't let anyone

92:18

Speaker A

judge you on those things? Because those people wanted them to stop obeying the commandments. and Christ is the reality. A shadow doesn't make the the actual instructions negated, brother.

92:28

Speaker A

Sure, but this. No, it doesn't. What good is a foreshadow once the thing it foreshadowed shows up?

92:33

Speaker A

All right, so let me get this straight. Um marriage is a shadow of our relationship with God, but now marriage is done away with or because Jesus say you won't be given in marriage in heaven? No, I'm I'm not talking about the here and now. We're talking about

92:46

Speaker A

sanctification in this life, right? What we should be doing. Okay, yeah. saying your your analogy falls apart because it's not something that you can actually take to a logical extent.

92:55

Speaker A

There's no entailment for you. You cannot just claim that it's a shadow of something so therefore we don't have to do it. It just means that I'm reading scripture. You may not be doing it the best or with

93:05

Speaker A

the right heart. That's the shadow application. It's not that it's an evil thing that you have to stop doing. It's that you're trying you're practicing to do this. This is what we're told in Leviticus 18 to practice his his ways,

93:16

Speaker A

his laws and statutes. the Israelites were told under the Old Covenant. I agree. Yeah, so in Matthew 19 Christ tells the person who asked how do we get eternal life, he says to do the commandments.

93:25

Speaker A

Very simply. Read the rest of the story. I've read it. He goes on to give him Deuteronomy 15 afterwards and tells him this is what you need.

93:32

Speaker A

What else do I need? And then he and then he quotes him Deuteronomy 15. No, what he does is he gives him commandments that aren't in the Torah.

93:38

Speaker A

Respectfully, because you're so unfamiliar with the front of your Bible you don't even realize what you're reading right there. That didn't sound respectful. Neither does a concoction of heresies, Rob. I know. I realize it doesn't sound respectful, but if it is it is what it is. I'm sorry,

93:53

Speaker A

Sean. I'm going to I'm going to have to call a cat a a cat right now. I mean I'm just telling you you're you're trying to call me a cult leader, you're trying to call me a concoction of heresies or whatever.

94:01

Speaker A

That's fine. People call me worse. It's no big deal. Okay, so let me ask you to you if you're if you're going to take that tenor with you, I'm going to lovingly say, look, I ain't no pushover, brother. Okay.

94:11

Speaker A

you I'm I'm trying to put the scriptures in front of you and all I've seen today this it's been recorded for an hour and 34 minutes.

94:18

Speaker A

You're dancing around the scriptures, you reinterpret the words, you just say I don't know and I don't know that could mean this, it could mean that. I can't take your critique on this topic seriously with that type of hermeneutic.

94:30

Speaker A

I'm sorry. I can't take it seriously if you are rejecting the divinity of Christ as well. There you go. That's fine. That's fine. Okay, let me ask you this. Do you worship Christ? Do you worship Jesus? Yeah, worship there's two definitions.

94:40

Speaker A

Do you know the two definitions of worship in scripture? Uh no. Enlighten me. Yeah, worship as obeisance where Philippians 2:11 every knee will bow. 100% I worship Christ. Christ offers worship in a temple to his father. That's the other definition of worship. So now Christ Christ doesn't

94:59

Speaker A

Christ doesn't have a temple. We will not be offering sacrifices of worship to Christ in a temple because he's our high priest doing that on our behalf to the almighty. Do you believe that Christ is almighty to the father? Yikes. What? Yikes? I just explained the biblical

95:14

Speaker A

process to you. No, you didn't. How are you a professor of the Bible, brother?

95:19

Speaker A

No, so so you're saying I asked you if you worship Jesus and you gave me a bounce around answer that said I worship you the two definitions that you told me to give you. That I said yeah.

95:31

Speaker A

Wow, okay, this is fun. Uh yeah, so if you worship Jesus you're saying you bow your knee, but you don't worship him in a different way?

95:40

Speaker A

Well, every knee bowed to Christ. Yeah, every every knee will That's called obeisance. It's called worship. in the same way because he is God. He just like all just like the Are you going to are you going to offer temple

95:50

Speaker A

sacrifices to the father? No, that's not how we worship today. Oh, really? So We offer our lives as a living sacrifice.

95:56

Speaker A

read you multiple prophecies in the future where all all nations will be offering burnt offerings to the father. Yeah, yeah, right.

96:04

Speaker A

You don't believe those words, do you? I believe they're 100% true. So then you're contradictory in your statements. You're speaking out both sides of your mouth. Words mean things. Listen to what I'm saying. They're 100% true. What does word burnt offering mean?

96:17

Speaker A

But I'm saying I don't know if they're 100% literal. Okay, so you're just reinterpreting I just want to encourage you, brother.

96:25

Speaker A

Um you do not have the authority to reinterpret scripture. It's been interpreted for us by scripture. Amen. I would say the same thing about you.

96:32

Speaker A

you against what you're doing with these words. That's exactly what I was going to say about you. Of course. Of course. Of course. I mean Have we finished up have we finished up Hebrews 7 or Hebrews 10 or the passages

96:43

Speaker A

therein that you think we need to address? Well, what did the I was going to ask this one question. What did the sacrifice of Jesus accomplish?

96:51

Speaker A

It got him to his priesthood. Hebrews 5. I'll put it on screen for you. No, I know you said that. Is that the only thing you think it accomplished? All it did was earn him the priesthood?

97:01

Speaker A

Only thing it did? Do you know how great an honor that is? Do you not understand that this is literally what he was prophesied to become? This is what it's telling you right here in Psalm 110. That's not the

97:11

Speaker A

only reason he was he sacrificed himself on the cross. The Bible gives us many other reasons. Brother, it directly tells you he was prophesied to become a high priest. He had to get to that through the unfortunate mechanism of the cross. The father knew how his son would die

97:26

Speaker A

when he was sent to a wicked adulterous generation. We have the writer of Hebrews directly telling us right here.

97:32

Speaker A

He learned through obedience from what he suffered. Having been made perfect became a source of its salvation of all who obey him in the order Melchizedek an eternal high priest. Yeah. It's a one-to-one correlation.

97:42

Speaker A

that. I'm not denying that. Cause and effect. Cause and effect. He went to the cross, he died, he suffered, he was made perfect at the resurrection, he's your high priest forever fulfilling the prophecy. He's literally tagging it on to the prophecy of why Christ was sent to the earth.

97:57

Speaker A

Yes, but that's not the only reason that the New Testament gives us. You can't just pull that out of scripture and say this is the only thing his sacrifice accomplished. Romans 5:8, 1 Peter 3:18 talk about his and Romans 3:25. He died

98:09

Speaker A

as a sin atonement for us for our sins. He He died to fulfill God's plan. as a propitiation Romans 3:25 to demonstrate God's love to establish a new covenant. These are all the reasons Christ Give me So you're working from a penal substitutionary presupposition.

98:27

Speaker A

Why do you want to put labels on stuff? Because that's literally what it's the scholars talk of This is the language of the scholars. This is what they've talked about from the days of the reformers as this PSA doctrine was reformed and refined using the exact verses that you

98:41

Speaker A

just gave me Romans 3:25 calling him a propitiation for us. Okay? J- Rob, Christ is called a shepherd. He didn't literally shepherd sheep in a field.

98:52

Speaker A

Christ is called Christ is called the bread of life. He didn't He wasn't literally a bread loaf that we eat.

98:59

Speaker A

Yeah. Christ is referred to as the guilt offering in Isaiah 53 which is different. John, I know what you're saying. from the lamb the Passover lamb. Okay, so there's a metaphor of him being called a propitiator for us.

99:10

Speaker A

Jesus did not die for our sin? Of course he died for our sins, but how and how does that play out through scripture? I just put on screen, it's on screen still for you to read. It's one way he died for our sins.

99:21

Speaker A

He can be obviously he can be called a propitiation. First Peter also talks about his blood sprinkles you clean. When you became a Christian, did you go into the back room of your church and have Christ blood brought out and sprinkled on you? So you don't believe that I'm sorry I know it

99:37

Speaker A

sounds I know it sounds ridiculous, but could you just try to address it humanly? Humanly? No, we don't You know why is because Then you understand there's metaphor and allegory applied. You understand there's allegory applied to Christ death pertaining to aspects of the law of God, right?

99:52

Speaker A

Of course, right. But you do you deny that So therefore Christ death is a propitiation for us, but then we get all this extra information telling us literally how he provides atonement for us and it's not through dying on the

100:04

Speaker A

cross because that would negate his father's law. That would negate the the role of a priest. It tells us right here how he makes atonement for us. When there's been a change in the priesthood, there's a necessarily a change in the

100:16

Speaker A

law as well and that's why the former commandments were Transfer. He got his priesthood after the cross, not at the cross. Transfer is a change. He got his priesthood after the cross, not at the cross. Did you hear what I said?

100:30

Speaker A

from from one location to another. Okay, so now you're reverting back to your old bad definition that we already cleared up. He did not get his priesthood at the cross. It was after his resurrection ascension to heaven. According that's that's how kind of how

100:44

Speaker A

Hebrews 5 describes it. That the the one led to the other. His life what they what scholars call the Christ event, right? His life, his death, his resurrection and ascension that according to Hebrews 5 that all played into was part of God's redemptive plan by which he was appointed a high

101:00

Speaker A

priest. Right? If you want to split the hairs with some sort of modern idea of at 11:59 on this particular day, that's when this thing happened. I mean, that's ridiculous. I feel like then you're scratching to try to maintain your your theology.

101:14

Speaker A

But if you want to look at what what the Bible actually says, it says that he died to atone for our sins. He died for our sins. Galatians 3 says he he became a curse to redeem us from the curse of the law.

101:26

Speaker A

You think that Christ Do you think that Christ literally became a curse? He took on the curses that were that were due to us. So you are preaching full on PSA. I don't care what you call it. I'm

101:38

Speaker A

preaching the Do you think a you think a a four-week-old baby who dies from birth complications deserve to go to the cross? Wait, do I think a four-week-old baby that died from birth complications? Do you think they deserve to go to the cross and Christ took their place?

101:55

Speaker A

Yeah. So you're full on PSA. Whatever you want to call me, I'm full on biblical. Yeah. No, it's not biblical, brother, at all. It's some of the reformers. It's a man-made tradition and it's actually it's actually it's actually documented how different it is

102:10

Speaker A

from the previous 1,500 years of Christian thought on atonement. Actually it might be a man-made document doctrine. Yeah, it is.

102:16

Speaker A

all doctrines are man-made, right? Is there anything else you'd like to say as we wrap this up? Is there anything you'd like to I'll say Romans 5 talks about how how sin entered the world through one man and righteousness entered

102:27

Speaker A

through Jesus. Right, when do you when do you get when does all mankind receive that righteousness of Christ? The moment they place their faith in him.

102:34

Speaker A

So you now literally have the righteousness of Christ on you? I do. Yes. That's amazing. I would go to heaven right now. If I were in God's presence right now You know wait, no, no, no. I'm talking too much your death.

102:44

Speaker A

I'm talking about literally in your life right now cuz you're you're just preaching Augustinian imputed righteousness right now, which is a Catholic concept. don't you? No, I like history. I like accuracy, brother, right? So look, all you're doing right now is you're telling

102:56

Speaker A

me that you you've in one side of your mouth 10 minutes ago you said you still sin. The next side you said you have the righteousness of Christ. Exactly. You don't understand how those are contradictory, sir? Isn't that amazing? God sees us No, you don't You don't have the

103:11

Speaker A

righteous You get the righteousness of Christ at the resurrection, No, you get it you get it at your at your salvation, at your putting your faith in him. Then why would you need to sanctify? Why would you need teachers to teach you

103:21

Speaker A

right behavior? Why would you need to sanctify and grow? I I love that you brought this up. The reason we need to be sanctified is because God cares more about us having a relationship with him than he cares

103:33

Speaker A

about us instantly being made sinless. Lovingly, that's your pastoral interpretation, man. That's just commentary.

103:39

Speaker A

you said is interpretation. Yeah, of course I'm giving you my interpretation. All I'm trying to say to you is if the righteousness of Christ was without sin.

103:46

Speaker A

Is the righteousness dikaios in the Greek, it means right behavior, moral character. You do not have the fullness of that right now.

103:53

Speaker A

In the same way that Abraham was called righteous in Genesis 15:6 even though he still sinned. Matter of fact, he sinned later in the same chapter.

104:01

Speaker A

Being justified is different from actual sin. Being justified before God is different from actually walking out the obedience. No, I disagree. Well, I mean I mean So therefore a poor brother, tonight you showed me that you're an an OSAS Trinitarian PSA holding Augustinian re

104:18

Speaker A

re repudiate or excuse me reformed believer shooting Yeah, you you fallen into all these man-made traditional doctrines of modern Christianity that has brought in all this presupposition and philosophical interpretation. And I put scriptures and no wonder I put scriptures on screen like the one we

104:37

Speaker A

still have on screen right now and you buck like mad going well, this can't mean what it says. I didn't say it can't mean what it says.

104:45

Speaker A

I interpreted what it says. Exactly. You interpreted the opposite of what it actually says on screen. Well, as you interpret it, it's the opposite, yeah. It literally says he's in service to God to make atonement for the sins of the people. Right. And how did I interpret that? You said that oh,

104:59

Speaker A

that was done at the cross. Yeah, it was. It's not. It's not. This Okay, because you're taking the metaphor and you're trying to make it into the literal application. It's No, no, no, it's not a metaphor. You you don't think

105:10

Speaker A

Jesus really atoned for our sin? He's atoning for our sins according to this verse on screen right here. man.

105:17

Speaker A

You're not listening. So when I say that he atoned for our sins at the cross because he's a propitiation offering for us by giving his life over for us, but then the rest of scripture explains oh, what's he doing now and what does it actually mean for him to be a

105:31

Speaker A

propitiation for us and it's telling you right on screen right here, but you just have to believe it. Oh, I believe that that is referring to his sin atonement on the cross as the doesn't say that in the chapter,

105:41

Speaker A

brother. You're inserting words into the chapter. It says that in the book. It actually does say that. In order to make atonement for the sins of the people, he made atonement. We're at an impasse, Rob.

105:51

Speaker A

We are at an impasse, yeah. I'm going to have to go with Jesus as our once for all covered all sin perfect sacrifice. Well, I think you're going to be readily surprised at the resurrection when the temple returns and you're required to go

106:03

Speaker A

up there with your offering. So it'll be a fun day and I'll give you a hug still, brother. It'll be okay. I'll hug you back. I'm I'm not I'm not, you know, prideful and like just trying to be right. I just want to sow seeds of

106:13

Speaker A

the sower sows the word, put the words on screen, ask you how you feel about them. I I take serious issue with your with your freedom to reinterpret things at will. Um I think that that's Freedom to reinterpret things. We're both interpreting. It's just a

106:30

Speaker A

It's just we can let the viewers decide. I say read And I got to say I got to say, brother, you might want to talk to your audience, brother. There's some wicked people shouting some wicked things in your

106:40

Speaker A

audience. Let let me say this as a sort of a closing thing. Uh I am 100% opposed to personal attacks against anyone even someone I disagree with. So the things I've said to you, Sean, were descriptions of where I think

106:53

Speaker A

your theology is. I haven't insulted you as a person. I didn't intend I didn't mean to insult you as a person. Really? Cult leader, huh?

107:00

Speaker A

I didn't actually call you a cult leader. Oh, you sure about that? You're smiling because you know you inferred that. But if you're a cult leader and I tell you that, it's a loving thing to do, right? So now you're not even being

107:11

Speaker A

honest. Well, no. We we can we'll throw the red flag and rewind the tape on exactly how I worded it. But here's my point. If all my viewers As much as I disagree with you and I think your theology is is off the ranch, I don't approve of the things that

107:27

Speaker A

people say about you. I've I've been getting lots of comments all week that Sean I know for a fact they aren't true. Like people say things about you that are lies. I hear that every day. I know and I'm I'm sorry that you had to go

107:39

Speaker A

through that. I I had the same thing. I I forget It just gives me more opportunity to forgive people and walk in the love of Christ. Hey, real quick.

107:46

Speaker A

You think that this Hebrew Torah thing is going to be toppled by your supposition with this question, but I got some bad news for you, man.

107:55

Speaker A

We're every uh Torah observant channel that I know of is growing still. We're getting testimonies every week from people coming to understand the fullness of obedience to Christ by the commandments of God, which is what Revelation 22:14 directly

108:11

Speaker A

tells us is how we get to the tree of life. So I just want to say I I my heart hurts for you because I think you're on you're fighting a losing battle here, brother. I think you're kicking against the

108:21

Speaker A

goats. And I would just want to encourage you to consider uh otherwise, right? I want you to be um I don't want you to be frustrated because you're going against what God is clearly doing across the world bringing people back to his commandments. Getting

108:37

Speaker A

away from philosophy. I appreciate your concern. Okay. Yeah. And I take your concern. I hear you. Um I don't like it I don't always like the way it comes out, but I hear your critique and I hear your concern

108:49

Speaker A

and I'll keep it in mind. All right. All right. Anything you'd like to say before we go? Thank you for reaching out for having me on and I pray God's blessings on you. You too. Bless you too, brother. And Uh

109:05

Speaker A

see you next time. All right. Hey, because we're because we're multi-streaming, um 1 second here. I'm not going to Guys in the audience, I'm not going to continue the stream after he leaves cuz we're we're sharing on each other's

109:16

Speaker A

platforms. So, that's unfair to him if I keep talking cuz it's going to He can't turn it off, basically. So, we're saying our goodbyes and wish everybody well. Study your Bibles and test everything we've said today, okay? Yeah, see you next time. Follow Jesus. Amen.

Topics: Hebrew Roots Torah observance Yom Kippur Leviticus 16 new covenant Mosaic law dietary laws Melchizedek substitutionary atonement Christian theology debate

Study this video

- [Flashcards from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/flashcard-maker/?from=transcript&id=95296)
- [Quiz on this video](https://sozai.app/tools/quiz-generator/?from=transcript&id=95296)
- [Crossword from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/crossword-maker/?from=transcript&id=95296)
- [Word search from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/word-search-maker/?from=transcript&id=95296)
- [Study guide from this video](https://sozai.app/tools/study-guide-maker/?from=transcript&id=95296)

Free, made by AI from this transcript. No signup.


---
This is the markdown twin of https://sozai.app/transcript/hebrew-roots-professor-solberg/ — the same content, without the markup.
Published by SozAI (https://sozai.app). Reuse and quotation are allowed with attribution and a link back.
Machine-readable index: https://sozai.app/llms.txt · data API: https://sozai.app/api/
